The GOLDEN GATE COLLECTION. Friday, 17 November at 6:30 PM HKT Lots (Friday, 17 November at 5:30 AM ET)

Transcription

1 The GOLDEN GATE COLLECTION Friday, 17 November at 6:30 PM HKT Lots (Friday, 17 November at 5:30 AM ET) Saturday, 18 November at 10:00 AM HKT Lots (Friday, 17 November at 9:00 PM ET) Cuisine Cuisine (Central) 金門珍藏 11 月 17 日星期五下午 6 時 30 分香港時間拍品編號 (11 月 17 日星期五上午 5 時 30 分美國東岸時間 ) 11 月 18 日星期六上午 10 時正香港時間拍品編號 (11 月 17 日星期五下午 9 時正美國東岸時間 ) 國金軒 ( 中環 )

2 The Golden Gate Collection Friday, 17 November at 6:30 PM (Lots 1-360) Saturday, 18 November at 10:00 AM (Lots ) Cuisine Cuisine (Central) 3101, Podium Level 3, IFC, 1 Harbour View Street, Central, Hong Kong Sale 1711H273 HDoors will open one hour before the auction begins, please arrive early to pre-register and secure a seat. Upcoming Zachys Wine Auctions December 1 & 2, 2017 New York December 8 & 9, 2017 Hong Kong In addition to the sales listed above, Zachys holds eauctions monthly. Please see our website zachys.com/auctions for details. Zachys Asia Please call or asia@zachys.com for all general inquiries about Zachys auctions in Asia. Zachys Consolidated Sea Shipment Zachys offers FREE consolidated sea shipping between Hong Kong and New York several times a year. Local delivery charges will apply. Please asia@zachys.com for more information. Zachys Consolidated Air Shipment Zachys offers special consolidated air shipping between Hong Kong and New York at a discounted rate of US$84 per 9L. These containers generally depart three weeks post auction. Local delivery charges will apply. Please asia@zachys.com for more information. Shipment of Spirits (New!) Zachys offers special consolidated shipping from Hong Kong to New York Fine Wine Storage. Rates will be provided upon request. Local delivery charges will apply. Please asia@zachys.com for more information before placing any bids on spirits in this auction. HLIVE ONLINE BIDDING! In addition to browsing the catalog and placing absentee bids online, now you can get in on the action live from the comfort of your home or office! Visit for details. Follow us on social zachys New York Hong Kong San Francisco Washington, DC bid@zachys.com zachys.com tel tel fax fax

3 金門珍藏 11 月 17 日星期五下午 6 時 30 分香港時間拍品編號 月 18 日星期六上午 10 時正香港時間拍品編號 國金軒 ( 中環 ) 香港中環港景街 1 號國際金融中心商場三樓 3101 店 拍賣編號 1711H273 H 拍賣會開始前一小時恭候入場, 請提早到達登記及留座 Upcoming Zachys Wine Auctions December 1 & 2, 2017 New York December 8 & 9, 2017 Hong Kong 施氏亞洲如欲以中文查詢施氏拍賣會事宜, 請聯絡 或電郵至 asia@zachys.com 施氏合併海運施氏每年均免費提供多次往返香港至紐約的合併海運服務, 本地運送將需另行收費 請電郵至 asia@zachys.com 了解詳情 施氏合併空運施氏為本次拍賣安排香港至紐約的合併空運服務, 並提供每九公升裝一箱八十四美元的優惠價格為您付運 這些貨櫃一般於拍賣會結束後三星期付運 本地運送將需另行收費 請電郵至 asia@zachys.com 了解詳情 付運烈酒 ( 新修訂!) 施氏將提供香港至紐約佳釀貯藏的烈酒合併付運服務, 歡迎向我們查詢相關運費 請注意, 本地運送將須另行收費 歡迎於競投本拍賣中的烈酒窖藏前, 電郵至 asia@zachys.com 了解詳情 H 網上即時競投! 現時除了可以於網頁瀏覽拍賣目錄 出價及下載有關資料外, 您更可即時安坐家中或公司進行網上即時競投, 詳情可瀏覽 立即於 Facebook Twitter, Instagram 及 WeChat,@zachysauctions 關注我們 zachys New York Hong Kong San Francisco Washington, DC bid@zachys.com zachys.com tel tel fax fax

4 4 Lots 62 & 63

5 Contents 目錄 頁數 Contacts For This Auction 6 拍賣團隊及聯絡資料 7 Introduction 10 引言 11 Lots 編號 1 至 Lots 編號 661 至 Buying & Bidding Information 174 關於購買與出價 176 Conditions of Sale 178 銷售條款 180 General Catalog Notes 182 目錄註解 184 Payment & Collection Form 186 付款及付運表格 187 Bidder Pre-Registration Form 188 競投者預先登記表格 189 Absentee Bid Form 190 場外出價表格 192 Index by Region & Producer 194 地區及酒莊索引 194 Designed by 設計 Kristen Hutton Alisa Lopano

6 Auction Team and Contacts Don Zacharia CEO Jeff Zacharia President Jamie Pollack Global Auction Director Fritz Hatton Advisor, Principal Auctioneer HONG KONG Unit A&B, 3/F, Tern Centre Tower II, No. 251 Queen s Road Central, Hong Kong fax asia@zachys.com NEW YORK 39 Westmoreland Avenue, White Plains, NY fax auction@zachys.com Please call or asia@zachys.com for all general inquiries about Zachys auctions in Asia. ZACHYS ASIA Auctioneers Fritz Hatton (# ) Jamie Pollack (# ) Jeff Zacharia (# ) Charles Antin (# ) Austin Zhang Consultant Elliot Faber Junko Watanabe Customer Service Maggie Ma Ivy Chan Elaine Chui Senior Whisky Advisor Japan Operations Supervisor Administrator & Customer Service Logistics Solution Specialist Senior Wine Specialist Terrence Tang Senior Business Development Manager Wine Specialists Ching Wong Private Accounts Manager Simon Choi Property Manager Stanley Tam Property Dora Kam Wine Specialist Wingate Ng Wine Specialist Beijing Austin Zhang Sales Director, China Marketing & Public Relations Sydney Corliss Marketing & Events Manager ZACHYS NEW YORK Consultants Dennis Foley Geoffrey Troy Charles Curtis MW Consignor Payment Cindy Bennett Rare Wine Consultant Senior Advisor Burgundy Consultant Bids, Customer Service & Buyer Payment Jodi Greco Customer Service Manager Danielle Castaldo Keody Ureña Logistics Mark Blasky Neil Maxwell Auction Warehouse Trevor McLawrence Art & Advertising Kristen Hutton Alisa Lopano Special Operations Warehouse Supervisor IT Blake Jines-Storey Creative Director Charles Antin Operations Managers Shoshana Filene Alicia Martell Europe Christine Erickson Senior Wine Specialists Stu Jakub Dan Stensland-Bos Dave Sutro Josephine Young Wine Specialists Kimberly Busch Michael Moser Sean Purce Junior Wine Specialists Julia Banks Alberto Soriano Macy Pigman Wine Specialist Assistants Megan McCarthy Jose Lopez Jesus Reyes Senior Wine Specialist Business Manager Senior Property Manager Head of Europe Senior Account Manager Property Catalog Editor-in-Chief Property Pricing Pricing eauction Property Property Marketing Coordinator Catalog Production Property Property 6

7 拍賣團隊及聯絡資料 Don Zacharia 主席及行政總裁 Jeff Zacharia 主席 Jamie Pollack 美洲區行政總監 Fritz Hatton 顧問及首席拍賣官 香港香港皇后大道中 251 號太興中心 2 座 3 樓 A 及 B 室 傳真 asia@zachys.com 紐約 39 Westmoreland Avenue, White Plains, NY 傳真 auction@zachys.com 施氏亞洲 : 如欲以中文查詢 Zachys 拍賣會事宜, 請聯絡 或電郵至 asia@zachys.com 施氏亞洲 拍賣官 Fritz Hatton (# ) Jamie Pollack (# ) Jeff Zacharia (# ) Charles Antin (# ) 張翛翰 顧問 Elliot Faber 渡辺順子 顧客服務部馬頌齊陳藹寧崔亦寧 高級威士忌顧問日本代表營運主任行政及顧客服務物流方案專員 高級葡萄酒專家鄧晉裕 葡萄酒專家黃凱晴蔡兆明譚朗軒甘曉雯伍偉佳 北京張翛翰 市場推廣及傳訊部 Sydney Corliss 高級業務發展經理私人客戶經理資產經理資產專員葡萄酒專家葡萄酒專家中國區銷售總監市場推廣及活動經理 施氏紐約顧問 Dennis Foley Geoffrey Troy Charles Curtis MW 託付者付款 Cindy Bennett 出價 顧客服務及買家付款 Jodi Greco Danielle Castaldo Keody Ureña 物流 Mark Blasky Neil Maxwell 倉務部 Trevor McLawrence 美術及廣告 Kristen Hutton Alisa Lopano 珍稀葡萄酒顧問高級顧問布根地葡萄酒顧問客戶服務經理營運專員倉務主任技術支援 Blake Jines-Storey 創意總監 Charles Antin 營運經理 Shoshana Filene Alicia Martell 歐洲 Christine Erickson 高級葡萄酒專家 Stu Jakub Dan Stensland-Bos Dave Sutro Josephine Young 葡萄酒專家 Kimberly Busch Michael Moser Sean Purce 初級葡萄酒專家 Julia Banks Alberto Soriano Macy Pigman 高級葡萄酒專家業務經理高級資產經理歐洲主管高級客戶經理資產部目錄總編輯資產部收藏估價部收藏估價部網上拍賣資產部資產部市場發展專員 葡萄酒專家助理 Megan McCarthy Jose Lopez Jesus Reyes 目錄製作資產部資產部 7

8 關於購買與出價 施氏亞洲 如欲以中文查詢施氏拍賣會事宜, 請聯絡 或電郵至 網上即時競投! 現時除了可以於網頁瀏覽拍賣目錄 出價及下載有關資料外, 您更可即時安坐家中或公司進行網上即時競投, 詳情可瀏覽 什麼是包裹貨批?包裹是指一系列擁有同等酒類 酒瓶容量 數量 註解及估值的貨批 由拍賣官斟酌決定下, 包裹中的首批買家可選擇以相同價錢獲得同一包裹中任何或所有貨批 如何識別包裹貨批?貨批註解中將清楚標明包裹貨批編號 例如 : Château Lafite Rothschild 2002 Pauillac, Premier Cru Classé original wood case Parcel: lots bottles per lot $ bottles per lot $ bottles per lot $ 網上競投包裹貨批如網上買家購得第一批包裹貨批, 此買家將收到訊息提示詢問, 要求決定購買餘下包裹貨批的數量 如此買家沒有回應訊息, 拍賣人將依照編號順序繼續拍賣 如買家不接受餘下貨批如獲勝買家不接受餘下貨批, 拍賣官會將下一個未售出貨批作開放競投, 而此貨批的買家可選擇以相同價錢獲得餘下包裹中任何或所有未售出貨批 競投將以此方式繼續進行, 直至這包裹內的所有貨批均被拍賣人宣佈已售出或未能售出為止 買家佣金如本目錄銷售條款中提及,23% 的買家佣金將會加進每一成功投得的貨批, 與及加上適用的銷售稅, 總和便是買家購買應付的總值 葡萄酒檢驗在拍賣會開始前, 有意競投者可透過預約, 於我們的溫度監控倉庫內檢驗任何貨批 請致電 預約 請注意 : 施氏提供此服務是為了顧客的便利, 施氏將不會對任何聯繫錯誤及場外 電話及網上出價競投失敗負責 8

9 關於購買與出價 提交場外出價如閣下未能親蒞拍賣會而仍想競投, 您可以透過書面形式指示施氏代表閣下出價 我們的代表在考慮保留價及其他出價後, 會嘗試以最低價格購買您想獲得的貨批 此服務費用全免而且保密 如需要提交場外出價表, 請使用於本目錄或於網頁 ( 附載的表格 請確定閣下會準確地填上貨批編號及您願意為此貨批支付的最高敲槌價 請注意 : 您的出價亦不包括買家佣金及適用銷售稅 買家佣金及適用銷售稅將加進每一貨批的敲槌價中 場外出價必須以順序編號的方式呈交, 否則將不獲處理 此外, 請利用場外出價表上的出價增量表 如果不正確地出價, 我們將會將您的出價調低至下一個增量 請於拍賣會第一部份開始前最少 24 小時儘早提交出價 於同等出價的情況下, 較早提交的出價表將擁有優先權 提交電話出價只有在施氏酌情決定及由潛在買家承擔風險的情況下, 潛在買家可透過電話出價 由於拍賣會場內只有有限的電話線路, 施氏必需於拍賣會第一部份開始前至少 48 小時確定服務安排 由施氏的酌情處理下, 電話出價只限於價值高於 HK$ 16,000 的貨批上及可能會被記錄 透過遞交電話出價, 潛在買家同意受到銷售條件及有限保用條款約束 請於場外出價表上標示您欲透過電話競投的貨批以及所用語言 網上競投施氏將不會為網上即時競投活動的任何爭論或失誤負責 如遇上競投者之間發生紛爭等任何問題, 拍賣人將決定成功買家及個人叫價牌號 在任何溝通延誤或失誤的情況下, 現場拍賣會將不會暫停拍賣, 網上即時競投者應預早向施氏提交緊急場外出價表格 透過互聯網登記及競投的潛在買家將同意受到銷售條款約束 付款買家應在拍賣會後 14 個日曆天內為所購的貨批付款 14 天後, 施氏有權保留利用買家預先提供的信用卡收取欠款的權利 限期後的欠款將有可能被收取月利率 2% 的逾期收費 此外, 發票日期起 21 天後才付款的買家需另繳交付款金額的 3% 作為罰款, 其後每 14 天將有可能再收取付款金額的 3% 作額外逾期收費 待所有款項及欠款繳清後, 付款才算完成 買家可透過信用卡 支票 郵政滙票 銀行轉賬或現金付款 請在付款時呈交付款及付運表格以加快拍賣會購得貨品的付款及付運程序 拍賣會購得的貨品將不會自動付運 於香港的拍賣會中, 港元及美元均可用作付款 施氏將自行決定香港拍賣會中繳付美元的匯率 為避免您所選購的貨品延誤釋出, 施氏預期買家應在拍賣會前提供銀行資料作參考 如買家以信用卡付款, 應在拍賣會當日或之前出示該信用卡 所有收費均由施氏及可適用的信用卡公司承認 Zachys 只接受 Visa MasterCard, American Express 信用卡 信用卡付款金額上限為一場拍賣會 $100,000 港元 雖然款項有可能超過 $100,000 港元, 但 Zachys 有權保留以該買家的信用卡繳交欠款並即時收取 3% 逾期罰款的權利 在適當財務機構不接納收費及支票的情況下, 買家需為所有到期的欠款負責 9

10 The Golden Gate Collection It s a great pleasure to present the Golden Gate Collection wines from one of the San Francisco Bay area s top collectors. Jeff Zacharia President As some of you may know, we re just coming off the great success of the single-owner auction, The Capital Collection, the first commercial wine auction in Washington D.C. in over 30 years. We wanted to bring something equally impressive to our friends in Hong Kong. The collection spans all of the world s great wine-producing regions as well as many decades, young and old. From a wide selection of rare Burgundy, both red and white, from producers such as DRC, Clos des Lambrays, Domaine Leroy, Rousseau, Jayer, and more, to the whites of Leflaive, Coche-Dury and Raveneau. Bordeaux is just as strong, with all the First Growths and Yquem, and the Rhône, Italy, Spain, and even a large selection of wines from the legendary Massandra Collection. From Madeira to California and Portugal, there is something here for everyone, and this auction represents the only opportunity to buy from this collection. There will be no part 2! This sale is titled The Golden Gate Collection because it was stored not far from the famous red bridge. All of the wines on offer today were stored in this home cellar, surrounded by natural rock formations, and temperature-controlled. The wines were packed and photographed in situ by Zachys and Michael Egan, before being shipped temperature-controlled to Hong Kong for this auction. A note on Eric Greenberg, the consignor of this collection: Eric Greenberg s collection at one point numbered over 60,000 bottles, and he has bought wines of questionable authenticity over the years. After an auction of approximately 17,000 bottles from his cellar in 2005, Eric was found civilly liable for fraud when 24 of the bottles were determined to be inauthentic. Zachys has inspected the Greenberg collection and selected the bottles for this auction, and Michael Egan, an independent expert, has also inspected and approved every bottle in this auction. Additional important information regarding this matter can be found in the Conditions of Sale. We look forward to seeing you in the sale room, or at one of the many events we have scheduled to taste wines from this collection. Please don t hesitate to be in touch should you have any questions. Sincerely, Jeff Zacharia President 10

11 金門珍藏 我非常榮幸向各位藏家呈獻 金門珍藏 - 它來自三藩市灣區, 經由一位世界級收藏家細心經營 悉心打造 Jeff Zacharia President 或許你們已略有所聞, 我們剛剛於美國華盛頓舉行了近三十多年來的首場商業洋酒拍賣會 這場重要的單一私人收藏拍賣會 - 首都珍藏 ( The Capital Collection) 取得空前成功 我們希望與香港的朋友們一同分享這份成功及喜悅, 因此帶來了同等份量及同樣精緻的頂級收藏 這收藏結集了當世所有偉大葡萄酒產地數十年來的精品, 由年代久遠以至當代年輕的也一一蘊藏其中 它擁有著法國著名布根地酒莊 DRC Clos des Lambrays Domaine Leroy Rousseau 及 Jayer 等的紅白美酒 ; 亦內藏 Leflaive Coche-Dury 及 Raveneau 的白葡萄珍釀 波爾多的星級收藏也媲美布根地, 擁有著區內全數一級酒莊及 Yquem 珍酩 除此以外, 它也盛載著隆河區 意大地 西班牙 以及來自傳奇瑪桑德拉珍藏 (Massandra Collection) 的瑰寶 馬德拉群島 美國加州及葡萄牙的珍品亦傲立於其中 這場拍賣會是開啟眼前這收藏寶庫的唯一鑰匙, 請把握這僅此一次的購藏良機! 這收藏本位處於美國著名的金門大橋附近, 而因此淵源這場拍賣會命名為 金門珍藏 所有於今天拍賣的葡萄佳釀原先存放於被天然岩石層包圍且恆温的酒窖當中 所有拍品在運送至香港作拍賣之前的包裝及拍攝程序皆於這獨特的酒窖中進行, 並由施氏佳釀及 Michael Egan 親自監督及處理, 而運送途中的溫度更受到嚴密監控 以下是一些資料關於是次收藏拍賣的委托人 Eric Greenberg:Eric Greenberg 的收藏量曾一度高達逾 60,000 瓶 ; 多年以來, 他曾購入不少可疑或不知真偽的葡萄佳釀 他於 2005 年拍售約 17,000 瓶葡萄佳釀, 當中 24 瓶被確定為贗品, 他最終被判欺詐並負上民事責任 施氏佳釀已仔細檢驗 Greenberg 之收藏, 並為是次拍賣挑選出一批洋酒 獨立專家 Michael Egan 亦為委托人之收藏作出檢驗, 並認為所有於是次拍賣的洋酒完全及真實 有關此事項的其他重要信息, 請參見頁後的銷售條款 我們十分期待與你於拍場上碰面, 或於一連串專為這收藏拍賣而籌備的洋酒鑑賞活動上分享心得 如閣下有任何疑問, 歡迎與我們聯絡 主席 Jeff Zacharia 謹啟 11

12 Day One Red Burgundy ( Lots 1-360) Day Two Bordeaux (Lots ) Sauternes (Lots ) Red Burgundy ( Lots ) White Burgundy ( Lots ) Rhône Valley ( Lots ) Champagne ( Lots ) Alsace ( Lots ) Germany ( Lots ) Italy ( Lots ) Spain ( Lots ) Portugal ( Lots ) Madeira ( Lots ) Massandra ( Lots ) Australia ( Lots ) California ( Lots ) 12 Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com

13 DAY ONE November 17, 2017 Lots Lot 296 Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com 13

14 Day 1 Lots Burgundy Burgundy Domaine de la Romanée-Conti The domaine is known for picking very late, sometimes, as in 1978, later than any other producers. They prune endlessly, make many passes through the vineyards at harvest and sort grapes rigorously both in the vineyard and at the winery. Average age of the vines is around thirtyfive to forty-five years with yields typically around thirty hl/ha. The wines are aged in new French oak casks for approximately twenty months. There is usually only one racking and since 1985 the wines from all casks in each cru have been blended together prior to bottling to reduce bottle variation. Recently they have been moving towards biodynamic viticultural practices. Like many of the region s leading growers they have seen concrete evidence of soil and vine health improvement. It s hard to imagine that these wines could get better, but that is what separates them from the rest of the pack: an unrelenting pursuit for perfection in the Pinot Noir grape. In addition to the majestic reds, a white is also produced from a plot in Montrachet. Their tiny parcel of vines was purchased in 1964 along with an even smaller amount of Bâtard- Montrachet: so small in fact that it is not sold, but rather entirely reserved for use at the domaine. Throughout the whole range of wines the glorious, true, clean flavor of the Pinot Noir comes shining through. At their best, these are yardstick examples of all that is glorious about Burgundy with Romanée-Conti the purest, most aristocratic and most intense example of Pinot Noir you could possibly imagine. Clive Coates, MW, Côte d Or 這個酒莊以遲採收著名, 有時甚至是最後一家生產商採收,1978 年便出現過這種情況 他們不斷地採摘, 莊園及酒廠對葡萄的分類十分嚴格, 葡萄在莊園及酒廠內均經過多重檢查 葡萄樹的平均樹齡約 35 至 45 年, 每年產量約 30hl/ha 葡萄酒存放於新法國橡木桶大概二十個月, 通常只有一次換桶, 使酒和沉澱物分開 自 1985 年起, 取自同一塊葡萄園葡萄所釀成的葡萄酒, 都會在入樽前進行混合, 以減少每瓶葡萄酒之間的差異 最近他們已轉用生物動力學栽培葡萄 正如區內其他領先的生產商一樣, 採用了新的方法後, 土壤及葡萄樹的健康明顯有所改善, 還可以把這美酒的品質再進一步提升, 實在使人難以想像 對 Pinot Noir 葡萄品種追求完美, 使它與其他葡萄酒有所分別 所有 Pinot Noir 系列的葡萄酒中都充滿一種高貴 真實及清純的味道 布根地產區中最好的 Pinot Noir 葡萄酒, 要數最純 最講究及最熱情的 Romanée-Conti 了 Clive Coates, MW, Côte d Or Echézeaux Domaine de la Romanée-Conti cm, lightly bin-soiled label 1 1 bottle per lot HK$ US$ Echézeaux Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 1998 lightly scuffed label "While this could certainly be drunk now with pleasure, for my taste I would advise leaving the '98 Ech in the cellar for another 3 to 5 years and then drink over the next 10 to 15..." BH 9/ bottle per lot HK$ US$ Echézeaux Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 1999 one bin-soiled label, one lightly scuffed label, different importers "There is excellent phenolic maturity to the equally ripe, rich and relatively supple medium-bodied flavors that are still underpinned by notably firm tannins and really lovely acid/ fruit balance on the beautifully long finish...this is one of the better DRC Echézeaux in a long time...93." BH 1/ bottles per lot HK$14,000-20,000 US$ Echézeaux Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 2005 one lightly bin-soiled label, one lightly scuffed label "This is a big wine by any measure with excellent mid-palate density and superb length...94." BH 1/ bottles per lot HK$38,000-55,000 US$ Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com

15 Grands Echézeaux Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 1997 "...classic red and black berry fruit and spice notes that precede slightly somber and reserved medium full flavors that are delicious...91." BH 1/ bottle per lot HK$ US$ Grands Echézeaux Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 1998 "...complex but reluctant aromas of spice, blackberry and cassis...very classy and stylish because even though it's a very powerful wine, it is still elegant and harmonious...92." BH 5/ bottle per lot HK$ US$ Grands Echézeaux Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 2000 lightly bin-soiled label "...round, supple yet quite intense flavors that offer better depth and concentration than the Echézeaux plus outstanding length...91." BH 1/ bottle per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Grands Echézeaux Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 2003 scuffed label "...round yet structured, muscular yet accessible flavors of phenomenal richness and power...92." BH 1/ bottle per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Grands Echézeaux Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 2004 "This isn't a big wine but the superb detail and unmatched precision are stunning...91." BH 1/ bottles per lot HK$14,000-20,000 US$ Grands Echézeaux Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 2005 three lightly scuffed labels "...muscular, robust and powerful big-bodied flavors that exude dry extract on the detailed and hugely persistent finish...96." BH 1/ bottles per lot HK$50,000-80,000 US$ ,000 La Tâche Domaine de la Romanée-Conti cm, lightly bin-soiled labels, lightly corroded capsules, one slightly depressed cork "The flavors are extremely rich, sweet and wonderfully concentrated with a deep, very sweet essence of pinot finish that still retains glimpses of its former power. The tannins are fully resolved and the finish is nothing but pure silk and velvet...95." BH 10/ bottles per lot HK$75, ,000 US$ ,000 La Tâche Domaine de la Romanée-Conti cm or better unless noted Lot 12: lightly bin-soiled and scuffed labels, three lightly marked labels, one lightly torn label, one marked monopole tag, one missing monopole tag, two cut capsules reveal fully branded corks, one with signs of old seepage Lot 13: one lightly bin-soiled label, seven lightly marked labels, two lightly nicked labels, four lightly scuffed labels, one marked label, one missing monopole tag, one torn label, four different importers Lot 14: four 2.5cm, one 3cm, six bin-soiled labels, two lightly scuffed labels, one lightly torn label, one lightly wine-stained label, one wine-stained label, one with wax adhered to label, one lightly torn capsule, three different importers, seven with signs of old seepage "The flavors are big, rich, refined, classy, penetrating and superbly powerful yet everything is in perfect balance...99." BH 6/ bottles per lot HK$140, ,000 US$18,000-26, bottles per lot HK$420, ,000 US$55,000-80, bottles per lot HK$420, ,000 US$55,000-80,000 Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com 15

16 La Tâche Domaine de la Romanée-Conti cm or better unless noted Lot 15: one 2.5cm, one 3cm, two lightly bin-soiled labels, one lightly nicked label, one lightly wine-stained label, one torn label, one wine-stained label, two different importers Lot 16: two 6-pack original wood cases "The slightly austere, tannic, wonderfully rich flavors are dense, in fact extremely dense with excellent depth and terrific complexity and a finish that seems to go on forever...96." BH 6/ bottles per lot HK$70, ,000 US$ , bottles per lot HK$200, ,000 US$26,000-38,000 La Tâche Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 1996 wine-stained and lightly scuffed label The tannins are big, ripe and are completely buffered by the sap with length that is simply phenomenal BH 7/ bottle per lot HK$16,000-24,000 US$ La Tâche Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 1998 lightly nicked label "It's worth pointing out that while this is still on the way up, I was pleasantly surprised at how approachable the '98 LT was even though there is more development potential to realize...95." BH 1/ bottle per lot HK$14,000-20,000 US$ La Tâche Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 1999 Lot 19: eight lightly bin-soiled labels, four lightly scuffed labels, one scuffed label, one torn vintage tag, three with signs of old seepage Lot 20: three lightly bin-soiled labels, four lightly marked labels, five lightly scuffed labels, one nicked monopole tag, one wine-stained label "...big, rich and enveloping flavors of hoisin and pure pinot extract of indescribable complexity and length. The big tannins are completely wrapped in velvet and the finish simply does not quit...99." BH 4/ bottles per lot HK$320, ,000 US$42,000-65, bottles per lot HK$320, ,000 US$42,000-65,000 La Tâche Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 2001 Lot 21: one lightly torn vintage tag, lightly bin-soiled labels, one lightly scuffed label Lot 22: five lightly bin-soiled labels, three with signs of old seepage The powerful, chiseled, pure flavors are remarkably detailed, precise and fine with mind bending complexity...aristocratic in every sense BH 1/ bottles per lot HK$80, ,000 US$10,000-16, bottles per lot HK$130, ,000 US$17,000-24,000 La Tâche Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 2002 Lot 23: banded original wood case Lot 24: one lightly bin-soiled label, one scuffed label, original wood case "Absolutely stunning aromas of pure cherry, strawberry and raspberry mark this La Tâche. It's vibrant, balanced and very elegant, with ripe fruit and tannins and a long finish...96." WS 6/ bottles per lot HK$100, ,000 US$13,000-19, bottles per lot HK$100, ,000 US$13,000-19, Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com

17 Lots 23 & 24 Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com 17

18 Lots 26 & Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com

19 La Tâche Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 2003 different importers "...a wine of finesse and purity...notes of plum, mocha and coffee, it is one powerful wine that possesses huge length...95." BH 1/ bottles per lot HK$34,000-50,000 US$ La Tâche Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 2005 Lot 26: one lightly scuffed label Lot 27: four lightly marked labels, four lightly scuffed labels, one with tissue paper adhered to label "...a huge but utterly classy and stylish wine that will undoubtedly go down as one of the all time great LT's...99." BH 1/ bottles per lot HK$70, ,000 US$ , bottles per lot HK$280, ,000 US$36,000-55,000 La Tâche Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 2007 banded original wood case "...wonderfully broad, spicy, fresh, airy and layered leads to intensely floral, mineral infused and focused medium weight plus flavors that possess a strikingly attractive mouth feel...95." BH 1/ bottles per lot HK$85, ,000 US$11,000-17,000 Richebourg Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 1996 one lightly scuffed label "A gorgeous, spicy and expressive nose of mostly black fruit aromas combines with rich, sweet and still tight medium full and quite firmly structured flavors that possess a long though slightly edgy and austere finish...92." BH 4/ bottles per lot HK$20,000-30,000 US$ Richebourg Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 1997 one lightly scuffed label, lightly corroded capsules, one with signs of old seepage "...elegant and refined while transitioning into rich, sweet and full-bodied flavors that possess good muscle and solid if not sensational depth and length...92." BH 1/ bottles per lot HK$16,000-24,000 US$ Richebourg Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 1999 five lightly bin-soiled labels, two lightly scuffed labels, one lightly torn label, three different importers "...impressively scaled medium weight plus flavors that are robust and overtly muscular where the finish retains a sense of robust power and stunning length...one of the great vintages for this fabled wine...96." BH 5/ bottles per lot HK$95, ,000 US$12,000-18,000 La Tâche Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 2008 Lot 29: one lightly scuffed label, two scuffed labels, two with signs of old seepage Lot 30: banded original wood case "...firm tannins that are completely enrobed by the impressive amount of extract that also coats the mouth on the hugely long and ever-so-slightly minty finish...the sheer length of the finish is immense, which is always a very positive sign...96." BH 1/ bottles per lot HK$46,000-65,000 US$ bottles per lot HK$95, ,000 US$12,000-17,000 Richebourg Domaine de la Romanée-Conti cm, wine-stained label, signs of old seepage "...very ripe, beautifully complex flavors...this has excellent density of extract and solid balance. Rich, long and impressive...93." BH 7/ bottle per lot HK$16,000-24,000 US$ Richebourg Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 2000 "Extremely ripe, indeed even notes of torrefaction and roast espresso beans precede big, robust, forceful austere black fruit flavors...really quite regal...92." BH 1/ bottles per lot HK$26,000-42,000 US$ Richebourg Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 2001 five lightly damp-stained labels, two lightly torn labels, one torn label "I particularly like the stupendously long and incredibly intense finish that offers a surprising sensation of almost pungent minerality...94." BH 1/ bottles per lot HK$70, ,000 US$ ,000 Richebourg Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 2002 one lightly marked label "...deep, wonderfully attractive plummy hint followed by powerfully spiced flavors that offer impeccable balance and real muscle...95." BH 1/ bottles per lot HK$19,000-28,000 US$ Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com 19

20 Richebourg Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 2004 lightly scuffed label "...almost brooding flavors that are as once supple yet precise and detailed, all wrapped in a powerful and muscular finish that delivers striking length...93." BH 1/ bottle per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Richebourg Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 2005 two lightly scuffed labels, one scuffed label "...extremely rich, full and sweet flavors that are quite floral in the mouth, all wrapped in a detailed and punchy finish where the tannic spine is completely buried...97." BH 1/ bottles per lot HK$75, ,000 US$ ,000 Richebourg Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 2007 banded original wood case "...supple, round and tautly muscled broad-shouldered flavors that are almost as pure as those of the RSV, all wrapped in a detailed, focused and almost painfully intense finish brimming with minerality and striking length...93." BH 1/ bottles per lot HK$50,000-75,000 US$ Romanée-Conti Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 1998 scuffed label "...refined, pure and concentrated medium full flavors that possess the usual spectacular detail on the gorgeously persistent finish...96." BH 4/ bottle per lot HK$65,000-95,000 US$ ,000 Romanée-Conti Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 1999 Lot 42: crooked monopole tag, lightly bin-soiled label Lot 43: one lightly nicked label, one lightly scuffed label, one scuffed label, different importers As seductive as the nose is and as awe-inspiring as the flavors are, the finish lasts literally for minutes, indeed I could still taste it the next day BH 4/ bottle per lot HK$95, ,000 US$12,000-18, bottles per lot HK$190, ,000 US$24,000-36,000 Romanée-Conti Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 2001 Lot 44: one lightly nicked label, lightly scuffed labels Lot 45: two lightly bin-soiled labels, one scuffed label, one wine-stained label, three with signs of old seepage The purity and detail are flat out incredible with nuanced, multi-layered flavors wrapped in pinot sap and culminating in an awe-inspiring finish BH 4/ bottles per lot HK$140, ,000 US$18,000-26, bottles per lot HK$280, ,000 US$36,000-55,000 Romanée-Conti Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 2002 Impeccably balanced with a certain tenderness here with tannins that are sophisticated and quite fine with the classic Romanée-Conti character of an almost spiritual sense of harmony BH 4/ bottles per lot HK$140, ,000 US$18,000-26,000 Romanée-Conti Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 2004 includes 3-pack original wood case "...combine to perfectly complement the equally reserved, pure and unbelievably precise...flavors underpinned by sophisticated tannins and huge length...94." BH 1/ bottles per lot HK$160, ,000 US$20,000-30,000 Romanée-Conti Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 2005 one lightly bin-soiled label, two lightly nicked labels, two lightly scuffed labels "The sweet, intense, focused, detailed and vibrant flavors offer superb drive and punch...absolutely crystalline...in a word, this is mind bending and in a visceral sense, this is a monumental wine of real emotional impact. Genius in a glass " BH 1/ bottles per lot HK$300, ,000 US$38,000-60, Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com

21 Lot 48 Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com 21

22 Romanée-Conti Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 2007 banded original wood case "A wafting, wave-like finish harbors the sort of exhilarating sheer refreshment one looks for in white wine, and a kaleidoscopic interchange of colorful floral, spice, fruit, carnal, and mineral elements such as few wines of any sort can deliver...96." WA 6/ bottles per lot HK$200, ,000 US$26,000-38,000 Romanée-Conti Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 2010 lightly bin-soiled, marked and scuffed label "Like all of the great vintages of this most famous of burgundies, it is almost inconceivably spherical with a Zen-like sense of harmony. I could taste this hours later...but it should be one of the all-time greats in due time. In short, young burgundy just doesn't get any better than this...99." BH 1/ bottle per lot HK$85, ,000 US$11,000-17,000 Romanée-St-Vivant Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 1996 one with signs of old seepage "Gentle at first, offering rose petal aromas, it turns quite savage and tough on the palate, with loads of fruit cloaked in the very firm tannin structure. The acidity is there, and the length is terrific...95." WS 9/ bottles per lot HK$15,000-22,000 US$ Romanée-St-Vivant Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 1998 "The medium full, rich, spicy and intense flavors possess ripe tannins underpinning the considerable structural spine...91." BH 4/ bottle per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Lot Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com

23 Lot 50 Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com 23

24 Romanée-St-Vivant Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 1999 Lot 53: one lightly nicked label, one scuffed label, different importers Lot 54: four lightly bin-soiled labels, two lightly marked labels, three with Italian importer label on back, one slightly protruded cork, one with signs of old seepage, one with slight glass imperfection "The palate is medium-bodied...there is superior clarity and focus, the tannins clearly fine and the finish shimmering with tension and femininity...96." WA 8/ bottles per lot HK$20,000-28,000 US$ bottles per lot HK$120, ,000 US$16,000-24,000 Romanée-St-Vivant Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 2001 one lightly bin-soiled label, one wine-stained label, two with signs of old seepage "...all wrapped together with a seductive kiss of sweetly scented, highly perfumed violets...96." BH 1/ bottles per lot HK$28,000-42,000 US$ Romanée-St-Vivant Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 2004 "The moderately full flavors are sappy, rich and sweet with ample volume and a palate drenching finish that benefits from an underlying sense of vibrancy...terrific stuff and exceptionally long " BH 1/ bottles per lot HK$20,000-28,000 US$ Romanée-St-Vivant Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 2007 original wood case two lightly scuffed labels "...seductively textured, detailed and gorgeously delineated middle weight flavors that possess laser-like focus if less density than is usually seen with this wine...94." BH 1/ bottles per lot HK$50,000-75,000 US$ Vosne-Romanée 1er Cru Duvault-Blochet Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 2002 Côte de Nuits, Premier Cru lightly bin-soiled labels "...very intense middle weight flavors that offer really lovely finishing detail and fine persistence. This is a very pretty wine...91." BH 1/ bottles per lot HK$10,000-15,000 US$ Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 1996 Echézeaux (2) one lightly scuffed label Grands Echézeaux (1) La Tâche (3) Richebourg (2) Romanée-Conti (1) slightly protruded cork, wrinkled capsule Romanée-St-Vivant (3) one lightly scuffed label 60 above 12 bottles per lot HK$200, ,000 US$26,000-38,000 Romanée-St-Vivant Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 2005 two lightly bin-soiled labels "...wonderfully fine and refined linear and firmly structured flavors that culminate in a precise, pure and driving finish that goes on and on...97." BH 1/ bottles per lot HK$100, ,000 US$13,000-19,000 Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 1996 Echézeaux (2) one damp-stained label, one glue-stained label Grands Echézeaux (1) lightly scuffed label La Tâche (3) Richebourg (2) Romanée-Conti (1) Romanée-St-Vivant (3) 61 above 12 bottles per lot HK$200, ,000 US$26,000-38, Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com

25 Assortment Case Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 1999 Lot 62: one Romanée-Conti, three La Tâche, two Richebourg, two Romanée-St-Vivant, two Grands Echézeaux, two Echézeaux, banded original wood assortment case Lot 63: one Romanée-Conti, three La Tâche, two Richebourg (one lightly damp-stained label), two Romanée-St-Vivant, two Grands Echézeaux, two Echézeaux, original wood assortment case banded prior to inspection 62 1 case per lot HK$300, ,000 US$38,000-60, case per lot HK$300, ,000 US$38,000-60,000 Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com 25

26 Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 1999 Echézeaux (2) Grands Echézeaux (2) La Tâche (3) one lightly bin-soiled label, one lightly damp-stained label, one lightly scuffed label Richebourg (2) Romanée-Conti (1) Romanée-St-Vivant (2) 64 above 12 bottles per lot HK$300, ,000 US$38,000-60,000 Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 1999 Echézeaux (2) Grands Echézeaux (2) La Tâche (3) one lightly bin-soiled label, one lightly scuffed label Richebourg (2) one lightly nicked label Romanée-Conti (1) Romanée-St-Vivant (2) one lightly bin-soiled label, one scuffed label 65 above 12 bottles per lot HK$300, ,000 US$38,000-60,000 Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 1999 Echézeaux (2) Grands Echézeaux (2) damp-stained and scuffed labels La Tâche (3) one lightly damp-stained label Richebourg (2) lightly scuffed labels Romanée-Conti (1) lightly bin-soiled and scuffed label Romanée-St-Vivant (2) lightly scuffed labels 66 above 12 bottles per lot HK$300, ,000 US$38,000-60,000 Assortment Case Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 2001 Parcel: lots 67 & 68 Lots 67 & 68: one Romanée-Conti, three La Tâche, two Richebourg, two Romanée-St-Vivant, two Grands Echézeaux, two Echézeaux, original wood assortment case banded prior to inspection Lot 69: one Romanée-Conti, three La Tâche (lightly bin-soiled labels, one torn vintage tag), two Richebourg (one lightly scuffed label, lightly bin-soiled labels, two Romanée-St-Vivant (lightly bin-soiled labels), two Grands Echézeaux (lightly binsoiled labels), two Echézeaux (one damp-stained label, lightly bin-soiled labels, one torn label), original wood assortment case 67 1 case per lot HK$200, ,000 US$26,000-38, case per lot HK$200, ,000 US$26,000-38, case per lot HK$200, ,000 US$26,000-38,000 Assortment Case Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 2002 Côte de Nuits Lot 70: one La Tâche, one Richebourg, one Romanée-St-Vivant, one Grands Echézeaux, one Echézeaux, one Vosne-Romanée Duvault-Blochet, banded original wood assortment case Lot 71: one La Tâche, one Richebourg, one Romanée-St-Vivant, one Grands Echézeaux, one Echézeaux, one Vosne-Romanée Duvault-Blochet, original wood assortment case 70 1 case per lot HK$55,000-80,000 US$ , case per lot HK$55,000-80,000 US$ , Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com

27 d Angerville Arnoux Volnay Champans Marquis d'angerville 1985 Côte de Beaune, Premier Cru 2cm or better, two lightly bin-soiled labels, two lightly scuffed labels, two marked labels 72 5 bottles per lot HK$10,000-15,000 US$ Volnay Champans Marquis d'angerville 1990 (9) 1.5cm or better, one lightly damp-stained label, two scuffed labels, one torn label, three wine-stained labels 1990 magnum (1) 2cm, bin-soiled and wine-stained label 73 above 9 bottles & 1 magnum (1.5L) per lot HK$17,000-26,000 US$ Romanée-St-Vivant Robert Arnoux 1999 two different importers "...almost sweet flavors with wave after wave of complexity and a finish that is all about silk and velvet. A gorgeous RSV " BH 1/ bottles per lot HK$28,000-42,000 US$ Vosne-Romanée Les Suchots Robert Arnoux 1999 Côte de Nuits, Premier Cru "A very intensely flavored, multi-dimensional wine. Fullish but splendidly concentrated wine. Everything in its place. Excellent fruit. Very fine grip. Very lovely." CC 3/ bottles per lot HK$12,000-19,000 US$ Volnay Clos des Ducs Marquis d'angerville 1990 Côte de Beaune, Premier Cru 2cm or better, one lightly damp-stained label, one lightly marked label 74 6 bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Volnay Taillepieds Marquis d'angerville 1990 Côte de Beaune, Premier Cru 2cm or better unless noted Lot 75: one 2.5cm, five bin-soiled labels, one lightly bin-soiled label, one wine-stained label Lot 76: two lightly bin-soiled labels, six wine-stained labels 75 8 bottles per lot HK$12,000-19,000 US$ bottles per lot HK$19,000-28,000 US$ Romanée-St-Vivant Robert Arnoux 1962 (1) 1cm 1966 (2) one 1cm, one 4cm, one bin-soiled label, one partially deteriorated label, one depressed cork, different bottlings 81 above 3 bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Volnay Caillerets Marquis d'angerville 2005 Côte de Beaune, Premier Cru bottles per lot HK$10,000-15,000 US$ Volnay Marquis d'angerville 2005 Champans (6) Clos des Ducs (6) 78 above 12 bottles per lot HK$13,000-20,000 US$ Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com 27

28 Bouchard La Romanée Bouchard Père et Fils 1999 lightly scuffed label "The intensity of this wine is dialed way up with thick, super ripe aromas of black berries, oriental spices, tea, leather and a trace of underbrush...96." BH 4/ bottle per lot HK$ US$ Chambertin Charlopin 1997 (3) 1998 (8) two different importers 1999 (4) 2001 (3) 2002 (4) 87 above 22 bottles per lot HK$19,000-28,000 US$ La Romanée Bouchard Père et Fils 2002 two scuffed labels "...powerful and very deep if presently tight and somber flavors of astonishing richness and length. But it's the seamless harmony, superb purity of expression and sheer class that distinguishes this. In a word, breathtaking...95." BH 4/ bottles per lot HK$46,000-70,000 US$ La Romanée Bouchard Père et Fils 2005 two lightly scuffed labels, one with signs of old seepage "A positively kaleidoscopic and utterly knockout nose... even cool medium full flavors that are like silk on the palate " BH 4/ magnums (1.5L) per lot HK$100, ,000 US$13,000-19,000 Romanée-St-Vivant Cathiard-Molinier cm, one torn label 85 2 bottles per lot HK$12,000-19,000 US$ Chambertin Charlopin 1999 mise en bouteille par Phillippe Charlopin pour Madame Jocelyne Baron, one with signs of old seepage bottles per lot HK$10,000-15,000 US$ Romanée-St-Vivant JJ Confuron 1996 (1) 1999 (3) 88 above 4 bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Mixed Burgundy Volnay Les Mitans Hubert de Montille 1985 (2) 3cm, lightly bin-soiled and marked labels, one lightly winestained label Pommard Grand Epenots Domaine de Montille 1993 (6) four lightly bin-soiled labels 89 above 8 bottles per lot HK$ US$ Musigny Drouhin-Laroze 1996 (2) 1999 (6) one marked label, one depressed cork 90 above 8 bottles per lot HK$13,000-19,000 US$ Claude Dugat Charmes-Chambertin 1993 (3) bin-soiled labels, one scuffed label Charmes-Chambertin 1995 (1) bin-soiled and wine-stained label Gevrey-Chambertin Lavaux St Jacques 1996 (2) wine-stained labels, different importers Chapelle-Chambertin 1997 (2) bin-soiled and lightly wine-stained labels Chapelle-Chambertin 1999 (1) heavily wine-stained label 91 above 9 bottles per lot HK$17,000-26,000 US$ Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com

29 Lot 89 Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com 29

30 Dugat-Py Charmes-Chambertin Dugat-Py 1993 bin-soiled and wine-stained labels 92 3 bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Chambertin Dugat-Py 2001 bin-soiled and wine-stained label "A viscous, yet perfectly-balanced effort, it sports an imposing, seemingly unending finish. This stately Burgundy transcends its vintage. Wow! " WA 6/ bottle per lot HK$10,000-15,000 US$ Chambertin Dugat-Py 2002 bin-soiled and wine-stained label "Immensely concentrated and profound, it must be tasted to be believed " WA 6/ bottle per lot HK$11,000-16,000 US$ Dugat-Py Charmes-Chambertin 1996 (1) bin-soiled and wine-stained label Mazis-Chambertin 1996 (1) bin-soiled and wine-stained label Mazis-Chambertin 2001 (2) wine-stained and lightly bin-soiled labels Mazis-Chambertin 2002 (1) bin-soiled and wine-stained label 95 above 5 bottles per lot HK$10,000-16,000 US$ Musigny Faiveley 1993 bin-soiled label 96 1 bottle per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Griotte-Chambertin Vieille Vigne Domaine Fourrier 2001 two different importers vines planted in 1928 "...a bit more weight and extract and when coupled with the knock-out complexity of the finish, this is a brilliant example of the appellation, combining sheer elegance with stunning purity, a combination that I find irresistible " BH 1/ bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Griotte-Chambertin Vieille Vigne Domaine Fourrier 2002 vines planted in 1928 "...buckets of sappy extract yet it retains a measure of reserve, especially on the silky, wonderfully long finish. In short, a supremely elegant wine that is the epitome of power without weight " BH 1/ bottles per lot HK$16,000-24,000 US$ Vieille Vigne Domaine Fourrier Gevrey-Chambertin Clos St Jacques 2001 (2) Chambolle-Musigny Gruenchers 2002 (8) Gevrey-Chambertin Clos St Jacques 2002 (3) Chambolle-Musigny Gruenchers 2006 (3) lightly bin-soiled, marked and scuffed labels 99 above 16 bottles per lot HK$17,000-26,000 US$ Pommard Grands Epenots 2cm or better unless noted Henri Gaunoux 1959 (5) one 2.5cm, one 3.5cm, two nicked labels, wine-stained labels Michel Gaunoux 1978 (2) bin-soiled labels, one lightly damp-stained label 100 above 7 bottles per lot HK$19,000-28,000 US$ Chambertin Clos de Bèze Robert Groffier 1999 one lightly nicked label, one wine-stained label, two different importers "Its liquid velvet-like personality screams of sur-maturite, yet it is fresh and delineated. It displays a prodigiously long, candied, supple finish...95." WA 8/ bottles per lot HK$10,000-15,000 US$ Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com

31 Gros Hudelot-Noëllat Richebourg A-F Gros 2005 "The mouth coating flavors are structured and muscular, offering serious size and weight yet there is nothing ponderous here as the balance is impeccable and this too is built to age " BH 4/ bottles per lot HK$15,000-22,000 US$ Richebourg Anne Gros 1996 one bin-soiled label, one lightly nicked label, one lightly scuffed label, different importers "The middle weight flavors are elegant and vibrant with excellent overall balance and length...beautiful fruit/acid/tannin balance...92." BH 5/ bottles per lot HK$13,000-19,000 US$ Richebourg Anne Gros 1999 two different importers "...magnificently concentrated on the palate. Fabulous fruit. Fullish weight. Very fine grip. The tannins are very ripe. Great length, complexity and vigor, intensity and quality. A great wine..." CC 3/ bottles per lot HK$30,000-46,000 US$ Richebourg Anne Gros 2002 "The flavor profile is intense, seductive and spicy with a wonderfully textured and velvety character to the big, rich, forceful flavors of uncommon depth and astonishing length...94." BH 1/ bottles per lot HK$20,000-28,000 US$ Richebourg Hudelot-Noëllat cm or better, bin-soiled labels bottles per lot HK$14,000-20,000 US$ Romanée-St-Vivant Hudelot-Noëllat 1996 two torn labels bottles per lot HK$15,000-22,000 US$ Romanée-St-Vivant Hudelot-Noëllat 1999 "The medium weight flavors are intense, pure and moderately structured with evident breed and this finishes with excellent persistence. Quite understated with moderately firm tannins and there is just no hiding how classy this is...93." BH 1/ bottles per lot HK$24,000-36,000 US$ Richebourg Hudelot-Noëllat 2002 Lot 109: one double label Lot 110: writing on label This intensity builds from the mid-palate and finally explodes on the finish with absolutely perfect acid/fruit balance and the phenomenal length just doesn t quit " BH 1/ bottles per lot HK$16,000-24,000 US$ magnum (1.5L) per lot HK$ US$ Romanée-St-Vivant Hudelot-Noëllat 2002 writing on label A wine that is at once highly expressive yet a model of grace and understatement. In short, this is wonderfully classy juice " BH 1/ magnum (1.5L) per lot HK$ US$ Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com 31

32 Henri Jayer It is interesting to reflect upon the fact that in many ways Henri Jayer is portrayed as a modernizer in Burgundy, as many of the techniques that he pioneered in the region have been embraced by legions of vignerons, but in many respects he represented a return to a very traditional approach to winemaking. His emphasis on viticultural practices and the meticulous care that he gave to his vineyards are simply the most obvious facets of his traditional methodology. Henri Jayer revolutionized winemaking during the course of his career. Amongst his very many accomplishments was his emphasis on limiting yields in the vineyard, allowing the cooled must to macerate for a few days prior to the onset of alcoholic fermentation to allow colors to set and adding to the aromatic complexity in the finished wine and bottling the wine unfined and unfiltered. He always spoke of the importance of treating the wine gently during the fermentation and elevage process, which he likened to moving a sleeping baby who must be carried to its bed from the sofa upon which it has fallen asleep. He also was a proponent of one hundred percent new oak for his wines. This was the one precept of his winemaking technique that cannot be described as traditional, and it is the one most often cited by modern winemakers when they seek to sprinkle a little of the fairy dust of Jayer inspiration on their own wines. There is little doubt that the concept that a Grand Cru deserves to be raised in one hundred percent new oak that is often heard in Burgundy these days can be traced back to Henri Jayer and his success with new wood. However, one of the interesting things I have always found about Henri Jayer s wines was that I have never tasted one that was over-oaked. John Gilman, View From the Cellar 從現實中看來, 令人感到有趣的是,Henri Jayer 既在不同範疇被塑造成布根地現代化的先驅, 令一眾釀酒師奉行許多由他開創的技術 ; 然而他在釀酒方面大多都回歸非常傳統的方法 他重視葡萄種植栽培的實踐, 而他一絲不苟地, 悉心護理著葡萄田, 正正就能表現出他對傳統方法論的重視 在 Henri Jayer 職業生涯中, 他在釀酒方面進行了突破性大改革 在他芸芸眾多的成就中, 最出眾的是以下數項 : 其一, 銳意限制葡萄田的產量 ; 其二, 在酒精發酵程序開始前數天, 先把葡萄酒液在低溫下進行浸泡 這既能先抽取顏色, 又能為成酒添加香氣複雜性 ; 其三, 葡萄酒裝瓶時不進行澄清和過濾過程 他經常提及在發酵和陳釀過程中需溫柔對待葡萄酒的重要性, 就好比從梳化上抱起一個熟睡的嬰兒, 然後輕放床上, 卻仍然安寐 此外, 他倡導他的葡萄酒使用 100% 全新木桶, 這是他釀酒技術中唯一一項不能視作傳統工序 當一些現代釀酒師欲為他們的葡萄酒冠上 Jayer 啟發之名, 則常引用此技術, 藉以為自己的葡萄酒冠上光環 近來在布根地常聽到一個概念, 就是特級葡萄田的葡萄酒應在 100% 全新木桶中發酵和陳釀, 而這概念則源自 Henri Jayer 以及他使用新木桶的成功 當中最為有趣的是在 Henri Jayer 所作的葡萄酒中, 我卻從未品嚐過一款擁有過重的木桶氣息 John Gilman, View From the Cellar Echézeaux Henri Jayer for Georges Jayer cm, signs of old seepage bottle per lot HK$14,000-20,000 US$ Echézeaux Henri Jayer for Georges Jayer cm, lightly bin-soiled label bottle per lot HK$19,000-28,000 US$ Echézeaux Henri Jayer for Georges Jayer 1990 Lot 114: 1.5cm, lightly marked label Lot 115: two 2cm or better, one 2.5cm, two 3cm, one 4cm, one with importer tag adhered to label, two lightly bin-soiled labels, one lightly damp-stained label, three lightly scuffed labels, one nicked label, one torn vintage tag, three cut capsules reveal fully branded corks, two lightly corroded capsules, one corroded capsule partially reveals cork, one cut capsule reveals vintage branded cork, three different importers, two with signs of old seepage bottle per lot HK$26,000-42,000 US$ bottles per lot HK$160, ,000 US$20,000-32,000 Echézeaux Henri Jayer for Georges Jayer 1991 one crooked vintage tag, lightly bin-soiled labels "A great smoky, earthy, spicy nose precedes textured, powerful, rich, long, utterly lovely flavors of considerable length, breed and elegance. Still quite youthful and fresh...in short, this is a really beautiful wine...93." BH 4/ bottles per lot HK$65,000-95,000 US$ ,000 Echézeaux Henri Jayer for Georges Jayer 1993 Lot 117: 3.5cm Lot 118: one 2.5cm, five 3cm, two wine-stained labels, two wine-stained vintage tags, one cut capsule reveals vintage branded cork, one loose capsule reveals vintage branded cork, two different importers "...beautifully complex, intense, pure, medium weight flavors of impressive density and length...93." BH 11/ bottle per lot HK$20,000-30,000 US$ bottles per lot HK$120, ,000 US$15,000-24, Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com

33 Echézeaux Henri Jayer for Georges Jayer 1994 nicked, lightly marked and scuffed label bottle per lot HK$17,000-26,000 US$ Nuits St Georges Henri Jayer for Georges Jayer 1996 Côte de Nuits one lightly torn label, one scuffed label, one loose capsule bottles per lot HK$24,000-36,000 US$ Echézeaux Henri Jayer for Georges Jayer 1998 Lot 122: one lightly nicked label, two marked labels, one loose capsule reveals fully branded cork bottles per lot HK$100, ,000 US$13,000-19, bottles per lot HK$100, ,000 US$13,000-19,000 Echézeaux Henri Jayer for Georges Jayer 1999 Lot 123: one loose capsule reveals fully branded cork Lot 124: one loose capsule reveals fully branded cork, two different importers Lot 125: two loose capsules reveal fully branded corks Lot 126: two lightly wine-stained labels, three loose capsules reveal vineyard and vintage branded corks, three different importers bottles per lot HK$38,000-55,000 US$ bottles per lot HK$240, ,000 US$32,000-46, bottles per lot HK$240, ,000 US$32,000-46, bottles per lot HK$240, ,000 US$32,000-46,000 Echézeaux Henri Jayer for Georges Jayer 2001 three lightly bin-soiled labels, one wine-stained label bottles per lot HK$50,000-75,000 US$ Echézeaux Henri Jayer 1978 one 2cm, one 3cm, bin-soiled and marked labels, one torn label, one corroded capsule, cut capsules reveal fully branded corks "...aromatically subdued, revealing only glimpses of spicy, almost entirely secondary aromas yet the flavors are exuberant and intensely spicy...93." BH 1/ bottles per lot HK$100, ,000 US$13,000-19,000 Echézeaux Henri Jayer cm, lightly bin-soiled label, loose capsule reveals fully branded cork bottle per lot HK$28,000-42,000 US$ Echézeaux Henri Jayer cm, one lightly bin-soiled label, one lightly marked label "...sweet, delicious, rich and exuberantly expressive flavors of striking length, superb complexity and real breed...93." BH 10/ bottle per lot HK$40,000-60,000 US$5,000-8,000 Vosne-Romanée Cros Parantoux Henri Jayer 1985 Côte de Nuits, Premier Cru 2cm, damp-stained, scuffed and lightly bin-soiled label, loose and cut capsule reveals fully branded cork "...absolutely knock-out aromatic complexity of earth, leather and lot of Vosne spice plus still very fresh, round, rich, full flavors that are like silk on the palate...95." BH 10/ bottle per lot HK$60,000-95,000 US$ ,000 Vosne-Romanée Cros Parantoux Henri Jayer 1987 Côte de Nuits, Premier Cru 3cm, torn and wine-stained label, signs of old seepage magnum (1.5L) per lot HK$100, ,000 US$13,000-19,000 Echézeaux Emmanuel Rouget For Georges Jayer 2002 five lightly marked labels bottles per lot HK$36,000-55,000 US$ Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com 33

34 Echézeaux Henri Jayer 1988 Lot 134: one 2cm, two 2.5cm, one lightly bin-soiled label, one marked label, two nicked labels, one loose capsule reveals fully branded cork, two cut capsules reveal fully branded corks, two different importers Lot 135: 2cm or better, scuffed and lightly wine-stained labels, one corroded capsule Lot 136: 2cm or better, scuffed and wine-stained labels "A beautifully complex mix of mostly secondary aromas with a touch of fresh primary fruit wrapped in spice and earth leads to rich if slightly edgy medium full, nicely punchy and powerful flavors that retain fine precision and length...92." BH 10/ bottles per lot HK$85, ,000 US$11,000-17, magnums (1.5L) per lot HK$140, ,000 US$18,000-26, magnums (1.5L) per lot HK$220, ,000 US$28,000-42,000 Vosne-Romanée Cros Parantoux Henri Jayer 1988 Côte de Nuits, Premier Cru Lot 137: 4.5cm, lightly marked label, cut capsule reveals fully branded cork Lot 138: 3cm, scuffed, torn and lightly bin-soiled label Lot 139: 2cm or better, lightly bin-soiled labels, one lightly nicked label, one torn label, one wine-stained label Lot 140: one 2.5cm, two 3cm, two lightly scuffed labels, one scuffed label, one torn label, wine-stained labels, two corroded capsules, one cut capsule reveals fully branded cork "This is still on its way up and curiously for such a rich, relatively tannic wine, this is rather refined on the finish...93." BH 6/ bottle per lot HK$36,000-55,000 US$ magnum (1.5L) per lot HK$95, ,000 US$12,000-17, magnums (1.5L) per lot HK$280, ,000 US$36,000-55, magnums (1.5L) per lot HK$280, ,000 US$36,000-55,000 Echézeaux Henri Jayer cm Lot 141: lightly scuffed label Lot 142: bin-soiled, deteriorated, heavily torn and wine-stained label bottle per lot HK$26,000-42,000 US$ magnum (1.5L) per lot HK$75, ,000 US$ ,000 Vosne-Romanée Cros Parantoux Henri Jayer 1989 Côte de Nuits, Premier Cru Lot 143: 2cm, nicked and lightly wine-stained label Lot 144: 3.5cm, bin-soiled and scuffed label, cut capsule reveals fully branded cork magnum (1.5L) per lot HK$120, ,000 US$16,000-24, magnum (1.5L) per lot HK$120, ,000 US$16,000-24,000 Vosne-Romanée Cros Parantoux Henri Jayer 1990 Côte de Nuits, Premier Cru Lot 145: 2.5cm, lightly bin-soiled label Lot 146: one 2cm, three 2.5cm, one 4cm, one damp-stained label, one deteriorated label, one heavily scuffed label, four lightly bin-soiled labels, two cut capsules reveal fully branded corks, one loose capsule reveals fully branded cork, two different importers Lot 147: 1cm, nicked and lightly damp-stained label, signs of old seepage Lot 148: 1cm, scuffed label, cut capsule reveals fully branded cork "This is a famous wine and I was fortunate enough to taste it again at Comme Chez Soi in Brussels in March Great. Outstanding plus." FH bottle per lot HK$65,000-95,000 US$ , bottles per lot HK$340, ,000 US$44,000-65, magnum (1.5L) per lot HK$190, ,000 US$24,000-36, magnum (1.5L) per lot HK$190, ,000 US$24,000-36,000 Echézeaux Henri Jayer cm or better, one lightly bin-soiled label, one lightly dampstained label, one lightly nicked label, two lightly scuffed labels, three lightly torn labels, one cut capsule reveals fully branded cork, two loose capsules reveal fully branded corks, two slightly protruded corks "Packed and powerful, this displays superb vibrancy and it continues to impress with its density and elegance...94." BH 7/ bottles per lot HK$95, ,000 US$12,000-18,000 Vosne-Romanée Les Beaumonts Henri Jayer 1993 Côte de Nuits, Premier Cru 2cm, lightly scuffed label, loose capsule reveals fully branded cork bottle per lot HK$24,000-36,000 US$ Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com

35 Vosne-Romanée Henri Jayer 1993 Côte de Nuits 2cm, lightly marked label, loose capsule reveals fully branded cork bottle per lot HK$17,000-26,000 US$ Vosne-Romanée Cros Parantoux Henri Jayer 1993 Côte de Nuits, Premier Cru Lot 152: 2cm or better, one heavily bin-soiled vintage tag, heavily scuffed label, one lightly damp-stained label, two lightly marked label, two lightly nicked labels, one with tape adhered to vintage tag, four loose capsules reveal fully branded corks, two slightly protruded corks, three different importers Lot 153: three 2cm or better, one 2.5cm, two 3cm, one crooked vintage tag, lightly bin-soiled labels, one marked label, one torn label, two lightly corroded capsules, one loose capsule reveals fully branded cork, two slightly protruded corks, two different importers Lot 154: one 2cm, one 3.5cm, lightly bin-soiled labels, one peeling label, one scuffed label, one cut cap reveals fully branded cork Lot 155: one 3cm, one 3.5cm, lightly scuffed labels, one winestained label, one heavily cut capsule reveals fully branded cork, one with signs of old seepage Lot 156: 3.5cm, lightly damp-stained labels, one scuffed label, one cut capsule reveals fully branded cork, one lightly corroded capsule, one loose capsule reveals fully branded cork, one with signs of old seepage Lot 157: 2.5cm, one lightly nicked label, one lightly scuffed label, one torn label, one with signs of old seepage "The tannins coat the mouth yet they are ripe and the wine exudes balance and harmony. While this is stunning now, it is nowhere close to ready...one of the truly great wines of the vintage...95." BH 11/ bottles per lot HK$260, ,000 US$34,000-50, bottles per lot HK$300, ,000 US$38,000-60, magnums (1.5L) per lot HK$220, ,000 US$28,000-42, magnums (1.5L) per lot HK$220, ,000 US$28,000-42, magnums (1.5L) per lot HK$220, ,000 US$28,000-42, magnums (1.5L) per lot HK$340, ,000 US$44,000-65,000 Echézeaux Henri Jayer 1995 lightly scuffed label "...excellent concentration and much better phenolic ripeness than many '95s, all wrapped in a powerful, delicious and still firm and long finish...93." BH 12/ bottle per lot HK$28,000-42,000 US$ Vosne-Romanée Cros Parantoux Henri Jayer 1995 Côte de Nuits, Premier Cru Lot 159: lightly torn and loose capsule reveals fully branded cork Lot 160: one lightly nicked label, different importers "The pieces are all in place for a long, slow evolution and if this can develop additional complexity over time, my score will improve...92." BH 11/ magnum (1.5L) per lot HK$80, ,000 US$10,000-16, magnums (1.5L) per lot HK$160, ,000 US$20,000-32,000 Vosne-Romanée Cros Parantoux Henri Jayer 1996 Côte de Nuits, Premier Cru Lot 161: one lightly damp-stained label, one lightly nicked label, two loose capsules reveal fully branded corks, three different importers Lot 162: heavily wine-stained label, wine-stained vintage tag, loose capsule reveals fully branded cork, 156 magnums produced Lot 163: wine-stained labels, two wine-stained vintage tags, three with signs of old seepage, 156 magnums produced Lot 164: four heavily wine-stained labels, two wine-stained labels, three wine-stained vintage tags, three different importers, two with signs of old seepage, 156 magnums produced "...fine delineation, excellent purity and fine length...there is prominent acidity, budding complexity and excellent finishing intensity...92." BH 3/ bottles per lot HK$500, ,000 US$65,000-95, magnum (1.5L) per lot HK$120, ,000 US$16,000-24, magnums (1.5L) per lot HK$460, ,000 US$60,000-90, magnums (1.5L) per lot HK$700,000-1,000,000 US$90, ,000 Vosne-Romanée Cros Parantoux Reserve Henri Jayer 1997 Côte de Nuits, Premier Cru two lightly bin-soiled labels, one lightly scuffed label, one loose capsule reveals fully branded cork "The sleek, delicious and still vibrant middle weight flavors exhibit plenty of minerality on the sappy and still moderately robust and tannic finale...92." BH 4/ bottles per lot HK$120, ,000 US$16,000-24,000 Vosne-Romanée Cros Parantoux Henri Jayer 1998 Côte de Nuits, Premier Cru one lightly bin-soiled label, one loose capsule reveals fully branded cork, one with signs of old seepage "Elegant, racy and beautifully detailed middle weight flavors underpinned by moderately firm tannins and fine length..." BH 10/ bottles per lot HK$95, ,000 US$12,000-18,000 Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com 35

36 Vosne-Romanée Cros Parantoux Reserve Henri Jayer 1999 Côte de Nuits, Premier Cru Lot 167: one marked label, two wine-stained labels, two winestained vintage tags, one loose capsule reveals fully branded cork, two different importers, one with signs of old seepage Lot 168: one lightly marked vintage tag, one lightly bin-soiled label, one lightly marked label, one wine-stained label, two different importers Lot 169: two lightly scuffed labels, one loose capsule reveals fully branded cork, two different importers Lot 170: two lightly scuffed labels, one wine-stained label, one wine-stained vintage tag, four loose capsules reveal fully branded corks, two different importers Lot 171: one nicked label, two loose capsules reveal fully branded corks, Martines importer Lot 172: one bin-soiled label, two nicked label, one torn label, ten wine-stained label, five wine-stained vintage tag, two with signs of old seepage "An expressive, ripe and elegant nose of Vosne style spice, moderate oak and a mix of earth, minerals and violets leads to rich, round and impressively precise flavors that deliver serious punch and excellent depth. I very much like the overall sense of harmony and fine balance here...94." BH 3/ bottles per lot HK$340, ,000 US$44,000-70, bottles per lot HK$460, ,000 US$60,000-90, bottles per lot HK$700,000-1,000,000 US$90, , bottles per lot HK$700,000-1,000,000 US$90, , bottles per lot HK$700,000-1,000,000 US$90, , bottles per lot HK$700,000-1,000,000 US$90, ,000 Volnay Michel Lafarge 2009 Clos du Château des Ducs (6) Les Mitans (6) 176 above 12 bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ La Grande Rue Lamarche 2005 individual original wood cases one scuffed label, one chipped wax capsule, one heavily chipped wax capsule, one protruded cork, one with signs of old seepage "...sweet, delicious, generous and round medium full flavors that are classy and refined, all wrapped in a strikingly persistent and explosive finish...95." BH 4/ jeroboams (3L) per lot HK$22,000-32,000 US$ Clos des Lambrays Domaine des Lambrays 2005 original wood case bin-soiled labels "Great energy propels this to a long, lingering aftertaste. A combination of power and finesse...95." WS 2/ bottles per lot HK$16,000-24,000 US$ Clos des Lambrays Domaine des Lambrays 2009 original wood case one scuffed label bottles per lot HK$11,000-16,000 US$ Echézeaux Lucien Jayer 1988 one 2cm, one 2.5cm, lightly bin-soiled labels bottles per lot HK$ US$ Echézeaux Jayer-Gilles 1996 damp-stained labels bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Echézeaux Jayer-Gilles 1998 bin-soiled labels, one torn label bottles per lot HK$10,000-15,000 US$ Clos des Lambrays Domaine des Lambrays 1996 (4) damp-stained labels, one lightly marked label, two lightly scuffed labels 1999 (4) 180 above 8 bottles per lot HK$11,000-16,000 US$ Chambertin Launay 2002 "...big, intense, muscled and robust yet supple flavors that are structured and deep on the powerfully long finish...a great effort...94." BH 4/ bottles per lot HK$ US$ Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com

37 Lots Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com 37

38 Domaine Leroy How do you determine great? Is it size? Is it quality? Is it price? Is it reputation (whatever that is)? Is it the amount of media coverage? However you do compute it, the greatest domaines of Burgundy today must be those under the control of Lalou Bize: the Domaine Leroy and her own Domaine d Auvenay. The estates of Jadot, Faiveley and Bouchard Père et Fils are far larger, that of Romanée-Conti the most splendid in terms of the percentage of Grand Cru terroir, but for the nobility of its wines, pride of place must go to Leroy and to Domaine d Auvenay. The sheer concentration, depth and intensity Lalou Bize manages to squeeze into her bottles is breathtaking. Lalou, born in Paris, was brought up in Meursault, in the mansion today occupied by her daughter Perrine. From the word go I was fascinated, she says. I was a cellar rat, watching and helping the cavistes rack the wines, taste them, bottle them. My mother kept calling me to come out of the cellar and play with my friends like a normal schoolgirl, but as soon as I could I crept back. In 1955 she persuaded her father to let her take over. She was twenty-three. He gave me carte blanche, she says. I started as I meant to go on. I bought finished wine, and only that which pleased me. Lalou is now happy at the Domaine Leroy and on her own. Look at my vines, she will say. Look how healthy and comfortable they are. And, being Lalou, she will not fail to point out a neighbor s plot of excessively abundant, uncontrolled growth. And come and taste the wine. Lalou s wines, according to her, are always extra. The one-time cellar rat is now a master in her own right, and the wines she produces are triumphantly brilliant. Clive Coates, Côte d Or 你會怎樣為偉大定義? 以它的數量? 品質? 價錢? 名氣? 還是在媒體的曝光率? 但無論你以甚麼標準去衡量, 由 Lalou Bize 女士所領導的 Domaine Leroy 和 Domaine d Auvenay( 由她私人擁有, 產量極小 ) 必定是布根地最偉大的酒莊之一 當然, 像 Louis Jadot, Bouchard, Faiveley 等著名酒商擁有更多的酒款和更大的產量 ; 羅馬尼康帝酒莊也擁有布根地最優秀的特級葡萄園, 但毫無疑問 Domaine Leroy 和 Domaine d Auvenay 在這些著名酒莊中佔有一個最重要的位置 由 Lalou 女士所釀造的酒, 在集中度, 深度和各方面是可以出色得令人窒息的 Lalou 女士生於巴黎, 在默蘇爾村成長 今天酒莊是由她女兒 Perrine 打理 Lalou: 如果用一個形容詞去形容, 我會說是 著迷 我小時候像一只酒窖的小老鼠, 在酒窖四處亂竄, 參與每個工序, 由換桶, 試酒到入瓶, 我媽媽不停叫我出去和其他小女孩玩耍 但每次我也是會回到酒窖裏 在 1955 年 Lalou 女士繼承了父親的酒莊 當年她才二十三歲 他全權委託我去打理, 她說 : 我像命中註定一樣地開始了, 當時我是由購入完酒開始的, 很高興我現在擁有兩個酒莊 看, 我葡萄樹是多麼的健康和有活力 Lalou 經常會毫不猶豫地指出她鄰居生產過盛和葡萄過份生長的問題 根據 Lalou 的釀酒哲學, 永遠都有 生產過盛 的問題 今天, 曾經的酒窖小老鼠已經成為釀酒大師 而她所釀的酒 -- 無與倫比 源自 Clive Coates 的 Côte d Or Bonnes-Mares Domaine d'auvenay 1993 lightly bin-soiled and torn label, signs of old seepage "...a strong mineral component woven into the wine's immense concentration of red and black fruits...92." WA 8/ bottle per lot HK$10,000-15,000 US$ Bonnes-Mares Domaine d'auvenay 1996 scuffed and lightly damp-stained label, signs of old seepage "This full-bodied, thick, highly-structured, intense, and extraordinarily proportioned wine is crammed with candied blackberries, cassis liqueur, beef blood, and loads of supple tannins...95." WA 8/ bottle per lot HK$12,000-19,000 US$ Mazis-Chambertin Domaine d'auvenay 1996 one lightly marked label, one lightly scuffed label, one lightly wine-stained label, two nicked labels, one scuffed label, one wine-stained label, signs of old seepage "Layers of black cherries, cassis, minerals, iron shavings, and plums can be found in this blockbuster's superbly-focused and extraordinarily delicious personality...bravo!...97." WA 8/ bottles per lot HK$65,000-95,000 US$ ,000 Bonnes-Mares Domaine d'auvenay 1999 one lightly wine-stained label, one with signs of old seepage "It coats the palate with compelling layers of sweet, dark flavors, as well as loads of ripe yet firm tannins. It also possesses an extraordinarily long finish..." WA 6/ bottles per lot HK$22,000-32,000 US$ Mazis-Chambertin Domaine d'auvenay 1999 nine 2cm or better, two 2.5cm, one lightly nicked label, one lightly scuffed label, two corroded capsules, three different importers, six with signs of old seepage "This deep, profound wine has admirable focus, great purity, harmony, and a mind-bogglingly long finish...95." WA 6/ bottles per lot HK$120, ,000 US$16,000-24,000 Mazis-Chambertin Domaine d'auvenay 2000 two lightly bin-soiled labels, three with signs of old seepage bottles per lot HK$28,000-42,000 US$ Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com

39 Lot 186 Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com 39

40 Lot Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com

41 Chambertin Maison Leroy cm, damp-stained and lightly bin-soiled label "...deep and still moderately structured flavors that possess excellent complexity on the powerful and impressively long finish...93." BH 4/ bottle per lot HK$22,000-32,000 US$ Chambertin Domaine Leroy 1997 one lightly nicked label, two different importers "This wine's personality envelopes the palate with lush fruit and spices. It is well-structured, concentrated, and immensely long in the finish...97." WA 10/ bottles per lot HK$60,000-95,000 US$ ,000 Chambertin Maison Leroy 1985 two 2cm or better, two 3.5cm, one damp-stained label, lightly bin-soiled labels, one wine-stained label, two slightly depressed corks, two with signs of old seepage "...fine, intense and focused flavors of real breed and class, not to mention impressive length...93." BH 1/ bottles per lot HK$42,000-60,000 US$ Chambertin Domaine Leroy 1998 one with sticker adhered to label, lightly scuffed labels, two different importers, one with signs of old seepage "It exhibits a nose of dark fruits and fresh herbs that gives way to a broad, medium-to-full-bodied character. This wine has massive layers of tarry black fruit...94." WA 10/ bottles per lot HK$50,000-70,000 US$ Chambertin Domaine Leroy cm, lightly bin-soiled label "The finish is powerful, robust and delivers exceptional length. The tannins are slightly edgy on the back end but there is so much sap that they are largely, if not completely buffered. Deep, stylish and classy wine...95." BH 8/ bottle per lot HK$15,000-22,000 US$ Chambertin Domaine Leroy 1999 one lightly bin-soiled label, one lightly marked label, one lightly nicked label, three lightly scuffed labels, one nicked label, four different importers "This is a extraordinarily classy effort with magnificent complexity and superb length...95." BH 4/ bottles per lot HK$340, ,000 US$44,000-65,000 Chambertin Domaine Leroy cm or better, one bin-soiled label, six lightly bin-soiled labels, one lightly nicked label, one lightly scuffed label, two scuffed labels, three chipped wax capsules, three different importers, nine with signs of old seepage "The flavors are massive, hugely structured and extremely rich and while this is an exceptionally dramatic wine, it's more of a monument to sheer size than purity, elegance or finesse." BH 1/ bottles per lot HK$300, ,000 US$38,000-60,000 Chambertin Domaine Leroy cm or better, lightly bin-soiled labels, two lightly scuffed labels, one wine-stained vintage tag, two with signs of old seepage bottles per lot HK$120, ,000 US$16,000-24,000 Chambertin Domaine Leroy 1996 five 2cm or better, one 3.5cm, one bin-soiled label, three lightly bin-soiled labels, four lightly marked labels, five lightly nicked labels, two torn labels, one wine-stained label, three different importers, two with signs of old seepage "...almost absurdly concentrated and thick, very pinot flavors that are powerful, focused and astonishingly long...94." BH 5/ bottles per lot HK$95, ,000 US$12,000-18,000 Chambertin Domaine Leroy 2000 two lightly scuffed labels, one scuffed label, two different importers, three with signs of old seepage "Perfumed and sweet with brooding, slightly austere flavors dripping with extract and a powerfully long, pungent, intense finish " BH 1/ bottles per lot HK$95, ,000 US$12,000-18,000 Chambertin Domaine Leroy 2001 two lightly bin-soiled labels, two with signs of old seepage "The finish is intense, pure and haunting and this too is flat out an emotionally thrilling, indeed dramatic wine...98." BH 1/ bottles per lot HK$75, ,000 US$ ,000 Chambertin Domaine Leroy 2002 Lot 199: lightly scuffed label Lot 200: one lightly scuffed label, four different importers, one with signs of old seepage "This superbly rich effort is extremely light on its feet for such a big wine and the innate sense of underlying tension and overall balance make for one exceptionally impressive wine...97." BH 1/ bottle per lot HK$24,000-36,000 US$ bottles per lot HK$280, ,000 US$36,000-55,000 Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com 41

42 Chambolle-Musigny Les Charmes Domaine Leroy 1996 Côte de Nuits, Premier Cru damp-stained and wine-stained labels bottles per lot HK$10,000-15,000 US$ Clos de la Roche Domaine Leroy 1990 eleven 2cm or better, one 2.5cm, six lightly bin-soiled labels, two lightly wine-stained labels, one wine-stained label, three lightly chipped wax capsules, four different importers, eleven with signs of old seepage "...exquisite equilibrium and focus, as well as a seemingly unending luxurious finish...98." WA 10/ bottles per lot HK$170, ,000 US$22,000-34,000 Clos de la Roche Domaine Leroy 1991 lightly bin-soiled labels, chipped wax capsules "...exotic wood (cedar and balsam), cassis, stone, and black fruit aromas...showing evidence of evolved fruit flavors, caramelized leaves, and sweet cedar. Chewy-textured and firm..." WA 10/ bottles per lot HK$16,000-24,000 US$ Clos de la Roche Domaine Leroy 1993 one lightly bin-soiled label, two lightly marked labels, one lightly scuffed label, one lightly wine-stained label, one nicked label, one scuffed label, two different importers "This 1993 unquestionably has the requisite power, richness, concentration, and density of fruit to stand up to its solid backbone...98." WA 10/ bottles per lot HK$70, ,000 US$ ,000 Clos de la Roche Domaine Leroy 1996 Lot 205: lightly bin-soiled labels, one scuffed label, three different importers Lot 206: six lightly bin-soiled labels, three lightly marked labels, one lightly wine-stained label, three different importers...beguiling aromas...medium-to-full-bodied and offers a chewy-textured flavor profile WA 10/ bottles per lot HK$36,000-55,000 US$ bottles per lot HK$110, ,000 US$14,000-20,000 Clos de la Roche Domaine Leroy 1998 two with stickers adhered to labels, five lightly bin-soiled labels, two different importers "It has huge quantities of sweet cherry, blackberry, and violetinfused blueberries, a huge velvety-textured character, and a full body...96." WA 10/ bottles per lot HK$42,000-60,000 US$ Clos de la Roche Domaine Leroy 1999 Lot 209: original wood case "...powerful, intense, meaty wine...pure, muscular, dense, and profound...96." WA 8/ bottles per lot HK$24,000-36,000 US$ bottles per lot HK$140, ,000 US$18,000-26,000 Clos de la Roche Domaine Leroy 2000 two lightly bin-soiled labels, one lightly torn label, two with signs of old seepage "This too offers outstanding complexity...medium weight, quite focused flavors and stunning length " BH 1/ bottles per lot HK$24,000-36,000 US$ Clos de la Roche Domaine Leroy 2001 one lightly nicked label, one scuffed label, two with signs of old seepage "...jammy, roasted, perfumed, slightly floral aromas and explosive ripe, very primary, rather robust flavors that just ooze pinot extrac...94." BH 1/ bottles per lot HK$28,000-42,000 US$ Clos de la Roche Domaine Leroy 2002 one lightly scuffed label, one lightly chipped wax capsule, three with signs of old seepage "...huge, indeed almost massive flavors of colossal proportions...this is dynamic, vibrant and almost implausibly long...96." BH 1/ bottles per lot HK$70, ,000 US$ , Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com

43 Lot 212 Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com 43

44 Clos de Vougeot Maison Leroy cm, bin-soiled label, signs of old seepage bottle per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Corton Maison Leroy 1966 Côte de Beaune, Grand Cru 4cm, torn and heavily bin-soiled label, corroded capsule bottle per lot HK$ US$ Clos de Vougeot Domaine Leroy 1993 lightly bin-soiled labels "Sweet, ripe, red and black cherry flavors pick up a truffle accent as this builds on the palate. Fine richness, culminating in a long finish...95." WS bottles per lot HK$42,000-60,000 US$ Corton Renardes Domaine Leroy 1990 Côte de Beaune, Grand Cru 2cm or better, one bin-soiled label, two lightly bin-soiled labels "...medium-to-full-bodied, silky-textured wine has great depth of dark cherry fruit in its flavor profile...structured, solid finish." WA 10/ bottles per lot HK$17,000-26,000 US$ Clos de Vougeot Domaine Leroy 1995 lightly bin-soiled and wine-stained label "...tightly wound, super-concentrated core...this firm, mediumto-full-bodied, backward wine is packed with loads of fruit and tannin...93." WA 10/ bottle per lot HK$ US$ Corton Renardes Domaine Leroy 1993 Côte de Beaune, Grand Cru one lightly marked label, two lightly scuffed labels, one scuffed label "Medium-to-full-bodied and hugely concentrated, it opens with spectacular, lushly-textured, intense fruit...94." WA 10/ bottles per lot HK$24,000-36,000 US$ Clos de Vougeot Domaine Leroy 1996 one lightly damp-stained label, one lightly marked label, one lightly nicked label, one lightly scuffed label, two lightly winestained labels, one marked label, one nicked label, one winestained label, two different importers bottles per lot HK$70, ,000 US$ ,000 Clos de Vougeot Domaine Leroy 1999 one lightly scuffed label, one nicked label "The flavors are supple but there is a solid tannic spine beneath the sap. A really fine effort...94." BH 5/ bottles per lot HK$24,000-36,000 US$ Corton Renardes Maison Leroy 1964 Côte de Beaune, Grand Cru 3.5cm, wine-stained and lightly bin-soiled label bottle per lot HK$ US$ Corton Renardes Domaine Leroy 1996 Côte de Beaune, Grand Cru one bin-soiled label, one lightly bin-soiled label, one lightly marked label, one nicked label, three different importers bottles per lot HK$28,000-42,000 US$ Corton Renardes Domaine Leroy 1999 Côte de Beaune, Grand Cru scuffed label "This gem also possesses a stupendously long, pure, and supple finish...97." WA 8/ bottle per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Corton Renardes Domaine Leroy 2000 Côte de Beaune, Grand Cru marked and lightly torn label "This is a real stunner of a wine and should drink well over many years " BH 1/ bottle per lot HK$ US$ Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com

45 Echézeaux Maison Leroy cm, nicked and lightly bin-soiled label bottle per lot HK$ US$ Griotte-Chambertin Maison Leroy cm, lightly bin-soiled and wine-stained label bottle per lot HK$ US$ Echézeaux Maison Leroy 1969 two 2cm or better, one 2.5cm, one lightly nicked label "...wonderfully spicy and expressive...medium full, delicious, intense flavors that display good finishing richness...91." BH 7/ bottles per lot HK$17,000-26,000 US$ La Romanée Maison Leroy cm or better, one lightly bin-soiled label "...an exceptional bottle of wine...copious fruit, lively personality, bright flavors, and prolonged, seamless finish...98." WA 11/ bottles per lot HK$32,000-50,000 US$ Gevrey-Chambertin Les Combottes Domaine Leroy 1999 Côte de Nuits, Premier Cru one lightly torn label "...an awesome, oily-textured mouthfeel, and a powerfully flavored and structured character...92." WA 8/ bottles per lot HK$22,000-32,000 US$ Grands Echézeaux Maison Leroy 1959 one 2cm, one 2.5cm, one lightly scuffed label, one winestained label "Rich, dazzlingly complex nose that is, remarkably enough, still youthful and leads to big, rich, ripe, deep, expansive flavors that still display a bit of tannin on the exquisitely long finish. This is a wonderful, fully mature, velvety wine...93." BH 7/ bottles per lot HK$20,000-28,000 US$ Grands Echézeaux Maison Leroy cm, bin-soiled label bottle per lot HK$12,000-19,000 US$ Grands Echézeaux Maison Leroy 1964 one 2.5cm, two 3.5cm "...wonderfully spicy, sweet and rich with still vibrant and punchy robust and powerful full-bodied flavors that offer both excellent complexity and a velvety finish that goes on and on..." BH 4/ bottles per lot HK$24,000-36,000 US$ Latricières-Chambertin Domaine Leroy 1993 lightly bin-soiled labels, signs of old seepage bottles per lot HK$20,000-28,000 US$ Latricières-Chambertin Domaine Leroy 1996 lightly bin-soiled labels, one lightly nicked label "It is immensely powerful as well as concentrated, and has its vintage's trademark freshness and grip WA 10/ bottles per lot HK$55,000-80,000 US$ ,000 Latricières-Chambertin Domaine Leroy 1997 one lightly scuffed label, different importers, one with signs of old seepage It has superb depth, power, and complexity, yet is presently tightly wound and firm. WA 10/ bottles per lot HK$11,000-19,000 US$ Latricières-Chambertin Domaine Leroy 1998 one lightly nicked label "Medium-to-full-bodied and ample, it is velvety-textured, muscular, and has an impressively long finish. This powerful wine is firmly structured...95." WA 10/ bottles per lot HK$16,000-24,000 US$ Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com 45

46 Latricières-Chambertin Domaine Leroy 1999 two lightly damp-stained labels, one lightly nicked label, one lightly scuffed label, one water-stained label, two different importers "...the finesse and elegance of the overall package is class personified. This is a thoroughbred race hose with its sleek, muscular flavor profile, superbly complex fruit and incredible length " BH 1/ bottles per lot HK$50,000-75,000 US$ Latricières-Chambertin Domaine Leroy 2009 two lightly bin-soiled labels, one lightly nicked label, signs of old seepage "...concentrated and beautifully well-delineated flavors possess excellent mid-palate concentration as well as outstanding intensity before terminating in a wonderfully persistent finish...95." BH 1/ bottles per lot HK$26,000-42,000 US$ Mazis-Chambertin Maison Leroy cm or better, lightly bin-soiled labels "Huge complex nose...should be capable of holding for another decade, or perhaps even longer as it is still fresh. Really lovely juice...92." BH 7/ bottles per lot HK$19,000-28,000 US$ Musigny Domaine Leroy cm, lightly bin-soiled and nicked label, chipped wax capsule partially reveals cork, signs of old seepage bottle per lot HK$28,000-42,000 US$ Musigny Domaine Leroy cm or better, lightly bin-soiled labels, one lightly glue-stained label, one lightly marked label, one lightly nicked label, one nicked label, one torn label, one wine-stained vintage tag, two with signs of old seepage "...frightfully concentrated, amazingly well-delineated wine that while full-bodied, never tastes heavy or tiring...98." WA 8/ bottles per lot HK$130, ,000 US$17,000-24,000 Musigny Domaine Leroy 1996 three damp-stained labels, five lightly bin-soiled labels, two lightly scuffed labels, one marked label, three slightly protruded corks, one cut capsule reveals fully branded cork, two different importers "The dark-colored 1996 Musigny displays super aromas of flowers, berries, and mint. It has huge breadth of fresh, succulent, and lush blueberries, raspberries, violets, and cherries...96." WA 10/ bottles per lot HK$220, ,000 US$28,000-42,000 Mazis-Chambertin Hospices de Beaune Cuvée Collignon Maison Leroy 1985 two 2cm or better, one 3cm, one with signs of old seepage bottles per lot HK$34,000-50,000 US$ Musigny Domaine Leroy 1997 lightly wine-stained labels, different importers "...full-bodied, opulent, and ample...well-structured and thickly-textured...95." WA 10/ bottles per lot HK$50,000-75,000 US$ Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com

47 Musigny Domaine Leroy 1998 one with sticker adhered to label, one lightly scuffed label, one lightly wine-stained label, one scuffed label, two different importers "...gorgeous aromas...it has extraordinary quantities of fruit...96." WA 10/ bottles per lot HK$160, ,000 US$20,000-32,000 Musigny Domaine Leroy 2001 one lightly nicked label, two scuffed labels, three with signs of old seepage "Stunningly elegant and pure...massive, powerful, stupendously intense flavors...emotionally thrilling juice and transcendent in every respect and the length is almost not believable...97." BH 1/ bottles per lot HK$120, ,000 US$16,000-24,000 Musigny Domaine Leroy 2002 lightly bin-soiled labels bottles per lot HK$70, ,000 US$ ,000 Nuits St Georges Les Boudots Domaine Leroy 1993 Côte de Nuits, Premier Cru lightly bin-soiled labels, one lightly marked label, one winestained vintage tag, two different importers, one with signs of old seepage bottles per lot HK$22,000-32,000 US$ Nuits St Georges Les Boudots Domaine Leroy 1999 Côte de Nuits, Premier Cru one lightly marked label "...a profound, highly concentrated, intense, elegant wine... awesomely fruit-dominated, harmonious offering. It is admirably long...reveals an outstanding structure...94." WA 8/ bottles per lot HK$26,000-42,000 US$ Nuits St Georges Les Boudots Domaine Leroy 1996 (1) lightly scuffed label 2002 (2) one lightly nicked label, one lightly scuffed label, one with signs of old seepage 250 above 3 bottles per lot HK$15,000-22,000 US$ Nuits St Georges Vignerondes Domaine Leroy 1999 Côte de Nuits, Premier Cru one lightly marked label, one lightly scuffed label "Wonderfully elegant fruit with extremely fine, minerally flavors yet they are quite dense and concentrated. The sève here is simply incredible " BH 1/ bottles per lot HK$12,000-19,000 US$ Richebourg Domaine Leroy 1990 two 2cm or better, one 4cm, one lightly bin-soiled label, two lightly wine-stained labels, two wine-stained vintage tags, two wax capsules, signs of old seepage, two different importers "Sumptuous and majestic...the length here is stunning as it lingers and lingers on the palate and the wine has the size of a classic Hermitage with its huge buried tannin...93." BH 1/ bottles per lot HK$55,000-80,000 US$ ,000 Richebourg Domaine Leroy cm or better, lightly bin-soiled labels, two different importers, two with signs of old seepage "...fine and intense black fruit with sexy, huge, powerful flavors and simply stupendous length...never loses its remarkable sense of balance and finesse...93." BH 10/ bottles per lot HK$80, ,000 US$10,000-16,000 Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com 47

48 Richebourg Domaine Leroy 1996 Lot 254: three lightly bin-soiled labels, three lightly marked labels, three lightly scuffed labels, one lightly torn label, one lightly wine-stained label, one scuffed label, one torn label, one slightly protruded cork, four different importers, two with signs of old seepage Lot 255: two lightly bin-soiled labels, three lightly marked labels, one lightly nicked label, one torn label, two different importers Lot 256: eight lightly scuffed labels, one scuffed label, one corroded capsule, three different importers, three with signs of old seepage "...sweet, sappy and extremely intense flavors that are much finer and more elegant than is typical for a Leroy Richebourg. This just oozes refinement and class...95." BH 10/ bottles per lot HK$220, ,000 US$28,000-42, bottles per lot HK$220, ,000 US$28,000-42, bottles per lot HK$220, ,000 US$28,000-42,000 Richebourg Domaine Leroy 1999 "...broad-shouldered, powerful, concentrated personality... Velvety-textured and dense...95." WA 8/ bottles per lot HK$140, ,000 US$18,000-26,000 Richebourg Domaine Leroy 2000 Lot 258: one lightly torn label, one scuffed label, one torn label, two different importers, three with signs of old seepage Lot 259: lightly bin-soiled and scuffed label "A dense, bold, medium to full-bodied wine, it slathers the palate...copious ripe and soft tannins are superb...94." WA 6/ bottle per lot HK$13,000-19,000 US$ bottles per lot HK$110, ,000 US$14,000-20,000 Romanée-St-Vivant Domaine Leroy cm, lightly bin-soiled label bottle per lot HK$12,000-19,000 US$ Romanée-St-Vivant Domaine Leroy 1993 one damp-stained label, one marked label, one scuffed label "...explosive...wonderfully precise and superbly long...an exceptionally impressive wine still on the way up that exudes nothing but sheer class...94." BH 1/ bottles per lot HK$28,000-42,000 US$ Romanée-St-Vivant Domaine Leroy 1996 Lot 264: two lightly scuffed labels, two lightly wine-stained labels, one wine-stained label, two different importers, four with signs of old seepage Lot 265: original wood case Lot 266: one lightly scuffed label, seven wine-stained labels, three different importers "...massively powerful, refined character...complex flavor profile...97." WA 10/ bottles per lot HK$65,000-95,000 US$ , bottles per lot HK$150, ,000 US$19,000-28, bottles per lot HK$150, ,000 US$19,000-28,000 Romanée-St-Vivant Domaine Leroy 1997 lightly marked labels "Dark plums, spices, mocha, and dried prunes burst from the glass. This medium-to-full-bodied liquid velvet is packed with chewy red and black fruits...95." WA 10/ bottles per lot HK$22,000-32,000 US$ Richebourg Domaine Leroy 2002 one lightly bin-soiled label, one scuffed label "...powerful, even robust, muscular and intense flavors are thick and oozing with extract of pinot that completely buffers the considerable tannins on the beautifully long finish...96." BH 1/ bottles per lot HK$32,000-50,000 US$ Richebourg Domaine Leroy 2009 one lightly bin-soiled label, one lightly damp-stained label, three lightly scuffed labels, two with signs of old seepage "A very ripe nose...usual excellent richness and intensity to the mineral-inflected broad-shouldered flavors that possess excellent concentration and length...95." BH 1/ bottles per lot HK$100, ,000 US$13,000-19,000 Romanée-St-Vivant Domaine Leroy 1999 original wood case one lightly bin-soiled label, one lightly damp-stained label, two lightly scuffed labels, two wine-stained labels "...ultra distinguished and refined...pure, classy and elegant with an incredible range...simply haunting in its beauty. In a word, gorgeous " BH 1/ bottles per lot HK$170, ,000 US$22,000-34,000 Romanée-St-Vivant Domaine Leroy 2002 lightly scuffed label "Enormously complex, highly aromatic yet reserved...fantastically pure, delineated and silky flavors possessing a certain focused and controlled power...97." BH 1/ bottle per lot HK$14,000-20,000 US$ Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com

49 Lots Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com 49

50 Romanée-St-Vivant Domaine Leroy 2009 one lightly bin-soiled label, one lightly scuffed label, one nicked label, one lightly corroded capsule, signs of old seepage "...polished flavors seem crafted from nothing other than gossamer-like pure silk that dances across the palate before terminating in a sophisticated and perfectly balanced finish... destined for greatness...98." BH 1/ bottles per lot HK$46,000-70,000 US$ Maison Leroy Santenay 1962 (2) one 4cm, one 4.5cm, bin-soiled labels Beaune Hospices de Beaune Cuvée Rosseau Deslandes 1969 (1) 2cm, stained and lightly bin-soiled label, signs of old seepage Savigny Les Beaune Les Serpentieres 1978 (1) 2cm, bin-soiled and lightly nicked label 277 above 4 bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Ruchottes-Chambertin Maison Leroy cm, bin-soiled and scuffed label, lightly corroded capsule, signs of old seepage bottle per lot HK$ US$ Vosne-Romanée Les Beaux Monts Domaine Leroy 1993 Côte de Nuits, Premier Cru three lightly bin-soiled labels, one lightly marked label, one lightly scuffed label "An absolutely knockout black fruit nose of superb complexity introduces big, rich, elegant and very powerful flavors of superb length...93." BH 10/ bottles per lot HK$38,000-55,000 US$ Domaine Leroy Vosne-Romanée Les Genaivrières 1990 (1) 3cm, lightly wine-stained label, signs of old seepage Volnay Santenots 1993 (1) lightly bin-soiled label, signs of old seepage 278 above 2 bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Vosne-Romanée Les Brûlées Domaine Leroy 1993 (2) bin-soiled labels 2002 (1) lightly scuffed label 279 above 3 bottles per lot HK$22,000-32,000 US$ Vosne-Romanée Les Beaux Monts Domaine Leroy 1996 Côte de Nuits, Premier Cru one lightly bin-soiled label, two lightly scuffed labels, two different importers "Profound aromas...full-bodied, extremely feminine, and massively ripe and vibrant core...96." WA 8/ bottles per lot HK$24,000-36,000 US$ Vosne-Romanée Les Beaux Monts Domaine Leroy 2002 Côte de Nuits, Premier Cru one lightly nicked label, three lightly scuffed labels, four with signs of old seepage "...stunningly beautiful, chiseled and equally muscular flavors but with even more size and weight yet for all the volume, the balance is perfect...94." BH 1/ bottles per lot HK$30,000-46,000 US$ Vosne-Romanée Les Brûlées Domaine Leroy 1996 Côte de Nuits, Premier Cru two lightly bin-soiled labels, two wine-stained labels bottles per lot HK$24,000-36,000 US$ La Romanée Liger-Belair 2002 lightly damp-stained label "...a breathtakingly fine wine that exhibits exquisite balance and an almost spiritual calm...96." BH 1/ bottle per lot HK$17,000-26,000 US$ La Romanée Liger-Belair 2003 one lightly bin-soiled label "...a seductive but discreet nose that is followed by equally tight, pure and understated flavors of superb precision and stunning complexity...94." BH 1/ bottles per lot HK$28,000-42,000 US$ Clos de la Roche Hubert Lignier 1999 one lightly nicked label, two wine-stained labels, three different importers "Ample yet highly delineated, it has a magnificently long, fruitfilled finish " WA 8/ bottles per lot HK$17,000-26,000 US$ Vosne-Romanée Les Brûlées Domaine Leroy 1999 Côte de Nuits, Premier Cru two different labels, three lightly scuffed labels, three different importers bottles per lot HK$46,000-70,000 US$ Hubert Lignier Charmes-Chambertin 1993 (1) Clos de la Roche 1996 (3) Clos de la Roche 1998 (1) wine-stained label 283 above 5 bottles per lot HK$11,000-16,000 US$ Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com

51 Lot 281 Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com 51

52 Méo-Camuzet Jean-Nicolas Méo of Domaine Méo-Camuzet has just celebrated his twentieth anniversary as a full-time vigneron, having first made wine at the family estate in the 1989 vintage. In many ways his two decades at the head of the domaine have dovetailed neatly with the renaissance that has swept through Burgundy in the same period of time, and it is rather extraordinary to see (particularly in a region so steeped in history) Domaine Méo-Camuzet rise to the very pinnacle of estates in Vosne-Romanée in just two short decades. This meteoric rise is directly reflective of Jean-Nicolas Méo s great talent and passion for the wines of Burgundy, coupled to the superb vineyard holdings that were secured by previous generations of the Méo and Camuzet families and the sagacity of the family to early on hire Henri Jayer to manage many of their vineyards and oversee much of their winemaking prior to Jean-Nicolas taking over the reins of the domaine. John Gilman, View From the Cellar Domaine Méo-Camuzet 的主人 Jean-Nicolas Méo 剛剛踏入成為全職酒農的第二十個年頭, 他早於 1989 年的家族莊園中釀造出屬於自家的葡萄酒 在這二十年當中, 他作為酒莊的主人, 從各方面帶領著自家酒莊走向成功之路, 帶來新氣象, 同一時間這亦是布根地的復興時代 ; Domaine Méo-Camuzet 在短短二十年間成為了 Vosne-Romanée 區域的頂級莊園, 這實屬罕聞, 萬中無一的例子 ( 尤其於一歷史悠久 充滿故事的土地上 ) 這顆明星的誕生正正揭示出 Jean-Nicolas Méo 非凡的天賦才華及對布根地葡萄酒的醉心與熱情 以及 Méo 及 Camuzet 家族世世代代對葡萄園的完美經營 ; 加上家族的睿智, 早於傳承至 Jean-Nicolas 以前, 聘請得殿堂級釀酒大師 Henri Jayer 管理各葡萄田及監督整個釀酒過程, 這種種因素, 娓娓道出了 Domaine Méo-Camuzet 的成功之道 John Gilman, View From the Cellar Nuits St Georges Aux Boudots Méo-Camuzet 1985 Côte de Nuits, Premier Cru 2cm or better, two lightly marked labels, lightly nicked labels, one wine-stained label bottles per lot HK$10,000-15,000 US$ Richebourg Méo-Camuzet 1985 one 1.5cm, one 2cm, one damp-stained label, one heavily deteriorated label, one lightly torn label, one scuffed label, one loose capsule reveals producer branded cork "...highly aromatic nose...fully resolved and utterly delicious medium-bodied flavors that are sweet, sappy and completely seductive on the gorgeously long finish...93." BH 7/ bottles per lot HK$50,000-75,000 US$ Vosne-Romanée Les Brûlées Méo-Camuzet 1985 Côte de Nuits, Premier Cru 1.5cm or better, one lightly marked label, one lightly nicked label "The flavors are rich, full, sweet and velvety...long and mouth coating finish. This is a really impressive effort...92." BH 5/ bottles per lot HK$10,000-15,000 US$ Richebourg Méo-Camuzet cm or better, one lightly damp-stained label, three lightly scuffed labels, two cut capsules reveal fully branded corks, two different importers, two with signs of old seepage "Flirts with a perfect 100 score...supple, ultrarich, ripe, smooth, creamy texture that you expect top-flight red Burgundies to deliver...99." WS 5/ bottles per lot HK$70, ,000 US$ ,000 Richebourg Méo-Camuzet 1993 marked and lightly scuffed label, cut capsule reveals fully branded cork "Near-perfect Pinot Noir...Elegant, racy and aristocratic, it has terroir etched in. Full-bodied, long and marvelously classy...99." WS 5/ bottle per lot HK$10,000-15,000 US$ Vosne-Romanée Aux Brûlées Méo-Camuzet 1993 Côte de Nuits, Premier Cru three with Riedel stamps, one lightly marked label, one lightly nicked label, one lightly scuffed label, one marked label, one nicked label, two scuffed labels, three different importers "...rich, delicious and velvety medium-bodied flavors that possess outstanding depth and length...93." BH 5/ bottles per lot HK$24,000-36,000 US$ Vosne-Romanée Cros Parantoux Méo-Camuzet 1993 Côte de Nuits, Premier Cru 1cm, scuffed label "This simply reeks class and is extremely impressive with layer after detailed layer...96." BH 1/ bottle per lot HK$11,000-16,000 US$ Richebourg Méo-Camuzet 1996 one missing vintage tag, scuffed labels, two wine-stained labels, one loose capsule reveals fully branded cork "...especially intense and lasts for minutes and though this is well structured, everything is in perfect balance. Power without weight in a refined, elegant style...93." BH 5/ bottles per lot HK$24,000-36,000 US$ Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com

53 Vosne-Romanée Aux Brûlées Méo-Camuzet 1996 Côte de Nuits, Premier Cru one lightly scuffed label, one lightly torn label, two scuffed labels bottles per lot HK$10,000-15,000 US$ Vosne-Romanée Cros Parantoux Méo-Camuzet 1996 Côte de Nuits, Premier Cru one heavily bin-soiled label, one missing vintage tag, scuffed labels, loose capsules reveals fully branded corks bottles per lot HK$28,000-42,000 US$ Echézeaux Les Rouges du Bas Méo-Camuzet bottles per lot HK$10,000-15,000 US$ Richebourg Méo-Camuzet 1999 three lightly scuffed labels, two different importers "Explosive black, sexy, powerful and dense...sweetness and perfect balance. This is a real show stopper...94." BH 7/ bottles per lot HK$100, ,000 US$13,000-19,000 Vosne-Romanée Aux Brûlées Méo-Camuzet 1999 Côte de Nuits, Premier Cru two different importers "Despite the imposing size, weight and power, this is a '99 that could be drunk now with pleasure...a great vintage for this wine...95." BH 6/ bottles per lot HK$46,000-65,000 US$ Vosne-Romanée Cros Parantoux Méo-Camuzet 1999 Côte de Nuits, Premier Cru one lightly bin-soiled label, three different importers "Massively proportioned and oozing Grand Cru power and finesse...unbelievably seductive...complexity and length keep coming in wave after wave " BH 1/ bottles per lot HK$70, ,000 US$ ,000 Richebourg Méo-Camuzet 2002 "Brooding, backward and tight but with more aromatic intensity...big, muscular and very powerful flavors and a huge amount of extract...95." BH 1/ bottles per lot HK$30,000-46,000 US$ Vosne-Romanée Cros Parantoux Méo-Camuzet 2002 Côte de Nuits, Premier Cru "Structured yet beautifully balanced with wonderfully depth... The minerality is almost pungent, especially so on the stunningly long backend " BH 1/ bottles per lot HK$28,000-42,000 US$ Méo-Camuzet Nuits St Georges Aux Murgers 1990 (1) 2cm, lightly torn and wine-stained label, missing vintage tag, cut capsule reveals fully branded cork Vosne-Romanée Aux Brûlées 1990 (1) 3cm, scuffed label, missing capsule reveals fully branded protruded cork Clos de Vougeot 1996 (1) scuffed label Corton Clos Rognet 1996 (2) one lightly nicked label, scuffed labels Nuits St Georges Aux Murgers 1996 (4) two lightly scuffed labels, one nicked label, two scuffed labels, one with signs of old seepage 300 above 9 bottles per lot HK$17,000-26,000 US$ Musigny Moine-Hudelot 1990 seven 2cm or better, one 3cm, one 3.5cm, one 4.5cm, two lightly bin-soiled labels bottles per lot HK$15,000-22,000 US$ Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com 53

54 Mommessin Clos de Tart Mommessin 1985 one 2.5cm, two 3cm, lightly scuffed labels, one loose capsule reveals fully branded cork, one depressed cork, two different releases "Remarkably elegant and spicy with rich, full, delicious and very complex, mouth coating flavors of superb depth and length...93." BH 10/ bottles per lot HK$12,000-19,000 US$ Clos de Tart Mommessin 1999 four different importers "...medium-bodied, sweet, harmonious and long flavors all underpinned by racy minerality. The tannins are firm and the density of extract impressive and the length incredible...92." BH 1/ bottles per lot HK$26,000-42,000 US$ Clos de Tart Mommessin 2002 "Super concentrated, silky and sweet in the mouth but with superb definition and energy...95." IWC 3/ bottles per lot HK$22,000-32,000 US$ Clos de Tart Mommessin 2005 Lot 305: one lightly nicked label, two lightly scuffed labels, one 6-pack original wood case, one 6-pack original wood case with damaged lid "...a magnificent bouquet of haunting intensity and purity... amazing focus. The palate is simply to die for...astonishingly fine-très Grand Cru, très délicieux...97." WA 10/ bottles per lot HK$30,000-46,000 US$ magnums (1.5L) per lot HK$15,000-22,000 US$ Chambertin Charles Mortet cm or better, lightly bin-soiled labels bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Chambertin Denis Mortet 1996 three lightly bin-soiled labels, two different importers, two with signs of old seepage "To be sure, this is certainly a wine of quality, delicious yet serious with a hint of ash on the long finish..." BH 1/ bottles per lot HK$16,000-24,000 US$ Chambertin Denis Mortet 2005 two wine-stained labels "...rich, full and powerful flavors...textured and velvety mouth feel to the superbly long, sweet and remarkably precise finish " BH 1/ bottles per lot HK$17,000-26,000 US$ Chambertin Denis Mortet 1993 (1) wine-stained vintage tag 2000 (1) wine-stained label 311 above 2 bottles per lot HK$ US$ Richebourg Denis Mugneret 1996 (1) bin-soiled and scuffed label 1999 (9) one lightly torn label, three nicked labels, one wine-stained label 312 above 10 bottles per lot HK$19,000-28,000 US$ Clos de Tart Mommessin 1996 (2) one damp-stained label, one lightly damp-stained label, one lightly scuffed label, different importers 1999 (2) 307 above 4 bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com

55 Lots 308 & 309 Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com 55

56 Lot Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com

57 JF Mugnier Musigny JF Mugnier 1993 wine-stained label, torn capsule reveals fully branded cork, signs of old seepage "...still relatively tight with flavors that are so precise that they seem to etch themselves into your palate before joining with a seamless finish that seems to go on and on...97." BH 11/ bottle per lot HK$10,000-15,000 US$ Musigny JF Mugnier 1999 one loose capsule reveals fully branded cork "Powerful yet subtle with wonderfully pure...finish that lasts for minutes and exudes energy and vibrancy...94." BH 7/ bottles per lot HK$55,000-80,000 US$ ,000 Musigny JF Mugnier 2001 "Ruby-tinged red color...very rich and supple but backward... Slow-building finish features superb sweetness and classy tannins...94." IWC 3/ bottles per lot HK$26,000-42,000 US$ Musigny JF Mugnier 2005 one 6-pack original wood case "An incredibly complex and kaleidoscopic nose features a dazzling array of aromas...sweet, pure and ultra refined fullbodied flavors that are harmonious and deep...99." BH 1/ bottles per lot HK$190, ,000 US$24,000-36,000 Nuits St Georges Clos de Marechale JF Mugnier 2005 Côte de Nuits, Premier Cru wine-stained labels magnums (1.5L) per lot HK$ US$ Chambertin Vieilles Vignes Christophe Perrot-Minot 1999 (3) 2002 (6) 318 above 9 bottles per lot HK$13,000-19,000 US$ Mazoyères-Chambertin Vieilles Vignes Perrot-Minot 2005 "...rich, concentrated and intense full-bodied and well muscled flavors...ample sap rounds off the very firm finish at present...93." BH 1/ bottles per lot HK$16,000-24,000 US$ Mazoyères-Chambertin Perrot-Minot 1997 (2) one lightly scuffed label Vieilles Vignes 2002 (10) one lightly wine-stained label, two different importers 320 above 12 bottles per lot HK$14,000-20,000 US$ NO LOT Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com 57

58 Ponsot Potel Chapelle-Chambertin Domaine Ponsot 2005 (4) one scuffed label 2005 magnums (2) one nicked label 322 above 4 bottles & 2 magnums (1.5L) per lot HK$13,000-19,000 US$ Clos de la Roche Domaine Ponsot 2005 original wood case "...it would be presumptuous to anoint this as the best ever but if it isn't, it will certainly take its rightful place among the very greatest. In sum, a 'wow' wine that makes you shake your head in sheer amazement...99." BH 1/ bottles per lot HK$60,000-95,000 US$ ,000 Griotte-Chambertin Domaine Ponsot 2005 "...classy, seductive and opulently textured flavors that are borderline thick as there is so much dry extract and sap on the sweet and palate staining finish...94." BH 1/ bottles per lot HK$ US$ Vosne-Romanée Les Gaudichots Nicolas Potel 2002 Côte de Nuits, Premier Cru original wood case bottles per lot HK$20,000-30,000 US$ Chambertin Nicolas Potel 2005 one lightly damp-stained label "...liqueur-like fruit intensity in the mouth never lose sight of the rose petals, nor cover up the chalk, wet stone and roasted meat that underlie a sumptuous, sultry finish " WA 6/ bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Romanée-St-Vivant Nicolas Potel bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Vosne-Romanée Les Gaudichots Nicolas Potel 2005 Côte de Nuits, Premier Cru bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Volnay Santenots Nicolas Potel 1964 (2) one 2cm, one 2.5cm, lightly bin-soiled labels 1966 (2) one 3cm, one 4cm, lightly bin-soiled labels 1969 (6) one 2cm, one 2.5cm, three 3cm, one 4.5cm, two with signs of old seepage 1971 (1) 4cm 329 above 11 bottles per lot HK$11,000-16,000 US$ Pommard Les Pezerolles Nicolas Potel 1969 (3) 3cm 1971 (2) 3.5cm, one damp-stained label, one lightly bin-soiled label 1978 (3) one 2cm, two 2.5cm above 8 bottles per lot HK$11,000-16,000 US$ Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com

59 Volnay Santenots Potinet-Ampeau 1959 Côte de Beaune, Premier Cru 1.5cm or better, one damp-stained label, one heavily torn label, four torn labels, six wine-stained labels bottles per lot HK$11,000-16,000 US$ Potinet-Ampeau Volnay Santenots 1966 (1) 3.5cm Pommard Pezerolles 1969 (3) two 3cm, one 4cm, two lightly bin-soiled labels Volnay Santenots 1969 (3) two 3cm, one 4cm, two lightly bin-soiled labels Pommard Pezerolles 1971 (3) one 2.5cm, two 3cm Volnay Santenots 1971 (3) one 3cm, two 3.5cm, two lightly bin-soiled labels 331 above 13 bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Volnay Clos de la Bousse d Or Pousse d Or 1969 Côte de Beaune, Premier Cru 2cm or better, one damp-stained label, one lightly torn label, one slightly protruded cork, one protruded cork, one with signs of old seepage bottles per lot HK$10,000-15,000 US$ Volnay Clos des 60 Ouvrées Pousse d Or 1971 Côte de Beaune, Premier Cru one 3cm, one 4cm, one 4.5cm, one bin-soiled label, one lightly damp-stained label, two corroded capsules, one lightly corroded capsule, one fully branded cork, two with signs of old seepage bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Pousse d'or Santenay Les Gravières 1969 (1) 3.5cm, tape adhered to label, corroded capsule partially reveals cork Volnay Clos de 60 Ouvrées 1969 (1) 4cm, lightly damp-stained label, lightly corroded capsule, signs of old seepage Volnay Clos L'Audignac 1969 (3) 2cm or better Santenay Les Gravières 1971 (3) one 2cm, one 3cm, one 4cm, damp-stained labels, two torn capsules partially reveals corks, two depressed corks Volnay Clos de la Bousse 1978 (2) one 2cm, one 2.5cm, wine-stained labels, one with signs of old seepage Volnay Clos L'Audignac 1978 (1) 4cm, bin-soiled label, lightly corroded capsule, signs of old seepage 334 above 11 bottles per lot HK$17,000-26,000 US$ Prieuré-Roch Clos Vougeot 1996 (5) four scuffed labels Chambertin Clos de Bèze 2001 (1) 335 above 6 bottles per lot HK$12,000-19,000 US$ NO LOT 337 NO LOT Chambertin Charles Vienot bottles per lot HK$ US$ Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com 59

60 Comte Georges de Vogüé Delicate, feminine and fragrant, the epitome of finesse: lace, silk and taffeta; violets and dog-roses; raspberries and blackcurrants with a finish of liquorice; amplitude and generosity; intensity without a trace of hardness. All this has been said by those attempting to describe the taste of Le Musigny. Le Musigny consists of two sub-climats, Le Musigny itself and at the same altitude next door to the south, Les Petits-Musigny. The lion s share, more than seven hectares, almost seventy percent, and including the totality of Les Petites-Musigny, belongs to the Domaine Comte Georges de Vogüé. This estate proclaims itself the Domaine des Musigny. The domaine also comprise 2.75 hectares of Bonnes-Mares, located entirely in the southern, Chambolle end of the climat, sixty ares of Amoureuses, 1.80 hectares of premiers crus (Baudes and Fuées) and a small parcel of village wine. Wines of the domaine are defined as classy and fragrant, very exciting indeed. The domaine is in good hands. The future is bright. Clive Coates, MW, Côte d Or 細緻 嬌柔及芳香, 是技巧的集中體現 : 嬌柔如花邊 絲及平紋皺絲織品, 芳香如紫羅蘭和犬薔薇, 有甘草根熬製的野草莓及黑加倫子果味, 豐富而寬廣, 強而不硬 品嚐過 Le Musigny 的人士, 都會嚐試用以上說話形容它的味道 Le Musigny 這個地方包含兩種次氣候帶, 一是 Le Musigny 本身的氣候帶, 另一是南面毗鄰位於同一海拔的 Les Petits-Musigny Comte Georges de Vogüé 酒莊面積非常大, 超過 7 公頃 ( 約七成面積 ), 包括整遍 Les Petites-Musigny 在 Le Musigny 內, 因此酒莊自稱是 Domaine des Musigny 酒莊範圍還包括南部 2.75 公頃 Bonnes-Mares 土地及 1.8 公頃 Chambolle 土地 (Baudes 及 Fuees) 葡萄園出產的葡萄酒優質而且芳香, 也很刺激 葡萄園有蓍妥善的管理, 前途一片光明 Clive Coates, MW, Côte d Or Musigny Vieilles Vignes Comte Georges de Vogüé cm, bin-soiled and scuffed label, fully cut capsule reveals fully branded cork, signs of old seepage "Attractive colour; distinctly floral bouquet, slightly singed, developing an almost Cabernet Franc raspberry scent; dry, most delightful flavour and great length...hhhh." MB 3/ bottle per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Musigny Vieilles Vignes Comte Georges de Vogüé cm, bin-soiled, scuffed, wine-stained and lightly torn label magnum (1.5L) per lot HK$ US$ Musigny Vieilles Vignes Comte Georges de Vogüé 1993 wine-stained and lightly bin-soiled label "...massively structured and thick flavors with dense, ripe tannins that are completely buffered by all the extract. This is flat out great...97." BH 11/ bottle per lot HK$ US$ Musigny Vieilles Vignes Comte Georges de Vogüé 1996 one damp-stained label, one lightly damp-stained label, different importers "...this is a very powerful wine with incredible length and perfect balance...94." BH 3/ bottles per lot HK$ US$ Musigny Vieilles Vignes Comte Georges de Vogüé 1998 one torn label partially obscures vintage, three lightly dampstained labels, one Danish importer bottles per lot HK$16,000-24,000 US$ Bonnes-Mares Comte Georges de Vogüé 1999 five damp-stained labels, one lightly wine-stained label, three different importers "Massive notes of blueberry and blackberry jam yet there is a certain austerity to the nose followed by flavors that are huge, firm, reserved and extremely dense...the length is just flat out stunning and very powerful...93." BH 1/ bottles per lot HK$14,000-20,000 US$ Musigny Vieilles Vignes Comte Georges de Vogüé 1999 two lightly bin-soiled labels, three lightly damp-stained labels, one lightly torn label, four different importers "...reveals wonderfully complex aromas...huge but fine, powerful but subtle and rich yet detailed with a stupendously long finish...this is genuinely stunning juice...96." BH 11/ bottles per lot HK$50,000-75,000 US$ Musigny Vieilles Vignes Comte Georges de Vogüé 2001 damp-stained labels "Opulent and lavish yet all remains exquisitely balanced and this is astonishingly precise. A real stunner of a wine...96." BH 10/ bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Musigny Vieilles Vignes Comte Georges de Vogüé 2002 one lightly tissue-stained label "...very serious, exuberantly fresh and impressively deep flavors...incredible combination of mind boggling complexity coupled with perfect balance...96." BH 1/ bottles per lot HK$24,000-36,000 US$ Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com

61 Bonnes-Mares Comte Georges de Vogüé 2005 "...all wrapped in a dazzling long finish that is perfectly balanced...95." BH 1/ bottles per lot HK$34,000-50,000 US$ Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com 61

62 Musigny Vieilles Vignes Comte Georges de Vogüé 2005 Lot 349: includes 12-pack original wood case "Prepare to be transported...a remarkable sense of energy and power on the almost unbelievably intense, focused and structured finish that seems to go on and on without end...99." BH 1/ bottles per lot HK$38,000-55,000 US$ bottles per lot HK$80, ,000 US$10,000-14,000 Musigny Vieilles Vignes Comte Georges de Vogüé 2009 original wood case four lightly tissue-stained labels, one damp-stained label, six lightly damp-stained labels "I could still taste this several hours later and if given sufficient cellar time, this should be one of the great vintages for this storied wine " BH 1/ bottles per lot HK$50,000-70,000 US$ Musigny Vieilles Vignes Comte Georges de Vogüé 2010 "...incredibly long and silky...this is another stunningly beautiful wine from de Vogüé " WA 2/ bottles per lot HK$22,000-32,000 US$ Musigny Vougeraie 2001 one scuffed label bottles per lot HK$30,000-46,000 US$ Vougeraie Musigny 1999 (1) Bonnes-Mares 2005 (6) 355 above 7 bottles per lot HK$11,000-16,000 US$ Mixed Burgundy Pommard Epenots Louis Latour 1959 (1) 4cm, damp-stained label, signs of old seepage Chambertin Camille Giroud 1971 (1) 2.5cm, lightly bin-soiled label Richebourg Remoissenet 1978 (1) 1.5cm, lightly bin-soiled and torn label 356 above 3 bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Mixed Burgundy Beaune Clos des Mouches Rouge F Gaunoux 1971 (1) 2cm, bin-soiled label Corton Clos du Roi Prince de Merode 1971 (2) one 3cm, one 3.5cm, lightly bin-soiled labels, one winestained label Chambertin Trapet 1978 (1) 4.5cm, glue-stained and lightly bin-soiled label Gevrey-Chambertin Armand Rousseau 1978 (1) 4cm, lightly bin-soiled and torn label, signs of old seepage Gevrey-Chambertin Petite Chapelle Cuvée Special Domaine les Perrières 1978 (1) 2cm, bin-soiled and torn label Pommard Lejeune 1978 (2) one 2.5cm, one 3cm, one torn label, one torn vintage tag Volnay Champans Marquis d'angerville 1978 (3) one 2cm, one 2.5cm, one 3cm 357 above 11 bottles per lot HK$13,000-19,000 US$ Musigny Vougeraie 2005 "A spicy, dusty and decidedly sweet nose that offers better aromatic complexity and a bit more depth dissolves into rich, full and intense flavors " BH 1/ bottles per lot HK$17,000-26,000 US$ Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com

63 Mixed Burgundy Clos Vougeot Jean Grivot 1980 (3) two 2cm or better, one 2.5cm, bin-soiled labels, one lightly torn label Echézeaux Chauvenet 1985 (2) one 2cm, one 2.5cm Chambertin Vieilles Vignes Louis Trapet 1989 (1) 3cm, lightly bin-soiled label Latricières-Chambertin Rossignol-Trapet 1990 (1) 1.5cm, bin-soiled label Latricières-Chambertin Domaine du Cœur 1998 (5) one lightly nicked label Clos de la Roche Nicolas Potel 1999 (2) Bonnes-Mares Nicolas Potel 2005 (1) lightly marked label Volnay Clos de la Bousse d Or Pousse d Or 2005 magnum (1) 358 above 15 bottles & 1 magnum (1.5L) per lot HK$13,000-19,000 US$ Mixed Burgundy Beaune Grèves Tollot-Beaut 1996 (1) bin-soiled and damp-stained label Chambertin Trapet 1996 (1) Clos Vougeot Denis Mugneret 1996 (1) bin-soiled and nicked label Clos Vougeot Musigni Gros Frère et Sœur 1996 (1) lightly damp-stained label Gevrey-Chambertin Clos St Jacques G Bartet 1996 (2) scuffed labels Gevrey-Chambertin Denis Mortet 1996 (1) damp-stained label Gevrey-Chambertin Les Champs Chenys Joseph Roty 1996 (2) lightly scuffed labels 360 above 9 bottles per lot HK$ US$ End of Day 1 Mixed Burgundy Clos de Vougeot Georges Mugneret 1985 (1) 2.5cm, lightly bin-soiled label Charmes-Chambertin Vieilles Vignes Denis Bachelet 1993 (1) bin-soiled label Ruchottes-Chambertin Christophe Roumier 1999 (1) bin-soiled label 359 above 3 bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com 63

64 64 Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com

65 DAY TWO November 18, 2017 Lots Lot 561 Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com 65

66 Lots Bordeaux & Bordeaux & sauternes sauternes Bordeaux Château Angélus 1995 St Emilion, Premier Grand Cru Classé (a) three different importers "Slightly reserved in the nose. Full-bodied, with loads of layered, velvety tannins. Big, yet refined and beautiful. Long and caressing...95." WS bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Château Angélus 2000 St Emilion, Premier Grand Cru Classé (a) Lot 363: two 6-pack original wood cases "Slightly reserved in the nose. Full-bodied, with loads of layered, velvety tannins. Big, yet refined and beautiful. Long and caressing...95." WS bottles per lot HK$14,000-20,000 US$ bottles per lot HK$32,000-50,000 US$ bottles per lot HK$32,000-50,000 US$ Château Bellevue 2000 St Emilion, Grand Cru Classé two 6-pack original wood cases bottles per lot HK$ US$ Château Le Bon Pasteur 2000 Pomerol original wood case Parcel: lots 366 & bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Château Certan de May 1998 Pomerol bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Château Clinet 1989 Pomerol bottom neck or better, bin-soiled labels, lightly corroded capsules, signs of old seepage "This spectacularly concentrated, full-bodied, multi-dimensional wine is the stuff of dreams " WA 12/ bottles per lot HK$10,000-15,000 US$ Château Clinet 1995 Pomerol one scuffed label bottles per lot HK$ US$ Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com

67 Lots Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com 67

68 Lots 371 & Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com

69 Château Clinet 2000 Pomerol original wood case Parcel: lots 371 & bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Château Clos L Eglise 1998 Pomerol bottles per lot HK$ US$ Château Clos L Eglise 2000 Pomerol two 6-pack original wood cases Lot 376: one lightly nicked label Parcel: lots 374 & bottles per lot HK$11,000-16,000 US$ bottles per lot HK$11,000-16,000 US$ bottles per lot HK$11,000-16,000 US$ Château Cos d Estournel 1982 St Estèphe, Deuxième Cru Classé ten bottom neck or better, two very top shoulder, lightly binsoiled labels, two lightly scuffed labels, three lightly torn labels, three different importers "The wine is medium to full-bodied with sweet tannins, a medium to full-bodied mouthfeel, and a silky finish...95." WA 6/ bottles per lot HK$20,000-28,000 US$ Château Cos d Estournel 2003 St Estèphe, Deuxième Cru Classé original wood case Lot 379: two lightly bin-soiled labels, one lightly nicked label, one lightly scuffed label "With extraordinary richness, full-bodied, and remarkable freshness, elegance, and persistence, this is one of the finest wines ever made by this estate...98." WA 4/ bottles per lot HK$14,000-20,000 US$ bottles per lot HK$14,000-20,000 US$ Château Cos d Estournel 2005 St Estèphe, Deuxième Cru Classé original wood case "Full and very layered with chewy polished tannins and a long, long finish. Just starting to open...99." JS 10/ bottles per lot HK$13,000-19,000 US$ Château Croix de Labrie 1998 St Emilion lightly bin-soiled labels bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Château Croix de Labrie 2000 St Emilion original wood case bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Château Ducru-Beaucaillou 1996 St Julien, Deuxième Cru Classé one lightly nicked label bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Château Ducru-Beaucaillou 2000 St Julien, Deuxième Cru Classé original wood case "...It's full body yet very finely textured with pretty fruit concentration and length...96." JS 6/ bottles per lot HK$15,000-22,000 US$ Château Ducru-Beaucaillou 1989 (2) bottom neck or better, lightly bin-soiled labels 1995 (6) 385 above 8 bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Château Gracia 2000 St Emilion, Grand Cru Classé original wood case bottles per lot HK$11,000-16,000 US$ Château Gruaud-Larose 2000 St Julien, Deuxième Cru Classé Lot 388: one lightly nicked label, two lightly scuffed labels, original wood case bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Château La Clusière 2000 St Emilion, Grand Cru Classé Lot 390: seven lightly scuffed labels, original wood case "Aromas of creme de cassis, blueberry liqueur, charcoal, licorice, and graphite are followed by a stunningly rich, fullbodied, elegant, pure, gentle giant of a wine " WA 6/ bottles per lot HK$26,000-42,000 US$ bottles per lot HK$50,000-75,000 US$ Château La Conseillante 2000 Pomerol original wood case "Full-bodied yet ethereal in the sense that it seems to combine power along with eloquence and delicacy, this is a beautifully pure wine that has just hit its plateau of full maturity...96." WA 6/ bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ bottles per lot HK$15,000-22,000 US$ Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com 69

70 Château Lafleur Originally part of the Le Gay estate, Lafleur is owned by the Robin family, also owners of Le Gay until Today Lafleur is managed by Jacques Guinaudeau, a cousin of the owners. The vineyard is just 200 meters from Pétrus and although gravelly in appearance, the soils do contain a fair amount of clay. The vines here are fairly old, having largely avoided the 1956 frost, and the yields are low, just twenty-six hl/ha. The grapes are total destemmed, and the wines spend roughly sixteen to twenty months in fifty percent new oak barriques. This is an extremely rich and heady wine, like liquid velvet, big and muscular when young, but mellowing wonderfully in time. Unfortunately for the many fans of Lafleur, production is a meager 1000 to 1200 cases a year. Lafleur 為 Robin 家族所擁有, 並原屬於 Le Gay 酒莊的一部份 ; 於 2002 年以前,Le Gay 亦為 Robin 家族所經營及擁有 時至今日,Lafleur 酒莊已經由酒莊擁有人的表兄弟 Jacques Guinaudeau 所主理 自家的葡萄園距離著名的 Pétrus 只有短短 200 米之遙 ; 土壤雖則看似鬆散, 充滿碎石, 事實卻擁有著相當份量的黏土地質 這裡的葡萄藤具有相當的歷史, 更曾大量避過 1956 年霜凍之劫 同時它的產量稀少, 產量每每介乎於每公頃 26 公石 所出產的葡萄皆全部去梗, 葡萄佳釀將陳釀於五成新的法國橡木酒桶中大概 16 至 20 個月 這葡萄佳釀豐富且具層次, 極具勁度, 如天鵝絨般細緻 ; 年輕的它強大帶勁, 但經時間沖薰卻變得成熟醇香 Lafleur 每年產量稀少, 共出產 1000 至 1200 箱, 這絶對令一眾 Lafleur 的愛好者求酒若渴 Château Lafleur 1975 Pomerol top shoulder, glue-stained label, fully cut capsule reveals fully branded cork "Massively proportioned with a boat-load of tannin to shed, this is a wine for the 21st century. This monumental wine may behave like some of the great 1928s " WA 2/ bottle per lot HK$14,000-20,000 US$ Château Lafleur 1982 Pomerol one bottom neck, seven very top shoulder, three top shoulder, one just below top shoulder, two glue-stained labels, two lightly bin-soiled labels, one lightly glue-stained label, one lightly marked label, three different importers "...remarkable opulence, the thickness and richness, yet the ability to seem fresh with laser-like precision are all things that must be tasted to be believed " WA 6/ bottles per lot HK$220, ,000 US$28,000-42,000 Château Lafleur 1989 Pomerol one bottom neck, one very top shoulder, two lightly bin-soiled labels, two lightly damp-stained labels, one lightly torn label "Full-bodied and powerful, with loads of tannins and chunky fruit...97." WS 5/ bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Château Lafleur 1990 Pomerol bottom neck or better, lightly bin-soiled and glue-stained labels, one lightly wine-stained label, different importers, one with signs of old seepage "This wine goes from strength to strength...a young, legendary wine...it is an amazing achievement! " WA 6/ bottles per lot HK$15,000-22,000 US$ Château Lafleur 1998 Pomerol two lightly nicked labels, one marked label, one nicked label "Full-bodied, with incredibly well-integrated tannins, a fine texture and a finish that persists for minutes...96." WS 1/ bottles per lot HK$11,000-16,000 US$ Château Lafleur 2000 Pomerol Lot 398: one lightly scuffed label, one loose capsule reveals fully branded cork, two different importers Lot 399: two different importers, one 6-pack original wood case, includes one 12-pack original wood case "...stacked and packed on the attack, with a multi-dimensional mid-palate of unbelievable intensity of concentration and richness, yet at the same time all this power is allied to striking elegance, purity, and depth " WA 6/ bottles per lot HK$46,000-65,000 US$ bottles per lot HK$85, ,000 US$11,000-17,000 Château Lafleur 2005 Pomerol two 3-pack original wood cases Parcel: lots 400 & 401 "Full-bodied, with a rich, powerful palate. Tannic and muscular, with great length. Super racy. Builds and goes and goes. So fine and beautiful. Mythic " WS 3/ magnums (1.5L) per lot HK$75, ,000 US$ , magnums (1.5L) per lot HK$75, ,000 US$ ,000 Château La Fleur Pétrus 2000 Pomerol includes 12-pack original wood case bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Château Le Plus de La Fleur de Bouard 2000 St George St Emilion original wood case "Filled with richness and intensity, with elegance, harmony, and poise, it is one of the top wines of the vintage. Sadly, very little is available...99." WA 6/ bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Château Gaffeliere Naudes 1945 St Emilion one top shoulder, one upper shoulder, one mid shoulder, dampstained labels, one lightly nicked label, one lightly wine-stained label bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com

71 Lots 400 & 401 Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com 71

72 La Mission Haut-Brion Although the histories of Château Haut-Brion and La Mission are entwined, both have always been separate entities, sharing a common family name. It is only since 1983 that they have shared the same proprietor when it was taken over by the owners of Haut-Brion On November 2nd 1983, the present owners acquired La Mission after the owner Francis Dewavrin was unable to resolved internal family disputes over the way the property was managed and it marks a convergence of histories between Château Haut-Brion and La Mission, though only in the sense that they share the same owner: Clarence Dillon. He enlisted Jean-Bernard Delmas as Château-manager and there followed a period that has consolidated La Mission s position as one of the greatest estates, hovering just outside the First Growths. Their commitment to innovation and improvements has been a catalyst for many estates in the Graves region to improve their wines, particularly with respect of clonal selection research. In 1987 the old chai was renovated, a new state-of-the-art cuvier was installed and a new bottling line was implemented in It must be emphasized that the estates are treated as separate entities, even though at some point the vines of both run side-by-side. In 2003 Jean-Bernard retired and handed the reins over to his son, Jean-Philippe Delmas. The Wines Certainly since the arrival of Jean-Bernard Delmas the style of wine has improved: the wine is more pure and the volatile acidity has been eradicated. At its best (the 1966, 1975, 1998) La Mission is a massive, tannic behemoth that has more in common with Château Latour than Château Haut-Brion. It is a powerful, sturdy wine with firm tannins and admirable longevity This is definitely one of the most intriguing wines in Bordeaux: the appeal of La Mission is that it seems to avoid the vagaries of winemaking trends and wears its heart on its sleeve. This is a classic wine in every sense of the word and it can make a seamless match with food. A poor La Mission is still a better wine than most; a good La Mission is a great wine and a great La Mission can be a religious experience. I have met few wine critics who do not hold this estate in high esteem: it is a wine for true wine lovers. Neil Martin, Wine Advocate, November 2006 雖然 Château Haut-Brion 和 La Mission 的歷史有着千絲萬縷的關係, 但一直是兩個獨立的個體, 只擁有共同的家族名稱 僅自 1983 年開始, 當它們被 Haut-Brion 的莊主接管, 就變成由同一個經營者所擁有 年 11 月 2 日, 由於當時 La Mission 的莊主 Francis Dewavrin 無法解決家庭內因管理莊園而起的爭論, 因此由現時的擁有人接管了酒莊, 這就標誌着 Château Haut-Brion 和 La Mission 之間的歷史融合 ; 雖然意義只在於被同一個人所擁有 :Clarence Dillon 他委派 Jean-Bernard Delmas 作為酒莊經理, 之後好一段時間都能鞏固 La Mission 作為最出色酒莊之一的地位, 僅次於一級酒莊 它們不斷創新和改進, 一直是 Graves 的催化劑, 令許多產區內的酒莊都着意提高它們的葡萄酒質素, 特別是有關無性繁殖選擇的研究 1987 年, 酒莊內存放桶裝酒的酒庫進行翻修工程, 安裝了先進的釀酒設備, 並於 1996 成立一條全新的入瓶生產線 必須強調的是, 儘管有時候葡萄藤栽種在對方的旁邊, 兩個酒莊一直被視為獨立的個體 2003 年,Jean-Bernard 退休, 並將他的葡萄酒王國傳給兒子 Jean-Philippe Delmas 當然, 自 Jean-Bernard Delmas 上任後, 葡萄酒的風格得以改善 : 酒變得更純淨, 而且酸度不穩定的問題已被根除 在最好的年份 ( 1966 年 1975 年和 1998 年 ),La Mission 是個單寧強勁的龐然大物, 比較之下, 似 Château Latour 多於 Château Haut-Brion 這葡萄酒剛勁有力, 單寧結實, 而且有令人讚嘆的陳年能力 這絕對是波爾多最吸引人的葡萄酒之一 :La Mission 的吸引力在於, 它似乎在迴避各種奇異的釀酒潮流, 而選擇坦蕩蕩地展露人前 這絕對是經典的葡萄酒, 可與食物配合得天衣無縫 就算是一瓶質素差的 La Mission, 仍然比大多數葡萄酒好 ; 一瓶質素好的 La Mission, 就是出色的葡萄酒, 而品嚐它可說是一次令人出神入化的體驗 我遇過的葡萄酒評論家, 只有少數對它不懷崇高敬意 : 這是給真正葡萄酒愛好者的葡萄酒 Neil Martin, 2006 年 11 月號 Wine Advocate Château La Mission Haut-Brion 1955 Graves, Cru Classé two very top shoulder, two top shoulder, two just below top shoulder, three upper shoulder, six bin-soiled labels, two heavily bin-soiled labels, one heavily torn label, one lightly binsoiled label, one scuffed label, one short capsule reveals fully branded cork, eight short capsules reveal vintage branded corks, three different importers, seven Nicolas Selection, one with signs of old seepage "The tannin has totally melted away...it is an amazing, complex, superbly well-balanced La Mission Haut-Brion! " WA 4/ bottles per lot HK$100, ,000 US$13,000-19,000 Château La Mission Haut-Brion 1961 Graves, Cru Classé Lot 406: one just below top shoulder, five upper shoulder, Nicolas stamp on lightly bin-soiled and damp-stained labels, short and lightly oxidized capsules reveal vintage branded corks Lot 407: one just below top shoulder, one upper shoulder, four upper-mid shoulder, damp-stained labels, five glue-stained labels, one heavily bin-soiled label, two nicked labels, one wine-stained label, one cut capsule reveals fully branded cork, one slightly depressed cork, four short capsules reveal vintage branded corks, one loose capsule reveals fully branded cork, short and oxidized capsules, three different importers "Dense, full-bodied, alcoholic, and super-rich, this soft, opulently-textured wine makes for a fabulous drink " RP bottles per lot HK$100, ,000 US$13,000-19, bottles per lot HK$100, ,000 US$13,000-19, Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com

73 Château La Mission Haut-Brion 1982 Graves, Cru Classé bottom neck or better, two lightly bin-soiled labels, one lightly damp-stained label, one lightly marked label "...colossal mouthfeel, a layered texture, incredible depth of fruit and glycerin, and copious, but well-integrated tannins that are largely concealed by the incredible amount of fruit " WA 6/ bottles per lot HK$65,000-95,000 US$ ,000 Château La Mission Haut-Brion 1989 Pessac Léognan, Cru Classé bottom neck or better, one loose capsule reveals fully branded cork, two different importers "Full-bodied with extraordinary opulence as well as sweet, well-integrated, velvety tannins, this fresh, lively, blockbuster La Mission appears to be one of those rare wines that never goes through a closed, unfriendly stage " WA 8/ bottles per lot HK$38,000-55,000 US$ Château La Mission Haut-Brion 1990 Pessac Léognan, Cru Classé bottom neck or better, one lightly bin-soiled label, one lightly scuffed label, one with signs of old seepage "A dark plum/blue/garnet color is followed by a sweet perfume of chocolate, rich, jammy, berry fruit, and hints of smoked herbs as well as meat juices. It remains a full-bodied, opulent, even ostentatious wine...96." WA 6/ bottles per lot HK$ US$ Château La Mission Haut-Brion 2000 Pessac Léognan, Cru Classé Lot 411: one loose capsule reveals fully branded cork, original wood case Lot 412: two lightly scuffed labels "Deep blue/purple, with a nose of creme de cassis, floral scents, graphite, and subtle smoke, the wine is pure, deep, sumptuously textured, full-bodied, powerful " WA 6/ bottles per lot HK$42,000-60,000 US$ bottles per lot HK$42,000-60,000 US$ Lots 411 & 412 Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com 73

74 La Mondotte 1996 St Emilion "...full-bodied and seamless, with gorgeously integrated acidity, alcohol, and tannin. Still remarkably thick, layered, and extravagantly rich...97." WA 4/ bottles per lot HK$15,000-22,000 US$ La Mondotte 1998 St Emilion Lot 414: original wood case Lot 415: one lightly nicked label "It is a colossal wine!...the ultimate garage wine, La Mondotte is ultra-concentrated, frightfully expensive, yet worth every cent...96." WA 4/ bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ bottles per lot HK$15,000-22,000 US$ La Mondotte 1999 St Emilion three lightly bin-soiled labels "Full-bodied and sumptuous, La Mondotte possesses amazing extract and richness for the vintage. its high tannin is hidden by a wealth of glycerin, fruit and extract. Moreover, the finish lasts for seconds...94." WA 4/ bottles per lot HK$ US$ La Mondotte 2000 St Emilion Lot 417: original wood case Lot 418: two 6-pack original wood cases Lot 419: two lightly bin-soiled labels, one loose capsule reveals fully branded cork, one 6-pack original wood case "A floral component also emerges as the wine sits in the glass. Extremely dense, full-bodied " WA 6/ bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ bottles per lot HK$19,000-28,000 US$ bottles per lot HK$19,000-28,000 US$ Château La Tour Haut-Brion 1959 Graves, Cru Classé nicked, scuffed, heavily damp-stained and glue-stained label, short capsule reveals vintage branded cork bottle per lot HK$ US$ L'Eglise Clinet Château L'Eglise Clinet 1995 Pomerol lightly damp-stained labels "Full-bodied and rich, with high tannin, but profound levels of fruit and richness, this dense, exceptionally well-delineated, layered, multidimensional L'Eglise Clinet only hints at its ultimate potential...96." WA 2/ bottles per lot HK$ US$ Château L'Eglise Clinet 1998 Pomerol "Full-bodied, with loads of fruit, fine tannins and an extremely long finish...96." WS 1/ bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Château L'Eglise Clinet 2000 Pomerol Lot 424: one marked label Lot 425: one lightly scuffed label, original wood case "Full-bodied with abundant tannin as well as a multidimensional, thick texture, this unevolved Pomerol has not changed much since its 2003 release. Gorgeous purity and a natural mouthfeel make for a dazzling wine " WA 6/ bottles per lot HK$13,000-19,000 US$ bottles per lot HK$24,000-36,000 US$ Château L'Eglise Clinet 2005 Pomerol original wood case with damaged lid "One of the monumental wines of the vintage...full body, and exceptional density and richness " WA 4/ bottles per lot HK$28,000-42,000 US$ Château Léoville Barton 2000 St Julien, Deuxième Cru Classé original wood case Parcel: lots 427 & bottles per lot HK$10,000-15,000 US$ bottles per lot HK$10,000-15,000 US$ Château La Tour Haut-Brion 1982 Graves, Cru Classé one bottom neck or better, two very top shoulder...powerful, full-bodied flavors, superb concentration, and a boatload of tannin...96." WA 6/ bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com

75 Léoville Las Cases The château gets its name from the Marquis de Las-Cases Beauvoice who, upon the dividing up of the vast Léoville estate, ended with the largest portion. Hugh Barton bought a quarter, Baron Poyferré (a relative) ended up with another quarter, and the remaining half went to the Marquis. As debt accumulated during the earlier part of the twentieth century, the estate was gradually acquired by its then manager, Theophile Skavinski. Jean-Hubert Delon, the estate s present owner, is one of his descendents. Although there are nearly 100 hectares under vine here, it is the fifty-three hectares of Grand Clos with that famous wall and arched entrance that is the primary source of fruit for the grand vin. The vines are planted to seventy percent Cabernet Sauvignon, seventeen percent Merlot and thirteen percent Cabernet Franc. Ageing is in sixty-five percent new oak barriques for fifteen to eighteen months, which just goes to show you don t need three and a half years in 100 percent new oak to make great wine. The second wine, Clos du Marquis, was one of Bordeaux first when the 1902 vintage debuted. These are serious wines, as good as any in the Médoc and in many years outperforming its second growth status. This estate could be called the Latour of St Julien, which is actually not very far from the truth as it does reside right next door to the First Growth! 酒莊名字源自於前身的 Léoville 酒莊, 其中一位繼承得最大片土地的承繼人 Marquis de Las-Cases Beauvoice 及後,Hugh Barton 購入當中土地的四分之一,Baron Poyferré 因親屬關係最終亦得到了另外的四分之一, 剩下的一半則回歸於 Marquis 的家族手中 二十世紀初酒莊債務累積龐大, 因此被當時的酒莊經理 Theophile Skavinski 逐步收購 時至今日, 酒莊已交由他的後人, 現今的酒莊主人 Jean-Hubert Delon 全權打理 莊園總面積接近 100 公頃, 但主要用作釀造出出色葡萄佳釀的優質果實卻來自佔地 53 公頃 擁有宏偉著名的圍牆及優雅的拱門入口的法國傳統莊園內 而當中葡萄七成屬於 Cabernet Sauvignon 一成七屬於 Merlot, 剩餘的一成三是 Cabernet Franc 這些葡萄將陳釀於六成半新的橡木桶內長達 15 至 18 個月, 足以說明釀造出色的佳釀根本不需用上全新橡木桶 也不需等待長達三年半的時光 酒莊打從 1902 年開始釀造它的副牌酒 Clos du Marquis, 它是首家釀造二軍酒的波爾多酒莊 Léoville Las Cases 所出之作, 可媲美任何 Medoc 地區的出品, 經過時間的洗禮, 它的出品已超越了二級酒莊的應有水平 ; 就算稱它為 聖朱利安的拉圖堡 ( The Latour of St Julien ) 也不為過, 皆因它亦位處於一級酒莊的旁邊! Château Léoville Las Cases 1982 St Julien, Deuxième Cru Classé original wood case eleven bottom neck or better, one very top shoulder, lightly bin-soiled labels, three lightly nicked labels "Classic lead pencil, cassis, kirsch, cedar, and spice characteristics are abundant in both the nose and full-bodied flavors " WA 6/ bottles per lot HK$24,000-36,000 US$ Château Léoville Las Cases 1996 St Julien, Deuxième Cru Classé Lot 430: two lightly marked labels, one lightly nicked label, one lightly torn label, five different importers Lot 431: one nicked label, original wood case Lot 432: two lightly nicked labels, original wood case "It is powerful and rich on the attack, with beautifully integrated tannin, massive concentration, yet no hint of heaviness...98." WA 4/ bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ bottles per lot HK$17,000-26,000 US$ bottles per lot HK$17,000-26,000 US$ Château Léoville Las Cases 2000 St Julien, Deuxième Cru Classé Lot 434: original wood case...with good acidity, the tell-tale purity, layered ripeness and intensity, and a profound finish WA 6/ bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ bottles per lot HK$19,000-28,000 US$ Château Léoville Las Cases 2005 St Julien, Deuxième Cru Classé original wood case Parcel: lots The palate is full, yet tight and powerful with perfect tannins and a long, long finish. The quality of the tannins is phenomenal, please leave this alone for ten years...99." JS 5/ bottles per lot HK$16,000-24,000 US$ bottles per lot HK$16,000-24,000 US$ bottles per lot HK$16,000-24,000 US$ Château Léoville Poyferré 2000 St Julien, Deuxième Cru Classé bottles per lot HK$ US$ Château L'Evangile 1975 Pomerol bottom neck or better, bin-soiled labels, two lightly torn labels "Powerful and forceful, with rich, jammy fruit buttressed by high tannin, this full-bodied, superbly extracted wine is soft enough to be approachable...96." WA 2/ bottles per lot HK$20,000-30,000 US$ Château L'Evangile 1982 Pomerol bottom neck or better, lightly bin-soiled labels, one winestained label "This opulent, full-bodied Pomerol caresses the palate with layers and layers of glycerin and fruit. The tannin is barely noticeable in this massive, rich, gorgeous effort...98." WA 6/ bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ ZACHYS tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com 75

76 Château L'Evangile 1990 Pomerol one bottom neck, two very top shoulder, lightly bin-soiled labels, one lightly glue-stained label, two different importers "It is a complex effort with lots of cedar, sweet caramelized black raspberries and cherries as well as hints of licorice and underbrush." WA 6/ bottles per lot HK$ US$ Château L'Evangile 1998 (7) lightly damp-stained labels, two different importers 1998 magnum (1) lightly bin-soiled label 442 above 7 bottles & 1 magnum (1.5L) per lot HK$10,000-15,000 US$ Château L'Evangile 2000 Pomerol Lot 443: includes 12-pack original wood case Lot 444: original wood case "Dense, rich, and full-bodied, with an opulence and succulence that are prodigious, the tannins are present but extremely sweet, and the wine multi-dimensional and just emerging as a compellingly complex, head-turning beauty...98." WA 6/ bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ bottles per lot HK$19,000-28,000 US$ Château Lynch-Bages 1961 Pauillac, Cinquième Cru Classé one top shoulder, one upper shoulder, lightly bin-soiled labels, one lightly damp-stained label, one lightly torn label, one short capsule reveals fully branded cork, one short capsule reveals fully vintage branded cork, one with signs of old seepage "...richly coloured, still impressively deep; beautiful nose with characteristic though toned down Lynch-Bages 'cassis', a touch of sweetness, nice weight, soft, rounded, harmonious, with well assimilated tannins. A perfect drink...hhhhh." MB 5/ bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Château Magrez Fombrauge 2000 St Emilion two 6-pack original wood cases Parcel: lots "...a big, sweet nose of camphor, creosote, blackberries, blueberries, espresso roast, graphite, and toasty oak, and a phenomenally layered, full-bodied, rich mouthfeel...98." WA 6/ bottles per lot HK$10,000-15,000 US$ bottles per lot HK$10,000-15,000 US$ bottles per lot HK$10,000-15,000 US$ bottles per lot HK$10,000-15,000 US$ Château Marojallia 2000 Margaux original wood case Parcel: lots bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Château Monbousquet 2000 St Emilion bottles per lot HK$ US$ Château Montrose 1990 St Estèphe, Deuxième Cru Classé bottom neck or better, one damp-stained label, one heavily damp-stained label, one lightly marked label, one marked label, one wine-stained label "...absolutely magnificent, broad, savory and mouth-filling. This is one of the all-time modern legends from Bordeaux as well as Château Montrose " WA 8/ bottles per lot HK$14,000-20,000 US$ Château Lynch-Bages 2000 Pauillac, Cinquième Cru Classé original wood case Parcel: lots 446 & 447 "...exhibits admirable purity, texture, mouthfeel and power combined with elegance. One of the all-time great examples of Lynch-Bages...97." WA 8/ bottles per lot HK$16,000-24,000 US$ bottles per lot HK$16,000-24,000 US$ Château Montrose 2000 St Estèphe, Deuxième Cru Classé Lot 458: one wrinkled label, includes 12-pack original wood case Lot 459: original wood case "Just starting to open, it shows beautiful spices and dark fruit on the nose and palate. It s full-bodied with ultra-fine, integrated tannins and an extremely complex, refined finish...96." JS 4/ bottles per lot HK$ US$ bottles per lot HK$11,000-16,000 US$ Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com

77 Château Palmer The estate was originally known as Château de Gasq, part of the vast holdings of the de Gasq family. When Alexandre de Gasq died early in the nineteenth century, his widow Marie Brunet de Ferriere had no interest in running a Château, and decided to sell. The buyer was General Palmer, the son of a wealthy MP who joined the army and soon rose to the position of Aidede-Camp to the Prince Regent. While in France, fighting near the end of Napoleonic wars, he went to Bordeaux where upon his arrival he had a chance meeting with Marie Brunet de Ferriere, then on her way to Paris to sell the Château. The idea of a wine estate in the area appealed to Palmer and in 1814, just two days after arriving in Bordeaux, Château de Gasq was his. Soon after that, Palmer s life became very difficult. He inadvertently became involved in a scandal in London that cost him his favor with the Prince Regent and also, in February 1815, resulted in a duel at noon on the outskirts of Paris with another important British commander. From then on he concentrated his efforts on winemaking. Over the next fifteen years he would spend a small fortune expanding the Château holdings, eventually more than doubling its size. He also changed the name to Château Palmer and began to market it in London. Unlike many Châteaux, Château Palmer entered the twentieth century in fine shape. However, after the war and then the depression, the Pèreires were in financial trouble and just prior to the Second World War they sold Château Palmer. With the estate operating at a big loss, and both cellars and vineyards in disrepair, Palmer was purchased by a consortium for almost nothing. Its main members, the Sichel and Mahler- Besse families, bought out their partners over time and by 1982 they owned it outright with one-third and two-thirds ownership respectively. Today there are again a number of shareholders, but Sichel and Mahler-Besse remain the biggest and still play a very important part in the direction of the Château. The estate is now managed by Thomas Duroux and Technical director Philippe Delfaut, with marketing and business development left to Bernard de Laage de Mieux. With their drive and business acumen Palmer remains constantly on the heels of Château Margaux. 莊園本名為 Château de Gasq, 為 de Gasq 家族所擁有 Alexandre de Gasq 於 19 世紀初與世長辭, 而他的遺孀 Marie Brunet de Ferriere 對於經營酒莊並沒有太大興趣, 所以決定把莊園出售 莊園由一個名為 Palmer 的軍官購入 貴為議會成員之子,Palmer 初次從軍便於短短時間內升為執政王族的副官 當時在法國, 拿破崙戰爭將近結束時,Palmer 啟程前往波爾多並在抵達後機緣巧合認識了寡婦 Marie Brunet de Ferriere, 當時她正準備啟程到巴黎將酒莊出售 Palmer 對於在波爾多擁有一座酒莊的想法產生濃厚興趣 在 1814 年, 於抵達波爾多後 2 日,Château de Gasq 便成為 Palmer 的囊中物 好境不常,Palmer 往後的軍事生涯變得崎嶇難行 他無意間被捲入一宗倫敦醜聞, 並因此失去當時執政王族對他的偏愛 接著於 1815 年 2 月,Palmer 跟一名重要的英國指揮官於巴黎市郊私自進行對決 自此 Palmer 便專心一意致力於釀酒 於往後 15 年間, 他花費了一筆小金額去擴展酒莊, 最終把酒莊擴充至原來的兩倍 他把酒莊改名為 Château Palmer 並開始推出倫敦市場 於 1853 年,Château Palmer 被企業及銀行家 Pèreire 家族收購 Pèreire 家族有意把酒莊大肆改造升級 首要事項便是把城堡改建成今天我們所見到充滿優雅格調的建築, 與位於 Pauillac 的 Château Pichon Longueville 出自於同一建築師之手筆 不需任何建築學的底子也不難發現兩座城堡設計上極為相似 與其他酒莊不同,Château Palmer 時至 20 世紀仍舊保持著精美的外觀 經歷了戰爭以及大蕭條,Pèreire 家族不敵財政困難, 在二次世界大戰前決定把 Château Palmer 出售 由於經營不善酒莊長期虧損, 酒窖及葡萄園日久失修,Château Palmer 以極低的價格被財團所收購 財團主要成員為 Sichel 及 Mahler-Besse 家族, 往後他們逐步把其餘成員股份收購, 直至 1982 年, 他們兩個家族分別各自持有三份之一及三份之二的酒莊股權 時至今日, 酒莊的股東已不止 Sichel 與 Mahler-Besse 兩大家族, 但他們仍佔有相當份量的股份, 相信於酒莊未來發展上, 將繼續扮演著重要的角色 酒莊現時由 Thomas Duroux 及技術總監 Philippe Delfaut 所管理, 而市場推廣及業務發展便由 Bernard de Laage de Mieux 所負責 在他們敏銳的商業觸覺帶動下,Château Palmer 經常緊貼在 Château Margaux 的後方 Château Palmer 1961 Margaux, Troisième Cru Classé bottom neck or better, one lightly scuffed label, one cut capsule reveals fully branded cork, one heavily torn capsule reveals fully branded cork, Mahler-Besse bottles per lot HK$60,000-95,000 US$ ,000 Château Palmer 1983 Margaux, Troisième Cru Classé two bottom neck or better, three very top shoulder, three top shoulder, one just below top shoulder, one lightly nicked label, seven lightly scuffed labels, two different importers, four Mahler-Besse bottles per lot HK$22,000-32,000 US$ Château Palmer 1989 Margaux, Troisième Cru Classé bottom neck or better, one lightly scuffed label, two different importers, three Mahler-Besse bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Château Palmer 2000 Margaux, Troisième Cru Classé Lot 463: original wood case "I love the blackberry, plum, chocolate and cedar character. It s very long and beautiful. The velvety, textured tannins are impressive...97." JS 4/ bottles per lot HK$19,000-28,000 US$ bottles per lot HK$20,000-30,000 US$ Château Pape Clément 2000 Pessac Léognan, Cru Classé original wood case one lightly bin-soiled label, two lightly scuffed labels "The wine is expansive, has a savory, broad palate and a fullbodied mouthfeel, yet possesses vivid purity and uplift. The tannins are still present, but they are sweet and well-integrated...96." WA 6/ bottles per lot HK$11,000-16,000 US$ Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com 77

78 Château Pavie In March 1998 Château Pavie was purchased by Gerard and Chantal Perse for $30.8 million. Perse was a self-made millionaire, the founder of two highly successful supermarket chains that were sold to pursue his dream: to own a prestigious Right Bank vineyard. His first acquisition was Château Monbousquet in 1993 followed by Pavie-Decesse in 1997 but Pavie was his jewel in the crown. I remember visiting the estate just after Perse had commenced his radical reconstruction of the château, encountering him in deep conversation with Dr Alain Raynaud (they were allegedly joined at the hip around this time.) The scale of the investment was quite astonishing; a car-park of heavy machinery, blanketed with a film of fine white dust from the sandstone building blocks that would form the foundation of Perse's "Xanadu". It remains the flagship of his empire to this day. Château Pavie is located south-east of the village of Saint Emilion with part of the vineyard on the plateau at the top of clayey soil, with a majority of the vineyard on the limestone soils on the côte with around 3 hectares on the less distinguished sandy soil at the bottom of the slope. There are hectares of vines: 60% Merlot, 30% Cabernet Franc and 10% Cabernet Sauvignon with an average vine-age of 45 years. The vineyard is pruned hard: 6 buds for old vines and 2 buds for young with extensive green harvesting in the summer months. Yields have been reduced from 55hl/ha under Valette, to an average of 30hl/ha and Perse did not hesitate in pulling up 28% of inferior vines and installing a new drainage system. Robert Parker, The Wine Advocate Château Pavie 1998 St Emilion, Premier Grand Cru Classé (a) "Extremely full-bodied, yet brilliantly delineated, powerful, and awesomely concentrated, it boasts a fabulous mid-palate as well as a finish that lasts for nearly a minute...95." WA 4/ bottles per lot HK$19,000-28,000 US$ Château Pavie 2000 St Emilion, Premier Grand Cru Classé (a) original wood case "...stunningly rich nose...fabulously concentrated and full-bodied, with a multidimensional mouthfeel " WA 8/ bottles per lot HK$38,000-60,000 US$ Château Pavie Decesse 2000 St Emilion, Grand Cru Classé original wood case "Monumental richness, sensational sweet tannin, a skyscraperlike mid-palate, and a 45+-second finish result in an extraordinary wine that is just reaching its plateau of full maturity...96." WA 6/ bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Château Pavie Macquin 1998 St Emilion, Grand Cru Classé bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Château Pavie Macquin 2000 St Emilion, Grand Cru Classé Lots : original wood case Lot 473: original wood case with damaged lid Parcel: lots bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Château Péby Faugères 1998 St Emilion bottles per lot HK$ US$ Château Péby Faugères 2000 St Emilion Lot 476: one lightly bin-soiled label, includes 12-pack original wood case Lot 477: original wood case bottles per lot HK$ US$ bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com

79 Château Pichon-Baron 1990 Pauillac, Deuxième Cru Classé three bottom neck or better, one very top shoulder, one lightly bin-soiled label, one lightly corroded capsule, three different importers "...it reveals an extraordinary bouquet of charcoal, incense, creme de cassis, blue and black fruits, and a hint of licorice as well as an impressively long finish...97." WA 6/ bottles per lot HK$ US$ Château Pichon-Baron 2000 Pauillac, Deuxième Cru Classé original wood case Lot 479: one torn label Lot 480: four lightly bin-soiled labels "It is superbly concentrated and very pure, with excellent texture and opulence. The acidity seems low, the tannin high but well-integrated. This is a compelling " WA 6/ bottles per lot HK$15,000-22,000 US$ bottles per lot HK$15,000-22,000 US$ Château Pichon Longueville Comtesse de Lalande 1995 Pauillac, Deuxième Cru Classé "Exquisite on the palate, this full-bodied, layered, multidimensional wine should prove to be one of the vintage's most extraordinary success stories WA 2/ bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Château Pichon Longueville Comtesse de Lalande 2000 Pauillac, Deuxième Cru Classé original wood case "This is a rich, opulent, stunning Pichon Lalande that is beginning to drink beautifully...96." WA 6/ bottles per lot HK$14,000-20,000 US$ Château Pichon Longueville Comtesse de Lalande 2003 Pauillac, Deuxième Cru Classé original wood case two lightly scuffed labels bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Château Tertre Roteboeuf 2000 St Emilion original wood case Nevertheless, there is a sweet character from the high glycerin level...velvety textured and full-bodied, but surprisingly youthful WA 6/ bottles per lot HK$20,000-30,000 US$ Château Tertre Roteboeuf 1990 (3) bottom neck or better, lightly bin-soiled labels 1995 (4) two bin-soiled labels 1998 (6) lightly damp-stained labels 485 above 13 bottles per lot HK$15,000-22,000 US$ Château Troplong Mondot 1990 St Emilion, Grand Cru Classé includes 12-pack original wood case bottom neck or better, six with importer tags adhered to labels, two different importers "Rich and full-bodied with lavish fruit, high glycerin, low acidity, and stunning purity...98." WA 6/ bottles per lot HK$16,000-24,000 US$ Château Troplong Mondot 2000 St Emilion, Grand Cru Classé Lots 487 & 488: original wood case Lot 489: damaged original wood case Parcel: lots 487 & bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Château Troplong Mondot 1990 (3) bottom neck or better 2000 (6) one damp-stained label 490 above 9 bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com 79

80 Château Trotanoy In the 1868 edition of Cocks & Feret s book on Bordeaux, Château Trotanoy was considered second only to Vieux Château Certan among Pomerol Châteaux. First mentioned in the 1750s, by the start of the nineteenth century Trotanoy was owned by the Giraud family and some twenty-five hectares in size, although French inheritance laws have made it much smaller today. The Giraud family eventually sold it in the 1920s to Pecresse, who then sold it to the rising Moueix family in 1953, and almost immediately Trotanoy began to produce some of the finest wines. The Wine Today Château Trotanoy has just eight hectares, with the blend and winemaking very similar to Pétrus. The ninety percent Merlot and ten percent Cabernet Franc vines average fifty years of age, some much longer; total annual production is approximately 2500 cases (about half that of Pétrus). Château Trotanoy 1945 Pomerol upper-mid shoulder, bin-soiled, damp-stained and torn label, short capsule reveals vintage branded cork, Nicolas Selection "With such amazing concentration and extract levels, there still remains the possibility that everything will weld together. If so, this wine could easily live for 100 years...95." WA 10/ bottle per lot HK$19,000-28,000 US$ Château Trotanoy 1955 Pomerol three upper shoulder, one upper-mid shoulder, two deteriorated labels, two heavily damp-stained labels, two heavily torn labels, two lightly bin-soiled labels, one torn label obscures vintage with vintage confirmed on cork, two corroded capsules, one with signs of old seepage bottles per lot HK$16,000-24,000 US$ Château Trotanoy 1970 Pomerol bottom neck or better, bin-soiled labels, one damp-stained label, one lightly corroded capsule, two different importers "The nose is just beginning to open. The flavors are so concentrated that I am going to go out on a limb and say this may be the most concentrated Trotanoy made in the post-world War II era...96." RP bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Château Trotanoy 1975 Pomerol one top shoulder, one just below top shoulder, bin-soiled labels, one heavily damp-stained label, one with signs of old seepage "Like so many top Pomerols in the 1975 vintage, there is a sweetness and jamminess to this wine's fruit that is not found in most 1975 Medocs. This is a glorious Trotanoy!...95." WA 2/ bottles per lot HK$ US$ Château Trotanoy 1998 Pomerol Lot 495: original wood case Lot 496: lightly bin-soiled labels "This structured, formidably-endowed, deep ruby/purple-colored, full-bodied, super-rich wine exhibits notes of toffee, truffles, and abundant blackberry, cherry, and currant fruit...95." WA 4/ bottles per lot HK$11,000-16,000 US$ bottles per lot HK$22,000-32,000 US$ Château Trotanoy 2000 Pomerol Lot 497: two 6-pack original wood cases Lot 498: one lightly bin-soiled label, three lightly nicked labels, one 6-pack original wood case "The wine is full-bodied, dense, and just beginning to shed its tannins. Generous and opulent, it is beginning to enter its plateau of full maturity...94." WA 6/ bottles per lot HK$20,000-30,000 US$ bottles per lot HK$20,000-30,000 US$ Château Valandraud 2000 St Emilion Lot 499: banded original wood case Lots 500 & 501: original wood case Parcel: lots 500 & 501 "Medium to full-bodied with a buffet of aromas and flavors as well as sweet tannin and a plush, succulent mouthfeel, this is a terrific effort...94." WA 6/ bottles per lot HK$12,000-19,000 US$ bottles per lot HK$12,000-19,000 US$ bottles per lot HK$12,000-19,000 US$ Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com

81 Château Valandraud 1995 magnums (2) one lightly damp-stained label, one wine-stained label 1998 (5) 502 above 5 bottles & 2 magnums (1.5L) per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Vieux Château Certan 1998 Pomerol original wood case Lot 504: one torn capsule "Full-bodied, with an almost dusty texture. Long and seamless, with beautiful, firm tannins and a racy finish. Wonderfully delicate sweet fruit on the finish...94." WS bottles per lot HK$13,000-19,000 US$ bottles per lot HK$13,000-19,000 US$ Vieux Château Certan 2000 Pomerol Lot 505: original wood case Lot 506: one lightly bin-soiled label, original wood case with damaged lid "A gorgeous wine of grace, elegance, and power...medium to full-bodied, elegant, and pure with low acidity as well as formidable tannins in the long finish...95." WA 6/ bottles per lot HK$14,000-20,000 US$ bottles per lot HK$14,000-20,000 US$ Mixed Bordeaux Vieux Château Certan 1952 (1) upper shoulder, bin-soiled and torn label, cut capsule reveals fully branded cork Château Léoville Poyferré 1953 (2) bottom neck or better, damp-stained and wine-stained labels 507 above 3 bottles per lot HK$ US$ Bordeaux 1961 Château Figeac (1) into neck, bin-soiled label, loose and short capsule reveals fully branded cork, rebouchée au Château en 2005 Château Gruaud-Larose (1) 3cm with elongated neck, scuffed label 508 above 2 bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Mixed Bordeaux bottom neck or better unless noted Château Magdelaine 1970 (4) one very top shoulder, two top shoulder, one upper shoulder, damp-stained labels Château La Mission Haut-Brion 1978 (1) upper-mid shoulder, lightly bin-soiled label, slightly protruded cork Château L'Eglise Clinet 1985 (3) lightly bin-soiled labels, two lightly marked labels, one lightly torn label Château Léoville Las Cases 1986 (2) damp-stained and lightly bin-soiled labels Château Montrose 1986 (1) very top shoulder, damp-stained label Château Lynch-Bages 1989 (1) lightly damp-stained label Château La Conseillante 1990 (1) very top shoulder, lightly bin-soiled label Château Haut-Brion 1995 (1) lightly scuffed label Château Trotanoy 1995 (2) 509 above 16 bottles per lot HK$22,000-32,000 US$ Bordeaux 1982 bottom neck or better Château Grand-Puy-Lacoste (2) damp-stained labels Château Gruaud-Larose (2) one lightly bin-soiled label, one oxidized and corroded capsule, different releases Château Montrose (1) damp-stained and scuffed label 510 above 5 bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Bordeaux 2000 Château Figeac (6) includes 12-pack original wood case Château Léoville Barton (6) includes 12-pack original wood case Château Marojallia (6) 511 above 18 bottles per lot HK$14,000-20,000 US$ Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com 81

82 Château Ausone Ausone is named for Ausonius, a fourth century poet and later Consul to Rome who lived in the area, although no proof exists that the current Ausone holdings and Ausonius were connected. What is known is that he owned vineyards in or near Bordeaux, and that since Roman times wine has been made in and around St Emilion. From the early eighteenth century Ausone was owned by the Cantenat family, eventually passing to a nephew, M. Lafargue. Lafargue is credited with building Ausone s reputation at the time; during his tenure it was considered the finest producer in all of St Emilion. In the early 1890s it passed to Lafargue s niece, Madame Challon, who later married Edouard Dubois. Edouard Dubois-Challon continued the work of Lafargue and by the time of the First World War Ausone was considered the wine of the commune, even greater than Cheval Blanc. This success and reputation enabled Dubois-Challon to acquire neighboring Château Belair in Alain Vauthier, the current proprietor, is a descendant of the family. For a long time Ausone had a reputation as an erratic performer, but more recently has begun to achieve its potential consistently. In 1989 Clive Coates wrote presciently in Grand Vins, I dare say it will not be long before Ausone fetches the same prices as Pétrus. Château Ausone 1961 St Emilion, Premier Grand Cru Classé (a) upper shoulder, one damp-stained label, lightly bin-soiled labels, one lightly marked label, one marked label, one with tissue paper adhered to label, short capsules reveal vintage branded corks bottles per lot HK$ US$ Château Ausone 1990 St Emilion, Premier Grand Cru Classé (a) one very top shoulder, one top shoulder, lightly bin-soiled labels "The aromatics suggest a fully mature wine, but in the mouth, the firm structure and density indicate this effort needs more time." WA 6/ bottles per lot HK$ US$ Château Ausone 1998 St Emilion, Premier Grand Cru Classé (a) "Extremely pure and penetrating, with fruit of steel and a powerful mineral underpinning. Finishes with strong, firm tannins and great persistence...95." IWC 7/ bottles per lot HK$32,000-50,000 US$ Château Ausone 2000 St Emilion, Premier Grand Cru Classé (a) Lot 516: one lightly scuffed label, two 6-pack original wood cases "Extremely rich, full-bodied, with astonishing power, precision, and delicacy, this is a sumptuous wine...98." WA 6/ bottles per lot HK$28,000-42,000 US$ bottles per lot HK$65,000-95,000 US$ ,000 Château Ausone 2003 St Emilion, Premier Grand Cru Classé (a) Lots 517 & 518: original wood case Lot 519: one lightly scuffed label, one scuffed label, two 6-pack original wood cases Lot 521: one lightly bin-soiled label, one lightly damp-stained label, one scuffed label Parcel: lots 517 & 518 Full-bodied with staggering concentration, a voluptuous texture, low acidity and well-integrated, melted tannins, this deep, multidimensional, profound Bordeaux is beginning to drink exceptionally well " WA 8/ bottles per lot HK$60,000-95,000 US$ , bottles per lot HK$60,000-95,000 US$ , bottles per lot HK$60,000-95,000 US$ , bottles per lot HK$60,000-95,000 US$ , magnums (1.5L) per lot HK$30,000-46,000 US$ Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com

83 Lots 515 & 516 Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com 83

84 Château Cheval Blanc Cheval Blanc has a relatively short history compared with the other top-rank Châteaux of Bordeaux. As recently as the 1830s it was still a part of Figeac. A portion of that estate was sold to the Ducasse family, then owners of L Evangile, and by twenty years later, when a Ducasse married a Fourcard- Loussac, the property was already some thirty-one hectares in size. The estate remained with the Fourcard-Loussac family until part of it was sold to Bernard Arnault and his company, LVMH, in Today, along with Château d Yquem, it is fully owned by Arnault and managed by the dynamic Pierre Lurton. Cheval Blanc 與其他波爾多頂級酒莊相比, 歷史相對較短 近至 19 世紀 30 年代, 它仍然是 Figeac 的一部分 Cheval Blanc 莊園的一部份曾被賣給 Ducasse 家族, 亦即是 L Evangile 的莊主 ;20 年後, 當 Ducasse 與 Fourcard-Loussac 家族聯婚時, 整個莊園已經約有 31 公頃大 莊園之後一直由 Fourcard-Loussac 家族所擁有, 直至 1998 年, 部分被出售予 Bernard Arnault 和他的公司 -LVMH 今天,Cheval Blanc 酒莊與 d Yquem 酒莊完全由 Arnault 擁有, 並由充滿活力的 Pierre Lurton 管理 Château Cheval Blanc 1990 St Emilion, Premier Grand Cru Classé (a) bottom neck or better Lot 523: nine lightly bin-soiled labels, one lightly marked label, one lightly nicked label, one lightly wine-stained label, six different importers Lot 524: bin-soiled and lightly damp-stained labels "...a complex bouquet of tobacco leaf, Christmas fruitcake, sweet black fruits, bordering on fig and plum, but no hint of overripeness, and notions of new saddle leather, mint, and incense " WA 6/ bottles per lot HK$20,000-30,000 US$ bottles per lot HK$60,000-95,000 US$ , magnums (1.5L) per lot HK$22,000-32,000 US$ Château Cheval Blanc 1998 St Emilion, Premier Grand Cru Classé (a) one lightly scuffed label "A wine that harkens back to the legendary 1947 Cheval Blanc " JS 9/ bottles per lot HK$30,000-46,000 US$ Château Cheval Blanc 1999 St Emilion, Premier Grand Cru Classé (a) "...medium body, extraordinary elegance...seamless beauty of finesse, charm, and concentration...93." WA 4/ bottles per lot HK$28,000-42,000 US$ Château Cheval Blanc 2000 St Emilion, Premier Grand Cru Classé (a) original wood case two lightly scuffed labels "A broad wine with compelling purity, a layered texture, and sweet tannin, with hints of coffee and earth in the background...99." WA 7/ bottles per lot HK$55,000-80,000 US$ , Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com

85 Château Haut-Brion Haut-Brion has the longest history of all the First Growths. The famous Pontac family set up the estate in the first portion of the sixteenth century. Wealthy and well connected, they had the means to promote the wine in fashionable places, and by the early 1700s it was as well known as a wine of the highest quality. While parts were split off, the estate stayed with the family until it was passed to Joseph Fumél in He was largely responsible for creating much of what we see today, including the buildings, the gardens and the general layout of the property. He famously hosted a visit from Thomas Jefferson on May 25, 1787, and became Mayor of Bordeaux three years later. With its popularity waning under a succession of different owners, the estate was finally put up for auction in 1836, where it was purchased by the Larreau family. Two years later, in 1838, they managed to acquire a further piece of the estate previously lost through inheritance laws. Although it was included as a First Growth in the 1855 classification of Bordeaux, difficult times lay ahead. A further succession of owners and the depression of the early 1930s forced another sale. This time, successful American financier Clarence Dillon stepped up, and for a little under $200,000 walked away with the estate. It remains in the Dillon family today. 著名的 Pontac 家族於十六世紀初建立 Haut-Brion 莊園 由於 Pontac 家族擁有財富及強大的人脈網絡, 他們當時能夠在各時尚場所推廣 Haut- Brion 葡萄酒 直至十八世紀初,Haut-Brion 酒莊出產的葡萄酒已經以優良品質而聞名於世 雖然 Pontac 家族成員之間有分歧, 但莊園一直由家族擁有 直到 1780 年, 莊園才轉讓給 Joseph Fumél Joseph Fumél 對莊園作出不少貢獻, 今日我們所看見的莊園, 包括建築物 花園及莊園的整體規劃等都是他精心之作 同年 5 月 25 日, 他在莊園舉辦了一次盛會, 邀得美國第三任總統 Thomas Jefferson 到訪, 三年後他更成為波爾多的市長 莊園其後經歷了幾代人的管理而日漸凋零, 結果於 1836 年, 莊園在拍賣會上被出售, 最後由 Larreau 家族投得 兩年後 ( 即 1838 年 ),Larreau 家族終於收購先前因為繼承法而失去的部份產業, 使莊園回復完整 雖然 Haut-Brion 在 1855 年波爾多的等級分類中已被列為一級酒莊, 但在之後近 100 年, 它仍然面對不少困難 再度經歷了幾代人的管理和 1930 年代的經濟大蕭條, 莊園又再次易主 這次美國銀行家 Clarence Dillon 用了不足 20 萬元便將 Haut-Brion 買下 ; 時至今日, 莊園仍由 Dillon 家族所擁有 Château Haut-Brion 1945 Graves, Premier Cru Classé very top shoulder, bin-soiled and wine-stained labels, cut capsules reveal fully branded corks, rebouchée au Château en 1985 "It is a fabulously rich, monumental example of a fully mature Haut-Brion that exhibits no signs of decline. Awesome! " WA 10/ bottles per lot HK$75, ,000 US$ ,000 Château Haut-Brion 1959 Graves, Premier Cru Classé 4cm, damp-stained and lightly scuffed label "Sensational. Mature, generous and deep, a many-layered wine that shows sweet berry and chocolate flavors under a layer of slightly scratchy tannins...98." WS 4/ bottle per lot HK$10,000-15,000 US$ Château Haut-Brion 1961 Graves, Premier Cru Classé two 3.5cm, two 4cm, four 4.5cm, one 5.5cm, two dampstained labels, four lightly bin-soiled labels, five nicked labels, one wine-stained label, five corroded capsules, three cut capsules reveal fully branded corks, one depressed cork, one torn capsule, one with signs of old seepage, three Mahler-Besse "...pure perfection, with gloriously intense aromas. This has always been a prodigious effort " WA 2/ bottles per lot HK$140, ,000 US$18,000-26,000 Château Haut-Brion 1989 Pessac Léognan, Premier Cru Classé Lot 531: 2cm, wine-stained and lightly scuffed label Lot 532: 1.5cm or better, one lightly nicked label, one marked label, damaged original wood case Lot 533: 2cm or better, two bin-soiled labels, one lightly nicked label, one lightly scuffed label, one lightly wine-stained label, one with signs of old seepage Lot 534: 2cm or better, two lightly bin-soiled labels, four lightly scuffed labels, three different importers "This is unbelievable. Greatest Haut-Brion ever made...fullbodied, with an amazing concentration of fruit and velvety tannins. The finish goes on for minutes " WS 5/ bottle per lot HK$ ,000 US$ bottles per lot HK$110, ,000 US$14,000-20, bottles per lot HK$110, ,000 US$14,000-20, bottles per lot HK$110, ,000 US$14,000-20,000 ZACHYS tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com 85

86 Château Haut-Brion 2000 Pessac Léognan, Premier Cru Classé Lot 535: original wood case Lot 536: two lightly damp-stained labels, one nicked label, original wood case Lot 537: one lightly bin-soiled label, two lightly nicked labels, two lightly scuffed labels, two with importer tags adhered to labels, original wood case Lot 538: one lightly nicked label, two lightly scuffed labels, one nicked label, damaged original wood case "...a deep, layered, sumptuously textured, full-bodied Haut- Brion, but one with extraordinary complexity...99." WA 6/ bottles per lot HK$50,000-75,000 US$ bottles per lot HK$50,000-75,000 US$ bottles per lot HK$50,000-75,000 US$ bottles per lot HK$50,000-75,000 US$ Château Haut-Brion 2003 Pessac Léognan, Premier Cru Classé original wood case Lot 539: one lightly nicked label Lot 540: two lightly nicked labels, two lightly scuffed labels Lot 541: one lightly nicked label, three lightly scuffed labels, one lightly torn label "While broad and ripe with a sweet, glyceral mouthfeel as well as a long, powerful, persistent finish, it retains its elegance and nobility. A wine of both power and finesse...95." WA 4/ bottles per lot HK$28,000-42,000 US$ bottles per lot HK$28,000-42,000 US$ bottles per lot HK$28,000-42,000 US$ Château Haut-Brion 2005 Pessac Léognan, Premier Cru Classé original wood case "One of my wines of the night, the 2005 Haut-Brion is stratospheric. Remarkably vivid and nuanced, the 2005 presents a compelling mélange of dark flavors laced with the savory/mineral notes that are so typical of Haut-Brion " AG 11/ bottles per lot HK$46,000-70,000 US$ Château Lafite Rothschild For as long as anyone can remember, Lafite has been the most highly regarded wine in Bordeaux. From their very first book, published in 1845, Cocks & Feret have listed Lafite first, and it was ranked first in the famous 1855 classification of Bordeaux. Fite is an old French term meaning small hill, rise or mound; it is from this humble feature in Bordeaux somewhat bland landscape that France s most esteemed producer takes its name. The Château itself is one of the oldest in Bordeaux, with much of it dating from the mid-sixteenth century. It was purchased by the wealthy Ségur family in the seventeenth century, but like much of the region at the time, the land was used for a variety of farming. Beginning in the 1670s, the Ségurs spent around twenty years converting a large portion of the land to vineyards. With Latour and Calon, as well as Lafite, under their ownership, the Ségurs began to find a market for their wines in London. It was first mentioned in the London Gazette in 1707 and soon became famous: by the early 1730s, it was a favorite of the Prime Minister, Robert Walpole. Lafite remained in the Ségur family until It was sold several times, finally to Baron de Rothschild in 1868, by which time there were some seventy-four hectares of vines. It was a new era of industrial wealth and the Rothschild purchase certainly added much celebrity to the area. 一直以來,Lafite 均被認定為 Bordeaux 最受人注目的葡萄酒,1845 年 Bordeaux 第一本有關葡萄酒專著 Cocks & Feret 中, 便將 Lafite 列於首位,1855 年, 更被列為 Bordeaux 之首 Fite 在舊式法語中意指小山崗, 面對這片美麗 柔和的土地, 酒莊便以此命名 Château Lafite 是 Bordeaux 最古老的酒莊之一, 其歷史可追溯至 16 世紀中葉, 17 世紀被 Ségur 家族收購, 一如當時這個地區的其他農地, 他們亦在農地上栽種多種農作物 1670 年代初,Ségur 家族花了約 20 年的時間, 將大部分的土地開發為葡萄園, 並為旗下 Latour Calon Lafite 等品牌開拓倫敦市場 1707 年在 倫敦公報 首次提及它們, 並且迅即成名 1730 年代, 它們更成為首相 Robert Walpole 喜愛的葡萄酒品牌 Ségur 家族擁有 Lafite 至 1784 年, 之後多次易手, 最後在 1868 年收歸 Baron de Rothschild 旗下, 當時大約有 74 公頃的葡萄園,Rothschild 這次收購土地行動更令這片土地聲名鵠起 Château Lafite Rothschild 1953 Pauillac, Premier Cru Classé top shoulder, short capsule reveals vintage branded cork, Mahler-Besse "It is velvety-textured, wonderfully round, and sweet, but so well-delineated and balanced " WA 10/ bottle per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Château Lafite Rothschild 1982 Pauillac, Premier Cru Classé two bottom neck or better, three very top shoulder, one top shoulder, one just below top shoulder, one upper shoulder, one lightly bin-soiled label, two lightly scuffed labels, five corroded capsules, one lightly corroded capsule, three different importers bottles per lot HK$120, ,000 US$16,000-24, Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com

87 Château Lafite Rothschild 1986 Pauillac, Premier Cru Classé bottom neck or better, three different importers "...beautifully defined, still full of energy...it must rank as one of the finest wines from the estate...98." WA 12/ bottles per lot HK$34,000-50,000 US$ Château Lafite Rothschild 1996 Pauillac, Premier Cru Classé Lot 546: three different importers "...may be the biggest, largest-scaled Lafite I have ever tasted... extremely powerful and full-bodied, with remarkable complexity...oozing with extract and richness, yet has managed to preserve its quintessentially elegant personality " WA 4/ bottles per lot HK$46,000-70,000 US$ magnums (1.5L) per lot HK$36,000-55,000 US$ Château Lafite Rothschild 1998 Pauillac, Premier Cru Classé "...close to perfection...the wine is elegant yet profoundly rich, revealing the essence of Lafite's character...the wine is spectacularly layered yet never heavy. The finish is sweet, super-rich, yet impeccably balanced and long...98." WA 4/ bottles per lot HK$24,000-36,000 US$ Château Lafite Rothschild 2000 Pauillac, Premier Cru Classé Lot 549: includes 12-pack original wood case Lot 550: original wood case Lot 551: original wood case with damaged lid "The wine is rich, medium to full-bodied, but has that ethereal elegance and purity that is always Lafite " WA 6/ bottles per lot HK$50,000-75,000 US$ bottles per lot HK$100, ,000 US$13,000-19, bottles per lot HK$100, ,000 US$13,000-19,000 Château Lafite Rothschild 2003 Pauillac, Premier Cru Classé original wood case Parcel: lots 552 & 553 "...extraordinary richness, opulence, power, purity, intensity and viscosity WA 4/ bottles per lot HK$70, ,000 US$ , bottles per lot HK$70, ,000 US$ ,000 Château Lafite Rothschild 1983 (1) very top shoulder, lightly bin-soiled and scuffed label 1990 (1) bottom neck 554 above 2 bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Lots Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com 87

88 Château Latour Some of my fondest wine memories are of drinking bottles of the renowned Château Latour. It is, without a doubt, one of the greatest wine estates in the world. While its history goes well back to the fourteenth century, Latour began to be clearly defined as one of the greatest wine estates in the world in the mid-nineteenth century, and amazingly, It has kept that position for the last 150 years. Their wines, which are known for their power, richness and longevity, are sought after by collectors and wine lovers throughout the world. As Robert M. Parker says of Château Latour in The World s Greatest Wine Estates, The wine produced here has been an impeccable model of consistent excellence, in great, mediocre, and poor vintages. For that reason, many have long considered Latour to be the Médoc s finest wine Latour remains one of the most concentrated, rich, tannic, and full-bodied wines in the world. Jeff Zacharia 我某些最難忘的葡萄酒經歷來自品嚐 Château Latour 的佳釀 它無疑是世上最優秀的酒莊之一 儘管它的歷史可追溯至十四世紀,Latour 為世上最好酒莊之一的名聲是在十九世紀中葉才被明確確認 令人驚訝地, 此地位維持了 150 年 它強勁, 豐富, 持久的酒長久以來一直是世界各地收藏家及葡萄酒愛好者的至愛 如 Robert M. Parker 在 The World s Greatest Wine Estates 所說 無論在偉大, 普通及差勁的年份, 此酒 [Latour] 均表現出優秀的穩定性 故此長久以來 Latour 普遍被認為是 Médoc 區最好的葡萄酒 Latour 一直都是世界上其中一支最集中 最豐富 最高單寧及最厚身的葡萄酒 Château Latour 1953 Pauillac, Premier Cru Classé one just below top shoulder, one upper shoulder, one binsoiled label, one heavily bin-soiled label, lightly corroded capsules bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Château Latour 1959 Pauillac, Premier Cru Classé one bottom neck, two top shoulder, one just below top shoulder, two upper shoulder, one heavily wine-stained label, lightly bin-soiled labels, one wine-stained label, one cut capsule reveals fully branded cork, three lightly oxidized capsules, one with signs of old seepage "A glorious, mammoth wine. It just goes from strength to strength...nose packed with fruit, full-bodied, its extract and sheer power seeming to absorb, partially to disguise its tannic intensity...beautifully developed bouquet, excellent flavour and perfect balance...hhhh(hh)!" MB 12/ bottles per lot HK$60,000-95,000 US$ ,000 Château Latour 1961 Pauillac, Premier Cru Classé one top shoulder, one upper shoulder, one damp-stained label, lightly bin-soiled labels, one wine-stained label, one corroded capsule partially exposing cork, signs of old seepage "...liquid perfection...unquestionably one of the Bordeaux legends of the century! " WA 6/ bottles per lot HK$38,000-55,000 US$ Jeff Zacharia Château Latour 1945 Pauillac, Premier Cru Classé upper-mid shoulder, handwriting on torn and heavily dampstained label, short capsule reveals vintage branded and protruded cork "Full-bodied and brimming over with sweet fruit character, ripe and velvety tannins. Long and succulent finish " WS 8/ bottle per lot HK$16,000-24,000 US$ Château Latour 1982 Pauillac, Premier Cru Classé five bottom neck or better, one very top shoulder, one binsoiled label, one lightly bin-soiled label, two lightly scuffed labels, one loose capsule reveals fully branded cork, two different releases "It is an amazing wine...don t miss it if you are a wine lover " WA 6/ bottles per lot HK$55,000-80,000 US$ ,000 Château Latour 1949 Pauillac, Premier Cru Classé top shoulder, lightly bin-soiled label, heavily torn capsule reveals vintage branded cork, later release "Sweet on the attack, with a rare opulence, a voluptuous texture, full body, terrific freshness, and a chewy, fleshy, succulent finish...98." WA 6/ bottle per lot HK$10,000-15,000 US$ Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com

89 Château Latour 1990 Pauillac, Premier Cru Classé bottom neck or better unless noted Lot 561: one very top shoulder, original wood case Lot 562: two top shoulder, four different importers Lot 563: one very top shoulder, one top shoulder, one just below top shoulder, three lightly damp-stained labels, four with signs of seepage, original wood case with damaged lid Lot 564: damp-stained labels, one lightly torn label, two with signs of old seepage "...plenty of sweet, ripe currant fruitiness, abundant glycerin, and full body " WA 6/ bottles per lot HK$50,000-75,000 US$ bottles per lot HK$50,000-75,000 US$ bottles per lot HK$50,000-75,000 US$ magnums (1.5L) per lot HK$26,000-38,000 US$ Château Latour 1995 Pauillac, Premier Cru Classé three lightly bin-soiled labels, one lightly scuffed label, two different importers The palate is wonderfully fleshy and opulent with velvety, approachable tannins and a long finish WA 11/ bottles per lot HK$19,000-28,000 US$ Château Latour 1996 Pauillac, Premier Cru Classé Lot 566: four lightly scuffed labels, three different importers Lot 567: original wood case Lot 568: two lightly bin-soiled labels, original wood case with damaged lid Lot 569: three bin-soiled labels, four lightly bin-soiled labels, three lightly damp-stained labels, original wood case Lot 570: one lightly scuffed label, two wine-stained labels "...classic Latour at its utmost...pure power that is stunningly balanced giving a generous level of fruit concentration...this is as good as it gets " WA 11/ bottles per lot HK$26,000-38,000 US$ bottles per lot HK$50,000-75,000 US$ bottles per lot HK$50,000-75,000 US$ bottles per lot HK$50,000-75,000 US$ magnums (1.5L) per lot HK$28,000-42,000 US$ Lots Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com 89

90 Lots Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com

91 Château Latour 2000 Pauillac, Premier Cru Classé Lot 571: includes 12-pack original wood case Lots 572 & 573: original wood case Lot 574: original wood case missing lid Parcel: lots 572 & this is one of the best...mind-blowing on the palate, it s an emotional and soulful red JS 4/ bottles per lot HK$30,000-46,000 US$ bottles per lot HK$60,000-95,000 US$ , bottles per lot HK$60,000-95,000 US$ , bottles per lot HK$60,000-95,000 US$ ,000 Château Latour 2003 Pauillac, Premier Cru Classé original wood case Parcel: lots "...very ripe, but not over-ripe, offers great freshness...dense, thick and unctuously textured, this staggering Latour is undeniably the most sumptuous, opulent wine WA 8/ bottles per lot HK$55,000-80,000 US$ , bottles per lot HK$55,000-80,000 US$ , bottles per lot HK$55,000-80,000 US$ ,000 Château Latour 1978 (2) one bottom neck, one very top shoulder, one damp-stained label, one glue-stained label, lightly scuffed labels, one loose capsule capsule reveals fully branded cork, different importers 1983 (1) just below top shoulder, damp-stained and heavily scuffed label, corroded capsule 1985 (3) bottom neck or better, two lightly scuffed labels 578 above 6 bottles per lot HK$13,000-19,000 US$ Château Margaux Perhaps the grandest of the Bordeaux Châteaux, Château Margaux is the epitome of style and refinement. At Château Margaux, one has truly arrived at the heart and soul of Bordeaux, the world s most renowned wine region. For centuries before the French Revolution, the Château was owned by the Lestonnac family. The revolution, though, saw the estate s owners beheaded, and when the heirs were unable to pay the costs of running the Château, Margaux was put up for auction. The successful bidder, the Marquis de la Colonilla, demolished the old Château, and in 1802 work began on the grand Château we know today. The Château was sold several times until it was acquired by the Ginestets, longtime shareholders who finally became sole owners in 1949, with the purchase financed by the sale of their St Emilion property, Clos Fortet. However, First Growth Châteaus are expensive to run, and to finance the operations of the estate, the owner sold off the vineyards of Dufort-Vivens in the 1960s and transferred Cos d Estournel to his sister in Even those moves, though, were not enough, and collapse of the Bordeaux market in the early 1970s forced Ginestet to sell the Château in 1976 to Greek supermarket magnate Andre Mentzelopoulos. A serious oenophile, he was also a major shareholder in the French wine firm, Nicolas. Margaux 酒莊是時尚和精巧的典範, 亦可說是波爾多眾多酒莊中最豪華的一個 若不曾到訪 Margaux 酒莊, 不算是到過世界著名釀酒地波爾多的心臟 法國大革命前幾個世紀, 這個莊園是由 Lestonnac 家族擁有的 法國大革命時,Margaux 酒莊的主人被送上斷頭台, 而他的繼承人又因為財困無力繼續經營莊園, 最終把它出售 Marquis de la Colonilla 在購入 Margaux 後拆毀了舊有的莊園, 於 1802 年開始修建而成今日我們所熟悉的豪華莊園 其後莊園曾數度易手, 在 1949 年由莊園股東之一 Ginestets 購入, 而成為它唯一的主人 之前 Ginestets 已經長期持有莊園的股份, 他們把 Saint Emilion 的物業 Clos Fortet 出售後才籌集到足夠資金購入這座莊園 由於經營一級酒莊的所費不菲, 為資助莊園的運作, 園主在 1960 年出售 Dufort- Vivens 葡萄園, 並於 1971 年把 Cos d Estournel 轉讓給其姊 可惜 1970 年初波爾多經濟衰退導至市場崩潰,Ginestet 被迫於 1976 年出售莊園予希臘超市大王 Andre Mentzelopoulos 他是一位品酒專家, 也是法國葡萄酒公司 Nicolas 的大股東 Château Margaux 1953 Margaux, Premier Cru Classé bottom neck or better, one lightly damp-stained label, two lightly scuffed labels, two lightly wine-stained label, one missing capsule, one heavily torn capsule reveals fully branded cork, two loose capsules reveal fully branded corks, rebouchée au Château en 2001 "Round and opulent, with a velvety texture and gobs of sweet, jammy fruit, this is Château Margaux at its most seductive...98." WA 10/ bottles per lot HK$46,000-65,000 US$ Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com 91

92 Château Margaux 1961 Margaux, Premier Cru Classé just below top shoulder, faded and heavily damp-stained label "Another splendid '61...with a fully evolved bouquet; sweet entry, dry finish, excellent body, fruit and flavour. Great length, still concentrated...sweet, brambly fruit, singed, fragrant; amazingly sweet...hhhhh." MB bottle per lot HK$ US$ Château Margaux 1982 Margaux, Premier Cru Classé bottom neck, scuffed label "Very full-bodied and dense for a Château Margaux, with a slight rusticity to the tannins, it boasts blockbuster power, richness, and impressive aromatics...98." WA 6/ bottle per lot HK$ US$ Château Margaux 1983 Margaux, Premier Cru Classé two top shoulder, one just below top shoulder, one lightly binsoiled label, one lightly marked label, one lightly scuffed label, different importers "The wine is medium to full-bodied, deep, rich, and powerful, with sweet tannins and loads of fruit concentration...96." WA 1/ bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Château Margaux 1990 Margaux, Premier Cru Classé very top shoulder, two lightly bin-soiled labels, one heavily faded label, one lightly nicked label, one lightly scuffed label, two different importers "Round and generous with low acidity, but an opulent, fullbodied richness that is fresh with laser-like precision " WA 6/ bottles per lot HK$16,000-24,000 US$ Château Margaux 1995 Margaux, Premier Cru Classé one lightly nicked label "Full-bodied and thick, yet racy, with masses of tannins and a harmonious structure " WS 1/ bottles per lot HK$20,000-30,000 US$ Château Margaux 1996 Margaux, Premier Cru Classé Lot 585: one loose capsule reveals fully branded cork, original wood case Lot 586: two lightly damp-stained labels, one lightly nicked label, seven lightly scuffed labels, four different importers "...a strong contender for wine of the vintage. It offers everything you desire from this First Growth...This is a Margaux that seems to light up the senses WA 10/ bottles per lot HK$46,000-65,000 US$ bottles per lot HK$46,000-65,000 US$ Château Margaux 2000 Margaux, Premier Cru Classé Lot 587: includes 12-pack original wood case Lot 588: original wood case with damaged lid Lot 589: two lightly scuffed labels, original wood case "...extraordinary seductiveness, complex aromatics, and purity...medium-bodied, with layers of concentration, stunning blue, red, and black fruits intermixed with spring flowers " WA 6/ bottles per lot HK$28,000-42,000 US$ bottles per lot HK$55,000-80,000 US$ , bottles per lot HK$55,000-80,000 US$ ,000 Château Margaux 2003 Margaux, Premier Cru Classé original wood case one lightly scuffed label "...offers extraordinary intensity as well as a surreal delicacy/ lightness. There is riveting freshness to this offering...99." WA 4/ bottles per lot HK$38,000-55,000 US$ Château Margaux 1979 (1) bottom neck, damp-stained label, signs of old seepage 1985 (1) bottom neck, lightly bin-soiled and nicked label 1986 (2) very top shoulder, lightly bin-soiled labels, one marked label 591 above 4 bottles per lot HK$11,000-16,000 US$ Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com

93 Lots 585 & 586 Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com 93

94 Mouton Rothschild While Mouton was always a highly regarded wine, a big change came when in 1922, when the twenty-one-year-old Baron Philippe decided to run the Château full-time. An innovator from the start of his tenure, in 1924 he decided that in order to guarantee quality the entire production would be bottled at the Château, and from 1934 he numbered each bottle released. Also, of course, he started the tradition of works of art on Mouton labels, featuring the famous Carlu ram s head from 1924 to 1926, and since a hiatus from then until 1945, each label has either been designed by a major artist or featured a tribute to a significant event in the Château s history. 正當 Mouton 葡萄酒備受推崇的時候,1922 年, 當時 21 歲的 Baron Philippe 決定全職經營莊園, 這個創意非凡的年青人為莊園帶來了很大的改變 1924 年,Baron Philippe 決定要為莊園生產葡萄酒的品質作出保証 ; 於是自 1934 年起, 每瓶出廠的葡萄酒都配置了一個編號 此外, 他又開始開展 Mouton 酒標的設計工作 ;1924 年至 1926 年間, 莊園採用了著名的 Carlu 公羊的頭作為酒標 不過酒標的設計工作並沒有持續下去, 直至 1945 年才恢復過來 自此以後酒莊的酒標都是由著名藝術家設計, 或是以莊園別具意義的歷史事件作插圖 Château Mouton Rothschild 1959 Pauillac, Deuxième Cru Classé two top shoulder, one just below top shoulder, three uppermid shoulder, two damp-stained labels, five lightly bin-soiled labels, one marked label, three cut capsules reveal fully branded corks, three lightly corroded capsules, three short capsules, two different importers "...one of the greatest Moutons made in the last thirty-five years...astonishingly young and unevolved, with a black/purple color, the wine exhibits a youthful nose of cassis, minerals, and new oak " RP bottles per lot HK$75, ,000 US$ ,000 Château Mouton Rothschild 1982 Pauillac, Premier Cru Classé five bottom neck or better, one very top shoulder, five dampstained labels, one heavily damp-stained label, one scuffed label, one with importer tag adhered to label, two torn capsules, three different importers "The creme de cassis, underlying floral note, full-bodied power, extraordinary purity, multilayered texture, and finish of over a minute are a showcase for what this Château accomplished in " WA 6/ bottles per lot HK$38,000-55,000 US$ Château Mouton Rothschild 1986 Pauillac, Premier Cru Classé Lot 594: two bottom neck or better, three very top shoulder, two lightly bin-soiled labels, one lightly damp-stained label, one lightly torn label, one wine-stained label, four different importers Lot 595: two very top shoulder, seven top shoulder, two just below top shoulder, one upper shoulder, lightly scuffed labels, three slightly protruded corks, two with signs of old seepage, original wood case "It boasts a full body of ultra richness, extraordinary length and beauty and an almost chiseled precision to the quality with fabulous length. It lasts for minutes on the palate " JS 3/ bottles per lot HK$26,000-38,000 US$ bottles per lot HK$60,000-95,000 US$ ,000 Château Mouton Rothschild 1995 Pauillac, Premier Cru Classé five scuffed labels, three different importers "Very beautiful wine. Mouton shows finesse yet richness in this vintage...94." WS bottles per lot HK$22,000-32,000 US$ Château Mouton Rothschild 2000 Pauillac, Premier Cru Classé Lot 597: includes 12-pack original wood case Lots 598 & 599: original wood case Parcel: lots 598 & 599 "A rich, tannic, earthy style, with loads of creme de cassis and floral notes...a full-bodied wine with plenty of coffee, earth, chocolatey notes " WA 6/ bottles per lot HK$60,000-95,000 US$ , bottles per lot HK$120, ,000 US$16,000-24, bottles per lot HK$120, ,000 US$16,000-24,000 Château Mouton Rothschild 1970 (1) upper shoulder, damp-stained and lightly scuffed label 1973 (1) top shoulder, bin-soiled and lightly nicked label, signs of old seepage 1985 (3) two top shoulder, one just below top shoulder, lightly binsoiled and scuffed labels, one nicked label 600 above 5 bottles per lot HK$11,000-16,000 US$ Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com

95 Pétrus Pétrus today is a little over eleven hectares, including five hectares purchased in 1969 from neighboring Château Gazin. The vineyards have clay topsoil and gravelly subsoil, allowing good initial water retention but excellent longer term drainage. The vines are old, around forty to fifty years, planted with ninety percent Merlot and five percent Cabernet Franc. To increase concentration the vines are pruned extensively and a green harvest is performed. At harvest time, nearly two hundred workers pick the grapes at their peak of balance and ripeness. Sometimes up to four passes are needed but if pressed, as in 1982, the entire harvest can be completed in just one day. The grapes are partially destemmed and after a fairly lengthy maceration period, sometimes almost a month, the wine spends twenty months in new oak before being fined (but not filtered) and bottled. Pétrus is a classic example of careful vineyard management and winemaking yet the result leaves evidence of something even greater. These methods combine with exquisite terroir for Merlot to create something that is, in good vintages, not only earth-shatteringly tasty, but distinctive, lending the name Pétrus majesty because of its quality but also its inimitability. Pétrus 莊園現時只約有 11 公頃, 包括 1969 年從毗鄰的 Gazin 酒莊購入的 5 公頃土地 Pétrus 的葡萄園表層的粘土能保持水份 ; 下層的砂礫土則有效排水 雜草有助吸收部份水份, 令土壤不會過於濕潤及減弱葡萄的濃度 葡萄樹樹齡約 40 至 50 年 雖然葡萄酒的混合中不常加入 Cabernet Franc, 莊園內種植的葡萄品種九成是 Merlot, 半成是 Cabernet Franc 為了提升葡萄的濃度及增加採收數量, 必須作相當程度的修剪 到了葡萄的採收期, 差不多需要 200 名工人採摘葡萄, 有時還要經過四重檢查 不過, 如果時間緊迫, 採收速度也可加快, 如在 1982 年, 僅用了一天便完成所有採收 部份葡萄經過適當的泡浸後已被壓碎, 這個過程有時需要長達約一個月之久 然後把它放入新的橡木桶內, 存放約 20 個月後 ( 不過濾, 就可以放入酒瓶內 Pétrus 是一個細心管理及釀製佳釀的典範, 當然它出產的成果往往都超越了這一切 Pétrus 的釀製方法結合了細膩的天然水土環境, 使 Merlot 成熟時能夠產生一種獨特的味道, 正因為它無與倫比的品質, 估且稱它為 Pétrus 至尊 Pétrus 1970 Pomerol one top shoulder, one just below top shoulder, three upper shoulder, one upper-mid shoulder, three nicked labels, two torn labels, one slightly protruded cork, two cut capsules reveal fully branded corks, three lightly oxidized capsules, two different importers "It is a profound Pétrus...unctuously textured and very full-bodied, with extraordinary sweetness and glycerin, and a layered, viscous finish...99." RP bottles per lot HK$60,000-95,000 US$ ,000 Pétrus 1975 Pomerol just below top shoulder, one bin-soiled label, one scuffed label, one torn label, one lightly oxidized and corroded capsule...reveals a youthful, rustic, brutally powerful style...extremely full-bodied, ferociously tannic, but awesomely concentrated WA 2/ bottles per lot HK$22,000-32,000 US$ Pétrus 1985 Pomerol very top shoulder, lightly bin-soiled, scuffed and torn label "At ten years of age, alongside the other first growths, positively opulent, fantastically full of fruit, concentrated mouthfilling...most recently, at 15 years of age, now mature looking, rich, complete...hhhhh." MB bottle per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Pétrus 1989 Pomerol two bottom neck or better, two very top shoulder, three lightly bin-soiled labels, two lightly damp-stained labels, two lightly nicked labels, two different importers It's a giant, yet also sophisticated and reserved...full-bodied, with opulent fruit and a depth of flavor that lasts for minutes on the palate WS 10/ bottles per lot HK$80, ,000 US$10,000-16,000 Pétrus 1998 Pomerol Lot 605: lightly damp-stained labels Lot 606: original wood case "...a virtually perfect Pétrus...enormous, with huge volume, an unctuous texture, sensational concentration, and a closed, muscular style...98." WA 4/ bottles per lot HK$65,000-95,000 US$ , magnums (1.5L) per lot HK$95, ,000 US$12,000-18,000 Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com 95

96 Château d Yquem Château d Yquem is the apex qualitatively and the centre geographically of the Sauternes area. Each major property occupies its own little hill. Yquem s is the highest. It is also the largest estate, the most perfectionistic, the most consistent. Unlike the rest of the region there was no cutting of corners, no lack of investment, no dip in quality in the sad days of the 1960s and 1970s. There is something very special, and indeed very consistent, about Yquem. The wine is more oaky than most in its youth. It is by quite some way the richest, most concentrated, most intense wine of its kind. In great years I have a marginal preference for 1989 over 1990 and 1988 it is nectar: the liquid quintessence of concentrated sunbeams, to quote Thomas Love Peacock. Clive Coates, The Wines of Bordeaux (2004) 無論從面積 產品質素和穩定性來說, 伊甘酒莊都稱得上是法國甜酒名鄉索泰爾納的王者 酒莊也是該地的頂尖地標, 莊內每個建築物各自雄踞山頭, 與區內經過 年代經濟低迷洗禮的混亂道路規劃和缺乏投資相比, 進入伊甘酒莊, 彷如進入了另一個世界 關於伊甘, 還有一樣非常特別而始終如一之處, 就是愈年輕的酒, 散發的橡木香愈濃郁, 這是該種酒最豐富 最濃縮 最強烈的形態 以最佳的幾個年份而言, 我個人偏好 1989 年多於 1990 和 1988 英國文學家皮考克的詩恰好可以形容它 : 將太陽光芒的精髓化成液體 Clive Coates, The Wines of Bordeaux (2004) Lot Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com

97 Château d Yquem 1959 Sauternes, Premier Cru Supérieur bottom neck or better, one with writing on label, one binsoiled label, one heavily bin-soiled label, one lightly scuffed label, one scuffed label, one torn label "Classic, exciting Yquem. Silky, creamy and round...fullbodied, with caramel and butterscotch complexity, it ends on a very intense finish...97." WS 5/ bottles per lot HK$14,000-20,000 US$ Château d Yquem 1975 Sauternes, Premier Cru Supérieur Lot 608: three very top shoulder, one top shoulder, bin-soiled labels, lightly oxidized capsules Lot 609: two bottom neck or better, one very top shoulder, two top shoulder, one just below top shoulder, bin-soiled labels "The palate is pure and detailed with a killer line of acidity, vibrant honeyed fruit and a mellifluous finish that is now fully expressive...simply magnificent...98." WA 6/ half-bottles (375ml) per lot HK$ ,000 US$ bottles per lot HK$22,000-32,000 US$ Château d Yquem bottom neck or better 1983 half-bottles (4) lightly bin-soiled and scuffed labels, two slightly depressed corks 1983 (2) 610 above 4 half-bottles (375ml) & 2 bottles per lot HK$ US$ Château d Yquem bottom neck or better, bin-soiled labels 1990 half-bottles (2) 1990 (4) one lightly damp-stained label, one scuffed label, one with cardboard adhered to label, two different importers 611 above 2 half-bottles (375ml) & 4 bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Château d Yquem 2001 Sauternes, Premier Cru Supérieur two 6-pack original wood cases "This large-scaled, youthful Yquem appears set to take its place among the most legendary vintages of the past " WA 4/ bottles per lot HK$36,000-55,000 US$ Château d Yquem 1988 (2) bottom neck or better, lightly bin-soiled labels 1989 half-bottles (2) bottom neck, lightly damp-stained labels 1989 (1) bottom neck, lightly bin-soiled label 1991 half-bottle (1) bin-soiled label 1995 half-bottle (1) bin-soiled label 613 above 4 half-bottles (375ml) & 3 bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Château Climens 1950 (1) top shoulder, nicked, lightly bin-soiled and scuffed label 1952 (1) bottom neck, bin-soiled, nicked and scuffed label, short capsule reveals branded cork 1962 (1) very top shoulder, bin-soiled and torn label, short capsule reveals branded cork 614 above 3 bottles per lot HK$ US$ Château Doisy Daëne L'Extravagant 1996 Sauternes, Deuxième Cru Classé It boasts a deep gold color, in addition to an unctuous texture, fabulous freshness, and notes of grapefruit and subtle oak...a huge wine, with lots of acidity and little mass and volume, this tour de force in wine making WA 4/ half-bottles (375ml) per lot HK$11,000-16,000 US$ Château Doisy Daëne L'Extravagant 1997 Sauternes, Deuxième Cru Classé lightly bin-soiled labels It is a triumph in wine making, and will undoubtedly last years WA 4/ half-bottles (375ml) per lot HK$11,000-16,000 US$ Château Doisy Daëne L'Extravagant 2001 Sauternes, Deuxième Cru Classé "Full-bodied, thick and powerful, with amazing richness and spiciness. It goes on and on and on. The concentration is phenomenal, yet it s lively and spicy. Huge finish " WS 6/ half-bottles (375ml) per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Château Suduiraut 1959 Sauternes, Premier Cru Classé bottom neck or better, one bin-soiled label, three lightly binsoiled labels, scuffed labels, three with signs of old seepage bottles per lot HK$ US$ Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com 97

98 Lots red red Burgundy Burgundy Burgundy Dujac This domaine was founded in 1968 by Jacques Seysses and currently comprises approximately fifteen hectares. Winemakers Jeremy and Diana Seysses have been at the helm of the Domaine since They believe that the success of their wines lie in the team effort at the Domaine from their Chef de Culture in the vineyard, Lilian Robin, to Jeremy s brother, Alec, and father, Jacques, who contribute in the cellar. In 2009, the Domaine began its conversion to total biodynamic farming practices. The Domaine chooses to emphasize intensity over power and prides itself on producing individualistic wines that are elegant, delicate, and complex. 這酒莊由 Jacques Seysses 於 1968 年所創立, 時至今日, 它佔地約 15 公頃 釀酒師 Jeremy Seysses 及 Diana Seysses 自 2001 年起成為了酒莊的掌舵人 他們堅信, 他們所釀造的佳釀之所以獲得空前成功, 全賴整個酒莊上下的努力, 包括葡萄園總監 (Chef de Culture) Lilian Robin Jeremy 的兄弟 Alec, 父親 Jacques 及所有對酒莊用心盡力的每一員 酒莊於 2009 年開始全面採用生物動力種植方式 它同時強調其出品佳釀雄渾濃郁, 而非單單只談力度 ; 它自翊所出品的葡萄酒高雅細緻, 複雜且富層次 Clos St Denis Dujac cm, nicked, damp-stained and lightly marked label, signs of old seepage "...the complexity and focus are such that this is really a fine effort...93." BH 6/ bottle per lot HK$24,000-36,000 US$ Clos de la Roche Dujac 1985 Lot 621: 2.5cm, damp-stained label Lot 622: one 2cm, one 3cm, wine-stained labels, one loose capsule reveals fully branded cork, different importers "Magnificent nose and flavors possessing superb complexity, finesse and outstanding length...92." BH 12/ half-bottle (375ml) per lot HK$11,000-16,000 US$ bottles per lot HK$38,000-55,000 US$ Clos St Denis Dujac cm "...a study in finesse and understatement. Very pretty and I can't help but admire the perfect harmony..." BH 1/ bottle per lot HK$12,000-19,000 US$ Clos de la Roche Dujac 1978 one 3cm, one 4.5cm, heavily damp-stained labels, one nicked label, one wine-stained label "...youthful, rich, delicious, highly complex flavors deliver plenty of depth and length plus that indescribable element of class...94." BH 11/ bottles per lot HK$30,000-46,000 US$ Clos de la Roche Dujac 1988 one 3.5cm, one 5cm, one lightly torn label, one lightly winestained label, one wine-stained label, one torn capsule, one with signs of old seepage bottles per lot HK$11,000-16,000 US$ Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com

99 Bonnes-Mares Dujac cm or better, lightly bin-soiled labels, different importers "...admirably complex...delicious, rich and mouth coating... both satisfying and impeccably well-balanced...93." BH 3/ bottles per lot HK$24,000-36,000 US$ Chambolle-Musigny Les Gruenchers Dujac 1990 Côte de Nuits, Premier Cru two 1.5cm or better, two 2.5cm, nicked and lightly bin-soiled labels, two different importers bottles per lot HK$11,000-16,000 US$ Clos de la Roche Dujac 1990 three 2cm or better, five 2.5cm, one bin-soiled label, one damp-stained label, two scuffed labels, one loose capsule reveals fully branded cork, three different importers "...absolutely stunning with soaring aromatics...a fine sense of elegance and finishing punch...94." BH 7/ bottles per lot HK$110, ,000 US$14,000-20,000 Echézeaux Dujac 1990 one 2cm, two 2.5cm, two 3cm, three 3.5cm, one 4cm, three slightly depressed corks, two different importers "...rich, powerful and still moderately structured medium full flavors underpinned by still firm but softening tannins and excellent length...91." BH 11/ bottles per lot HK$75, ,000 US$ ,000 Bonnes-Mares Dujac 1993 one 1cm, one 2cm, one lightly wine-stained label "An explosive, extremely complex and high-toned nose...long, velvety and impressively complex finish...92." BH 12/ bottles per lot HK$15,000-22,000 US$ Clos de la Roche Dujac 1993 lightly scuffed labels "...one of those rare grands crus that has shown magnificently from day one and has never missed a beat since...pure, intense, terrifically long finish...93." BH 10/ bottles per lot HK$32,000-50,000 US$ Clos St Denis Dujac cm or better, lightly bin-soiled and nicked labels "...aromatic elegance and purity...nothing short of sensational as is the dramatic complexity; this can be enjoyed merely on the nose alone...91." BH 10/ bottles per lot HK$12,000-19,000 US$ Bonnes-Mares Dujac 1996 lightly bin-soiled labels, different importers "Big and robust yet remarkably elegant...rich, pure, detailed, gorgeously intense flavors of considerable distinction and excellent length..." BH 5/ bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Clos de la Roche Dujac 1996 one bin-soiled label, one lightly bin-soiled label, two lightly scuffed labels, three different importers, one with signs of old seepage "...round yet focused flavors offering excellent depth and length. This has everything it needs to be great and should age effortlessly...92." BH 5/ bottles per lot HK$55,000-80,000 US$ ,000 Clos de la Roche Dujac 1997 one damp-stained label, two different importers "...combines Dujac's trademark elegance with power, density, and jammy, super-ripe flavors...medium to full-bodied, complex, and mouth-coating offering...93." WA 10/ bottles per lot HK$19,000-28,000 US$ Chambolle-Musigny Les Gruenchers Dujac 1999 Côte de Nuits, Premier Cru one lightly bin-soiled label, one lightly marked label, two different importers "Incredibly complex nose...the inner density here is terrific. Absolutely first rate..." BH 1/ bottles per lot HK$12,000-19,000 US$ Clos de la Roche Dujac 1999 two lightly bin-soiled labels, two lightly nicked labels, one lightly scuffed label, two different importers "Slightly austere with a mineral essence that tends to suppress the pinot baby fat lurking beneath the surface. The potential here is enormous...93." BH 2/ bottles per lot HK$36,000-55,000 US$ Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com 99

100 Chambolle-Musigny Les Gruenchers Dujac 2001 Côte de Nuits, Premier Cru bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Bonnes-Mares Dujac 2002 "...intensely powerful, delicious, lush, full-bodied, perfumed, meltingly seductive flavors that are gorgeously textured and incredibly sappy...a real stunner of a wine...93." BH 1/ bottles per lot HK$26,000-38,000 US$ Charmes-Chambertin Dujac 2002 one lightly bin-soiled label "...superb depth of material and solid density, all supported by buried tannins that are completely wrapped in sappy extract. A beautifully elegant yet altogether serious effort that also finishes with a touch of warmth and a very subtle hint of wood...92." BH 1/ bottles per lot HK$22,000-32,000 US$ Clos de la Roche Dujac 2002 Lot 640: one lightly bin-soiled label, one lightly scuffed label, one lightly wine-stained vintage tag Lot 641: one lightly scuffed label, one scuffed label "Utterly captivating...impressively concentrated and powerfully structured, but also a wine of great finesse and sex appeal " IWC 3/ bottles per lot HK$42,000-60,000 US$ bottles per lot HK$55,000-80,000 US$ ,000 Clos St Denis Dujac 2002 "Not at all a weighty style but not flimsy either. Sweeter and silkier than usual for this wine at this early stage. Finishes with terrific subtle length " IWC 3/ bottles per lot HK$26,000-38,000 US$ Chambolle-Musigny Les Gruenchers Dujac 2005 Côte de Nuits, Premier Cru "...rich, full and ripe flavors that are textured, sweet and firmly structured on the mineral-inflected finish...91." BH 1/ bottles per lot HK$11,000-16,000 US$ Clos St Denis Dujac 2005 two scuffed labels "...concentrated, pure and detailed flavors wrapped in a wonderfully intense, balanced and strikingly long finish. This oozes class and refinement...96." BH 1/ bottles per lot HK$55,000-80,000 US$ ,000 Clos de la Roche Dujac 2005 two lightly bin-soiled labels Lot 646: two lightly scuffed labels "...focused, intense, vibrant and well-muscled full-bodied flavors that carry ample authority and punch on the complex, broad and superbly long finish...95." BH 1/ bottles per lot HK$46,000-70,000 US$ bottles per lot HK$50,000-75,000 US$ Echézeaux Dujac 2005 three lightly bin-soiled labels, one lightly nicked label "...ripe black fruit aromas that continue onto the silky and seductively round and velvety flavors " BH 1/ bottles per lot HK$26,000-38,000 US$ Gevrey-Chambertin Aux Combottes Dujac 2005 Côte de Nuits, Premier Cru one lightly marked label "...wonderfully expressive...sweet, delicious, rich, detailed and altogether serious, packing good punch and energy into a finish that is all grace and harmony " BH 1/ bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Echézeaux Dujac 2002 "Intense, extremely expressive...outstanding density and unusually silky tannins plus a certain seductive quality to the subtly complex and persistent finish " BH 1/ bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Romanée-St-Vivant Dujac Fils et Père 2005 one lightly marked label "A sensationally broad and expressive...built on finesse and refinement, not punch yet the sense of harmony and poise is nothing short of remarkable...95." BH 1/ bottles per lot HK$28,000-42,000 US$ Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com

101 Lots 640 & 641, 646 & 647 Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com 101

102 Romanée-St-Vivant Dujac 2006 "...the sheer class this exudes propels this to the front of the class, particularly on the hugely long and mouth coating finish " BH 1/ bottles per lot HK$24,000-36,000 US$ Chambertin Dujac 2007 "Don't miss!...precise, intense and driving medium full flavors that possess simply terrific length and vibrancy " BH 1/ bottles per lot HK$24,000-36,000 US$ Romanée-St-Vivant Dujac 2008 Lot 653: one lightly bin-soiled label "Boasts a silky, utterly palate-staining texture with extraordinary energy and grip...great class, and the mounting finish of spices and flowers goes on and on " IWC 3/ bottles per lot HK$15,000-22,000 US$ bottles per lot HK$60,000-95,000 US$ ,000 Clos St Denis Dujac 2009 one lightly bin-soiled label "The Clos St Denis is the epitome of weightless elegance. Dark raspberries, flowers and sweet spices wrap around the eternal finish...96." WA 4/ bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Echézeaux Dujac 2009 two different importers "...a weightless expression of grace and class...gorgeous inner fragrance and impossibly fine tannins are first-rate " WA 5/ bottles per lot HK$19,000-28,000 US$ Romanée-St-Vivant Dujac 2009 one lightly scuffed label "...can be slow out of the gate, but once it starts blossoming in bottle it is truly majestic. Readers lucky enough to find the 2009 are in for a treat...97." WA 4/ bottles per lot HK$34,000-50,000 US$ Vosne-Romanée Aux Malconsorts Dujac 2008 Côte de Nuits, Premier Cru "...absolutely complete and ethereal wine...deep and very intensely flavored, with a svelte profile, a fine core of fruit, tangy acids and wonderful length...94." JBG 1/ bottles per lot HK$19,000-28,000 US$ Chambertin Dujac 2009 one scuffed label "...flat-out stunning. It boasts gorgeous textural finesse and sheer energy...combines power and finesse...pure sophistication...98." WA 4/ bottles per lot HK$32,000-50,000 US$ Dujac Morey St Denis 1978 (2) one 3cm, one 3.5cm, one damp-stained label, one winestained label, one with signs of old seepage Chambolle-Musigny Les Gruenchers 1985 (2) 3cm, one damp-stained label, one nicked label, one winestained label Chambolle-Musigny Les Gruenchers 2002 (2) one scuffed label Chambolle-Musigny Les Gruenchers 2004 (5) Gevrey-Chambertin Aux Combottes 2005 (2) one lightly marked label Chambolle-Musigny Les Gruenchers 2006 (2) one lightly scuffed label 661 above 15 bottles per lot HK$19,000-28,000 US$ Clos de la Roche Dujac 2009 three lightly bin-soiled labels "...very pure and classy...deep, fullish, pure and complex... intensely flavored and beautifully focused finish " JBG 11/ bottles per lot HK$26,000-38,000 US$ Dujac Clos St Denis 1996 (1) Echézeaux 1999 (1) Clos de la Roche 2001 (1) Clos de la Roche 2009 (1) scuffed label 662 above 4 bottles per lot HK$13,000-19,000 US$ Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com

103 Roty Since 1710 the family has been based in Gevrey. The current reputation of Domaine Joseph Roty was down to Joseph himself, not just the comments of Remington and Clive, but also the quality of domaine s highly sought-after wines, wines mainly produced from old and in some cases some very, very old vines très vieilles vignes if you prefer! Joseph started the core of today s domaine in the late 1960s with vines that came from his grandfather, vines that included Mazy (they spell like Rousseau), Griotte and Charmes-Chambertin Grand Crus. Joseph was lost to this world in 2008, and although widow Roty still works behind the scenes, it is the sons of Joseph Philippe and Pierre-Jean the elventh generation at this family domaine that do the heavy stuff while a twelfth generation are playing in the yard. Philippe had anyway being working progressively more with his father since about 1990 there is very little that has been changed. Bill Nanson Charmes-Chambertin Cuvée Trés Vieilles Vignes Joseph Roty cm, tape adhered to heavily wine-stained labels, one with Denmark tax tag adhered to capsule "...dramatically powerful, beautifully textured, indeed even opulent and velvety flavors...92." BH 11/ bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Mazis-Chambertin Joseph Roty 1985 two 2.5cm, two 3cm, two bin-soiled labels, one faded label, two heavily bin-soiled labels, one heavily damp-stained label, one torn label, wine-stained labels, one with tape adhered to label, one torn capsule, two different importers, one with signs of old seepage bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Mazis-Chambertin Joseph Roty cm or better, one lightly torn label, two nicked labels, winestained labels, one loose capsule reveals producer branded cork bottles per lot HK$11,000-16,000 US$ Charmes-Chambertin Cuvée Trés Vieilles Vignes Joseph Roty 1990 eleven 1.5cm or better, one 2.5cm, bin-soiled and wine-stained labels, four different importers bottles per lot HK$42,000-60,000 US$ Mazis-Chambertin Joseph Roty 1993 lightly bin-soiled and scuffed labels, one lightly torn label, one wine-stained label, two different importers, two with signs of old seepage bottles per lot HK$24,000-36,000 US$ Charmes-Chambertin Cuvée Trés Vieilles Vignes Joseph Roty 1996 one heavily torn label, one lightly scuffed label, two different importers "This is superbly classy juice...it gives a seductively textural impact on the palate...94." BH 10/ bottles per lot HK$16,000-24,000 US$ Charmes-Chambertin Cuvée Trés Vieilles Vignes Joseph Roty 1999 one bin-soiled label, two different importers, one with signs of old seepage "...extraordinarily concentrated, powerful, and chewy-textured...extremely expressive and last throughout its unbelievably long, thick, and sweet finish " WA 8/ bottles per lot HK$22,000-32,000 US$ Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com 103

104 Griotte-Chambertin Joseph Roty 1999 lightly bin-soiled labels, three lightly scuffed labels "Massive aromas...this comes across as pure extract of pinot with a finish that I could remember that next day...95." BH 1/ bottles per lot HK$10,000-15,000 US$ Mazis-Chambertin Joseph Roty 1999 one lightly torn label "Knockout aromas...big-bodied, amazingly intense, earthy flavors and a long, relatively muscular finish that displays budding complexity...92." BH 1/ bottles per lot HK$11,000-16,000 US$ Charmes-Chambertin Cuvée Trés Vieilles Vignes Joseph Roty 2002 "The powerful, indeed forceful flavors coat and stain the palate...flat out incredible juice and worth a special search to find...95." BH 1/ bottles per lot HK$19,000-28,000 US$ Griotte-Chambertin Joseph Roty bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Mazis-Chambertin Joseph Roty 2002 one marked label bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Charmes-Chambertin Cuvée Trés Vieilles Vignes Joseph Roty 2005 Lot 676: one with signs of old seepage "...with uncanny intensity and clarity...a dark and rising tide of mineral and carnal flavors meets the fruit and spice in a thunderous finish " WA 4/ bottles per lot HK$26,000-38,000 US$ bottles per lot HK$26,000-38,000 US$ Mazis-Chambertin Joseph Roty 2005 "...palate-staining crystalline black raspberry fruit, licorice and meaty pan scrapings, an abundance of exceedingly fine tannin, and a clear, poised finish " WA 4/ bottles per lot HK$22,000-32,000 US$ Charmes-Chambertin Cuvée Trés Vieilles Vignes Joseph Roty 2009 "...strikingly pure and refined...deep, full-bodied and pure and plush on the attack...vibrant, focused and very young finish " JBG 6/ bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Charmes-Chambertin Cuvée Trés Vieilles Vignes Joseph Roty 2010 "...massively long and impeccably well-balanced...in short, this is a stunner of a wine and if you can find it buy it " BH 1/ bottles per lot HK$10,000-15,000 US$ Joseph Roty Charmes-Chambertin Cuvée Trés Vieilles Vignes 1991 (2) one bin-soiled label, one damp-stained label, one winestained label Charmes-Chambertin Cuvée Trés Vieilles Vignes 1993 (1) wine-stained and lightly torn label, signs of old seepage Griotte-Chambertin 1993 (2) one lightly bin-soiled label, one nicked label, one winestained label Mazis-Chambertin 1996 (3) one lightly bin-soiled label, one lightly nicked label, one lightly scuffed label Mazis-Chambertin 1998 (2) one torn label 680 above 10 bottles per lot HK$20,000-30,000 US$ Joseph Roty Charmes-Chambertin Cuvée Trés Vieilles Vignes 2005 (1) Griotte-Chambertin 2010 (2) Mazis-Chambertin 2010 (4) 681 above 7 bottles per lot HK$12,000-19,000 US$ Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com

105 Lots 675 & 676 Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com 105

106 Rouget Emmanuel began working with his uncle Henri (that s Henri Jayer of course) in the early 1980s. From 1985 he began releasing wines under his own label. He worked closely with his Henri Jayer until his passing and today has taken over much of the Henri Jayer portfolio including making the wines for Henri s brother, George. Rouget follows pretty closely the methods used by his late uncle, these include; two sortings of grapes (one in the vineyard and one in the cellars), cold pre-fermentation, 100 percent new oak and of course incredible attention to detail from vineyard to bottle. Needless to say Emmanuel has developed into a very serious winemaker over the years and today stands well and truly among the elite of Burgundy. No serious cellar is complete without them. Echézeaux Emmanuel Rouget cm, bin-soiled and marked label, corroded capsule, signs of old seepage bottle per lot HK$ US$ Vosne-Romanée Cros Parantoux Emmanuel Rouget 1989 Côte de Nuits, Premier Cru one 2cm, one 3cm, marked and lightly wine-stained labels, one scuffed label, wine-stained vintage tags, one corroded capsule, signs of old seepage bottles per lot HK$24,000-36,000 US$ Vosne-Romanée Les Beaumonts Emmanuel Rouget 1990 Côte de Nuits, Premier Cru 2cm or better, one damp-stained label, two lightly dampstained labels, one nicked label, one cut capsule reveals fully branded cork bottles per lot HK$20,000-30,000 US$ Echézeaux Emmanuel Rouget 1993 marked and lightly damp-stained labels, cut capsules reveals fully branded corks "Stunning from start to finish, seamless in its silky texture, exotic...sensational...95." WS 5/ bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Vosne-Romanée Cros Parantoux Emmanuel Rouget 1993 Côte de Nuits, Premier Cru bin-soiled labels, one with importer tag adhered to label, one cut capsule reveals fully branded cork, two loose capsules, two different importers ''Racy, sleek Premier Cru, showing digital definition in every aspect of its flavor components...very long, focused finish...95." WS 5/ bottles per lot HK$28,000-42,000 US$ Echézeaux Emmanuel Rouget 1996 two marked labels, two cut capsules reveal fully branded corks "...a full-bodied, velvety-textured, and immensely refined wine...magnificently proportioned, balanced...complex, concentrated and pure personality " WA 2/ bottles per lot HK$12,000-19,000 US$ Vosne-Romanée Cros Parantoux Emmanuel Rouget 1996 Côte de Nuits, Premier Cru one lightly scuffed label, one torn label, one wine-stained label, cut capsules reveal fully branded corks "...ever-so-slightly austere but the intensity and purity are notable with first class elegance, superb detail and a driving, intense and relatively powerful finish...94." BH 7/ bottles per lot HK$16,000-24,000 US$ Vosne-Romanée Cros Parantoux Emmanuel Rouget 1999 Côte de Nuits, Premier Cru one lightly bin-soiled label Lot 689: one lightly nicked label, two wine-stained labels, three different importers Lot 690: loose capsules reveals vintage branded corks "...round, sexy, seductive, earthy, nicely rich and detailed flavors of excellent intensity and fine length..." BH 4/ bottles per lot HK$130, ,000 US$17,000-24, bottles per lot HK$20,000-30,000 US$ Echézeaux Emmanuel Rouget 1999 wine-stained labels, two with signs of old seepage "...round, sexy, seductive, earthy, nicely rich and detailed flavors of excellent intensity and fine length...94." BH 12/ bottles per lot HK$26,000-38,000 US$ Vosne-Romanée Emmanuel Rouget 1996 (1) lightly bin-soiled and scuffed label Les Beaumonts 1996 (1) establishment Riedel stamp on lightly nicked and winestained label, loose capsule reveals vintage branded cork 2005 (6) 692 above 8 bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ ZACHYS tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com

107 Georges Roumier The domaine was enlarged a number of times since its inception in 1924, with Georges acquiring a bit more Bonnes-Mares in 1952, as well as two parcels of Clos Vougeot in the same year. In 1953 the Roumiers also purchased the monopole Premier Cru Morey St Denis Clos de la Bussierre. In 1968, Jean-Marie s wife, Odile Ponnelle, purchased a tract of unplanted Corton-Charlemagne, which was subsequently committed to vine and the first Roumier Corton-Charlemagne was released in the 1974 vintage. In 1978 the domaine finally purchased the small slice of Musigny that they had been sharecropping since the mid-1920s. Domaine Georges Roumier is one of my favorite domaines in all of the Côte d Or. In my personal cellar, by quite some margin, I have more Roumier wines than from any other producer. I find them to be extremely reliable for cellaring, and to deliver at their apogees all the majestic complexity for which Burgundy is rightly renowned. Out of the blocks they are not the typically delicate style of Chambolle, but rather wines that are full and well-structured in their youth. For young Chambolles they are atypical, but within the fullness of time, they develop all the silk and perfume for which the wines of this village are so rightly cherished. From the superbly-crafted Chambolle-Musigny village bottling that I buy in depth in every vintage to the lonely bottle of Roumier Musigny, these are among the greatest wines that I have in my cellar, and bottles that I look forward to growing old with comfortably. John Gilman, View From the Cellar 酒莊自 1924 年成立以來, 多次擴張版圖, 包括 1952 年 Georges 增加在 Bonnes-Mares 擁有的面積, 以及在同年買下兩塊 Clos Vougeot 土地 1953 年,Roumier 家族亦買入 Morey St Denis 的一級獨佔園 (monopole Premier Cru) Clos de la Bussierre 1968 年,Jean-Marie 的妻子 Odile Ponnelle 買下部份未開墾的 Corton-Charlemagne 土地, 並開始栽種葡萄, 因此 Roumier 第一瓶 Corton-Charlemagne 就在 1974 年面世 直至 1978 年, 酒莊終於買入一小塊由 1920 年代中期開始已經以分成制 (sharecropping) 耕作的 Musigny 土地 Georges Roumier 是眾多黃金丘 (Côte d Or) 酒莊中, 我最喜愛之一 我的私人酒窖中,Roumier 葡萄酒的數量, 遠遠超過其他酒莊 我認為他們非常適合窖藏, 而且在最頂峰的時候, 盡顯布根地享譽盛名的非凡複雜性 他們從最初開始, 已有別於 Chambolle 的經典風格 - 年輕時豐富而且結構出色 雖然年輕時不是經典的 Chambolle, 但隨著時間過去, 他們展現出這村莊的葡萄酒為人喜愛的香氣和柔順口感 無論是我每個年份都有收藏 以精湛工藝釀造的 Chambolle-Musigny 村酒, 抑或是孤芳自賞的 Roumier Musigny, 都是我酒窖中的極品珍藏, 亦是我迎接光輝歲月的好知己 John Gilman 曾於 «View From the Cellar» 提及 Chambolle-Musigny Amoureuses Georges Roumier 1996 Côte de Nuits, Premier Cru one lightly nicked label, one loose capsule reveals fully branded cork "Superbly rich and complex fruit that explodes from the glass with elegant and stunning purity...93." BH 7/ bottles per lot HK$19,000-28,000 US$ Bonnes-Mares Georges Roumier 1999 three lightly marked labels, one loose capsule reveals fully branded cork "...rich, broad, and expansive...silky-textured and leads to a long, black pepper-filled finish..." WA 8/ bottles per lot HK$85, ,000 US$11,000-17,000 Chambolle-Musigny Amoureuses Georges Roumier 2000 Côte de Nuits, Premier Cru "Pure silk with incredibly textured flavors. Seductive, sexy, beautifully complex...compelling, pungent, driving flavors and a long, pure finish..." BH 1/ bottle per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Bonnes-Mares Georges Roumier 2002 "A complete and seamless wine of enormous complexity and considerable underlying reserve...95." BH 4/ bottles per lot HK$70, ,000 US$ ,000 Chambolle-Musigny Les Cras Georges Roumier 2005 Côte de Nuits, Premier Cru "...complex aromas...rich and intensely mineral-inflected medium full flavors that carry wonderful sense of underlying tension that focuses the precise and explosive finish " BH 1/ bottles per lot HK$13,000-19,000 US$ Morey St Denis Clos de la Bussière Georges Roumier 2005 Côte de Nuits, Premier Cru "A very fresh and unusually bright...rich, full and admirably intense flavors that are at once powerful yet supple, all wrapped in a punchy and more complex and minerally finish...91." BH 1/ bottles per lot HK$12,000-19,000 US$ Bonnes-Mares Georges Roumier 2009 "All the elements are in the right place in this extraordinary, moving wine " WA 4/ bottles per lot HK$13,000-19,000 US$ Georges Roumier Morey St Denis Clos de la Bussière 1978 (1) 4.5cm, bin-soiled and lightly wine-stained label Chambolle-Musigny Les Cras 1996 (2) Morey St Denis Clos de la Bussière 1996 (3) nicked labels, two wine-stained labels, signs of old seepage 700 above 6 bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ NO LOT Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com 107

108 Rousseau One will get little argument to the assertion that Domaine Armand Rousseau is the finest estate in Gevrey-Chambertin... The vintages of the 1980s and 1990s at Domaine Rousseau have produced one of the greatest runs of profound Burgundy ever witnessed by any estate in the region, with the domaine producing legendary efforts in the widely recognized great years of the span from 1985 to Their two flagship bottlings of Chambertin and Chambertin Clos de Bèze have always ranked amongst the top dozen wines to be found in these vintages. However, what it generally not known is how brilliant the Rousseau wines have been in the more difficult vintages of this stretch, such as 1986, 1987, 1992, 1998 and 2000, where the wines have delivered astonishing quality for their respective vintages, and are amongst the great sleepers to be found. The size and dimension of the lesser years may not quite match the great vintages, but the complexity, breed and suave refinement that are the hallmarks of Domaine Rousseau wines are to be found in every one of these wines. Of the two Grand Crus at the pinnacle of the brilliant portfolio of Rousseau wines, the Chambertin Clos de Bèze tends to be the more exotic and spicy of the two wines, with glorious fruit tones of black cherry, plum, blood orange often augmented by notes of Gevrey s grilled meat, chocolate and exotic spices. The Chambertin is typically the slightly slower wine to unfold, with a more understated profile of plum, red cherry and strawberry, coupled with notes of cocoa powder, coffee, grilled meats and violets. Both are full-bodied wines which are raised in one hundred percent new oak, but always impeccably balanced, tangy and never come across as over-oaked. They are amongst the very greatest red wines to be found in the world. John Gilman, View From the Cellar Domaine Armand Rousseau 被認為是 Gevrey-Chambertin 區的最佳酒莊, 這個說法可能會惹來小小的爭議在 1980 和 1990 年代中,Domaine Rousseau 所釀製的年份葡萄酒是這區域中最佳的葡萄酒之一, 它能彰顯出布根地 (Burgundy) 深邃的韻味, 特別是 1985 至 1999 年的年份葡萄酒, 最受推崇, 堪稱經典 其中兩個旗艦產品 Chambertin 和 Chambertin Clos de Bèze, 更在 年間, 經常被評為 12 大之一 其實,Rousseau 叫人欽佩之處, 就是在次要 差劣的年份, 例如 : 和 2000 年份, 也能釀製出叫人充滿驚喜的葡萄酒 雖然次要年份葡萄酒與上佳年份葡萄酒, 不可同日而語, 但其複雜性 優雅風格等, 均不失 Domaine Rousseau 的特性 Rousseau 的兩隻 Grand Crus, 盡顯其登峰造極的造詣 ;Chambertin Clos de Bèze 更見奇特動人之處和充滿香料氣息, 帶有黑櫻桃 梅子 橘子味道之餘, 還有 Gevrey 烤肉 朱古力和香料的韻味, 加強了其口感味道 Chambertin 是典型的 慢熱 型葡萄酒, 帶有梅子 紅櫻桃 草莓的味道, 還混雜了可可粉 咖啡 烤肉和紫羅蘭的氣息 由於採用 100% 新橡木, 令兩者口感均十分豐潤, 但有很好的平衡 香氣撲鼻, 卻又不會予人橡木味過重的感覺 可以說, 它們是世界上最偉大的紅酒之一 John Gilman, View From the Cellar Chambertin Armand Rousseau cm, bin-soiled label, slightly protruded cork bottle per lot HK$32,000-50,000 US$ Chambertin Armand Rousseau 1985 one 1.5cm, one 2cm, one 2.5cm, lightly bin-soiled labels, two lightly damp-stained labels, two lightly nicked labels, one cut capsule reveals fully branded cork, one lightly corroded capsule...medium depth, lovely colour, mature rim; excellent bouquet; magical, highly sensitive fruit, elegant, perfect condition. Class act...hhhhh. MB 8/ bottles per lot HK$70, ,000 US$ ,000 Chambertin Armand Rousseau cm, damp-stained label Bigger, richer and with better intensity plus a bit more midpalate depth and weight BH 7/ bottle per lot HK$10,000-15,000 US$ Chambertin Armand Rousseau cm or better, damp-stained labels, one lightly torn label, one nicked label, one lightly corroded capsule, two different importers...pure and incredibly complex and elegant...sweet and quite intricate displaying Grand Cru richness and stupendous length BH 12/ bottles per lot HK$100, ,000 US$13,000-19, ZACHYS tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com

109 Chambertin Armand Rousseau cm or better, lightly bin-soiled labels, three lightly scuffed labels, one missing vintage tag, two wine-stained labels, one wrinkled label, two different importers, one with signs of old seepage Perfumed...very rich and forward medium weight flavors of exceptional length...multiple, and consistent, notes BH 5/ bottles per lot HK$160, ,000 US$20,000-30,000 Chambertin Armand Rousseau 1999 Lot 711: one lightly nicked label, one missing vintage tag, two different importers Lot 712: two lightly bin-soiled labels, one lightly torn label...a simply knock out Chambertin, worthy of every accolade reserved for the very best in Burgundy BH 11/ bottles per lot HK$140, ,000 US$18,000-26, magnums (1.5L) per lot HK$100, ,000 US$13,000-19,000 Chambertin Armand Rousseau 1991 damp-stained labels, one nicked label, corroded capsules, different bottlings, one with signs of old seepage This is supreme in its expression of that which is Chambertin, offering power without weight yet an intensity and pungency of flavors that must be experienced to be believed...reference standard Chambertin BH 1/ bottles per lot HK$38,000-55,000 US$ Chambertin Armand Rousseau 1993 five lightly bin-soiled labels, six lightly scuffed labels, one winestained label, one corroded capsule, three different importers, one with signs of old seepage...restrained, pure and powerful, extremely rich, almost massive flavors that offer a core of inner sweetness and then does a slow build to an intense, extremely long finish BH 11/ bottles per lot HK$160, ,000 US$20,000-32,000 Chambertin Armand Rousseau 1996 Lot 710: one lightly marked label, eight lightly nicked labels, one nicked label, one scuffed label, one torn label, two loose capsules reveal fully branded corks, three different importers One of the greatest wines of the vintage with one of the most complex and stunning panoply of still youthful pinot fruit aromas I have ever experienced BH 4/ bottle per lot HK$10,000-15,000 US$ bottles per lot HK$120, ,000 US$16,000-24,000 Chambertin Armand Rousseau phenomenal aromatic complexity...it is packed, powerful and beautifully complex and is an outstanding wine BH 11/ bottles per lot HK$14,000-20,000 US$ Chambertin Armand Rousseau 2001 two different importers...fullish and still quite tight, with outstanding acidity currently reigning in the depth of fruit that one can still sense in the mid-palate...blossoms beautifully in a peacock s tail JBG 5/ bottles per lot HK$85, ,000 US$11,000-17,000 Chambertin Armand Rousseau 2002 Lot 715: one scuffed label, one heavily scuffed obscures vintage tag, two loose capsules reveal fully branded corks, two different importers Profound aromas of raspberry and strawberry liqueur and sappy oak, with an almost honeyed sweetness IWC 3/ bottles per lot HK$65,000-95,000 US$ , bottles per lot HK$110, ,000 US$14,000-20,000 Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com 109

110 110 Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com

111 Lots 715 & 716 Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com 111

112 Lot Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com

113 Chambertin Armand Rousseau serious power and weight on the rich, full and driving finish that possesses an exuberant underlying sense of energy... Arguably the Chambertin of the vintage BH 1/ bottles per lot HK$190, ,000 US$24,000-36,000 Chambertin Clos de Bèze Armand Rousseau 1969 one 3cm, one 4cm, one heavily deteriorated label, one corroded capsule, cut capsules reveal fully branded corks bottles per lot HK$46,000-65,000 US$ Chambertin Clos de Bèze Armand Rousseau cm, loose capsule reveals fully branded cork...a soaring, very expressive, kaleidoscope of spicy, pure aromas BH 10/ bottle per lot HK$20,000-30,000 US$ Chambertin Clos de Bèze Armand Rousseau 1989 Lot 720: 1.5cm, nicked and heavily damp-stained label, loose capsule reveals fully branded cork Lot 721: 1.5cm or better, two deteriorated labels, heavily damp-stained labels, one heavily deteriorated label, one cut capsule reveals fully branded cork, one with signs of old seepage Substantial, very full and expressive nose...intense, complex, large-scaled flavors, excellent length and Grand Cru finesse BH 10/ bottle per lot HK$ ,000 US$ bottles per lot HK$28,000-42,000 US$ Chambertin Clos de Bèze Armand Rousseau cm or better, scuffed and heavily damp-stained labels, one heavily wine-stained label, one with signs of old seepage Wonderfully complex aromatics...flavors of real distinction and very good length...delivers plenty of mouth coating velvet and spice BH 11/ bottles per lot HK$26,000-38,000 US$ Chambertin Clos de Bèze Armand Rousseau cm, bin-soiled and lightly nicked label...offers an explosion of incredibly complex aromas...akin to the unfolding of a peacock s tail. Rich, dense and structured...a wonderful combination of power and finesse BH 4/ bottle per lot HK$19,000-28,000 US$ Chambertin Clos de Bèze Armand Rousseau 1993 one bin-soiled label, two lightly damp-stained labels, two with signs of old seepage...a simply dazzling breadth of aromas...detailed, driving and still very fresh flavors that display astounding depth...slow building, wonderfully persistent length BH 10/ bottles per lot HK$42,000-60,000 US$ Chambertin Clos de Bèze Armand Rousseau 1996 one wine-stained vintage tag, one lightly bin-soiled label, ten marked labels, one wine-stained vintage tag, one with writing on vintage tag, one torn vintage tag obscures vintage loose capsule reveals vintage branded cork, three different importers, two with signs of old seepage...tannic, sappy, intense, remarkably complex flavors...fresh, long and beautiful BH 10/ bottles per lot HK$95, ,000 US$12,000-17,000 Chambertin Clos de Bèze Armand Rousseau 1999 two lightly scuffed labels, two different importers...medium to full-bodied, elegant, and unctuously textured... impeccably ripened tannins detectable in its exceptionally long and delineated finish WA 8/ bottles per lot HK$55,000-80,000 US$ ,000 Chambertin Clos de Bèze Armand Rousseau 2001 two different importers...has a creamy, voluptuous bouquet...very perfumed and feminine...perfect acidity and a caressing texture...incredible clarity and delineation. Stunning WA 3/ bottles per lot HK$50,000-75,000 US$ Chambertin Clos de Bèze Armand Rousseau 2002 Lot 729: lightly scuffed labels...exuberant, big, rich, round and intensely sappy. The finish explodes in the mouth and is superbly complex with first rate vibrancy BH 1/ bottles per lot HK$46,000-70,000 US$ bottles per lot HK$ US$ Gevrey-Chambertin Les Cazetiers Armand Rousseau 2005 Côte de Nuits, Premier Cru A somewhat riper nose of black cherry and violet hints leads to serious, intense, round and sweet flavors underpinned by a powerful, detailed and sappy finish that possesses a firm core of ripe tannins. BH 1/ bottles per lot HK$10,000-15,000 US$ Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com 113

114 Gevrey-Chambertin Clos St Jacques Armand Rousseau 1969 Côte de Nuits, Premier Cru one 2cm, one 4.5cm, one 5cm, one damp-stained label, one lightly scuffed label, one lightly torn label, one corroded capsule partially reveals cork, two with signs of old seepage bottles per lot HK$24,000-36,000 US$ Gevrey-Chambertin Clos St Jacques Armand Rousseau 1985 Côte de Nuits, Premier Cru 2.5cm, nicked and lightly bin-soiled label, loose capsule reveals fully branded cork bottle per lot HK$13,000-19,000 US$ Gevrey-Chambertin Clos St Jacques Armand Rousseau 2002 Côte de Nuits, Premier Cru Lot 734: one lightly marked label, one lightly scuffed label Its satin-textured personality coats the taster s palate with boisterous dark cherry, cinnamon, spicy oak, and blackberry flavors that linger in its extensive finish WA 6/ bottles per lot HK$30,000-46,000 US$ bottles per lot HK$55,000-80,000 US$ ,000 Gevrey-Chambertin Clos St Jacques Armand Rousseau 2005 Côte de Nuits, Premier Cru Lot 735: one with sticker adhered to label, one lightly marked label Lot 736: six with stickers adhered to labels, two with signs of old seepage...extremely fresh and this sense of vibrancy and freshness suffuses the rich, round and even more powerful lithe and tautly shaped flavors BH 1/ bottles per lot HK$30,000-46,000 US$ bottles per lot HK$60,000-95,000 US$ ,000 Gevrey-Chambertin Clos St Jacques Armand Rousseau 1979 (1) 1.5cm, bin-soiled, damp-stained, lightly torn and winestained label 1989 (2) 1.5cm, one lightly damp-stained label, one lightly marked label, one marked label, one with signs of old seepage 737 above 3 bottles per lot HK$14,000-20,000 US$ Gevrey-Chambertin Lavaux St Jacques Armand Rousseau 2005 Côte de Nuits, Premier Cru Invigorating juiciness, savory meatiness and salty, chalky mineral character mark a finish of clarity, depth and polish WA 4/ bottles per lot HK$19,000-28,000 US$ Mazis-Chambertin Armand Rousseau cm, bin-soiled label bottle per lot HK$ US$ Ruchottes-Chambertin Clos des Ruchottes Armand Rousseau cm, lightly bin-soiled and nicked label, cut capsule reveals fully branded cork bottle per lot HK$ US$ Ruchottes-Chambertin Clos des Ruchottes Armand Rousseau rich, full and sweet medium weight plus flavors that deliver fine punch and precision on the delineated and exceptionally pure mineral infused finish BH 1/ bottles per lot HK$34,000-50,000 US$ Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com

115 Lots white white Burgundy Burgundy Jean-François Coche-Dury: Jean-François Coche s name is now murmured with the same respectful awe that is reserved for Henri Jayer. In many ways, he wears a mantle in the pantheon of white Burgundy winemakers that Monsieur Jayer wears amongst the red winemakers. From three-starred Michelin restaurants to the auction floors of New York and London, it is the white wines of Monsieur Coche that are the most ardently sought after. For those Burgundy lovers lucky and clever enough to secure bottles of Coche-Dury wines, the treasures that they are able to lock away in their cellars are a fine hedge against the vagaries of growing old. The white Burgundy crown that rests so easily on the head of Jean-François Coche is a rather remarkable achievement, when one pauses to consider his rather meager vineyard holdings versus the scores of white wine-producing domaines whose holdings are chock full of Grand Crus and illustrious Premier Crus. The two crown jewels amongst the white wines in the Coche cellar are the Meursault Perrières and the Corton-Charlemagne. The Corton- Charlemagne s first release was the 1986 vintage, and it is as fine a bottle of Corton Charlie as one can ever hope to find. It is very slow to unfold, and in any top vintage requires a minimum of ten years of bottle age to really blossom and begin to drink well. The Coche-Dury Meursault Perrières is the other twin titan in the cellar. Many Burgundy lovers, often over a glass of inspired Côte d Or rouge or blanc, like to banter about which vineyards are worthy of promotion in the appellation controlée system if the French were ever to open up the Pandora s Box or reclassification. Almost universally, the vineyard of Meursault Perrières is mentioned as clearly worthy of Grand Cru status. If one were to choose and example of why this is the case, one could do no better than a bottle of Coche-Dury Meursault Perrières. This is a complete wine that quite easily rivals the quality of the Corton-Charlemagne in the cellar. In some vintages the Corton looks to be the better of the two, sometimes the Meursault Perrières. But in virtually every vintage the Meursault Perrières is a long-lived wine of uncompromising brilliance, and well worth the price of admission. There are not many Bâtard-Montrachets or Chevalier-Montrachets that I would trade even up for a bottle of Coche-Dury Meursault Perrières. John Gilman, View From the Cellar, July 2003 Jean-François Coche-Dury: Meursaults 中的佼佼者及更多更多 - Jean-François Coche 的名字在葡萄酒界耳語流傳, 有著與 Henri Jayer 同樣的崇高地位, 備受尊崇 他在釀造白葡萄酒的技藝上出類拔萃, 在芸芸的白布根地葡萄釀酒師當中, 猶如帶著神聖的光環, 與別不同 由三星米芝蓮餐廳以至紐約及倫敦的拍賣場上,Coche 先生的白葡萄往往備受各界注視, 獲各大藏家追捧 若布根地的愛好人仕有幸得到 Coche-Dury 的佳釀, 只將其好好保存於酒窖當中, 它會猶如懂得魔法一般, 保持著年輕活力 Jean-François Coche 輕鬆的坐上了白布根地的寶坐, 絕對是一個非常出色的成就, 十分了不起 ; 你試想想他只有一個非常細少的葡萄園, 但他卻擁有著滿滿的特級園及一級園傑作 John Gilman, View From the Cellar,2003 年 7 月 Corton-Charlemagne Coche-Dury 1989 Côte de Beaune, Grand Cru one 2cm or better, one 3cm, one faded label, one lightly scuffed label, two scuffed labels, two oxidized capsules, two different importers This is one of the finest white wines I have ever had the pleasure of drinking and represents for me one of the supreme expressions of this vineyard...as if this weren t enough, the length this wine displays is so extraordinary that only a few of the best examples of Montrachet approach it BH 6/ bottles per lot HK$75, ,000 US$ ,000 Meursault Les Rougeots Coche-Dury 1989 Côte de Beaune one 2cm, one 2.5cm, one 3.5cm, one lightly bin-soiled label, one lightly nicked label, one lightly torn label, one winestained label, different importers, one with signs of old seepage bottles per lot HK$14,000-20,000 US$ Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com 115

116 Corton-Charlemagne Coche-Dury 1990 Côte de Beaune, Grand Cru 2cm, scuffed label, lightly corroded capsule...the tremendous depth and purity of the wine are sensed more than tasted on the attack...perfectly balanced, with a huge core of fruit, flawless focus, and plenty of firm acidity JBG 7/ bottle per lot HK$26,000-38,000 US$ Meursault Perrières Coche-Dury 1990 Côte de Beaune, Premier Cru 2cm, lightly damp-stained label...big, muscular, rich and gorgeously nuanced palate staining flavors that offer huge length and real power plus class and breed to burn BH 6/ bottle per lot HK$14,000-20,000 US$ Corton-Charlemagne Coche-Dury 1999 Côte de Beaune, Grand Cru one cut capsule reveals branded cork The balance here is perfect and this is without question one of the finest examples of Corton-Charlemagne that I have ever tasted BH 6/ bottles per lot HK$75, ,000 US$ ,000 Meursault Perrières Coche-Dury 1999 Côte de Beaune, Premier Cru two lightly bin-soiled labels, two different importers This is a dramatic, powerful, concentrated and complete wine that is still on the way up though to be sure, the 99 Perrières has arrived at a point where it could certainly be enjoyed now BH 6/ bottles per lot HK$46,000-70,000 US$ Corton-Charlemagne Coche-Dury 1992 Côte de Beaune, Grand Cru lightly bin-soiled, nicked and scuffed labels, different importers There is a hint of botrytis on the hugely long and sweet flavors that display a touch of toasty oak on the enormously long flavors. In a word, this is brilliant BH 11/ bottles per lot HK$50,000-75,000 US$ Corton-Charlemagne Coche-Dury 1996 Côte de Beaune, Grand Cru Lot 747: lightly scuffed label, cut and lightly corroded capsule reveals fully branded cork Lot 748: one lightly scuffed label, one nicked label, one loose capsule reveals fully branded cork...minerality dominates the mid-palate and explodes like a grenade on the stupendously long finish. This is truly a great wine in every respect BH 10/ bottle per lot HK$24,000-36,000 US$ bottles per lot HK$50,000-75,000 US$ Meursault Les Rougeots Coche-Dury 1999 Côte de Beaune This hugely expressive, medium-bodied wine has outstanding amplitude to its imposing, chewy-textured, and velvety personality. WA 2/ bottles per lot HK$16,000-24,000 US$ Puligny-Montrachet Enseignères Coche-Dury 1999 Côte de Beaune bottles per lot HK$11,000-16,000 US$ Corton-Charlemagne Coche-Dury 2000 Côte de Beaune, Grand Cru one lightly nicked label, three lightly scuffed label, one cut capsule reveals fully branded cork, two different importers, two with signs of old seepage...positively crystalline and concentrated, dense flavors that deliver the hallmark delineation, power and breathtaking persistence of classically styled Corton-Charlemagne BH 6/ bottles per lot HK$60,000-95,000 US$ , Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com

117 Lot 749 Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com 117

118 Meursault Caillerets Coche-Dury 2000 Côte de Beaune, Premier Cru one lightly bin-soiled label, one scuffed label bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Meursault Perrières Coche-Dury 2000 Côte de Beaune, Premier Cru three lightly bin-soiled labels, two lightly nicked labels, three different importers This has turned out to be even slightly better than I originally foresaw and one that has arrived at its apogee though it should continue to age gracefully for years. A genuinely great effort BH 6/ bottles per lot HK$38,000-55,000 US$ Meursault Les Rougeots Coche-Dury 2000 Côte de Beaune...gorgeously complex, intense, refined and beautifully precise flavors of terrific focus and cut BH 7/ bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Corton-Charlemagne Coche-Dury 2002 Côte de Beaune, Grand Cru one depressed cork, two different importers The 02 Corton-Charlemagne is a great wine in every respect that to my taste is approaching its apogee but has not quite reached it...in sum, this is most impressive BH 6/ bottles per lot HK$130, ,000 US$17,000-24,000 Meursault Coche-Dury 2002 Côte de Beaune There is a silver bead of acidity and a long, inspiring citric fresh finish that brims over with mineralite. Heavenly! WA 7/ bottles per lot HK$22,000-32,000 US$ Meursault Chevalières Coche-Dury 2002 Côte de Beaune, Premier Cru bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Meursault Perrières Coche-Dury 2002 Côte de Beaune, Premier Cru one lightly bin-soiled label, one slightly depressed cork This is wonderfully elegant, strikingly complex, gorgeously pure and stunningly precise and long, replete with the pungent minerality of a great Perrières and the class and linearity of a top Grand Cru BH 7/ bottles per lot HK$26,000-38,000 US$ Coche-Dury Meursault 1996 (1) Puligny-Montrachet Enseignères 2000 (1) lightly torn label Puligny-Montrachet Enseignères 2002 (1) 761 above 3 bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com

119 Domaine Leflaive Joseph Leflaive was a very astute purchaser of vineyard land during the first two decades of the twentieth century, so that today the domaine s roster of vineyards is the greatest constellation of white Burgundy patrimony in the Côte de Beaune. These include just under two full hectares in Chevalier-Montrachet, an equal slice in Bâtard-Montrachet, a bit more than a hectare in Bienvenues-Bâtard-Montrachet (out of a total of 2.3 hectares), just over three hectares in the beautiful Premier Cru of Pucelles, three-quarters of a hectare in Combettes, 1.27 hectares in Folatières, and nearly five hectares in Premier Cru Clavoillon. In 1991, the topping on the cake was added when the domaine purchased a very small,.08 hectare slice of Le Montrachet itself. John Gilman, View From the Cellar Joseph Leflaive 是 20 世紀 10 至 20 年代, 一位非常精明的葡萄園買家, 因此到了今天, 酒莊在 Côte de Beaune 擁有最多勃艮第白酒葡萄園 當中在 Chevalier-Montrachet 約有 2 公頃 在 Bâtard- Montrachet 的與前者相約 在 Bienvenues-Bâtard-Montrachet 有 1 公頃多 ( 總面積只有 2.3 公頃 ), 在 Pucelles 有 3 公頃多美麗的一級田 在 Combettes 有 3/4 公頃 在 Folatières 有 1.27 公頃及在 Clavoillon 約有 5 公頃一級田 1991 年, 酒莊購入一塊很小 只有 0.08 公頃的 Le Montrachet, 就如在蛋糕上加上丁點裝飾 John Gilman, View From the Cellar Chevalier-Montrachet Domaine Leflaive 1979 Côte de Beaune, Grand Cru one 2.5cm, one 3cm, one heavily bin-soiled label, one lightly torn label, different importers bottles per lot HK$12,000-19,000 US$ Bâtard-Montrachet Domaine Leflaive 1983 Côte de Beaune, Grand Cru one 3.5cm, one 4cm, one torn label, wine-stained labels Palish; wonderfully fragrant, nutty, oaky bouquet and flavour. Rich, fullish, yet lean and steely. Lemon-like acidity. Very high mark...hhhhh. MB bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Chevalier-Montrachet Domaine Leflaive 1983 Côte de Beaune, Grand Cru 3cm, partially deteriorated label The flavors are incredibly impressive for their viscosity and density yet there is nary a hint of heaviness or lack of perfect balance. In short, this is a stunner of a wine that is at the top of its game but the density and balance will permit it to hold for years BH 11/ bottle per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Chevalier-Montrachet Domaine Leflaive 1986 Côte de Beaune, Grand Cru 4cm, scuffed and heavily damp-stained label...rich, full, refined, almost unctuous flavors that offer remarkable clarity and precision on the superbly long backend. Extremely classy juice BH 4/ bottle per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Chevalier-Montrachet Domaine Leflaive 1992 Côte de Beaune, Grand Cru one bin-soiled label, one damp-stained label, one scuffed label, one torn label, different importers, one with signs of old seepage...rich, dense, sappy, mouth coating, sexy flavors that exhibit incredible length...plenty of minerality BH 3/ bottles per lot HK$12,000-19,000 US$ Bienvenues-Bâtard-Montrachet Domaine Leflaive 1996 Côte de Beaune, Grand Cru one with signs of old seepage This wine is extremely exuberant...expressing super-ripe pear, peach, earth, toast, and lemon flavors WA 6/ bottles per lot HK$11,000-16,000 US$ Chevalier-Montrachet Domaine Leflaive 1996 Côte de Beaune, Grand Cru one lightly bin-soiled label, one lightly nicked label, two lightly scuffed labels, one scuffed label, one with signs of old seepage...detailed, pure and racy middle weight complex flavors underpinned by intense minerality and superb length BH 3/ bottles per lot HK$22,000-32,000 US$ Bâtard-Montrachet Domaine Leflaive 1999 Côte de Beaune, Grand Cru one with importer tag adhered to label, one lightly nicked label, one lightly scuffed label, two wine-stained vintage tags, two different importers, two with signs of old seepage As you would expect, there is superb mineralité locked into this wine, though it is expressed more aromatically than on the palate. Still, it is a deeply impressive wine and it should continue to give pleasure over the next decade at least WA 6/ bottles per lot HK$12,000-19,000 US$ Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com 119

120 Chevalier-Montrachet Domaine Leflaive 1999 Côte de Beaune, Grand Cru two different importers, two with signs of old seepage...curiously silky yet surprisingly powerful and muscular palate impression and a racy intensity that just oozes class BH 12/ bottles per lot HK$17,000-26,000 US$ Puligny-Montrachet Les Pucelles Domaine Leflaive 1999 Côte de Beaune, Premier Cru two different importers, four with signs of old seepage...impeccably balanced with impressive length and a fine, almost delicate acid structure. There is real elegance here and a certain very appealing nervosité BH 12/ bottles per lot HK$10,000-15,000 US$ Bâtard-Montrachet Domaine Leflaive 2000 Côte de Beaune, Grand Cru two different importers, one with signs of old seepage Big, rich and mouthfilling, with harmonious ripe acidity framing the peach and pear fruit flavors. Very dense and very long; the dusty finish seems almost tannic but retains lovely fruit and finesse IWC 9/ bottles per lot HK$10,000-15,000 US$ Bienvenues-Bâtard-Montrachet Domaine Leflaive 2000 Côte de Beaune, Grand Cru two with signs of old seepage This is an extravagant wine with a broad, hugely intense flavor profile, packed with spices, minerals, and toasted oak. It is exuberant, crammed with fruit, and long WA 12/ bottles per lot HK$14,000-20,000 US$ Chevalier-Montrachet Domaine Leflaive 2000 Côte de Beaune, Grand Cru one with signs of old seepage...a complete wine with mind boggling purity and a finish that seems like liquefied rock. Stony, intense BH 12/ bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Chevalier-Montrachet Domaine Leflaive 2002 Côte de Beaune, Grand Cru one lightly scuffed label, one nicked label, three different importers, one with signs of old seepage A supremely elegant nose of white flower and limestone notes are followed by sweet, pungently mineral and ultra precise middle weight flavors that offer simply incredible focus with an almost painfully intense, stunningly long finish BH 5/ bottles per lot HK$46,000-65,000 US$ Puligny-Montrachet Les Pucelles Domaine Leflaive 2002 Côte de Beaune, Premier Cru one lightly nicked label, one wine-stained label, one with signs of old seepage Medium-bodied, refined, and well-focused, it boasts loads of spiced apple flavors in its pure, concentrated core. This rich wine is admirably well-balanced, fresh, and impressively long WA 2/ bottles per lot HK$15,000-22,000 US$ Domaine Leflaive Bâtard-Montrachet 1979 (1) 4cm, torn and heavily bin-soiled label Bienvenues-Bâtard-Montrachet 1983 (1) 2.5cm, damp-stained and torn label 777 above 2 bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Puligny-Montrachet Domaine Leflaive Les Pucelles 1983 (2) one 2.5cm, one 3cm, lightly wine-stained labels, one scuffed label, one torn label, one with signs of old seepage Les Pucelles 1992 (2) torn and lightly bin-soiled labels Les Folatières 1996 (1) lightly damp-stained and marked label Les Pucelles 1996 (2) lightly bin-soiled labels, one lightly nicked label, different importers, signs of old seepage Les Folatières 1999 (4) two lightly scuffed labels, two with signs of old seepage 778 above 11 bottles per lot HK$17,000-26,000 US$ Domaine Leflaive Bâtard-Montrachet 1992 (1) 3.5cm, damp-stained label, signs of old seepage Bienvenues-Bâtard-Montrachet 1992 (2) one wrinkled vintage tag, importer tags adhered to dampstained labels, one with signs of old seepage Bâtard-Montrachet 1996 (2) one with signs of old seepage 779 above 5 bottles per lot HK$19,000-28,000 US$ Domaine Leflaive Bienvenues-Bâtard-Montrachet 1999 (3) one lightly nicked label, one lightly scuffed label, signs of old seepage Bâtard-Montrachet 2002 (1) lightly damp-stained label 780 above 4 bottles per lot HK$10,000-15,000 US$ Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com

121 d'auvenay Chevalier-Montrachet Domaine d Auvenay 1996 Côte de Beaune, Grand Cru bin-soiled labels, two wine-stained labels, three with signs of old seepage This wine s purity, precision, delineation, and focus render its citrus fruit-infused minerality almost lace-like. At present a touch austere, it possesses unbridled power, intensity, and concentration of fruit WA 4/ bottles per lot HK$110, ,000 US$14,000-20,000 Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com 121

122 Criots Bâtard-Montrachet Domaine d Auvenay 1996 Côte de Beaune, Grand Cru bin-soiled, scuffed and lightly damp-stained labels, one slightly depressed cork, two slightly protruded corks, two with signs of old seepage bottles per lot HK$65,000-95,000 US$ ,000 Chevalier-Montrachet Domaine d Auvenay 1999 Côte de Beaune, Grand Cru different importers...powerful, focused and impressively concentrated medium-bodied flavors brimming with minerality and excellent vibrancy on the hugely long finish...in short, a stunner of a wine BH 12/ bottles per lot HK$30,000-46,000 US$ Criots Bâtard-Montrachet Domaine d Auvenay 1999 Côte de Beaune, Grand Cru It is harmonious, muscular, and has an intense mineral-ladencore whose flavors are maintained throughout its extraordinarily long finish WA 2/ bottle per lot HK$15,000-22,000 US$ Puligny-Montrachet Les Folatières Domaine d Auvenay 1999 Côte de Beaune, Premier Cru bottles per lot HK$12,000-19,000 US$ Chevalier-Montrachet Domaine d Auvenay 2000 Côte de Beaune, Grand Cru Intense, penetrating, driving, palate staining and crystalline in its precision with a finish that I could taste the next day. Another reference standard effort and if this adds additional weight over time BH 7/ bottles per lot HK$34,000-50,000 US$ Puligny-Montrachet La Richarde Domaine d Auvenay 2000 Côte de Beaune bottles per lot HK$22,000-32,000 US$ Domaine d Auvenay 1996 bin-soiled label Auxey Duresses (1) scuffed and lightly wine-stained label Meursault Les Gouttes d Or (1) lightly scuffed and wine-stained label, slightly protruded cork, signs of old seepage 788 above 2 bottles per lot HK$ US$ Montrachet Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 1964 Côte de Beaune, Grand Cru 5cm, damp-stained and heavily bin-soiled label, dark color, 1st vintage of Montrachet DRC bottle per lot HK$46,000-65,000 US$ Montrachet Comtes Lafon 1996 Côte de Beaune, Grand Cru five lightly bin-soiled labels, four scuffed labels, two different importers...vibrant, muscular, dense and exceptionally powerful flavors that possess flat out incredible detail, all wrapped in a racy, elegant and gorgeously pure finish BH 11/ bottles per lot HK$60,000-95,000 US$ ,000 Chevalier-Montrachet La Cabotte Bouchard Père et Fils 1999 Côte de Beaune, Grand Cru one nicked label, two different importers...which beautifully complement the chiseled, exquisitely muscular flavors and persistence that must be experienced to be believed BH 6/ bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com

123 Montrachet Domaine Ramonet 1999 Côte de Beaune, Grand Cru one with importer tag adhered to label, one cut capsule reveals fully branded cork Painfully intense with palate staining, focused and layered flavors and phenomenal length that is hard to believe. A genuinely great wine BH 3/ bottles per lot HK$16,000-24,000 US$ Chevalier-Montrachet La Cabotte Bouchard Père et Fils 2002 Côte de Beaune, Grand Cru Then as extraordinarily fresh in the mouth as on the nose; the wine s strong acids and powerful minerality give it great penetration and serve to intensify the citrus and stone flavors IWC 9/ bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Bâtard-Montrachet Marc Colin 2002 Côte de Beaune, Grand Cru four lightly bin-soiled labels The finish genuinely borders, at the moment anyway, on being flat out painful as wave after wave of mouthwatering extract stains the palate. A great Bâtard BH 7/ bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Chevalier-Montrachet Michel Niellon 2002 Côte de Beaune, Grand Cru two different importers...classy, pure, gorgeous textured, firm and refined flavors that possess razor sharp definition and a finish of crystalline minerality BH 7/ bottles per lot HK$22,000-32,000 US$ Chablis Les Clos Raveneau 2002 Chablis, Grand Cru one chipped wax capsule, one with signs of old seepage Pure, dense, muscular, exceptionally well-balanced, this brilliant wine boats a complex flavor profile of salty pears, earth, flint, and hints of candied lemons WA 2/ bottles per lot HK$14,000-20,000 US$ Corton-Charlemagne Bonneau du Martray 2002 Côte de Beaune, Grand Cru original wood case Ripe apple and peach flavors are rich and persistent, with vanilla and mineral notes emerging on the finish. The long, expansive finish reveals its potential WS 6/ bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Chablis Valmur Raveneau 2002 Chablis, Grand Cru This full-bodied wine wows the taster with its concentration, depth, awesomely supple texture, as well as by its huge length WA 2/ bottles per lot HK$12,000-19,000 US$ Bâtard-Montrachet Michel Niellon 2004 Côte de Beaune, Grand Cru one lightly scuffed label Like many examples of Bâtard in 2004, this is more elegant than it usually is and while it can t match the supremely refined Chevalier in this regard, it comes much closer than it usually does. A knockout and worth a special search BH 7/ bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com 123

124 Lot Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com

125 Montrachet Pierre-Yves Colin-Morey 2004 Côte de Beaune, Grand Cru one lightly bin-soiled label...intense and firm medium full flavors that are powerful and equally focused on the hugely long finish BH 7/ bottles per lot HK$20,000-30,000 US$ Chevalier-Montrachet Pierre-Yves Colin-Morey 2004 Côte de Beaune, Grand Cru...refined, complex and beautifully defined flavors that are tightly wound and impressively vibrant, particularly on the powerfully long and chiseled finish that cuts like a knife BH 12/ bottles per lot HK$15,000-22,000 US$ Montrachet Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 2007 Côte de Beaune, Grand Cru banded original wood case...rich and monumentally constructed flavors that possess an almost chewy texture yet the mouth feel is one of satin and silk, all wrapped in a palate staining mildly toasty finish that displays impeccable balance and incredible length BH 7/ bottles per lot HK$110, ,000 US$14,000-20,000 Bienvenues-Bâtard-Montrachet Carillon 1996 (2) bin-soiled labels, one torn label 1999 (1) 803 above 3 bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Mixed Burgundy Chevalier-Montrachet Les Demoiselles Louis Latour 1996 (3) scuffed labels Puligny-Montrachet Combettes Etienne Sauzet 1996 (5) two lightly nicked labels Bâtard-Montrachet Marc Morey 1999 (6) two lightly scuffed labels Corton-Charlemagne Bonneau du Martray 2004 (9) two different importers 804 above 23 bottles per lot HK$15,000-22,000 US$ Mixed Burgundy Corton-Charlemagne Georges Roumier 1996 (2) lightly bin-soiled and damp-stained labels Bâtard-Montrachet Michel Niellon 2004 (1) Corton-Charlemagne Pierre-Yves Colin-Morey 2007 (1) lightly nicked label 805 above 4 bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Chevalier-Montrachet Domaine Ramonet 1999 (2) one previously cut capsule reveals fully branded cork Marc Colin 2000 (6) three lightly bin-soiled labels, one lightly torn label, two different importers 806 above 8 bottles per lot HK$10,000-15,000 US$ Chablis Raveneau Butteaux 2002 (3) Valmur 2002 (1) Valmur 2004 (2) 807 above 6 bottles per lot HK$10,000-15,000 US$ Montrachet 2002 Amiot Guy et Fils (2) scuffed labels Colin-Deléger (1) 808 above 3 bottles per lot HK$ US$ Mixed Burgundy Meursault Charmes Jean Boillot 1999 (3) missing capsules reveal fully branded corks Puligny-Montrachet Perrières Jean Boillot 2000 (6) one lightly damp-stained label Puligny-Montrachet 1er Cru Le Cailleret Montille 2002 (9) one damp-stained label 809 above 18 bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com 125

126 Lots rhône Rhône Rhône Beaucastel Châteauneuf-du-Pape Hommage à Jacques Perrin Château Beaucastel 1989 Rhône one 2cm, one 2.5cm, lightly bin-soiled labels The wine is exceptionally full-bodied and tannic, as well as awesomely concentrated and magnificently well-balanced WA 2/ bottles per lot HK$11,000-16,000 US$ Châteauneuf-du-Pape Hommage à Jacques Perrin Château Beaucastel 1999 Rhône two lightly wine-stained labels, two torn labels, two different importers Extremely full-bodied, with masses of extract, high tannin, and a structured, long finish WA 12/ bottles per lot HK$22,000-32,000 US$ Bonneau Châteauneuf-du-Pape Reserve des Célestins Henri Bonneau 2009 Rhône two lightly bin-soiled labels bottles per lot HK$12,000-19,000 US$ Châteauneuf-du-Pape Reserve des Célestins Henri Bonneau 2011 Rhône bottles per lot HK$11,000-16,000 US$ Châteauneuf-du-Pape Reserve des Célestins Henri Bonneau 1995 (2) one with sticker adhered to label, one loose capsule 1999 (4) three lightly bin-soiled labels, one lightly scuffed label 816 above 6 bottles per lot HK$12,000-19,000 US$ Châteauneuf-du-Pape Hommage à Jacques Perrin Château Beaucastel 2001 Rhône one lightly torn label, two wine-stained labels A huge lashing of tannin as well as a formidable structure result in the antithesis of its more flattering, forward, and voluptuous sibling, the classic Beaucastel WA 2/ magnums (1.5L) per lot HK$12,000-19,000 US$ Châteauneuf-du-Pape Hommage à Jacques Perrin Château Beaucastel 1990 (1) 1.5cm, lightly bin-soiled and scuffed label 1995 (1) 1.5cm, lightly bin-soiled label 2000 (1) wine-stained label, heavily corroded capsule, signs of old seepage 813 above 3 bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com

127 JL Chave Hermitage JL Chave 1978 Rhône 1.5cm, nicked and lightly scuffed label This has always been one of Chave s greatest vintages... Memorizing its aromas, its flavors, its texture, and its length is a quick education in what great wine is all about RP bottle per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Ermitage Cuvée Cathelin JL Chave 1991 Rhône 1.5cm, lightly scuffed label Full-bodied, dense, and powerful, this is a deeply concentrated, rich, compelling bottle of Hermitage RP bottle per lot HK$24,000-36,000 US$ Guigal Marcel Guigal-perfectionist, fanatical, pernickety-is the super star of the appellation and probably sells more Côte-Rôtie under his own label than all the other growers combined. Despite this size, however, the quality is exemplary-as they should be at the prices he charges! He harvests late, insists on very low yields, and keeps the wines in a combination of barrel and small foudres and demi-muids, all newish wood, for up to three and a half years before bottling. Their wines are so concentrated they can withstand this wait without drying out, and remain profound, rich and individual. La Landonne is the Brune, La Mouline the Blonde, La Turque the sort of hermaphroditic mixture. Usually my favourite is the Landonne. The Château d Ampuis bottling combines elements of both the sectors of Côte-Rôtie, from vines in the climats of La Pommiere, Le Pavillon, La Garde and Le Clos. Clive Coates, An Encyclopedia of The Wines and Domaines of France Hermitage JL Chave 1991 Rhône one 1.5cm, one lightly bin-soiled label, one scuffed label, two different importers With excellent richness and medium to full body, this deep, graceful wine should turn out to be slightly richer than the 1987, and perhaps equal to the sumptuous RP bottles per lot HK$20,000-30,000 US$ Ermitage Cuvée Cathelin JL Chave 1995 Rhône heavily scuffed label obscures vintage loose capsule reveals fully branded cork Rich and powerful, with a formidable tannin level in the finish, it possesses a saturated purple color, great purity of fruit, considerable mouthfeel and length WA 10/ bottle per lot HK$16,000-24,000 US$ Hermitage JL Chave 2009 Rhône includes 12-pack original carton The extraordinary bouquet is followed by a wine of extravagant intensity as well as tremendous focus and precision... Anyone who loves Hermitage and has a cold cellar should be lining up to get a few bottles of this beauty WA 12/ bottles per lot HK$11,000-16,000 US$ Hermitage JL Chave 1999 (3) 2000 (4) 822 above 7 bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Marcel Guigal- 完美主義者 狂熱 愛挑剔 他是產區中的大明星, 或許他自家品牌賣出的 Côte-Rôtie 酒, 相比其他酒農全部加起來的更多 儘管產量大, 但質量絕對是模範 而他的定價就是他的葡萄酒質素的定位! 他選擇延遲收割期, 堅持非常低的產量, 並混合使用全新木桶 中型木桶和大木桶, 陳釀多達 3.5 年才入瓶 他們的葡萄酒非常集中, 所以能承受這長期的陳放, 而不會乾涸, 並保持出色 豐富和風格獨特 La Landonne 是棕色,La Mouline 是金色, 而 La Turque 是兩者混合 通常我最喜歡的是 Landonne Château d Ampuis 入瓶時混合了 Côte-Rôtie 兩個區域的元素, 萃取自 La Pommiere Le Pavillon La Garde 和 Le Clos 地區內的葡萄. Clive Coates, An Encyclopedia of The Wines and Domaines of France Côte-Rôtie La Mouline Guigal 1966 Rhône one 1.5cm, one 2cm, two 2.5cm, one bin-soiled label, two lightly bin-soiled labels, one lightly nicked label, one lightly torn label, one marked label, one scuffed label, one torn label, two wine-stained labels, one with signs of old seepage bottles per lot HK$120, ,000 US$16,000-24,000 Côte-Rôtie La Mouline Guigal 1969 Rhône three 2cm or better, three 2.5cm, five lightly bin-soiled labels, one lightly scuffed label, four torn labels, two wine-stained labels, one lightly corroded capsule, two different importers, one with signs of old seepage bottles per lot HK$95, ,000 US$12,000-17,000 Côte-Rôtie La Mouline Guigal 1971 Rhône 2cm, lightly bin-soiled and damp-stained label bottle per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com 127

128 Côte-Rôtie La Mouline Guigal 1978 Rhône 1.5cm, corroded capsule, signs of old seepage On the palate, this wine reveals unreal concentration, layers of thick, juicy fruit, beautifully integrated acidity and tannin... one of the greatest wines made in this century WA 5/ bottle per lot HK$22,000-32,000 US$ Côte-Rôtie La Mouline Guigal 1989 Rhône 2cm or better, one lightly scuffed label, one lightly torn label, one lightly wine-stained label, one wine-stained label, two different importers, two with signs of old seepage Very full-bodied, with a dreamy opulence, gobs of fruit, an unctuous texture, and powerful finish WA 7/ bottles per lot HK$12,000-19,000 US$ Côte-Rôtie La Mouline Guigal 1983 Rhône 2.5cm, lightly bin-soiled labels...this wine reveals a distinctive, violet, cassis, bacon fat aroma intermixed with smoked duck and Asian spice components. Extremely full-bodied and sturdy RP bottles per lot HK$11,000-16,000 US$ Côte-Rôtie La Mouline Guigal 1985 Rhône six 2cm or better, five 2.5cm, one 3cm, eight bin-soiled labels, one nicked label, four scuffed labels, six corroded capsules, two cut capsules reveal fully branded corks, one torn capsule, two different importers One of the all-time great La Moulines...one of the most concentrated but profoundly endowed and well-balanced wines I have ever tasted RP bottles per lot HK$80, ,000 US$10,000-16,000 Côte-Rôtie La Turque Guigal 1985 Rhône 2cm or better, lightly bin-soiled labels, one lightly wine-stained label, one with signs of old seepage Sweet, thick, highly concentrated flavors contain enough acidity and soft wood tannin RP bottles per lot HK$20,000-30,000 US$ Côte-Rôtie La Mouline Guigal 1988 Rhône 2cm or better, lightly bin-soiled labels Among so many exceptional La Mouline s, this is one of the most profound...this thick, super concentrated, full-bodied, tannic La Mouline is loaded with fruit, massive, and full-bodied RP bottles per lot HK$10,000-15,000 US$ Côte-Rôtie La Turque Guigal 1988 Rhône 1.5cm or better, three lightly bin-soiled labels, two different importers This thick, unctuously textured, full-bodied, monster...exhibits awesome concentration, terrific purity RP bottles per lot HK$14,000-20,000 US$ Côte-Rôtie La Turque Guigal 1989 Rhône 2cm or better, two bin-soiled labels, one nicked vintage tag, one scuffed label, one wine-stained label, two different importers, one with signs of old seepage Full-bodied, dense, and thick, this wine possesses the essence of black cherries WA 7/ bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Côte-Rôtie La Turque Guigal 1990 Rhône 2cm or better, two bin-soiled labels, one torn label, one winestained vintage tag, two torn capsules, one with signs of old seepage...sweet, generous, incredibly harmonious personality, it is an unforgettable wine...one of the most velvety-textured, decadently rich palates I have encountered, this fabulous wine has a finish that lasts more than a minute RP bottles per lot HK$11,000-16,000 US$ Côte-Rôtie La Mouline Guigal 1998 Rhône one lightly scuffed label...a seamless, full-bodied classic with many characteristics of the 1997 La Landonne, but more structure, tannin, and muscle...this wine s aromatic fireworks, sumptuous texture, and seamless personality represent perfection WA 4/ bottles per lot HK$17,000-26,000 US$ Côte-Rôtie La Landonne Guigal 1999 Rhône Lot 836: lightly damp-stained labels, one lightly nicked label, two nicked labels Lot 838: one lightly torn label, one with signs of old seepage Literally out of this world in terms of flavor concentration and balance, the finish lasts well over 60 seconds WA 6/ bottles per lot HK$12,000-16,000 US$ bottles per lot HK$24,000-32,000 US$ bottles per lot HK$46,000-65,000 US$ Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com

129 Côte-Rôtie La Mouline Guigal 1999 Rhône original wood case Parcel: lots It is unctuously-textured, full-bodied, and fabulously concentrated with a tremendous purity and seamlessness...a wine of singular greatness WA 6/ bottles per lot HK$46,000-65,000 US$ bottles per lot HK$46,000-65,000 US$ bottles per lot HK$46,000-65,000 US$ Côte-Rôtie La Turque Guigal 1999 Rhône Lot 842: one lightly nicked label, one torn label Lot 843: one scuffed label, one torn label, original wood case Lot 844: two lightly scuffed labels, original wood case with damaged lid Lot 845: two lightly damp-stained labels, one nicked label, one scuffed label, two with signs of old seepage, original wood case with damaged lid Lot 846: two lightly damp-stained labels, two scuffed labels, one torn label, original wood case...phenomenal intensity, sweet, well-integrated tannin, huge body, and loads of concentrated fruit WA 6/ bottles per lot HK$17,000-26,000 US$ bottles per lot HK$42,000-60,000 US$ bottles per lot HK$42,000-60,000 US$ bottles per lot HK$42,000-60,000 US$ bottles per lot HK$42,000-60,000 US$ Côte-Rôtie Brune et Blonde Guigal 1966 (2) one 2cm, one 3cm, nicked and lightly bin-soiled labels 1969 (2) one 2.5cm, one 3cm, one bin-soiled label, one lightly binsoiled label, different labels 847 above 4 bottles per lot HK$11,000-16,000 US$ Côte-Rôtie Guigal La Mouline 1993 (1) lightly wine-stained label La Landonne 1995 (1) torn label La Mouline 1995 (2) one lightly wine-stained label, one wine-stained label, one with signs of old seepage La Turque 1998 (1) scuffed label, slightly depressed cork La Mouline 2001 (3) La Turque 2001 (3) one lightly scuffed label 848 above 11 bottles per lot HK$19,000-28,000 US$ Sabon Châteauneuf-du-Pape Le Secret de Sabons Domaine Roger Sabon 1998 Rhône one lightly marked label, two different importers Unctuously-textured, with a sumptuous, compelling, meaty richness revealing notes of barbecue spice and earth, it is extremely long with a finish that lasts 50+ seconds...monumental as well as majestic WA 12/ bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Châteauneuf-du-Pape Le Secret de Sabons Domaine Roger Sabon 1999 Rhône two different importers bottles per lot HK$ US$ Châteauneuf-du-Pape Le Secret de Sabons Domaine Roger Sabon 2000 Rhône two different importers, two with signs of old seepage bottles per lot HK$ US$ bottles per lot HK$10,000-15,000 US$ Châteauneuf-du-Pape Le Secret de Sabons Domaine Roger Sabon 2001 Rhône one lightly scuffed label Amazingly full-bodied, with a viscous texture, beautifully integrated acidity, tannin, and alcohol, this massively proportioned yet gorgeously balanced, impeccably pure wine is one of the world s greatest expressions of ancient vines and natural/artisinal winemaking WA 2/ bottles per lot HK$16,000-26,000 US$ No Lot Châteauneuf-du-Pape Les Cailloux Cuvée Centenaire Lucien et Andre Brunel 1990 Rhône three 2cm or better, three 2.5cm, three lightly bin-soiled labels, three lightly nicked labels, two different importers...full-bodied and exceptionally generous, with a sweet taste due to the fabulous ripeness and richness of the fruit WA 1/ bottles per lot HK$12,000-19,000 US$ Hermitage La Chapelle Jaboulet 1990 Rhône 2cm or better, four lightly bin-soiled labels, one lightly torn label, two cut capsules reveal fully branded corks, five different importers There is extraordinary freshness for such a mammoth wine in addition to abundant tannin, an amazing 60-second finish, and a level of glycerin and thick, fleshy texture WA 6/ bottles per lot HK$20,000-30,000 US$ Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com 129

130 Châteauneuf-du-Pape Les Cailloux Cuvée Centenaire Lucien et Andre Brunel 1998 Rhône four lightly marked labels, two different importers...rich, full-bodied, and unctuously-textured, with extraordinary purity, WA 12/ bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Châteauneuf-du-Pape Cuvée da Capo Pegau 1998 Rhône...shows extraordinary precision and definition...thick, unctuously textured, but with zesty acidity and sweet tannin WA 6/ bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Côte-Rôtie Côte Brune Jamet 1999 Rhône bottles per lot HK$10,000-15,000 US$ Châteauneuf-du-Pape Vieilles Vignes Domaine de la Vieille Julienne 2000 Rhône two different importers bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Châteauneuf-du-Pape Reserve Deux Frères Pierre Usseglio 2001 Rhône bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Châteauneuf-du-Pape Les Cailloux Cuvée Centenaire Lucien et Andre Brunel 1989 (2) one 1cm, one 3cm, nicked and lightly bin-soiled labels Reserve Clos du Caillou 1998 (6) two lightly scuffed labels, one scuffed label, two different importers Les Cailloux Cuvée Centenaire Lucien et Andre Brunel 2000 (6) 864 above 14 bottles per lot HK$11,000-16,000 US$ Châteauneuf-du-Pape Domaine de Marcoux Vieilles Vignes 1989 (5) two 2.5cm, two 3cm, one 5cm, one bin-soiled label, two damp-stained labels, four lightly bin-soiled labels, one lightly marked label, one torn label, two with wax capsules, one with heavy signs of old seepage, four with signs of old seepage Vieilles Vignes 1998 (1) Domaine et Selection 2000 magnums (6) Vieilles Vignes 2001 (5) 865 above 11 bottles & 6 magnums (1.5L) per lot HK$13,000-19,000 US$ Châteauneuf-du-Pape La Reine des Bois Mordoree 1998 (3) two different importers 2001 (6) 866 above 9 bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Châteauneuf-du-Pape Reine des Bois Mordoree 2003 Rhône two 6-pack original wood cases three lightly bin-soiled labels bottles per lot HK$ US$ Mixed Rhône Châteauneuf-du-Pape Reserve Château Rayas 1981 (1) 3.5cm, partially deteriorated label, wine-stained vintage tag, lightly corroded capsule, signs of old seepage Hermitage La Chapelle Jaboulet 1988 (1) 1.5cm, bin-soiled label, slightly depressed cork Châteauneuf-du-Pape Cuvée Papet Clos du Mont Olivet 1989 (4) 2cm or better, one lightly nicked label, one lightly winestained label, one wine-stained label, one with signs of old seepage Hermitage La Chapelle Jaboulet 1989 (1) 2.5cm, damp-stained label, cut capsule reveals fully branded cork Châteauneuf-du-Pape Château Beaucastel 1990 (3) 2cm or better, one lightly bin-soiled label, two lightly dampstained labels Châteauneuf-du-Pape Cuvée Papet Clos du Mont Olivet 1990 (1) 2cm 863 above 11 bottles per lot HK$12,000-19,000 US$ Mixed Rhône Châteauneuf-du-Pape Blanc Vieilles Vignes Château Beaucastel 1996 (1) Châteauneuf-du-Pape Blanc Reserve Château Rayas 1998 (1) lightly bin-soiled label Châteauneuf-du-Pape Cuvée Vieilles Vignes Janasse 1998 (5) Côte-Rôtie La Barbarine Gangloff 1999 (4) Côte-Rôtie La Serie Noir Gangloff 1999 (6) Châteauneuf-du-Pape Charvin 2000 (2) Châteauneuf-du-Pape Cuvée Vieilles Vignes Janasse 2000 (6) Châteauneuf-du-Pape Reserve Deux Frères Pierre Usseglio 2003 (6) original wood case 867 above 31 bottles per lot HK$19,000-28,000 US$ Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com

131 Lot 859 Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com 131

132 Lot Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com

133 Lots champagne Champagne Champagne Bollinger Bollinger Vieilles Vignes Françaises Blanc de Noirs 1982 Champagne into foil, scuffed label bottle per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Bollinger Vieilles Vignes Françaises Blanc de Noirs 1999 Champagne three with importer tags adhered to labels The mousse is exceptionally fine, as is everything about this wine. Although the wine possesses superb density and richness, it remains light on the palate and supremely graceful WA 12/ bottles per lot HK$24,000-36,000 US$ Bollinger Vieilles Vignes Françaises Blanc de Noirs 1989 Champagne into foil bottle per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Bollinger Vieilles Vignes Françaises Blanc de Noirs 1990 Champagne into foil, lightly bin-soiled labels, one oxidized foil, two different importers bottles per lot HK$55,000-80,000 US$ ,000 Bollinger RD into foil 1979 (1) scuffed and lightly bin-soiled label, disgorged on October 22, (1) disgorged on April 27, (1) disgorged on April 27, above 3 bottles per lot HK$ US$ Bollinger Vieilles Vignes Françaises Blanc de Noirs 1996 Champagne two scuffed labels, two different importers The bouquet is mute, tight, and powerful, like a distant rumbling thunderstorm. The palate is met by an oily, creamy essence of dark fruit and licorice RJ 10/ bottles per lot HK$50,000-75,000 US$ Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com 133

134 Dom Pérignon Dom Pérignon The Wine World s Strongest Brand Dom Pérignon-the name alone makes most of us break out in a delightful smile. When we think of this 17th-century monk from Hautvillers-so often pointed out as the father of Champagne we either regard him with historical reverence, or associate his name with the proudest of all wine labels and everything else that follows in its glamorous, sparkling wake Back in 1936, Moët & Chandon s marketing director Robert-Jean de Vogüé could not possibly have imagined what he had done when he dreamed up the idea of the world s first prestige champagne a champagne with a sky-high price that was supposed to be even better than the vintage wine, along with a spectacular look that won respect and prompted extravagant enjoyment The style itself is ultra-sophisticated, with an amazingly silky softness combined with toasted fireworks, backed up by an exotic fruitiness in a medium body. When Dom Pérignon is at its best I find notes of forest morelles, cream, peach and an overabundance of roasted coffee beans and nuttiness. Dom Pérignon Rosé is an even more exquisite and rare product that has been molded in a similar form, though its full-bodied shape leans more to strawberry or orange, where the whiter somewhat lighter variety becomes exotic and toasted. Dom Pérignon Oenothèque is the latest child in this distinguished family. At Richard Geoffroy s initiative they now release a restricted number of old, well-preserved bottles from Moët s own cellar in different stages of maturity. The wine can be newly disgorged, but it isn t a fixed thing. What is guaranteed, however, is that the wines are in the best possible condition, and that they most likely will act a little more youthfully than the bottles that have been out on the market for a while. This treasure is now decorated with a luxurious black label in unmistakable style. And speaking of style In an age when PR people constantly want to minimalize labels and change both bottle design and packaging, Dom Pérignon stands there like a Sophia Loren of the champagne world, unchanged and as timelessly sexy. The balance conveyed in the subtly curvaceous shape of the bottle, paired with an olive green label in the shape of a coat of arms adorned with cursive writing, is still as magical as ever. Since 1970 the wine itself is made exclusively in steel tanks and the grapes are mainly Pinot Noir from Aÿ, Bouzy, Verzenay and Hautvillers, as well as Chardonnay in approximately equal amounts from Cramant and Mesnil. Richard Juhlin, Champagne Club 一提起 Dom Pérignon, 很多人都會展現出燦爛的笑容 追思這位 17 世紀 Hautvillers 的僧侶, 不少人把他看成是香檳之父 今天看來, 他既是一位令人尊崇的歷史人物, 亦是一個值得引以為傲的世界頂級品牌, 代表了華麗 閃爍 追溯至 1936 年,Moet & Chandon 的市場總監 Robert-Jean de Vogüé 又怎會想像得到, 他當時欲創製世界上第一隻尊貴香檳的意念與夢想, 日後竟會獲得如此空前的成功 Dom Pérignon 的風格十分精細 高雅, 口感細滑, 蘊含烤烘的木味和引人入勝的果味, 酒身相當豐潤 除此之外, 我更發它帶有忌廉 桃 烤烘咖啡和果仁味道 而 Dom Pérignon Rosé 則更加獨特及稀有 ; 其酒身十分豐潤, 偏向帶有草莓和柑橘的氣息 Dom Pérignon Oenothèque 是在此卓越家族中最年青的一員, 在現任總釀酒師 Richard Geoffroy 的推動下, 每年都會留存一批同年份的香檳, 務求將成熟 繁複口感推至極致 此瑰寶以典雅尊貴的黑色酒瓶包裝, 叫人難忘 談到風格, 不少公關人士不斷地希望在標籤 酒瓶設計甚至在裝潢上加以改變 ; 但 Dom Pérignon 卻猶如香檳世界的蘇菲亞羅蘭般, 保持經典及超越時間的性感 豐腴線條的樽瓶 橄欖綠色盾形標籤 典雅的草書字體, 令 Dom Pérignon 魔幻般超越永恆 自從 1970 年以後,Dom Pérignon 只採用鋼製釀酒桶 ; 葡萄方面, 只採用 Ay Bouzy Verzenay 和 Hautvillers 的 Pinot Noir, 另外相同分量的 Chardonnay, 只採用 Cramant 和 Mesnil 所產者 我很驕傲地說, 我可能是嘗過最多著名頂級酒莊 有年份好酒之第一人! Richard Juhlin, Champagne Club Dom Pérignon Oenothèque 1959 Champagne into foil, one with importer tag adhered to label, two different importers, two different releases, disgorged in bottles per lot HK$55,000-80,000 US$ ,000 Dom Pérignon Oenothèque 1962 Champagne into foil, two different releases, disgorged in 2002 The shape is round and vintage-typically rich, but the wine is vigorous and orange-sated as usual, with a taste of apricot marmalade. Brilliant! RJ 5/ bottles per lot HK$38,000-55,000 US$ Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com

135 Lot 875 Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com 135

136 Lot Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com

137 Dom Pérignon Rosé 1962 Champagne 2cm below foil, lightly bin-soiled and scuffed labels The bouquet is overwhelming with its plumpness and extremely rich caramel-toffee character. The taste, with its treacly, layer-upon-layer concoction of goodies, is almost chewable RJ 3/ bottles per lot HK$36,000-55,000 US$ Dom Pérignon Oenothèque 1966 Champagne six individual original wood cases into foil, disgorged in bottles per lot HK$85, ,000 US$11,000-17,000 Dom Pérignon Oenothèque 1990 Champagne into foil, disgorged in 2003 Lot 878: one torn label, two lightly corroded foils, one lightly torn foil, two different importers Lot 879: one torn foil partially reveals cork Lot 880: one lightly scuffed label, one torn label, three lightly corroded foils, two different importers This has really come together, showing mature aromas and flavors of citrus and berry confit, coffee and mineral. Big and robust, yet well-balanced and sophisticated, with a long, coffee-tinged finish. Absolutely delicious WS 11/ bottles per lot HK$34,000-50,000 US$ bottles per lot HK$36,000-55,000 US$ bottles per lot HK$36,000-55,000 US$ Dom Pérignon Rosé 1990 Champagne Lot 881: into foil Lot 882: 0.5cm below foil Besides wonderful structure there are layers of red and exotic fruit, with blood orange as the guiding star. All these fruits are sensitively braided together with all the classically toasted fireworks! RJ 7/ bottles per lot HK$12,000-19,000 US$ magnums (1.5L) per lot HK$16,000-24,000 US$ Dom Pérignon 1996 Champagne Lot 883: one torn foil partially exposing cork Lot 884: one wine-stained label, two different importers Very crisp, fine, youthful and fresh in the mouth, the finish provides layers of minerals, citrus fruits and a pleasant creaminess in texture and flavour WA 5/ bottles per lot HK$17,000-26,000 US$ bottles per lot HK$17,000-26,000 US$ Dom Pérignon Rosé 1996 Champagne one lightly damp-stained label Lot 885: one lightly scuffed label Parcel: lots 886 & 887 What a wine. The 1996 Rosé has begun to fill out rather dramatically. Today it is rich, powerful and totally seductive WA 11/ bottles per lot HK$11,000-16,000 US$ bottles per lot HK$22,000-32,000 US$ bottles per lot HK$22,000-32,000 US$ Dom Pérignon Rosé 2002 Champagne A big, full-bodied wine, the 2002 is probably the most overly vinous, intense Rosé ever made by longtime Chef de Caves Richard Geoffroy. Layers of cool, insistent minerality balance the fruit beautifully on the crystalline, vivid finish WA 12/ bottles per lot HK$10,000-15,000 US$ Dom Pérignon 1973 (1) 1.5cm below foil, lightly bin-soiled label 1975 (2) one into foil, one 1cm below foil, different importers 1978 (1) info foil, lightly scuffed label 1985 (1) 0.5cm below foil 1990 magnums (2) 0.5cm below foil, scuffed labels 889 above 5 bottles & 2 magnums (1.5L) per lot HK$15,000-22,000 US$ Dom Pérignon Rosé 1975 (1) 1cm below foil, bin-soiled and nicked label 1982 (2) one into foil, one 2cm below foil, one lightly damp-stained label, one lightly torn foil partially reveals cork, different importers, different releases 1985 (2) into foil 1990 magnum (1) 1cm below foil 1995 (2) 890 above 7 bottles & 1 magnum (1.5L) per lot HK$26,000-38,000 US$ Dom Pérignon 1990 (4) info foil, one lightly scuffed label, one oxidized foil, two different importers 1996 (5) one torn foil partially reveals cork, two different importers 891 above 9 bottles per lot HK$13,000-19,000 US$ Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com 137

138 Krug Of all the wine world s luxury brands, Krug is perhaps the most glittering. No expense is spared in its production, though the techniques used are in fact remarkably artisanal, including fermentation in small, old wooden casks. Time is of the essence: the overall ageing cycle is the best part of a decade here, with all wines being aged for at least six years sur pointes (upended, after the ordinary ageing period that follows the second fermentation is concluded). No expense is spared, either, in the pricing of its five wines, the cheapest of which, Grande Cuvée, costs as much as many rival houses top cuvées. This is a wine of magnificent complexity and layered richness, nourishing and diverting, as detailed and textured as a Gobelin tapestry. It contains wines from a decade s worth of vintages and from at least twenty different crus (not all of them Grand or even Premier, one might note); Krug makes no secret, too, of its need and love for Pinot Meunier. (The Krug 1928 vintage, regarded by the family as the greatest ever, contained twenty percent Meunier, and there is eighteen percent in the finely honed 1988.) There is also a relatively understated rosé of pale tawny hue, and a series of vintage wines of magnificent stylistic oscillation, fully respecting the potential of each year. The Collection vintage wines have spent more years in the Krug cellars in Reims; disgorgement took place at the same time as for ordinary vintage wines. Finally, a champagne de terroir: the pure Chardonnay Clos du Mesnil, vinified from wines in a genuine 1.9 hectares walled vineyard within the village of Le Mesnil, purchased by Krug in 1971, and released as a vintage wine beginning with In great years (like 1988) it is magnificent and multi-dimensioned. Andrew Jefford, The New France Krug 在葡萄酒世界當中, 一眾美麗奢華的品牌面前 ; 它或許是當今最璀璨奪目的一顆明珠 它的生產過程一絲不荀, 毫不吝嗇, 依然堅持固我, 利用出色的手工技術締造出一代佳釀, 忠於細小且滿載歲月的木桶中進行發酵程序 陳年的時間亦大於一切 : 整個陳釀過程長達十年之久, 而精髓在於將酒液倒置陳年 ( Sur Pointes) 最少六年 ( 頭尾倒置, 瓶頸向下 這程序, 卻是經過 一般 的熟成過程及二次發酵步驟完成後方始進行 ) 完美的品質自然擁有著相符的價值,Krug 旗下的五款珍酩中,Grande Cuvée 價格最為廉宜, 但卻不亞於其他競爭對手所出產的頂級 cuvées 這葡萄佳釀帶有旖旎的複雜性及層次豐富 圓潤 引人入勝, 如哥白林掛毯般細緻幼滑, 紋理清晰 它包含了價值整整十年的陳釀功夫與時光, 及源自至少二十個大大小小的葡萄園 ( 您或會注意到, 它們並不是全部屬於特級園或一級園 ) ;Krug 對 Pinot Meunier 的渴求與鍾情一向是公開的秘密 ( 獲酒莊家族視為有史以來最偉大的 The Krug 1928 年, 包含了百分之二十的 Meunier; 而於精心雕琢的 1988 年珍酩中卻帶有百分之十八 ) 除此以外,Krug 同時亦擁有相對低調 滲有淡淡黃褐色色調的 rosé 系列, 及種種風格華麗的陳年佳釀, 以迎合每年不同的潮流風格和可能性 精選年份的葡萄佳釀較其他系列的花費更長年期陳釀, 並沉澱位於漢斯 (Reims) 中 Krug 的自家酒窖當中 ; 除渣過程 ( disgorgement ) 亦與 一般 年份的葡萄佳釀同時進行 最後, 有關香檳中的特有風土氣息 : 它充滿著濃濃源自 Chardonnay Clos du Mesnil 的純淨風土氣息 ;Krug 於 1971 年購入位於 Le Mesnil 村莊的這片葡萄園, 佔地 1.9 公頃, 首批推出的佳釀年份為 1979 年, 並一直延續至今 一些偉大年份的佳釀 ( 如 1988 年 ), 它們璀璨華麗且擁有不同尺寸外表 Andrew Jefford, The New France Krug 1969 Champagne into oxidized foil, bin-soiled and torn label...with tart apple flavors and ripe pear notes, as well. Fresh, light and delicate. WS 8/ bottle per lot HK$12,000-19,000 US$ Krug 1973 Champagne into lightly oxidized foil, lightly bin-soiled label, German importer A wonderfully accessible Champagne that fills the room with its euphoric bouquet of honey, peach, and apricot. The taste is concentrated and developed, with an expansive fruit and silkysmooth structure RJ 3/ bottle per lot HK$ US$ Krug Collection 1979 Champagne into oxidized foil, lightly bin-soiled label It still has the Montrachet-like elegance, like a young 1979 Krug. A fantastic masterpiece of absolute world class RJ 2/ bottle per lot HK$10,000-15,000 US$ Krug into foil 1985 (3) one lightly torn label Clos du Mesnil 1985 (1) lightly bin-soiled and wine-stained label 896 above 4 bottles per lot HK$17,000-26,000 US$ Krug 1975 Champagne into foil, bin-soiled and lightly scuffed label This marvelous Champagne is truly classic and will last a very long time. Deep nutty flavor and great length RJ 5/ bottle per lot HK$ US$ Krug 1989 Champagne into foil, one lightly bin-soiled label, one missing label with vintage confirmed on neck tag, one torn label The 1989 Krug was explosive on the nose and full-bodied on the palate where it offered a racy, almost wild expression of sweet, ripe fruit AG 11/ magnums (1.5L) per lot HK$14,000-20,000 US$ Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com

139 Krug 1990 Champagne into foil Lot 898: two lightly scuffed labels Lot 899: bin-soiled labels, one heavily scuffed label...the fruit is so rich that the acidity is beautifully enveloped. Warmly toasted, almost burned, smoky aromas are present, together with notes of orchids, vanilla, and dried fruit RJ 10/ bottles per lot HK$10,000-15,000 US$ magnums (1.5L) per lot HK$22,000-32,000 US$ Krug Clos du Mesnil 1990 Champagne into foil, three partially deteriorated labels, one vintage partially obscured by back label, one deteriorated label, wine-stained labels A seductive mosaic of biscuit, honey and walnut oil lead to baking bread and citrus in this masculine, youthful Champagne WS 2/ bottles per lot HK$42,000-60,000 US$ Krug 1996 Champagne Lot 901: two different importers Lot 902: two lightly oxidized capsules...stratospheric, with layers of explosive fruit that flow effortlessly to the multi-dimensional, captivating finish. It is another eternal Champagne from Krug WA 7/ bottles per lot HK$24,000-36,000 US$ bottles per lot HK$30,000-46,000 US$ Lot 898 Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com 139

140 Louis Roederer Roederer did not get its present name until 1833, but was in existence as far back as 1760 under the name of Dubois Père & Fils. Louis Roederer was a hardworking man who succeeded in selling his Champagne in several important export markets. Roederer s real ace was, as with Clicquot, the Russian market. Tsar Alexander II wanted a more impressive label to show his guests, and in 1876 he made a special order for the first transparent Cristal bottles, which at that time actually were made of genuine crystal...in the 1930 s...camille Olry- Roederer took the helm. She invested the money earned from sales in some exceptional vineyards: in Aÿ, Hautvillers, Cumières, Louvois, Verzy, Verzenay, Vertus, Avize, Cramant, Chouilly, and Le Mesnil. Roederer also owns several well-respected vineyards in other locations: Roederer Estate, Ramos Pinto, Haut-Beauséjour and Château de Pez. Today the firm is the most financially successful in the region, thanks largely to these vineyards, which supply Roederer with some seventy percent of its grapes. The house is now run by Jean-Claude Rouzaud who works according to the same principles as those applied in past decades...roederer is without doubt a brilliant Champagne house with an exceptional portfolio of wines. The non-vintage Champagne is brilliant. The Rosé and Blanc de Blancs offer an aristocratic elegance typical of the house, and the vintage wine is always among the best. Cristal is today the most sought-after cuvée de prestige, and has perhaps the most appetizing appearance of any wine in the world. Cristal Rosé is not only the most expensive rosé Champagne it is obviously the best. In my opinion, this house is one of the four best in all of Champagne. Every vintage is stunning. Richard Juhlin, The Champagne Club Louis Roederer 是位非常勤力的酒商, 在出口優質香檳至幾個外國大市場方面尤其成功 在 1833 年, 他從長輩手上接手了自 1760 年便開業的老字號 Dubois Père & Fils 酒廠, 並以自己的名字為新酒廠命名 他的真正皇牌是利用 Clicquot 香檳與俄羅斯建立的良好關係 : 俄羅斯沙皇亞歷山大二世為了在宴會上以最炫目的香檳招待賓客, 於 1876 年時曾向 Louis Roederer 特別訂製了世上首款水晶香檳, 其所以名為水晶香檳, 是因為香檳瓶的確是以真正的水晶製造的 酒廠經歷百年之後, 在 1930 年代酒廠由 Camille Olry-Roederer 接掌, 這位釀酒界著名的寡婦為酒廠收購了 Aÿ Hautvillers Cumières Louvois Verzy Verzenay Vertus Avize Cramant Chouilly 和 Le Mesnil 等多地的優質萄葡園 ; 而在 Ramos Pinto, Haut-Beauséjour 和 Château de Pez 等著名酒莊內, 也有 Roederer 的葡萄園, 當然還有他們酒廠旁邊的莊園 上列的多個葡萄園, 產量佔酒廠所需約七成的葡萄, 令他們成為區內經營得最成功的酒廠 酒廠現在由 Jean- Claude Rouzaud 按照酒廠過去幾十年一貫的理念和方法來經營 他們無疑是家佳品眾多的出色香檳商, 不標年份香檳固然出色, 玫瑰酒和 Blanc de Blancs 白萄葡酒也為酒廠增添了一份貴族的雅氣, 年份酒的質量更是自不待言 再說, 他們的水晶香檳可謂是當世最受追捧的佳釀, 世人追逐的豈止是瓶中美酒, 酒瓶本身已足夠使人垂涎三尺 酒廠出品的粉紅水晶香檳 (Cristal Rosé) 除了是目前最高價的玫瑰香檳, 也無可否認是芸芸玫瑰香檳當中最好的 我個人認為,Roederer 是目前四大最佳香檳商之一, 每個年份的作品, 都有信心保證 源自 Richard Juhlin 的 The Champagne Club Louis Roederer Cristal 1966 Champagne into foil, lightly damp-stained label It s hard to conceive of a wine being more enjoyable than this one. The fruit is incredibly dense and the style is unimpeachable. A classic Champagne that has everything and more. A little lighter and more elegant than the awesome RJ 5/ bottle per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Louis Roederer Cristal Rosé 1989 Champagne one individual original wood case into foil, one scuffed label, one corroded neck tag...with a sparklingly colorful knockout fruit and generous softness. Without doubt one of this vintage s absolutely foremost Champagnes RJ 12/ magnums (1.5L) per lot HK$14,000-20,000 US$ Louis Roederer Cristal 1990 Champagne into foil, four lightly bin-soiled labels, seven oxidized foils, three different importers A classic of power and finesse, richness and delicacy, it may be the greatest Cristal I have ever tasted! WA 10/ bottles per lot HK$32,000-50,000 US$ Louis Roederer Cristal Rosé 1990 Champagne into foil, one damp-stained label, four lightly bin-soiled labels, one oxidized foil, three different importers Cristal Rosé 90 can t be anything but wonderful. This is a very young and as-yet discreet Champagne with a peerless balance and finesse RJ 9/ bottles per lot HK$42,000-60,000 US$ Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com

141 Louis Roederer Cristal 1996 Champagne Lot 907: one lightly scuffed label Lots 908 & 909: five lightly corroded foils Parcel: lots 908 & 909 This has weight yet a sensation of weightlessness thanks to its seamless texture and harmony. Still firm and forceful yet elegant, offering citrus, pastry, biscuit and hazelnut notes enmeshed in the creamy texture. Great structure for aging WS 11/ bottles per lot HK$28,000-42,000 US$ bottles per lot HK$28,000-42,000 US$ bottles per lot HK$28,000-42,000 US$ Louis Roederer Cristal Rosé 1996 Champagne Lot 910: individual original wood cases Lot 911: one damaged individual original wood case, two individual original wood cases My winner when the 10 most eminent Cuvée Prestige Rosés on the market were lined up blind in front of my nose...it only took a second to find this beautiful Cristal. One of the most superior wines in the world! RJ 8/ bottles per lot HK$12,000-19,000 US$ magnums (1.5L) per lot HK$24,000-36,000 US$ Louis Roederer Cristal 2002 Champagne two different importers This beautifully-sculpted Champagne possesses notable clarity but with the additional depth of fruit that is characteristic of this vintage. It is a gorgeous, seductive Cristal of the highest level WA 12/ bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Louis Roederer Cristal Rosé 2002 Champagne one lightly scuffed label...attractive spiciness, a hint of candied orange and impressive, gently sweet persistence IWC 11/ bottles per lot HK$24,000-36,000 US$ Louis Roederer Cristal 2004 Champagne It is a powerful, structured Cristal layered with considerable fruit WA 12/ bottles per lot HK$12,000-19,000 US$ Louis Roederer Cristal Rosé 2005 Champagne bottles per lot HK$11,000-19,000 US$ Louis Roederer Cristal 2000 Champagne The fantastic thing is that the fruitiness is very young and bursting with energy, with tones of spring flowers, gooseberries and red currants along with sweet pineapple, paw-paw and mango. Phenomenally Cristally and delightfully sensual RJ 2/ bottles per lot HK$16,000-24,000 US$ Louis Roederer Cristal 1996 (1) 2000 (5) one damp-stained label, one lightly damp-stained label 2005 (6) 917 above 12 bottles per lot HK$14,000-20,000 US$ Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com 141

142 Pol Roger Extra Cuvée de Reserve Extra Dry 1964 Champagne into foil, lightly bin-soiled labels, one scuffed label bottles per lot HK$ US$ Salon Blanc de Blancs Le Mesnil 1990 Champagne four bin-soiled labels, one lightly bin-soiled label, two oxidized foils It has real depth and concentration, combining fresh floral and citrus notes with its signature nutty flavor. Each provides an incredible Champagne experience WS 8/ bottles per lot HK$36,000-55,000 US$ Salon Blanc de Blancs Le Mesnil 1996 Champagne two bin-soiled labels, one lightly bin-soiled label, one scuffed label There s just a hint of greenness, marking its youthful impetuosity. Has great length WS 12/ bottles per lot HK$19,000-28,000 US$ Champagne 1990 Gosset Celebris (4) one 3.5cm below short foil, three 4cm below short foil, one nicked label, one scuffed label, two different importers Pol Roger Cuvée Sir Winston Churchill (1) into foil, nicked and scuffed label 921 above 5 bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Lot Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com

143 Lots alsace alsace Alsace Riesling Vendange Tardive Hors Choix Clos St Hune Trimbach 1989 Alsace 2cm or better bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Riesling Clos Ste Hune Trimbach Vendange Tardive 1989 (6) 2cm or better, one scuffed label, two different importers 1996 (2) 924 above 8 bottles per lot HK$14,000-20,000 US$ Riesling Clos Ste Hune Trimbach 1981 (2) one 2.5cm, one 3cm, one damp-stained label, one lightly bin-soiled label, one lightly nicked label 1983 (1) 2cm, lightly bin-soiled label Vendange Tardive 1983 (2) 2cm or better, bin-soiled labels 923 above 5 bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com 143

144 Lots germany germany Germany Riesling Spatlese #19 Auction Scharzhofberger Egon Müller 1997 Mosel bottles per lot HK$12,000-19,000 US$ Riesling Eiswein Kiedricher Grafenberg Robert Weil 1998 Rheingau half-bottles (375ml) per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Riesling Eiswein Kiedricher Grafenberger Robert Weil 1999 Mosel three with signs of old seepage half-bottles (375ml) per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Rieslaner Trockenbeerenauslese Mussbacher Eselshaut Müller-Catoir 2001 Pfalz half-bottles (375ml) per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Riesling Beerenauslese Rosalack Schloss Johannisberg 1943 (1) 2.5cm, torn, lightly bin-soiled and scuffed label, signs of old seepage Trockenbeerenauslese Niersteiner Flaschenhahl Franz Karl Schmitt 1945 (3) 1cm or better, one torn capsule fully reveals cork, one with signs of old seepage 929 above 4 bottles per lot HK$ US$ Riesling Trockenbeerenauslese Kabinett Hochheimer Kichenstuck Domdechant Werner'siches 1969 (3) 2cm or better, lightly bin-soiled labels, one torn label, two lightly oxidized capsule, two with signs of old seepage Beerenauslese Erbacher Rheinhell Schloss Reinhartshausen 1970 (1) 2cm Eiswein Bernkasteler Doctor Dr. Thanisch 1970 (1) 2cm, bin-soiled and lightly torn label, depressed cork, oxidized capsule Beerenauslese Eltviller Sonnenberg Von Simmern 1971 (3) two 2cm or better, one 2.5cm, two lightly scuffed labels Auslese Gold Capsule Saarburger Rausch Zilliken 1983 (3) 1.5cm or better, lightly scuffed labels, one torn label, oxidized capsules Auslese Brauneberger Juffer Sonnenuhr Fritz Haag 1989 (1) 0.5cm, lightly damp-stained label 930 above 12 bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com

145 Riesling Beerenauslese Goldcap Brauneberger Juffer-Sonnenuhr #20 Fritz Haag 1995 half-bottles (2) sticker adhered to labels, one lightly torn label, one with signs of old seepage Eiswein Bernkasteler Doctor Reichsgraf von Kesselstatt 1995 magnum (1) heavily bin-soiled label, chipped wax capsule, signs of old seepage Beerenauslese Scharzhofberger Reichsgraf von Kesselstatt 1996 half-bottles (3) Eiswein Auction Goldcap Saarburger Rausch Zilliken 1998 half-bottles (5) one with signs of old seepage Eiswein Maximin Grunhauser Abtsberg Von Schubert 1998 half-bottles (2) one lightly torn label Auslese Long Gold Cap Brauneberger Juffer Sonnenuhr #13 Fritz Haag 2000 half-bottle (1) Auslese Long Goldkap Erdener Pralat Dr. Loosen 2000 half-bottles (2) 931 above 15 half-bottles (375ml) & 1 magnum (1.5L) per lot HK$13,000-19,000 US$ Riesling Zeltinger Molitor Sonnenuhr TrockenbeerenausleseH #06 Auction 1997 half-bottle (1) Eiswein Gold Cap # half-bottles (2) bin-soiled and lightly scuffed labels Sonnenuhr Auslese HHH #29 Auction 1999 half-bottles (3) Sonnenuhr Auslese HHH 1999 (3) 934 above 6 half-bottles (375ml) & 3 bottles per lot HK$12,000-19,000 US$ Riesling Eiswein Oberhauser Brucke Donnhoff 1998 (1) # half-bottles (6) # half-bottles (6) # half-bottle (1) # above 13 half-bottles (375ml) & 1 bottle per lot HK$11,000-16,000 US$ Riesling 1997 Beerenauslese Eitelbacher Karthauserhofberg half-bottles (2) signs of old seepage Beerenauslese Wehlener Sonnenuhr Dr. Loosen half-bottles (2) Trockenbeerenauslese Hochheimer Kirchenstuck Domdechant Werner 500ml bottle (1) bin-soiled and lightly torn label Trockenbeerenauslese Ruppertsberger Reiterspfad Basserman-Jordan half-bottles (5) wine-stained labels 932 above 9 half-bottles (375ml) & one 500ml per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Riesling Eiswein Kiedricher Grafenberger Robert Weil 1997 half-bottles (2) 2001 half-bottle (1) 2002 half-bottles (5) 933 above 8 half-bottles (375ml) per lot HK$ US$ Riesling 1999 Auslese Goldcap Saarburger Rausch Zilliken magnum (1) lightly bin-soiled label, corroded capsule, signs of old seepage Auslese Graacher Domprobst Auction Schaefer (4) Auslese Long Goldcap Auction Eitelbacher Karthauserhofberg (3) Auslese Long Goldcap Bernkasteler Doctor Dr. Thanisch (3) Beerenauslese Schloss Johannisberg magnums (2) lightly scuffed labels, one chipped wax capsule, signs of old seepage Eiswein Furst Von Metternich Schloss Johannisberg magnums (2) one damp-stained label, nicked labels, one scuffed label, signs of old seepage Eiswein Kiedricher Grafenberger Robert Weil half-bottles (6) four with signs of old seepage 936 above 6 half-bottles (375ml), 10 bottles & 5 magnums (1.5L) per lot HK$17,000-26,000 US$ Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com 145

146 Lots italy itlay Italy Sassicaia 1985 Tuscany one bottom neck, two very top shoulder, one bin-soiled label, one lightly bin-soiled label, one scuffed label, two loose capsules reveal fully branded corks, two different importers Exceptionally dense, concentrated, and full-bodied, this wine possesses layers of concentrated fruit that are beautifully balanced by the wine s sweet tannin and well-integrated acidity... one of the greatest wines made this century WA 2/ bottles per lot HK$32,000-50,000 US$ Sassicaia 1990 (3) bottom neck or better, one lightly bin-soiled label 1997 (3) one lightly scuffed label, one lightly torn label 2001 (6) 938 above 12 bottles per lot HK$19,000-28,000 US$ Solaia Antinori 1985 (3) one very top shoulder, one top shoulder, one just below top shoulder, one with writing on label 1989 (1) bottom neck, lightly scuffed label 1990 (2) bottom neck or better 1995 (3) one lightly torn label, one scuffed label 1997 (3) one lightly marked label, nicked labels 939 above 12 bottles per lot HK$15,000-22,000 US$ Biondi Santi Brunello di Montalcino Riserva Biondi Santi 1955 Tuscany one top shoulder, one just below top shoulder, torn and lightly bin-soiled labels, one depressed cork, one lightly corroded capsule bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Brunello di Montalcino Riserva Biondi Santi 1971 Tuscany bottom neck or better, two depressed corks, one lightly corroded capsule bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Brunello di Montalcino Riserva "Centenario" Biondi Santi 1982 Tuscany two bottom neck or better, two very top shoulder, one lightly torn label, two different importers bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Brunello di Montalcino Riserva Biondi Santi 1997 Tuscany Opens up with time in the glass, but could use another 5 to 10 years of aging WS bottles per lot HK$30,000-46,000 US$ Brunello di Montalcino Biondi Santi Riserva 1964 (1) upper shoulder, lightly bin-soiled label 1966 (1) upper shoulder, bin-soiled, damp-stained and torn label 1971 (4) two very top shoulder, two upper shoulder, lightly bin-soiled labels, two scuffed labels, one lightly corroded capsule Riserva 1985 (1) bottom neck Riserva Centenario 1988 (1) bottom neck 944 above 8 bottles per lot HK$11,000-16,000 US$ Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com

147 Gaja In the mid-nineteenth century the Gaja family began producing wine in Piedmont. Giovanni Gaja established the winery and Angelo, the fourth generation, joined the family firm in Angelo Gaja, born in 1940 and the present director of the family firm, has a degree in enology from Alba as well as a masters in economics. In 1974 he went to California, where he presumably fell under the spell of the barrique. Gaja has achieved unequivocal success aging his Barbarescos in small, new oak barrels, where the wine takes on a certain subtlety and suppleness without losing the personality of the Nebbiolo grape. Gaja is the largest private owner of vineyards in the Barbaresco zone, with 153 acres of vines in Barbaresco, Treiso, and Alba. They own fourteen different vineyards in Barbaresco and Treiso that make up their Barbaresco normale. Besides this regular Barbaresco, Gaja bottles three individual crus. Of the three, Costa Russi matures the soonest. It is the most open, with a sweeter taste and more intense aroma. Sori Tildin is more closed and concentrated; it is firm in texture and holds more in reserve. Sori San Lorenzo is the hardest of all in its youth, requiring age to show its real quality. It is the slowest maturing of the crus as well as the longest lived. Wasserman, Italy s Noble Red Wines 在十九世紀中葉 Gaja 家族已經開始在皮埃蒙特地區釀酒, 酒莊由 Giovanni Gaja 所創建, 而今天的第四代莊主 Angelo Gaja 是在 1961 年加入這家族企業的 1940 年出生的 Angelo, 先在亞爾巴修讀釀酒學和完成他的經濟學碩士, 後來他到訪加州, 可能就是在那裏令 Angelo 明白到小橡木桶對葡萄酒的影響力 今天 Gaja 酒莊因為使用全新的小橡木桶熟成, 不單改革了傳統 ( 意大利傳統是使用巨大的斯洛伐克木桶 ) 更取得了巨大的成功 因為使用適當的小木桶不單保留了 Nebbiolo 葡萄品種的特色, 而且令到酒質更細緻和柔順 在 Barbaresco 地區,Gaja 是擁有最多葡萄園的家族 在 Barbaresco,Treiso 和 Alba 一共有 153 英畝 他們的 Barbaresco 酒款是由 Treiso 和 Barbarseco 地區的十四個葡萄園所調配而成 在 Barbaresco 以外, 還有三款單一葡萄園 : 分別是 Costa Russi - 最早成熟 ; 些許帶甜的口感和比較濃厚的滋味, 香味比較特出 Sori Tildin 是比較封閉但集中度很高, 質感厚實適合窖藏 最後一款 Sori San Lorenzo 是年輕時非常難親近的, 需要長時間去展示她的真正實力 是三個葡萄園中熟成最慢但同時最長壽命的酒款 源自 Wasserman 的 Italy s Noble Red Wines Sori San Lorenzo Gaja 1997 Piedmont one lightly torn label There is tremendous balance here between the rich dark fruits, toasted oak and spices, and the more backward flavors of tar, licorice, and balsam all of which are wrapped around an intense core of minerality WA 12/ bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Sori Tildin Gaja 1997 Piedmont one bin-soiled label, one lightly bin-soiled label Full-bodied, with velvety, rich tannins and a long finish. Refined and very well-done WS 11/ bottles per lot HK$15,000-22,000 US$ Sperss Gaja 1997 Piedmont two bin-soiled labels, one lightly scuffed label A virtually perfect effort represents the essence of truffles, earth, and black cherries in its striking aromatics and multidimensional, opulent, full-bodied palate WA 6/ bottles per lot HK$20,000-30,000 US$ Sori Tildin Gaja 1998 Piedmont...it exhibits abundant aromatic fireworks, fabulous fruit concentration, a layered opulence, more intensity, glycerin, and depth than the Costa Russi, and a spectacularly long finish WA 10/ bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Costa Russi Gaja 2000 Piedmont original wood case Full-bodied, with ultra-fine tannins and an incredible finish. This is so fine and so long. A real beauty that grows and grows on the palate. Great Nebbiolo. Greatest Costa Russi ever WS 7/ double magnum (3L) per lot HK$12,000-19,000 US$ Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com 147

148 Sori San Lorenzo Gaja 2000 Piedmont Lot 951: one marked label, original wood case Lot 952: two 3-pack original wood cases Lot 953: lightly bin-soiled label, signs of old seepage, original wood case Full-bodied, with masses of velvety tannins and a long, long, caressing finish. Solid WS 7/ bottles per lot HK$15,000-22,000 US$ bottles per lot HK$19,000-28,000 US$ magnums (1.5L) per lot HK$20,000-30,000 US$ double magnum (3L) per lot HK$10,000-15,000 US$ Sori Tildin Gaja 2000 Piedmont Lot 956: individual original wood cases "Amazing aromas of plums, strawberries and minerals follow through to a full-bodied palate, with ultraripe tannins and a long, mineral and blackberry aftertaste. Gorgeous. So fresh and structured...96." WS 7/ bottles per lot HK$10,000-15,000 US$ bottles per lot HK$17,000-26,000 US$ double magnums (3L) per lot HK$19,000-28,000 US$ Brunello di Montalcino Sugarille Pieve Santa Restituta Gaja 2001 Tuscany bottles per lot HK$12,000-19,000 US$ Sori Tildin Gaja 2001 Piedmont "Full-bodied, with ultra-fine tannins and a long, long finish. Shows wonderful finesse and class...95." WS 10/ bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Sori San Lorenzo Gaja 2001 Piedmont "Full-bodied, with fine tannins and a fresh finish. Lovely. Seductive and racy. Very long indeed. Strength yet finesse...96." WS 10/ bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Barbaresco Gaja 1961 (2) one 2.5cm, one 3.5cm, one bin-soiled label, one lightly binsoiled label Sori Tildin 1970 (2) one 2cm, one 2.5cm, one bin-soiled label, one lightly binsoiled label Sori Tildin 1971 (1) 2cm, bin-soiled label Sori San Lorenzo 1978 (1) 3.5cm, glue-stained and scuffed label 960 above 6 bottles per lot HK$12,000-19,000 US$ Gaja Barbaresco 1989 (1) 2cm, bin-soiled label Barbaresco Sori San Lorenzo 1989 (2) 2cm or better, lightly bin-soiled labels Barbaresco Sori San Lorenzo 1990 (2) 1.5cm or better, lightly bin-soiled labels, one lightly torn label Barbaresco Sori Tildin 1990 (2) 1.5cm or better, one lightly bin-soiled label, one lightly torn label Sperss 1990 (2) bottom neck or better, lightly bin-soiled labels 961 above 9 bottles per lot HK$19,000-28,000 US$ Gaja Sperss 1996 (4) one lightly bin-soiled label, one lightly torn label Costa Russi 2000 (3) Costa Russi 2001 (5) 962 above 12 bottles per lot HK$16,000-24,000 US$ Brunello di Montalcino Pieve Santa Restituta Gaja 1997 Rennina (4) three with importer tags adhered to labels, one nicked label Sugarille (2) one damp-stained label, one scuffed label 963 above 6 bottles per lot HK$ US$ Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com

149 Lots 950 & 951 Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com 149

150 Bruno Giacosa Bruno Giacosa was born in the town of Nieve, within the Barbaresco DOCG. As young as thirteen Bruno was assisting his father and grandfather in the cellars, and by the age of fifteen he was fully employed in the family firm. Bruno s grandfather, Carlo Giacosa, started the firm in the late nineteenth century when the wine was sold in demi-johns and not estate bottled. It was not until the 1960s that the Giacosas began to sell more wine in bottle than in demi-john! Up until 1964 the family did not offer any individual cru bottlings of either Barbaresco or Barolo, and following tradition in the region, they were labeled simply as Barolo or Barbaresco. It is noted that even as far back as Carlo Giacosa s time, the wines were vinified and kept separately in the cellars. The two vineyards which they primarily purchased from at that time, the Gallina and Santo Stefano, were only blended together for the Barbaresco Riserva Speciale and therefore all regular Barbaresco bottlings were in effect two distinct Barbarescos released under the same label. Like so many of the top producers in Piedmont, the Giacosas did not own any of the vineyards from which they made their wines. In 1982, they finally purchased a vineyard holding of their own, the 8.4 hectare Falletto vineyard in the village of Serralunga. This purchase in Barolo was followed up more than a decade later when the Giacosa family bought pieces in two of the greatest terroirs in Barbaresco, the Asili and Rabaja vineyards, in time to produce bottlings of the 1996 vintage. The style of Giacosa s wines are quite traditional, though the fermentations are not quite as long as many of their neighbors of the old school. Typically the maceration will now last from fourteen to twenty-four days for the Barbarescos and Barolos, which is quite a bit shorter than a producer such as Giuseppe Mascarello, whose Barolo Monprivato macerates for at least thirty days (down from sixty days in years past). Following this maceration the wines are racked into large casks called botti and aged for three to four years. The control of the winery is now in the capable hands of daughter Bruna Giacosa and Cellarmaster Dante Scaglione. There are no wines that match the prestige or class of Giacosa s in all of Barbaresco and only a select few which share the crown in Barolo. John Gilman, View From the Cellar Barbaresco Santo Stefano di Neive Bruno Giacosa 1978 Piedmont top shoulder, bin-soiled label bottle per lot HK$ US$ Barolo Bussia di Monforte Riserva Speciale Bruno Giacosa 1978 Piedmont bottom neck or better, lightly bin-soiled and scuffed labels bottles per lot HK$14,000-20,000 US$ Barolo Collina Rionda di Serralunga Bruno Giacosa 1978 Piedmont bottom neck, lightly scuffed label bottle per lot HK$15,000-22,000 US$ Barbaresco Santo Stefano di Neive Riserva Bruno Giacosa 1982 Piedmont two bottom neck or better, one very top shoulder, one lightly torn label, scuffed labels "At once delicate and powerful, it shows the notable structure of the 1982 vintage and promises to deliver a profound, emotionally moving drinking experience...98." WA 4/ bottles per lot HK$19,000-28,000 US$ Barbaresco Santo Stefano di Neive Riserva Bruno Giacosa 1985 Piedmont three bottom neck or better, one very top shoulder, one lightly scuffed label "The wine is full-bodied, gorgeously-nuanced, and multidimensional, with considerable glycerin and layers of flavor. It unfolds fabulously in the mouth, exhibiting remarkable intensity and complexity...96." WA 2/ bottles per lot HK$36,000-55,000 US$ Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com

151 Barolo Falletto di Serralunga Riserva Bruno Giacosa 1985 Piedmont bottom neck or better, one lightly bin-soiled label, one lightly scuffed label bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Barolo Falletto di Serralunga Riserva Bruno Giacosa 1990 Piedmont bottom neck or better "...huge, massively proportioned, thick, and muscular...95." WA 4/ bottles per lot HK$19,000-28,000 US$ Barolo Falletto di Serralunga Riserva Bruno Giacosa 1996 Piedmont faded labels "This muscular, massive wine gave me chills. It is an exquisite, virtually perfect Barolo...Awesome!...98." WA 6/ bottles per lot HK$20,000-30,000 US$ Bruno Giacosa 1997 Barbaresco Santo Stefano di Neive (6) Barolo Falletto di Serralunga (6) Barolo Le Rocche del Falletto (5) one lightly bin-soiled label, two lightly scuffed labels 975 above 17 bottles per lot HK$16,000-24,000 US$ Bruno Giacosa 2000 Barbaresco Rabaja (6) two lightly damp-stained labels Barbaresco Santo Stefano di Neive (6) Barolo Falletto di Serralunga (6) Barolo Le Rocche del Falletto di Serralunga Riserva (1) 976 above 19 bottles per lot HK$19,000-28,000 US$ Bruno Giacosa Barolo Falletto di Serralunga 2001 (6) Barbaresco Asili 2007 (6) 977 above 12 bottles per lot HK$11,000-16,000 US$ Barbaresco Rabaja Riserva Bruno Giacosa 2001 Piedmont "...explosive, deeply spiced balsamic nose, layers of sweet dark fruit and big, imposing structure...98." WA 10/ bottles per lot HK$11,000-16,000 US$ Barbaresco Asili Riserva Bruno Giacosa 2007 Piedmont "...sweet, perfumed and totally gorgeous in its round, sensual fruit. Silky, elegant tannins frame the long, harmonious finish...97." WA 2/ bottles per lot HK$12,000-19,000 US$ Bruno Giacosa Barbaresco Santo Stefano di Neive Riserva 1990 (1) bottom neck Barolo Villero di Castiglione Falletto 1990 (3) bottom neck or better, one scuffed label Barbaresco Santo Stefano di Neive Riserva 1998 (2) scuffed labels 974 above 6 bottles per lot HK$14,000-20,000 US$ Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com 151

152 Lots 978 & Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com

153 Soldera In Brunello di Montalcino one name more than any other is sought out by collectors the world over, it is that of Gianfranco Soldera at his Case Basse estate in Brunello. These are simply special wines, the hallmarks here are incredible depth, knockout texture and of course supreme complexity. Although relatively recent when compared to many in the region, beginning only in the late 1970s, Soldera has earned a reputation for quality that is second to none. Soldera embodies a rare combination of both modern and traditional techniques. Green harvesting, sorting tables and then ageing for five plus years in large old Slovenian oak casks. The results are remarkable and almost hard to believe, yet year after year the boundary for quality is pushed to its limits, and they age superbly too. 在芸芸眾多的 Brunello di Montalcino 當中, 僅有來自 Gianfranco Soldera 的 Case Basse 莊園出品才令當世收藏家趨之若鶩 她是一款特別的葡萄酒, 特點在於令人難以置信的深度 傑出的質感 出眾的複雜性 雖然 Soldera 創立於 20 世紀 70 年代末, 並相對於同區的其他酒莊年輕 歷史較短, 但它一向以高質量見稱, 並以質量第一贏得了尊重及聲譽 Soldera 體現了現代及傳統釀酒技藝罕見但完美的揉合 酒莊採用綠色收割法 善用篩選枱 然後將原液注入古舊的斯洛文尼亞大型橡木桶中醇化五年以上 經過以上多番程序, 成品非常出色, 令人驚喜 ;Soldera 年復一年的釀製出色佳釀, 將其作品質量推至了極緻, 而他的醇化陳年亦非常出色 Brunello di Montalcino Case Basse Soldera 1985 Tuscany bottom neck or better, lightly bin-soiled labels bottles per lot HK$26,000-38,000 US$ Brunello di Montalcino Riserva Case Basse Soldera 1990 Tuscany very top shoulder, one lightly scuffed label, different importers "...extremely powerful and full-bodied, with layers of highly concentrated, ripe fruit. Despite its massive size, it retains a gracefulness and sense of elegance...98." WA 4/ bottles per lot HK$14,000-20,000 US$ Brunello di Montalcino Riserva Intistieti Case Basse Soldera 1995 Tuscany five lightly bin-soiled labels, two lightly scuffed labels, one loose capsule reveals fully branded cork, four different importers bottles per lot HK$26,000-38,000 US$ Brunello di Montalcino Riserva Case Basse Soldera 1997 Tuscany Lot 981: two lightly scuffed labels, one scuffed label Lot 982: two lightly scuffed labels, one torn capsule reveals fully branded cork, two different importers Lot 983: six lightly scuffed labels, one lightly torn label "Silky and seamless but also gripping, with a powerful spine of acidity framing and carrying the pungent strawberry, raspberry, rose petal and mineral flavors " IWC 10/ bottles per lot HK$34,000-50,000 US$ bottles per lot HK$34,000-50,000 US$ bottles per lot HK$34,000-50,000 US$ Brunello di Montalcino Riserva Case Basse Soldera 2001 Tuscany Parcel: lots 984 & 985 "Deceptively medium-bodied at this stage, it appears to be holding back much of its potential but will be a remarkable wine in another decade or so. This is a superb effort from Montalcino's most eccentric producer...96." WA 11/ bottles per lot HK$34,000-50,000 US$ bottles per lot HK$34,000-50,000 US$ Brunello di Montalcino Riserva Case Basse Soldera 2004 Tuscany "From start to finish this is a towering effort. The 2004 Riserva is so beautiful it can be enjoyed with no guilt whatsoever today " WA 5/ bottles per lot HK$16,000-24,000 US$ bottles per lot HK$32,000-50,000 US$ Brunello di Montalcino Riserva Case Basse Soldera 1995 (2) lightly bin-soiled labels 1996 (5) 988 above 7 bottles per lot HK$19,000-28,000 US$ Barolo Cantina Mascarello 1964 Piedmont one 2cm, one 3.5cm, one damp-stained label, one lightly damp-stained label, signs of old seepage bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Barolo Sandrone 1978 Piedmont three 2.5cm, one 3cm, one bin-soiled label, three lightly dampstained labels, one lightly scuffed label bottles per lot HK$10,000-15,000 US$ Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com 153

154 Barolo Bricco Bussia Vigna Cicala Aldo Conterno 1990 Piedmont 1.5cm or better, one lightly bin-soiled label, one lightly nicked label, two lightly scuffed labels, one torn label, one winestained label, two different importers "The super-concentrated 1990 Barolo Vigna Cicala Bussia is an outstanding wine " WA 4/ bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Messorio-Merlot Macchiole 1998 Tuscany one 6-pack original wood case three lightly scuffed labels "Super-ripe blueberries, blackberries, tar, licorice and smoke are just some of the nuances that flow from the sweet, textured " WA 3/ bottles per lot HK$15,000-22,000 US$ Barolo Cannubi Boschis Sandrone 1997 Piedmont one lightly scuffed label, one scuffed label "...sweet nose of black fruits, minerals, scorched earth, smoke, dried herbs, and wet stones...tremendous unctuousity yet superb delineation...fabulous extract as well as a multidimensional mid-palate and finish...96." WA 6/ bottles per lot HK$15,000-22,000 US$ Barolo Brunate Roberto Voerzio 1997 Piedmont two 3-pack original wood cases "Full-bodied, with a wonderful concentration of fruit. Big and velvety, yet refined and caressing " WS 11/ magnums (1.5L) per lot HK$12,000-19,000 US$ Barolo La Serra Roberto Voerzio 1997 Piedmont "Full-bodied, with very refined, polished tannins and a super long, sweet fruit aftertaste. Goes on and on...97." WS 11/ bottles per lot HK$12,000-19,000 US$ Percarlo San Giusto a Rentennano 1997 Tuscany bottles per lot HK$10,000-15,000 US$ Redigaffi Tua Rita 2000 Tuscany "Boasting great intensity, glorious ripeness, formidable purity, and a finish that lasts nearly a minute, this is the stuff of dreams! " WA 12/ bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Redigaffi Tua Rita 2001 Tuscany original wood case "Full-bodied, with loads of black pepper and spice, refined tannins and a super long finish...97." WS 10/ bottles per lot HK$12,000-19,000 US$ Brunello di Montalcino Montosoli Altesino 2001 Tuscany bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Brunello di Montalcino Riserva Madonna del Piano Valdicava 2001 Tuscany "This is so complex and long, and the mouthfeel is spellbinding. Develops wonderfully in the glass, becoming more and more rich with air. One of the greatest Brunellos I have ever tasted " WS 4/ bottles per lot HK$11,000-19,000 US$ Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com

155 Brunello di Montalcino Valdicava 2001 Tuscany two 6-pack original cartons bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Redigaffi Tua Rita 2004 Tuscany two 6-pack original wood cases "Full-bodied, with super silky tannins and a long, long finish. Harmonious and wonderful...98." WS 10/ bottles per lot HK$11,000-19,000 US$ Barolo Barbero Giorgio 1961 (6) three very top shoulder, two just below top shoulder, one upper shoulder, two heavily torn labels, one lightly torn label, two torn labels, one wine-stained label, one lightly corroded capsule, four with signs of old seepage Marchesi di Barolo 1961 (5) three 2cm or better, one 3.5cm, one 4.5cm, lightly dampstained labels, two corroded capsules, one torn capsule reveals partially branded cork, signs of old seepage Riserva Ceretto 1964 (2) one very top shoulder, one top shoulder, lightly bin-soiled labels 1003 above 13 bottles per lot HK$13,000-19,000 US$ Barolo Gran Bussia Aldo Conterno 1985 (2) 2cm or better, lightly scuffed labels, one lightly wine-stained label 1989 (1) 1.5cm, lightly scuffed label 1004 above 3 bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Vigna L'Apparita Castello di Ama bottom neck or better unless noted 1988 (4) one heavily torn label, one lightly bin-soiled label 1989 (6) lightly bin-soiled labels 1990 (6) one very top shoulder, lightly bin-soiled labels 1995 (6) 1005 above 22 bottles per lot HK$16,000-24,000 US$ Barolo Cannubi Boschis Sandrone 1989 (1) 1cm, lightly scuffed label 1990 (2) 1cm or better, one lightly oxidized capsule 1995 (2) 1996 (5) 1006 above 10 bottles per lot HK$16,000-24,000 US$ Barolo Aldo Conterno Bricco Bussia Vigna Cicala 1989 (3) 2cm or better, lightly bin-soiled labels, two lightly nicked labels 1990 (1) 1.5cm Bricco Bussia Vigna Colonnello 1990 (3) 1cm or better, one lightly marked label, two lightly winestained labels Cicala 1996 (4) lightly scuffed labels 1007 above 11 bottles per lot HK$11,000-16,000 US$ Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com 155

156 Barolo Bricco Rocche Ceretto 1990 (4) two bottom neck or better, two very top shoulder, lightly binsoiled labels Bricotto Bussia Clerico 1990 (2) bottom neck or better, bin-soiled labels Pajana Clerico 1990 (1) top shoulder, wine-stained and lightly bin-soiled label, signs of old seepage Riserva La Rocca e la Pira Roagna 1990 (3) one bottom neck, one very top shoulder, one top shoulder, one scuffed label, one torn label Riserva Pira e Figli 1990 (2) one 2cm, one 2.5cm, lightly nicked labels Villero Riserva Vietti 1996 (6) one nicked label, one scuffed label 1008 above 18 bottles per lot HK$19,000-28,000 US$ Brunello di Montalcino Riserva Altesino 1990 (5) four very top shoulder, one top shoulder Vigna del Quercione Riserva Campogiovanni 1990 (2) bottom neck or better, lightly bin-soiled labels Salvioni 2001 (6) 1009 above 13 bottles per lot HK$11,000-16,000 US$ No Lot Barolo Roberto Voerzio Barolo Cerequio 1997 (5) one lightly marked label Brunate 1998 (3) Cerequio 1998 (3) La Serra 1998 (3) Rocche dell'annunziata Torriglione 2004 (1) 1011 above 15 bottles per lot HK$12,000-19,000 US$ Brunello di Montalcino 1997 Altesino (6) Siro Pacenti (5) Tenuta Nuova Casanova di Neri (6) 1012 above 17 bottles per lot HK$11,000-16,000 US$ Brunello di Montalcino Vigna di Pianrosso Ciacci Piccolomini d Aragona Riserva 1997 (6) 1997 (6) 1013 above 12 bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Castello dei Rampolla Sammarco 1997 (4) Vigna d Alceo 1997 (3) Vigna d Alceo 1999 (6) two different importers Vigna d Alceo 2000 (4) 1014 above 17 bottles per lot HK$13,000-19,000 US$ Le Macchiole Messorio 1997 (6) two lightly scuffed labels Scrio Syrah 1997 (5) Messorio 2004 (6) individual original wood cases 1015 above 17 bottles per lot HK$19,000-28,000 US$ Redigaffi Tua Rita 1997 (2) heavily faded labels obscure vintage 1998 (5) 1016 above 7 bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Barolo Roberto Voerzio 2000 Brunate (6) La Serra (6) Rocche dell'annunziata Torriglione (6) one lightly nicked label 1017 above 18 bottles per lot HK$19,000-28,000 US$ Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com

157 Lots spain spain Spain Pingus Pingus is a very new and hugely successful winery in Ribera del Duero. Run by a young, Danish born renowned winemaker, Peter Sisseck, the winery has produced astonishing results (and prices) in a very short period of time. Located in a winery said by John Radford, Spanish wine expert, to resemble a pink flying saucer, Pingus is part of an elite club of top Spanish wine producers. Yields are incredibly low, the wines are extremely concentrated, allocation is miniscule. Crianza and Reserva wines are made from ancient, gnarled Tempranillo vines. Sisseck is said to be a genius in the vineyard, where pruning has become an art form. Pingus 是位西班牙北部 Ribera del Duero 區的新酒莊, 它的歷史雖則不長, 但卻出類拔萃, 名留青史 這西班牙酒莊背後的主人是一名年輕 聞名於世的丹麥釀酒師 :Peter Sisseck; 這酒莊在非常短的時間裡已創造出驚人的成就 ( 當然包括驚人的價格 ) 西班牙葡萄酒專家 John Radford 曾說過,Pingus 就像一隻在酒區中飛翔的粉紅色飛碟, 特別出眾耀眼, 而它更是頂級西班牙酒莊精英俱樂部的一份子 Pingus 產量非常低, 但葡萄酒非常集中, 分配量不大 佳釀級及珍藏級葡萄酒由古老, 精緻的丹魄葡萄酒製成 Sisseck 是洋酒界的天才, 他的出品可堪稱藝術品 Pingus 1995 Ribera del Duero importer tags adhered to lightly bin-soiled labels "The palate is medium-bodied with surprising succulent on the entry underpinned by crisp acidity. There is almost a sense of conservatism to this Pingus, but it is undeniably well balanced...92." WA 8/ bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Pingus 1996 Ribera del Duero lightly scuffed labels, two different importers "Massive in the mouth, with a sumptuous texture, immense body, high levels of glycerin, and a multilayered mid-palate...96." WA 4/ bottles per lot HK$11,000-16,000 US$ Pingus 1998 Ribera del Duero "This full-bodied, opulently-textured, viscous, concentrated wine is fat, expansively flavored, and multilayered. It is an outstanding effort, with well-integrated acidity and tannin " WA 4/ bottles per lot HK$11,000-19,000 US$ Pingus 1999 Ribera del Duero short capsules reveal vintage branded corks "Enormous levels of extract and richness are accompanied by a full-bodied, glycerin-imbued, thick, viscous finish. The tannin is nearly hidden by the wine's wealth of fruit and concentration...98." WA 8/ bottles per lot HK$38,000-55,000 US$ Pingus 2000 Ribera del Duero short capsules reveal vintage branded corks "The palate is fully loaded with glycerine-rich black fruit that lends it an unctuous texture that is neatly counterbalanced by requisite acidity. This is the Pingus that the 1998 wanted to be...96." WA 8/ bottles per lot HK$17,000-26,000 US$ Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com 157

158 Pingus 2001 Ribera del Duero one scuffed label, short capsules reveal vintage branded corks "...copious quantities of barbecue smoke-infused blackberry and cassis flavors. The finish lasts for nearly a minute...95." WA 4/ bottles per lot HK$20,000-30,000 US$ Pingus 2003 Ribera del Duero one lightly bin-soiled label, short capsules reveal vintage branded corks "The palate is rounded and opulent on the entry: an unashamedly luscious wine with a silky-smooth texture...94." WA 8/ bottles per lot HK$20,000-30,000 US$ Pingus 2004 Ribera del Duero original wood case "The tannins are totally concealed and the pure finish is remarkably long " WA 2/ bottles per lot HK$28,000-42,000 US$ Pingus 2005 Ribera del Duero three lightly scuffed labels, short capsules reveal vintage branded corks "...notes of toasty new oak, mineral, scorched earth, espresso, blueberry, and blackberry can be discerned...99." WA 2/ bottles per lot HK$24,000-36,000 US$ Pingus 2006 Ribera del Duero short capsules reveal vintage branded corks "Voluptuous on the palate in a measured way, it has superb balance, layered, complex flavors, ripe tannin that is entirely covered by the fruit...98." WA 6/ bottles per lot HK$22,000-32,000 US$ Pingus 2009 Ribera del Duero two 6-pack original wood cases "The nose is very perfumed and balsamic, with notes of violets and ripe, juicy fruit, quite high-pitched. The oak is well-integrated into the wine. The palate is very powerful, full-bodied, concentrated but balanced...97." WA 7/ bottles per lot HK$42,000-60,000 US$ Pingus 2010 Ribera del Duero short capsules reveal vintage branded corks "The palate is medium-bodied, with very fine tannins good acidity and freshness. This is really superb, with astonishing balance and power. With time in the glass it develops more complex aromas...98." WA 8/ bottles per lot HK$42,000-60,000 US$ Pingus 2011 Ribera del Duero short capsules reveal vintage branded corks "Big and powerful with so much dried fruit, black cherry and toasted oak. Rich and very long. A voluptuous wine...95." JS 7/ bottles per lot HK$22,000-32,000 US$ Pingus 2013 Ribera del Duero original wood case Full body, very layered and refined. Ultra-fine tannins. Wonderful length JS 7/ bottles per lot HK$17,000-24,000 US$ Pingus Amelia 2003 (4) 2005 (6) one lightly scuffed label 1033 above 10 bottles per lot HK$17,000-26,000 US$ Pingus 2008 Ribera del Duero short capsules reveal vintage branded corks "The palate is blessed with a Château Margaux-like sense of symmetry that leads to a tensile, precise finish that carries on for a minute in the mouth. This will turn out to be an awesome Pingus...97." WA 8/ bottles per lot HK$19,000-28,000 US$ Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com

159 Vega Sicilia Vega Sicilia, often called the Lafite of Spain for its elegance, is among the oldest extant wineries in Spain and remains among its most celebrated. Toribio Lecanda purchased 2,000 acres of farmland from the Marquis de Valbuena in 1848, but it was not until 1864 that his son, Eloy, began to convert it to viticulture by planting Cabernet Sauvignon, Malbec and Pinot Noir. Originally, he made brandy, and even before it was a winery Vega Sicilia was appointed to be the brandy supplier to the royal family of Spain. Vega Sicilia Único ( unique ) and Valbuena both date from 1915, when the vineyards had recovered sufficiently from phylloxera to permit great wine to be made. Único, made only in outstanding years, is typically mostly Tempranillo, with the balance Cabernet Sauvignon, Malbec and Merlot. It spends at least seven years in barrel, and at least three in bottle, before release, and in some vintages, it is aged for astonishingly long periods before it reaches the market. The 1970, for example, was not released until 1995, and magnums did not follow until 2000! The wine lives up to its designation as unique. It is intensely fragrant, complex on the palate but also extremely concentrated, with very high acidity to balance the richness. Occasionally, the winery will release a small quantity of wine designated Reserva Especial, a blend of two or three Únicos; these bottlings are generally considered to be of the same high quality as the single vintage releases. Vega Sicilia 是西班牙最古老及最著名的酒莊之一, 因為她的優雅而經常被稱為西班牙的拉菲古堡 她的歷史可追溯至十九世紀中期 年,Toribio Lecanda 當時從 Marquis de Valbuena 手中購入了 2,000 英畝的農地, 在往後的 16 年間, 這塊土地僅被用作耕種一般的農作物 ; 直至 1864 年,Toribio Lecanda 的兒子 Eloy 開始種植赤霞珠 馬爾貝克及黑皮諾等葡萄, 將普通的農地打造成手屈一指的葡萄酒莊園 Eloy 他於早期只專注釀造香醇濃郁的高品質白蘭地, 並早於 Vega Sicilia 酒莊建立以前, 他更是西班牙王室的白蘭地指定供應商 直至 1915 年, 葡萄園從葡萄根瘤蚜蟲禍完全恢復過來, 並有力生產出偉大的葡萄酒, 因此兩款著名的葡萄酒 Vega Sicilia Único ( unique ) 及 Valbuena 便從此誕生 Único 只於特別好的年份才釀製, 成份以丹魄為主, 混合少量的赤霞珠 馬爾貝克及梅洛 這款葡萄酒在釀製過程中必需於酒桶中醇化至少七年, 並需經歷三次轉桶, 一些年份的佳釀在推出巿場之前, 甚至醇化更長時間 ; 以 1970 年的佳釀為例, 它直至 1995 年才推出巿面, 而 1.5 公升裝更於 2000 年才面世 Vega Sicilia Único 1962 Ribera del Duero four very top shoulder, one top shoulder, four lightly dampstained labels, two lightly nicked labels, one scuffed label, one lightly corroded capsule, three different importers "Youthful, vivacious and utterly compelling, this is a profound wine that even after four decades is surfeit with precocity. Undoubtedly, this must be one of the greatest Spanish wines to have graced this planet " WA 8/ bottles per lot HK$42,000-60,000 US$ Vega Sicilia Único 1964 Ribera del Duero Lot 1035: one very top shoulder, three top shoulder, three just below top shoulder, two upper shoulder, eight lightly glue-stained labels, two lightly nicked labels, one lightly winestained label, four corroded capsules, two different importers, two with signs of old seepage Lot 1036: bottom neck or better, bin-soiled labels, one winestained label, one depressed cork, one oxidized capsule "There are vibrant citrus fruits on the finish that ensure the '64 remains exuberant and vivacious...but overall, this remains a seductive Único of immense breeding and passion...96." WA 8/ bottles per lot HK$32,000-50,000 US$ magnums (1.5L) per lot HK$16,000-24,000 US$ Vega Sicilia Único 1968 Ribera del Duero top shoulder, one lightly nicked label, one nicked label "An awesome wine!...extremely full-bodied, massively rich, and unctuous, with layers of jammy fruit, adequate acidity, and moderate tannin, this huge wine's well-focused, structural component keeps everything in balance...98." WA 2/ bottles per lot HK$14,000-20,000 US$ Vega Sicilia Único 1970 Ribera del Duero three very top shoulder, three top shoulder, one just below top shoulder, one bin-soiled label, two lightly nicked labels, one lightly scuffed label, four scuffed labels, three different importers "It has a thrilling Bordeaux-like personality on the nose that is more aloof than other vintages. The Cabernet component in the blend is pronounced, forming the backbone and austerity of this wine...97." WA 8/ bottles per lot HK$32,000-50,000 US$ Vega Sicilia Único 1981 Ribera del Duero two bottom neck or better, two very top shoulder, two top shoulder, one lightly nicked label, one nicked label, three different importers "There is a sense of symmetry, the leitmotif of great Único wines. Fresh and vital, this 1981 is a stunning addition to the pantheon of great wines from this estate...96." WA 8/ bottles per lot HK$14,000-20,000 US$ Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com 159

160 Vega Sicilia Único 1983 Ribera del Duero two very top shoulder, one top shoulder, three just below top shoulder, four lightly bin-soiled labels, one lightly wine-stained label, one corroded capsule, one with signs of old seepage "...this huge, rich, concentrated wine is already multi-dimensional and complex, as well as unbelievably delicious...95." WA 4/ bottles per lot HK$12,000-19,000 US$ Vega Sicilia Único 1986 Ribera del Duero two bottom neck or better, four very top shoulder, two lightly scuffed labels, four scuffed labels, one with signs of old seepage "A harmonious wine, that appears to have much of its development ahead of it, there is good glycerin, full body, copious tannin, and a backward yet promising style...92." WA 4/ bottles per lot HK$13,000-19,000 US$ Vega Sicilia Único 1989 Ribera del Duero bottom neck or better "It possesses tremendous density, an opulent, textured, fullbodied palate, great purity, and moderate tannin...94." WA 2/ bottles per lot HK$12,000-19,000 US$ Vega Sicilia Único 1990 Ribera del Duero bottom neck or better, two different importers "There is great weight and potency, building in the mouth that is rich in glycerine and climaxes with a spicy, meaty finish that tightly grips the mouth. It has a Right Bank, Cabernet Franc like persona...96." WA 8/ bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Lot Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com

161 Vega Sicilia Único 1994 Ribera del Duero Lot 1044: two lightly scuffed labels Lot 1045: four 3-pack original wood cases "This bodega has produced many profound wines, but the 1994 Único Reserva may be the greatest vintage released since their legendary 1970 and A truly prodigious effort...it should be a wine for the history books " WA 6/ bottles per lot HK$26,000-38,000 US$ bottles per lot HK$32,000-50,000 US$ Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com 161

162 Vega Sicilia Reserva Especial NV Ribera del Duero Lot 1046: eight bottom neck or better, two very top shoulder, one top shoulder, one lightly bin-soiled label, one marked label, one scuffed label, one with signs of old seepage, one Lot 024/00, one Lot 024/04, four Lot 004/99, three Lot 018/98, two Lot 005/96 Lot 1047: eleven Lot 024/04, one Lot 004/ bottles per lot HK$16,000-24,000 US$ bottles per lot HK$17,000-26,000 US$ Vega Sicilia Único 1976 (2) two bottom neck or better, bin-soiled labels, one scuffed label 1985 (1) one top shoulder, one lightly marked label 1048 above 3 bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ L Ermita Velles Vinyes Alvaro Palacios 1998 Priorat two lightly bin-soiled labels, one lightly nicked label "The blockbuster, opaque purple-colored 1998 L'Ermita (the finest since the 1995 and 1994) exhibits a full-bodied personality...this is an exceptionally impressive/expressive wine...97." WA 8/ bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ L'Ermita Velles Vinyes Alvaro Palacios 1994 (2) 1995 (2) 1997 (3) one lightly scuffed label partially obscures vintage, loose capsules reveal fully branded corks 1999 (6) one scuffed label, two different importers 2001 (2) 1050 above 15 bottles per lot HK$19,000-28,000 US$ Marques de Murrieta Castillo Ygay Gran Reserva Especial 1970 Rioja six bottom neck or better, one very top shoulder bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com

163 Lots port port Port Burmeister Port Riserva Novidade 1887 Douro very top shoulder, faded label, signs of old seepage bottle per lot HK$ US$ Fonseca 1977 Douro eleven bottom neck or better, one very top shoulder, importer tags adhered to bin-soiled labels, two corroded capsules, two different importers, four with signs of old seepage "What amazing aromas of berry and flowers. Full and sweet, the tannins are complete dissolved. The fruit is perfect. This goes on for minutes " JS 8/ bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Fonseca 1992 (3) one bin-soiled label 1994 (10) five lightly scuffed labels, one scuffed label, two different importers 1054 above 13 bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Quinta do Noval Nacional 1963 Douro bottom neck or better, one deteriorated label, one partially deteriorated label, one with tape adhered to label, one with signs of old seepage "Like several other of the very best 1963 Ports, the 63 Nacional is still a fairly young wine and will continue to dazzle for another fifty or sixty years. It was an absolute privilege to taste this legendary wine! " JBG 10/ bottles per lot HK$32,000-50,000 US$ Quinta do Noval Nacional 1997 Douro four lightly bin-soiled labels, one lightly scuffed label "On the palate the wine is deep, full-bodied and nascently complex, with a sappy core of fruit, suave tannins and simply outstanding length and grip on the focused and still very youthful finish " JBG 10/ bottles per lot HK$22,000-32,000 US$ Quinta do Noval Nacional 2000 Douro "On the palate the wine is pure, full-bodied and very vibrant, with great mid-palate depth, firm, ripe tannins and a very long, quite powerful and still very youthful finish " JBG 10/ bottles per lot HK$ US$ Taylor Fladgate 1955 (2) bottom neck or better, bin-soiled labels, one Berry Bros & Rudd label, fully embossed capsules 1963 (1) just below top shoulder, sticker adhered to lightly bin-soiled label, chipped wax capsule partially reveals cork, signs of old seepage 1966 (1) bottom neck, scuffed label, shipper label, fully embossed capsule 1058 above 4 bottles per lot HK$ US$ Mixed Port Burmeister Reserva 1963 (1) into neck, bin-soiled label Croft 1963 (1) bottom neck, bin-soiled and scuffed label, embossed capsule Warres 1963 (1) bottom neck, lightly wine-stained label, Grant's shipper label, fully embossed capsule Fonseca 1970 (2) bottom neck or better, one bin-soiled label, one scuffed label, one with tape adhered to label, one Army and Navy Store's embossed capsule, slightly protruded corks 1059 above 5 bottles per lot HK$ US$ Mixed Port Taylor Fladgate 1992 (1) scuffed label Taylor Fladgate 1994 (6) four lightly bin-soiled labels, two different importers Quinta do Noval 1997 (6) 1060 above 13 bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com 163

164 Lots madeira madeira Madeira Madeira Malvasia Reserva Velha Barbeito 1834 Madeira bottom neck or better, one lightly bin-soiled label, two lightly scuffed labels, one chipped wax capsule, one bottled in February 2000, two bottled in September 2000, Rare Wine Co Selection bottles per lot HK$19,000-28,000 US$ Madeira Boal Barbeito 1863 Madeira bottom neck or better, stenciled labels, different bottlings bottles per lot HK$11,000-19,000 US$ Madeira Malvazia Barbeito bottom neck, stenciled label, bottled in October 2000, Rare Wine Co Selection Reserva Velha 1875 (1) 1875 (1) 1063 above 2 bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Madeira Malvasia Reserva Velha Barbeito 1900 Madeira bottom neck or better, lightly chipped wax capsules, bottled in February 2000, Rare Wine Co Selection bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Madeira Sercial Reserva d Oliveiras 1862 Madeira bottom neck or better, stenciled labels bottles per lot HK$14,000-20,000 US$ Madeira Reserva d Oliveiras bottom neck or better, stenciled labels Verdelho 1850 (1) Terrantez 1880 (1) Malvasia 1900 (2) Verdelho 1900 (1) 1066 above 5 bottles per lot HK$19,000-28,000 US$ Madeira Sercial Cossart Gordon Solera 1860 (1) very top shoulder, importer tag adhered to wine-stained label, signs of old seepage Bual Blandys 1907 (2) bottom neck or better, stenciled labels Boal Reserva Barbeito 1920 (1) bottom neck, stenciled label 1067 above 4 bottles per lot HK$13,000-19,000 US$ Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com

165 Lots massandra Massandra Massandra Situated on the Black Sea in modern Ukraine s Crimea are the esteemed vineyards and winery of Massandra. The area was first planted with vines in the mid-nineteenth century when it was still a part of Imperial Russia. Vineyards around Massandra have long supported a widely heterogeneous assortment of imported grape varietals from around Europe. From the beginning the refinement of wines produced at Massandra quickly attracted favorable attention from the Tsar himself. By the twilight of the nineteenth century Massandra was producing an array of wines specifically for the Tsar bearing his seal. The best known Massandra wines have always been of the dessert variety, emulating a range of styles from Sherry to Madeira, Port to Marsala, and Tokays to Muscats. Perhaps as deserving of legend as the Massandra wines themselves is the vast and intricate system of cellars bored into the mountainsides. The labyrinth of cellars boasts 21 different 150 meter tunnels where strategically placed air shafts maintain a constant degrees Centigrade. Natural springs also sustain cellar humidity levels at percent. These conditions have allowed wines at Massandra to age under prime conditions, with many examples going back to the estate s inception. Massandra still produces and ages superior wines, both sweet and dry, and is sitting on a comprehensive library of all the wines produced there since the beginning. Having survived both the Russian Revolution and World War II unscathed, the cellars of Massandra are a living page out of Eastern European History. These wines were famously put on display at the Yalta conference where Joseph Stalin, Winston Churchill, and Franklin Roosevelt tasted old vintages of sweet Massandras together in memorable photos. 受人尊敬的 Massandra 葡萄園和釀酒廠位於黑海 現今烏克蘭的克里米亞 在 19 世紀中葉, 當它仍是俄羅斯帝國一部分的時候, 該地區已經開始種植葡萄 一直以來,Massandra 周邊的葡萄園都支持從歐洲各地廣泛地進口不同的葡萄品種 起初,Massandra 釀製的精緻葡萄酒已吸引到沙皇的注意 到了 19 世紀初,Massandra 專門為沙皇釀造一系列葡萄酒, 酒瓶還得到他的封印 最有名的 Massandra 酒, 一向是模仿各種風味的甜酒種類 - 由 Sherry 到 Madeira Port 到 Marsala, 還有 Tokays 到 Muscats 位處山腰上 龐大而複雜的酒窖系統, 就如 Massandra 葡萄酒本身一樣傳奇 這迷宮般的酒窖, 擁有 21 條 150 米不同的隧道, 當中巧妙地放置的空氣軸, 令空間長期保持在攝氏 13 至 14 度 天然的泉水還可令酒窖的濕度水平維持在 90% 至 95% 這些條件讓 Massandra 葡萄酒在優秀的條件下陳年, 從酒莊初期的例子便可知一二 Massandra 仍然生產和陳放頂級的葡萄酒, 有甜也有乾身的, 而且是一個全面的 圖書館, 收藏了酒莊從一開始釀造的葡萄酒 酒莊經歷了俄國革命和第二次世界大戰仍毫髮無損,Massandra 酒窖有如東歐歷史的活頁 這些酒曾經出現在著名的 Yalta conference 上,Joseph Stalin Winston Churchill 和 Franklin Roosevelt 一同品嚐舊年份的甜 Massandras, 至今已成為令人難忘的照片 Massandra Red Port Muscat 1923 Crimea upper shoulder, signs of old seepage bottles per lot HK$ US$ Massandra Livadia White Muscat 1928 Crimea one very top shoulder, one mid shoulder, signs of old seepage bottles per lot HK$ US$ Massandra Al Danil Tokay 1929 Crimea one bottom neck, one top shoulder, one chipped wax capsule, signs of old seepage bottles per lot HK$ US$ Massandra White Muscat 1929 Crimea one bottom neck, two top shoulder, one chipped wax capsule, signs of old seepage bottles per lot HK$ US$ Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com 165

166 Massandra White Muscat 1934 Crimea one upper shoulder, one mid shoulder, heavily chipped wax capsules, signs of old seepage bottles per lot HK$ US$ Massandra Gurzuf Pink Muscat 1937 Crimea mid shoulder, one chipped wax capsule, signs of old seepage bottles per lot HK$ US$ Massandra Ayu Dag Cahors 1938 Crimea one top shoulder, one just below top shoulder, one mid shoulder, signs of old seepage bottles per lot HK$ US$ Massandra White Muscat 1939 Crimea one top shoulder, one upper shoulder, one mid shoulder, one heavily chipped wax capsule fully reveals cork, signs of old seepage bottles per lot HK$ US$ Massandra Pink Muscat 1940 Crimea very top shoulder, one heavily chipped wax capsule bottles per lot HK$ US$ Massandra Livadia Red Port 1940 Crimea mid shoulder, one chipped wax capsule, signs of old seepage bottles per lot HK$ US$ Massandra Livadia White Muscat 1938 Crimea one very top shoulder, one mid shoulder, one with signs of old seepage bottles per lot HK$ US$ Massandra White Muscat 1938 Crimea one 6.5cm, one 8cm, one 9cm, one chipped wax capsule, signs of old seepage bottles per lot HK$ US$ Massandra No. 90 Ayu Dag Cahors 1939 Crimea one just below top shoulder, one upper shoulder, one mid shoulder, signs of old seepage bottles per lot HK$ US$ Massandra Gurzuf Pink Muscat 1939 Crimea one top shoulder, one just below top shoulder, one mid shoulder, signs of old seepage bottles per lot HK$ US$ Massandra White Muscat 1940 Crimea very top shoulder, signs of old seepage bottles per lot HK$ US$ Massandra Alupka White Port 1940 Crimea two upper-mid shoulder, one mid shoulder, signs of old seepage bottles per lot HK$ US$ Massandra South Coast Tokay 1948 Crimea one 4.5cm, one 5cm, one 6.5cm, two heavily chipped wax capsules reveal corks, one with signs of old seepage bottles per lot HK$ US$ Massandra White Muscat 1959 Crimea two top shoulder, one upper shoulder, one chipped wax capsule, signs of old seepage bottles per lot HK$ US$ Massandra Kastel White Muscat 1939 Crimea one upper shoulder, two mid shoulder, signs of old seepage bottles per lot HK$ US$ Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com

167 Lots australia australia Australia Penfolds Grange Penfolds first vineyard was established in 1844 at Magill, South Australia, by Dr. Christopher Rawson Penfold. For over 100 years, Penfolds, like most Australian wineries, produced mostly fortified wines and brandies. In 1950, Penfolds chief winemaker, Max Schubert, visited Europe, primarily to study sherry production in Spain. However, the last leg of the trip was a stop in Bordeaux where he was served forty plus year old examples of the great growths of the region. Being awed by the longevity of these unfortified reds, Shubert sought to produce a wine in Australia endowed with the same long-lived potential as the greats of Bordeaux. On his return to Australia he instituted at Penfolds many of the winemaking techniques he had seen in Bordeaux. Shubert sought greater control over the fermentation process than was typical in Australian wineries at the time. He was, however, limited by Australia s lack of Bordeaux grape varietals. Thus, Schubert decided to base his wine on the Shiraz grape, which was already grown in abundance all over South Australia. The early vintages of this experimental wine were made from Shiraz grapes grown at Magill and Morphett Vale near Adelaide. The wine was aged in new American oak for one year, lending an exotic wood character to match the rich Shiraz fruit. The fulfillment of Shubert s goal became known as Penfolds Grange Hermitage (and after the 1989 vintage simply as Penfolds Grange). The 1952 vintage was Schubert s first commercial vintage. Critics rejected early vintages in their youth for tasting like dry port and Schubert was ordered by the Penfolds Company to stop production in However, he continued making wine in secret for the vintages of 1957, 1958 and 1959 using no oak. In 1960 one of the Company s board members went back to taste the original Granges. At eight or nine years old with a little maturity the 1951, 1952 and 1953 were finally opening up, fruit emerging with the tannins softening, enhanced by the sweetness of the oak. The wines were now showing great promise, the quality finally being recognized and Penfolds resumed commercial production. At that point, Max Schubert and Grange ushered in the modern age of Australian wine. The 1955 vintage of Grange won a gold medal at the Sydney Wine Show in 1962, and since numerous vintages have won 126 gold, seventy-six silver and forty-two bronze medals, plus twentyeight trophies and seven championship awards at various competitions in Australia and abroad. Penfolds Grange is still produced with top quality materials and practices, affording at least a thirty to fifty year lifecycle in the best vintages. Penfolds has been produced every year since 1951, with good bottles from the 1950s and 1960s still affording exceptional drinking. Grange classically displays dazzling aromatics, deep color, and a striking youthfulness with a palate redolent of blackberries, plums, leather, cedar, cassis and smoke. A lovely silky texture is another hallmark of the Grange style. With a track record of unrivalled excellence spanning the last fifty plus vintages, Penfolds Grange has risen to be recognized as Australia s finest wine. Penfolds Grange Hermitage 1976 South Australia five bottom neck or better, one very top shoulder, one just below top shoulder, two lightly bin-soiled labels, one lightly torn label, two wine-stained labels, two with importer tags adhered to labels, two different importers, two reconditioned by Penfolds in 1994, two reconditioned by Penfolds in 2000/2001 "Notes of blackberry liqueur intermixed with cassis, charcoal, new saddle leather, and underbrush resonate from the glass. Huge, thick, unctuously textured, with extraordinary concentration but perfect harmony among all of its elements " WA 2/ bottles per lot HK$38,000-55,000 US$ Penfolds Grange Hermitage 1982 South Australia one bottom neck, four very top shoulder, two top shoulder, one just below top shoulder, one damp-stained label, two wine-stained labels, two lightly oxidized capsules, one with signs of old seepage "The wine seems low in acidity, sweet in tannin with the firmness, ripeness, richness, and powers of seduction. The wine is gorgeously opulent and impossible to resist...95." WA 2/ bottles per lot HK$20,000-30,000 US$ Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com 167

168 Penfolds Grange Hermitage 1986 South Australia one very top shoulder, two top shoulder, one deteriorated label, wine-stained labels, two different importers, signs of old seepage "This multi-dimensional wine's huge extraction of fruit, profound flavor concentration, astonishing balance, and layers of fruit make it the greatest of the modern day Granges...99." WA 8/ bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Penfolds Grange 1995 South Australia four wine-stained labels, two oxidized capsules "A massive wine, majestic in its proportions, combining power and grace in equal measure...tannins swarm in, but don't overwhelm the finish, which echoes all day and night...97." WS 12/ bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Penfolds Grange 1998 South Australia Lot 1091: two different importers Lot 1092: two 6-pack original wood cases "...astonishing wine, utterly seamless, maybe the best Grange yet. Powerful, aristocratic and impressive in the way it gathers up its flavors and lets them hang on and on while the finish lingers...99." WS 5/ bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ bottles per lot HK$28,000-42,000 US$ Penfolds Grange Hermitage 1977 (1) bottom neck, lightly bin-soiled and scuffed label 1980 (4) bottom neck or better, one lightly torn label, two winestained labels, one with sticker adhered to label, three oxidized capsule, two different importers 1093 above 5 bottles per lot HK$11,000-16,000 US$ Penfolds Grange 1990 (3) bottom neck or better, one bin-soiled label, wine-stained labels, one oxidized capsule 1991 (3) bottom neck or better, two lightly bin-soiled labels, one wine-stained label, two different importers 1992 (2) bottom neck or better, wine-stained labels, one with signs of old seepage 1993 (2) wine-stained labels, one with signs of old seepage 1994 (2) one wine-stained label, oxidized capsules 1094 above 12 bottles per lot HK$22,000-32,000 US$ Clarendon Hills Astralis 1994 (2) 1998 (7) 2003 (6) 1095 above 15 bottles per lot HK$14,000-20,000 US$ Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com

169 Lots california california California Abreu Vineyards Madrona Ranch Cabernet Sauvignon 2007 Napa Valley lightly damp-stained labels, one wine-stained label "The 2007 Madrona Ranch is a compelling, creamy-styled red offering an assortment of aromas, including white chocolate, graphite, forest floor, blackberries, cassis and blueberries. Pure, multilayered and super-rich, without any harshness or astringency...98." WA 12/ bottles per lot HK$ US$ Bond Assortment Four Pack 2004 case (1) one bottle each Melbury, Pluribus, St Eden, Vecina, original wood assortment case St Eden Napa Valley Red 2007 (4) one 3-pack original wood case Vecina Napa Valley Red 2007 (1) 1097 above 5 bottles & 1 asortment case per lot HK$17,000-24,000 US$ Bryant Family Vineyard Cabernet Sauvignon 2009 Napa Valley "An impeccable sense of refinement and polish rounds out this huge, glorious Cabernet Sauvignon. This is a wine of extraordinary elegance...97." WA 12/ bottles per lot HK$11,000-16,000 US$ Bryant Family Vineyard Cabernet Sauvignon 2004 (2) one with sticker adhered to label, one lightly scuffed label, one lightly torn label Bettina Bryant Proprietary Blend 2009 (2) 1099 above 4 bottles per lot HK$ US$ Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com 169

170 Harlan Estate 2005 Napa Valley original wood case "...exhibits a gorgeous thick-looking, ruby/purple color in addition to a beautiful nose...full-bodied, dense, pure, and revealing sweeter tannin...97." WA 12/ bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Harlan Estate 2007 Napa Valley one 3-pack original wood case The finish lasts nearly a full minute. Because of its overwhelming richness and sweet tannins, this brilliant wine seems to be approachable now WA 12/ bottles per lot HK$16,000-24,000 US$ Heitz Wine Cellars Martha's Vineyard Cabernet Sauvignon 1974 Napa Valley one top shoulder, one upper shoulder, one bin-soiled label, one lightly damp-stained label, one wine-stained label, one with signs of old seepage "...spectacular, huge, Mouton-Rothschild-like nose...remarkably youthful. Staggeringly concentrated...this is a monumental effort!...98." WA bottles per lot HK$14,000-20,000 US$ Hundred Acre Ark Cabernet Sauvignon 2005 (1) 2008 (3) 2009 (6) 1104 above 10 bottles per lot HK$19,000-28,000 US$ Ridge Vineyards Monte Bello Cabernet Sauvignon 1968 (1) bottom neck, damp-stained label 1970 (2) one bottom neck, one top shoulder, torn labels, one with tape adhered to label, oxidized capsules 1105 above 3 bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Saxum James Berry Vineyard 2007 (1) 2009 (3) 1106 above 4 bottles per lot HK$ US$ Schrader To Kalon Vineyard Cabernet Sauvignon 2009 Beckstoffer (3) RBS Beckstoffer (3) 1107 above 6 bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Hundred Acre Ark Cabernet Sauvignon 2007 Napa Valley...a full-bodied opulence, wonderful intensity, but the wine is not weighty or overripe. Fleshy and voluptuous with terrific floral notes WA 12/ bottles per lot HK$19,000-28,000 US$ Schrader To Kalon Vineyard Cabernet Sauvignon 2009 lightly bin-soiled labels CCS Beckstoffer (3) T6 Beckstoffer (3) 1108 above 6 bottles per lot HK$ ,000 US$ Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com

171 Lot 1100 Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com 171

172 Lots 1109 & Zachys tel / fax / bid@zachys.com zachys.com