: 1 : IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA, DHARWAD BENCH. Before THE HON BLE MR.JUSTICE H.N.NAGAMOHAN DAS

Transcription

1 : 1 : IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA, DHARWAD BENCH Dated this the 7 th day of October 2013 Before THE HON BLE MR.JUSTICE H.N.NAGAMOHAN DAS Writ Petition No.46460/2002 C/w W.P.No.398/2000, W.P.No.528/2007, W.P.No.3508/2000, W.P.No.4233/2000, W.P.No.8367/2000, W.P.No.9395/2000, W.P.No.9867/2000, W.P.No.11825/2000, W.P.No.21915/2000, W.P.No.22311/2000, W.P.No.32144/2000, W.P.No.3880/2000, W.P.No.433/2001, W.P.No.194/2002, W.P.No.13838/2002, W.P.No.17712/2002, W.P.No.38334/2002, W.P.No.3621/2006, W.P.No.172/2007, W.P.No.435/2007, W.P.No.18602/2006, W.P.No.3930/2005 In W.P.No.46460/2002 BETWEEN: 1. MR. B.MELLAREDDY, AGED ABOUT 55 YEARS, S/O B RAMA REDDY, PROP MANJUNATHA CHEMICALS FERTILISERS, BELLARY. 2. MR. J.THIPPERUDRAPPA, AGE: 48 YEARS, S/O J SANNA BASAVANNA GOWDA, UMA MAHESHWARA AGRO AGENCIES, SHOP NO 2, EDIGA HOSTEL COMPLEX, DOUBLE ROAD, BELLARY-1.

2 : 2 : 3. SRI. C. CHANDRASHEKAR, AGE: 52 YEARS, S/O NARAYANAPPA SRI MAHALAXMI AGRO AGENCIES, AMBEDKAR COMPLEX, STALL NO 10, DOUBLE ROAD, BELLARY G. RAMAKRISHNA REDDY, AGE: 35 YEARS, S/O G VEERA REDDY SRI. RENUKA AGRO TRADERS, STALL NO.11, AMBEDKAR COMPLEX, DOUBLE ROAD, BELLARY. 5. B. HARI S.BABU, AGE: 30 YEARS, S/O B.SUBBARAMAIAH, SEETHARAM AGENCIES, FERTILISERS AND PESTICIDES, SHOP NO 4, NEAR BUS STAND, BELLARY K.BALBIR REDDY, AGE: 40 YEARS, S/O SANKA REDDY, M/S. HALE BASAVESHWARA AGRO CHEMICALS, STALL NO 5, ARYA EDIGA HOSTEL COMPLEX, DOUBLE ROAD, BELLARY D.SHESHADRI, S/O SUBBARALU, AGE: 46 YEARS, SRI. KANKADURGA AGRO CHEMICALS, NO 9, DOUBLE ROAD, BELLARY D.S.JYANAMURTHY, AGE: 62 YEARS, S/O SIDDARAPPA, AMARESHWARA & CO., DEALERS IN FERTILISERS CHEMICALS SEEDS AND AGRICULTURAL COMPONENTS, BALAJI KALYANA MANTAP, STALL NO 485.

3 : 3 : 9. H. SRINIVASA REDDY, AGE: 39 YEARS, S/O H.HAMMA REDDY, VENKATESHWARA AGRO CHEMICALS, K.C. ROAD, BELLARY M.C.CHINNAPPA REDDY, AGE: 46, S/O HANUMANTHA REDDY MARUTHI AGRO AGENCIES, K.C. ROAD, BELLARY. PETITIONERS (BY SRI. B.N.SHIVANNA, V.ANJANE GOWDA & D.M.RENUKA MURTHY, ADVOCATES) A N D : 1. JOINT DIRECTOR OF AGRICULTURE, JOINT DIRECTORS OFFICE, BELLARY. BELLARY DISTRICT. 2. THE DIRECTOR OF AGRICULTURE, SHESHADRI ROAD, BANGALORE ASSISTANT DIRECTOR OF AGRICULTURE, BELLARY TALUK, BELLARY. 4. JOINT DIRECTOR OF AGRICULTURE, CHITRADURGA....RESPONDENTS (BY SMT. K.VIDYAVATHI, ADDL. GOVT. ADVOCATE) THIS WP IS FILED UNDER ARTICLES 226 & 227 OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA WITH A PRAYER TO QUASH THE IMPUGNED ORDER DATED ISSUED BY R1 VIDE ANNEXURE-A AND DIRECT R1 TO RENEW THE LICENSE OF THE PETITIONERS 1 TO 10 BY TAKING RS.30/

4 : 4 : In W.P.No.398/2000 BETWEEN KISAN AGRO AGENCIES GUNJ AREA, GULBARGA, BY ITS PROPRIETOR, REVANASIDDAPPA, S/O BASAWANAPPA UDAMNALLI, AGE MAJOR, OCC: BUSINESS, R/O GULBARGA....PETITIONER (BY SRI. N.P.VIVEKMEHTA, ADVOCATE) AND 1. UNION OF INDIA, BY ITS SECRETARY, DEPARTMENT OF AGRICULTURE AND CO-OPERATION, KRISHI BHAVAN, NEW DELHI. 2. DIRECTOR OF AGRICULTURE, NEAR K.R.CIRCLE, BANGALORE....RESPONDENTS (BY SHRI. C.SHASHIKANTHA, ACGSC & SRI. ASHOK HARANAHALLI, CGSC FOR R1; SMT. K.VIDYAVATHI, AGA R2) THIS WP IS FILED UNDER ARTICLES 226 & 227 OF CONSTITUTION OF INDIA PRAYING TO DECLARE THAT RULE 10(2)(a) OF THE INSECTICIDE (AMENDED) RULE 1999 AS UNCONSTITUTIONAL AND ARBITRARY. IN W.P.NO.528/2007 BETWEEN M/S BHAVANI AGRO CHEMICALS, SHOP NO 30, PAL COMPLEX,

5 : 5 : CITY BUS STAND, HEAD POST OFFICE ROAD, SUPER MARKET, GULBARGA, BY ITS PROPRIETOR, SRI. PRAKASH, S/O CHENNABASSAYYA HIREMATH, AGE 39 YEARS....PETITIONER (BY SRI. SHARANABASAPPA K BABSHETTY, ADVOCATE) AND 1. UNION OF INDIA, BY ITS SECRETARY, DEPARTMENT OF AGRICULTURE AND CO-OPERATION, (KRISHI BHAVAN), DR.RAJENDRA PRASAD ROAD, NEW DELHI. 2. THE COMMISSIONER AND DIRECTOR OF AGRICULTURE, GOVERNMENT OF KARNATAKA, SHESHADRI ROAD, BANGALORE. 3. THE JOINT DIRECTOR OF AGRICULTURE, GULBARGA....RESPONDENTS (BY SHRI. D.R.ANANDEESWARA, CGSC FOR R1 SMT. K.VIDYAVATHI, ADDL. GOVT. ADV., FOR R2 & R3) THIS W.P. IS FILED UNDER ARTICLES 226 & 227 OF CONSTITUTION OF INDIA PRAYING TO DECLARE THAT RULE 10(2)(a) OF THE INSECTICIDES (AMENDED) RULE 1999 AS UNCONSTITUTIONAL AND ARBITRARY, IN SO FAR AS PETITIONER IS CONCERNED

6 : 6 : IN W.P. NO.3508/2000 BETWEEN 1. S.SHIVAKUMAR, MAJOR, S/O LATE G.SHIVAPPA, PROPRIETOR, GURU CHEMICALS & FERTILISERS, NO.2, III MAIN ROAD, NEW THARAGUPET, BANGALORE / 2. K.SUBRAMANYAM, MAJOR, S/O KALASA KRISHNA RAO, PROPRIETOR, KARNATAKA FARMS SUPPLIES, ST.JOHN AMBULANCE ASSOCIATION BUILDING, SAMPANGIRAMANAGARA, BANGALORE B.L.NAGENDRA GUPTA, MAJOR, S/O LATE B.S.LAKSHMINARAYANA SETTY, PROPRIETOR, NAGENDRA FERTILIZERS, NO.3, III MAIN ROAD, NEW THARAGUPET, BANGALORE B.K.MUKTHAR PASHA, MAJOR, S/O ABDUL RAHIM, PROPRIETOR, KISSAN AGRO SERVICES, NO.1, III MAIN ROAD, NEW THARAGUPET, BANGALORE M.V.SHANKARANARAYANA SETTY, MAJOR, S/O VENKATA NRAYANAPPA, PROPRIETOR, SHREE ADHISHEHSA FERTILISERS, NEAR K.S.R.T.C BUS STAND, NH 4, SIRA

7 : 7 : 6. S.PUTTALINGAIAH, MAJOR, S/O B.S.SUGURAPPA, PROPRIETOR, SRI SOMESHWARA FERTILISERS, N.H-4, SIRA P.R.RAMU, MAJOR, S/O P.L.RANGAPPA, PROPRIETOR, SRI RANGA TRAERS, N.H.4, SIRA. 8. S.KARIAPPA, MAJOR S/O SIDDALINGAPPA, PROPREITOR, SIDDALINGESWARA TRADERS, SIRA. 9. S.C.ASHWATHANARAYANA SETTY, MAJOR, S/O LATE S.CHELUMAIAH SETTY, PROPRIETOR, S.CHALUMAIAH & SONS, N.H.4, SIRA. 10. C.T.RAVIKUMAR, MAJOR, S/O THIMMEGOWDA, PROPRIETOR, BASAVESWARA FERTILISERS, N.S.ROAD, CHELUR. 11. N.LAXMIPARHY, MAJOR, S/O LATE NARASAPPA, PROPRIETOR, SRI. LAKSHMINARASIMHA TRADERS, J.C.K COMPLEX, B.H.ROAD GUBBI MANJUNATHASWAMY, MAJOR, S/O K.S.SADHASHIVAIAH, PROPRIETOR, SRI SIDDALINGESWARA TRADERS, IN FRONT OF BUS STAND, (NEAR CHANNABASAVESHWARA

8 : 8 : TALKIES) GUBBI. 13. H.R.NARASIMHAGUPTA, MAJOR, S/O H.N.RAMAIAH SETTY, PROPRIETOR, KARNATAKA AGRO SUPPLIES, 2 ND MAIN ROAD, NEW MANDIPET, TUMKUR G.P.VEERANNA, MAJOR, S/O PEDDAPPA, PROPRIETOR SWATHI TRADERS 2 ND MAIN RAOD, NEW MANDIPET TUMKUR K.N.NATARAJU, MAJOR, S/O K.C.NAGARAJU, PROPRIETOR, NATARAJA FERTILIZERS, 2 ND MAIN ROAD, NEW MANIDI PET, TUMKUR B.L.MANIKYRAJU, MAJOR, S/O LATE LAXMIPATHAIAH, PROPRIETOR SRI PARSWANATHA TRADERS & FERTILISERS, MANDYA MERCHANTS AND COMMISSIONS AGENTS, 2 ND MAIN ROAD, NEW MANDIPET, TUMKUR T.S.RAJENDRA, MAJOR, S/O T.S.SIDAPPA, PROPRIETOR, SPIC AGRO SERVICE CENTRE, C/O NIRAJAN TRADING COMPANY FERTILISERS, SEEDS AND PESTICIDES DEALER, KUNIGAL ROAD, HONNUDIKE HAND POST. TUMKUR T.S.NIRANJANA, MAJOR,

9 : 9 : S/O T.S.SIDDAPPA, PROPRIETOR NIRANJAN TRADING CO., DEALERS IN FERTILISERS PESTISIDES & SEEDS, 2 ND MAIN ROAD, NEW MANDIPET, TUMKUR PETITIONERS (BY SRI. N.G.PHADKE, MEERABAI, ADVOCATES) AND 1. UNION OF INDIA, JOINT SECRETARY, (PLANT PROTECTION) MINISTRY OF AGRICULTURE, DEPARTMENT OF AGRICULTURE & CO.OPERATION, KRISHI BHAVAN, NEW DELHI STATE OF KARNTAKA, ITS PRINCIPAL SECRETARY, AGRICULTURAL & HORTICULTURAL DEPT, VIDHANA SOUDHA, BANGALORE RESPONDENTS (By SHRI. N. DEVHADASS, ASG FOR R1 SMT. K.VIDYAVATHI, ADDL. GOVT. ADVOCATE FOR R2) THIS WP FILED UNDER ARTICLES 226 & 227 OF CONSTITUTION OF INDIA PRAYING TOCALL FOR THE RECORDS FROM R1 RELATING TO IMPUGNED NOTIFICATION DT IN SO FAR AS IT RELATES TO THE AMENDMENT OF RULE 10(2) OF THE INSECTICIDES RULES, 1971, AND QUASH THE SAME AS ILLEGAL AND WITHOUT JURISDICTION

10 : 10 : IN W.P. NO.4233/2000 BETWEEN 1. SUN AGRO SEEDS, SHOP NO.3, SARASWATHI LODGE BUILDINGS, 3 RD MAIN ROAD, GANDHINAGAR, BANGALORE , SRI. S.N.CHANDRA RAJ GUPTA, S/O K.S.NARAYANA SHETTY, NO.26, 1 ST MAIN ROAD, N.R.COLONY, BANGALORE INDO AMERICAN SEEDS, AITHAL COMPLEX, NO.6, 2 ND CROSS, GANDHINAGAR, BANGALORE , SRI. K.S.SHIVA KUMAR, S/O K.S.SURYA NARAYANA NO.53, 12 TH MAIN, 3 RD BLOCK JAYANAGAR, BANGALROE NATIONAL AGRO AGENCIES, NO.6, SARASWATHI LODGE BUILDING 2 ND CROSS, GANDHINAGAR, BANGALORE , SRI. B.R.ASHWATH NARAYAN, S/O B.R.RATHADAIAH NO.15, 5 TH CROSS, SHANKARAPURAM, BANGALORE YASHWASWI AGRO SEEDS, MAHAVEEN PLAZA, 2 ND CROSS, GANDHINAGAR, BANGALORE , A.R.HARISH S/O A.G.RAMAIAH SETTY, 2 ND CROSS, GANDHINAGAR, BANGALORE

11 : 11 : 5. AJAY AGRO SEEDS, NO.3, GIRISH COMPLEX, OPP: SYNDICATE BANK, 2ND CROSS, GANDHINAGAR, BANGALORE , SRI. D.N.RAMESH KUMAR, S/O D.NARAYANA SETTY, D.NO.54/2, M.M.V.ROAD, BASAVANAGUDI, BANGALORE SHREE AGRO SEEDS, NO.4 & 5, GIRISH COMPLEX, 2 ND CROSS, GANDHINAGAR, BANGALORE , SRI. K.SRINIVAS, S/O M.KRISHNAIAH SETY, NO.1262, 7 TH CROSS, 27 TH MAIN, 1 ST PHASE, J.P.NAGAR, BANGALORE KARNATAKA AGRO SEEDS, NO.9 & 10, GIRISH COMPLEX OPP. SYNDICATE BANK, 2 ND CROSS, GANDHINAGAR, BANGALORE , SRI. PRABHAKAR GUPTA, S/O P.VENKATAPPA, NO.22, 5TH CROSS 6TH MAIN, HANUMANTHANAGAR, BANGALORE KISSAN SEEDS CORPORATION, NO.3, ARYA VIDYA SHALA BUILDING, 5 TH MAIN,GANDHINAGAR, BANGALORE SRI G.GOPAL, S/O G.MUNISHAMAYYA, NO.84, 4TH MAIN,

12 : 12 : AMAR JYOTHI LAYOUT, R.T.NAGAR, BANGALORE SAMRUDHI AGRO SEEDS, NO.2, SAJJAN LODGE BUILDING 6TH MAIN, GANDHINAGAR, BANGALORE , SRI. B.L.RAMA KRISHNA PRASAD, S/O B.S.LAKSHMINARAYAN, NO.22, 6TH CROSS, 5 TH MAIN, N.R.COLONY, BANGALORE UNIVERSAL AGRO SEEDS, SAJJAN LODGE BUILDING, 6TH MAIN ROAD, GANDHINAGAR, BANGALORE , SRI. M.K.NARAYANA MURTHY, S/O M.K.KRISHNA MURTHY, S/O M.K.KRISHNA SETTY NO.54/4, 14TH MAIN ROAD, VIJAYANAGAR, BANGALORE INTERNATIONAL AGRO SEEDS, NO.28, 6TH MAIN ROAD, SAJJAN LODGE BUILDING, GANDHINAGAR, BANGALORE , SRI. D.N.MALLIKARJUN, S/O D.NARAYANA SETTY, NO.2, BARANI NATIONAL HIGH SCHOOL, BANGALORE. 12. ALL INDIA AGRO KENDRA, 5 TH MAIN ROAD, GANDHINAGAR, BANGALORE , SRI. P.V.BHAGVAN BABU S/O P.K.VENKATACHALAPATHY SETTY NO.25, YELLAPPA GANDEN,

13 : 13 : 10TH CROSS, MALLESWARAM, BANGALORE ALL INDIA AGRO SEEDS, NO.19, S.C.ROAD ANANDA RAO CIRCLE, BANGALORE , SRI. P.K.RAMACHANDRA GUPTA, S/O P.KRISHNA SHETTY, D.NO.37/1, S.B.ROAD, 2 ND FLOOR, V.V.PURAM, BANGALORE PADMA AGRO SEEDS, G-3, BRIGADE PLAZA, S.C.ROAD, ANAND RAO CIRCLE, BANGALORE , SRI. VENKATESH S.N. S/O S.V.NAGARAJA SHETTY, R.V.ROAD, D. NO.95, BASAWANAGUDI, BANGALORE NEW KARNATAKA SEEDS NO.G-4, BRIGADE PLAZA, A.A.CIRCLE S.C.ROAD, BANGALORE , SRI. M.RAMACHANDRAPPA, S/O ALTE K.MUNISHAMAPA D.NO.521, 4 TH CROSS, 2 ND BLOCK, R.T.NAGAR, BANGALORE SRINIVASA AGRO SEEDS, NO.2, TRINETRA MARKET, III MAIN ROAD, N.T.PET, BANGALORE , D.V.MANOHARA GUPTA, S/O ALTE D.V.S.GUPTA NO.62, RAM IYENGAR ROAD,

14 : 14 : V.V.PURAM, BANGALORE SAMRUDHI AGRO CENTRE, NO.217/4, 3 RD MAIN ROAD, N.T.PET, BANGALORE , SRI. B.L.MURALI KRISHNA, S/O LATE B.S.LAKSHMI NARAYANA SETTY, NO.28, SAMRUDHI PUTTANNA ROAD, BASAVANAGUDI, BANGALORE SRINIVASA AGRO CORPORATION, NO.2/11, TRINETRA MARKET, 3 RD MAIN ROAD, N.T.PET BANGALORE P.USHA SATHYAN, W/O P.R.SATHYANARAYANA SETTY. 19. UNITED AGRO SEEDS, NO.3/4, 3 RD MAIN ROAD, N.R.TPET, BANGALORE , ITS L.C.RAVISHANAKR, NO.14, RANGA RAO ROAD, SHANKARAPURAM, BANGALORE SRI. BALAJI AGRO SEEDS, NO.2/7, TRINETRA MARKET, 3 RD MAIN ROAD, N.T.PET. BANGALORE , SRI. K.NARAYANA GUPTA, NO.2/7 TRINETRA MARKET, 3RD MAIN ROAD, N.T.PET, BANGALORE

15 : 15 : 21. ARUL AGRO CENTER, NO.88/1, I FLOOR, 3 RD MAIN ROAD, N.T.PET, BANGALORE , SRI. A.ANBALUGAN, NO.88/1, I FLOOR, 3 RD MAIN ROAD, N.T.PET, BANGALORE PETITIONERS (By SRI. S.K.V.CHALAPATHY & K.N.SRINIVASA, ADVS.,) A N D : 1. UNION OF INDIA, JOINT SECRETARY (PLANT PRODUCTION), MINISTRY OF AGRICULTURE, DEPARTMENT OF AGRICULTURE AND CO.OPERATION, KRISHI BHAVAN, NEW DELHI DIRECTOR OF AGRICULTURE, GOVERNMENT OF KARNATAKA, SHESHADRI ROAD, BANGALORE RESPONDENTS (BY SHRI. S.N.ASHWATHANARAYANA, CGSC FOR R1 SMT. K.VIDYAVATHI, ADDL. GOVT. ADV., FOR R2) THIS WP FILED UNDER ARTICLES 226 & 227 OF CONSTITUTION OF INDIA PRAYING TO QUASH THE AMENDED RULE 10 UNDER ANN-A AND B IN SO FAR AS IT RELATES TO PRESCRIBING THE FEES OF RS.500 FOR EVERY INSECTICIDE FOR GRANT OR RENEWAL OF LICENCE SUBJECT TO A MAXIMUM OF RS.7,500/

16 : 16 : IN W.P. NO.8367/2000 BETWEEN 1. SRI. NEW CHANNAVEERA AGRO AGENCY, FILTERBED ROAD GULBARGA. PROP: CHANNABASAPPA S/O: VEERANNA SIRGOND AGE: 26 YEARS, OCC: BUSINESS 2. VIJAYA AGRO AGENCY, GUNJ ROAD, GULBARGA PROP: MADIVALAPPA S/O: NINGAPPA HENDI, AGE: 35 YEARS, OCC: BUSINESS 3. LAXMI AGRO SUPPLIERS, GUNJ, BUS STAND, HBD ROAD, PROP: R V PRAKASH, S/O R V VENKATARAMAIAH AGE: 45 YEARS, OCC: BUSINESS, 4. ANAND TRADING COMPANY, NEHRU GUNJ, GULBARGA PROP: GOPAL RAO, S/O NARAYANARAO KHAMITKAR AGE:45 YEARS, OCC: BUSINESS. 5. ANAND TRADERS, NEHRU GUNJ, GULBARGA PROP: MADHUSUDAN S/O GOPAL RAO KHAMITKAR, AGE: 23 YEARS, OCC: BUSINESS 6. MRITYUNJAYA TRADERS, PROP: SOMASHEKAR G NADKATTI AGE: 55, OCC: BUSINESS

17 : 17 : 7. JAJEE AGRO AGENCY, KIRANA BAZAR, GULBARGA. PARTNER, VIJAYAKUMAR, S/O PRABHAKAR JAJEE, AGE: 45 YEARS, OCC: BUSINESS, 8. PRABHUDEV AGRO AGENCY, GUNJ, GULBARGA. PROP: NAGARAJ S/O SHANKARGOUDA PATIL AGE: 25 YEARS, OCC: BUSINESS, 9. KEDARNATH JAJEE, S/O KASHAPPA JAJEE, KIRANA BAZAR, GULBARGA, MNG. PT., KEDARNATH JAJEE, AGE: 45 YEARS, OCC: BUSINESS 10. JAJEE PESTICIDES, RAGHUJI BUILDING, FILTERBED ROAD GULBARGA, MNG. PT. K.K.JAJEE, AGE: 45 YEARS, OCC: BUSINESS, 11. KRISHNA FERTILIZERS & PESTICIDES, GUNJ, GULBARGA, PROP: V AMARNATH, S/O A V PADMANABHA GUPTA, AGE: 42 YEARS, OCC: BUSINESS 12. VEERABHADRESHWARA AGRO ASSOCIATES, GUNJ, GULBARGA, MNG. PT., SANGANNA, S/O CHANDRASHEKHAR PATIL, AGE: 42, OCC: BUSINESS 13. M/S CLASSIC PESTICIDES, NEHRU GUNJ, OPP: SBH, GULBARGA, MNG. PARTNER, SIDDANNA S/O KASIRAYA BIRADAR, AGE: 34 YEARS, OCC: BUSINESS

18 : 18 : 14. SRI. SAI NIDHI ENTERPRISES, GUNJ, OPP: SBH, GULBARGA, PROP: VEERANNA, S/O KASIRAYA BIRADAR, AGE: 37, OCC: BUSINESS 15. JYOTHI AGRO TRADERS, BIYANI COMPLEX, GUNJ, MAIN ROAD, GULBARGA, PROP: CHANDRASHEKHAR, S/O SIDRAMAPPA TALLALLI, AGE: 47 YEARS, OCC: BUSINESS ALL ARE RESIDENTS OF GULBARGA TQ. & DIST: GULBARGA....PETITIONERS (By SRI. N.P.VIVEKMEHTA, ADVOCATE) AND 1. UNION OF INDIA, BY ITS SECRETARY, DEPARTMENT OF AGRICULTURE AND CO.OPERATION, (KRISHI BHAVAN), DR RAJENDRAPRASAD ROAD. NEW DELHI. 2. DIRECTOR OF AGRICULTURE, K.R.CIRCLE, BANGALORE....RESPONDENTS (BY SMT. K.VIDYAVATHI, ADDL. GOVT. ADVOCATE FOR R2) THIS W.P. FILED UNDER ARTICLES 226 & 227 OF CONSTITUTION OF INDIA PRAYING TO DECLARE THAT RULE 10(2)(a) OF THE INSECTICIDE (AMENDED) RULE, 1999 AS UNCONSTITUTIONAL AND ARBITRARY

19 : 19 : IN W.P. NO.9395/2000 BETWEEN 1. D.CHANDRASHEKHAR, DIBBADAHALLI AGRO SERVICES CHAMARAJPET, DAVANGERE H P SHEETHAL PRASAD, PARSHWANATH AGRO AGENCIES, DISTRIBUTOR FOR SEEDS & PESTICIDES, BEHIND N.R.ROAD, JAIN TEMPLE, DAVANGERE K H KESHAVAMURTHY, MAJOR, PRESIDENT OF DAVANGERE DIST. PESTICIDE FERTILIZERS AND SEED DEALER ASSOCIATION, DAVANGERE. 4. S V NELIVIGI, SHRUTHI AGRO AGENCIES DISTRIBUTORS:SANDOZ (I) LTD, BOMBAY, MAHAVEER ROAD DAVANGERE. 5. B M GANESHAN, KANCHAN HYBRID SEED CO., DISTRIBUTORS:SEED AND PESTICIDES MAHAVEER ROAD, DAVANGERE NARYAN C KULKARNI SHAKTHI AGRO AGENCIES 276/1, CHAMARAJPET BESIDE BALAGAVI COMPLEX DAVANGERE PRATAPARUDRA, PROPRIETOR, SIDDALINGESHWARA AGRO AGENCIES 181/2, NARASARAJA ROAD,

20 : 20 : DAVANGERE G S PRAKASH CHAIRMAN AND MANAGING DIRECTOR KALPATARU SEED PVT LTD., 206/6, MAHAVEER ROAD, DAVANGERE G S PRAKASH PROPRIETOR AGRO HYBRID SEEDS CORPORATION DR.NAGANAGOWDA BUILDING OLD HOSPITAL ROAD DAVANGERE G S PRAKASH CHAIRMAN & MANAGING DIRECTOR AKSHAY AGRO SALES PVT LTD 206/6, MAHAVEER ROAD DAVANGERE K P KRISHNAMURTHY VENKATAKRISHNA TADERS 206/3A, MAHAVEER ROAD DAVANGERE G SHIVANNA KAAMADENU SEEDS AND AGRO CHEMICAL CORPORATION P.B.ROAD, DAVANGERE T M GIRISH, PRORPEITOR, GURU RENUKA AGRO CENTRE, NO.291/1, CHAMARAJPET, DAVANGGERE LION B H RAMESH BHAWAN, SAHANA AGRO AGENCY, 179/13, N.R.ROAD,

21 : 21 : DAVANGERE , 15. G M INDUMATHI, PROPIETOR, SREE MALLIKARJUNA SEEDS AND AGRO CHEMICALS CORP. AUTHORISED DEALER, E.I.D PARRY (INDIA) LTD MAHAVEER ROAD, DAVANGERE B O UDAYKUMAR, PROPRIETOR, HANUMANAHALLI AGRO AGENCIES 169/C,NARASARAJ ROAD, DAVANGERE B V VIJAYKUMAR, PROPRIETOR, VENKATESHWARA SEED CENTRE, NO.173/3, NARASARAJ ROAD, DAVANGERE C KRISHNA, PROPRIETOR, VIKAS HYBRID SEEDS, 6/202/1, NARASARAJ ROAD, DAVANGERE. 19. PRADEEP N NEELGUND, PROPRIETOR, MANDARA AGRO NEEDS, 179/11, NEXT TO KARUR VYSYA BANK, NARASARAJ ROAD, DAVANGERE K JAGADEESHWAR, KAVALAHALLI AGRO AGENCIES, NEW BAMBOO BAZAR ROAD, DAVANGERE G B CHANDRASHEKHARA, PROPRIETOR, SREE KOTTURESHWARA AGRO AGENCIES, 106/7B, R.M.C LINK ROAD,

22 : 22 : DAVANGERE A GANGADHARAPPA, PROPRIETOR, SREE ANANBERU RANGANATH AGRO, AGENCIES, K.R.ROAD, SHYAMANUR SHIVAPPA COMPLEX, DAVANGERE T R DEVENDRAPPA, DEEPA AGRO CORPORATION, K.R.ROAD, DAVANGERE U S REVANASIDDAIAH PROPRIETOR MALALKERE AGRO AGENCIES DAVANGERE KAMALAKAR, VERNEKAR ENTERPRISES, MANDIPET DAVANGERE KAMALAKAR, VERNEKAR AGRO FERTILIZERS, MANDIPET, DAVANGERE , 27. V G NAGARAJ, PROPRIETOR, MANJUNATHA AGRO AGENCIES, MANDIPET. DAVANGERE A P NAGARAJA, PROPRIETOR, ESWAR AGRO AGENCIES, NO.64, NARASARAJ ROAD, DAVANGERE SIDDAPPA N KITTR, PROPRIETOR, 205/3 BOMMAJJA BUILDING, NARASARAJ ROAD, DAVANGERE

23 : 23 : 30. N VIJAY KUMAR, PROPRIETOR, 213/4, BEHIND JAIN TEMPLE, NARASARAJ ROAD, DAVANGERE SHIVANNA B M, PROPRIETOR VIJAYALAKSHMI TRADING CO., NARASARAJ ROAD, DAVANGERE H E MURTHY, PROPRIEOTR, MARULASIDDESHWAR FERTILIZERS K.R.ROAD, DAVANGERE , 33. RAJU Y G, PROPRIETOR, BHAGYASHREE SEED CENTRE, 181/2, VYSYA BANK, NARASARAJ ROAD, DAVANGERE H G LAKUSH, PROPRIETOR, SUNEEL FERTILIZERS, 179/12, NEXT TO KARUR VYSYA BANK, NARASARAJ ROAD, DAVANGERE P VIJAY KUMAR, PROPRIETOR, VIJAY AGRO CHEMICALS AND SEEDS NARASARAJ ROAD DAVANGERE D B RAGHUNANDAN, PROPRIETOR, SAMRUDHI AGRO CENTRE, 173/4, NARASARAJ ROAD, DAVANGERE H K RAVI, SHIVAKUMAR RAVI FERTILIZERS,

24 : 24 : NARASARAJ ROAD, DAVANGERE C M JAYAPPA, GURUBASAVA AGRO AGENCY, NARASARAJ ROAD, DAVANGERE G H SUKUMAR, PROPRIETOR GUMMANUR SRI CHANNABASAVESHWARA AGRO AGENCIES, 219/10, NARASARA ROAD, DAVANGERE , 40. M BANIDA, BETUR MARADI KRUSHI SAMPATHU, 222/1, NARASARAJ ROAD, DAVANGERE J B BHAKTAVATSALAM, PROPRIETOR, 284/1, MAHAVEER ROAD, DAVANGERE B M UVAYA KUMAR, PROPRIETOR, BALEHOLADA AGRO AGENCIES, 219/13, NARASARAJ ROAD, DAVANGERE GNENISH NAIK, SWASTIK SEEDS CO., CHAMARAJENDRA, CIRCLE, MAHAVEER ROAD, DAVANGERE G E MAHANTESH, PROPRIETOR, CHETANA SEEDS CENTRE OLD HOSPITAL ROAD, (NEAR CHAMARAJENDRA CIRCLE) DAVANGERE

25 : 25 : 45. K H KESHAVAMURTHY, PROPRIETOR, MARUTI AGRO FERTILIZERS, CHAMARAJPET, DAVANGERE S J SREEDHAR, SRINIDHI AGRO CHEMICALS, 275/2C, BELAGAVI COMPLEX, CHAMARAJPET, DAVANGERE H A GIRISH, PROPRIETOR, BALAJI AGRO AGENCIES, 378/1 CHAMARAJPET, DAVANGERE B A KOTRESHAPPA, PROPRIETOR, KOTTURESHWARA TRADERS, NARASARAJA ROAD, DAVANGERE G K ARVIND KUMAR, PROPRIETOR, BANASHANKARI AGRO AGENCIES, 688, NARASARAJA ROAD, DAVANGERE K A VISHWANATH, KARNATAKA AGRO FERTILIZERS, 689/2, VEERESH NILAYA, NEAR GANESHA TEMPLE, NARASARAJA ROAD, DAVANGERE T S SANKAPPA, PROPRIETOR, PRASHANTH AGRO FERTILIZERS, N.R.ROAD, DAVANGERE V BASAVARAJAPPA, VENKATESHWARA AGRO FERTILIZERS,

26 : 26 : K.R.ROAD, DAVANGERE B K KUBERAPPA, BHAVIHAL KALLESHWARA AGRO CENTRE, OPP. KSRTC BUS STAND, A-3, PB ROAD, DAVANGERE G JAYAPRAKASH, PROPRIEOTR SRI RAGHAVENDRA TRADING COMPANY, DAVANGERE KUMAR AGRO AGENCIES, 217/2, NARASARAJA ROAD, DAVANGERE K V JAYADEVAPPA, PROPRIEOTR VEERABHADRESHWARA AGRO AGENCIES, 211/A-3, NARASARAJA ROAD, DAVANGERE PRORPIETOR, SREE BASAVESHWARA AGRO CENTRE, CHAMARAJAPET, DAVANGERE , 58. N G SWAMY, PROPRIETOR, VISHWABANDHU FERTILIZERS, K.R.ROAD, DAVANGERE M SHADAKAPPA, PROPRIETOR, SREE NANDI AGRO FERTILIZERS, 145/2E, K.R.ROAD, DAVANGERRE D J HALESHI, BASAVESHWARA AGRO AGENCIES, K.R.ROAD, DAVANGERE

27 : 27 : 61. M SATYANARAYAN, DIVYABHIRAMI AGENCIES, NO.323/5, CHIGATERI COMPOUND, OLD HOSPITAL ROAD, DAVANGERE H N SHIVAKUMAR, PROPRIETOR, SREE SIDDESWARA SEEDS CENTRE, 133/1, K.R.ROAD, DAVANGERE G LAXMIDEVI, PROPRIETOR, SINGRIHALLI AGRO FERTILIZERS, NARASARAJA ROAD, DAVANGERE R G BADARINATHA, PROPRIETOR, SRIKAR AGENCIES, 242/A, NEAR HASABAVI CIRCLE, CHAMARAJPET, DAVANGERE B CHIDANAND, PROPRIETOR, SEEDS CENTRE, MAHAVEER ROAD, DAVANGERE K JAYACHANDRAPPA, DEEPA AGRO AGENCIES, K.R.ROAD, DAVANGERE PETITIONERS (BY SRI. B.N.SHIVANNA, ADVOCATE) A N D 1. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA, ITS SECY, DEPARTMENT OF AGRICULTURE, M.S.BUILDING, BANGALORE-1

28 : 28 : 2. THE DIRECTOR OF AGRICULTURE, OFFICE OF THE DIRECTORATE OF AGRICULTURE, SESHADRI ROAD BANGALORE THE JOINT DIRECTOR OF AGRICULTURE, THE LICENCING AUTHORITY OF INSECTICIDE PESTICIDE, RUNGICIDE AND SEEDS, SITTING IN CHITRADURGA COVERING ENTIRE DAVANGERE AND CHITRADURGA 4. THE DEPUTY DIRECTOR OF AGRICULTURE, DAVANGERE TALUK DAVANGERE. 5. THE ASSISTANT DIRECTOR OF AGRICULTURE, DAVANGERE TALUK DAVANGERE DISTRICT....RESPONDENTS (BY SMT. K.VIDYAVATHI, ADDL. GOVT. ADVOCATE) THIS WP FILED UNDER ARTICLES 226 & 227 OF CONSTITUTION OF INDIA PRAYING TOQUASH THE IMPUGNED ORDER VIDE ANN-A DT BY R5 UNDER THE DIRECTION BY R3; AND DIRECT R3 TO RENEW THE PETITIONERS LICENCE PAYMENT OF RS IN W.P.NO.9867/2000 BETWEEN 1. LAKSHMI TRADING CO., NO.10, 3RD CROSS, S.C.ROAD, BANGALORE , SRI. SHEKAR BABU.

29 : 29 : 2. KOMANNA SEEDS, CARNATGON ROAD, BANGARPET, SRI. M.PERUMAL. 3. SREE MANJUNATHA ENTERPRISES, KADUGODI MAIN ROAD, BANGALORE SRI. M.R.NATARAM. 4. AKSHAYA AGRO SEEDS PVT LTD., NO.7, POOJA COMPLEX, 3RD MAIN, CHAMARAJPET, BANGALORE SRI. S.C.MURTHY. 5. INDIAN HYBRID SEEDS CO NO.72, KALASIPALYAM MAIN ROAD BANGALORE , SYED REHAMATHULLA 6. SRI VINAYAKA AGRO TRADERS, NO.2/9, TRINETRA MARKET, 3 RD MAIN, N.T.PET, BANGALORE SRI. S.V.MURALIDHAR 7. INDUSTRIES AND CHEMICALS NO.2/1, TRINETRA COMPLEX 3 RD MAIN, N.T.PET, BANGALORE SRI S.V.MURALIDHAR 8. MAHESHWARA ENTERPRISES NO.4/1, 3 RD MIAN ROAD

30 : 30 : N.T.PET, BANGALORE , SRI. N.MALLIKARJUN 9. S.R.AGRO SALES, NO.36/1, NARASIMHARAJA ROAD, OOSMARIA BUILDING, BANGALORE. SHAHTAJ BEGUM. 10. A.R.SHARIFF AND SONS, NO.15, NARASIMHARAJA ROAD, BANGALORE. BASHEER AHMED SHARIFF. 11. SRINIVASA AGRO AGENCIES, NO.18, N.R.ROAD, BANGALORE-2, SRI. S.S.SHESHADRI. 12. MERUT AGRO CHEMICALS NO.18, N.R.ROAD BANGALORE SRI VENKATESH 13. KARNATAKA PESTICIDES AND AGENCIES, NO.18, N.R.ROAD BANGALORE GAYATHRI 14. SRI RAMA AGENCIES, NO.18, N.R.ROAD, BANGALORE , SRI. S.SHESHADRI

31 : 31 : 15. SRINIVASA FERTILIZERS, CHELUR ROAD, CHINTAMANI , SRI. N.NAGIREDDY 16. SHANKAR FERTILIZERS, FERTILIZE DEALER, CHELUR RAOD, CHINTAMANI SRI. D.GOPALA REDDY. 17. S.L.V. TRADERS, CHELUR ROAD, CHINTAMANI SRI. R.D.KRISHNA 18. SREE MAHANANDI SEEDS AND PESTICIDES, NO.2, A.P.M.C COMPLEX, 2 ND WARD, CHELUR ROAD, CHINTAMANI, KOLAR DISTRICT. SRI. N.NARAYANA SWAMY 19. SRI VANI TRADERS, CHELUR ROAD, A.P.M.C YARD, CHINTAMANI , SRI. V.NARAYANASWAMY 20. I.N.R. SEEDS & PESTICIDES, CHELUR ROAD, CHINTAMANI , SRI. N.SRINIVASA REDDY.

32 : 32 : 21. RAITHABANDHU TRADERS, CHELUR ROAD, CHINTAMANI REPRESENTED. BY SRI. K.R.SRINIVASA REDDY 22. RAJANI TRADERS, NEAR WOOD LANDS, M.G.ROAD, CHINTAMAI SRI. K.S.AUJAPPA 23. MARUTHI FERTILIZERS, CHELUR ROAD, CHINTAMANI, SRI. B.K.CHANDRA MOHAN 24. SRI. VIJAY AGRO TRADERS, GAJANANA CIRCLE, M.G.ROAD, CHINTAMANI , SRI. R.RAMESH BABU. 25. Y.C.A. TRADERS, FERTILIZER TRADERS, M.G.ROAD, CHINTAMANI SRI. Y.L.ADINARAYANA SETTY. 26. RAGHURAM SEEDS AND FERTILIZERS, CHELUR, CHINTAMANI , SRI. VENKATA RAMANA SETTY 27. LAKSHMI TRADERS, NO.14, STADIUM COMPLEX,

33 : 33 : DOUBLE ROAD, CHINTAMANI. SRI. C.SHIVANNA 28. VIJAYA LAKSHMI SEEDS, OPP. BUS STAND, CHINTAMANI, SRI. GOVINDA REDDY 29. KALPRARUKSHA TRADERS, CHELUR ROAD, CHINTAMANI. SRI. D.S.MALLIKARJUN 30. C.NAGARAJ, DEALERS IN FERTILIZERS PESTICIDES & SEEDS, OLD BUS STAND, DODDABALLAPUR SRI. C.NAGARAJ. 31. G GOVINDARAJ DEALERS IN FERTILIZERS SEEDS AND AGRO CHEMICALS OLD BUS STAND DODDABALLAPUR SRI. G.GOVINDARAJU 32. SAPTAGIRI TRADERS, PADMA COMPLEX, OPP. POST OFFICE, B.B.ROAD, YELAHANKA SRI. H.G.SRINVASA....PETITIONERS (BY SRI. S.K.V. CHALAPATHY & K.N.SREENIVAS, ADVS.,)

34 : 34 : A N D : 1. UNIOIN OF INDIA, JT SECRETARY (PLANT PRODUCTION) MINISTRY OF AGRICULTURE, DEPARTMENT OF AGRICULTURE AND CO.OPERATION, KRISHI BHAVAN, NEW DELHI THE DIRECTOR, DEPARTMENT OF AGRICULTURE, GOVERNMENT OF KARNATAKA, SESHADRI ROAD, BANGALORE....RESPONDENTS (BY SMT. K.VIDYAVATHI, ADDL. GOVT. ADV., FOR R2) THIS W.P. FILED UNDER ARTICLES 226 & 227 OF CONSTITUTION OF INDIA PRAYING TO QUASH THE AMENDED RULE 10 UNDER ANX.A AND B IN SO FAR AS IT RELATES TO PRESCRIBING THE FEES OF RS.500 FOR EVERY INSECTICIDE FOR GRANT OR RENEWAL OF LICENSCE SUBJECT TO A MAXIMUM OF RS.7,500/ IN W.P. NO.11825/2000 BETWEEN 1. KARNATAKA STATE FERTILISERS SEEDS & PESTICIDES DEALERS' ASSOCIATION, NO.2, II FLOOR III MAIN ROAD, NEW THARAGUPET, BANGALORE , BY ITS HONORARY SECY SRI. S.SHIVAKUMAR 2. SRI. G GURUSIDDAIAH, MAJOR,

35 : 35 : S/O G.GURUBASAVAIAH M/S EESHA AGTEC & M/S DHAANYA GREEN TECH 16 & 16/1, 9 TH A MAIN, 36 TH CROSS, 5 TH BLOCK, JAYANAGAR, BANGALORE SRI PARSWANATH, MAJOR, S/O R J ANANTHARAJAIAH PROP: OMKAR AGENCIES I MAIN ROAD, NEW MANDIPET TUMKUR SRI. D.NARAYANA, MAJOR, S/O D.VENKATARAJAIAH PROP: SRI POONAM ASSICIATES NO.93, 3 RD MAIN, NEW THARAGUPET, BANGALORE SRI VASANTHA A, MAJOR, S/O C K ASWATHA SETTY PROP: KUNCHAM TRADERS II MAIN ROAD, NEW MANDIPET TUMKUR 6. SRI CHANDRA BABU G.A., MAJOR, S/O G.AYYANNA PROP: MANJU AGENCIES I MAIN ROAD, NEW MANDIPET, TUMKUR. 7. SRI SIDDAGANGAPPA MAJOR, S/O B.RUDRAPPA PROP: SRI MANJUNATHA FERTILISERS I MAIN ROAD, NEW MANDIPET TUMKUR SMT MANJULA L., MAJOR, W/O G P MUDALAGIRI PROP: M/S SRINIDHI FERTILISERS

36 : 36 : SIDDIVINAYAKA VEGETABLE MARKET TUMKUR SMT B S SUSHEELA MAJOR, W/O CHANDRAPPA PROP: M/S SWAMY AYYAPPA FERTILISERS I MAIN, MANDIPET TUMKUR 10. SMT NALINI NAGESH MAJOR, W/O S R NAGESH PROP: GARDEN CITY AGRICULTURAL AGENCIES, NO.292, KANAKAPURA MAIN ROAD, JAYANAGAR VII BLOCK BANGALORE PETITIONERS (BY SRI. N.G.PHADKE & MEERA BAI, ADVOCATES) A N D : 1. UNION OF INDIA, JOINT SECRETARY (PLANT PROTECTION) MINISTRY OF AGRICULTURE, DEPT OF AGRICULTURE & COOPERATION, KRISHI BHAVAN. NEW DELHI STATE OF KARNATAKA, ITS PRINCIPAL SECRETARY, AGRICULTURAL & HORTICULTURAL DEPT. VIDHANA SOUDHA, BANGALORE RESPONDENTS (BY SMT. K.VIDYAVATHI, ADDL. GOVT. ADV., FOR R2) THIS W.P. IS FILED UNDER ARTICLES 226 & 227 OF CONSTITUTION OF INDIA PRAYING TOQUASH THE IMPUGNED NOTIFICATION IN G.S.R.NO.371 (E) DT

37 : 37 : IN SO FAR AS IT RELATES TO THE AMENDMENT OF RULE 10(2) OF THE INSECTICIDES RULES, IN W.P.NO.21915/2000 BETWEEN J M KOTRESH PROPRIETOR M/S SRIGURU AGRO AGENCIES DEALER IN PESTICIDES 227/1, MAHAVEER NILAYA NEAR DELUXE ROADLINES NARASARAJ ROAD,DAVANGERE N G RAMAKRISHNA GENERAL MANAGER JAGANMATHA AGRO SALES PVT. LTD DEALER IN PESTICIDES SRI BALAJI BUILDING BINNY COMPANY ROAD DAVANGERE THIPPESWAMY SUNEEL FERTILIZERS DALER IN PESTICIDES 179/12, NEXT TO KARUR VYSYA BANK NARASARAJ ROAD DAVANGERE 4. M S BASAVARJAPPA PROPRIETOR, BHADRA HYBRID SEEDS COMPANY, DEALER IN PESTICIDES AGRO COMPLEX, SHOP NO.2 P.B.ROAD, DAVANGERE M K CHANDRASHEKARAPPA PROPRIETOR

38 : 38 : MULLEKATTE SHIVALINGAPPA & CO. DEALER IN PESTICIDES 240/1, BEHIND CHAMARAJPET DAVANGERE M K CHANDRSHEKARAPPA PROPRIETOR SHEKAR AGRO SERVICE CENTRE DEALER IN PESTICIDES NO.240, CHAMARAJPET DAVANGERE G.KRISHNAMURTHY PROPRIETOR MAHALAXMI AGRO AGENCIES DEALER IN PESTICIDES 173/2A, NARASARAJ ROAD DAVANGERE-1 8. G.N.PATEL, PROPRIETOR M/S PATEELA AGENCIES DEALER IN PESTICIDES 162/2, NARASARAJ ROAD DAVANGERE-1 9. V.D.LAXMESHWAR PROPRIETOR M/S SHRIRAM AGRO AGENCIES DEALER IN PESTICIDES 221/6, ALUR BASAPPA BUILDING NARASARAJ ROAD DAVANGERE K.H.RAMESH, PROPRIETOR MARUTHI AGRO INPUTS DEALER IN PESTICIDES 280/3, R.G.N. BUILDING, MAHAVEER ROAD (CHAMARAJENDRA CIRCLE), DAVANGERE-1

39 : 39 : 11. N.B.BHUMA, PROPRIETOR MYSORE SEEDS CORPORATION DEALER IN PESTICIDES 227/3, NARASARAJ ROAD DAVANGERE R.G.MANJUNATH, PROPRIETOR BASAVESWARA AGRO CENTRE DEALER IN PESTICIDES CHAMARAJPET, DAVANGERE G.THIMMAPPA, PROPRIETOR G.VEERABASAOOA & CO., DELAER IN PESTICIDES HADADI ROAD DAVANGERE K.PRASAD, PROPRIETOR SREE VENAKTESHWARA AGRO FERTILISERS DEALER IN PESTICIDES DOOR NO.281/D, CHAMARAJ CIRCLE MAHAVEER ROAD DAVANGERE T.N.UMESH, PROPRIETOR SRI KALLESHWARA AGRO CORPORATION DEALER IN PESTICIDES 249/2, CHAMARAJPET DAVANGERE PRAGATI AGRO FERTILIZERS DEALER IN PESTICIDES NARASARAJ ROAD DAVANGERE B.VIRUPAKSHA, PROPRIETOR ASHWINI AGRO AGENCIES DELAER IN PESTICIDES 231/4,, NARASARAJ ROAD

40 : 40 : DAVANGERE P.S.LAXMINARAYANA PROPRIETOR SRI VASAVI SEEDS CENTRE DEALER IN PESTICIDES 283, MAHAVEER ROAD DAVANGERE S.VENAKTESH, PROPRIEOTR SRI THIRUMALA AGRO AGENCIES DEALER IN PESTICIDES CHURCH COMPLEX, K.R.ROAD DAVANGERE G.S.PRAKASH, PROPRIETOR AGRO HYBRID SEEDS CORPORATION DEALER IN PESTICIDES DR.NAGANAGOWDA BUILDING OLD HOSPITAL ROAD DAVANGERE Y.DEVANDRAPPA, PROPRIETOR VINAYAKA AGRO KENDRA DEALER IN PESTICIDES 201/2, NARASARAJ ROAD DAVANGERE S.V.SUBHASH, PROPRIETOR SHRIRAKSHA AGRO AGENCIES DEALER IN PESTICIDES 288/1-B, I FLOOR CHAMARAJPET DAVANGERE NIRMALAMMA PROPRIETOR, ADITYA AGRO AGNECIES DEALER IN PESTICIDES 211/3, NARASARAJ ROAD OPP. KARUR VYSYA BANK

41 : 41 : DAVANGERE K.H.NAGARAJ, PROPRIETOR SRI. RENUKA AGRO AGENCIES DEALER IN PESTICIDES APMC DEPOT NO.6 OPP. NEW BUS STAND, P.B.ROAD DAVANGERE D.E.DEVENDRAPPA, PROPRIETOR SRINIDHI SEEDS CENTRE DEALER IN PESTICIDES 284, MAHAVEER RAOD DAVANGERE M.H.NIJANANANDA, PROPRIEOTR AGRO INDUSTRIAL CORP., DEALER IN PESTICIDES PSOT BOX NO.85 MANDIPET, DAVANGERE B.R.SRINIVAS, PROPRIETOR GOVARDHAN AGRO AGENCIES DEALER IN PESTICIDES 195/1, NARASARAJ ROAD DAVANGERE-1...PETITIONERS (BY SRI. B.N.SHIVANNA, ADVOCATE) AND 1. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA, ITS SECRETARY, DEPARTMENT OF AGRICULTURE, M.S.BUILDING, BANGALORE THE DIRECTOR OF AGRICULTURE, OFFICE OF THE DIRECTORATE OF

42 : 42 : AGRICLTURE, SESHADRI ROAD, BANGALORE THE JOINT DIRECTOR OF AGRICULTURE, THE LICENCING AUTHORITY OF INSECTICIDE, PESTICIDE FUNGICIDE AND SEEDS SITTING IN CHITRADURGA COVERING ENTIRE DAVANGERE AND CHITRADURGA DISTRICTS. 4. THE DEPUTY DIRECTOR OF AGRICULTURE, DAVANGERE TALUK, DAVANGERE DISTRICT. 5. THE ASSISTANT DIRECTOR OF AGRICUTLURE, DAVANGERE TALUK, DAVANGERE DISTRICT....RESPONDENTS (BY SMT. K.VIDYAVATHI, ADDL. GOVT. ADVOCATE) THIS W.P. FILED UNDER ARTICLES 226 & 227 OF CONSTITUTION OF INDIA PRAYING TO DIRECT THE R3 TO RENEW THE LICENCE BY TAKING RS. 30/- TO CARRY ALL COMPANIES INSECTICIDE BUSINESS AND QUASH VIDE ANX. A DT ISSUED BY THE R5 UNDER THE DIRECTION BY R IN W.P. NO.22311/2000 BETWEEN 1. K SRINIVASALU, PROPRIETOR ABHILASH AGRO SEEDS DELAER IN PESTICIDES MUNICIPAL STALL NO.9

43 : 43 : DOUBLE ROAD BELLARY D S MALLIKARJUNA, PROPRIETOR ANUPAMA AGENCIES DEALER IN PESTICIDES OPP:KSRTC BUS STAND DOUBLE ROAD BELLARY K RAMAPPA, PROPRIETOR USHA AGRO SEEDS DEALER IN PESTICIDES MUNICIPAL STAL NO.3 DOUBLE ROAD BELLARY D HANUMANTHARAO, PROPRIETOR SRI. VIJAYALAKSHMI AGRO SEEDS, DEALERS IN PESTICIDES MUNICIPAL STALL NO.14, DOUBLE ROAD, BELLARY B V MUKKANAN, PROPRIETOR ASHOK AGRO SEED SUPPLIES DEALERS IN PESTICIDES K.C.ROAD, BELLARY E R MOHAN, PROPRIETOR ANANDATHA HYBRID SEEDS DEALERS IN PESTICIDES 2-A, K.C.ROAD BELLARY D BALIREDDI, PROPRIETOR SHREE SIDDESHWARA AGENCIES DEALERS IN PESTICIDES MEENAKSHI COMPLEX SHOP NO.1, K.C.ROAD

44 : 44 : BELLARY T NAGESHWARRAO, PROPRIETOR SARITHA AGRO SEEDS DEALERS IN PESTICIDES MEENAKSHI LODGE STALL, STALL NO.7, K.C.ROAD BELLARY PETITIONERS (BY SRI. B.N.SHIVANNA, ADVOCATE) AND 1. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA, ITS SECY, DEPARTMENT OF AGRICULTURE, M.S.BUILDING, BANGALORE THE DIRECTOR OF AGRICULTURE, OFFICE OF THE DIRECTORATE OF AGRICULTURE, SESHADRI ROAD BANGALORE THE JOINT DIRECTOR OF AGRICULTURE THE LICENCING AUTHORITY OF INSECTICIDE, PESTICIDE, FUNGICIDE AND SEEDS, SITTING IN BELLARY COVERING ENTIRE BELARY DISTRICT. 4. THE DEPUTY DIRECTOR OF AGRICULTURE, BELLARY TALUK, BELLARY DISTRICT. 5. THE ASSISTANT DIRECTOR OF AGRICULTURE, BELLARY TALUK, BELLARY DISTRICT....RESPONDENTS (By SMT. K.VIDYAVATHI, ADDL. GOVT. ADVOCATE)

45 : 45 : THIS W.P. FILED UNDER ARTICLES 226 & 227 OF CONSTITUTION OF INDIA PRAYING TO QUASH THE ORDER VIDE ANNEX.A. DT. ISSUED BY R5 UNDER THE DIRECTION BY THE R3; AND DIRECT R3 TO RENEW THE LICENSE OF PETITIONER NO.1 TO 8 BY TAKING RS. 30/ IN W.P. NO.32144/2000 BETWEEN CHINTAMANI TALUK AGRICULTURAL MARKETING CO-OP SOCIETY LTD, CHINTAMANI, KOLAR DISTRICT, BY ITS SERCRETARY, SRI. K.V.NARASIMHA MURTHY, S/O VENKATARAYAPPA, MAJOR....PETITIONER (BY SRI Y.R.SADASIVA REDDY, ADVOCATE) AND 1. UNION OF INDIA, ITS JOINT SECRETARY (PLANT PRODUCTION), MINISTRY OF AGRICULTURE, DEPARTMENT OF AGRICULTURE & COOPERATION, KRISHI BHAVAN, NEW DELHI THE DIRECTOR, DEPARTMEN TOF AGRICULTURE, GOVERNMENT OF KARNATAKA, SESHADRIPURAM, BANGALORE RESPONDENTS (BY SRI. ASHOK HARANAHALLI, ADVOCATE FOR R1

46 : 46 : SMT. K.VIDYAVATHI, ADDL. GOVT. ADV., FOR R2) THIS W.P. FILED UNDER ARTICLES 226 & 227 OF CONSTITUTION OF INDIA PRAYING TO QUASH VIDE ANX. A AND B IN SO FAR AS IT RELATES TO PRESCRIBING THE FEES OF RS.500 FOR EVERY INSECTICIDES FOR GRANT OR RENEWAL OF LICENCE SUBJECT TO A MAXIMUM OF RS.7,500/ IN W.P. NO.3880/2000 BETWEEN K H KESHAVAMURTHY, MAJOR, PRESIDENT OF DAVANGERE DISTRICT PESTICIDE FERTILISERS AND SEED DEALERS ASSOCIATION, DAVANGERE....PETITIONER (BY SRI. B.N.SHIVANNA, ADVOCATE) AND 1. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA, ITS SECRETARY, DEPARTMENT OF AGRICULTURE, M.S.BUILDING, BANGALORE THE DIRECTOR OF AGRICULTURE, OFFICE OF THE DIRECTORATE OF AGRICULTURE, SESHADRIPURAM ROAD, BANGALORE-1 3. THE JOINT DIRECTOR OF

47 : 47 : AGRICULTURE, DAVANGERE TALUK, DISTRICT: DAVANGERE. 4. THE DEPUTY DIRECTOR OF AGRICULTURE, DAVANGERE TALUK, DISTRICT: DAVANGERE. 5. THE ASSISTANT DIRECTOR OF AGRICULTURE, DAVANGERE, TALUK: DAVANGERE, DISTRICT: DAVANGERE....RESPONDENTS (BY SMT. K.VIDYAVATHI, ADDL. GOVT. ADVOCATE) THIS WP FILED UNDER ARTICLES 226 & 227 OF CONSTITUTION OF INDIA PRAYING TO QUASH THE IMPUGNED ORDER VIDE ANN-A DT BY R IN W.P. NO.433/2001 BETWEEN 1. K SUBBA RAO, PROP: SRI GURUDATTA ENTERPRISES CHAMARAJPET, DAVANAGERE 2. R P M GOVARDAN, PROP: M/S SREE RAMANJANEYA FARM SUPPLIES DEALERS IN FERTILISERS & INSECTICIDES 32/1, BANGALORE ROAD, BELLARY B V VALLABAI PATEL, PROP: M/S SRI MANJUNATHA AGRO SEED SUPPLIES, NO.105/2, 16TH WARD BANGALORE ROAD BELLARY

48 : 48 : 4. B VALLABAI PATEL, PROP: M/S SRI MANJUNATHA AGRO SEED SUPPLIES, NO.16/2, 9TH WARD BANGALORE ROAD BELLARY B KANAKA REDDY, PROP: M/S SRI VENKATADRI ENTERPRISES STALL NO.15,OPP: NATARAJA THEATRE DOUBLE ROAD, BELLARY 6. S D CHANNEGOWDA, PROP: M/S AMARESHWARA AGRO AGENCIES 108/XVI, KRISHNACHARI ROAD BELLARY SHANTHI TRADING CO., KHANIS COMPLEX, NEAR PROP: TALED, RADHAKRISHNA ROAD BELLARY, VIJAYAKUAMR TALED BELLARY 8. SRI MANJUNATH AGRO CENNTRE PANCHAJANYA COMPLEX 101/B, K.R.ROAD DAVANAGERE. 9. SRI. TARALABALU AGRO SERVICE, DOOR NO.101/B, K R ROAD, DAVANAGERE NATIONAL CHEMICALS & FERTILIZERS, NO.306, III MAIN, N T PET, BANGALORE DHANDDEVI TRADERS, PROP: DHANRAJ JAIN, PESTICIDES DEALERS MAIN ROAD, GANGAVATHI

49 : 49 : KOPPAL. 12. SREELAKHA AGENCIES, PROP: M BALAIAH, K.C.ROAD, BELLARY....PETITIONERS (BY SRI. B.N.SHIVANNA, C.C.NARAYANA, ADVOCATES) AND 1. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA, ITS SECRETARY, DEPARTMENT OF AGRICULTURE, M.S.BUILDING, BANGALORE THE DIRECTOR OF AGRICULTURE, OFFICE OF THE DIRECTORATE OF AGRICULTURE, SESHADRI ROAD, BANGALORE THE JOINT DIRECTOR OF AGRICULTURE THE LICENSING AUTHORITY OF INSECTICIDE, PESTICIDE, FUNGICIDE AND SEEDS, SITTING IN BELLARY. COVERING ENTIRE BELLARY DISTRICT 4. THE JOINT DIRECTOR OF AGRICULTURE BANGALORE RURAL & URBAN DIST THE LICENSING AUTHORITY OF INSECTICIDES, PESTICIDES, BANGALORE. 5. JOINT DIRECTOR OF AGRICULTURE, BANGALORE RURAL AND URBAN DIST. 6. THE JOINT DIRECTOR OF AGRICULTURE, DAVANAGERE TALUK, DAVANAGERE DISTRICT. 7. THE ASST DIRECTOR OF

50 : 50 : AGRICULTURE BELLARY DIST., BELLARY....RESPONDENTS (BY SMT. K.VIDYAVATHI, ADDL. GOVT. ADVOCATE) THIS WP FILED UNDER ARTICLES 226 & 227 OF CONSTITUTION OF INDIA PRAYING TO DIRECT THE R3 TO RENEW THE PETITIONER LICENCE BY TAKING RS.30/-; AND QUASH THE IMPUGNED ORDER VIDE ANN-A ISSUED BY R IN W.P. No.194/2002 BETWEEN 1. DAVULURI RADHAKRISHNA MURTHY PROPRIETOR, SRINIVASA AGRO CHEMICALS D.NO. 97/4, (L) WARD XVI KRISHNAMACHARI RAOD BELLARY K MANIKYAM, PROPRIEOTR M/S. ASHWINI AGRO CHEMICALS D.NO. 212/3, COMMING ROAD OPP PANDURANGA TEMPLE BELLARY P BASAVANA GOUDA, PROPRIETOR SREE GURU KATTE BASAWESHWARA FERTILISERS AND CHEMICALS CAR STREET NEAR KANEEKAL BUSSTAND BELLARY BASAVANAGOUDA S PROPRIETOR SAGAR AGRO AGENCIES

51 : 51 : STALL N.2 G.S. COMPLEX, K.C. ROAD BELLARY H SHIVA KUMAR, PROPRIETOR GANGADHAR AGENCIES D.NO. 90, WARD NO. XIV K.C. ROAD BELLARY G INATHAREDDY, PROPRIETOR SREE KRISHNA TRADING CO HAVINAHAL SHARANAPAP COMPELX BALAJIRAO ROAD BELLARY P HANUMANTHA REDDY PROPRIETOR LAKSHMIVENKATESHWARA TRADERS OPP ADB BANK NEAR KSRTC BUS STAND BELLARY Y ESWARA RAO PROPRIETOR ANNAPURA AGRO AGENCIES K.C. ROAD BELLARY PETITIONERS (BY SRI B.N.SHIVANNA & C.C.NARAYANA, ADVOCATES) AND 1. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA, ITS SECRETARY, DEPARTMENT OF AGRICULTURE, M.S. BUILDING, BANGALORE THE DIRECTOR OF AGRICULTURE, OFFICE OF THE DIRECTORATE OF

52 : 52 : AGRICULTURE, SESHADRI ROAD, BANGALORE THE JOINT DIRECTOR OF AGRICULTURE, THE LICENSING AUTHORITY OF INSECTICIDE, PESTICIDE FUNGICIDE AND SEEDS, SITTING IN BELLARY COVERING ENTIRE, BELLARY DISTRICT. 4. THE DEPUTY DIRECTOR OF AGRIL BELLARY TALUK, BELLARY DISTRICT. 5. THE ASSISTANT DIRECTOR OF AGRICULTURE, BELLARY TALUK, BELLARY DISTRICT....RESPONDENTS (BY SMT. K.VIDYAVATHI, ADDL. GOVT. ADVOCATE) THIS WP FILED UNDER ARTICLES 226 & 227 OF CONSTITUTION OF INDIA PRAYING TO QUASH THE IMPUGNED ORDER VIDE ANN-A DT. IN NO. ISSUED BY THE FIFTH RESPONDENT UNDER THE DIRECTION BY R3; AND DIRECT R3 TO RENEW THE LICENSE OF PETITIONER NO.1 TO 8 BY TAKING RS.30/-. IN W.P. NO.13838/2002 BETWEEN PRAKASH AGRO AGENCIES FILTER BED ROAD UDNOOR COMPLEX NEHRU GUNJ GULBARGA BY ITS PROPRIETOR PRAKASH K SUTAR AGE:32 YEARS 2. M/S. NAGARAJ AGRO AGENCY FILTERBED ROAD

53 : 53 : GULBARGA BY ITS PROPRIETOR SRI. NAGENDRAPPA TADKAL AGE:40 YEARS 3. MAHAVEER AGRO SERVICE CENTRE NEHRU GUNJ GULBARGA BY ITS PROPRIETOR PADMARAJ VARDHAMAN AGE:32 YEARS....PETITIONERS (BY SRI. SHARANABASSAPPA K.BABSHETTY, ADVOCATE) AND 1. UNION OF INDIA, BY ITS SECRETARY, DEPARTMENT OF AGRICULTURE, AND CO.OPERATION (KRISHI BHAVAN) DR. RAJENDRA PRASAD ROAD, NEW DELHI. 2. DIRECTOR OF AGRICULTURE, K.R.CIRCLE, BANGALORE....RESPONDENTS (BY SMT. K.VIDYAVATHI, ADDL. GOVT. ADV., FOR R2) (R1-SD) THIS W.P. FILED UNDER ARTICLES 226 & 227 OF CONSTITUTION OF INDIA PRAYING TO DECLARE THAT RULE 10(2) (a) OF THE INTECTICIDE (AMENDED) RULES, 1999 AS UNCONSTITUTIONAL AND ARBITRARY.

54 : 54 : In W.P. No.17712/2002 BETWEEN 1. SRI.S M BASAVARAJA PROPRIETOR, AGE: 42 YEARS, M/S. ANNAPURANA AGRO AGENCIES, SHOP NO.01, S LINGANNA COMPLEX, CAR STREET, BELLARY SRI.A KRISHNA PROPRIETOR, AGE: 38 YEARS, M/s. SREE LAKSHMI VENKATESHWARA TRADERS, 59/1, 11 TH WARD CAR STREET, BELLARY SRI.J HARINATH AGE: 44 YEARS S/O J BHEEMAPPA SHETTY, PROPRIETOR, M/s.HARI CHEMICALS AND FERTILISERS, D.NO.32, WARD NO.7 TH, OPP.NAGARESWARA TEMPLE, BANGALORE ROAD, BELLARY SRI. M M ULLAGADDI PROPRIETOR, AGE: 49 YEARS, M/s.VISHWARADYA AGRO SUPPLIES D NO.48, WARD NO.11, DODDABASAVESWARA COMPLEX, CAR STREET, BELLARY SRI.RAJASHEKAR GOWDA PROPRIETOR, AGE: 35 YEARS, M/s.SREE VIRUPAKSHESWARA SWAMY AGRO CHEMICALS, NEAR OLD RAYADURGA BUS - STAND BANGALORE ROAD, BELLARY

55 : 55 : 6. SRI.N T ASWATH NARAYANA AGE: 29 YEARS, S/O N T HANUMANTHA RAYADU PROPRIETOR Ms.N T HANUMANTH RAYUDU OLD RAYADURGA BUS STAND, BANGALORE ROAD, BELLARY SRI.S WADIYAR PROPRIETOR, AGE 46 YEARS, M/s.SWATHI ENTERPRISES SREE LAKSHMI NARASIMHA COMPLEX K C ROAD, BELLARY SRI.V ANJINAYALU, AGE: 32 YEARS, S/O VERAIAH, PROPRIETOR M/s.VIGNESHWARA ENTERPRISES SHOP NO.02 S LINGANNA COMPLEX KANEKAL BUS STAND, CAR STREET, BELLARY SRI.SRIMANNARAYANA AGE: 33 YEARS, S/O MASTAN RAO M/s.VIGNESHWARA CHEMICALS & PESTICIDES S LINGANNA COMPLEX SHOP NO 6 KANEKAL BUS STAND, CAR STREET BELLARY SRI. P CHENNAKESHVALU AGE: 40 YEARS, S/O RAJEVAIAH, PROPRIETOR M/s.VIJAYA LAKSHMI AGRO AGENCIES NEAR KANEKAL BUS STAND CAR STREET, BELLARY

56 : 56 : 11. SRI.P MALLIKARJUNA REDDY PROPRIETOR, AGE: 49 YEARS, M/s.MARUTHI CHEMICALS AND FERTILISERS K C ROAD OPP CHAMBER OF COMMERCE BELLARY SMT.P KOTESHWARI W/O P SAMBA SHIVA RAO AGE: 31 YEARS M/s.VIJAYALAKSHMI AGRO TRADERS BALAJI RAO ROAD BELLARY SRI.P RAMAKOT AGE: 48 YEARS S/O VENKATA RAMAIAH PROPRIETOR M/s. KRISHNA AGRO CHEMICALS DURGAPPA COMPLEX, K C ROAD BELLARY (By Sri.N J BALIGA, Adv.,)... PETITIONERS AND 1. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA, REP. BY ITS SECRETARY, DEPARTMENT OF AGRICULTURE, M S BUILDING, BANGALORE THE DIRECTOR OF AGRICULTURE, OFFICE OF THE DIRECTORATE OF AGRICULTURE, SESHADRI ROAD BANGALORE THE JOINT DIRECTOR OF AGRICULTURE THE LICENSING AUTHORITY IN INSECTICIDE, PESTICIDE FUNGICIDE AND SEEDS

57 : 57 : SITING IN BELLARY COVERING ENTIRE BELLARY DIST 4. THE DEPUTY DIRECTOR OF AGRICULTURE BELLARY - TALUK, BELLARY DIST. 5. THE ASSISTANT DIRECTOR OF AGRICULTURE, BELLARY TALUK, BELLARY DIST....RESPONDENTS (By Smt.K.VIDYAVATHI, AGA) THIS WRIT PETITION IS FILED UNDER ARTICLES 226 & 227 OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA QUASH ANNEXURE-C DATED 12/1/2000 PASSED BY THE 3 RD RESPONDENT. In W.P.No.38334/2002 BETWEEN 1. SMT.L MEENA KUMARI, W/O SRI.B MURALI KRISHNA, AGE: 38 YEARS, M/S SIRI AGRO TECH, SHOP No.2, SIRI COMPLEX, 4 TH CROSS, PATELNAGAR, BELLARY. 2. SRI.B MURALI KRISHNA S/O SRI.B RAMAIAH SETTY AGE: 43 YEARS, M/S SIRI AGRO MARKETERS SHOP No.25/29, 1 ST CROSS, PATELNAGAR, BELLARY. 3. SRI.TEDDY JOSE THEKKEKARA S/O T J JOSE, AGE: 33 YEARS, "BABA ENTEPRISES', 10TH WARD, 100/1 ADHI SHAKTHI COMPLEX,

58 : 58 : CAR STEET, BELLARY 4. SRI.VIJAYA KUMAR GUPTHA S/O SUBHASH KUMAR GUPHAT AGE: 47 YEARS, M/S PARMOUNT PESTICIDES PVT LTD SRI DODDA BASAVESHWARA COMPLEX, No49, 11 TH WARD, CAR STREET, BELLARY. 5. SRI.K SHASHI KRISHNA S/O K KRISHNA MOHAN AGE : 29 YEARS, M/S SREE LAXMI VENKATESHWARA AGRO DISTRIBUTERS, MUDLUR ANGINAPA COMPOUND, MILLARPET, BOMMANL ROAD, BELLARY. 6. SRI.P K MISHRA S/O R K MISHRA AGE: 50 YEARS, M/S SHIPONCHEMICAL PVT LTD., 7/7, MUNDLUR ANJINAPPA COMPOUND, RUPANGADI ROAD, MILLARPET, BELLARY. 7. SRI.G SATHYANARAYANA S/O G APPA RAO AGE: 42 YEARS, M/S HINDUSTAN PEST CONTROL, 303/A, RAGHAVA KRISHNA COMPLEX, K C ROAD, BELLARY. 8. SRI.DORAI RAJ KUPPURANGAM S/O KUPPARANGAM AGE: 56 YEARS, M/S GREEN CROP INTERNATIONAL PVT., LTD., RAGHVA KRISHNA COMPLEX, C-7, BLOCK, K C ROAD, BELLARY... PETITIONERS (By Sri. N J BALIGA : K VENKATA, ADV S.,)

59 : 59 : AND 1. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA ITS SECRETARY, DEPARTMENT OF AGRICULTURE, M S BUILDING, BANGALORE THE DIRECTOR OF AGICULTURE, OFFICE OF THE DIRECTORATE OF AGRICULTURE, SESHADRI ROAD, BANGALORE THE JOINT DIRECTOR OF AGRICULTURE, THE LICENSING AUTHORITY OF INSECTICIDE, PESTICIDE, FUNGICIDE AND SEEDS SITING IN BELLARY COVERING ENTIRE BELLARY DIST. 4. THE DY DIECTOR OF AGRICULTURE BELLARY TQ BELLARY DIST 5. THE ASST DIRECTOR OF AGRICULTURE BELLARY TQ BELLARY DIST... RESPONDENT(S) (By Smt.K.VIDYAVATHI, AGA) THIS WRIT PETITION IS FILED UNDER ARTICLES 226 & 227 OF CONSTITUTION OF INDIA PRAYING TO QUASH VIDE ANNEXURE-C DATED BY R3. In W.P.No.3621/2006 BETWEEN 1. M/S VIJAYA AGRO AGENCIES SHOP NO , NEAR MARGAMMA TEMPLE GUNJ ROAD GULBARGA

60 : 60 : BY ITS PROPRIETOR SRI MADIVALAPPA S/O NINGAPPA HENDOLI AGED 43 YEARS 2. M/S GANGADHAR TRADING CO SHOP NO , ASHOK CHOWK FITTER BED ROAD, GULBARGA BY ITS PROPRIETOR SRI SATISH V RANGA AGED : 31 YEARS 3. M/S GANGA AGRO TRADERS SHOP NO FILTER BED ROAD, GULBARGA BY ITSPROPRIETOR SRI LAXMIKANTH S/O AMBARAYA PAGADI AGED: 40 YEARS 4. M/S KISSAN AGRO AGENCIES SHOP NO , FILTER BED ROAD, GULBARGA, BY ITS PROPRIETOR SRI REVANSIDDAPPA S/O BASAWANAPPA UDAMNALLI AGE: 46 YEARS 5. M/S MALLIKARJUNA SALES CORPORATION SHOP NO D 5, INDUSTRIAL ESTATE, GULBARGA BY ITS PROPRIETOR SRI U.B. CHANDRASHEKAR AGE: 48 YEARS 6. M/S MAHANTESHWAR KRISHI BHANDAR SHOP NO /3 FILTER BED ROAD GULBARGA, BY ITS PROPRIETOR SMT SIDDAMMA W/O SHIVAKUMAR PATIL AGE: 34 YEARS 7. M/S SHUBHAM AGRO SUPPLIES SHOP NO SALI COMPLEX, NEHRU GUNJ, GULBARGA BY ITS PROPRIETOR SRI SHIVAKARANA S/O CHANDRA SHETTY NIGGUDAGI

61 : 61 : AGE: 49 YEARS 8. M/S GANESH AGRO CHEMICALS SHOP NO 8-143/7, UDNOOR COMPLEX, NEHRU GUNJ, GULBARGA BY ITS PARTNER SRI PRASHANT PAUL S/O DEVENDRA KUMAR PAUL AGE: 29 YEARS 9. M/S NARIBOLI AGRO SALES SHOP NO 7, COTTON MARKET GUNJ GULBARGA BY ITS PARTNER SI MADIVALAPPA NINGAPPA HUNDI, AGE: 43 YEARS 10. M/S SURAJ AGRO AGENCIES SHOP NO /27/A3-3, BEHIND CENTRAL WARE HOUSE, NEHRU GUNJ GULBARGA BY ITS PROPRIETOR SMT GEETA W/O SHIVAPPA ANGADI AGE: 44 YEARS 11. M/S BHUVANESHWARI KRISHI KENDRA SHOP NO CMC , HANUMANT TEMPLE COMPLEX GUNJ GULBARGA BY ITS PARNTER SRI PRASAD KUMAR S/O SHIVASHARNAPPA DEGAON AGE: 22 YEAS 12. M/S PEDDI AGRO TECH SHOP NO NETAJI CHOWK GULBARGA BY ITS PROPRIETOR SRI AMARNATH S/O RAJASHEKHAR PADDI AGE: 23 YEARS 13. M/S NAGARAJ AGRO AGENCIES SHOP NO NETAJI CHOWK GUNJ ROAD GULBARGA, BY ITS PROPRIETOR SRI NAGENDRAPPA S/O ANNARAO TADKAL AGE: 44 YEARS

62 : 62 : 14. M/S DANESHWARI AGRO SALES SHOP NO 3, BEHIND HANUMAN TEMPLE NEHRU GUNJ, GULBARGA, BY ITS PARTNER SRI VIJAYKUMAR S/O REVANASIDDAPPA INGINSHETTY AGE: 34 YEARS 15. M/S SURAJ AGENCIES PESTICIDE DEALER SHOP NO /27/A/3-2, BEHIND CENTRAL WARE HOUSE, NEHRU GUNJ GULBARGA BY IS H.U.F. KARTHA SRI SHIVAPPA S/O SHIVALINGAPPA ANGADI AGE: 54 YEAS 16. M/S SAINATH FERTILIZERS SHOP NO /4 RAGHOJI BUILDING NEHRU GUNJ, GULBARGA, BY ITS PROPRIETOR SRI SUSHILKUMAR S/O MALSHETTAPPA MAMDY AGE:35 YEARS 17. M/S ZUARI INDUSTRIES LTD C AND F AGENT M/S. SAINATH FERTILIZERS RAGHOJI BUILDING, NEHRU GUNJ, GUULBARGA BY ITS PROPRIETOR, SRI SUSHILKUMAR S/O MALSHETTAPPA MAMDY AGE: 35 YEAS 18. M/S DEVI AGENCIES UDNOOR COMPLEX FILTER BED ROAD NEHRU GUNJ GULBARGA, BY ITS PROPRIETOR SRI SUSHILKUMAR, S/O MALSHETTAPPA MANDY AGE: 35 YEARS....PETITIONERS (BY SRI. SHARANABASSAPPA K.BABSHETTY, ADVOCATE) A N D : 1. UNION OF INDIA,

63 : 63 : BY ITS SECRETARY, DEPARTMENT OF AGRICULTURE AND CO-OPERATION (KRISHI BHAVAN), DR RAJENDRA PRASAD ROAD, NEW DELHI. 2. THE COMMISSIONER AND DIRECTOR OF AGRICUTURE, GOVT OF KARNATAKA, SHESHADRI ROAD, BANGALORE. 3. THE JOINT DIRECTOR OF AGRICULTURE, GULBARGA....RESPONDENTS (BY SRI. D.R.ANANDEESWARA, CGSC FOR R1 SMT. K.VIDYAVATHI, ADDL. GOVT. ADV., FOR R2 & R3) THIS WP FILED UNDER ARTICLES 226 & 227 OF CONSTITUTION OF INDIA PRAYING TO DECLARE THAT RULE 10(2)(a) OF THE INSECICIDES (AMENDED) RUELS 1999 AS UNCONSTITUTIONAL AND ARBITRARY IN SO FAR AS PETITONERS IS CONCERNED. In W.P.No.172/2007 BETWEEN 1. MR MRUTHUNJAYA PRASAD AGED ABOUT 48 YEARS, PARTNER, M/S MRUTHYUNJAYA AGRO KENDRA, KAVALI BLDNG, NEW COTTON MARKET HUBLI 2. MR NEELAPPA S KENDUR AGED ABOUT 42 YEARS, PARTNER

64 : 64 : M/S UNITED AGRO SERVICES NEW COTTON MARKET, HUBLI 3. MR NEELESH AGED ABOUT 44 YEARS, SABERO ORGANICS GURARAT LTD M V HUBLI BLDNG NEW COTTON MARKET HUBLI 4. MR SHASHIKANT BASAPPA BALIKGAR AGED ABOUT 43 YEARS, PROPRIETOR, SHREE SOMESHWAR AGRO KENDRA MADHURA CHAITANYA COMPLEX NEELIGIN RD, HUBLI 5. RUDRAGOUDA SHETTAPPA HANNI AGED ABOUT 54 YEARS, DESAI ENTERPRISES, # 4, KAVALI BLDNG NEW COTTON MARKET HUBLI 6. SHANTESH S HAVERISHETTAR AGED ABOUT 55 YEARS, M/S C M HAVERISHETTAR # 43, KAVALI BLDNG, NEW COTTON MARKET HUBLI 7. SUHAS S HAVERISHETTAR AGED ABOUT 46 YEARS, PARTNER, SANGAMESH AGRO CENTRE MORRUSAVIRMATH COMPLEX NEAR OLD BUS-STAND HUBLI 8. SUHAS S.HAVERISHETTAR, AGED ABOUT 46 YEARS, PARTNER, SANGAMESH AGRO AGENCIES, MOORUSAVIRMATH COMPLEX,

65 : 65 : NEAR OLD-BUS STAND, HUBLI. 9. SHIVARDURAPPA N PVATANNAVAR AGED ABOUT 56 YEARS, SIDDESHWAR RAITALYA, HDMC COMPLEX OLD GRASS MARKET, DHARWAD 10. SHIDDARAM GANGAPPA NADAKATTI AGED ABOUT 48 YEARS, PROPRIETOR, MRUTYUNJAYA SEEDS CORPORATIN OLD DALAL MARKET, DHARWAD 11. MURUGEPPA F KOTUR AGED ABOUT 65 YEARS, PARTNER, KOTURU SHETKI BHANDARA MARKET, DHARWAD 12. GANGADHAR SHIDDAYYA ADAVIMATH AGED ABOUT 54 YEARS, PROPRIETOR M/S ADVIMATH & COMPANY GANDHI MARKET, BELLARY GALLI HUBLI 13. NINGAPPA NEELAKANTHAPPA MADLI AGED ABOUT 29 YEARS, PROPRIETOR SRI SIDDAROODHA AGRO AGENCIES MADHURA CHAITANYA COMPLEX NEELIGN RD, HUBLI 14. SHIVAPPA NINGAPPA KARIKATTI AGED ABOUT 44 YEARS, PROPRIETOR, M/S KARNATAKA TRADERS STALL # 8, KURAHATTI BLDNG NAVANAGAR, HUBLI