Proximate Composition of Two Sea Cucumber Species Holothuria pavra and Holothuria arenicola in Persian Gulf

Similar documents
2011 ORGANIC SOYBEAN VARIETY TRIAL MATERIALS AND METHODS

ScienceDirect. Development of a method for manufacturing noodles from finger millet

The Effect of Oat Bran Fiber on Texture, Moisture and Palatability of Pumpkin Muffins

Asian Journal of Food and Agro-Industry ISSN Available online at

Evaluation of Yogurt with Enhanced Cysteine Content

The Effect of Quinoa on the Taste and Texture of Chocolate Chip Cookies. Hannah Doren Tarryn Hake Mitch Simmonds NUTR 453.

Effects of chemical treatments on dormancy breaking and some sprouting characteristics of two potato cultivars in different tuber sizes

Garlic Sprouts Grown Indoors at Kitchen Sites

I. RESURSE GENETICE, AMELIORAREA SPECIILOR POMICOLE GENETIC RESOURCES, BREEDING OF DECIDUOUS FRUIT TREES SPECIES

How to get the best eating quality of pork

The effect of seed treatments on the yield and yield components of various levels of sprouted wheat

Central NC Organic Bell and Hot Pepper Variety Trial, Summer 2014

Some Physical Properties of Sweet Cherry (Prunus avium L.) Fruit

Acknowledgements. Recent Research: Vine Balance and Fruit Thinning. Brief Outline. Take Aways. How many of you have read? Vine Balance.

Postharvest Application of 1-Methylcyclopropene (1-MCP) Extends Shelf Life of Kiwifruit

Food Research International

Temporal variation in temperature and rainfall differentially affects ectomycorrhizal colonization at two contrasting sites

2014 Sunflower Planting Date Trial

Abstract. Ramiréz-Aristizabal, L. S. * ; Ortiz, A. ; Restrepo-Aristizabal, M.F.; Salinas-Villada, J.F. Universidad Tecnológica de Pereira,Colombia

Preview. Chapter 3. Labor Productivity and Comparative Advantage: The Ricardian Model

Effect of Whitener Type and Paddy Moisture Content on Rice Grain Damage During Milling Process

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF FOOD ENGINEERING

Rudd Report. Are Fast-Food Restaurants Keeping Their Promises to Offer Healthier Kids Meals? Summary. August 2017

The Impact of Supplementation of Green Tea Powder in Yellow Cupcakes. Teryn Sapper & Christian Ordaz November 22, 2010 F&N 453

Crackers Made of Green Mussel Shells Substitution as High Calcium Snacks

Archived at

Comparative of fermentation in red and yellow watermelon juice by lactic acid bacteria

PREPARATION AND HANDLING FRESH-CUT ROOT VEGETABLES. MERETE EDELENBOS DEPT. OF FOOD SCIENCE AARHUS UNIVERSITY DENMARK

Separation of Sunlight and Temperature Effects on the Composition of Vitis vinifera cv. Merlot Berries

Production of Two Types of Pocket-Forming Flat Bread by the Sponge and Dough Method

Research Article Oenological and Quality Characteristic on Young White Wines (Sauvignon Blanc): Effects of High Hydrostatic Pressure Processing

Volume 2, ISSN (Online), Published at:

Effect of AVG Application on Fruit Set, Yield and Fruit Size in Abate Fetel and Packam s Triumph Pears in a Semi-Commercial Statistical Trial

The determination of iron in grapes and their alcoholic

The Effect of Acetic and Lactic Acid on the Oil Uptake, Texture and Color of Rice (Sang Tarom) During Cooking

Early-Maturing Sweet Oranges: Research Update on Earlygold, Itaborai, Ruby, and Westin Sweet Oranges 1

Performance of Seyval Blanc Grape in Four Training Systems Over Five Years

Environmental Initiatives in South African Wineries: A Comparison Between Small and Large Wineries

The Relationship Between Palm Oil Index Development and Mechanical Properties in the Ripening Process of Tenera Variety Fresh Fruit Bunches

Southward transplanted cage-culture of sea cucumbers Apostichopus japonicus in China s Shengsi Islands

Evaluation of Grey Forecasting Method of Total Domestic Coffee Consumption in Indonesia

Effects of guar gum and arabic gum on the physicochemical, sensory and flow behaviour characteristics of frozen yoghurt

Research Article Chemometrics of Wheat Composites with Hemp, Teff, and Chia Flour: Comparison of Rheological Features

Effects of transglutminase on the quality of white salted noodles made from Korean wheat cultivars

*Joseph Adubofuor, Michael Amoafo Mensah and Sylvia Dabri

Influence of Gibberellic Acid (GA 3 ) on Fruit Quality of Sweet Cherries John Cline

by high-performance liquid chromatography

The "Frozen-pack" Method of Preserving. Berries. The future of the frozen pack" seems assured when a product of unquestioned merit

2006 BELL PEPPER VARIETY EVALUATION TRIALS

Optimized wine quality potential through fruit-zone management practices in red varieties

Coffee Berry Processing By-Product Valorization: Coffee Parchment as a Potential Fiber Source to Enrich Bakery Goods

Factors Associated with Dough Stickiness as Sensed by Attenuated Total Reflectance Infrared Spectroscopy

Article. Discrimination of Commercial Roasted and Ground Coffees According to Chemical Composition. Romilaine M. N. de Souza and Marta T.

Chemical Characterization of Wines Fermented

International Journal of PharmTech Research CODEN (USA): IJPRIF, ISSN: Vol.8, No.4, pp , 2015

Consumer evaluation of cold smoked fat in beef sausages

The effects of UV-C treatment on the quality of orange, carrot and celery juice blend

Document downloaded from: This paper must be cited as:

Ensiling characteristics and aerobic stability of temperate grasses containing different concentrations of water soluble carbohydrates

Characterization of Fruitbody Morphology on Various Environmental Conditions in Pleurotus ostreatus

Influence of Citrus Rootstocks in Bioactive Compounds of Clementines

Relationship between fermentation behaviour, measured with a 3D vision Structured Light technique, and the internal structure of bread.

EFFECT OF BORON AND ARSENIC ON JUICE ACIDITY

Archives 2015 vol

Further Investigations. Storing, and Ripening. of Pears from. Rogue River Valley. Agricultural Experiment Station Oregon State Agricultural College

Archives 2016 vol *

Journal of Food Engineering

THE EXTRACTION KINETICS OF ANTHOCYANINS AND PROANTHOCYANIDINS FROM GRAPE TO WINE IN THREE DIFFERENT VARIETIES

J. //«/. Brew., May-June, 1976, Vol. 82, pp FACTORS RESPONSIBLE FOR THE DECREASE IN ph DURING BEER FERMENTATIONS

Celiac sprue (celiac sprue also has been called celiac

Relationship Between Microclimatic Data, Aroma Component Concentrations and Wine Quality Parameters in the Prediction of Sauvignon blanc Wine Quality

Cluster-zone leaf removal refers to deliberate removal of selected

Semi-commercial evaluation of SmartFresh with South African export avocados in static containers at the Westfalia packhouse during 2002

Surveillance and outbreak reports

VALUE ADDITION OF IDLI THROUGH INCORPORATION OF GREENS AND LEGUMES

Physicochemical Properties and Fatty acid composition of Dikanut (Irvingia Gabonensis) seed oil

Effects of Prohexadione-calcium on Grape Yield Components and Fruit and Wine Composition

Effect of Phosphate Salts on the Pasting Properties of Korean Instant-Fried Noodle

Biological Control of Alternaria Fruit Rot of Chili by Trichoderma Species under Field Conditions

Effect of Ultra-high Pressure Treatment on the Chemical Properties, Colour and Sensory Quality of Young Red Wine

Impact of Shoot and Cluster Thinning on Yield, Fruit Composition, and Wine Quality of Corot noir

RESEARCH ON LOW-ALKALOID CONCENTRATION IN VARIETIES OF LUPIN (LUPINUS SP.) IN LITHUANIA. Received: 25 January 2010 Accepted: 25 June 2010

Flax: a user s guide, with recipes

Influence of some safety post-harvest treatments on fruit quality and storability of Guava fruits

Volume : 07 Issue :01 Jan.-Mar Pages:

Application of Toasted Oak and Micro-oxygenation to Ageing of Cabernet Sauvignon Wines

Optimization of extraction of phenolic antioxidants from peanut skins

Assessment of Metal Chelating, Bioautography and Spot Screening by TLC of Green Tea (Camellia sinensis)

EFFECT OF DIFFERENT PROPAGULE TYPES, GROWING MEDIA AND ROOTING HORMONES ON INITIAL SPROUTING OF THE MEDICINAL PLANT CYPERUS ROTUNDUS L.

Rapid Reduction in Aroma Volatiles of Pacific Rose Apples in Controlled Atmospheres

Atmospheric CO2 Levels

ain Advanced Fruit Management Technical Manual Asia Pacific Plant Growth Regulator No. bins picked Date 21-Feb 28-Feb 7-Mar 14-Mar 21-Mar 28-Mar

EFFECT OF SPIRULINA (SPIRULINA PLATENSIS) ADDITION ON TEXTURAL AND QUALITY PROPERTIES OF COOKIES

Agronomic approaches in yield and quality stability of high oleic sunflowers (Helianthus annuus L.)

CARBOHYDRATE FERMENTATION REACTIONS OF STAPHYLOCOCCI*

MALTING CONDITIONS FOR EVALUATION OF RYE CULTIVARS

Euhrychiopsis lecontei Distribution, Abundance, and Experimental Augmentations for Eurasian Watermilfoil Control in Wisconsin Lakes

Timing of partial defoliation affects carbohydrate

EVALUATION OF SEED AND IN-FURROW AT-PLANTING APPLIED INSECTICIDES ON SORGHUM

Gibberellic Acid (GA3), an Influential Growth Regulator for Physiological Disorder Control and Protracting the Harvesting Season of Sweet Orange

Transcription:

Avilble online t www.scholrsreserchlibrry.com Annls of Biologicl Reserch, 212, 3 (3):135-1311 (http://scholrsreserchlibrry.com/rchive.html) ISSN 976-1233 CODEN (USA): ABRNBW Proximte Composition of Two Se Cucumber Species Holothuri pvr nd Holothuri renicol in Persin Gulf Ali Rez Slrzdeh 1 *Mjid Afkhmi 2 Kzem Drvish Bstmi 2 Mrym Ehsnpour 1 Aid Khzli 2 nd Amin Mokhleci 3 1 Deprtment of Fishery, Islmic Azd University, Bndr Abbs Brnch, Bndr Abbs, Irn 2 Young Reserchers Club, Islmic Azd University, Bndr Abbs Brnch, Bndr Abbs, Irn 3 Young Reserchers Club, Islmic Azd University, Centrl Tehrn Brnch, Tehrn, Irn _ ABSTRACT This study compred the chemicl compositions of se cucumbers hrvested from the Bndr-elengeh cost in South of Irn July 211. Their Moisture, sh, protein, nd ft contents were mesured nd recorded. The verge protein, moisture, sh, crude fiber nd ft were 17.61±.95%, 67.82±3.81%, 32.74±1.17%, 1.87±.5% n d 2.43±.53% in H.prv nd 24.37±1.93%, 69.45±3.9%, 1.86±.4%, 2.29±.5% nd 2.88±.47% in H.renicol respectively. Crude ft nd moisture content doesn't show ny significnt difference (p>.5). Significnt vritions were lso observed between protein, sh nd crude fiber contents (p<.5) which sh content in H.prv ws more thn H.renicol otherwise protein nd crud fiber content in H.renicol were more thn H.pvr(p<.5). Keywords: Se cucumber, chemicl composition, Persin Gulf. _ INTRODUCTION The se cucumber belongs to the Echinoderm phylum. It hs been trditionl tonic food in mny Asin countries for thousnds of yers. In Chin, 134 species hve been found, mong which only 2 species re edible nd of medicinl functions [1]. They re usully mrketed s frozen, cooked-dried, cooked-slted nd cooked-slted-dried products [2].they live on rocky substrt, soft sediments nd phnerogm se grss beds, in depths tht vry between nd 1 m [3]. In the ocens, there re hundreds of vrieties of se cucumbers. Although the commercil vlue of species grown in different res under different conditions cn rnge from few to thousnds of US dollrs per kilogrm, no detiled comprison hs been mde of their chemicl components nd nutritionl vlue. With the development of the food industry, vrious kinds of nutriments nd tonic products re now mde of the se cucumber, including dried products (beche-de-mer), pickled products, wter-risen products, orl liquids nd cpsules. 135

Mjid Afkhmi et l Annls of Biologicl Reserch, 212, 3 (3):135-1311 The mjor edible prts of se cucumber re the body wll minly consisting of collgen nd mucopolyscchrides. More thn 21 types of collgen hve so fr been identified in vrious tissues nd their roles hve been investigted [4]. Se cucumbers re well known to exert beneficil effects on humn helth. These echinoderms re used in Asin trditionl medicine to mintin fitness during long fishing trvels or to prevent, reduce or cure severl Ailments like constiption, renl deficiency or rthritis. Severl ppers published in the lst two decdes cme in support to these medicinl purposes showing multiple biologicl ctivities of se cucumber extrcts s wound heling promoter nd exhibiting ntimicrobil, nticncer, nd immunomodultory properties [5-8]. However, there were only few reports bout chemicl composition being used in the geogrphicl clssifiction of qutic food mterils. Furthermore, the chemicl composition of se cucumbers re influenced by the locl environmentl fctors especilly the wter environment. In Irn, se cucumbers re not well known nd they re not consumed s food, lthough they hve been consumed in mny countries for hundreds of yers. Few studies on se cucumbers in Irn were crried out [9-12] Therefore, there is scrce informtion regrding to H. prv nd H.renicol, which re commonly observed in Bndr-e-Lengeh cost. There is no informtion exists relting to most se cucumber species of Irn in terms of their proximte composition. Therefore, we imed to study the proximte composition of two species of fresh se cucumbers; H. prv nd H.renicol from costl regions of Irn. MATERIALS AND METHODS Se cucumber smples Se cucumber smples including Holothuri renicol (1 specimens) nd Holothuri prv (1 specimens) were collected during low tide from the Bndr-e-lengeh cost in South of Irn July 211(Fig 1).They were kept in iced boxes nd trnsported to the lbortory where they were wshed with cold wter, weighed nd mesured. Anlyses of protein Totl protein ws determined by using Kjeldhl method [13]. A conversion fctor of 6.25 ws used to convert totl nitrogen to crude protein for ll vrieties of fish. Moisture, Ash nd fiber nlyses The muscle ws homogenized by food processor (Brun Combimx 6), nd moisture content of 5 g of homogenized smple ws determined by drying the smple in oven t 15 C until constnt mss ws obtined [14]. Ash nd Fiber were determined by using the bsic AOAC method [14] by heting the smples in the furnce t 55 C for 8 12 h. Ech smple nlyzed three times. Lipid nlyses Totl lipids of se cucumber species were extrcted (seprtely) ccording to the Bligh nd Dyer method [15]. After phse equilibrtion, the lower Chloroform lyer (TL) ws removed nd dried in rotry vcuum evportor t 32 C. The extrcted lipids were weighed in order to determine the TL, nd then redissolved in chloroform/methnol (9:1, v/v) nd finlly stored t C until used. Additionlly, in order for tht to be confirmed, liquots were evported in preweighed 136

Mjid Afkhmi et l Annls of Biologicl Reserch, 212, 3 (3):135-1311 vils to constnt weight to determine the lipid content. To prevent oxidtion t-butylhydroquinone ws dded to ll smples during preprtion. Sttisticl nlysis Dt sttisticl nlysis ws crried out with SPSS softwre nd Excel. Dt normlity checked by using Kolmogrove-smironoff test. Significnt difference between chemicls chrcteristic between two fishes ws determined by using t- test bout 5% probbilities. Dt re expressed s mens's., n vlues re given for ech tble. RESULTS Tbles 1 nd 2 represent proximte composition (wet weight bses) of two se cucumber species investigted in this study. The verge protein, moisture, sh, crude fiber nd ft were 17.61±.95%, 67.82±3.81%, 32.74±1.17%, 1.87±.5% nd 2.43±.53% in H.prv nd 24.37±1.93%, 69.45±3.9%, 1.86±.4%, 2.29±.5% nd 2.88±.47% in H.renicol, respectively. Crude ft nd moisture content does not show ny significnt difference (p>.5) which the highest vlue of crude ft nd moisture were observed for H.renicol (3.73% nd 73.59 %), respectively (Fig. 2). Significnt vritions were lso observed between protein, sh nd crude fiber contents (p<.5), where sh content in H.prv ws more thn H.renicol; otherwise, protein nd crud fiber content in H.renicol were more thn H.prv (p<.5) (Fig. 3). Tble 1 Proximte composition (% wet weight bsis) of H. prv Prmeters Length(cm) Weight(g) Ash % Moisture % crude fiber % Protein % Ft % Min 1 23 31.56 62.3.89 15.8 1.4 Mx 12 26 34.98 75.2 2.5 19 3.37 Averge 11.11 24.44 32.74 67.92 1.87 17.61 2.43 SD.78 1.13 1.17 3.81.5.95.53 Tble 2 Proximte composition (% wet weight bsis) of H.renicol Prmeters Length(cm) Weight(g) Ash % Moisture crude fiber % Protein % Ft % Min 1 21 1.38 62.32 1.48 2.9 2.1 Mx 13 24 11.35 73.59 3.2 27.6 3.73 Averge 11.55 22.55 1.86 69.49 2.29 24.37 2.88 SD.88 1.23.4 3.9.5 1.93.47 Tble 3 compring between results of this study with other regions Species H.prv (This study) H.renicol (This study) H. polii (Aydın et l., 211) H. tubulos (Aydın et l., 211) H. mmmt (Aydın et l., 211) Moisture (%) 67.92 ± 3.81 69.49 ± 3.9 81.24 ±.4 84.3 ±.2 85.24 ±.3 Protein (%) 17.61±.95 24.37±1.93 8.66 ± 1.2 8.82 ±.3 7.88 ±.3 Ft (%) 2.43±.53 2.88±.47.15 ±.4.18 ±.5.9 ±.8 Ash (%) 32.74±1.17 1.86±.4 7.85 ±.9 5.13 ±.6 5.13 ±.1 137

Mjid Afkhmi et l Annls of Biologicl Reserch, 212, 3 (3):135-1311 4 3.5 3 2.5 F t 2 1.5 1.5 H. prv H.renicol 8 7 6 5 M o is tu r e (% ) 4 3 2 1 H. prv H.renicol Fig 2 comprison of ft nd moisture in H. prv nd H.renicol 3 25 b 2 Protein 15 1 5 H. prv B. mrmort 138

Mjid Afkhmi et l Annls of Biologicl Reserch, 212, 3 (3):135-1311 4 35 3 Ash (%) 25 2 15 1 5 H. prv H.renicol b 3 b 2.5 Crude fiber(%) 2 1.5 1.5 H. prv H.renicol Fig 3 comprison of protein, sh nd crud fiber in H. prv nd H.renicol. 139

Mjid Afkhmi et l Annls of Biologicl Reserch, 212, 3 (3):135-1311 DISCUSSION Chemicl constituents in medicinl mterils re the substntil foundtions of curtive effects, which differ mong vrious regions. For exmple, se cucumbers of the sme species but in different geogrphicl regions provide discrimintive functions in medicl pplictions [16, 17], nd thus it requires specil tretments in commercil trde nd sfety mngement. Becuse it is impossible for ordinry consumers to distinguish se cucumbers of vrious geogrphicl regions, using the sensory methods of sight, smell nd tste, it is importnt to develop methods to differentite between se cucumbers from vrious geogrphicl regions to ressure consumers, protect geogrphicl indiction, ensure fir competition, reinforce governmentl supervision nd permit the implementtion of product recll. In recent yers, reserch efforts hve been focused on the potentil of nlyticl techniques for the determintion of griculturl products; ccording to geogrphicl origin [18, 19].Se cucumbers generlly contin higher moisture nd lower protein content thn mrine fish nd shellfish. Proximte compositionl dt for fresh se cucumbers vry gretly; moisture 82 92.6%, protein 2.5 13.8%, ft.l.9%, sh l.5 4.3% nd crbohydrte 2.2%. [2]. Moisture, protein, ft nd sh contents of 3 se cucumber species from Aegen Se of Turkey rnged between 81.24% nd 85.24%, 7.88% nd 8.82%,.9% nd.18%, nd 5.13% nd 7.85%, respectively, with significnt chnges mong species (P<.5) hving been determined[21]. The dt found in the present study for protein, ft nd sh contents were more thn the rnge reported by Chng-Lee et l. [2] nd Aydin et l. [21] (Tble 3). The protein content is importnt when considering qulity nd texture of the muscle of the qutic niml. Muscles of qutic nimls tht contin smll mounts of protein tend to lose much wter upon cooking, which ruins the texture of the met. Food resources cn ffect lipid contents of some holothurins becuse of their selective feeding nd chnges in the food supply of se environment [22].Therefore, it is importnt to study the biochemicl composition of different species of se cucumbers from different regions. According to our results, chemicl compounds of the se cucumbers H.renicol nd H. pvr though coming from the sme environmentl conditions hd differences from ech other nd from others in the sme study. Chemicl compounds my be subjected to sesonl vritions in feeding behvior [2] or to individul or geogrphicl vritions [23]. O zer et l. [24] lso emphsized tht hndling procedures cn ffect the chemicl composition of se cucumbers. Acknowledgement The uthors wish to cknowledge the Bndr bss brnch Islmic Azd University for finncil support nd coopertion in implementing this project. REFERENCES [1]L.Y. Lio.Chin Acdemic Journl Electronic Publishing House 21, 35, 1-4. [2] FAO. Fisheries Sttistics 29. 27. [3]W. Fischer, M. Schneider, M.L. Buchot. Fiches FAO d identifiction des espe`ces pour les besoins de l peˆche 1987, Rev.1. [4]K. Gelse, E. Poschl, T. Aigner. Advnced Drug Delivery Reviews 23, 55, 1531-1546. [5]D.L. Aminin. Journl of Medicinl Food 21, 4,127-135. [6]B.D. Fredlin, B.H. Ridzwn, A.A.Z. Zinl Abidin, M.A. Kswndi, H. Ziton, I.Zli. Generl Phrmcology 199, 33, 337-34. 131

Mjid Afkhmi et l Annls of Biologicl Reserch, 212, 3 (3):135-1311 [7]B. Ridzwn, M.A. Kswndi MA, Y. Azmn, M. Fud. Generl Phrmcology 1995, 26, 1539-1543 [8]F. Tin, X. Zhng, Y. Tong, Y. Yi, S. Zhng, L.Li. Cncer Biology nd Therpy 25, 4, 874-882. [9]T. Amini Rd. Pjouhesh nd Szndegi 24, 68, 19-23. (In Persin). [1]A. Shkouri, T. Aimorird, M.B. Nbvi, P. kochnin, A. svri, A. J. Biol.sci 29, 9,184-187. [11]A.R Dbbgh, M. R Sedght, H. Rmeshi, E. Kmrni. SPC Beche-de-mer Informtion Bulletin 211, 31, 35-38. [12] A.R Dbbgh, M. keshvrz. world Applied Science Journl 211b, 13, 1933-1937. [13]S.E. Ritzmnn, J.C. Dniels JC. Little Brown, Boston 1975. [14]AOAC. Helrich K (Ed). Arlington, VA, USA 199. [15]E.G. Bligh, W.J. Dyer. Cndin Journl of Biochemistry nd Physiology 1959, 37, 911 917. [16]J.F. Wng, S. GAO, Y.M. Wng, Q. M, B.X. Ren, C.H.H Xue. Periodicl of Ocen University of Chin 29, 39, 228-232. [17]Q. Zho, J.F. Wng, Y. Xue, Y. Wng, S. GAO, M. Lei, C.H.H. Xue. Journl of Fishery Sciences of Chin 28, 15, 154-159. [18]B. Peres, N. Brlet, G. Loiseu, N. Montet. Food Control 27, 18, 228-235. [19]L.M. Reid, C.P. O Donnell, G. Downey.Trends in Food Science nd Technology 26, 17, 344-353. [2]M.V. Chng-Lee, R.J. Price, L.E. Lmpil LE.Journl of Food Science 1989, 54, 567-572. [21]M. Aydın, S.S Hu, T. Bekir, E. Yilmz, K. Sevim. Interntionl Journl of Food Science nd Technology 211, 46, 5-58. [22]R.R. Neto, G.A. Wolff, D.S.M. Billett, K.L. Mckenzie, A. Thompson. Deep-se Reserch 1 26, 53, 516-527. [23]M.L. Ginger, D.S.M. Billett, K.L. Mckenzie. Progress in Ocenogrphy 21, 5, 47-421. [24]N.P. O zer, S. Mol, C. Vrlık. Turkish Journl of Fisheries nd Aqutic Sciences 24, 4, 71-74. 1311