Breakfast Served all day Oatmeal w/ Everything $8 walnuts, pecans, raisins, strawberries, and raspberries Huntsman s Breakfast $10 grilled ham, potato cakes topped with two fried eggs French Toast $7 1 slice $5 strawberries and custard add $2 French Omelette $10 (gouda & ham) or (bacon & sausage) or (french feta) Bacon Egg Cheese Bagel $5 substitute sausage Bagel & Cream Cheese $3.50 wheat or plain Smoothies $5 fresh fruit, dark berry, soy blue, or mango love drinks Brewed Coffee $2 Irish Crème $3 Puccino $5 blended espresso, custard and ice: Oreo, Mocha, Caramel or Peppermint Chocolate Chip Payne s Quake $5 espresso custard shake Payne s Reaction $5 Payne s special invention Floozy $5 custard topped with hot chocolate Flustard Floozy $6 vanilla custard w/espresso shot Indiana Espresleyan $5 Espresso & Chai over custard Smoothies $5 fresh fruit, dark berry, soy blue, or mango love Custard Latte $5 Chocolate, Vanilla, Pumpkin Spice Payne s Smoker $5 Mocha with scoop of chocolate custard Chai latte $4 Zebra Mocha $5 Teas Chamomile Citrus Blossum, Earl Grey, English Breakfast, Tropical Green, Chai, Organic African Nectar, Mountain Spring Jasmine All $2.50
Sundaes Cookie Monster $5 Oreos, cookie dough and hot fudge Hot Fudge $5 Flustard $4 Vanilla custard topped with espresso Jenny s Reese $5 Reese s Peanut Butter cups, hot fudge, Peanut butter sauce Turtle $5 Pecans, hot fudge, caramel Rhubarb Crumble $5 Stewed Rhubarb with Granola Topping James Dean s Payne $5 Based on James Dean s favorite, vanilla custard espresso and raspberries Dessert Sticky Toffee Pudding $6 Made with Dates and toffee sauce Bread Pudding $6 Granny Payne s recipe Mary Stearn s Apple Cake $6 with walnuts and golden raisins Dessert Taster Plate $9 half of each three desserts w/ custard Rhubarb Crumble $5 stewed Rhubarb and Granola Worms and Dirt $5 Oreos and Sour gummie Worms Shakes Oreo, Chocolate, Vanilla, Gingerbread, Malt, Peppermint, Quake $5
Entrees All served with your choice of Fattoush, Moroccan Lentil Salad, Poached Pear Salad Walnut and Brie Salad or Cup of Soup Bangers & Mash $16 Payne s own Cumberland sausage with Onion gravy & rutabaga mash British Chicken Curry $12 Mild aromatic Korma with steamed potatoes & Naan bread Country-Style Pork Ribs $18 mashed potatoes, green beans & bacon BBQ Sauce Beef Stew $18 in classic French Bourguignon style sauce Spatchcock Chicken $18 For two, with garlic, pepper, lime & olive oil Main Street Pork Chop $14 with mustard cream sauce and mash Duck in Blackberry Sauce $18 blackberry wine reduction & mash Sandwiches Payne s Clubhouse $10 Half $7 Apple Walnut Brie Panini $8 Mushroom Basil Melt $10 Half $ Goat Cheese Club Wrap $10 Chicken Salad Wrap $10 Rye Reuben $10 The Earl of Pulled Pork $12 with Kentucky Bourbon sauce Tuna & Walnut Bourriche $9 Pepperoni BBQ Bourriche $9
SouP Gluten free Soup of the Day $5.50 Add a Grilled Cheese! Scottish Lentil & Garlic with Gouda Grilled Cheese $9 Sweet Potato & Ginger with Pepperjack Grilled Cheese $9 Roast Onion & Sage with Havarti Grilled Cheese $9 Potato & Onion with Bacon Brie Grilled Cheese $10 Famous Grilled Cheese & Tomato Soup $9 Bouriche Grilled Cheese Black Bean and Tomato $9 With Pepperjack Grilled Cheese Wine Jax Taureau Glass $7 Bottle $33 Jax Chardonnay Glass $7 Bottle $33 Seven Hills Riesling $6 Bottle $30 Flor Prosecco $7 Bottle $33 Three floyd s Beer Munster, IN Draft Pint $4.50 22oz $6 Pitcher $15 Prices vary Ask your server for listing Mimosas Orange or Elderflower $7 Draft Cider Woodchuck Hopsation $4 Ask server for listing
Appetizers Mash $6 with Brussels Sprouts & Brandy Sauce Hummus & Pita $6 Soup of The Day $5.50 Salads Walnut & Brie Salad $6 with mandarins & balsamic vinaigrette Coronation Chicken $8 Chicken salad with bacon and apricots Burgers With chips Beef Burger $10 caramelized onions, swiss cheese, tomato Salmon Burger $9 with slaw, sprouts, sour cream Turkey & Bacon Burger $9 slaw, tomato, mozzarella Veggie Burger $9 slaw, tomato, sprouts and quac Moroccan Lentil Salad $6 steamed lentils with spinach, cilantro and mint Fattoush (fat*toosh) $6 chopped cucumber, radish, tomato with minted yogurt dressing Poached Pear & Goat Cheese Salad $6 White wine poached pear, grilled & served on bed of fresh spinach
www.paynescustardandcoffee.com 765.998.0668 A 18% tip will be automatically added to tables of 8 or more. A 10% tip will be added to take out orders. We appreciate your understanding and thank you for your patronage.