APPENDIX F Lee County, FL Gasparilla Island CSRM draft integrated section 934 report & draft environmental assessment I. Overview Public Access and Sharing Assessment The project is located in Lee County, on the lower Gulf of Mexico coast of Florida, about 9 miles south of the entrance to Tampa Bay. Gasparilla Island is bounded on the north by Gasparilla Pass and on the south by Boca Grande Channel. The project length is 2.8 miles and spans Florida Department of Environmental Protection () reference monuments R-1.5 (R-11 plus a 1,2 foot long north extending taper) and R-24.5 (R-24 plus a 6 foot long south extending taper). For the present study a cost share recalculation was completed using Section 13(d) of WRDA 1986 guidelines: costs assigned to developed lands (publicly or privately owned) are cost shared 65 and 35% non-federal. Undeveloped public lands are cost shared 65 and 35% non-federal. s with exclusively private benefits and lands with insufficient parking and/or public are 1% non- Federal cost. s owned by the Federal government are 1 cost. Note that, for the purposes of this report, developed indicates the presence of buildings and/or other infrastructure such as street ends or other transportation facilities. If lands are not within ¼ mile of public and either public parking or a bus stop, then the associated costs will be 1% non-federal. Figure 1 shows a image for subject area depicting R-monuments and public points. Figure 1: image for subject area depicting R-monuments and public points
II. Project area Description The total the project area, based on shore length information provided by the Lee County Property Appraiser s office (verified using Google Earth), is estimated to be about 14,96 feet (or approximately 2.8 miles) long. There are twenty-one (21) property owners who were unwilling to grant the required easements. The combined shore these properties is 11 feet. The costs associated with these areas are covered 1% by the non-federal sponsor. There are multiple parcels that are publicly or privately owned and not publicly ible, i.e., they are not located within ¼ mile of public and public parking. The combined shore these properties is 596 feet. These properties are not cost-shared, and therefore the costs associated with these areas are covered 1% by the non-federal sponsor. There is one property that is federally owned land with shore 99 feet; therefore, the costs associated with this area is covered 1. The rest of the properties in the study area, totaling an estimated 12,373 feet, are publicly ible, developed or undeveloped, public or private lands including transportation facilities comprised of street ends, and the cost share for these lands is covered 65, 35% non-federal. Overall, the cost share for the study area is estimated to be 6.38 and 39.62% non-federal for future nourishment events. A summary is shown in Table 1. Table 1: Sharing Summary for Periodic Nourishment Ownership/ Maximum level of Federal participation x Length of non-federal Participation Developed lands (publicly or privately owned) and undeveloped lands (publicly or privately owned) with public and easements 65% 12,373 8,42 4,331 Developed and undeveloped with no easements % 1,1 1,1 Developed and undeveloped with no public between 1/4 mile % 596 596 Federal owned 1% 99 99 TOTAL 14,96 9,32 5,928 COST SHARE 6.38% 39.62% Additional detail on how percentages were calculated are given in Table 2.
Table 2: Detailed Sharing for Periodic Nourishment PARCEL x (/N) 42 181 SHORE LN Fort Myers Beach 33931 1 1 43 18 18TH ST W Boca Grande 1 5 44 171 17TH ST W Boca Grande 1 2 This list of parcels appear to begin directly south of R-1, but does not include parcels inside the taper to R-1.5. Parcel list extends south to R-24.5 which includes tapers. This parcel is approximately 15 feet south of R-1, the northern boundary of the project. The list does not give cost sharing to parcels north of this. BEGINNING OF AUTHORIZED FEDERAL PROJECT LIMITS 45 beach 17th Street 99 65% 5 N/a 32.5 46 17 17TH ST W Boca Grande 1 65% 291 189.15 1511 GASPARILLA RD Boca Grande 47 69 65% 312 22.8 151 GASPARILLA RD Boca Grande 48 1 65% 283 183.95 49 beach 14th Street 99 65% 51 N/a 33.15 5 14 14TH ST W Boca Grande 1 R-11 % 152 no easement 51 131 13TH ST W Boca Grande 1 % 1 no easement 52 beach 13th Street 99 65% 49 N/a 31.85 53 13 13TH ST W Boca Grande 1 65% 126 81.9 54 1221 12TH ST W Boca Grande 1 65% 12 78 55 beach 12th Street 99 65% 49 N/a 31.85 56 121 12TH ST W Boca Grande 1 % 121 no easement 57 1111 11TH ST W Boca Grande 1 % 124 no easement 58 beach 11th Street 99 65% 51 N/a 33.15 59 111 11TH ST W Boca Grande 1 65% 266 172.9 6 beach 1th Street 99 65% 5 N/a 32.5 61 91 9TH ST W Boca Grande 1 R-12 65% 222 144.3
x (/N) 62 beach 9th Street 99 65% 6 N/a 39 81 GASPARILLA RD Boca Grande 63 1 65% 522 339.3 64 beach 7th Street 99 65% 63 N/a 4.95 65 & 67 888 7th ST E 39 R-13 65% 972 631.8 66 beach 5th Street/Gasparilla Inn 99 65% 124 N/a 8.6 68 beach 4th Street 99 R-14 65% 6 N/a 39 692 4 4TH ST W Boca Grande 1 65% 12 N/a 66.3 361 GILCHRIST AV Boca Grande 7 1 65% 1 65 351 GILCHRIST AV Boca Grande 71 1 65% 5 32.5 341 GILCHRIST AV Boca Grande 72 1 65% 11 65.65 732 31 3RD ST W Boca Grande 1 65% 1 N/a 65 74 public parking 3rd Street 99 65% 6 N/a 39 752 3 3RD ST W Boca Grande 1 65% 1 N/a 65 255 GILCHRIST AV Boca Grande 76 1 65% 151 98.15 235 GILCHRIST AV Boca Grande 77 1 65% 99 64.35 211 GILCHRIST AV Boca Grande 78 1 65% 99 64.35 79 Banyan Street 99 R-15 65% 6 N/a 39 8 2 BANAN ST Boca Grande 1 65% 13 66.95 171 GILCHRIST AV Boca Grande 812 1 65% 124 N/a 8.6 121 GILCHRIST AV Boca Grande 82 1 65% 146 94.9 83 111 GILCHRIST AV Boca Grande 65% 74 48.1 84 public parking 1st Street 99 65% 47 N/a 3.55 852 1 GULF BLVD Boca Grande 1 65% 125 N/a 81.25 86 11 GULF BLVD Boca Grande % 25 no easement 87 13 GULF BLVD Boca Grande 77 R-16 65% 267 173.55 87 9 65% 25 16.25 87 132 GULF BLVD Boca Grande 1 65% 8 52 87 134 GULF BLVD Boca Grande 1 65% 75 48.75 This parcel verified in 213 as developed, not vacant.
x (/N) 87 138 GULF BLVD Boca Grande 1 65% 85 55.25 88 15 GULF BLVD Boca Grande 1 65% 71 46.15 89 16 GULF BLVD Boca Grande 1 65% 121 78.65 9 174 GULF BLVD Boca Grande 1 65% 115 74.75 91 184 GULF BLVD Public Parking & Access 65% 33 N/a 214.5 This was not in 27/28 info provided by sponsor or recorded in the 28 addendum. 92 22 GULF BLVD Boca Grande 88 R-17 1% 99 N/a 99 93 94 95 96 97 98 99 1 11 12 29 GULF BLVD 21 Boca Grande 1 65% 41 26.65 29 GULF BLVD 2 Boca Grande 1 65% 26 16.9 29 GULF BLVD 19 Boca Grande 1 % 28 no easement 29 GULF BLVD 18 Boca Grande 1 65% 27 17.55 29 GULF BLVD 17 Boca Grande 1 65% 27 17.55 29 GULF BLVD 16 Boca Grande 1 65% 3 19.5 29 GULF BLVD 15 Boca Grande 1 65% 3 19.5 29 GULF BLVD 14 Boca Grande 1 65% 27 17.55 29 GULF BLVD 12 Boca Grande 1 65% 28 18.2 29 GULF BLVD 11 Boca Grande 1 R-18 65% 4 26 Google Pro US Parcel Data lists Standard as "MGOV". Assuming this signifies Federal property, therefore cost share remains 1% Fed as it was in 28 addendum. 13 32 GULF BLVD Boca Grande 4 65% 351 16.9 only 26 feet of this parcel is covered by parking and at Parcel Number (91) which covers 1/4 mile (132 feet north and south of its location). 28 evaluation only gave 5% cost share to this parcel. That value was maintained for 213, However, it should likely be 65%.
x (/N) 14 beach Seagrape Colony/Boca grande beach resort 9 65% 19 N/a 12.35 15 34 GULF BLVD Boca Grande 1 65% 55 35.75 55 16 344 GULF BLVD Boca Grande 1 65% 62 4.3 117 17 35 GULF BLVD Boca Grande 1 65% 123 79.95 24 Added to evaluation due to fact that sponsor has easement (2 ft walkway for public use and to the beach). In Google Earth, street-view, and parking can be seen. However signs on south side of entrance apprears to read "All parking reserved for residents", and "Members Only". There is potential on-street parking, but no public parking/ signs are apparent. 18 beach Seagrape Colony 9 65% 22 N/a 14.3 262 19 356 GULF BLVD Boca Grande 1 65% 77 11 36 GULF BLVD 66 Boca Grande 65% 75 111 37 GULF BLVD Boca Grande 65% 68 112 38 GULF BLVD 1 Boca Grande 1 65% 28 113 38 GULF BLVD 2 Boca Grande 1 65% 16 114 38 GULF BLVD 3 Boca Grande 1 65% 23 115 38 GULF BLVD 4 Boca Grande 1 65% 23 116 38 GULF BLVD 5 Boca Grande 1 65% 15 5.5 48.75 44.2 18.2 1.4 14.95 14.95 9.75 339 (Baily St.) In Google Earth, an trail can be seen on this narrow parcel (indicates public ). There is an entrance from the main road, but this appears to be a driveway for Seagrape Colony. No signs indicate public or parking. 414 VACANT 482 This parcel verified in 213 as developed, not vacant. 51 526 549 572 587 117 beach Seagrape Colony 9 R-19 65% 18 11.7 65 118 38 GULF BLVD 6 Boca Grande 1 % 16 621 no easement (Barbosa St.) This is not readily apparent using data available in Google Earth, including parcel data. From street-level view, there appears to be a potential unsigned (though heavily vegetated) and potential onstreet parking. No signs indicate or parking.
x (/N) 119 38 GULF BLVD 7 Boca Grande 1 65% 15 9.75 636 12 38 GULF BLVD 8 Boca Grande 1 65% 21 13.65 657 121 38 GULF BLVD 9 Boca Grande 1 65% 22 14.3 679 38 GULF BLVD 1 Boca Grande 122 1 65% 21 13.65 7 38 GULF BLVD 11 Boca Grande 123 1 65% 21 13.65 721 38 GULF BLVD 12 Boca Grande 124 1 65% 23 14.95 744 38 GULF BLVD 13 Boca Grande 125 1 65% 23 14.95 767 38 GULF BLVD 14 Boca Grande 126 1 65% 16 1.4 783 38 GULF BLVD 15 Boca Grande 127 1 65% 31 2.15 814 128 39 GULF BLVD Boca Grande 1 % 56 87 no easement 129 394 GULF BLVD Boca Grande 1 65% 7 45.5 94 13 beach Sundown Colony 9 65% 22 N/a 14.3 131 42 GULF BLVD 1 Boca Grande 1 65% 33 132 42 GULF BLVD 2 Boca Grande 1 65% 16 133 42 GULF BLVD 3 Boca Grande 1 65% 16 134 42 GULF BLVD 4 Boca Grande 1 65% 23 135 42 GULF BLVD 5 Boca Grande 1 65% 23 136 42 GULF BLVD 6 Boca Grande 1 65% 17 137 42 GULF BLVD 7 Boca Grande 1 65% 15 138 42 GULF BLVD 8 Boca Grande 1 65% 25 139 42 GULF BLVD 9 Boca Grande 1 65% 21 21.45 1.4 1.4 14.95 14.95 11.5 9.75 16.25 13.65 33 49 65 88 111 128 143 168 189 (Lafitte St.) Added to evaluation due to fact that sponsor has easement. This is not readily apparent using data available in Google Earth, including parcel data. From street-level view, there appears to be a potential unsigned (though heavily vegetated) and potential on-street parking. No signs indicate or parking. Noted as seperate parcel on spreadsheet, but Lee property appriaser shows not its own parcel but is actually within private parcel.
x (/N) 14 141 142 42 GULF BLVD 1 Boca Grande 42 GULF BLVD 11 Boca Grande 42 GULF BLVD 12 Boca Grande 1 % 16 1 65% 15 1 65% 25 143 common element for condo 9 65% 78 n/a 9.75 16.25 5.7 25 no easement 22 245 323 144 beach Sundown Colony 9 65% 2 n/a 13 145 146 147 148 149 15 151 152 153 154 155 156 157 158 159 16 42 GULF BLVD 13 Boca Grande 1 % 23 23 no easement 42 GULF BLVD 14 Boca Grande 1 65% 15 9.75 38 42 GULF BLVD 15 Boca Grande 1 % 19 57 no easment 42 GULF BLVD 16 Boca Grande 1 65% 26 16.9 83 42 GULF BLVD 17 Boca Grande 1 65% 24 15.6 17 42 GULF BLVD 18 Boca Grande 1 65% 17 11.5 124 42 GULF BLVD 19 Boca Grande 1 % 19 143 no easement 42 GULF BLVD 2 Boca Grande 1 65% 26 16.9 169 42 GULF BLVD 21 Boca Grande 1 65% 25 16.25 194 42 GULF BLVD 22 Boca Grande 1 % 18 212 no easement 42 GULF BLVD 23 Boca Grande 1 65% 18 11.7 23 42 GULF BLVD 24 Boca Grande 1 65% 24 15.6 254 42 GULF BLVD 25 Boca Grande 1 65% 24 15.6 278 42 GULF BLVD 26 Boca Grande 1 65% 18 11.7 296 42 GULF BLVD 27 Boca Grande 1 65% 24 15.6 32 42 GULF BLVD 28 Boca Grande 1 R-2 65% 49 31.85 369 large parcel containing pool and other roofed structure. (Kidd St.) Added to evaluation due to fact that sponsor has easement. This is not readily apparent using data available in Google Earth, including parcel data. From street-level view, there appears to be a potential unsigned (though heavily vegetated) and potential on-street parking directly south of the pool. No signs indicate or parking. Noted as seperate parcel, but Lee property appriaser shows not its own parcel but is actually within private parcel. This parcel verified in 213 as developed, not vacant.
x (/N) 161 Luke Street R.O.W 9 65% 2 n/a 13 162 46 GULF BLVD 1 Boca Grande 1 65% 27 17.55 27 163 46 GULF BLVD 9 Boca Grande 1 65% 16 1.4 43 164 46 GULF BLVD 8 Boca Grande 1 65% 15 9.75 58 165 46 GULF BLVD 7 Boca Grande 1 % 25 83 no easement 166 46 GULF BLVD 6 Boca Grande 1 65% 24 15.6 17 167 46 GULF BLVD 5 Boca Grande 1 65% 23 14.95 13 168 46 GULF BLVD 4 Boca Grande 1 65% 23 14.95 153 169 46 GULF BLVD 3 Boca Grande 1 % 18 171 no easement 17 46 GULF BLVD 2 Boca Grande 1 65% 18 11.7 189 171 46 GULF BLVD 1 Boca Grande 1 % 35 224 no easement 172 48 GULF BLVD 1 Boca Grande 1 65% 25 16.25 249 173 48 GULF BLVD 2 Boca Grande 1 65% 22 14.3 271 174 48 GULF BLVD 3 Boca Grande 1 65% 21 13.65 292 175 48 GULF BLVD 4 Boca Grande 1 65% 18 11.7 31 176 48 GULF BLVD 5 Boca Grande 1 65% 21 13.65 331 177 48 GULF BLVD 6 Boca Grande 1 65% 2 13 351 178 48 GULF BLVD 7 Boca Grande 1 65% 2 13 371 179 48 GULF BLVD 8 Boca Grande 1 65% 19 12.35 39 18 48 GULF BLVD 9 Boca Grande 1 65% 21 13.65 411 48 GULF BLVD 1 Boca Grande 181 1 65% 25 16.25 436 48 GULF BLVD 11 Boca Grande 182 1 65% 24 15.6 46 48 GULF BLVD 12 Boca Grande 183 1 65% 28 18.2 488 48 GULF BLVD 13 Boca Grande 184 1 65% 19 12.35 57 (Luke St.) Added to evaluation due to fact that sponsor has right-of-way. This can not be identified using data available in Google Earth, including parcel data. There appears to be a narrow lot that is undeveloped, but there is no apparent or parking.
x (/N) 185 48 GULF BLVD 14 Boca Grande 1 65% 33 21.45 54 186 beach Boca Grande Shores 9 65% 14 n/a 9.1 554 187 5 GULF BLVD 1 Boca Grande 1 65% 43 188 5 GULF BLVD 2 Boca Grande 1 65% 43 189 5 GULF BLVD 3 Boca Grande 1 65% 33 19 5 GULF BLVD 4 Boca Grande 1 65% 35 191 5 GULF BLVD 5 Boca Grande 1 65% 41 192 5 GULF BLVD 6 Boca Grande 1 65% 43 193 5 GULF BLVD 7 Boca Grande 1 65% 37 194 5 GULF BLVD 8 Boca Grande 1 R-21 65% 37 195 5 GULF BLVD 9 Boca Grande 1 65% 4 196 5 GULF BLVD 1 Boca Grande 1 65% 37 27.95 27.95 21.45 22.75 26.65 27.95 24.5 24.5 26 24.5 597 64 673 78 749 792 829 866 96 943 197 beach Boca Grande Shores 9 65% 26 N/a 16.9 969 198 54 GULF BLVD 1 Boca Grande 1 65% 4 26 19 199 54 GULF BLVD 2 Boca Grande 1 65% 32 2.8 141 2 54 GULF BLVD 3 Boca Grande 1 % 51 192 no easement 21 54 GULF BLVD 4 Boca Grande 1 65% 39 25.35 1131 22 54 GULF BLVD 5 Boca Grande 1 % 37 1168 no easement 23 54 GULF BLVD 6 Boca Grande 1 65% 38 24.7 126 24 54 GULF BLVD 7 Boca Grande 1 65% 47 3.55 1253 25 54 GULF BLVD 8 Boca Grande 1 % 33 1286 no easement This is not readily apparent using data available in Google Earth, including parcel data. From street-level view, there are no signs outside of Boca Grande Shores indicating public beach. There appears to be a narrow lot that is undeveloped, but there is no apparent or parking. This can not be identified using data available in Google Earth, including parcel data. There appears to be a narrow lot that is undeveloped, but there is no apparent or parking.
x (/N) 34 ft are covered 26 54 GULF BLVD 9 Boca Grande 1 65% 4 22.1 1326 54 GULF BLVD 1 Boca Grande 27 1 % 48 N 28 beach Woodwind Beach 9 % 19 N/a N 29 57 GULF BLVD 2 Boca Grande 1 % 35 21 57 GULF BLVD 3 Boca Grande 1 % 37 211 57 GULF BLVD 4 Boca Grande 1 % 4 212 57 GULF BLVD 5 Boca Grande 1 % 42 213 57 GULF BLVD 6 Boca Grande 1 % 41 214 57 GULF BLVD 7 Boca Grande 1 % 4 N N no easement N N N N This can not be identified using data available in Google Earth, including parcel data. There appears to be a narrow lot that is undeveloped, but there is no apparent or parking. 215 57 GULF BLVD 8 Boca Grande 1 % 48 216 57 GULF BLVD 9 Boca Grande 1 65% 36 217 218 57 GULF BLVD 1 Boca Grande 57 GULF BLVD 11 Boca Grande 1 65% 36 1 65% 44 219 beach Island House 9 65% 16 N/a 1.4 136 4 feet covered (but no easement) 23.4 1312 23.4 1276 28.6 124 22 576 GULF BLVD Boca Grande 1 65% 78 5.7 118 221 58 GULF BLVD Boca Grande 1 R-22 65% 119 77.35 112 222 59 GULF BLVD Boca Grande 1 65% 97 63.5 983 223 596 GULF BLVD Boca Grande 1 65% 97 63.5 886 224 61 GULF BLVD Boca Grande 82 65% 5 N/a 32.5 789 1196 only 8 feet of this parcel is covered by parking and at Parcel Number (225) which covers 1/4 mile (132 feet north and south of its location). However, there is no easement. This can not be identified using data available in Google Earth, including parcel data. There appears to be a narrow lot that is undeveloped, but there is no apparent or parking. *Google Earth US parcel data lists lot width as 85 ft.
x (/N) 225 68 GULF BLVD Public Parking and Access 225 68 GULF BLVD Boca Grande 82 82 R-23 65% R-23 and R-24 65% 2199 N/a 226 777 GULF BLVD Boca Grande 21 65% 11 65.65 END OF AUTHORIZED FEDERAL PROJECT LIMITS 1429.35 1496. 932.5 Access is in the middle of the parcel. The northern boundary of the parcel is approx. 739 feet north of the. 146 Lot size only given in sq. ft. There are 146 feet from point to southern boundary of lot. Project covers to R-24 plus 6 ft taper. This analysis, as in 28, assumes total lot is covered in cost sharing. However, lot may extend further south than 24.5. 6.38 cost share