Saint Martin Orange Wine Show Results 2017

Transcription

1 Saint Martin Orange Wine Show Results 2017

2 Class 01 Sparkling Wine Judges: Nick Bulleid, Ulrich Grey-Smith, Lucy Maddox, Nicole Puttick Class comments: The gold exemplifies the fine delicate finish that this style requires. Several wines finished coarse or thick. The Prosecco's were judged within their style, without comparison with the traditional method wines. Entered: 17 Judged: 17 1 Top Drop Pty Ltd (See Saw Wines) See Saw 2017 Prosecco, Riesling, Marsanne 48.5 Bronze 2 Davis Premium Vineyards Davis Premium Vineyards 2016 Carillion Blanc de Blancs Chardonnay Sassy Wines Sassy Wines 2016 Sparkling Arneis 46.5 Bronze 4 Cargo Road Wines Cargo Road Wines 2016 Sparkling Sauvignon Blanc Top Drop Pty Ltd (See Saw Wines) See Saw 2016 Prosecco 47.0 Bronze 6 Logan Logan 2014 Vintage M Cuvee Chardonnay, Pinot Noir, Pinot Meunier 51.0 Silver 7 Pepper Tree Wines Pepper Tree Wines 2014 'Silenus' Chardonnay, Pinot Noir 52.0 Silver 8 Ross Hill Wines Ross Hill Wines 2013 Blanc de Blancs Chardonnay De Salis Wines De Salis Wines 2013 Blanc De Blanc Chardonnay 48.0 Bronze 10 Printhie Wines Swift Sparkling 2011 Rose Chardonnay, Pinot Noir 55.5 Top Gold 11 Printhie Wines Swift Sparkling 2011 Vintage Chardonnay, Pinot Noir 49.0 Bronze 12 Gilbert Family Wines Gilbert by Simon Gilbert 2010 Methode Traditionnelle Pinot Meunier, Pinot Noir, Chardonnay 13 Printhie Wines Swift Sparkling 2010 Swift Blanc de Blancs Chardonnay 47.5 Bronze 14 Philip Shaw Wines Philip Shaw Wines NV The Edinburgh Chardonnay, Pinot Noir Printhie Wines Swift Sparkling NV Swift NV Cuvee Chardonnay, Pinot Noir 49.5 Bronze 16 Tamburlaine Wines Tamburlaine NV Au Naturel Premium Cuvee Chardonnay 48.5 Bronze 17 Montoro Wines Montoro Wines 2013 'Opal Eyes' Sparkling Shiraz 50.0 Bronze 46.0 Page 1 of 16

3 Class 02 Riesling Judges: Stu Knox, Ulrich Grey-Smith, Lucy Maddox, William Wilson Class comments: A very strong class with most wines showing good balance and length. Top wine has a fine acid line, finesse and character. Entered: 24 Judged: 24 1 Cooks Lot Cooks Lot 2017 Allotment 333 Riesling Highland Heritage Estate Highland Heritage Estate 2017 Riesling 55.0 Silver 3 Printhie Wines Printhie Wines 2017 MCC Riesling 54.0 Silver 4 Horner Wines Horner Wines 2017 Little Jack Riesling Logan Logan 2017 Weemala Riesling Tamburlaine Wines Tamburlaine 2017 Orange Reserve Riesling 46.5 Bronze 7 Rowlee Wines Rowlee Wines 2017 Riesling 46.5 Bronze 8 Pepper Tree Wines Pepper Tree Wines 2017 'Stone Mountain' Single Vineyard Riesling Davis Premium Vineyards Davis Premium Vineyards 2017 Carillion Estate Grown Riesling 56.0 Top Gold 10 Cargo Road Wines Cargo Road Wines 2017 Riesling 55.5 Gold 11 Centennial Vineyards Centennial Vineyards 2017 Reserve 115 Riesling Helm wines Helm wines 2017 Riesling 47.5 Bronze 13 Patina Patina 2016 Riesling 47.5 Bronze 14 Philip Shaw Wines Philip Shaw Wines 2016 Experimenting Riesling 51.0 Silver 15 Cooks Lot Cooks Lot 2016 Allotment 333 Riesling 47.5 Bronze 16 Gilbert Family Wines Gilbert by Simon Gilbert 2016 Riesling Slow Wine Co Slow Wine Co 2016 Riesling 55.0 Silver 18 Patina Patina 2016 Scandalous Riesling Brangayne of Orange Brangayne of Orange 2016 Riesling Colmar Estate Colmar Estate 2016 Block 6 Riesling 53.0 Silver 21 Davis Premium Vineyards Davis Premium Vineyards 2016 Carillion Estate Grown Riesling 47.0 Bronze 22 Cargo Road Wines Cargo Road Wines 2016 Riesling Gilbert Family Wines Gilbert by Simon Gilbert 2012 Riesling 53.0 Silver 24 Highland Heritage Estate Highland Heritage Estate 2011 Nikki D Riesling 53.0 Silver Page 2 of 16

4 Class 03 Sauvignon Blanc Judges: Nick Bulleid, Nick Spencer, Drew Tuckwell, Nicole Puttick Class comments: A good class with stronger medals showing varietal intensity, freshness and balance. Many others suffered from loss of freshness, poorly judged use of phenolics or simply needed better finishing. Entered: 25 Judged: 25 1 Philip Shaw Wines Philip Shaw Wines 2017 No19 Sauvignon Blanc Swinging Bridge Swinging Bridge 2017 Sauvignon Blanc 48.5 Bronze 3 Ross Hill Wines Ross Hill Wines 2017 Lily Sauvignon Blanc Cooks Lot Cooks Lot 2017 Allotment 689 Sauvignon Blanc 47.0 Bronze 5 Jacksons Hill Jacksons Hill 2017 Sauvignon Blanc Top Drop Pty Ltd (See Saw Wines) See Saw 2017 Organically Grown Sauvignon Blanc Brokenwood Wines Brokenwood Wines 2017 Forest Edge Vineyard Sauvignon Blanc 53.5 Silver 8 Colmar Estate Colmar Estate 2017 Sauvignon Blanc 51.0 Silver 9 Panther's Patch Wines Panther's Patch Wines 2017 Sauvignon Blanc Angullong Wines Angullong 2017 Sauvignon Blanc 49.0 Bronze 11 Horner Wines Horner Wines 2017 Little Jack Sauvignon Blanc 48.0 Bronze 12 Brangayne of Orange Brangayne of Orange 2017 Sauvignon Blanc Printhie Wines Printhie Wines 2017 Mountain Range Sauvignon Blanc 55.5 Gold 14 Tamburlaine Wines Tamburlaine 2017 Orange Reserve Fume Blanc Sauvignon Blanc Mortimer's Wines Pty Ltd Mortimer's Wines Pty Ltd 2016 Chestnut Garth Sauvignon Blanc 56.0 Top Gold 16 Pepper Tree Wines Pepper Tree Wines 2017 Limited Release Sauvignon Blanc Centennial Vineyards Centennial Vineyards 2017 Sauvignon Blanc Orange Mountain Wines Orange Mountain Wines 2017 Sauvignon Blanc 46.5 Bronze 19 Stockman's Ridge Wines Stockman's Ridge Wines 2016 Rider Sauvignon Blanc Highland Heritage Estate Highland Heritage Estate 2016 Fume Blanc Sauvignon Blanc 46.5 Bronze 21 Logan Logan 2016 Sauvignon Blanc Gilbert Family Wines Gilbert by Simon Gilbert 2015 Sur Lie Sauvignon Blanc Slow Wine Co Slow Wine Co 2015 Sauvignon Blanc Red Chilli Wine Co Red Chilli Wine Co 2015 The Dog Catcher Sauvignon Blanc 46.5 Bronze 25 Highland Heritage Estate Highland Heritage Estate 2015 Sauvignon Blanc 45.0 Page 3 of 16

5 Class 04A Chardonnay 2016 & 2017 Judges: Stu Knox, Nick Spencer, Drew Tuckwell, William Wilson Class comments: Overall a very good class. However some wines showing premature ageing. Generally well handled oak. Entered: 34 Judged: 34 1 Printhie Wines Printhie Wines 2017 Mountain Range Chardonnay 46.5 Bronze 2 Rikard Wines Rikard 2016 Chardonnay Swinging Bridge Swinging Bridge 2016 'Block D' Chardonnay Philip Shaw Wines Philip Shaw Wines 2016 No11 Chardonnay 46.5 Bronze 5 Rikard Wines Rikard 2016 Black Label Chardonnay Swinging Bridge Swinging Bridge 2016 'Mrs Payten' Chardonnay 51.0 Silver 7 Ross Hill Wines Ross Hill Wines 2016 Pinnacle Series Chardonnay Cooks Lot Cooks Lot 2016 allotment 3 Handpicked Chardonnay 51.5 Silver 9 Colmar Estate Colmar Estate 2016 Chardonnay 52.0 Silver 10 Ross Hill Wines Ross Hill Wines 2016 Maya and Max Chardonnay Cooks Lot Cooks Lot 2016 allotment 168 Chardonnay 48.5 Bronze 12 Brokenwood Wines Brokenwood Wines 2016 Forest Edge Vineyard Chardonnay 55.5 Gold 13 Colmar Estate Colmar Estate 2016 Block 1 Chardonnay Brangayne of Orange Brangayne of Orange 2016 Chardonnay Colmar Estate Colmar Estate 2016 Block 2 Chardonnay 49.0 Bronze 16 Wine Insights Climbing 2016 Chardonnay Gilbert Family Wines Gilbert 2016 Chardonnay 54.0 Silver 18 Highland Heritage Estate Highland Heritage Estate 2016 Chardonnay 46.5 Bronze 19 Printhie Wines Printhie Wines 2016 MCC Chardonnay 46.5 Bronze 20 Angullong Wines Angullong 2016 The Castle Chardonnay 46.5 Bronze 21 Brangayne of Orange Brangayne of Orange 2016 Isolde Reserve Chardonnay 48.0 Bronze 22 Logan Logan 2016 Chardonnay Mortimer's Wines Pty Ltd Mortimer's Wines Pty Ltd 2016 Autumn Chardonnay Tamburlaine Wines Tamburlaine 2016 Orange Reserve Chardonnay 55.5 Gold 25 Pepper Tree Wines Pepper Tree Wines 2016 Limited Release Chardonnay Mortimer's Wines Pty Ltd Mortimer's Wines Pty Ltd 2016 Chestnut Garth Chardonnay Rowlee Wines Rowlee Wines 2016 Chardonnay 56.0 Top Gold 28 Davis Premium Vineyards Davis Premium Vineyards 2016 'The Crystals' Carillion Single Vineyard Chardonnay 47.0 Bronze 29 Gartelmann Wines Gartelmann Wines 2016 Sarah Elizabeth Chardonnay 46.5 Bronze 30 Pepper Tree Wines Pepper Tree Wines 2016 Varietal Chardonnay 48.5 Bronze 31 Darragh Darragh 2016 Chardonnay Heifer Station Wines Heifer Station Wines 2016 Chardonnay 46.5 Bronze 33 Pepper Tree Wines Pepper Tree Wines 2016 'Venus Block' Single Vineyard Chardonnay 55.5 Gold 34 Orange Mountain Wines Orange Mountain Wines 2016 Miss Hayley Chardonnay 39.0 Page 4 of 16

6 Class 04B Chardonnay 2015 & older Judges: Nick Bulleid, Ulrich Grey-Smith, Lucy Maddox, Nicole Puttick Class comments: A good class of varying styles. A few wines losing freshness. Managing oak and phenolics remains a challenge. Entered: 21 Judged: 20 1 Patina Patina 2015 Chardonnay Amour Wines Amour 2015 Chardonnay Swinging Bridge Swinging Bridge 2015 'Block D' Chardonnay 48.5 Bronze 4 Cooks Lot Cooks Lot 2015 Allotment 3 Handpicked Chardonnay Philip Shaw Wines Philip Shaw Wines 2015 No6 Chardonnay 46.5 Bronze 6 Patina Patina 2015 Reserve Chardonnay Swinging Bridge Swinging Bridge 2015 Mrs Payten Chardonnay 56.0 Top Gold 8 Philip Shaw Wines Philip Shaw Wines 2015 Experimenting Chardonnay 55.5 Gold 9 De Salis Wines De Salis Wines 2015 Chardonnay 47.5 Bronze 10 Top Drop Pty Ltd (See Saw Wines) See Saw 2015 Chardonnay Brokenwood Wines Brokenwood Wines 2015 Forest Edge Vineyard Chardonnay 46.5 Bronze 12 De Salis Wines De Salis Wines 2015 Wild Chardonnay Colmar Estate Colmar Estate 2015 Block 1 Chardonnay 51.0 Silver 14 Slow Wine Co Slow Wine Co 2015 Chardonnay 48.0 Bronze 15 De Salis Wines De Salis Wines 2015 Lofty 'Blue Label' Chardonnay 46.5 Bronze 16 Printhie Wines Printhie Wines 2014 Super Duper Chardonnay Slow Wine Co Slow Wine Co 2014 Chardonnay 46.5 Bronze 18 Borrodell Vineyard Withdrawn 19 Strawhouse Wines Strawhouse Wines 2014 Strawhouse Chardonnay Philip Shaw Wines Philip Shaw Wines 2012 No11 Chardonnay 51.0 Silver 21 Gilbert Family Wines Gilbert by Simon Gilbert 2012 Chardonnay 53.0 Silver Page 5 of 16

7 Class 05 Pinot Gris/Grigio Judges: Stu Knox, Nick Spencer, Drew Tuckwell, William Wilson Class comments: A solid class of wines. The best examples showed freshness and length. Good to see a variety of styles being presented. Entered: 20 Judged: 20 1 Philip Shaw Wines Philip Shaw Wines 2017 The Gardener Pinot Gris 54.5 Silver 2 Swinging Bridge Swinging Bridge 2017 Pinot Gris Cooks Lot Cooks Lot 2017 allotment 666 Pinot Gris 56.0 Top Gold 4 Jacksons Hill Jacksons Hill 2017 Pinot Grigio Colmar Estate Colmar Estate 2017 Pinot Gris 52.0 Silver 6 Wine Insights Climbing 2017 Pinot Gris 55.5 Gold 7 Printhie Wines Printhie Wines 2017 Mountain Range Pinot Gris, Gewürztraminer, Riesling 46.5 Bronze 8 Angullong Wines Angullong 2017 Pinot Grigio 46.5 Bronze 9 Brangayne of Orange Brangayne of Orange 2017 Pinot Grigio Logan Logan 2017 Clementine Pinot Gris Tamburlaine Wines Tamburlaine 2017 On The Grapevine Pinot Gris Pinot Gris, Gewürztraminer 47.5 Bronze 12 Rowlee Wines Rowlee Wines 2017 Pinot Grigio 54.0 Silver 13 Davis Premium Vineyards Davis Premium Vineyards 2017 Carillion Estate Grown Pinot Gris 47.5 Bronze 14 Gartelmann Wines Gartelmann Wines 2017 Stephanie Pinot Gris 47.5 Bronze 15 Stockman's Ridge Wines Stockman's Ridge Wines 2016 Rider Pinot Gris Top Drop Pty Ltd (See Saw Wines) See Saw 2016 Pinot Gris Colmar Estate Colmar Estate 2016 Pinot Gris 51.0 Silver 18 Gilbert Family Wines Gilbert by Simon Gilbert 2016 Pinot Grigio 48.0 Bronze 19 Rowlee Wines Rowlee Wines 2016 Pinot Gris Slow Wine Co Slow Wine Co 2015 Pinot Gris 41.0 Page 6 of 16

8 Class 06 Other White variety or blend Judges: Nick Bulleid, Ulrich Grey-Smith, Lucy Maddox, Nicole Puttick Entered: 12 Class comments: An uneven class, but the highlights were very attractive. A few wines were too stale. Judged: 11 1 Colmar Estate Colmar Estate 2017 Le Moche Blend Philip Shaw Wines Philip Shaw Wines 2017 The Dreamer Viognier 47.5 Bronze 3 Orange Mountain Wines Orange Mountain Wines 2016 Viognier Boree Lane Vines & Wines Pty Ltd Boree Lane Vines & Wines Pty Ltd 2017 "Trifecta" Sauvignon Blanc, Gewürztraminer, Viognier 48.5 Bronze 5 Davis Premium Vineyards Davis Premium Vineyards 2016 Lovable Rogue Funky Ferment Verduzzo 51.0 Silver 6 Cargo Road Wines Cargo Road Wines 2017 Gewurztraminer Traminer Logan Logan 2017 Weemala Gewürztraminer Colmar Estate Colmar Estate 2016 Gewürztraminer 48.0 Bronze 9 Tamburlaine Wines Tamburlaine 2017 Wine Lovers Gewürztraminer 53.5 Silver 10 Boree Lane Vines & Wines Pty Ltd Boree Lane Vines & Wines Pty Ltd 2016 Gewürztraminer Slow Wine Co Slow Wine Co 2015 Gewürztraminer Borrodell Vineyard Withdrawn Page 7 of 16

9 Class 07 Dessert or Fortified Wine Judges: Stu Knox, Nick Spencer, Drew Tuckwell, William Wilson Entered: 2 Class comments: Nice wines but top wine showed greater depth and complexity. Judged: 2 1 Rowlee Wines Rowlee Wines 2017 Late Harvest Riesling 48.0 Bronze 2 Gilbert Family Wines Gilbert by Simon Gilbert 2013 Late Harvest Riesling 52.5 Silver Page 8 of 16

10 Class 08 Rose Judges: Stu Knox, Nick Spencer, Drew Tuckwell, William Wilson Entered: 16 Class comments: A solid group of wines. Best of them showed good balance and freshness. Judged: 16 1 Patina Patina NV Rose Merlot, Chardonnay, Pinot Noir, Riesling, Cabernet Franc Swinging Bridge Swinging Bridge 2017 #004 Pinot Noir 46.5 Bronze 3 Ross Hill Wines Ross Hill Wines 2017 Jessica Rose Sangiovese, Pinot Grigio Top Drop Pty Ltd (See Saw Wines) See Saw 2017 Rose Pinot Noir 52.0 Silver 5 Colmar Estate Colmar Estate 2017 Pinot Rose Pinot Noir 56.0 Top Gold 6 Printhie Wines Printhie Wines 2017 Snow Line Pinot Rose Pinot Noir, Pinot Meunier, Pinot Gris 46.5 Bronze 7 Angullong Wines Angullong 2017 Fossil Hill Rosato Sangiovese 51.0 Silver 8 Horner Wines Horner Wines 2017 Little Jack Rose Merlot Brangayne of Orange Brangayne of Orange 2017 Rose Shiraz 48.0 Bronze 10 Logan Logan 2017 Hannah Rose Shiraz, Pinot Noir, Cabernet Sauvignon Pepper Tree Wines Pepper Tree Wines 2017 Limited Release Rose Pinot Noir 55.5 Gold 12 Centennial Vineyards Centennial Vineyards 2017 Reserve Rose Corvina, Rondinella Philip Shaw Wines Philip Shaw Wines 2016 Pink Billy Shiraz, Merlot, Cabernet Franc, Sauvignon Blanc, Pinot Noir 14 Cooks Lot Cooks Lot 2016 Allotment 365 Rose Shiraz Heifer Station Wines Heifer Station Wines 2016 Merlot, Shiraz 46.5 Bronze 16 Slow Wine Co Slow Wine Co 2015 Rose Pinot Noir Page 9 of 16

11 Class 09 Pinot Noir Judges: Nick Bulleid, Ulrich Grey-Smith, Lucy Maddox, Nicole Puttick Class comments: A pleasure to see Pinot Noir performing well in Orange! The varying styles all showed pinot's supple, fleshy balance and fine tannins. Several wines were too tannic. Entered: 30 Judged: 30 1 Philip Shaw Wines Philip Shaw Wines 2016 No8 Pinot Noir 51.0 Silver 2 Colmar Estate Colmar Estate 2016 Pinot Noir 53.0 Silver 3 Rikard Wines Rikard 2016 Black Label Pinot Noir 49.5 Bronze 4 Swinging Bridge Swinging Bridge 2016 MAW Pinot Noir 56.0 Top Gold 5 Cooks Lot Cooks Lot 2016 Allotment 1111 Pinot Noir 51.0 Silver 6 Top Drop Pty Ltd (See Saw Wines) See Saw 2016 Pinot Noir Brokenwood Wines Brokenwood Wines 2016 Forest Edge Vineyard Pinot Noir Cooks Lot Cooks Lot 2016 Allotment 9 Handpicked Pinot Noir 50.0 Bronze 9 Colmar Estate Colmar Estate 2016 Block 1 Pinot Noir 47.5 Bronze 10 Logan Logan 2016 Pinot Noir 55.5 Gold 11 Gilbert Family Wines Gilbert by Simon Gilbert 2016 Barrel Select Pinot Noir 47.0 Bronze 12 Gilbert Family Wines Gilbert by Simon Gilbert Pinot Noir 46.5 Bronze 13 Rikard Wines Rikard 2016 Pinot Noir Ross Hill Wines Ross Hill Wines 2016 Pinnacle Series Griffin Road Vineyard Pinot Noir Brangayne of Orange Brangayne of Orange 2016 Pinot Noir 48.0 Bronze 16 Colmar Estate Colmar Estate 2016 Block 3 Pinot Noir 53.0 Silver 17 Logan Logan 2016 Weemala Pinot Noir Mortimer's Wines Pty Ltd Mortimer's Wines Pty Ltd 2016 BFL Pinot Noir Rowlee Wines Rowlee Wines 2016 R Series Pinot Noir 49.0 Bronze 20 Darragh Darragh 2016 Pinot Noir 49.0 Bronze 21 Ross Hill Wines Ross Hill Wines 2015 Pinnacle Series Wallace Lane Vineyard Pinot Noir Stockman's Ridge Wines Stockman's Ridge Wines 2015 Rider Pinot Noir Highland Heritage Estate Highland Heritage Estate 2015 Pinot Noir Slow Wine Co Slow Wine Co 2015 Pinot Noir 54.0 Silver 25 Logan Logan 2015 Pinot Noir Pepper Tree Wines Pepper Tree Wines 2015 Limited Release Pinot Noir De Salis Wines De Salis Wines 2014 Lofty Pinot Noir Slow Wine Co Slow Wine Co 2014 Pinot Noir 46.5 Bronze 29 De Salis Wines De Salis Wines 2014 Pinot Noir De Salis Wines De Salis Wines 2014 Lofty 'Blue Label' Pinot Noir 49.5 Bronze Page 10 of 16

12 Class 10 Bordeaux varieties Judges: Stu Knox, Nick Spencer, Drew Tuckwell, William Wilson Class comments: A slightly disappointing class. Overall a lack of freshness, too many green characters and questions on extraction. Entered: 24 Judged: 24 1 Philip Shaw Wines Philip Shaw Wines 2015 The Conductor Merlot 47.5 Bronze 2 Ross Hill Wines Ross Hill Wines 2016 Isabelle Cabernet Franc, Merlot 48.0 Bronze 3 Cooks Lot Cooks Lot 2016 allotment 8989 Cabernet Sauvignon, Merlot 49.0 Bronze 4 Tamburlaine Wines Tamburlaine 2016 Orange Reserve Malbec 55.0 Silver 5 Printhie Wines Printhie Wines 2016 Mountain Range Merlot Merlot 46.5 Bronze 6 Tamburlaine Wines Tamburlaine 2016 Wine Lovers Full House Malbec, Cabernet Franc, Petit Verdot, Merlot, Cabernet Sauvignon 7 Darragh Darragh 2016 Cabernet Sauvignon, Cabernet Franc 49.0 Bronze 8 Cargo Road Wines Cargo Road Wines 2016 Merlot Tamburlaine Wines Tamburlaine 2016 Orange Reserve Merlot Cargo Road Wines Cargo Road Wines 2016 Cabernet Sauvignon, Merlot Centennial Vineyards Centennial Vineyards 2016 Reserve Merlot Merlot Philip Shaw Wines Philip Shaw Wines 2015 No17 Merlot, Cabernet Franc 48.0 Bronze 13 Ross Hill Wines Ross Hill Wines 2015 Pinnacle Series Griffin Road Vineyard Cabernet Franc Cooks Lot Cooks Lot 2015 Allotment 8989 Cabernet Sauvignon, Merlot 47.5 Bronze 15 Stockman's Ridge Wines Stockman's Ridge Wines 2015 Rider Cabernet Franc, Merlot Wine Insights Climbing 2015 Merlot Logan Logan 2015 Cabernet Merlot Cabernet Sauvignon, Merlot, Cabernet Franc 50.0 Bronze 18 Ross Hill Wines Ross Hill Wines 2014 'The Griffin' Cabernet Sauvignon, Merlot, Cabernet Franc 19 Stockman's Ridge Wines Stockman's Ridge Wines 2014 Rider Merlot Highland Heritage Estate Highland Heritage Estate 2014 Merlot Slow Wine Co Slow Wine Co 2014 Merlot Logan Logan 2014 Cabernet Merlot Cabernet Sauvignon, Merlot, Cabernet Franc Mortimer's Wines Pty Ltd Mortimer's Wines Pty Ltd 2014 Autumn Merlot De Salis Wines De Salis Wines 2013 'M' Merlot Page 11 of 16

13 Class 11 Shiraz Judges: Nick Bulleid, Stu Knox, Ulrich Grey-Smith, Lucy Maddox, Nick Spencer, Drew Tuckwell, Nicole Puttick, William Wilson Class comments: Overall strong. 2016's tended to be more tannic, while 2015 and 2014's showed better balance. Several older wines retained freshness well. There were a couple of oak-savaged wines, occasional VA and sulfide. Entered: 50 Judged: 48 1 Philip Shaw Wines Philip Shaw Wines 2016 The Idiot Shiraz Ross Hill Wines Ross Hill Wines 2016 Jack's Lot Shiraz Cooks Lot Cooks Lot 2016 allotment 1010 Shiraz 47.5 Bronze 4 Philip Shaw Wines Philip Shaw Wines 2016 No89 Shiraz Cooks Lot Withdrawn 6 Printhie Wines Printhie Wines 2016 Mountain Range Shiraz Angullong Wines Angullong 2016 Shiraz Printhie Wines Printhie Wines 2016 Super Duper Syrah Mortimer's Wines Pty Ltd Mortimer's Wines Pty Ltd 2015 Chris Derrez Shiraz Angullong Wines Angullong 2016 Fossil Hill Shiraz, Viognier 46.5 Bronze 11 Tamburlaine Wines Tamburlaine 2016 Orange Reserve Syrah 53.5 Silver 12 Mortimer's Wines Pty Ltd Mortimer's Wines Pty Ltd 2016 Autumn Shiraz Gartelmann Wines Gartelmann Wines 2016 Diedrich Shiraz Centennial Vineyards Centennial Vineyards 2016 Shiraz 46.5 Bronze 15 Montoro Wines Montoro Wines 2016 Artisan Shiraz 55.5 Gold 16 Cargo Road Wines Cargo Road Wines 2016 Reserve Shiraz 51.0 Silver 17 Heifer Station Wines Heifer Station Wines 2016 Shiraz Centennial Vineyards Centennial Vineyards 2016 Reserve Shiraz, Viognier Amour Wines Amour 2015 Shiraz Cooks Lot Cooks Lot 2015 Allotment 1010 Shiraz 48.0 Bronze 21 Ross Hill Wines Ross Hill Wines 2015 Pinnacle Series Griffin Road Vineyard Shiraz Highland Heritage Estate Highland Heritage Estate 2015 Shiraz Angullong Wines Angullong 2015 Fossil Hill Shiraz, Viognier 48.0 Bronze 24 Cooks Lot Cooks Lot 2015 Allotment 8 Handpicked Shiraz 55.5 Gold 25 Gilbert Family Wines Gilbert by Simon Gilbert 2015 Shiraz 47.0 Bronze 26 Highland Heritage Estate Highland Heritage Estate 2015 Patrono Series Shiraz Angullong Wines Angullong Wines 2015 Crossing Reserve Shiraz Logan Logan 2015 Shiraz 54.5 Silver 29 Boree Lane Vines & Wines Pty Ltd Boree Lane Vines & Wines Pty Ltd 2015 Shiraz 48.5 Bronze 30 Roaring Fork Wine Co. Roaring Fork Wine Co Shiraz 2015 Shiraz 52.0 Silver 31 Brangayne of Orange Brangayne of Orange 2015 Shiraz 54.5 Silver 32 Strawhouse Wines Strawhouse Wines 2015 Strawhouse Shiraz 47.5 Bronze 33 Logan Logan 2015 Ridge of Tears 970m Orange Shiraz Shiraz Mortimer's Wines Pty Ltd Mortimer's Wines Pty Ltd 2015 Simon Gilbert Shiraz Shiraz 47.0 Bronze 35 Pepper Tree Wines Pepper Tree Wines 2015 Limited Release Shiraz 46.5 Bronze 36 Sassy Wines Sassy Wines 2015 The Fabian Shiraz, Viognier 51.0 Silver 37 Centennial Vineyards Centennial Vineyards 2015 Reserve Shiraz 53.0 Silver 38 Gartelmann Wines Gartelmann Wines 2015 Diedrich Shiraz 56.0 Top Gold 39 Montoro Wines Montoro Wines 2015 Pepper Shiraz 52.0 Silver 40 Centennial Vineyards Centennial Vineyards 2015 Reserve Shiraz, Viognier Davis Premium Vineyards Davis Premium Vineyards 2015 'The Feldspars' Carillion Shiraz 47.5 Bronze 42 Cooks Lot Cooks Lot 2014 Allotment 8 Handpicked Shiraz Stockman's Ridge Wines Stockman's Ridge Wines 2014 Rider Shiraz 52.0 Silver 44 Printhie Wines Printhie Wines 2014 MCC Shiraz Shiraz Angullong Wines Angullong Wines 2014 Crossing Reserve Shiraz 54.0 Silver 46 Wine Insights Cumulus 2013 Shiraz 48.0 Bronze 47 Davis Premium Vineyards Davis Premium Vineyards 2013 'The Feldpsars' Carillion Shiraz 52.0 Silver 48 Montoro Wines Montoro Wines 2013 Pepper Shiraz 52.0 Silver 49 Faisan Estate Wines Withdrawn Page 12 of 16

14 50 Orange Mountain Wines Orange Mountain Wines 2013 Master Joshua Shiraz, Viognier 48.0 Bronze Page 13 of 16

15 Class 12 Cabernet Sauvignon Judges: Nick Bulleid, Ulrich Grey-Smith, Lucy Maddox, Nicole Puttick Class comments: Two fine golds, one with generous berry fruit, the other cabernet's varietal leafiness but both with good tannin balance. The many bronzes had good flavour but most were quite astringent. Entered: 20 Judged: 20 1 Highland Heritage Estate Highland Heritage Estate 2016 Cabernet Sauvignon 46.5 Bronze 2 Printhie Wines Printhie Wines 2016 Mountain Range Cabernet Sauvignon, Merlot Tamburlaine Wines Tamburlaine 2016 Orange Reserve Cabernet Sauvignon 56.0 Top Gold 4 Centennial Vineyards Centennial Vineyards 2016 Limited Release Cabernet Sauvignon 47.0 Bronze 5 Philip Shaw Wines Philip Shaw Wines 2015 No5 Cabernet Sauvignon 46.5 Bronze 6 Ross Hill Wines Ross Hill Wines 2015 Pinnacle Series Cabernet Sauvignon 50.0 Bronze 7 Wine Insights Climbing 2015 Cabernet Sauvignon Highland Heritage Estate Highland Heritage Estate 2015 Patrono Series Cabernet Sauvignon 47.5 Bronze 9 Panther's Patch Wines Panther's Patch Wines 2015 Cabernet Sauvignon 46.5 Bronze 10 Angullong Wines Angullong Wines 2015 Crossing Reserve Cabernet Sauvignon 46.5 Bronze 11 Boree Lane Vines & Wines Pty Ltd Boree Lane Vines & Wines Pty Ltd 2015 Cabernet Sauvignon 46.5 Bronze 12 Printhie Wines Printhie Wines 2015 Super Duper Cabernet Sauvignon 46.5 Bronze 13 Red Chilli Wine Co Red Chilli Wine Co 2015 Mystique Cabernet Sauvignon 51.0 Silver 14 Brangayne of Orange Brangayne of Orange 2015 Cabernet Sauvignon Cabernet Sauvignon 55.5 Gold 15 Mortimer's Wines Pty Ltd Mortimer's Wines Pty Ltd 2015 Chestnut Garth Cabernet Sauvignon Cabernet Sauvignon 16 Davis Premium Vineyards Davis Premium Vineyards 2015 'The Volcanics' Carillion Cabernet Sauvignon 17 Swinging Bridge Swinging Bridge 2013 Cabernet Sauvignon Bronze 48.0 Bronze 18 Wine Insights Cumulus 2013 Cabernet Sauvignon 46.5 Bronze 19 Davis Premium Vineyards Davis Premium Vineyards 2013 'The Volcanics' Carillion Cabernet Sauvignon 47.5 Bronze 20 Stockman's Ridge Wines Stockman's Ridge Wines 2009 Outlaw Cabernet Sauvignon 51.0 Silver Page 14 of 16

16 Class 13 Red Variety or Blend Judges: Stu Knox, Nick Spencer, Drew Tuckwell, William Wilson Entered: 14 Class comments: A nice flight of wines. Overall a good understanding of varietal styles. Judged: 14 1 Ross Hill Wines Ross Hill Wines 2016 Pistol Packin' Momma Red Merlot, Cabernet Sauvignon, Sangiovese, Tempranillo 2 Angullong Wines Angullong 2016 Fossil Hill Sangiovese 46.5 Bronze 3 Logan Logan 2017 Clementine Blushing Minnie Pinots Pinot Noir, Pinot Gris, Pinot Meunier Bronze 4 Angullong Wines Angullong 2016 Fossil Hill Tempranillo 56.0 Top Gold 5 Swinging Bridge Swinging Bridge 2016 #006 TemPinot Tempranillo, Pinot Noir 48.5 Bronze 6 Centennial Vineyards Centennial Vineyards 2016 Reserve Rondinella Corvina Rondinella, Corvina Angullong Wines Angullong 2016 Fossil Hill Barbera 55.5 Gold 8 Davis Premium Vineyards Davis Premium Vineyards 2016 Lovable Rogue Moon Child Aglianico Rowlee Wines Rowlee Wines 2016 R Series Nebbiolo 54.0 Silver 10 Angullong Wines Angullong Wines 2016 Fossil Hill Sagrantino 48.0 Bronze 11 Centennial Vineyards Centennial Vineyards 2016 Reserve Barbera Stockman's Ridge Wines Stockman's Ridge Wines 2015 Handcrafted Zinfandel Angullong Wines Angullong 2015 Fossil Hill Sagrantino 47.5 Bronze 14 Davis Premium Vineyards Davis Premium Vineyards 2013 Carillion Estate Grown Cabernet Sauvignon, Merlot 39.5 Page 15 of 16

17 Class 14 Mature Red Judges: Stu Knox, Nick Spencer, Drew Tuckwell, William Wilson Entered: 2 Class comments: Light and shade in this class. Top wine still showing great vibrancy. Judged: 2 1 Swinging Bridge Swinging Bridge 2010 Reserve Cabernet Sauvignon Davis Premium Vineyards Davis Premium Vineyards 2009 'The Feldspars' Carillion Shiraz, Viognier 55.5 Top Gold Page 16 of 16