Day One Lots

Transcription

1 Day One Lots

2 MAGNUM MANIA (LOTS 1-5) The only thing better than great Claret is great Claret in magnum. This concise consignment of large format Bordeaux comes direct from an avid collector in London. All wines were removed from professional temperature- and humidity-controlled warehouse in the UK. BORDEAUX Château Latour 2000 "Generous, round...feels very luxurious and reminiscent of the 1982 in the expansiveness on the palate, the balance and the sheer depth of flavors and nuances..." SF. 1 6 magnums (1.5L) per lot US$ ,000 Château Latour 2003 one lightly wine-stained label "...very ripe, but not over-ripe, offers great freshness... Dense, thick and unctuously textured, this staggering Latour is undeniably the most sumptuous, opulent wine WA 8/ magnums (1.5L) per lot US$ ,000 Château Mouton Rothschild 2003 three lightly damp-stained labels, lightly scuffed labels "...full-bodied, meaty, powerful, dry flavors as well as a huge finish...reminded me of a hypothetical blend of the 1982 and 1986 Moutons " WA 4/ magnums (1.5L) per lot US$ Château Montrose 2003 St Estèphe, Deuxième Cru Classé with damaged lid "Dense, full-bodied and rich with an unctuous texture, well-integrated, melted tannins, and a long, heady finish, this big, brawny, super-intense, gorgeous " WA 8/ bottles per lot US$ Château Margaux 2003 Margaux, Premier Cru Classé banded "...offers extraordinary intensity as well as a surreal delicacy/lightness. There is riveting freshness to this offering...99." WA 4/ magnums (1.5L) per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com

3 AN EXCELLENT COLLECTION OF 2000, 2003, AND 2009 BORDEAUX (LOTS 6-27) From three of the top vintages of the past twenty years comes this wonderful collection of pristine top Bordeaux. Pétrus, Margaux, Latour, and the legendary 2000 Mouton, all in easy to handle taster sized lots. Purchased mostly on release as futures and stored in a professional built, temperature- and humidity-controlled home wine cellar. BORDEAUX Château Haut-Brion 2000 Pessac Léognan, Premier Cru Classé one lightly damp-stained label, one lightly scuffed label, one with signs of old seepage "...a deep, layered, sumptuously textured, full-bodied Haut-Brion, but one with extraordinary complexity...99." WA 6/ bottles per lot US$ Château Lafite Rothschild 2000 lightly bin-soiled and nicked label "The wine is rich, medium to full-bodied, but has that ethereal elegance and purity that is always Lafite " WA 6/ bottle per lot US$ Château Latour 2000 lightly bin-soiled labels, one lightly scuffed label "Generous, round...feels very luxurious and reminiscent of the 1982 in the expansiveness on the palate, the balance and the sheer depth of flavors and nuances..." SF. 8 2 bottles per lot US$ Château Margaux 2000 Margaux, Premier Cru Classé lightly damp-stained labels, one lightly scuffed label "Medium-bodied, with layers of concentration, stunning blue, red, and black fruits intermixed with spring flowers " WA 6/ bottles per lot US$ Château Mouton Rothschild 2000 "A rich, tannic, earthy style, with loads of creme de cassis and floral notes...a full-bodied wine with plenty of coffee, earth, chocolatey notes " WA 6/ bottle per lot US$ Château Lafite Rothschild 2003 "...extraordinary richness, opulence, power, purity, intensity and viscosity " WA 4/ bottles per lot US$ Château Latour 2003 "...very ripe, but not over-ripe, offers great freshness... Dense, thick and unctuously textured, this staggering Latour is undeniably the most sumptuous, opulent wine " WA 8/ bottles per lot US$ Château Margaux 2003 Margaux, Premier Cru Classé one lightly scuffed label "...offers extraordinary intensity as well as a surreal delicacy/lightness. There is riveting freshness to this offering...99." WA 4/ bottles per lot US$ Pétrus 2003 Pomerol "Amazing, jaw-dropping quality. Full-bodied, with super silky, seductive tannins and a finish that lasts for minutes. Out of this world...98." WS 3/ bottle per lot US$ Château Haut-Brion 2005 Pessac Léognan, Premier Cru Classé "One of my wines of the night, the 2005 Haut-Brion is stratospheric. Remarkably vivid and nuanced...a compelling mélange of dark flavors laced with the savory/mineral notes that are so typical of Haut-Brion " AG 11/ bottles per lot US$ Château Latour 2008 "The wine possesses full-bodied power as well as a boatload of tannin...the hallmark of a great wine and potentially top-notch vintage is the sweetness of the tannin, and that is evident " WA 4/ bottles per lot US$ Château La Mission Haut-Brion 2000 Pessac Léognan, Cru Classé two wine-stained labels, two different importers "...pure, deep, sumptuously textured, full-bodied, powerful " WA 6/ bottles per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com 11

4 Château Léoville Barton 2000 St Julien, Deuxième Cru Classé includes 12-pack "Take textbook St.-Julien...then dial it up a notch. This has terrific energy to offset the admirable depth and length, and hasn't even started a second phase yet. One of the stars of the vintage...96." WS 12/ bottles per lot US$ Château Lynch-Bages 2000 Pauillac, Cinquième Cru Classé two lightly scuffed labels "...exhibits admirable purity, texture, mouthfeel and power combined with elegance. One of the all-time great examples of Lynch-Bages...97." WA 8/ bottles per lot US$ Château Montrose 2000 St Estèphe, Deuxième Cru Classé "Just starting to open...it's full-bodied with ultra-fine, integrated tannins and an extremely complex, refined finish...96." JS 4/ bottles per lot US$ Château Pavie 2000 St Émilion, Premier Grand Cru Classé (a) one lightly nicked label, two different importers "...stunningly rich nose...fabulously concentrated and fullbodied, with a multidimensional mouthfeel " WA 8/ bottles per lot US$ Château Cos d Estournel 2003 St Estèphe, Deuxième Cru Classé "With extraordinary richness, full-bodied, and remarkable freshness, elegance, and persistence, this is one of the finest wines ever made by this estate...98." WA 4/ bottles per lot US$ Château Léoville Poyferré 2003 St Julien, Deuxième Cru Classé six lightly scuffed labels "Impressive. Full-bodied, thick and powerful, with loads of fruit and big, velvety tannins. Goes on for minutes on the palate. Huge wine. Very, very impressive. This is one of the big surprises of the vintage...95." WS 3/ bottles per lot US$ Château Montrose 2003 St Estèphe, Deuxième Cru Classé "Dense, full-bodied and rich with an unctuous texture, well-integrated, melted tannins, and a long, heady finish, this big, brawny, super-intense, gorgeous " WA 8/ bottles per lot US$ Château Pavie 2008 St Émilion, Premier Grand Cru Classé (a) "...full-bodied...youthful, dense purple color and is seriously endowed with concentrated, rich fruit, licorice, graphite, forest floor, and loads of dark plum and black and red currant fruit " WA 8/ bottles per lot US$ Château Pichon-Baron 2000 Pauillac, Deuxième Cru Classé "It is superbly concentrated and very pure, with excellent texture and opulence. The acidity seems low, the tannin high but well-integrated...a compelling " WA 6/ bottles per lot US$ Château Trotanoy 2009 Pomerol "Very full-bodied, with silky tannins, fabulous opulence and palate presence " WA 2/ bottles per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com

5 BORDEAUX AND BARBARESCO FROM AN ESTEEMED NY COLLECTOR (LOTS 28-31) This consignment comes to Zachys courtesy of an avid collector and lover of the grape. Sourced from reputable auction houses, these bottles were stored in perfect temperature- and humidity-controlled conditions until being removed for consignment. BORDEAUX ITALY Château Latour 1985 one very top shoulder, three just below top shoulder, oxidized capsules "Full-bodied, with soft, velvety tannins and a long, ultraripe fruit finish. Still very fresh and young...93." WS 8/ bottles per lot US$ Château Lafite Rothschild 1986 one very top shoulder, one top shoulder, one with light tissue paper adhered to label "...beautifully defined, still full of energy...it must rank as one of the finest wines from the estate...98." WA 12/ bottles per lot US$ Barbaresco Gaja 1978 Piedmont 4cm, three lightly torn labels, one scuffed label The nose suggests a mature wine, with aromas of leather and cocoa dominating, although on the palate the wine shows generous amounts of dark fruit in a concentrated style with much persistence, length and the structure of the vintage WA 5/ bottles per lot US$ Château Lafite Rothschild 1990 bottom neck or better, one slightly depressed cork "...it boasts gorgeous aromas of cedar, tobacco leaf, cassis, and lead pencil shavings. The explosive aromas are followed by a fleshy, full-bodied wine...96." WA 6/ bottles per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com 13

6 WINES SOLD TO BENEFIT ST MARK'S EPISCOPAL CHURCH (LOTS 32-34) All proceeds from this consignment will benefit St Mark's-in-the-Valley Community Services based in Los Olivos, Santa Ynez Valley, California. Every rural wine-producing region needs public institutions that serve everyone very broadly. St Mark's-in-the-Valley Episcopal Church serves the Santa Ynez Valley in many ways: as a no-fee community center for non-profit groups and community meetings, as a daily welcome center for area visitors, residents and workers, and as an arts venue for concerts and art exhibits, in addition to being home to an Episcopal parish. Annually, St Mark's serves more than 100 regional organizations and special programs with meeting and event space. It is also home to a top-flight professional preschool and to the area's Jewish community. A certified community kitchen to address food insecurity is in the works. These community services are supported by members of St Mark's and generous donors from the wider community making available these key community services. The wines were generously donated by a longtime collector with an amazing home cellar filled with only the finest gems. BORDEAUX BURGUNDY Château Haut-Brion 1959 Graves, Premier Cru Classé 4.5cm, bin-soiled and damp-stained label, oxidized capsule "Sensational. Mature, generous and deep, a many-layered wine that shows sweet berry and chocolate flavors under a layer of slightly scratchy tannins...98." WS 4/ bottle per lot US$ Musigny Maison Leroy cm, scuffed label, light color, depressed cork "Ethereal scents, a lush and silky texture and intense flavors of ripe, rich, sweet fruit. Powerful and youthful, the plum, cherry and mineral character are incredibly balanced...98." WS 12/ bottle per lot US$ Château La Mission Haut-Brion 1961 Graves, Cru Classé very top shoulder, bin-soiled and damp-stained label "Dense, full-bodied, alcoholic, and super-rich, this soft, opulently-textured wine makes for a fabulous drink " RP bottle per lot US$ Romanée-Conti Domaine de la Romanée-Conti cm, marked and lightly scuffed label, cut capsule reveals vineyard and vintage branded cork "...a somber yet unbelievably complex...incredibly rich, dense, round and velvety full-bodied, beautifully nuanced flavors that completely coat the palate...98." BH 4/ bottle per lot US$16,000-24,000 La Tâche Domaine de la Romanée-Conti cm, glue-stained and lightly bin-soiled label "...concentrated, sweet, very rich essence of mature burg with superb length and quality depth...92." BH 4/ bottle per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com

7 LARGE FORMAT BORDEAUX AND FABULOUS GRAND GRU BURGUNDIES, INCLUDING LA TÂCHE 1990 (LOTS 35-57) Property of a highly experienced and longtime Zachys client, the trophies on offer by this veteran and very knowledgeable collector need no introduction. DRC, Rousseau, Liger-Belair, Leroy, and Mugnier are as sought-after as it gets. The magnum OWC of Haut- Brion Blanc 2007 is almost as rare. All removed from a custom-built temperature-controlled home cellar. BORDEAUX BURGUNDY Château Lafite Rothschild 2003 "...extraordinary richness, opulence, power, purity, intensity and viscosity " WA 4/ bottles per lot US$ Château Lafite Rothschild 2005 Provenance: Zachys, December 2012 "The finish is long, with a coffee, almost meaty aftertaste. Very beautiful and balanced...98." WS 3/ double magnum (3L) per lot US$ Château Pavie 2005 St Émilion, Premier Grand Cru Classé (a) "This beauty is intense and full-bodied, with magnificent concentration, a majestic mouthfeel...a tour de force in winemaking " WA 8/ double magnum (3L) per lot US$ Château Haut-Brion Blanc 2007 Pessac Léognan, Cru Classé "Full-bodied, offering amazing density and richness. Loads of fruit are restrained, like a ballerina with perfect form. A tense, poised wine that blows your mind with its balance and structure...97." WS 3/ magnums (1.5L) per lot US$ ,000 Château Haut-Brion Blanc 2008 Pessac Léognan, Cru Classé "...exhibits great fruit intermixed with notes of lanolin, damp earth, graphite, honeyed citrus and orange butter...94." WA 5/ magnum (1.5L) per lot US$ DOMAINE DE LA ROMANÉE-CONTI La Tâche Domaine de la Romanée-Conti cm or better, one lightly bin-soiled label, lightly scuffed labels, one marked label, one wine-stained label "The flavors are big, rich, refined, classy, penetrating and superbly powerful yet everything is in perfect balance...99." BH 6/ bottles per lot US$11,000-16,000 La Tâche Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 1996 lightly scuffed label "The tannins are big, ripe and are completely buffered by the sap with length that is simply phenomenal...96." BH 7/ bottle per lot US$ La Tâche Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 1999 lightly scuffed label "...big, rich and enveloping flavors of hoisin and pure pinot extract of indescribable complexity and length. The big tannins are completely wrapped in velvet and the finish simply does not quit...99." BH 4/ bottle per lot US$ La Tâche Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 2009 lightly wine-stained monopole tag, scuffed and lightly wine-stained label, signs of old seepage "It boasts incredible richness and depth, yet remains elusive. Silky, impossibly refined tannins frame the seamless, resonant finish...everything is simply in the right place...97." WA 4/ bottle per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com 15

8 Clos de la Roche Vieilles Vignes Domaine Ponsot 2006 one with signs of old seepage "...deep full-bodied flavors that completely drench the palate...very suave character to the balanced and equally long finish...93." BH 1/ bottles per lot US$ Chambertin Armand Rousseau 2009 lightly scuffed labels "...flavors that are rich, powerful, serious and densely concentrated, all wrapped in a silky, palate staining, explosive and colossally persistent finish...98." BH 1/ bottles per lot US$ Musigny JF Mugnier 2009 "This is a decidedly powerful, almost extreme style of Musigny...An explosive, mineral-drenched finish lingers on the palate. The 2009 is flat-out dazzling. Wow...98." WA 4/ bottles per lot US$ ,000 Vosne-Romanée Les Beaux Monts Domaine Leroy 2009 Côte de Nuits, Premier Cru wine-stained back label, wine-stained label, signs of old seepage "This is a dazzling wine endowed with tons of class and sheer pedigree. It is not to be missed...96." WA 11/ bottle per lot US$ La Romanée Liger-Belair 2010 lightly scuffed label, short capsule reveals domaine and vineyard branded cork "The bouquet is at once closed, reserved and stunningly complex...on the palate the wine is deep, full-bodied, very pure and nicely reserved...flawless focus and balance, suave, fine-grained tannins and an utterly seamless, pure and tangy finish that goes on forever " JBG 1/ magnum (1.5L) per lot US$10,000-15,000 Musigny Joseph Drouhin 2010 scuffed label "On the palate the wine is deep, full-bodied, and brilliantly pure on the attack, wonderfully sappy and transparent at the core, with fine-grained, substantial tannins and simply haunting length and grip on the regal and utterly sublime finish " JBG 12/ bottle per lot US$ Chevalier-Montrachet Domaine Leflaive 2007 Côte de Beaune, Grand Cru "This is really a lovely effort that is almost as powerful as the Bâtard but as one would expect, finer and even a bit longer with an almost painfully intense backend. A very impressive effort " BH 7/ magnum (1.5L) per lot US$ Montrachet Etienne Sauzet 2007 Côte de Beaune, Grand Cru one lightly damp-stained label, two lightly scuffed labels, one scuffed label "In sum, an absolute knockout. Amazingly, this rivals the '93 as the best Montrachet Sauzet has ever made, and anyone who has tasted a well-stored bottle knows that is high praise...97." BH 7/ bottles per lot US$ Corton-Charlemagne Pierre-Yves Colin-Morey 2008 Côte de Beaune, Grand Cru chipped wax capsule partially reveals cork "This is presently an understated yet powerful wine possessing huge amounts of dry extract and stunning verve " BH 1/ jeroboam (3L) per lot US$ Montrachet Bouchard Père et Fils 2010 Côte de Beaune, Grand Cru "Despite all of the muscle and concentration, there is absolutely no heaviness, indeed the acid support is such that this comes across as impeccably well-balanced on the palate staining finish. This is a magnificent wine...98." BH 6/ magnum (1.5L) per lot US$ SPECIALIST'S PICK: LOT 52 Time after time, I have been at a blind tasting where this Corton in different vintages steals the show. I just had the 2005 in Magnum, and it was breathtaking. This 2008 in 3L from one of the best white producers in Burgundy would be where I would be sure to place some bids today! Shoshana Filene 16 ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com

9 Lot 48 ZACHYS tel fax zachys.com 17

10 SPECIALIST'S PICK: LOT 54: The Krug Savoir Faire is a rare bottle indeed: 71 wines from 11 vintages, the oldest being 1988 and the youngest This wine has the highest proportion of reserve wines in Grande Cuvée's history. For lovers of Krug this is a rare gem. Charles Antin CHAMPAGNE CALIFORNIA Krug Grande Cuvée Savoir-Faire NV Champagne 54 6 bottles per lot US$ ITALY Masseto 2006 Tuscany "A wine of breathtaking depth, it also reveals superb clarity, freshness and vibrancy in a sumptuous, beautifullybalanced style...99." WA 8/ bottles per lot US$ Harlan Estate 1997 "...this enormously-endowed, profoundly rich wine must be tasted to be believed. The finish exceeds one minute " WA 12/ magnum (1.5L) per lot US$ AUSTRALIA Penfolds Grange 2008 South Australia two slightly depressed corks "...a very complex...clearly a wonderfully opulent and a magic vintage for this label " WA 2/ bottles per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com

11 A CONSUMMATE COLLECTOR (LOTS 58-60) This tristate area collector purchased all his wines direct, and all wines have been stored in temperature-controlled storage since acquisition. A COUPLE OF RARITIES (LOTS 61 & 62) From a dedicated collector comes these two special lots of Pétrus 1995 and Montrachet DRC 2001, from a wellmaintained and perfectly stored cellar of course! BORDEAUX BORDEAUX Pétrus 2000 Pomerol one lightly scuffed label "It has a sumptuous, unctuous texture, plenty of tannin, but also vibrancy and brightness. This is a remarkable wine " WA 6/ bottles per lot US$20,000-30,000 BURGUNDY Pétrus 1995 Pomerol bottom neck "Unquestionably one of the vintage's superstars...on the palate, it possesses teeth-staining extract levels, massive body, and rich, sweet black fruits buttressed by powerful, noticeable tannin...96." WA 2/ bottle per lot US$ BURGUNDY Richebourg Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 2007 one lightly scratched glass "...supple, round and tautly muscled broad-shouldered flavors...detailed, focused and almost painfully intense finish brimming with minerality and striking length...93." BH 1/ bottles per lot US$ ,000 Montrachet Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 2001 Côte de Beaune, Grand Cru scuffed label "Wonderfully pure and ripe...racy, intense, superbly dense flavors that display a good deal more minerality than usual and the incredibly long finish has the grip of a red...94." BH 7/ bottle per lot US$ CHAMPAGNE Dom Pérignon 1985 Champagne 1.5cm or better below foil, lightly scuffed labels, one lightly torn capsule partially reveals cork "The flavour is delicate and fruitily elegant, with a sophisticated smoothness and long aftertaste...the wine is now back in a shyly floral, creamy, elegant phase of its own. Super delightful...95." RJ 8/ magnums (1.5L) per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com 19

12 AN ARRAY OF FINE WINES (LOTS 63-75) From a frequent consignor and longtime friend, this offering features rare California wine, as well as the lauded 2005 Pavie (100 points) and 2009 La Tâche. All diligently sourced and stored in temperature and humidity control. BORDEAUX CALIFORNIA Château Mouton Rothschild 2000 "A rich, tannic, earthy style, with loads of creme de cassis and floral notes...a full-bodied wine with plenty of coffee, earth, chocolatey notes " WA 6/ bottle per lot US$ Château Pavie 2005 St Émilion, Premier Grand Cru Classé (a) "...magnificent concentration, a majestic mouthfeel... Beautifully rich, full and multidimensional, this is a tour de force in winemaking " WA 8/ bottles per lot US$ BURGUNDY La Tâche Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 2009 lightly scuffed label "It boasts incredible richness and depth, yet remains elusive. Silky, impossibly refined tannins frame the seamless, resonant finish...everything is simply in the right place...97." WA 4/ bottle per lot US$ Grands Echézeaux Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 2011 "It gently builds, never losing its head mind you, towards a lightly spiced finish that fans out beautifully...93." WA 2/ bottle per lot US$ Shafer Vineyards Hillside Select Cabernet Sauvignon 2013 Stag's Leap District "Massively concentrated but incredibly elegant and poised, this is a wine of great energy and vibrancy. It is fabulously deep, built like a skyscraper, and set for an incredibly long life " WA 10/ double magnum (3L) per lot US$ Colgin Tychson Hill Vineyard Cabernet Sauvignon 2014 "Great precision, vibrant underlying acidity, and sweet, long tannins make this a sumptuous mouthful of wine with a finish of close to 45+ seconds...fabulous effort...98." WA 10/ bottles per lot US$ Next of Kyn No. 8 Red 2014 Assortment California original wood assortment case three 750ml bottles & one magnum (1.5L) Parcel: lots 69 & case per lot US$ case per lot US$ Screaming Eagle Cabernet Sauvignon 2015 Lot 72: "...signature elegance and finesse, it's the incredibly fine, oh-so-pixelated tannins that help to define the signature of this vineyard...a very sensuous, pensive style " WA 10/ bottles per lot US$ bottles per lot US$ Sine Qua Non Le Chemin Vers L'Heresie Grenache 2015 Ventura 73 9 bottles per lot US$ Sine Qua Non Trouver L'Arene Syrah 2015 Ventura 74 9 bottles per lot US$ Abreu Vineyards 2013 original carton Las Posadas Howell Mountain Red (3) Thorevilos Cabernet Sauvignon (3) 75 above 6 bottles per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com

13 A SENSATIONALLY RARE SELECTION FROM A DC COLLECTOR (LOTS ) We return to you with another installment from this devoted and passionate East Coast collector. Having spent decades in the fine wine industry, this collector has acquired some of the finest and rarest wines from Bordeaux, Burgundy, Italy and Champagne. Highlights abound, such as stellar vintages like the 1959 Latour, and 1937 Mouton (out of Mag!), 2009 La Romanée Liger-Belair, and even an impressive selection from Taittinger if you're in a bubbly sort of mood. The collector spared no expense when amassing his collection, which were all meticulously sourced over decades of detailed research from private collections and removed from professional, temperature- and humidity-controlled wine storage. BORDEAUX Château Mouton Rothschild 1937 Pauillac, Deuxième Cru Classé one upper-mid shoulder, one mid shoulder, heavily binsoiled labels, one heavily wine-stained label, one with signs of old seepage "Surprisingly tannic for such an old wine, but a lovely drink all the same, with smoky aromas and concentrated blackberry flavors..." WS 5/ magnums (1.5L) per lot US$ Château Cheval Blanc 1947 St Émilion, Premier Grand Cru Classé (a) upper shoulder, lightly bin-soiled label, depressed cork, lightly corroded capsule A consistent 100-point performer...the crown jewel in any millionaire collector's cellar. I have always been overwhelmed by its almost port-like viscosity and unreal richness " WA 12/ half-bottle (375ml) per lot US$ Château Mouton Rothschild 1953 Pauillac, Deuxième Cru Classé mid shoulder, importer tag adhered to nicked and heavily damp-stained label, Nicolas Stamp Another outstanding vintage, with characteristic cassis flavor and chocolate, currant and cedar nuances, as well as an herbaceous note that blends well with the lovely, sweet fruit flavor on the long finish. WS 5/ magnum (1.5L) per lot US$ Pétrus 1955 Pomerol upper shoulder, loose lightly torn and bin-soiled label, slightly depressed cork, authenticated by the Château bottle per lot US$ Château Latour 1959 upper shoulder, damp-stained, nicked and scuffed label "Very expressive and nuanced...this is a spectacular bottle..." SF bottle per lot US$ Château Margaux 1986 Margaux, Premier Cru Classé one bottom neck, one top shoulder, lightly bin-soiled labels, one lightly oxidized capsule "...emotionally moving. Still incredibly youthful, it showed incredible focus and depth, all backed up by considerable structure...striking in every way " AG 2/ bottles per lot US$ Château Mouton Rothschild 2006 "The full-bodied, powerful 2006 possesses extraordinary purity and clarity " WA 12/ imperial (6L) per lot US$ Château Pavie 2005 St Émilion, Premier Grand Cru Classé (a) "Beautifully rich, full and multidimensional, this is a tour de force in winemaking and certainly one of the top dozen or so 2005 Bordeaux...drink it over the following years! " WA 8/ nebuchadnezzar (15L) per lot US$ ,000 Château Troplong Mondot 2005 St Émilion "...a great effort and a superstar of the vintage...fullbodied, multi-layered, and spectacularly pure and rich, it is a tour de force, and a great tribute " WA 6/ imperial (6L) per lot US$ Château d'yquem 1967 Sauternes, Premier Cru Supérieur one bottom neck, one very top shoulder, one top shoulder, bin-soiled labels, two lightly damp-stained labels, one slightly depressed cork, one with signs of old seepage "...stands up to all the hype-unforgettable for its purity, elegance, harmony, its 'total' everything...seamless, nearly endless finish. Easy to understand its reputation as the greatest Yquem of the last 35 years " WS 5/ bottles per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com 21

14 BURGUNDY DOMAINE DE LA ROMANÉE-CONTI La Tâche Domaine de la Romanée-Conti cm, lightly nicked and heavily bin-soiled label, lightly torn vintage tag, UK exporter stamp "Exuberant, gorgeously spicy, indeed even classic La Tâche nose trimmed in hints of caramel lead to warm, rich, full-bodied flavors of considerable depth and complexity with structure that has fully resolved itself and stunning length...91." BH 11/ bottle per lot US$ Echézeaux Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 1989 includes 12-pack two 1.5cm or better, two 2.5cm, one 3.5cm, Riedel stamped labels bottles per lot US$ ,000 Richebourg Domaine de la Romanée-Conti cm, scuffed and lightly bin-soiled label "...very ripe, beautifully complex flavors...this has excellent density of extract and solid balance. Rich, long and impressive...93." BH 7/ bottle per lot US$ Mazis-Chambertin Armand Rousseau 2011 one 6-pack original carton ''There is excellent power and punch to the lightly mineral-tinged middle weight plus flavors that possess plenty of underlying tension before culminating in a markedly animale finish " BH 1/ bottles per lot US$ Gevrey-Chambertin Clos St Jacques Armand Rousseau 2013 Côte de Nuits, Premier Cru "...gorgeous aromatic lift and energy. Polished and refined throughout...looks to be one of the wines of the vintage " AG 4/ bottles per lot US$ Charmes-Chambertin Armand Rousseau 2014 "This has so much finesse and detail. The palate is taut and crisp, bright...leading to a very refined and sustained finish. This is a lovely wine -- sensual yet understated " WA 12/ bottles per lot US$ Armand Rousseau 2012 Charmes-Chambertin (2) Clos de la Roche (3) 93 above 5 bottles per lot US$ ARMAND ROUSSEAU Chambertin Clos de Bèze Armand Rousseau 1999 "...medium to full-bodied, elegant, and unctuously textured...impeccably ripened tannins detectable in its exceptionally long and delineated finish " WA 8/ bottle per lot US$ Chambertin Clos de Bèze Armand Rousseau 2005 scuffed label "A positively kaleidoscopic nose...the rich, full and utterly classic flavors are a study of the harmonious liaison of refinement and power that culminate in an explosive and driving finish...98." BH 1/ bottle per lot US$ Charmes-Chambertin Armand Rousseau 2011 one 6-pack original carton "This just needs to find its groove, but there is potential, especially because it performed so exquisitely a few months back...90." WA 11/ bottles per lot US$ Armand Rousseau 2013 Charmes-Chambertin (4) one lightly bin-soiled label Clos de la Roche (2) one lightly bin-soiled label Mazy-Chambertin (2) 94 above 8 bottles per lot US$ Echézeaux Emmanuel Rouget cm, damp-stained and marked label "The Echézeaux has exceptional purity of raspberry fruit, deep color, a long, flowing fruitiness, medium to full body..." RP bottle per lot US$ Bonnes-Mares Comte Georges de Vogüé 1993 nicked and lightly bin-soiled label "...a big and still relatively burly wine with an expressive, intense nose revealing some aged notes (but no sous bois) to accompany the black fruit followed by muscular, concentrated and beautifully detailed flavors of excellent intensity and first class length...93." BH 12/ magnum (1.5L) per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com

15 Clos St Denis Dujac 2006 "...slides gracefully into the full, sweet and equally mouth coating flavors that drench the palate in seve...finish that seems to go on and on without end...93." BH 1/ magnums (1.5L) per lot US$ Vosne-Romanée Les Chaumes Liger-Belair 2006 Côte de Nuits, Premier Cru "...this represents another elegant, almost delicate and ethereal (yet, intensely-flavored) performance for the estate...91." WA 12/ bottles per lot US$ Clos de Vougeot Lucien Le Moine 2007 one 6-pack original carton, includes one 6-pack original carton "...a bright, well-stuffed, firmly and finely tannic palate, leading to a finish of impressively saliva-inducing savor. This should be fascinating to follow for the better part of a decade " WA 6/ bottles per lot US$ Chambolle-Musigny Les Feusselottes Mugneret-Gibourg 2009 Côte de Nuits, Premier Cru "It shows lovely textural richness and depth all the way through to the layered, sexy finish " WA 4/ magnums (1.5L) per lot US$ La Romanée Liger-Belair 2009 short capsule reveals vintage branded cork "Knockout...Like liquid silk in the mouth but with superb energy...rising, palate-staining finish features noble tannins and exhilarating sweetness...96." IWC 3/ magnum (1.5L) per lot US$11,000-16,000 Echézeaux Clerget 2012 two 12-pack original cartons bottles per lot US$ Musigny Louis Jadot 2012 "There is an effortless quality here that is totally captivating and it probably represents the apogee of Louis Jadot's mammoth portfolio this year " WA 12/ magnum (1.5L) per lot US$ Lot 101 ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com 23

16 RHÔNE CHAMPAGNE Hermitage JL Chave 1983 Rhône 3.5cm, lightly bin-soiled label, lightly oxidized capsule "On the palate the wine is full-bodied, deep, pure and very transparent down to its stony soil, with a rock solid core of pure, black raspberry fruit, great complexity, melting tannins, bright acids and stunning length and grip on the pure and profound finish...96." JBG 11/ magnum (1.5L) per lot US$ Châteauneuf-du-Pape Vieux Telegraphe 1989 Rhône 6cm, damp-stained and scuffed label, missing lid "...a full-bodied, structured and chewy effort that's fully mature, yet has the concentration and depth to continue evolving nicely...offers a big, mouthful of Châteauneuf-du- Pape love...91." WA 10/ one 9 Liter per lot US$ Châteauneuf-du-Pape Château Beaucastel 1989 jeroboam (1) 5cm, chipped wax capsule, 1990 jeroboam (1) 5.5cm 106 above 2 jeroboams (3L) per lot US$ Louis Roederer Cristal Rosé 1974 Champagne into corroded foil, scuffed label bottle per lot US$ Louis Roederer Cristal 1979 Champagne into foil, lightly scuffed label "...has an exotic nose of orchids and honeysuckle, along with several jars of roasted coffee. The taste is a sensual experience, with a richness reminiscent of hazelnut-filled milk chocolate. Long and classical...96." RJ 6/ bottle per lot US$ Dom Ruinart Rosé 2002 Champagne Lot 109: disgorged in January 2015, original carton Lot 110: disgorged in June 2014, two 6-pack original cartons "When the 2002 finally emerges fully, it is going to be truly monumental " AG 11/ bottles per lot US$ bottles per lot US$ Jacques Selosse Blanc de Blancs Millesime 2005 Champagne disgorged on November 25, 2015 Lot 111: includes 6-pack original carton Lot 112: two 6-pack original cartons bottles per lot US$ bottles per lot US$ Philipponnat Clos des Goisses 2005 Champagne two 6-pack original cartons disgorged in November 2014 "The palate's really rich and structurally powerful; it has a long and chiseled shape that drives deep and long. Powerful yet supple and curvaceous, seductive texture. A great Champagne...95." JS 7/ bottles per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com

17 SPECIALIST'S PICK: LOTS was an outstanding vintage in Champagne, and it wasn't easy to stand out following the exceptional 2002 & 2004's! Taittinger's prestige cuvee is all about texture, it is rich, full bodied, luxurious and will only continue to shine over the next 10+ years. Julia Banks GERMANY Riesling Trockenbeerenauslese Herrenberg Maximin Grünhaus von Schubert 1959 Mosel 1.5cm, wine-stained label bottle per lot US$ ITALY Taittinger Comtes de Champagne Blanc de Blancs 2006 Champagne Lots : four 6-pack original cartons Lot 118: individual original coffrets, two 3-pack original cartons Lot : Parcel: lots Parcel: lots "The 2006 has been nothing short of magnificent both times I have tasted it. Comtes de Champagne remains the single best value (in relative terms) in tête de cuvée Champagne " AG 7/ bottles per lot US$ bottles per lot US$ bottles per lot US$ bottles per lot US$ magnums (1.5L) per lot US$ methuselah (6L) per lot US$ methuselah (6L) per lot US$ methuselah (6L) per lot US$ Jacques Selosse Blanc de Blancs Brut Initial NV Champagne two 6-pack original cartons Lots : disgorged on October 10, 2016 Lot 126: disgorged on May 30, 2016 Parcel: lots As is often the case, the Initial stands out for its focus, vibrancy and tension. The Initial is the freshest of the Selosse wines and is therefore a great introduction to the house style WA 11/ bottles per lot US$ bottles per lot US$ bottles per lot US$ bottles per lot US$ bottles per lot US$ Barolo Cannubi Riserva Cantina Mascarello 1947 Piedmont one 4cm, one 6cm (with elongated neck), bin-soiled labels, one heavily torn label, one lightly corroded capsule, different bottlings bottles per lot US$ Barolo Riserva Cantina Bartolo Mascarello 1958 Piedmont one 3cm, one 3.5cm, one 4cm, one 5cm, heavily binsoiled labels, one lightly torn label bottles per lot US$ Barolo Cantina Bartolo Mascarello 1961 Piedmont 4cm, heavily bin-soiled label bottle per lot US$ Barolo Cantina Bartolo Mascarello 1964 Piedmont two 4cm, one 4.5cm, one 5cm, heavily bin-soiled labels "It was a very beautiful, delicate Barolo...it was a fantastic wine that captured the essence of this warm vintage in its ripe fruit and generous, enveloping personality...this bottle provided plenty of enjoyment...93." AG 11/ bottles per lot US$ Sassicaia 1988 Tuscany one individual, one individual original wood case missing lid one bottom neck, one very top shoulder, one lightly torn label, one with signs of old seepage "Full-bodied, it's firm and rock-solid yet tastes very silky thanks to sensational concentration of fruit. Loads of minerally, peppery character and blackberry and red berry flavors. Super charged, intense, long finish...97." WS 7/ magnums (1.5L) per lot US$ NO LOT ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com 25

18 BURGUNDY, ITALY & CHAMPAGNE'S ALL-STARS (LOTS ) The following offering epitomizes exactly the kind of cellar we would love to walk into and select something blind for drinking. Three of our favorite regions represented by their greatest producers from Rousseau to the heralded Gianfranco Soldera, Giacomo Conterno, and large format Dom Pérignon. There is nothing we wouldn't love to drink here. All wines were removed from a temperature- and humidity-controlled warehouse in Europe. BURGUNDY CHAMPAGNE Chambertin Clos de Bèze Armand Rousseau cm or better, one lightly scuffed label "Wonderfully complex aromatics...flavors of real distinction and very good length...delivers plenty of mouth coating velvet and spice...92." BH 11/ bottles per lot US$ Chambertin Armand Rousseau 2005 "...serious power and weight on the rich, full and driving finish that possesses an exuberant underlying sense of energy...arguably the Chambertin of the vintage...99." BH 1/ bottle per lot US$ Dom Pérignon 1995 Champagne bottle #71 "The aromatic palette is the same as usual, with its exotic fruit and breakfast-y notes, as well as an unusually strong dash of vanilla that is a distinguishing feature of the vintage...93." RJ 8/ jeroboam (3L) per lot US$ Dom Pérignon Rosé 2003 Champagne individual s bottle #31 & 116 "Finely detailed in texture, with an expressive flavor profile...matched to vivid acidity and a rich, minerally character. Broad and creamy on the palate, featuring a long, echoing finish...96." WS 12/ jeroboams (3L) per lot US$ , ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com

19 ITALY Barolo Monfortino Riserva Giacomo Conterno 1961 Piedmont top shoulder, bin-soiled, torn and wine-stained label, corroded capsule "The 1961 Barolo Riserva Monfortino was especially beautiful and fresh. It offered a similar flavor profile as the 1958 with greater harmony and balance, if not quite as much sheer power...94." WA 5/ bottle per lot US$ Sassicaia 1970 Tuscany mid shoulder, heavily damp-stained label "A charmer that's supple, lush and silky, offering distinctive minty, red berry aromas and flavors and fresh character..." WS 7/ bottle per lot US$ Sassicaia 1972 Tuscany mid shoulder, bin-soiled label "...a surprising level of richness and dark succulence despite its advanced age...this remains a very valid and interesting wine that does not lack in terms of overall integrity or persistence..." WA 4/ bottle per lot US$ Sassicaia 1997 Tuscany lightly damp-stained label "...this Tuscan red is full-bodied on the palate, with intense velvety tannins. Long, long finish...93." WS 7/ double magnum (3L) per lot US$ Toscana IGT Case Basse di Gianfranco Soldera 2008 Tuscany "...super-silky, impeccably polished tannins...drop-dead gorgeous...gentle hints of spice linger on the sensual, ravishing finish...an extraordinary wine...96." AG 2/ bottles per lot US$ bottles per lot US$ Toscana IGT Case Basse di Gianfranco Soldera 2009 Tuscany Parcel: lots The tannins remain quite imposing, but I am inclined to think the 2009 will open up earlier than is typically the case here...it is fascinating to taste AG 2/ bottles per lot US$ bottles per lot US$ bottles per lot US$ bottles per lot US$ Masseto 1989 Tuscany bottom neck "Pleasant and fresh, with black olive and berry aromas and flavors, almost tobaccolike. It's medium-bodied, with soft tannins and a light finish..." WS 10/ bottle per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com 27

20 SELECTIONS FROM A WESTCHESTER AFICIONADO (LOTS ) After years of keeping our glasses full, Zachys is honored to offer the first selections from this generous consignor's cellar. The following lots were all purchased through Zachys Retail and kept in pristine temperature-controlled storage since purchase. All wines tasted over several years of shared enjoyment have been in perfect condition, bid with absolute confidence! Lots 155 & ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com

21 BURGUNDY ARMAND ROUSSEAU Chambertin Armand Rousseau 1999 "...a simply knock out Chambertin, worthy of every accolade reserved for the very best in Burgundy...93." BH 11/ bottles per lot US$ ,000 Chambertin Clos de Bèze Armand Rousseau 1999 one lightly nicked label "...medium to full-bodied, elegant, and unctuously textured...impeccably ripened tannins detectable in its exceptionally long and delineated finish " WA 8/ bottles per lot US$ ,000 Gevrey-Chambertin Clos St Jacques Armand Rousseau 1999 Côte de Nuits, Premier Cru lightly scuffed labels "...intensely sappy pinot fruit, long, rich, powerful and earthy flavors all held together by extraordinary balance. This is just flat out reference standard CSJ " BH 1/ bottles per lot US$ Chambertin Armand Rousseau 2002 "Profound aromas of raspberry and strawberry liqueur and sappy oak, with an almost honeyed sweetness " IWC 3/ bottles per lot US$ Bonnes-Mares Georges Roumier 1999 lightly damp-stained labels "...rich, broad, and expansive...silky-textured and leads to a long, black pepper-filled finish..." WA 8/ bottles per lot US$ Bonnes-Mares Georges Roumier 2005 "...that continues on the rich, intense and quite firmly structured big-boned flavors that are hugely long...96." BH 1/ bottles per lot US$ ITALY GIACOMO CONTERNO Barolo Monfortino Riserva Giacomo Conterno 1999 Piedmont Lot 158: "...an endless counterpoint of aromas, flavors and sensations that are hard to fully capture with mere words...98." WA 10/ bottles per lot US$ double magnum (3L) per lot US$ Barolo Monfortino Riserva Giacomo Conterno 2000 Piedmont "...explodes from the glass with a luxurious, expansive personality that leaves me speachless. Endowed with generous ripe fruit, it is a seamless, seductive Monfortino that possesses incredible length as well as purity in a style...97." WA 10/ bottles per lot US$ Chambertin Clos de Bèze Armand Rousseau 2002 "...exuberant, big, rich, round and intensely sappy. The finish explodes in the mouth and is superbly complex with first rate vibrancy " BH 1/ bottles per lot US$ Gevrey-Chambertin Clos St Jacques Armand Rousseau 2002 Côte de Nuits, Premier Cru two lightly nicked labels "Its satin-textured personality coats the taster's palate with boisterous dark cherry, cinnamon, spicy oak, and blackberry flavors that linger in its extensive finish " WA 6/ bottles per lot US$ Barolo Monfortino Riserva Giacomo Conterno 2001 Piedmont "...dense, pure and intense to the core...it is majestic though...there is so much to look forward to...98." AG 5/ bottles per lot US$ magnums (1.5L) per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com 29

22 BAROLO, BARBARESCO & BUBBLES! (LOTS ) The following lots hail from a repeat consignor in Europe who has amassed an incredible collection of Italian and Champagne icons from some of the greatest vintages across the 60s, 70, and 80s. Many of these bottles are just starting to reach their peak drinking age, making it a perfect time to acquire them. With Giacosa, Conterno, and Dom Pérignon, you'll be tasting the stars. All wines were removed from professional temperature- and humidity-controlled cellar in London. BORDEAUX Château Rieussec 2001 Sauternes, Premier Cru Classé "Full-bodied, very sweet with fantastic concentration of ripe and botrytized fruit, yet balanced and refined...absolutely mind-blowing " WS 6/ bottles per lot US$ CHAMPAGNE DOM PÉRIGNON Dom Pérignon 1966 Champagne one 2.5cm below foil, one 3cm below foil, one torn foil, one torn foil partially reveals cork "In the mouth one can perceive the finest marmalade and small uplifting bubbles. Majestic aftertaste...96." RJ 6/ bottles per lot US$ Dom Pérignon 1970 Champagne 2cm or better below foil, one lightly torn foil partially reveals cork, two Italian importer "...pale; excellent, lightly oaky-smoky bouquet; dry, crisp, refined. Very good..." MB 9/ bottles per lot US$ Dom Pérignon 1976 Champagne 2cm or better below foil, Italian importer "Gold color. Lovely aromas of honeyed almonds and peach pie. On the palate, a blend of citrus liqueur, peach soda, lemon, apricot, and candy cane. Seems to have a substantial dosage. At its mature peak. Wonderful. Outstanding." FH 5/ bottles per lot US$ Dom Pérignon 1982 Champagne into foil, one torn foil partially reveals cork, Italian importer "Medium light lemon gold color. Bright and still youthful aromas of Meyer lemon and lime. Moderate, fairly relaxed acidity. The apparently substantial dosage makes it seem a bit soda-poppy with hints of sugar cane and stalk. Excellent." FH 5/ bottles per lot US$ Jacques Selosse Cuvée Exquise NV Champagne "The finish is long, clean and refreshing. The Exquise would make a terrific match to seared foie gras and fruitbased desserts...92." WA 12/ bottles per lot US$ ITALY Amarone Recioto dell Valpolicella Classico Superiore Bertani 1961 Veneto Lot 168: four 4.5cm, seven 5cm, one 6cm, one torn label, one with signs of old seepage, 720ml Lot 169: 5cm, 720ml 168 twelve 720ml per lot US$ twelve 720ml per lot US$ Barolo Monfortino Riserva Giacomo Conterno 1961 Piedmont one just below top shoulder, one upper-mid shoulder, heavily bin-soiled labels, oxidized capsules, signs of old seepage "...especially beautiful and fresh. It offered a similar flavor profile as the 1958 with greater harmony and balance, if not quite as much sheer power...94." WA 5/ bottles per lot US$ Barolo Giacomo Conterno 1964 Piedmont Lot 171: one 2.5cm, one 3cm, three 4cm, bin-soiled labels, one lightly torn label, 720ml Lot 172: five 3.5cm, four 4cm, three 4.5cm, four lightly torn labels, one torn label, 720ml "...presents an incredibly fresh, delicate and perfumed nose that continues seamlessly onto the palate, showing flavors of cherries and spices, and finishing with very sweet, soft tannins...truly exceptional and unforgettable...98." WA 4/ five 720ml per lot US$ twelve 720ml per lot US$ Barolo Collina Rionda di Serralunga Bruno Giacosa 1971 Piedmont bottom neck, lightly bin-soiled label, oxidized capsule, 720ml 173 one 720ml per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com

23 MAGNIFICENT WINE from the GRAND COLLECTION of a GLOBETROTTING GOURMAND (LOTS ) A longtime collector, great friend of Zachys and a widely traveled gourmand (though without the waistline to match) has chosen Zachys to offer a portion of his superb wine collection of European, American, and Australian gems as part of a judicious downsizing, which still leaves him with more than enough trophy wine to enjoy and share with friends. The hallmark of this collection is the focus on marquee producers, from First Growth Bordeaux, to finest Burgundies from DRC, Jayer, Rousseau, and Coche-Dury, Chave in the Rhône, Harlan, Colgin, and Shafer in California, and Hill of Grace and Grange in the Barossa. There are a handful of extreme rarities, including Jayer and Rousseau from the 1978 vintage, La Mouline 1976, Único 1962, and Grange Most of the pre-2000 vintage wines in this collection were purchased in the secondary market between fifteen and twenty-five years ago, including Zachys and Zachys-Christie's auctions, and placed in long term commercial storage from which they have been removed for this sale. If rated by Michelin, this wine collection would unquestionably earn three stars. ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com 31

24 BORDEAUX Château Ausone 1990 St Émilion, Premier Grand Cru Classé (a) into neck, torn, wine-stained and lightly scuffed label Provenance: Zachys, April 2016 Lot 289 "...offers up sweet, jammy fruit notes as well as a firm finish with the tell-tale crushed rock minerality that this estate often achieves. The aromatics suggest a fully mature wine, but in the mouth, the firm structure and density indicate this effort needs more time...91." WA 6/ imperial (6L) per lot US$ Château Cheval Blanc 1978 St Émilion, Premier Grand Cru Classé (a) two very top shoulder, four top shoulder, four lightly binsoiled labels "The wine is still dark ruby, with a relatively stubborn and backward bouquet...on the palate, the wine is tannic, medium bodied, and admirably concentrated." RP bottles per lot US$ Château Cheval Blanc 1986 St Émilion, Premier Grand Cru Classé (a) includes 12-pack five bottom neck or better, one very top shoulder, one lightly damp-stained label "Medium to full-bodied, and moderately tannic...the wine is rich, intense, and well-made...92." WA 12/ bottles per lot US$ Château Cheval Blanc 1995 St Émilion, Premier Grand Cru Classé (a) "A beautiful Cheval Blanc. Compacted and extremely fruity with gorgeous ripe fruit character...full-bodied, with velvety tannins...94." WS 1/ double magnums (3L) per lot US$ Château Cheval Blanc 2000 St Émilion, Premier Grand Cru Classé (a) "A broad wine with compelling purity, a layered texture, and sweet tannin, with hints of coffee and earth in the background...99." WA 7/ bottles per lot US$ ,000 Château Haut-Brion 1961 Graves, Premier Cru Classé one 4cm, one 4.5cm, lightly bin-soiled labels, lightly corroded capsules, Georgia tax stamps "...pure perfection, with gloriously intense aromas. This has always been a prodigious effort " WA 2/ bottles per lot US$ Château Haut-Brion 2000 Pessac Léognan, Premier Cru Classé "...a deep, layered, sumptuously textured, full-bodied Haut-Brion, but one with extraordinary complexity...99." WA 6/ bottles per lot US$ Château Lafite Rothschild 1986 bottom neck or better, eight with importer tags adhered to labels "...beautifully defined, still full of energy...it must rank as one of the finest wines from the estate...98." WA 12/ bottles per lot US$10,000-16,000 Château Lafite Rothschild 1989 ten bottom neck or better, two very top shoulder, one lightly damp-stained label "Wonderful berry and tobacco character, with chocolate and cedar. Full-bodied, yet elegant and silky. Beautifully long. This is always outstanding...94." WS 2/ bottles per lot US$ Château Latour 1988 bottom neck or better, two slightly depressed corks, one with signs of old seepage Provenance: Zachys, "The Vault I" "Full-bodied, with ultrafine tannins and a long, long finish. Caresses every inch of the palate. It's the quality of the tannins that's impressive here. What a great and beautiful wine...96." WS double magnums (3L) per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com

25 Lot 181 ZACHYS tel fax zachys.com 33

26 Lot ZACHYS tel fax zachys.com

27 Château Latour 1996 "...reminiscent to the 1990 Latour...the same generosity on the palate and similar notes on the nose. The major differences are that the 1996 shows more herbal and almost saline qualities, which set it apart and make it a truly breathtaking effort..." SF bottles per lot US$ ,000 Château Margaux 1986 Margaux, Premier Cru Classé four bottom neck or better, one top shoulder, two lightly bin-soiled labels, one slightly protruded cork "...emotionally moving. Still incredibly youthful, it showed incredible focus and depth, all backed up by considerable structure...striking in every way " AG 2/ bottles per lot US$ Château Mouton Rothschild 1985 bottom neck "...glorious...all the exotic Mouton fragrance; soft, flavoury, crisp..." MB double magnum (3L) per lot US$ Château Mouton Rothschild 1996 "Incredible nose of ultraripe fruit, it's yet subtle and complex. Full-bodied, with very ripe, almost sweet fruit and a long, long caressing finish. Superb...96." WS bottles per lot US$ Château Pichon-Baron 1961 Pauillac, Deuxième Cru Classé bottom neck or better, one previously cut capsule reveals fully branded cork "...the 1961 Pichon-Longueville has a big, spicy, dampearth, cedary bouquet, and rich, fat, substantial flavors..." RP bottles per lot US$ Château Lynch-Bages 1970 Pauillac, Cinquième Cru Classé upper shoulder, two depressed corks Provenance: Zachys, December 2016 "Nath Johnston" bottles per lot US$ Château Léoville Las Cases 1982 St Julien, Deuxième Cru Classé one bottom neck, five very top shoulder, two top shoulder, two damp-stained labels, one wine-stained label, four lightly oxidized capsules, two different importers, two with signs of old seepage "Classic lead pencil, cassis, kirsch, cedar, and spice characteristics are abundant in both the nose and full-bodied flavors " WA 6/ bottles per lot US$ Château Angélus 1985 St Émilion, Premier Grand Cru Classé (a) three very top shoulder, nine top shoulder Provenance: Zachys, December 2016 "Nath Johnston" "Very concentrated, with plum and cassis character and a hint of nuts. It's full-bodied, with well-integrated tannins and loads of coffee and fruit on the finish..." WS 10/ bottles per lot US$ Château Léoville Las Cases 1988 St Julien, Deuxième Cru Classé four bottom neck or better, two very top shoulder, one damp-stained label, two with signs of old seepage "An outstanding Las Cases,...Full-bodied, with velvety tannins and lovely tobacco, violet and berry aromas and flavors. Extremely fruity finish...92." WS 11/ magnums (1.5L) per lot US$ Château La Mission Haut-Brion 1989 Pessac Léognan, Cru Classé bottom neck or better, three lightly damp-stained labels, one wine-stained label "Full-bodied with extraordinary opulence as well as sweet, well-integrated, velvety tannins...fresh, lively, blockbuster La Mission " WA 8/ bottles per lot US$10,000-16,000 ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com 35

28 Château La Mission Haut-Brion 1995 Pessac Léognan, Cru Classé "...more powerful, richer, riper, sweeter fruit...glycerinendowed, fuller-bodied personality. The dark saturated purple color is followed by aromas of sweet, earthy fruit... With low acidity and chewy, full-bodied flavors, this intense " RP bottles per lot US$ Château Calon Ségur 2000 St Estèphe, Troisième Cru Classé Provenance: Zachys, September bottles per lot US$ Château Clinet 2000 Pomerol bottles per lot US$ Château Cos d Estournel 2005 St Estèphe, Deuxième Cru Classé "Full and very layered with chewy polished tannins and a long, long finish. Just starting to open...99." JS 10/ imperial (6L) per lot US$ Château Palmer 2005 Margaux, Troisième Cru Classé "...long, multi-dimensional and textured. This wonderfully pure, stunning wine once again performs as a First Growth...98." WA 6/ bottles per lot US$ CHÂTEAU D'YQUEM Château d'yquem 1948 Sauternes, Premier Cru Supérieur one just below top shoulder, one upper-mid shoulder, one mid shoulder, bin-soiled labels, one nicked label, two torn labels, two corroded capsules, short capsules reveal fully branded corks, two with signs of old seepage "Very sweet and yummy...it's lovely on the palate, with ripe and nicely sweet character. Shows good harmony from dried fruit, honey and maple syrup flavors." WS 5/ bottles per lot US$ Château d'yquem 1983 Sauternes, Premier Cru Supérieur with damaged lid bottom neck or better, three heavily wine-stained labels, six lightly wine-stained labels, two scuffed labels, three slightly depressed corks, four with signs of old seepage "...an attractive orange-gold, its bouquet emitting the usual scents, but with great intensity, apricots, honeyed botrytis, creme brulee; a sweet, creamy wine masking considerable power and assertiveness..." MB 11/ bottles per lot US$ Château d'yquem 1989 Sauternes, Premier Cru Supérieur bottom neck or better "...a large-scaled, massively rich, unctuously-textured wine that should evolve effortlessly for a half century or more... the richest Yquem made in the eighties...97." RP bottles per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com

29 BURGUNDY SPECIALIST'S PICK: LOT 199: A bottle I drank many years ago at Bar Boulud to finish after a 1961 Claret dinner. An excellent Yquem from a vintage you don't see too often. Essential buying for birth years or verticals. Charles Antin Château d'yquem 1994 Sauternes, Premier Cru Supérieur "Yellow-gold color. Intense aromas of petrol, spice and honey, with dried apricot. Full-bodied, very sweet, with a green apple and honey character; petrol character comes through on the finish..." WS 5/ bottles per lot US$ Château d'yquem 1998 Sauternes, Premier Cru Supérieur "...it is well-delineated, with wonderfully sweet aromas... Medium to full-bodied...it is gorgeously pure, precise, and strikingly complex...95." WA 10/ half-bottles (375ml) per lot US$ Château d'yquem 1999 Sauternes, Premier Cru Supérieur half-bottles (375ml) per lot US$ Château d'yquem 2000 Sauternes, Premier Cru Supérieur half-bottles (375ml) per lot US$ DOMAINE DE LA ROMANÉE-CONTI La Tâche Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 1986 one 1.5cm, one 3cm, lightly marked labels, one nicked vintage tag, scuffed labels, one with signs of old seepage "...forward, elegant, fine, ultra spicy aromas framed by the barest hint of sous bois leading to medium weight, relatively fine flavors...this is an undeniable success..." BH 10/ bottles per lot US$ Echézeaux Domaine de la Romanée-Conti cm, lightly scuffed label "This wine is a gorgeously elegant, complex, feminine, highly-detailed and rich wine." WA 8/ magnum (1.5L) per lot US$ Grands Echézeaux Domaine de la Romanée-Conti cm, lightly scuffed label, lightly corroded capsule, signs of old seepage magnum (1.5L) per lot US$ Grands Echézeaux Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 1996 five with importer tags adhered to labels, one lightly marked label, one scuffed label, one wine-stained label "With 90 minutes of air, this becomes superbly elegant and spicy with outstanding precision and detail...94." BH 7/ bottles per lot US$11,000-16,000 ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com 37

30 Richebourg Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 1996 importer tags adhered to labels, two lightly marked labels "...rich, sweet and still tight medium full and quite firmly structured flavors that possess a long though slightly edgy and austere finish...92." BH 4/ bottles per lot US$12,000-18,000 Assortment Case Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 1997 original wood assortment case one Romanée-Conti (slightly protruded cork), three La Tâche, two Richebourg, two Romanée-St-Vivant (one with signs of old seepage), one Grands Echézeaux (signs of old seepage), three Echézeaux (one marked label) case per lot US$28,000-42,000 Richebourg Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 1998 lightly bin-soiled labels, consecutive bottle numbers "...quite expressive...multi-layered flavor profile of good intensity, detail and exceptional length. Very concentrated with medium sized tannins...94." BH 1/ bottles per lot US$10,000-15,000 Assortment Case Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 2000 original wood assortment case banded prior to inspection one Romanée-Conti, three La Tâche, two Richebourg, two Romanée-St-Vivant, two Grands Echézeaux, two Echézeaux Provenance: Zachys, March 2004 Lot case per lot US$38,000-55,000 Lot ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com

31 DUJAC Clos de la Roche Dujac cm, bin-soiled labels, one scuffed label, one lightly corroded capsule, one slightly depressed cork, one loose capsule reveals fully branded cork "An expressive nose featuring strong secondary aromas leads to delicious, complex and moderately firm flavors that offer a wonderfully long if slightly drying finish...91." BH 11/ bottles per lot US$ ,000 Clos de la Roche Dujac 1995 Lot 213: one lightly bin-soiled label Lot 214: lightly marked and scuffed label, heavily chipped wax capsule reveals cork, "...a fabulous effort for the vintage...on the palate the wine is medium-full, but really deep and packed with fruit, with great delineation, and serious reserves in the midpalate " JBG 1/ bottles per lot US$ methuselah (6L) per lot US$ ,000 Clos St Denis Dujac 1996 "On the palate the wine is deep, full-bodied and very pure, with a lovely sappy core, impeccable focus and seamless balance, and a very long, modestly tannic and dancing finish...95." JBG 9/ bottles per lot US$ Clos de la Roche Dujac 2001 "...explode from the glass that merge seamlessly into bigger, richer, rounder and more muscular flavors. Authoritative, gorgeously textured and very stylish...93." BH 1/ jeroboam (3L) per lot US$ Echézeaux Henri Jayer cm, lightly wine-stained label, tape adhered to vintage tag, cut capsule reveals fully branded cork, signs of old seepage "...aromatically subdued, revealing only glimpses of spicy, almost entirely secondary aromas yet the flavors are exuberant and intensely spicy...93." BH 1/ bottle per lot US$ ,000 Vosne-Romanée Les Beaux Monts Domaine Leroy 1990 Côte de Nuits, Premier Cru 2cm or better Lot 220: lightly bin-soiled label "Deep and very darkly colored with extremely ripe, borderline over ripe nose that evidences loads of spice and rich black fruits followed by sexy, sappy, intense flavors... Impressive...92." BH 5/ bottle per lot US$ bottle per lot US$ Bonnes-Mares Dujac 2001 "Austere, backward and brooding nose of red and black fruit, crushed herbs and a touch of earth and leather with full, complex, driving, muscular and very powerful flavors...possess outstanding persistence...93." BH 1/ magnum (1.5L) per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com 39

32 Lots ZACHYS tel fax zachys.com

33 ARMAND ROUSSEAU One will get little argument to the assertion that Domaine Armand Rousseau is the finest estate in Gevrey- Chambertin. The vintages of the 1980s and 1990s at Domaine Rousseau have produced one of the greatest runs of profound Burgundy ever witnessed by any estate in the region, with the domaine producing legendary efforts in the widely recognized great years of the span from 1985 to Their two flagship bottlings of Chambertin and Chambertin Clos de Bèze have always ranked amongst the top dozen wines to be found in these vintages. Of the two Grand Crus at the pinnacle of the brilliant portfolio of Rousseau wines, the Chambertin Clos de Bèze tends to be the more exotic and spicy of the two wines, with glorious fruit tones of black cherry, plum, blood orange often augmented by notes of Gevrey's grilled meat, chocolate and exotic spices. The Chambertin is typically the slightly slower wine to unfold, with a more understated profile of plum, red cherry and strawberry, coupled with notes of cocoa powder, coffee, grilled meats and violets impeccably balanced, tangy and never come across as over-oaked. They are amongst the very greatest red wines to be found in the world. John Gilman, View From the Cellar Gevrey-Chambertin Clos St Jacques Armand Rousseau 2000 Côte de Nuits, Premier Cru "There is however even better power and drive with outstanding acid/fruit balance and seamless integration " BH 1/ bottles per lot US$ Chambertin Clos de Bèze Armand Rousseau 2002 one lightly scuffed label, one wine-stained vintage tag "...exuberant, big, rich, round and intensely sappy. The finish explodes in the mouth and is superbly complex with first rate vibrancy " BH 1/ bottles per lot US$16,000-26,000 Charmes-Chambertin Armand Rousseau 2005 "...rich, sweet, textured and fleshy flavors that are generous but not soft on the opulent and deep finish." BH 1/ bottles per lot US$ Gevrey-Chambertin Lavaux St Jacques Armand Rousseau 2005 Côte de Nuits, Premier Cru bottles per lot US$ Chambertin Armand Rousseau cm "...purity and finesse. The fine, velvety, almost lacy flavors are elegant, seductive and rich with perfect finishing acidity...extremely impressive...93." BH 1/ bottle per lot US$ Chambertin Armand Rousseau cm "Perfumed...very rich and forward medium weight flavors of exceptional length...multiple, and consistent, notes...93." BH 5/ bottle per lot US$ Chambertin Clos de Bèze Armand Rousseau cm, wine-stained vintage tag "...a simply dazzling breadth of aromas...detailed, driving and still very fresh flavors that display astounding depth... slow building, wonderfully persistent length...96." BH 10/ bottle per lot US$ Chambertin Clos de Bèze Armand Rousseau 2000 original carton "...unbelievably complex aromas and flavors...rich and vibrant with Grand Cru weight and size " BH 1/ bottles per lot US$12,000-18,000 Griotte-Chambertin Vieilles Vignes Domaine Ponsot cm or better, lightly scuffed labels, one slightly depressed cork bottles per lot US$ Mazis-Chambertin Domaine d'auvenay 1995 two 1.5cm or better, one 3.5cm, one wine-stained label, one with signs of old seepage "...must be tasted to be believed. Highly structured, fullbodied and powerful...95." WA 6/ bottles per lot US$ Vosne-Romanée Les Beaumonts Emmanuel Rouget 1996 Côte de Nuits, Premier Cru "Absolutely stunning. Deep, pure aromas of cassis, violets and vanilla are followed by rich flavors and silky texure. Everything is woven together by juicy acidity,with a cascade of berries on the finish...94." WS bottles per lot US$ Mazis-Chambertin Faiveley 2012 Provenance: Zachys, May 2016 "As is typically the case there is also more size, weight, richness and power if a bit less refinement and minerality to the large-scaled flavors " BH 1/ bottles per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com 41

34 COCHE-DURY Meursault Perrières Coche-Dury 1990 Côte de Beaune, Premier Cru 1.5cm, lightly torn label "...big, muscular, rich and gorgeously nuanced palate staining flavors that offer huge length and real power plus class and breed to burn...93." BH 6/ bottle per lot US$ Meursault Perrières Coche-Dury 1992 Côte de Beaune, Premier Cru 3.5cm "The nose explodes from the glass...the thrill ride continues with medium weight, full, rich, impressively layered flavors dripping with minerality followed by a vibrant, palate staining, immensely long finish. An incredible performance...96." BH 10/ bottle per lot US$ Meursault Perrières Coche-Dury 1993 Côte de Beaune, Premier Cru 2cm, slightly depressed cork "...a stunning wine, offering up a deep and refined nose... This is an excellent bottle of wine that is reference point Perrières...94." JBG 7/ bottle per lot US$ Meursault Perrières Coche-Dury 1996 Côte de Beaune, Premier Cru "...offers up a melange of blinding intensity...on the palate the wine is full-bodied, razor sharp and packed to the core...a mind-boggling wine...99." JBG 6/ bottle per lot US$ Puligny-Montrachet Clavoillon Domaine Leflaive 2005 Côte de Beaune, Premier Cru one with signs of old seepage "...round, rich and concentrated flavors that possess real texture due to the solid dry extract on the mouth coating and solidly long finish...91." BH 7/ bottles per lot US$ Meursault Clos de la Barre Comtes Lafon 2007 Côte de Beaune original carton "For a wine with a light touch, this finishes with impressive thrust, not to mention aromatic persistence. Lafon calls this his favorite Clos de la Barre in a long time...91." IWC 9/ bottles per lot US$ Puligny-Montrachet Clavoillon Domaine Leflaive 2007 Côte de Beaune, Premier Cru two 6-pack s "On the palate, this is concentrated and seamless, with balance and harmony. Just needs time to show all its features. Offers fine length, with a chalky feel at the end...94." WS 6/ bottles per lot US$ Corton-Charlemagne Henri Boillot 2009 Côte de Beaune, Grand Cru two 6-pack s "This one struck me as a shape-shifting solid masquerading as a liquid today; it has the chewiness and structure of a red wine " IWC 9/ bottles per lot US$ Meursault Clos des Ambres Arnaud Ente 2009 Côte de Beaune "The very complex bouquet is excellent...on the palate the wine is full-bodied, crisp and very minerally on the backend...great focus and cut on the finish. Just a beautiful bottle of Meursault...93." JBG 11/ bottles per lot US$ Meursault Goutte d'or Arnaud Ente 2009 Côte de Beaune, Premier Cru "Sweet spot Outstanding...precise and seriously persistent finish. This explosive effort offers plenty of personality. Color me impressed " BH 2/ bottles per lot US$ Meursault La Seve Du Clos Arnaud Ente 2010 Côte de Beaune original carton "On the palate the wine is deep, full-bodied and very, very pure and elegant on the attack...stunning balance, great length...electric finish. A brilliant, brilliant Meursault " JBG 12/ bottles per lot US$ SPECIALIST'S PICK: LOT 243 On a recent trip to France, I took advantage of the slightly more affordable costs of the wines of Arnaud Ente, including the one listed above. I love the precise and linear quality that these wines have. They do not display the roundness and richness you find in many Meursaults, but truly showcase the elegance of the region. Shoshana Filene 42 ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com

35 Lots 233, 235 & 236 ZACHYS tel fax zachys.com 43

36 RHÔNE CHAVE Considered widely as the quintessential Hermitage producer, Chave typifies traditionalism in both viticulture and his winemaking philosophy. The Domaine, begun in 1481, has been handed down from generation to generation. While Gerard Chave still maintains a presence, it is his son, Jean-Louis who is at the helm making some of the best wines in France, if not the world over. The family owns eight plots of land on the hill of Hermitage and in a time when single vineyard Cuvées are all the rage, still holds true to the belief that the assemblage of all of the grapes produces a more complex, powerful and artisanal wine. To Jean-Louis the soil differences found in each plot of land profoundly affect production which is why the expression of the blend is superior to the single vineyard. Chave is passionate about allowing the grapes to achieve complete ripeness via a long hang time on the vine and therefore the wines exude profound extraction as well as substantial alcohol. There is also a natural selection of low yielding fruit due to an average vine age of sixty years or more which adds greater intensity to the wines. The vineyards are farmed organically and the horse and plough are utilized to this day! The Hermitage Rouge is made of 100 percent Syrah while the Blanc is generally eighty percent Marsanne and twenty percent Roussanne. In vinification, contrary to modernist techniques once again, Chave eschews new oak, using only ten percent for the Rouge and mostly old oak and stainless steel for the fermentation and aging of the Blanc. The white Hermitage has the texture and richness of a great white Burgundy with immense complexity and the ability to age substantially. When serving the Blanc, Jean- Louis advises that they are not chilled too much, and are always decanted for a short period. The Rouge is a highlight. Hermitage JL Chave 1985 Rhône 2cm or better, torn labels "...profound...on the palate the wine is full-bodied, packed with fruit, with great focus and grip, bright acids, some serious ripe tannins, and a long, complex and palate-staining finish...95." JBG 12/ bottles per lot US$ Hermitage JL Chave 1997 Rhône "...gorgeous, evolved bouquet...creamy-textured, fullbodied, and opulent, this low acid, gloriously ripe, layered " WA 2/ bottles per lot US$ Hermitage JL Chave 1999 Rhône original carton two with signs of old seepage "...fabulous texture, purity, and sweetness as well as a finish that lasts for nearly a minute...96." WA 4/ bottles per lot US$ Hermitage JL Chave 2001 Rhône Lot 248: heavily chipped wax capsule fully reveals cork, signs of old seepage "Great richness and texture here, with notes of tar, minerals, saddle leather and cocoa rippling through the finish. Mouthwatering acidity balances it all...95." WS 8/ bottles per lot US$ jeroboam (3L) per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com

37 Hermitage JL Chave 2002 Rhône original carton "...sweet notes of melted licorice, briery berries, earth, and herbs. Medium to full-bodied, pure, elegant, and intense " WA 12/ bottles per lot US$ Hermitage Blanc JL Chave 1999 Rhône original carton "...an oily, unctuously-textured wine with low acidity, faboulous, concentrates, honeysuckle, citrus, liquid mineral, and acacia flower-like flavors...94." WA 4/ bottles per lot US$ Hermitage JL Chave 2007 Rhône "...notes of creme de cassis, loamy soil, crushed rocks and acacia flowers, a rare opulence and a full-bodied style. Reminiscent of the 1991 Hermitage...95." WA 2/ bottles per lot US$ Hermitage JL Chave 2009 Rhône "Anyone who loves Hermitage and has a cold cellar should be lining up to get a few bottles of this beauty " WA 12/ bottles per lot US$ Hermitage JL Chave 2012 Rhône "...superb mid-palate depth and a focused, structured finish. It's a beautiful, classy 2012 that will have years of longevity " WA 12/ bottles per lot US$ Hermitage Blanc JL Chave 1997 Rhône "One of my favorite white Hermitage to drink now...it is an unctuously-textured, full-bodied white with an evolved personality...94." WA 4/ bottles per lot US$ Hermitage Blanc JL Chave 1989 (4) three 2cm or better, one 2.5cm 1994 (6) one lightly scuffed label, one lightly wine-stained vintage tag, one with signs of old seepage 255 above 10 bottles per lot US$ Hermitage Blanc JL Chave 1995 (6) one oxidized capsule 1996 (6) two oxidized capsules 256 above 12 bottles per lot US$ Hermitage Blanc JL Chave 1998 (6) 2000 (6) 257 above 12 bottles per lot US$ Hermitage Blanc JL Chave original carton 2003 (6) 2012 (6) 258 above 12 bottles per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com 45

38 Lot ZACHYS tel fax zachys.com

39 Côte-Rôtie La Mouline Guigal 1976 Rhône two 2cm or better, one 3cm, one lightly nicked label, one lightly scuffed label, two corroded capsules "...so concentrated; one simply does not see wines such as this...extremely unctuous and viscous, with mind-boggling concentration " RP bottles per lot US$ ,000 Côte-Rôtie La Turque Guigal 2002 Rhône four 3-pack s "Fruity, soft, round, and substantial " WA 2/ bottles per lot US$ Châteauneuf-du-Pape Reserve des Célestins Henri Bonneau 1989 Rhône 2cm or better, two slightly depressed corks "...deep and brilliantly profound in its purity and complexity, as it soars from the glass...99." JBG 11/ bottles per lot US$ Hermitage La Chapelle Jaboulet 1989 Rhône two 2cm or better, one 2.5cm, one 3cm, two 3.5cm, one lightly scuffed label, one slightly depressed cork, one with signs of old seepage "...a fabulous wine that offers sensational aromatic fireworks to go with full-bodied richness and depth...blockbuster texture and a finish that just won't quit...96." WA 9/ bottles per lot US$ Hermitage La Chapelle Jaboulet 1998 Rhône individual s jeroboams (3L) per lot US$ Châteauneuf-du-Pape Reserve des Célestins Henri Bonneau 1990 Rhône 2cm or better, heavily nicked labels, one lightly winestained vintage tag, one torn vintage tag, one with signs of old seepage "This full-bodied, viscous, prodigious Châteauneuf-du-Pape must be tasted to be believed. It is more like a food than a beverage " WA 1/ bottles per lot US$ Châteauneuf-du-Pape Reserve des Célestins Henri Bonneau 1995 Rhône "...exhibits a dense saturated plum/garnet color as well as an intense nose of roasted meats, beef blood, plum, cherry, and blackberry liqueur, truffle, and spice box...95." WA 10/ bottles per lot US$ Châteauneuf-du-Pape Hommage à Jacques Perrin Château Beaucastel 1995 Rhône "...massive richness, opaque purple color, and sweet, earthy fruit that oozes over the palate with extraordinary intensity and purity...it is a modern-day classic...96." WA 10/ bottles per lot US$ Châteauneuf-du-Pape Hommage à Jacques Perrin Château Beaucastel 2003 (6) 2004 (3) 267 above 9 bottles per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com 47

40 CHAMPAGNE KRUG Krug Clos du Mesnil 1982 Champagne individual original cartons in individual original wood cases into foil "A ripe, opulent vintage that makes for a rich, almost thick Champagne that's packed with...flavors that linger on the finish. For all the power and breadth, it's still lively and can age even longer...97." WS 2/ bottles per lot US$ Krug 1985 Champagne original carton into foil, late release from Krug to Farr Vintners in 1999 "...wonderful, elusive nose of smoke, cream, honey, nuts, peaches, and vanilla...very long aftertaste of vanilla...92." RJ 5/ bottles per lot US$ Krug Clos du Mesnil 1986 Champagne into foil "The peach, vanilla, honey and tangerine flavors ride a crest of bracing acidity, dry and forceful, to a lingering aftertaste of spring blossoms and hazelnut...98." WS 11/ bottle per lot US$ Krug 1995 Champagne original carton "Warm and toasty aromas of lemon meringue pie. with rich, semi-tart flavors. Crowd pleaser. Excellent plus." FH 5/ bottles per lot US$ Dom Pérignon Rosé 2000 Champagne individual original coffrets in two 3-pack original cartons "The wine continues to blossom on the palate, with utterly beguiling detail, clarity and polish, all qualities that resonate on the rich, expansive finish...96." WA 3/ bottles per lot US$ Jacques Selosse Blanc de Blancs Brut Initial NV Champagne disgorged on February 21, stands out for its focus, vibrancy and tension. The Initial is the freshest of the Selosse wines and is therefore a great introduction to the house style WA 11/ bottles per lot US$ Jacques Selosse Version Originale NV Champagne original carton disgorged on March 21, 2007 "The wine literally covers every inch of the palate with layers of mineral-drenched fruit. This is a fabulous showing for the Version Originale...96." WA 11/ bottles per lot US$ Krug Clos du Mesnil 1989 Champagne individual original cartons in individual original wood cases into foil "Is there a better wine in this world than Clos du Mesnil? I doubt it. The '89 is one of the richest and most delicious vintages ever...97." RJ 3/ bottles per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com

41 Lots 268, 270 & 271 ZACHYS tel fax zachys.com 49

42 ALSACE ITALY TRIMBACH Riesling Clos Ste Hune Trimbach 1981 Alsace 2cm or better, four lightly bin-soiled labels, one lightly scuffed label, two with signs of old seepage "...dry and fresh...the style for dry Riesling. The wine is fresh, and still has some tension and vitality...with energy and drive..." WA 10/ bottles per lot US$ Riesling Clos Ste Hune Trimbach 1986 Alsace 1.5cm or better bottles per lot US$ Riesling Clos Ste Hune Trimbach 1990 Alsace 1.5cm or better, three lightly nicked labels "Expressive aromas and flavors...give this well-integrated wine good depth and length. A fine example of traditional Alsace Riesling that shows finesse and sophistication...92." WS 9/ bottles per lot US$ Riesling Clos Ste Hune Trimbach 2008 Alsace two 3-pack s "A classic Alsace Riesling in a steely style, yet shows lovely integration and accessibility, with the dense midpalate and creamy texture...long, focused finish...95." WS 2/ bottles per lot US$ Sammarco Castello dei Rampolla 1985 Tuscany seven lightly bin-soiled labels, one torn label, two different importers bottles per lot US$ Barbaresco Santo Stefano di Neive Bruno Giacosa 1995 Piedmont two 6-pack s "...reveals an intensely fragrant nose...full-bodied, with moderate tannin in the finish, this is an expressive, rich, expansively flavored Barbaresco...91." WA 8/ bottles per lot US$ Barbaresco Sori Tildin Gaja 1995 Piedmont "Loads of fruit on the nose, with plenty of toasted oak. Full-bodied, with chewy tannins and a long finish..." WS 11/ bottles per lot US$ Le Pergole Torte Montevertine 1997 Tuscany one lightly marked label "Class in a glass...full-bodied, very tight tannin structure, with a chewy finish..93." WS 7/ magnums (1.5L) per lot US$ Riesling Clos Ste Hune Trimbach 2009 Alsace "...tight-grained, seamless fabric...a veritable rolling block of mineral and fruit distillate, boasting energy and grip, if also a bit of heat...91." WA 5/ bottles per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com

43 SPAIN VEGA SICILIA Vega Sicilia Único 1962 Ribera del Duero bottom neck "Youthful, vivacious and utterly compelling, this is a profound wine that even after four decades is surfeit with precocity. Undoubtedly, this must be one of the greatest Spanish wines to have graced this planet " WA 8/ magnum (1.5L) per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com 51

44 Vega Sicilia Único 1965 Ribera del Duero two 3-pack s four bottom neck or better, one top shoulder, one just below top shoulder, two bin-soiled labels, one winestained label "The palate was beautifully balanced...there is a sense of completeness to the 1965 that is irresistible...94." WA 8/ bottles per lot US$ Vega Sicilia Único 1970 Ribera del Duero three bottom neck or better, seven very top shoulder, one top shoulder, one just below top shoulder, three lightly scuffed labels "It has a thrilling Bordeaux-like personality on the nose... The Cabernet component in the blend is pronounced, forming the backbone and austerity of this wine...97." WA 8/ bottles per lot US$ ,000 Vega Sicilia Único 1985 Ribera del Duero individual s into neck "...considerable complexity...rich flavors...full-bodied... layered, nuanced character...a lush, round, generouslyendowed finish...substantial as well as elegant, savory style...93." WA 4/ magnums (1.5L) per lot US$ L'Ermita Velles Vinyes Alvaro Palacios 1996 Priorat Lot 291: "Full-bodied, dense, and thick, with an unctuous texture...it is super-intense, but exceptionally well-balanced " WA 4/ bottles per lot US$ one 5 Liter per lot US$ L'Ermita Velles Vinyes Alvaro Palacios 1997 Priorat nicked and lightly scuffed label "...so concentrated and well structured, but this rich red effortlessly marries power and grace. A benchmark for the appellation...96." WA 11/ one 5 Liter per lot US$ Clos Erasmus 1998 Priorat "...flirts with perfection...powerful, with an unctuous texture, and super-extracted, rich, concentrated flavors, this blockbuster effort boasts extravagant quantities of fruit, glycerin, extract, tannin, and personality...it is a winemaking tour de force...99." WA 8/ bottles per lot US$ Vega Sicilia Único 1989 Ribera del Duero bottom neck or better "It possesses tremendous density, an opulent, textured, full-bodied palate, great purity, and moderate tannin...94." WA 2/ bottles per lot US$ Vega Sicilia Único 1991 Ribera del Duero two 3-pack s "...remarkably youthful effort...full-bodied and intense, with sweet tannin, outstanding density as well as purity, and a layered mouthful " WA 4/ bottles per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com

45 CALIFORNIA BOND Bond Assortment 2003 original wood assortment case one magnum (1.5L) each Melbury, Pluribus, St Eden, and Vecina Provenance: Zachys, February magnum case per lot US$ Bond Assortment 2005 original wood assortment case one magnum (1.5L) each of Melbury, Pluribus, St Eden, and Vecina Provenance: Zachys, February magnum case per lot US$ Bond Melbury Red 2007 "A full-bodied texture, wonderful opulence, sweet velvety tannins and an extraordinary integration of all its component parts make for a prodigious Cabernet Sauvignon...97." WA 12/ bottles per lot US$ Bond Pluribus Red 2007 "...exhibits tell-tale Spring Mountain characteristics...a wine of great intensity and full-bodied power yet with a freshness and delineation that are remarkable " WA 12/ bottles per lot US$ Bond Quella Red 2007 "A magical combination...full-bodied, majestically rich wine with a multilayered texture, silky tannins and a phenomenally long finish of over 50 seconds...97." WS 12/ bottles per lot US$ Bond Assortment 5-Pack 2008 original wood assortment case one bottle each of Melbury, Pluribus, Quella, St Eden, & Vecina Parcel: lots 300 & case per lot US$ case per lot US$ Bond Assortment 2008 original wood assortment case one magnum (1.5L) each of Melbury, Pluribus, Quella, St Eden, & Vecina magnum case per lot US$ Bond Assortment 2009 original wood assortment case one magnum each of Melbury, Pluribus, Quella, St Eden, & Vecina magnum case per lot US$ Bond Quella Red 2009 individual s bottles per lot US$ Bond St Eden Red 2009 individual s "...simply stunning...a wine of textural brilliance and spherical palate presence...97." WA 12/ bottles per lot US$ Bond Assortment 5-Pack 2010 original wood assortment case one bottle each of Melbury, Pluribus, Quella, St Eden, & Vecina case per lot US$ Bond Assortment 2011 original wood assortment case one magnum each of Melbury, Pluribus, Quella, St Eden, & Vecina magnum case per lot US$ Bond Red 2006 St Eden (6) Vecina (6) 308 above 12 bottles per lot US$ Bond Red 2006 Melbury (6) Pluribus (6) 309 above 12 bottles per lot US$ Bond Red 2008 Melbury (6) St Eden (6) 310 above 12 bottles per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com 53

46 BRYANT FAMILY COLGIN Bryant Family Vineyard Cabernet Sauvignon 1994 two lightly damp-stained labels "Well done, rich and balanced, with tight, dense, chewy tannins...complexity and depth, with subtle flavor nuances and a persistent aftertaste...93." WS 11/ bottles per lot US$ Colgin Herb Lamb Vineyard Cabernet Sauvignon 1996 "...a provocative nose...extremely full-bodied and rich... large-scaled yet extraordinarily rich...its sweet tannin and remarkable 40+-second finish are amazing...97." WA 12/ bottles per lot US$ Bryant Family Vineyard Cabernet Sauvignon 2010 "Again, the striking purity and singular character of this Bryant Cabernet Sauvignon oozes potential as well as pedigree...99." WA 10/ bottles per lot US$ Colgin IX Estate Red 2008 "Full-bodied, with very fine tannins and lovely fruit. Soft and silky fruits. Amazing backbone of tannins...99." JS 6/ bottles per lot US$ Bryant Family Vineyard Cabernet Sauvignon 2002 (1) 2003 (1) sticker adhered to label 2004 (1) sticker adhered to label 2005 (1) 2006 (3) 2008 (3) 313 above 10 bottles per lot US$ Colgin IX Estate Red 2009 "Rich, deep and full-bodied, this voluptuous, sensational blend boasts an inky/purple color...97." WA 10/ bottles per lot US$ Colgin Herb Lamb Vineyard Cabernet Sauvignon 2001 (3) 2002 (3) 2003 (3) 317 above 9 bottles per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com

47 GRACE Cabernet Sauvignon Caymus Vineyards Grace Family Vineyard 1981 double magnum (1) bottom neck Caymus Vineyards Grace Family Vineyard 1982 double magnum (1) into neck, chipped wax capsule Grace Family 1983 double magnum (1) bottom neck, bottle #19/80 Grace Family 1984 magnum (1) very top shoulder, 150th Celebration, original wood case Grace Family 1985 magnum (1) bottom neck, chipped wax capsule, 318 above 2 magnums (1.5L) & 3 double magnums (3L) per lot US$ Grace Family Cabernet Sauvignon 1986 magnum (1) into neck, chipped wax capsule, 1987 magnum (1) into neck, lightly chipped wax capsule 1988 magnum (1) into neck, 1989 magnum (1) bottom neck, 1990 magnum (1) into neck, 1991 magnum (1) 1992 magnum (1) chipped wax capsule, signs of old seepage, original wood case 1993 magnum (1) 1994 magnum (1) 1995 magnum (1) 319 above 10 magnums (1.5L) per lot US$ Grace Family Cabernet Sauvignon 1996 liter (1) 1997 liter (1) 1998 liter (1) 1999 liter (1) 2000 liter (1) 2001 liter (1) 2002 liter (1) 2003 liter (1) 2004 liter (1) 2005 liter (1) 320 above ten 1L per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com 55

48 HARLAN Harlan Estate, owned by Bill Harlan, is a luxury, worldclass, Cabernet Sauvignon-based wine produced from a steep, terraced vineyard on the western side of Napa Valley, high above Napa's famous Martha's Vineyard. Approximately twenty-four acres are in vine and the yields to date have been very low. Bill Harlan, better-known as one of the principals of Merryvale Vineyards...has only one objective: to produce one of the greatest red wines of California. The wines are a blend of approximately two-thirds Cabernet Sauvignon and the remainder Cabernet Franc and Merlot. Bob Levy, Merryvale's winemaker and Michel Rolland, the well-known Bordeaux oenologist, are the architects behind these exceptional efforts. Stylistically the wines are the equivalent of a hypothetical La Mission Haut-Brion/Cheval Blanc blend. They are rich, powerful wines with unmistakable elegance, complexity, and purity. Robert Parker, "The Wine Advocate" Harlan Estate 1996 "...extraordinary intensity...a texture oozing with glycerin and concentrated fruit...one of the most concentrated and complete red wines one could hope to taste...98." WA 1/ bottles per lot US$ Harlan Estate 1999 "Enormously complex, rich and concentrated, with layers of currant, black cherry, blackberry and chocolate-mocha flavors that are intense and focused...97." WS 11/ bottles per lot US$ Harlan Estate 2000 "A tremendous wine. Dense, tight and chewy, with firm... Well-focused, precisely balanced and full of concentrated flavors...94." WS 11/ bottles per lot US$ Harlan Estate 2003 "...it comes across like a hypothetical blend of a top-notch Pauillac and Graves. Superb texture, low acidity, and gorgeous purity as well as richness...95." WA 12/ magnums (1.5L) per lot US$ Harlan Estate 2005 "...exhibits a gorgeous thick-looking, ruby/purple color in addition to a beautiful nose...full-bodied, dense, pure, and revealing sweeter tannin...97." WA 12/ magnums (1.5L) per lot US$ Harlan Estate 2006 "Its dense ruby/purple color is followed by classic aromas of creme de cassis, melted licorice, smoked meats, burning embers, and graphite...96." WA 12/ bottles per lot US$ Harlan Estate 2008 "Deliciously ripe, complex and aromatic, yet tight and closed...the impressive finish shows detailed flavors and nuances...96." WS 8/ bottles per lot US$ Harlan Estate 2010 "Rich, full-bodied and softer than I would have expected in this vintage, it is a prodigious, multidimensional, compelling wine " WA 10/ bottles per lot US$ magnum (1.5L) per lot US$ Harlan Estate 2011 "Deep, round and generous with silky tannins and a forward, evolved style...93." WA 10/ bottles per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com

49 SHAFER Vineyards Shafer Vineyards Hillside Select Cabernet Sauvignon 1995 Stag's Leap District two lightly scuffed labels "It is remarkable how the finest California Cabernets combine extraordinary power and richness with balance and elegance. A stupendous wine, it is worth a special effort to obtain...99." WA 1/ bottles per lot US$ Shafer Vineyards Hillside Select Cabernet Sauvignon 1999 Stag's Leap District "A monumental wine, bold, rich, smooth and concentrated...ultraripe fruit with a measure of elegance and finesse, its tannins are supple and seamless...97." WS 11/ bottles per lot US$ Shafer Vineyards Hillside Select Cabernet Sauvignon 2001 Stag's Leap District with damaged lid "...exquisite bouquet of charcoal, sweet oak, black currant liqueur, and graphite. Full-bodied and powerful, with superb intensity, length, persistence, purity, and texture...99." WA 12/ bottles per lot US$ Shafer Vineyards Hillside Select Cabernet Sauvignon 2003 Stag's Leap District Provenance: Zachys, December 2013 "...aromas of camphor, black currants, licorice, crushed rocks, and white flowers...impeccable balance, purity, and length...95." WA 12/ bottles per lot US$ Shafer Vineyards Hillside Select Cabernet Sauvignon 2010 Stag's Leap District "It's classic California Cabernet, but beautifully put together, showing impeccable craftsmanship and fabulous potential " WA 12/ bottles per lot US$ Shafer Vineyards Hillside Select Cabernet Sauvignon 1993 (6) two slightly depressed corks, 1994 (2) 337 above 8 bottles per lot US$ Dominus Estate 2008 two 6-pack s "Bigger body and more structure, fat, density and texture...99." WA 12/ bottles per lot US$ Dalla Valle Vineyards Maya 2009 two 3-pack s "Full-bodied with remarkable density as well as a multidimensional personality, and abundant, well-integrated tannins " WA 10/ bottles per lot US$ Levy & McClellan Cabernet Sauvignon individual s 2008 (3) 2009 (6) 340 above 9 bottles per lot US$ Shafer Vineyards Hillside Select Cabernet Sauvignon 2004 Stag's Leap District "Pure, rich, intense and vibrant, with tight, sharply focused...ends with a pleasant burst of ripe fruit flavors that are long and persistent...94." WS 10/ bottles per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com 57

50 AUSTRALIA PENFOLDS Henschke Hill of Grace Shiraz 1991 Eden Valley magnum (1.5L) per lot US$ Penfolds Grange Hermitage 1971 South Australia just below top shoulder, importer tag adhered to nicked and wine-stained label, signs of old seepage "It could easily be mistaken for an old, magnificent Pomerol given its voluptuous texture, glorious richness, unctuosity, and phenomenal concentration, fat, and length. This is the real thing!...96." WA 8/ bottle per lot US$ Penfolds Grange Hermitage 1978 South Australia four bottom neck or better, two very top shoulder bottles per lot US$ Penfolds Grange Hermitage 1983 South Australia four bottom neck or better, two top shoulder, one binsoiled label, one nicked label, one torn label "...enormously powerful, rich, high acid characteristics. It is somewhat of a paradox to taste...seems very youthful, very backward...92." WA 1/ bottles per lot US$ Penfolds Grange 1991 South Australia "...distinctive for the harmony that's beneath the hedonistic fanfare of flavors. A stunning wine...95." WS 1/ bottles per lot US$ Penfolds Grange 1994 South Australia "A magnificent edifice of a wine, elegant and refined in structure but dripping with flavor...this just doesn't quit...96." WS 11/ bottles per lot US$ Henschke Hill of Grace Shiraz 1995 Eden Valley bottles per lot US$ Henschke Hill of Grace Shiraz 1996 Eden Valley bottles per lot US$ Clarendon Hills Astralis 1997 McLaren Vale two 6-pack original cartons "...most elegant...a more feminine, stylish effort offering a rich, layered texture as well as sweet tannins...93." WA 6/ bottles per lot US$ Henschke Hill of Grace Shiraz 1997 Eden Valley "Medium to full-bodied, it has good acid balance and concentration and a medium level of chewy tannins through the long finish...92." WA 4/ bottles per lot US$ Clarendon Hills Astralis 1999 South Australia Lot 352: two 6-pack s "Amazingly rich and seductive, a towering wine...the tannins are present, but totally submerged in the flavors...95." WS 6/ bottles per lot US$ bottles per lot US$ Penfolds Grange 1997 South Australia two 6-pack s "...a gorgeously sweet nose...opulently-textured, extremely soft, layered, and seductive, with Grange's tell-tale personality well-displayed, but in a seamless, seductive style...94." WA 10/ bottles per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com

51 A JAW DROPPING COLLECTION of FINE WINES (LOTS ) From one of the country's great collectors comes this stunning selection of rare Bordeaux and Burgundy. The Bordeaux alone would make for a sale highlight. The First Growths from the best vintages: 1990 Latour, 1989 and 1990 Haut- Brion, 2000 Mouton (the list goes on) make up a significant part of the cellar. But when you couple it with the Burgundy, a truly impressive cellar takes shape. The mature Rousseau alone is one of the most impressive selections we've seen at auction in recent memory. The Musigny from de Vogue is equally impressive. Rouget, Roumier, Dugat-Py: you name it the Grands Crus start coming and never stop. The white wines are just as impressive, with Lafon, Leflaive, Sauzet, Ramonet, and Raveneau all sharing an alreadycrowded stage. The majority of this offering was purchased on release from reputed NY area retailers and stored in multiple professional storage facilities. ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com 59

52 BORDEAUX CHÂTEAU HAUT-BRION CHÂTEAU CHEVAL BLANC Château Cheval Blanc 1982 St Émilion, Premier Grand Cru Classé (a) two bottom neck or better, two very top shoulder, one lightly damp-stained label, one lightly scuffed label Red fruits dominant on nose and very luscious on the palate. The wine is soft and plush, but lots of velvety red fruit throughout. This had none of the grassy notes I sometimes get out of this wine... SF bottles per lot US$ Château Cheval Blanc 1990 St Émilion, Premier Grand Cru Classé (a) one bottom neck, one very top shoulder, lightly nicked labels "...a complex bouquet of tobacco leaf, Christmas fruitcake, sweet black fruits, bordering on fig and plum, but no hint of overripeness, and notions of new saddle leather, mint, and incense " WA 6/ bottles per lot US$ Château Cheval Blanc 2000 St Émilion, Premier Grand Cru Classé (a) "A broad wine with compelling purity, a layered texture, and sweet tannin, with hints of coffee and earth in the background...99." WA 7/ bottles per lot US$ SPECIALIST'S PICK: LOT 359 This is such a joy to drink now with a soaring aromatic nose full of deep, smoky, cedar essence. Beautiful balance, finely textured, and evolved tannin plus a dense concentration of fruit on palate show its promising potential to be enjoyed now or hold for years to come. Unmistakably Haut-Brion. Josephine Young Château Haut-Brion 1982 Graves, Premier Cru Classé 2.5cm, damp-stained labels, one heavily scuffed label, one marked label, one with signs of old seepage Very aromatic on the nose with lots of minerality and damp gravel notes. Interesting and expressive..." SF bottles per lot US$ Château Haut-Brion 1989 Pessac Léognan, Premier Cru Classé 1.5cm or better, importer tags adhered to heavily scuffed and wine-stained labels "This is unbelievable. Greatest Haut-Brion ever made...fullbodied, with an amazing concentration of fruit and velvety tannins. The finish goes on for minutes " WS 5/ bottles per lot US$ Château Haut-Brion 1990 Pessac Léognan, Premier Cru Classé 1.5cm or better, two lightly damp-stained labels "In terms of the brilliant complexity and nobility of the aromatics...the 1990 offers an aromatic explosion that is unparalleled...98." WA 6/ bottles per lot US$ Château Haut-Brion 1995 Pessac Léognan, Premier Cru Classé Lot 361: lightly scuffed labels "Multi-dimensional and rich, with layers of ripe fruit, and beautifully integrated tannin and acidity...96." WA 2/ bottles per lot US$ bottles per lot US$ Château Haut-Brion 1998 Pessac Léognan, Premier Cru Classé "The nose is just fantastic, just soars from the glass with brilliant delineation and freshness...the palate is awesome...98." WA 5/ bottles per lot US$ Château Haut-Brion 2000 Pessac Léognan, Premier Cru Classé lightly scuffed labels "...a deep, layered, sumptuously textured, full-bodied Haut-Brion, but one with extraordinary complexity...99." WA 6/ bottles per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com

53 Lots 354, 371 & 377 ZACHYS tel fax zachys.com 61

54 CHÂTEAU LAFITE ROTHSCHILD CHÂTEAU LATOUR Château Lafite Rothschild 1986 bottom neck or better "...beautifully defined, still full of energy...it must rank as one of the finest wines from the estate...98." WA 12/ bottles per lot US$ Château Lafite Rothschild 1990 two bottom neck or better, one very top shoulder, two different importers "...it boasts gorgeous aromas of cedar, tobacco leaf, cassis, and lead pencil shavings. The explosive aromas are followed by a fleshy, full-bodied wine...96." WA 6/ bottles per lot US$ Château Lafite Rothschild 1995 one lightly bin-soiled label, four different importers Full-bodied, with a solid core of tannins and a long, silky finish. Still holding back, but is concentrated and powerful WS bottles per lot US$ Château Lafite Rothschild 1996 "...extremely powerful and full-bodied, with remarkable complexity...oozing with extract and richness, yet has managed to preserve its quintessentially elegant personality " WA 4/ bottles per lot US$ Château Lafite Rothschild 1998 "...close to perfection...the wine is elegant yet profoundly rich, revealing the essence of Lafite's character...the wine is spectacularly layered yet never heavy...98." WA 4/ bottles per lot US$ Château Lafite Rothschild 1999 "Long, caressing finish. Super fine, well-structured...95." WS 3/ bottles per lot US$ Château Lafite Rothschild 2001 one lightly glue-stained label, one loose capsule reveals fully branded cork "Deep and generous...full-bodied, with big velvety tannins and a super long finish...96." WS 3/ bottles per lot US$ Château Latour 1982 two very top shoulder, one top shoulder, one dampstained label, one lightly scuffed label "This is the freshest, most resounding and interesting example of this wine I have ever tried. Very approachable and enjoyable, with the Latour strength, but still soft with an excellent finish..." SF bottles per lot US$ Château Latour 1990 five bottom neck or better, two very top shoulder, one top shoulder, one damp-stained label, three lightly dampstained labels, one scuffed label, one wine-stained label "The nose was tremendous with all the typical Latour characteristics...it was concentrated and dense on the palate... Very open and generous and wonderful to drink at present..." SF bottles per lot US$ Château Latour 1995 Lot 373: one lightly bin-soiled label Lot 374: "The palate is wonderfully fleshy and opulent with velvety, approachable tannins and a long finish WA 11/ bottles per lot US$ bottles per lot US$ Château Latour 1996 three lightly scuffed labels "...generosity on the palate and similar notes on the nose...a truly breathtaking effort...way too young to drink now, although I am still glad I did..." SF bottles per lot US$ ,000 Château Latour 2003 two lightly scuffed labels "...very ripe, but not over-ripe, offers great freshness... Dense, thick and unctuously textured, this staggering Latour is undeniably the most sumptuous, opulent wine " WA 8/ bottles per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com

55 CHÂTEAU MARGAUX CHÂTEAU MOUTON ROTHSCHILD Château Margaux 1982 Margaux, Premier Cru Classé three bottom neck or better, one very top shoulder, two lightly scuffed labels This wine was breathtaking!...beautiful as soon as it was opened and did not really evolve over the course of the evening, but stayed at a really great spot... SF bottles per lot US$ Château Mouton Rothschild 1982 bottom neck, damp-stained and scuffed label Half the people in the room picked this as the favorite in this lineup...did keep getting better in the glass and showed a tremendous depth of fruit and formidable structure... SF bottle per lot US$ Château Margaux 1983 Margaux, Premier Cru Classé three very top shoulder, one top shoulder, one just below top shoulder, one upper-mid shoulder "The wine is medium to full-bodied, deep, rich, and powerful, with sweet tannins and loads of fruit concentration...96." WA 1/ bottles per lot US$ Château Mouton Rothschild 1986 just below top shoulder, lightly scuffed label "It boasts a full body of ultra richness, extraordinary length and beauty and an almost chiseled precision to the quality with fabulous length. It lasts for minutes on the palate " JS 3/ bottle per lot US$ Château Margaux 1986 Margaux, Premier Cru Classé three very top shoulder, one top shoulder, one just below top shoulder, one upper shoulder, one lightly wine-stained label "...emotionally moving. Still incredibly youthful, it showed incredible focus and depth, all backed up by considerable structure...striking in every way " AG 2/ bottles per lot US$ Château Margaux 1990 Margaux, Premier Cru Classé three bottom neck or better, one very top shoulder, one damp-stained label, one scuffed label, three different importers "Round and generous with low acidity, but an opulent, full-bodied richness that is fresh with laser-like precision " WA 6/ bottles per lot US$ Château Margaux 1996 Margaux, Premier Cru Classé "...a strong contender for wine of the vintage. It offers everything you desire from this First Growth...This is a Margaux that seems to light up the senses " WA 10/ bottles per lot US$ Château Mouton Rothschild 1995 "Very beautiful wine. Mouton shows finesse yet richness in this vintage...94." WS bottles per lot US$ Château Mouton Rothschild 1996 "Incredible nose of ultraripe fruit, it's yet subtle and complex. Full-bodied, with very ripe, almost sweet fruit and a long, long caressing finish. Superb...96." WS bottles per lot US$ Château Mouton Rothschild 1998 "...an extremely powerful, super-concentrated wine...massive, with awesome concentration...96." WA 4/ bottles per lot US$ Château Mouton Rothschild 2000 "A rich, tannic, earthy style, with loads of creme de cassis and floral notes...a full-bodied wine with plenty of coffee, earth, chocolatey notes " WA 6/ bottles per lot US$ ,000 Château Margaux 2000 Margaux, Premier Cru Classé banded "Medium-bodied, with layers of concentration, stunning blue, red, and black fruits intermixed with spring flowers " WA 6/ bottles per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com 63

56 CHÂTEAU ANGÉLUS CHÂTEAU DUCRU-BEAUCAILLOU Château Angélus 1995 St Émilion, Premier Grand Cru Classé (a) "Slightly reserved in the nose. Full-bodied, with loads of layered, velvety tannins. Big, yet refined and beautiful. Long and caressing...95." WS bottles per lot US$ Château Angélus 2000 St Émilion, Premier Grand Cru Classé (a) one lightly nicked label "Slightly reserved in the nose. Full-bodied, with loads of layered, velvety tannins. Big, yet refined and beautiful. Long and caressing...95." WS bottles per lot US$ Château Angélus 2005 St Émilion, Premier Grand Cru Classé (a) "The tannins are beautifully integrated but still present, and the wood, acidity, alcohol, etc., are all beautifully assimilated in this magnificent, majestic vintage of Angélus " WA 8/ bottles per lot US$ CHÂTEAU COS D'ESTOURNEL Château Cos d'estournel 1996 St Estèphe, Deuxième Cru Classé "Dark-colored...full-bodied...Long, long finish. One of the wines of the vintage...95." WS 1/ bottles per lot US$ Château Cos d Estournel 2003 St Estèphe, Deuxième Cru Classé "With extraordinary richness, full-bodied, and remarkable freshness, elegance, and persistence, this is one of the finest wines ever made by this estate...98." WA 4/ bottles per lot US$ Château Ducru-Beaucaillou 1995 St Julien, Deuxième Cru Classé "The greatest Ducru produced this century. Breathtaking aromas...full-bodied and tannic, yet very fine and long in the mouth. This has fabulous structure for aging...97." WS 6/ bottles per lot US$ Château Ducru-Beaucaillou 1996 St Julien, Deuxième Cru Classé "The palate is medium-bodied with fine tannin, crisp acidity, moving firmly into secondary stage...93." WA 10/ bottles per lot US$ Château Ducru-Beaucaillou 2000 St Julien, Deuxième Cru Classé "...clearly outstanding now and seems to get better and better with age...its full body yet very finely textured with pretty fruit concentration and length...96." JS 6/ bottles per lot US$ Château Ducru-Beaucaillou 2003 St Julien, Deuxième Cru Classé "...a full-bodied, opulent wine with loads of fruit and glycerin as well as a plush texture...94." WA 8/ bottles per lot US$ Château Ducru-Beaucaillou 2005 St Julien, Deuxième Cru Classé "A nice, complex wine...full-bodied, with pure fruit...this is balanced and silky, a beautiful harmony. Give this some time if you can...95." JS 5/ bottles per lot US$ Château Cos d Estournel 2005 St Estèphe, Deuxième Cru Classé "Full and very layered with chewy polished tannins and a long, long finish. Just starting to open...99." JS 10/ bottles per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com

57 CHÂTEAU L'EGLISE CLINET CHÂTEAU L'EVANGILE Château L'Eglise Clinet 1995 Pomerol two different importers "...this dense, exceptionally well-delineated, layered, multidimensional L'Eglise Clinet only hints at its ultimate potential...96." WA 2/ bottles per lot US$ Château L'Eglise Clinet 1996 Pomerol four lightly bin-soiled labels, two lightly scuffed labels "...an uncommonly rich, concentrated wine...fat, concentrated, and medium to full-bodied, with a layered, multidimensional, highly nuanced personality...93." WA 4/ bottles per lot US$ Château L'Eglise Clinet 1998 Pomerol Lot 403: "Full-bodied, with loads of fruit, fine tannins and an extremely long finish...96." WS 1/ bottles per lot US$ bottles per lot US$ Château L'Eglise Clinet 2000 Pomerol "Full-bodied with abundant tannin as well as a multidimensional, thick texture...gorgeous purity and a natural mouthfeel make for a dazzling wine " WA 6/ bottles per lot US$ Château L'Evangile 1990 Pomerol three bottom neck or better, three very top shoulder, two lightly scuffed labels "It is a complex effort with lots of cedar, sweet caramelized black raspberries and cherries as well as hints of licorice and underbrush..." WA 6/ bottles per lot US$ Château L'Evangile 1998 Pomerol "Captivating aromas...huge, silky tannins and an extralong, caressing finish...incredible class, with everything in wonderful proportions. The greatest L'Evangile ever made...98." WS 1/ bottles per lot US$ Château L'Evangile 2000 Pomerol "Dense, rich, and full-bodied, with an opulence and succulence that are prodigious, the tannins are present but extremely sweet...98." WA 6/ bottles per lot US$ Château L'Evangile 2005 Pomerol "Full-bodied, with layer upon layer of velvety tannins and chocolate, berry, vanilla and tea flavors. Lasts for minutes. I am blown away by this wine " WS 3/ bottles per lot US$ Château La Conseillante 1989 Pomerol bottom neck or better, one lightly bin-soiled label, three lightly damp-stained labels, one lightly scuffed label "...great purity, sweet tannin, but noticeable structure and muscle, this is a relatively large-scaled La Conseillante that has always been one of the top wines of the vintage...96." WA 1/ bottles per lot US$ Château La Conseillante 2000 Pomerol "Full-bodied yet ethereal in the sense that it seems to combine power along with eloquence and delicacy, this is a beautifully pure wine that has just hit its plateau of full maturity...96." WA 6/ bottles per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com 65

58 CHÂTEAU LÉOVILLE LAS CASES Château Léoville Las Cases 1982 St Julien, Deuxième Cru Classé two bottom neck or better, three very top shoulder, two damp-stained labels, one lightly damp-stained label, one lightly scuffed label "Classic lead pencil, cassis, kirsch, cedar, and spice characteristics are abundant in both the nose and full-bodied flavors " WA 6/ bottles per lot US$ Château Léoville Las Cases 1986 St Julien, Deuxième Cru Classé Lot 412: two very top shoulder, three just below top shoulder, one with signs of old seepage Lot 413: four bottom neck or better, seven very top shoulder, one top shoulder "The wine has always been phenomenally concentrated, yet wonderfully fresh and vigorous...it is a great example of Léoville Las Cases " WA 1/ bottles per lot US$ bottles per lot US$ Château Léoville Las Cases 1998 St Julien, Deuxième Cru Classé eight bin-soiled labels "A broad yet focused entry on the palate reveals firm tannin, medium to full body, superb concentration and purity, as well as a totally symmetrical mouthfeel...93." WA 4/ bottles per lot US$ Château Léoville Las Cases 2000 St Julien, Deuxième Cru Classé "...with good acidity, the tell-tale purity, layered ripeness and intensity, and a profound finish " WA 6/ bottles per lot US$ Château Léoville Las Cases 2009 St Julien, Deuxième Cru Classé "It boasts an inky/purple color, monumental concentration and lots of sweet, jammy...fruit intermixed with crushed rock and mineral notes " WA 2/ magnums (1.5L) per lot US$ Château Léoville Las Cases 1990 St Julien, Deuxième Cru Classé eleven bottom neck or better, one very top shoulder, six wrinkled labels, two different importers "In the mouth, it is full-bodied, and while technically low in acidity, there is a freshness, delineation, and classicism...96." WA 6/ bottles per lot US$ SPECIALIST'S PICK: LOT 414: Drank a bottle of this wine recently at Amali in NYC. This vintage always shows well, but this particular bottle of LLC was excellent. It's just a classic, excellent Bordeaux, rich but fresh. Charles Antin Château Léoville Las Cases 1996 St Julien, Deuxième Cru Classé "It stands as one of the best wines of the vintage... You might call it 'proper Claret.' You might call it 'delicious"...98." WA 10/ bottles per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com

59 CHÂTEAU MONTROSE CHÂTEAU PALMER Château Montrose 1990 St Estèphe, Deuxième Cru Classé bottom neck or better, one lightly scuffed label "...absolutely magnificent, broad, savory and mouth-filling. This is one of the all-time modern legends from Bordeaux as well as Château Montrose " WA 8/ bottles per lot US$ Château Montrose 1996 St Estèphe, Deuxième Cru Classé "Licorice, underbrush and floral notes were all present in this wine, which has good acidity...95." WA 8/ bottles per lot US$ Château Montrose 2000 St Estèphe, Deuxième Cru Classé six lightly scuffed labels "Just starting to open...it's full-bodied with ultra-fine, integrated tannins and an extremely complex, refined finish...96." JS 4/ bottles per lot US$ Château Montrose 2003 St Estèphe, Deuxième Cru Classé includes 12-pack "Dense, full-bodied and rich with an unctuous texture, well-integrated, melted tannins, and a long, heady finish, this big, brawny, super-intense, gorgeous " WA 8/ bottles per lot US$ Château Montrose 2005 St Estèphe, Deuxième Cru Classé "Full body with soft, silky tannins and lots of rich fruit. Still chewy. This is just starting to open up now...96." JS 10/ bottles per lot US$ Château Palmer 1989 Margaux, Troisième Cru Classé bottom neck or better unless noted Lot 426: three lightly scuffed labels Lot 427: one very top shoulder, two top shoulder, three lightly torn labels, three Mahler-Besse "...sweet, jammy nose...full-bodied and supple, with low acidity, copious quantities of ripe fruit and glycerin...95." WA 2/ bottles per lot US$ bottles per lot US$ Château Palmer 1999 Margaux, Troisième Cru Classé with damaged lid "...both power and elegance, it offers sweet tannin along with flavors that caress the palate...this is terrific stuff!...95." WA 4/ bottles per lot US$ Château Palmer 2000 Margaux, Troisième Cru Classé "I love the blackberry, plum, chocolate and cedar character. It's very long and beautiful. The velvety, textured tannins are impressive...97." JS 4/ bottles per lot US$ Château Palmer 2005 Margaux, Troisième Cru Classé "...long, multi-dimensional and textured. This wonderfully pure, stunning wine once again performs as a First Growth...98." WA 6/ bottles per lot US$ Château Montrose 2006 St Estèphe, Deuxième Cru Classé "Full-bodied with a savory, expansive mid-palate as well as sweet, noble tannins " WA 2/ bottles per lot US$ Château Montrose 1995 (4) 2005 (6) includes 12-pack 425 above 10 bottles per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com 67

60 CHÂTEAU PICHON LALANDE Château Pichon Longueville Comtesse de Lalande 1982 Pauillac, Deuxième Cru Classé one bottom neck, two very top shoulder, one just below top shoulder, one damp-stained label, two lightly scuffed labels Everyone loved this bottle...it had a beautiful dark fruit nose and very giving fruit on the palate... SF bottles per lot US$ Château Pichon Longueville Comtesse de Lalande 1995 Pauillac, Deuxième Cru Classé one lightly bin-soiled label "Exquisite on the palate, this full-bodied, layered, multidimensional wine should prove to be one of the vintage's most extraordinary success stories WA 2/ bottles per lot US$ Château Pichon Longueville Comtesse de Lalande 1996 Pauillac, Deuxième Cru Classé one nicked label "I am not sure I possess the vocabulary to describe just how captivating the 1996 is, but I do know this: If I had an opportunity to pick up a few well-stored bottles I would take it in a nanosecond " AG 2/ bottles per lot US$ Château Trotanoy 1998 Pomerol "This structured, formidably-endowed, deep ruby/purplecolored, full-bodied, super-rich wine exhibits notes of toffee, truffles, and abundant blackberry, cherry, and currant fruit...95." WA 4/ bottles per lot US$ Château d'yquem 2001 Sauternes, Premier Cru Supérieur "This large-scaled, youthful Yquem appears set to take its place among the most legendary vintages of the past WA 4/ half-bottles (375ml) per lot US$ Château d'yquem bottom neck or better unless noted 1988 (2) very top shoulder, lightly bin-soiled labels, one slightly protruded cork, one with signs of old seepage 1989 (2) one lightly scuffed label 1990 (2) 437 above 6 bottles per lot US$ Château Pichon Longueville Comtesse de Lalande 2003 Pauillac, Deuxième Cru Classé bottles per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com

61 BURGUNDY Echézeaux Domaine de la Romanée-Conti cm or better, lightly scuffed labels, one marked label bottles per lot US$ Romanée-St-Vivant Domaine de la Romanée-Conti cm or better, one lightly bin-soiled label, lightly scuffed labels "Wonderful aromatics of Vosne spice, black fruit and hints of earth and violets followed by rich, velvety flavors of stunning complexity and exceptional length...93." BH 8/ bottles per lot US$ Richebourg Anne Gros 1995 one damp-stained label, one lightly scuffed label, one with signs of old seepage "Despite the intensity and massive character of both the fruit and flavors, the wine displays impeccable balance...93." BH 10/ bottles per lot US$ Richebourg Gros Frère et Sœur 1996 "Pronounced aromas...complex, beautiful flavors of unusual finesse. This is not especially dense but it offers superb definition and outstanding finishing complexity...93." BH 1/ bottles per lot US$ Richebourg Anne Gros 1998 "The wine simply exudes class...may one day rival Anne's greatest wine to date, the 1993 Richebourg. One of the top ten wines I have tasted from " BH 1/ bottles per lot US$ Richebourg Anne Gros 2000 "Full, deep red. Compelling...Sweet but precise and penetrating, with lovely harmonious acidity...a superb 2000!...93." IWC 3/ bottles per lot US$ Richebourg Anne Gros 2001 five marked labels "...an extremely subtle complexity lead to round, big if not massive, velvety, stunningly long flavors that exude breed and unmistakable class...94." BH 1/ bottles per lot US$ Richebourg Anne Gros 2002 "The flavor profile is intense, seductive and spicy with a wonderfully textured and velvety character to the big, rich, forceful flavors of uncommon depth and astonishing length...94." BH 1/ bottles per lot US$ Richebourg Anne Gros 2004 "...taut, focused and concentrated as there is slightly better mid-palate sap and a bit better balance. This is fresh and intense with a lovely sense of transparency " BH 1/ bottles per lot US$ Richebourg Anne Gros 2006 "An elegant, pure and reserved spicy, cool and equally layered black and blue fruit nose...really lovely intensity, balance and outstanding length " BH 1/ bottles per lot US$ Richebourg Anne Gros 1999 "Great length, complexity and vigor, intensity and quality. A great wine..." CC 3/ bottles per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com 69

62 70 ZACHYS tel fax zachys.com

63 Lots 440, 442, 443 & 446 ZACHYS tel fax zachys.com 71

64 Lot ZACHYS tel fax zachys.com

65 DOMAINE LEROY Clos de Vougeot Domaine Leroy cm or better, one wine-stained vintage tag, four lightly chipped wax capsules "...aromatics are fresh and youthful...medium-to-fullbodied and firm, this blackberry and cassis-flavored wine remains backward and tight...92." WA 10/ bottles per lot US$ ,000 Chambertin Domaine Leroy 1995 three 2cm or better, one 3cm "...thick, full-bodied, robust wine bursts with layers of toasty, jammy cassis, earth tones and an attractive wild game component " WA 6/ bottles per lot US$12,000-20,000 Clos de Vougeot Domaine Leroy 1995 one bin-soiled label, three wine-stained labels, one winestained vintage tag, one heavily depressed cork, one with signs of old seepage "...tightly wound, super-concentrated core...this firm, medium-to-full-bodied, backward wine is packed with loads of fruit and tannin...93." WA 10/ bottles per lot US$10,000-16,000 Vosne-Romanée Les Beaux Monts Domaine Leroy 1995 Côte de Nuits, Premier Cru 2cm or better, one scuffed label "Stylish and aristocratic yet down-to-earth, this full-bodied, exciting red starts out with great subtlety, then builds in intensity, concentration and complexity as it unfolds...92." WS 11/ bottles per lot US$ Clos de Vougeot Domaine Leroy 1996 one lightly marked label, two lightly nicked labels, one with tissue paper adhered to label, one torn label "Its medium-to-full-bodied, satin-textured personality is highly structured and youthfully firm...95." WA 10/ bottles per lot US$12,000-18,000 Latricières-Chambertin Domaine Leroy 1996 bin-soiled labels "It is immensely powerful as well as concentrated, and has its vintage's trademark freshness and grip...97." WA 10/ bottles per lot US$ ,000 Clos de Vougeot Domaine Leroy 2001 four lightly scuffed labels, one with signs of old seepage "...explosive aromas of subtle toast, dried herbs and obvious earth notes that combine with big, robust, fantastically intense full-bodied flavors that deliver unbelievable concentration...94." BH 6/ bottles per lot US$ Richebourg Domaine Leroy 2002 "...powerful, even robust, muscular and intense flavors are thick and oozing with extract...completely buffers the considerable tannins on the beautifully long finish...96." BH 1/ bottles per lot US$ Nuits St Georges Domaine Leroy 2004 Côte de Nuits six lightly wrinkled labels, one with signs of old seepage "...intense medium full flavors that are powerful, muscular and powerful, all wrapped in a strikingly long finish. This is a 'wow' wine...93." BH 4/ bottles per lot US$ ,000 ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com 73

66 ARMAND ROUSSEAU Chambertin Armand Rousseau cm, lightly scuffed and wine-stained label, signs of old seepage "...pure and incredibly complex and elegant...sweet and quite intricate displaying Grand Cru richness and stupendous length...94." BH 12/ bottle per lot US$ Chambertin Armand Rousseau cm, bin-soiled labels, one lightly nicked label "Perfumed...very rich and forward medium weight flavors of exceptional length...multiple, and consistent, notes...93." BH 5/ bottles per lot US$ ,000 Chambertin Clos de Bèze Armand Rousseau cm or better, one lightly damp-stained label, one winestained label, one wine-stained vintage tag, two with signs of old seepage "Wonderfully complex aromatics...flavors of real distinction and very good length...delivers plenty of mouth coating velvet and spice...92." BH 11/ bottles per lot US$10,000-16,000 Chambertin Clos de Bèze Armand Rousseau 1991 two lightly bin-soiled labels, three lightly scuffed labels "...offers an explosion of incredibly complex aromas... akin to the unfolding of a peacock's tail. Rich, dense and structured...a wonderful combination of power and finesse...94." BH 4/ bottles per lot US$20,000-30,000 Chambertin Armand Rousseau cm or better, one lightly damp-stained label, one nicked label, one scuffed label, one torn label "...restrained, pure and powerful, extremely rich, almost massive flavors that offer a core of inner sweetness and then does a slow build to an intense, extremely long finish...94." BH 11/ bottles per lot US$ ,000 Chambertin Clos de Bèze Armand Rousseau cm or better, one lightly bin-soiled label, two lightly marked labels, two scuffed labels, one marked vintage tag "...a simply dazzling breadth of aromas...detailed, driving and still very fresh flavors that display astounding depth... slow building, wonderfully persistent length...96." BH 10/ bottles per lot US$10,000-15,000 Chambertin Armand Rousseau 1995 one scuffed label, two loose capsules reveal fully branded corks "...the Chambertin has a massive, deeply spicy, sweet, very thick, super-complex palate with sauteed bacon notes " WA 6/ bottles per lot US$18,000-28,000 Chambertin Clos de Bèze Armand Rousseau 1995 one lightly scuffed label "...wonderfully concentrated flavors of impressive depth and simply incredible balance for such a big, structured, powerful wine...94." BH 1/ bottles per lot US$ Chambertin Armand Rousseau 1996 one lightly scuffed label, two lightly wine-stained labels "One of the greatest wines of the vintage with one of the most complex and stunning panoply of still youthful pinot fruit aromas I have ever experienced...95." BH 4/ bottles per lot US$11,000-16,000 Chambertin Clos de Bèze Armand Rousseau 1996 "...tannic, sappy, intense, remarkably complex flavors... Fresh, long and beautiful...92." BH 10/ bottles per lot US$ Chambertin Armand Rousseau 1998 lightly scuffed labels "...a broad range of nuances, including earth, anise, clove and a whiff of oak toast that dissolves into the rich, intense, muscled and powerful flavors...93." BH 4/ bottles per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com

67 Lots 458, 459, 469 & 477 ZACHYS tel fax zachys.com 75

68 Chambertin Armand Rousseau 1999 two different importers "...a simply knock out Chambertin, worthy of every accolade reserved for the very best in Burgundy...93." BH 11/ bottles per lot US$18,000-28,000 Chambertin Armand Rousseau 2001 "...fullish and still quite tight, with outstanding acidity currently reigning in the depth of fruit that one can still sense in the mid-palate...blossoms beautifully in a peacock's tail...96." JBG 5/ bottles per lot US$ Chambertin Clos de Bèze Armand Rousseau 1999 "...medium to full-bodied, elegant, and unctuously textured...impeccably ripened tannins detectable in its exceptionally long and delineated finish " WA 8/ bottles per lot US$14,000-22,000 Gevrey-Chambertin Clos St Jacques Armand Rousseau 1999 Côte de Nuits, Premier Cru one lightly damp-stained label, two lightly nicked labels, one lightly scuffed label "...intensely sappy pinot fruit, long, rich, powerful and earthy flavors all held together by extraordinary balance. This is just flat out reference standard CSJ " BH 1/ bottles per lot US$ Chambertin Armand Rousseau 2000 "...phenomenal aromatic complexity...it is packed, powerful and beautifully complex and is an outstanding wine...93." BH 11/ bottles per lot US$ ,000 Chambertin Clos de Bèze Armand Rousseau 2000 "...unbelievably complex aromas and flavors...rich and vibrant with Grand Cru weight and size " BH 1/ bottles per lot US$ Gevrey-Chambertin Clos St Jacques Armand Rousseau 2000 Côte de Nuits, Premier Cru one bin-soiled label "There is however even better power and drive with outstanding acid/fruit balance and seamless integration " BH 1/ bottles per lot US$ Chambertin Clos de Bèze Armand Rousseau 2001 one lightly bin-soiled label "...has a creamy, voluptuous bouquet...very perfumed and feminine...perfect acidity and a caressing texture...incredible clarity and delineation. Stunning...96." WA 3/ bottles per lot US$ ,000 Chambertin Armand Rousseau 2002 "Profound aromas of raspberry and strawberry liqueur and sappy oak, with an almost honeyed sweetness " IWC 3/ bottles per lot US$16,000-24,000 Chambertin Clos de Bèze Armand Rousseau 2002 "...exuberant, big, rich, round and intensely sappy. The finish explodes in the mouth and is superbly complex with first rate vibrancy " BH 1/ bottles per lot US$10,000-17,000 Chambertin Clos de Bèze Armand Rousseau 2003 "The rich, intense and full-bodied flavors are relatively supple yet wrapped in dense but fine tannins buffered by superb mid-palate sap " BH 1/ bottles per lot US$ Chambertin Armand Rousseau 2004 original carton "The medium full flavors are reserved, tight, precise and very pure with extraordinarily good punch and precision... Outstanding stuff...93." BH 1/ bottles per lot US$11,000-16, ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com

69 SPECIALIST'S PICK: LOT 481 From a notoriously challenging vintage, this master winemaker was able to craft a tremendous bottle of wine. I was astounded by how good this bottle showed. After a full day with lots of great bottles on offer, I was ready to throw in the towel and then someone opened up this beauty. I may have stuck around for a glass or two Shoshana Filene Chambertin Clos de Bèze Armand Rousseau 2004 "...rich, supple, elegant and pure flavors where the structure arrives all at once on the seriously long finish...93." BH 1/ bottles per lot US$ Chambertin Armand Rousseau 2006 "An extremely impressive wine and one of the finest wines of the vintage...94." BH 1/ bottles per lot US$ Chambertin Armand Rousseau 2008 "Good bright, dark red...broad but youthfully closed... Finishes very long and perfumed " IWC 3/ bottles per lot US$ Chambertin Clos de Bèze Armand Rousseau 2008 "...incredibly complex and refined...balanced, refined and mouth coating flavors that possess superb depth and excellent finishing intensity " BH 1/ bottles per lot US$ Chambertin Clos de Bèze Armand Rousseau 2006 two different labels, two nicked labels...well focused flavors underpinned by very firm tannins and plenty of underlying tension as you can really sense the energy here BH 1/ bottles per lot US$ Chambertin Armand Rousseau 2007 "...dusty, textured, precise and palate staining big-bodied flavors that are exceptionally tight on the linear but hugely long finish...94." BH 1/ bottles per lot US$ Chambertin Armand Rousseau 2011 "...outstanding richness to the powerful and impressively scaled...this is a stunner of a wine and one of the great wines of the 2011 vintage...96." BH 1/ bottles per lot US$ Chambertin Clos de Bèze Armand Rousseau 2011 "...gorgeous combination of power and refinement along with flat out superb complexity on the explosively long, focused and beautifully well-balanced finish...95." BH 1/ bottles per lot US$ Chambertin Clos de Bèze Armand Rousseau 2007 two different labels, one damp-stained label "...intensely mineral suffused big-bodied flavors that for all the focused muscularity sacrifice none of the fine detail this wine is known for, all wrapped in an almost painfully intense and explosively long finish " BH 1/ bottles per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com 77

70 VOGÜÉ Delicate, feminine and fragrant, the epitome of finesse: lace, silk and taffeta; violets and dog-roses; raspberries and blackcurrants with a finish of liquorice; amplitude and generosity; intensity without a trace of hardness. All this has been said by those attempting to describe the taste of Le Musigny. Le Musigny consists of two sub-climats, Le Musigny itself and at the same altitude next door to the south, Les Petits-Musigny. The lion's share, more than seven hectares, almost seventy percent, and including the totality of Les Petites-Musigny, belongs to the Domaine Comte Georges de Vogüé. This estate proclaims itself the Domaine des Musigny. The domaine also comprise 2.75 hectares of Bonnes-Mares, located entirely in the southern, Chambolle end of the climat, sixty ares of Amoureuses, 1.80 hectares of premiers crus (Baudes and Fuées) and a small parcel of village wine. Wines of the domaine are defined as classy and fragrant, very exciting indeed. The domaine is in good hands. The future is bright. Clive Coates, MW, Côte d'or Musigny Vieilles Vignes Comte Georges de Vogüé cm or better, one damp-stained label "This loaded effort should prove to be one of the longestlived red Burgundies made in the last twenty years...96." WA 2/ bottles per lot US$ Musigny Vieilles Vignes Comte Georges de Vogüé 1993 one with importer tag adhered to label "...massively structured and thick flavors with dense, ripe tannins that are completely buffered by all the extract. This is flat out great...97." BH 11/ bottles per lot US$ Musigny Vieilles Vignes Comte Georges de Vogüé 1995 "...this stupendous Burgundy has a thick, almost viscous, velvety texture, with copious quantities of fat, chewy, red berries " WA 6/ bottles per lot US$ Musigny Vieilles Vignes Comte Georges de Vogüé 1996 two lightly damp-stained labels "...this is a very powerful wine with incredible length and perfect balance...94." BH 3/ bottles per lot US$ Musigny Vieilles Vignes Comte Georges de Vogüé 1997 "...breathtaking nose...luxurious, yet well-defined, personality " WA 10/ bottles per lot US$ Musigny Vieilles Vignes Comte Georges de Vogüé 1998 four wrinkled labels "...impressive density...simply an awesome display of power and grace...94." BH 4/ bottles per lot US$ Chambolle-Musigny Les Amoureuses Comte Georges de Vogüé 1999 Côte de Nuits, Premier Cru two lightly scuffed labels "A stunning example of classic Amoureuses with its ruby and black hues, spicy and sexy red and black fruits, soil and mineral inflected flavors and superb length. In short, this is drop dead gorgeous " BH 1/ bottles per lot US$ Musigny Vieilles Vignes Comte Georges de Vogüé 1999 damp-stained labels "...reveals wonderfully complex aromas...huge but fine, powerful but subtle and rich yet detailed with a stupendously long finish...this is genuinely stunning juice...96." BH 11/ bottles per lot US$ Musigny Vieilles Vignes Comte Georges de Vogüé 2000 "Supremely elegant...reveals outstanding depth, purity, and concentration...exceptionally long, expressive, plump character...93." WA 6/ bottles per lot US$ Musigny Vieilles Vignes Comte Georges de Vogüé 2001 one 6-pack "Opulent and lavish yet all remains exquisitely balanced and this is astonishingly precise. A real stunner of a wine...96." BH 10/ bottles per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com

71 Musigny Vieilles Vignes Comte Georges de Vogüé 2002 "...very serious, exuberantly fresh and impressively deep flavors...incredible combination of mind boggling complexity coupled with perfect balance...96." BH 1/ bottles per lot US$ Musigny Vieilles Vignes Comte Georges de Vogüé 2008 "...a wine I could smell all day...shows terrific concentration and depth, dazzling finesse, and a nicely pointed, direct finish. It is an eternal wine...97." WA 5/ bottles per lot US$ Musigny Vieilles Vignes Comte Georges de Vogüé 2003 "The incredibly sappy and powerful medium full flavors are sweet and supple yet there is a very firm tannic spine buried beneath the mountain of dry extract...93." BH 1/ bottles per lot US$ Musigny Vieilles Vignes Comte Georges de Vogüé 2004 one lightly bin-soiled label "The rich, full and powerful flavors are sweet, supple and utterly classy and the intensity this wine displays is seriously impressive...96." BH 1/ bottles per lot US$ Musigny Vieilles Vignes Comte Georges de Vogüé 2009 "I could still taste this several hours later and if given sufficient cellar time, this should be one of the great vintages for this storied wine " BH 1/ bottles per lot US$ Vosne-Romanée Cros Parantoux Emmanuel Rouget 1993 Côte de Nuits, Premier Cru two 2cm or better, one 2.5cm, two lightly nicked labels, one lightly scuffed label, two different importers ''Racy, sleek Premier Cru, showing digital definition in every aspect of its flavor components...very long, focused finish...95." WS 5/ bottles per lot US$ Musigny Vieilles Vignes Comte Georges de Vogüé 2005 two lightly wrinkled labels "Prepare to be transported...a remarkable sense of energy and power on the almost unbelievably intense, focused and structured finish...99." BH 1/ bottles per lot US$ Musigny Vieilles Vignes Comte Georges de Vogüé 2006 "...explosive, energetic and hugely long yet incredible precise finish that is also built on a base of firm minerality. This is almost exotic in character yet everything is in beautiful concordance. In a word, great...96." BH 1/ bottles per lot US$ Musigny Vieilles Vignes Comte Georges de Vogüé 2007 two bin-soiled labels "...round, intense, muscular and exceptionally stylish broad-scaled flavors that possess excellent power and a building intensity that develops from the mid-palate to the explosive yet seductive finish " BH 1/ bottles per lot US$ Echézeaux Emmanuel Rouget 1995 two different importers "Remarkably supple and forward with elegant red fruits framed by traces of earth and a touch of oak followed by sweet, sappy, modulated, round flavors that offer excellent detail and fine length..." BH 10/ bottles per lot US$ Echézeaux Emmanuel Rouget 1996 three wrinkled labels "...a full-bodied, velvety-textured, and immensely refined wine...magnificently proportioned, balanced...complex, concentrated and pure personality " WA 2/ bottles per lot US$ ,000 Mazis-Chambertin Vieilles Vignes Dugat-Py 1996 "...spicy black pinot fruit aromas nuanced with hints of earth, crushed herbs and the classic gamy character of a fine Mazis that introduces extremely concentrated, powerful and intense full-bodied flavors that are a beautiful combination of muscle and detail...93." BH 10/ bottles per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com 79

72 Bonnes-Mares Georges Roumier 1999 one lightly marked label, one lightly scuffed label "...rich, broad, and expansive...silky-textured and leads to a long, black pepper-filled finish..." WA 8/ bottles per lot US$ Charmes-Chambertin Cuvée Trés Vieilles Vignes Joseph Roty 1999 original carton "...extraordinarily concentrated, powerful, and chewy-textured...extremely expressive and last throughout its unbelievably long, thick, and sweet finish " WA 8/ bottles per lot US$ Charmes-Chambertin Dugat-Py 1999 "Everything is in perfect harmony in an ultra ripe style. Impressive juice...93." BH 1/ bottles per lot US$ Clos de la Roche Dujac 1999 one lightly scuffed label "Slightly austere with a mineral essence that tends to suppress the pinot baby fat lurking beneath the surface. The potential here is enormous...93." BH 2/ bottles per lot US$ ,000 Mazis-Chambertin Vieilles Vignes Dugat-Py 1999 one lightly nicked label, two lightly scuffed labels bottles per lot US$ Musigny JF Mugnier 1999 two lightly scuffed labels "As one would expect from this vintage it was very structured and concentrated. It felt too young to drink, particularly when in a flight with the 2001 and " SF bottles per lot US$ ,000 Richebourg Méo-Camuzet 1999 one lightly scuffed label "Explosive black, sexy, powerful and dense...sweetness and perfect balance. This is a real show stopper...94." BH 7/ bottles per lot US$ Clos de Vougeot Méo-Camuzet 2000 three with signs of old seepage "Remarkably supple, rich, complex, layered with mocha, chocolate, espresso, toasted coconut and loads of ripe black currant flavors. Silky as they get...92." WS 2/ bottles per lot US$ Gevrey-Chambertin Clos St Jacques Vieille Vigne Domaine Fourrier 2000 Côte de Nuits, Premier Cru original carton bottles per lot US$ Mazis-Chambertin Vieilles Vignes Dugat-Py 2000 two lightly bin-soiled labels "Awash in minerality plus a touch of the sauvage, gamy quality for which the cru is justifiably famous. Harmonious, long and all is in perfect balance...94." BH 1/ bottles per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com

73 Lot 517 ZACHYS tel fax zachys.com 81

74 Lots 512 & ZACHYS tel fax zachys.com

75 Musigny Georges Roumier 2000 lightly scuffed labels "This finishes with tremendous length and intensity. Quite structured but the sap tends to bury it. Extremely impressive...93." BH 1/ bottles per lot US$16,000-24,000 Charmes-Chambertin Cuvée Trés Vieilles Vignes Joseph Roty 2002 "The powerful, indeed forceful flavors coat and stain the palate...flat out incredible juice and worth a special search to find...95." BH 1/ bottles per lot US$ Charmes-Chambertin Cuvée Trés Vieilles Vignes Joseph Roty 2001 two different importers "...there is a mind boggling amount of mid-palate sap and punch and it completely coats the mouth and the persistence is exemplary...94." BH 1/ bottles per lot US$ Charmes-Chambertin Dugat-Py 2002 one lightly marked label, one lightly scuffed label, one lightly wrinkled label "...sappy, vibrant, intense and powerful flavors that are impeccably balanced and superbly long. A breathtaking wine...94." BH 1/ bottles per lot US$ Mazis-Chambertin Vieilles Vignes Dugat-Py 2001 "The big, intense, powerful, even robust flavors display perfect balance and a subtle note of torrefaction and it's remarkable how such a powerful wine can remain so harmonious...94." BH 1/ bottles per lot US$ Richebourg Méo-Camuzet 2001 "Its dense layers of black cherries, blackberries, blueberries, and spices conquer the taster's palate " WA 6/ bottles per lot US$ Bonnes-Mares Georges Roumier 2002 "A complete and seamless wine of enormous complexity and considerable underlying reserve...95." BH 4/ bottles per lot US$ Chambolle-Musigny Les Amoureuses JF Mugnier 2002 Côte de Nuits, Premier Cru one scuffed vintage tag, one lightly bin-soiled label, one lightly nicked label "Wonderfully sweet and perfumed in the mouth, with silky flavors of red berries and flowers. Dense, juicy and broad wine, finishing with very fine tannins and unflagging flavor " IWC 3/ bottles per lot US$ Clos de la Roche Vieilles Vignes Domaine Ponsot 2002 "...superbly sappy, concentrated and very pure flavors that display flat out incredible length and impeccable balance...93." BH 1/ bottles per lot US$ Clos St Denis Dujac 2002 "Not at all a weighty style but not flimsy either. Sweeter and silkier than usual for this wine at this early stage. Finishes with terrific subtle length " IWC 3/ bottles per lot US$ Mazis-Chambertin Vieilles Vignes Dugat-Py bottles per lot US$ Musigny JF Mugnier 2002 "It was a close second overall for the wine of the night. It showed sweet red fruit notes on the nose, beautiful roundness and depth of flavor, and above all elegance..." SF bottles per lot US$ Chambertin Dugat-Py 2004 lightly bin-soiled label "This is a stunning wine, combining impressive power, depth and incredible length into a harmonious whole " BH 1/ bottle per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com 83

76 Mazis-Chambertin Vieilles Vignes Dugat-Py 2004 "This is a classy, beautifully precise effort of real style and harmony...in a word, breathtaking " BH 1/ bottles per lot US$ Richebourg Méo-Camuzet 2004 one lightly scuffed label "...a linear and reserved but impeccably well-balanced finale that is trimmed in a deft touch of wood " BH 1/ bottles per lot US$ Charmes-Chambertin Cuvée Trés Vieilles Vignes Joseph Roty 2005 one lightly scuffed label "...with uncanny intensity and clarity...a dark and rising tide of mineral and carnal flavors meets the fruit and spice in a thunderous finish " WA 4/ bottles per lot US$ Clos de la Roche Vieilles Vignes Domaine Ponsot 2005 two lightly scuffed labels "...pure rich and powerful flavors that are opulent, sweet and dripping...stains and saturates the palate on the hugely proportioned yet impeccably balanced finish...99." BH 1/ bottles per lot US$ Vosne-Romanée Emmanuel Rouget 2005 Côte de Nuits bottles per lot US$ COMTES LAFON Meursault Perrières Comtes Lafon 1993 Côte de Beaune, Premier Cru three with importer tags adhered to labels, two wrinkled labels, two different importers "There is a presence to this that great wines seem to possess and there is good upside here. Simply dazzling with certain urgency that I find riveting...94." BH 10/ bottles per lot US$ Meursault Perrières Comtes Lafon 1999 Côte de Beaune, Premier Cru two lightly scuffed labels "The intensity builds from the mid-palate and continues on to the long, dynamic, harmonious finish...94." BH 7/ bottles per lot US$ Meursault Charmes Comtes Lafon 2000 Côte de Beaune, Premier Cru two lightly scuffed labels "This offers a finish that is rich, penetrating, long and impeccably well balanced. A really beautifully effort...92." BH 7/ bottles per lot US$ Meursault Perrières Comtes Lafon 2002 Côte de Beaune, Premier Cru one lightly bin-soiled label, one lightly nicked label, one lightly scuffed label The flavors are quite powerful, firm and crystalline, underscored by pronounced and ripe acidity buffered by a lovely touch of sweet and sappy extract. Simply beautiful juice BH 7/ bottles per lot US$ Clos de la Roche Vieilles Vignes Domaine Ponsot 2009 "This is a classy wine with absolutely superb complexity, impeccable balance and almost uncanny presence, all delivered with grace and power...a wow' wine " BH 1/ bottles per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com

77 DOMAINE LEFLAIVE Chevalier-Montrachet Domaine Leflaive 1995 Côte de Beaune, Grand Cru two scuffed labels, two with signs of old seepage "Racy, floral, fresh, and engaging on the nose, the wine's awesome entry is filled with intense flavors of minerals and toasted apricots. Silky-textured, full-bodied, classy, and refined " WA 4/ bottles per lot US$ Chevalier-Montrachet Domaine Leflaive 1996 Côte de Beaune, Grand Cru two lightly scuffed labels, two different importers "...detailed, pure and racy middle weight complex flavors underpinned by intense minerality and superb length...96." BH 3/ bottles per lot US$ Chevalier-Montrachet Domaine Leflaive 1999 Côte de Beaune, Grand Cru five lightly scuffed labels, one with signs of old seepage "...curiously silky yet surprisingly powerful and muscular palate impression and a racy intensity that just oozes class...94." BH 12/ bottles per lot US$ Puligny-Montrachet Les Folatières Domaine Leflaive 1999 Côte de Beaune, Premier Cru "This is very fine, even delicate with outstanding detail finishing with excellent cut. Beautiful wine..." BH 7/ bottles per lot US$ Chevalier-Montrachet Domaine Leflaive 2000 Côte de Beaune, Grand Cru two lightly bin-soiled labels, one lightly damp-stained label "...a complete wine with mind boggling purity and a finish that seems like liquefied rock. Stony, intense...95." BH 12/ bottles per lot US$ Puligny-Montrachet Les Pucelles Domaine Leflaive 2000 Côte de Beaune, Premier Cru "This really dances on the palate. Finishes vibrant, firmedged and long. A superb Premier Cru...93." IWC 9/ bottles per lot US$ Chevalier-Montrachet Domaine Leflaive 2002 Côte de Beaune, Grand Cru "A supremely elegant nose...simply incredible focus with an almost painfully intense, stunningly long finish...94." BH 5/ bottles per lot US$ Chevalier-Montrachet Domaine Leflaive 2004 Côte de Beaune, Grand Cru "The palate is energetic and vibrant, with a killer line of acidity that marries beautifully with the shimmering citric fruit...long and persistent finish. Outstanding...96." WA 2/ bottles per lot US$ Puligny-Montrachet Domaine Leflaive Les Folatières 1996 (3) Les Folatières 2002 (3) Les Pucelles 2002 (3) 553 above 9 bottles per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com 85

78 ETIENNE SAUZET Bâtard-Montrachet Etienne Sauzet 1999 Côte de Beaune, Grand Cru "The opulent, strikingly perfumed nose explodes from the glass, in fact this is so showy that it's almost ostentatious yet nothing is out of balance...the length is absolutely show stopping...94." BH 2/ bottles per lot US$ Chevalier-Montrachet Etienne Sauzet 1999 Côte de Beaune, Grand Cru one lightly scuffed label "This just oozes class and breed and the balance is perfect with acidity that exquisitely frames each nuance yet remains in the background as a supporting, rather than dominating, element...96." BH 5/ bottles per lot US$ Montrachet Etienne Sauzet 2000 Côte de Beaune, Grand Cru "...an indescribable purity of expression...a superb density and sappiness. Despite the power and volume, this comes across as almost silky with stupendous intensity and length that is borderline hard to believe...95." BH 7/ bottles per lot US$ Bâtard-Montrachet Etienne Sauzet 2002 Côte de Beaune, Grand Cru "Reserved, backward and almost closed on the nose...the ample flavors are impressively scaled...it is a good deal more powerful and possesses a finish that seems to go on and on...94." BH 7/ bottles per lot US$ Montrachet Etienne Sauzet 2004 Côte de Beaune, Grand Cru "It is a brilliant wine...on the palate the wine is full-bodied, deep and refined, with stunning elegance, great focus and purity, and a very long, complex and racy finish...96." JBG 3/ bottles per lot US$ Chevalier-Montrachet Colin-Deléger 1999 Côte de Beaune, Grand Cru one lightly glue-stained label "...taut, racy, beautifully defined flavors...perfectly proportioned and seamless with a finish that is not only prodigiously long but breathtakingly intense...the acid/fruit balance displayed here is nothing short of brilliant...96." BH 9/ bottles per lot US$ Montrachet Domaine Ramonet 1999 Côte de Beaune, Grand Cru lightly scuffed label, loose capsule reveals fully branded cork "Painfully intense with palate staining, focused and layered flavors and phenomenal length that is hard to believe. A genuinely great wine...97." BH 3/ bottle per lot US$ Bâtard-Montrachet Domaine Ramonet 2000 Côte de Beaune, Grand Cru two different importers "...muscular full-bodied flavors that retain excellent focus and incredible intensity...94." BH 8/ bottles per lot US$ Chablis Valmur Raveneau 2000 Chablis, Grand Cru "On the palate the wine is deep and tightly-knit...depth at the core, great acid structure, laser-like focus, and tremendous length and grip on the finish " JBG 12/ bottles per lot US$ Montrachet Domaine Ramonet 2000 Côte de Beaune, Grand Cru two different importers "Quite elegant and remarkably well balanced...this delivers wave after wave of sappy extract on the seemingly never-ending finish. It never ceases to amaze me how Montrachet can be so big yet so light on the palate...96." BH 7/ bottles per lot US$ Bâtard-Montrachet Domaine Ramonet 2001 Côte de Beaune, Grand Cru one slightly protruded cork, four with signs of old seepage "Incredibly beautiful and elegant aromas...gorgeously pure and delineated medium full flavors that seem as though they're chiseled directly from solid rock...95." BH 10/ bottles per lot US$ Chablis Blanchots Raveneau 2002 Chablis, Grand Cru one lightly damp-stained label, two heavily chipped wax capsules, one with signs of old seepage "Astounding purity of expression...silky, ultra fine, linear and almost delicate yet with considerable power, precision and length...94." BH 10/ bottles per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com

79 Lots 560 & 563 ZACHYS tel fax zachys.com 87

80 Chablis Montée de Tonnerre Raveneau 2002 Chablis, Premier Cru "Big, powerful, very masculine and exceptionally intense flavors blessed with huge extract...a great effort that explodes on the backend and lingers for minutes...93." BH 10/ bottles per lot US$ Chevalier-Montrachet Henri Boillot 2002 Côte de Beaune, Grand Cru "...as it's constructed along the classic Chevalier lines of silk, lace and an intense stoniness rather than power and richness. A brilliant effort...95." BH 7/ bottles per lot US$ CHAMPAGNE Pol Roger Cuvée Sir Winston Churchill 1996 Champagne individual original coffrets in two 6-pack original cartons "Probably the foremost Winston Churchill that the world has ever seen since the prime minister passed away! Incomparably grand and impressive. A wine with which to fill your cellar...97." RJ 12/ bottles per lot US$ Montrachet Domaine Ramonet 2003 Côte de Beaune, Grand Cru one lightly scuffed label, one previously cut foil reveals fully branded cork "...rich, full and beautifully textured flavors all wrapped in a powerful, long and utterly classy finish...94." BH 7/ bottles per lot US$ Chablis Les Preuses René et Vincent Dauvissat 2007 Chablis, Grand Cru includes 12-pack original carton bottles per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com

81 Treasures from a EUROPEAN CELLAR (LOTS ) The following consignment comes to Zachys from a very longtime friend and enthusiastic collector in Europe. Spruce up your cellar with any of the superb wines from this curated selection of lots, which make up a tiny fraction of our consignor's full collection at home. The most collectible names of the moment are all found here some young, and some just waiting to be opened! From rare vintages of Bordeaux First Growths dating back to the early 1920s, 30s, and 40s, to highlights from Burgundy such as DRC back to the 1970s as well as multiple lots of Coche-Dury and Rousseau, this collection has something for every Francophile in the wine world. All wines were removed from a temperature-controlled cellar and underwent highly critical inspection and provenance check by Zachys senior team of specialists. Bid with excitement and confidence in this collection you won't see many of these wines again any time soon! ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com 89

82 BORDEAUX CHÂTEAU LAFITE ROTHSCHILD CHÂTEAU CHEVAL BLANC Château Cheval Blanc 1949 St Émilion, Premier Grand Cru Classé (a) upper-mid shoulder, bin-soiled and torn label, short capsule reveals vintage branded cork "Fully mature and glorious. Lovely aromas...shows great elegance and class...97." WS 3/ bottle per lot US$ Château Cheval Blanc 1964 St Émilion, Premier Grand Cru Classé (a) Lot 572: five top shoulder, two upper shoulder, two uppermid shoulder, bin-soiled labels, two damp-stained labels, one wine-stained label, one corroded capsule, two lightly corroded capsules, four with signs of old seepage Lot 573: upper shoulder, bin-soiled label, lightly corroded capsule Lot 574: one very top shoulder, two top shoulder, three upper shoulder, bin-soiled labels, lightly corroded capsules, two previously cut capsules, signs of old seepage "...powerful, yet restrained bouquet...the wine remains amazingly young and tannic, with layer upon layer of ripe fruit. This is a heavyweight, old-style Cheval Blanc...95." WA 10/ bottles per lot US$ , magnum (1.5L) per lot US$ magnums (1.5L) per lot US$15,000-24,000 CHÂTEAU HAUT-BRION Château Lafite Rothschild 1928 nicked, lightly tissue-stained, heavily bin-soiled and dampstained label, corroded capsule, signs of old seepage Lot 580: upper-mid shoulder Lots & 580.2: mid shoulder Parcel: lots & bottle per lot US$ bottle per lot US$ bottle per lot US$ Château Lafite Rothschild 1945 upper-mid shoulder, heavily deteriorated label obscures vintage, short capsule reveals vintage branded cork, vintage embossed on glass "Just about every note over the years refers to a glorious fragrance which seems to unravel itself after 15 or 20 minutes in the glass...a glorious mouthful..." MB 4/ bottle per lot US$ Château Lafite Rothschild 1959 upper shoulder, deteriorated label, short and lightly corroded capsule reveals vintage branded cork "One of the best-ever Lafites...The extraordinary ability to exude not only an immediate cedary perfume...a Lafite specialty, the way it opens up further avenues of fragrance and subtle by-paths, lingering in the mouth..." MB 12/ bottle per lot US$ Château Haut-Brion 1949 Graves, Premier Cru Classé one upper shoulder, two upper-mid shoulder, heavily binsoiled labels, short capsules reveal vintage branded corks, one protruded cork "...nice flavour, balanced, refreshing and 'good to drink'...a wine of great power and length with an end taste of singed heather..." MB bottles per lot US$ Château Lafite Rothschild 1996 (1) 1998 (1) 583 above 2 bottles per lot US$ Château Haut-Brion 1959 Graves, Premier Cru Classé Lots 576 & 577: 4cm, bin-soiled and damp-stained label Lot 578: 4cm, bin-soiled and damp-stained label, corroded capsule, signs of old seepage Lot 579: one 3cm, one 3.5cm, three 4cm, three 4.5cm, three 5cm, one 5.5cm, seven damp-stained labels, four scuffed labels, two tissue-stained labels, eight lightly corroded capsules, Parcel: lots 576 & 577 "Sensational. Mature, generous and deep, a many-layered wine that shows sweet berry and chocolate flavors under a layer of slightly scratchy tannins...98." WS 4/ bottle per lot US$ bottle per lot US$ bottle per lot US$ bottles per lot US$24,000-36, ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com

83 CHÂTEAU LATOUR CHÂTEAU MOUTON ROTHSCHILD Château Latour 1959 Lot 584: upper-mid shoulder, Danish importer tag adhered to bin-soiled and marked label, cut capsule reveals producer branded cork, Danish tax stamp adhered to lightly corroded capsule, signs of old seepage Lot 585: one very top shoulder, one top shoulder, one binsoiled label, one lightly nicked label, new capsules, one with signs of old seepage, one cut capsule reveals fully branded cork "Very expressive and nuanced...this is a spectacular bottle..." SF bottle per lot US$ bottles per lot US$ CHÂTEAU MARGAUX Château Mouton Rothschild 1949 Pauillac, Deuxième Cru Classé upper shoulder, damp-stained, torn and taped on label, short corroded capsule reveals vintage branded cork, signs of old seepage "...possesses superb concentration and a remarkably long finish. It appears to be fully mature, yet the balance, length, and tannin level...a formidable Mouton...94." WA 10/ bottle per lot US$ Château Mouton Rothschild 1950 Pauillac, Deuxième Cru Classé upper shoulder, damp-stained and nicked label, short and lightly corroded capsule reveals vintage branded cork bottle per lot US$ Château Margaux 1945 Margaux, Premier Cru Classé upper shoulder, heavily bin-soiled and lightly damp-stained label, heavily corroded capsule reveals cork, signs of old seepage "A vivacious and fabulously fragrant bottle at the Sveass dinner and showing its magnificent best at both of the Wagner's Margaux tastings in 1997 and " MB bottle per lot US$ Château Margaux 1953 Margaux, Premier Cru Classé Lot 587: upper shoulder, lightly bin-soiled label, heavily corroded capsule reveals cork Lot 588: upper shoulder, faded and nicked label, corroded capsule reveals slightly depressed cork "Round and opulent, with a velvety texture and gobs of sweet, jammy fruit, this is Château Margaux at its most seductive...98." WA 10/ bottle per lot US$ magnum (1.5L) per lot US$ Château Mouton Rothschild 1955 Pauillac, Deuxième Cru Classé one top shoulder, two upper shoulder, one upper-mid shoulder, one lightly bin-soiled label, two lightly deteriorated labels, two corroded capsules, one slightly depressed cork, one slightly protruded cork, one with signs of old seepage, one Reserve du Château "In the mouth, there is stunning concentration, magnificent extraction of fruit, and plenty of tannin in the long finish. The wine still tastes remarkably young...amazing!...97." WA 10/ bottles per lot US$ Château Mouton Rothschild 1959 Pauillac, Deuxième Cru Classé upper shoulder, deteriorated and torn label, corroded capsule, short capsule reveals vintage branded cork, protruded cork, signs of old seepage "...one of the greatest Moutons...Astonishingly young and unevolved " RP bottle per lot US$ Château Margaux 1996 Margaux, Premier Cru Classé lightly damp-stained label "...a strong contender for wine of the vintage. It offers everything you desire from this First Growth...This is a Margaux that seems to light up the senses " WA 10/ magnum (1.5L) per lot US$ Château Mouton Rothschild 1982 very top shoulder, one damp-stained label, one lightly damp-stained label, one with signs of old seepage Half the people in the room picked this as the favorite in this lineup...did keep getting better in the glass and showed a tremendous depth of fruit and formidable structure... SF bottles per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com 91

84 Château Pichon Longueville Comtesse de Lalande 1948 Pauillac, Deuxième Cru Classé one upper shoulder, three upper-mid shoulder, deteriorated and faded labels, one heavily wine-stained label, corroded and short capsules reveal vintage branded corks bottles per lot US$ Château L'Evangile 1949 Pomerol upper-mid shoulder, lightly bin-soiled label, lightly corroded capsule, short capsule reveals vintage branded cork bottle per lot US$ Vieux Château Certan 1949 Pomerol one top shoulder, two upper shoulder, one upper-mid shoulder, heavily bin-soiled, damp-stained and torn labels, one corroded capsule partially reveals cork, two short capsules reveals vintage branded corks, one corroded capsule, two oxidized capsules bottles per lot US$ Château La Mission Haut-Brion 1955 Graves, Cru Classé one upper shoulder, one upper-mid shoulder, heavily binsoiled and damp-stained labels, one nicked label, different capsules, short capsules reveal vintage branded corks, one with signs of old seepage "The tannin has totally melted away...it is an amazing, complex, superbly well-balanced La Mission Haut- Brion! " WA 4/ bottles per lot US$ Château Palmer 1961 Margaux, Troisième Cru Classé two upper shoulder, two upper-mid shoulder, dampstained and faded labels, three nicked labels, corroded capsules, signs of old seepage "...an indescribably lovely bouquet and flavour...." MB 9/ magnums (1.5L) per lot US$32,000-48,000 Château Pichon Longueville Comtesse de Lalande 1982 Pauillac, Deuxième Cru Classé one bottom neck, one very top shoulder, three top shoulder, two lightly bin-soiled labels, one lightly oxidized capsule It had a beautiful dark fruit nose and very giving fruit on the palate... SF bottles per lot US$ SAUTERNES Château La Tour Blanche 1919 Sauternes, Premier Cru Classé one top shoulder, one upper shoulder, one deteriorated label, torn labels, one corroded capsule, short capsules reveal vintage branded corks, signs of old seepage, one chipped glass bottles per lot US$ Château d'yquem 1937 Sauternes, Premier Cru Supérieur top shoulder, heavily wine-stained label, short capsule reveals vintage branded cork, darker color appropriate for age "...It is a legendary wine...the nose gently unfurls in the glass...the palate is linear and correct on the entry and certainly gives notice of an immensely powerful Yquem...96." WA 6/ bottle per lot US$ Château d'yquem 1976 Sauternes, Premier Cru Supérieur five very top shoulder, three top shoulder, one heavily torn label, seven lightly bin-soiled labels, one wine-stained label, one missing label with vintage embossed capsule, three protruded corks, two corroded capsules, six with signs of old seepage "...a very powerful thick, viscous Yquem...The wine is viscous, rich, and an amazingly great Yquem " WA 12/ bottles per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com

85 BURGUNDY DOMAINE DE LA ROMANÉE-CONTI Richebourg Domaine de la Romanée-Conti cm, heavily bin-soiled and damp-stained label, corroded capsule, signs of old seepage, Interdiction d'exporter aux USA & UK "The flavors are rich, full and velvety with excellent volume and the finish goes on and on and completely coats the palate...95." BH 11/ bottle per lot US$ La Tâche Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 1959 one 4cm, one 4.5cm, one heavily deteriorated label partially obscuring vintage, one remnants of label with missing vintage and bottle number, previously cut capsules reveal vineyard & vintage branded corks "...incredibly rich, dense and pure flavors of stunning depth and length...this is flawless and drinking perfectly with nothing but sheer silk and velvet in the mouth...97." BH 1/ bottles per lot US$ ,000 Romanée-Conti Domaine de la Romanée-Conti cm, deteriorated label, missing monopole tag, cut capsule reveals corroded and vintage branded cork, corroded capsule "Very rich...broad, ample, lovely texture, very velvety. Rich. Full, concentrated, very good grip. Real intensity here. Multi-dimensional. Again a lot of structure... Brilliant " CC 10/ bottle per lot US$ ,000 Romanée-Conti Domaine de la Romanée-Conti cm, scuffed, heavily torn and wine-stained label obscures vintage and bottle number, protruded cork, corroded capsule, signs of old seepage "...clean nose...round, soft, generous and easy flavors... delicious. This is one of those interesting wines that manages to be classy and refined..." BH 4/ bottle per lot US$ ,000 Grands Echézeaux Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 2010 "The Grands Echézeaux shows off phenomenal inner perfume and sweetness in a deceptively understated style that is immensely appealing. A seriously long, intense finish rounds things out in style " WA 2/ bottles per lot US$ Hospices de Beaune Cuvée Dames Hospitalieres SA Leroy 1952 Côte de Beaune 3.5cm, torn, heavily bin-soiled and damp-stained label bottle per lot US$ Mazis-Chambertin Armand Rousseau 1971 one 4cm, one 4.5cm, bin-soiled and torn labels, one missing vintage tag, one cut capsule reveals vintage branded cork, one corroded capsule, light color bottles per lot US$ Romanée-St-Vivant Marey-Monge cm, lightly scuffed label, corroded capsule partially reveals cork, slightly depressed cork magnum (1.5L) per lot US$ Bonnes-Mares Dujac cm, lightly damp-stained and scuffed label bottle per lot US$ Morey St Denis Dujac 2001 Côte de Nuits original carton bottles per lot US$ Vosne-Romanée Les Malconsorts Sylvain Cathiard 2005 Côte de Nuits, Premier Cru original carton "...big, robust and well-muscled though not rustic with just superb dry extract on the palate saturating finish that goes on and on. Wow and this has so much potential...93." BH 1/ bottles per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com 93

86 Gevrey-Chambertin Lavaux St Jacques Claude Dugat 2009 Côte de Nuits, Premier Cru original carton "...a serious wine that has begun to close down in bottle...a great sign for the future...the balance of fruit and structure is compelling...this should be a magical bottle once it awakens...94." WA 4/ bottles per lot US$ Chambolle-Musigny Amoureuses Georges Roumier 2011 Côte de Nuits, Premier Cru lightly damp-stained label "This is actually quite firm yet the tannins are so wellintegrated that this seems more forward than it really is... flat out superb length. If you can find a bottle or two, don't miss it " BH 1/ bottle per lot US$ Gevrey-Chambertin Clos St Jacques Armand Rousseau 2014 Côte de Nuits, Premier Cru "You can feel the mouth tingling here with wonderful tension and poise on the sustained finish " WA 12/ bottles per lot US$ Richebourg Anne Gros 2003 (2) 2004 (1) 618 above 3 bottles per lot US$ COCHE-DURY Corton-Charlemagne Coche-Dury 2005 Côte de Beaune, Grand Cru lightly scuffed labels "Wonderfully sweet and rich, gaining breadth and texture as it mounts on the back half...monumental, utterly complete " IWC 9/ bottles per lot US$10,000-16,000 Meursault Perrières Coche-Dury 2007 Côte de Beaune, Premier Cru lightly bin-soiled label "...subtly creamy palate, this diversity of mineral notes harmonizes vibrantly...finishes with a striking combination of pithy piquancy, minerality, and refreshment...94." WA 12/ bottle per lot US$ Corton-Charlemagne Coche-Dury 2011 Côte de Beaune, Grand Cru one slightly depressed cork "...the elegant, ripe and beautifully layered...excellent concentration to the broad-shouldered and moderately powerful flavors...95." BH 6/ bottles per lot US$ Meursault Les Chevalières Coche-Dury 2012 Côte de Beaune, Premier Cru bottle per lot US$ SPECIALIST'S PICK: LOT 620: Drank the 2007 Coche-Dury Meursault Perrières at last year's Zachys pre-auction BYO dinner prior to La Paulée. A total stunner. Persistent, complex and lengthy. Charles Antin Meursault Coche-Dury 2002 (1) 2010 (1) 2011 (1) 2012 (1) 2013 (2) 623 above 6 bottles per lot US$ Meursault Perrières Maison Leroy 1996 Côte de Beaune, Premier Cru Lot 624: nicked labels, one depressed cork, slightly dark colors Lot 625: one scuffed label, one torn label, one slightly protruded cork, one corroded capsule bottles per lot US$ bottles per lot US$ Puligny-Montrachet Les Folatières Domaine d'auvenay 1997 Côte de Beaune one with paper adhered to label, damp-stained labels, scuffed capsules This superb wine is redolent with layers of earth, acacia blossom, white truffles, and peaches. WA 2/ bottles per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com

87 Lots ZACHYS tel fax zachys.com 95

88 Lots 629 & ZACHYS tel fax zachys.com

89 RHÔNE Hermitage JL Chave 1976 Rhône four 2cm or better, one 2.5cm, one heavily torn label, four torn labels, three wine-stained labels, four torn vintage tags bottles per lot US$ ITALY Barolo Monfortino Riserva Giacomo Conterno 1971 Piedmont upper shoulder, one lightly bin-soiled label, one winestained label, wine-stained vintage tags, corroded capsules, one slightly protruded cork, signs of old seepage "The 1971 Barolo Riserva Monfortino was stunning right out of the gate. Still deeply-colored, it coated the palate with a massive, imposing expression of fresh, vibrant fruit...98." WA 5/ bottles per lot US$ Brunello di Montalcino Case Basse Soldera 1985 Tuscany bottom neck, torn and lightly bin-soiled label magnum (1.5L) per lot US$ Barbaresco Santo Stefano di Neive Riserva Bruno Giacosa 1989 Piedmont bottom neck or better, one with signs of old seepage "Full-bodied, it's silky and caressing on the finish. Delicious." WS 12/ bottles per lot US$ Barbaresco Riserva Bruno Giacosa 1990 Piedmont bottom neck, nicked label "A soft, decadent Barolo with plenty of fruit...full-bodied, with velvety, caressing tannins..." WS 12/ magnum (1.5L) per lot US$ Barbaresco Santo Stefano di Neive Riserva Bruno Giacosa 1990 Piedmont bottom neck or better "Warm, open and generous, the wine shows superb balance, with a purity of fruit that powers through to the long, round finish...96." WA 2/ bottles per lot US$ Messorio Le Macchiole 2008 Tuscany banded individual s "...simply marvelous...layers of dark fruit take shape beautifully in the glass...mid-weight, refined Messorio endowed with tons of balance and sheer finesse...97." WA 4/ magnums (1.5L) per lot US$ Barbaresco Asili Riserva Bruno Giacosa 2000 magnum (1) 2004 magnum (1) torn label 635 above 2 magnums (1.5L) per lot US$ BORDEAUX Château Cheval Blanc 1948 St Émilion, Premier Grand Cru Classé (a) Lot 636: one upper shoulder, one upper-mid shoulder, damp-stained labels, one torn label, one protruded cork, one short capsule reveal fully branded cork, one oxidized capsule Lot 637: two just below top shoulder, four upper shoulder, damp-stained labels, three torn labels, one with tissuestained label, short capsules reveals vintage branded corks, two corroded capsules, three oxidized capsules, one with signs of old seepage "The wine retains an opaque plum/licorice-like color. A huge, earthy, soy, cedar, roasted herb nose is followed by a wine of immense power, body, intensity, and structure...96." WA 10/ bottles per lot US$ bottles per lot US$10,000-16,000 Château Mouton Rothschild 1948 Pauillac, Deuxième Cru Classé upper shoulder, damp-stained and lightly torn label, short oxidized capsule reveals vintage branded cork, slightly protruded cork "...still deep, attractive; lovely Mouton aroma, rich, scented, roses; medium weight, assertive...." MB 3/ bottle per lot US$ Château Grand-Puy-Lacoste 1947 Pauillac, Cinquième Cru Classé three just below top shoulder, two upper shoulder, two protruded corks bottles per lot US$ Brunello di Montalcino Case Basse Soldera 1990 Tuscany bottom neck or better, one lightly scuffed label "...a magnificent, rich, complex nose...the wine is extremely powerful and full-bodied, with layers of highly concentrated, ripe fruit...98." WA 4/ bottles per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com 97

90 MAJOR BOTTLES from a MAJOR COLLECTOR (LOTS ) These selections come from a seasoned collector with three decades of experience buying. The consignment begins with an ample selection of Bordeaux, though there are some Burgundian, Italian, and Californian gems to round out the offering. From DRC to Mouton to Conterno to Opus, the wines in this offering are nothing short of impressive and deserve your undivided attention. Upon arrival, these were transferred to a professional storage facility on the East Coast until removal for consignment. 98 ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com

91 BORDEAUX Château Mouton Rothschild 2006 "...stunning aromatics...built like a skyscraper with multiple dimensions...super-concentrated, beautiful blend...96." WA 12/ bottles per lot US$ Château La Mission Haut-Brion 1998 Pessac Léognan, Cru Classé "So complex...it's rich and flavorful and at the same time fresh and racy. A modern classic...99." JS 1/ bottles per lot US$ Château Cos d Estournel 2000 St Estèphe, Deuxième Cru Classé "The palate is full-bodied with ripe tannins, superb symmetrical structure...very well balanced, very focused, broadening out nicely towards the ravishing, supple finish...96." WA 9/ bottles per lot US$ Château Gruaud-Larose 2000 St Julien, Deuxième Cru Classé bottles per lot US$ La Mondotte 2000 St Émilion "A floral component also emerges as the wine sits in the glass. Extremely dense, full-bodied " WA 6/ bottles per lot US$ Château Angélus 2005 St Émilion, Premier Grand Cru Classé (a) "The tannins are beautifully integrated but still present, and the wood, acidity, alcohol, etc., are all beautifully assimilated in this magnificent, majestic vintage of Angélus " WA 8/ bottles per lot US$ Château L'Eglise Clinet 2005 Pomerol one lightly scuffed label "One of the monumental wines of the vintage...full body, and exceptional density and richness " WA 4/ bottles per lot US$ Château L'Evangile 2005 Pomerol "Full-bodied, with layer upon layer of velvety tannins and chocolate, berry, vanilla and tea flavors. Lasts for minutes. I am blown away by this wine " WS 3/ bottles per lot US$ Château Larcis Ducasse 2005 St Émilion, Grand Cru Classé "A blockbuster with superb elegance, finesse, and precision, it represents an exceptional achievement " WA 5/ bottles per lot US$ Les Forts de Latour 2005 Pauillac "...beautiful wine from this estate. Medium to full-bodied... the wine is extremely pure, broad, savory, and quite expensive...this is really of classified growth quality...93." WA 6/ bottles per lot US$ Château Pape Clément 2005 Pessac Léognan, Cru Classé two 6-pack s "This majestic, multidimensional wines is one of the great, great wines of the vintage. It should drink well for at least another 25 years...99." WA 6/ bottles per lot US$ Château Smith Haut Lafitte 2005 Pessac Léognan, Grand Cru Classé bottles per lot US$ Château Tertre Roteboeuf 2005 St Émilion Full-bodied and opulent with high, but remarkably sweet, velvety tannins as well as a stunning texture and a finish that lasts nearly a minute...kudos to the proprietor WA 4/ bottles per lot US$ Château Valandraud 2005 St Émilion bottles per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com 99

92 Château Ducru-Beaucaillou 2009 St Julien, Deuxième Cru Classé "Full-bodied and intense with Ducru's inimitable elegance and purity...magnificent! " WA 2/ bottles per lot US$ Château Haut-Bailly 2009 Pessac Léognan, Grand Cru Classé "It is full-bodied yet elegant, powerful yet delicate, and remarkably velvety-textured, sumptuous and loaded with upside potential...kudos to Haut-Bailly! " WA 4/ bottles per lot US$ Château Léoville Poyferré 2009 St Julien, Deuxième Cru Classé "A soaring bouquet...super-concentrated wine with silky tannins, stunning amounts of glycerin, a voluptuous, multilayered mouthfeel...displaying fabulous definition " WA 2/ bottles per lot US$ Château La Fleur Pétrus 2010 Pomerol two banded 6-pack s "Fresh and clean...full body, with silky tannins and a tangy finish. I like the balance and finesse to this young Lafleur Pétrus. So refined and beautiful...98." JS 2/ bottles per lot US$ Les Forts de Latour 2010 Pauillac "...expansive, savory, full-throttle wine, which is better than many vintages of the great Latour itself from the past...97." WA 2/ bottles per lot US$ Château Lynch-Bages 2010 Pauillac, Cinquième Cru Classé seven lightly scuffed labels "Full body, with ultra-fine tannins and a juicy delicious finish. Long and beautiful. This is the best Lynch in a long, long time. I love the precision here...98." JS 2/ bottles per lot US$ Château Pape Clément 2009 Pessac Léognan, Cru Classé bottles per lot US$ magnums (1.5L) per lot US$ Château Pontet-Canet 2009 Pauillac, Cinquième Cru Classé two lightly bin-soiled labels "Black as a moonless night...irrefutable purity, laser-like precision, colossal weight and richness, and sensational freshness " WA 2/ magnums (1.5L) per lot US$ Château L'Eglise Clinet 2010 Pomerol "Very expansive, multi-dimensional, with stunning purity, richness and equilibrium. The finish is very long, with significant tannins, but they are beautifully integrated " WA 5/ bottles per lot US$ Château Pape Clément 2010 Pessac Léognan, Cru Classé "Full and vibrant on the palate with a minty note... Wonderful structure. Firm but ripe tannins and very long... Great potential...96." JS 2/ magnums (1.5L) per lot US$ Château Pontet-Canet 2010 Pauillac, Cinquième Cru Classé "There's a wonderful purity to this. It goes on for minutes... Seamless. There's an amazing transparency that shows you all the elements of the wine's unique terrior " JS 2/ bottles per lot US$ Château d'yquem 2008 Sauternes, Premier Cru Supérieur two 6-pack s "...an understated Yquem that should age effortlessly and returning to the glass it graces you with hints of almond and a dash of spice " WA 4/ half-bottles (375ml) per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com

93 BURGUNDY DOMAINE DE LA ROMANÉE-CONTI The domaine is known for picking very late, sometimes, as in 1978, later than any other producers. They prune endlessly, make many passes through the vineyards at harvest and sort grapes rigorously both in the vineyard and at the winery. Average age of the vines is around thirty-five to forty-five years with yields typically around thirty hl/ha. The wines are aged in new French oak casks for approximately twenty months. There is usually only one racking and since 1985 the wines from all casks in each cru have been blended together prior to bottling to reduce bottle variation. Recently they have been moving towards biodynamic viticultural practices. Like many of the region's leading growers they have seen concrete evidence of soil and vine health improvement. It's hard to imagine that these wines could get better, but that is what separates them from the rest of the pack: an unrelenting pursuit for perfection in the Pinot Noir grape. In addition to the majestic reds, a white is also produced from a plot in Montrachet. Clive Coates, MW, "Côte d'or" Echézeaux Domaine de la Romanée-Conti cm "...explosive...very firm, densely concentrated, massively structured flavors of superb depth and extract..." BH 2/ bottle per lot US$ La Tâche Domaine de la Romanée-Conti cm, scuffed label "...dense, in fact extremely dense with excellent depth and terrific complexity and a finish that seems to go on forever...95." BH 11/ magnum (1.5L) per lot US$ ,000 Richebourg Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 1996 "...rich, sweet and still tight medium full and quite firmly structured flavors that possess a long though slightly edgy and austere finish...92." BH 4/ bottle per lot US$ Romanée-St-Vivant Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 1997 one lightly scuffed label "Beautiful ripe fruit and elegant structure in this gorgeous Pinot Noir...91." WS 6/ bottles per lot US$ Echézeaux Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 1999 "This is one of the better DRC Echézeaux in a long time...93." BH 1/ bottle per lot US$ Assortment Case Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 2001 original wood assortment case one Romanée-Conti, three La Tâche (one lightly scuffed label), two Richebourg, two Romanée-St-Vivant, two Grands Echézeaux (one scuffed label), two Echézeaux case per lot US$32,000-48,000 Richebourg Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 2001 banded "I particularly like the stupendously long and incredibly intense finish that offers a surprising sensation of almost pungent minerality...94." BH 1/ bottles per lot US$10,000-15,000 La Tâche Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 2002 scuffed label "It's vibrant, balanced and very elegant, with ripe fruit and tannins and a long finish...96." WS 6/ bottle per lot US$ La Tâche Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 2007 "...wonderfully broad, spicy, fresh, airy and layered leads to intensely floral, mineral infused and focused medium weight plus flavors that possess a strikingly attractive mouth feel...95." BH 1/ bottles per lot US$17,000-26,000 ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com 101

94 102 ZACHYS tel fax zachys.com

95 Lot 672 ZACHYS tel fax zachys.com 103

96 Lots 668, 674, 675 & ZACHYS tel fax zachys.com

97 Echézeaux Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 2008 consecutive bottle numbers "A notably riper, intensely spicy, airy and extremely fresh nose...rich, velvety and mouth coating medium-bodied flavors...outstanding length...93." BH 1/ bottles per lot US$ La Tâche Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 2008 "...firm tannins that are completely enrobed by the impressive amount of extract that also coats the mouth on the hugely long and ever-so-slightly minty finish...96." BH 1/ bottle per lot US$ Corton Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 2009 Côte de Beaune, Grand Cru one lightly scuffed label "...decidedly opulent...a gorgeous, striking wine in its own way...95." WA 4/ bottles per lot US$ La Tâche Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 2009 "It boasts incredible richness and depth, yet remains elusive. Silky, impossibly refined tannins frame the seamless, resonant finish...everything is simply in the right place...97." WA 4/ bottle per lot US$ Corton Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 2010 Côte de Beaune, Grand Cru "The supporting structure possesses a high degree of phenolic maturity and outstanding length...this is relatively fine, at least within the context of the typical robust and chewy style of a classic Corton...93." BH 1/ bottles per lot US$ La Tâche Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 2010 "This is perhaps even more floral than the Richebourg and every bit as spicy on the ultra-pure, cool and remarkably elegant mix of red and blue pinot fruit, red currant and wild red berries that are openly mineral-inflected...98." BH 1/ bottle per lot US$ Romanée-Conti Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 2011 banded Parcel: lots 682 & 683 "As it virtually always is at this point in its development, this is an exercise in understatement, poise and controlled power with an unrivaled purity of expression. In sum, this is Zen-like...96." BH 1/ bottles per lot US$36,000-55, bottles per lot US$36,000-55,000 La Tâche Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 2013 "...very complex and beautifully balanced. Perfect acidity, surfeit with tension...crescendos to a pixelated finish that has enormous persistence in the mouth. Stunning " WA 12/ bottles per lot US$15,000-24,000 Richebourg Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 2013 banded "...wonderful definition...a cashmere texture on the palate, extraordinarily smooth with outstanding weight on the finish. Gentle and self-effacing, this should be compelling once in bottle " WA 12/ bottles per lot US$10,000-15,000 Romanée-St-Vivant Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 2013 banded "The palate already has the florality and femininity of a Grand Cru, but with the backbone one might discern in a Richebourg. The finish is extraordinarily long " WA 12/ bottles per lot US$ ,000 Romanée-Conti Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 2014 "...remarkably intense and beautifully well-detailed...stony, powerful, focused and explosively long finish that delivers sneaky good length...97." BH 1/ bottle per lot US$11,000-16,000 ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com 105

98 LEROY How do you determine great? Is it size? Is it quality? Is it price? Is it reputation' (whatever that is)? Is it the amount of media coverage? However you do compute it, the greatest domaines of Burgundy today must be those under the control of Lalou Bize: the Domaine Leroy and her own Domaine d'auvenay. The estates of Jadot, Faiveley and Bouchard Père et Fils are far larger, that of Romanée-Conti the most splendid in terms of the percentage of Grand Cru terroir, but for the nobility of its wines, pride of place must go to Leroy and to Domaine d'auvenay. The sheer concentration, depth and intensity Lalou Bize manages to squeeze into her bottles is breathtaking. Lalou, born in Paris, was brought up in Meursault, in the mansion today occupied by her daughter Perrine. From the word go I was fascinated, she says. I was a cellar rat, watching and helping the cavistes rack the wines, taste them, bottle them. My mother kept calling me to come out of the cellar and play with my friends like a normal schoolgirl, but as soon as I could I crept back. In 1955 she persuaded her father to let her take over. She was twenty-three. He gave me carte blanche, she says. I started as I meant to go on. I bought finished wine, and only that which pleased me. Lalou is now happy at the Domaine Leroy and on her own. Look at my vines, she will say. Look how healthy and comfortable they are. And, being Lalou, she will not fail to point out a neighbor's plot of excessively abundant, uncontrolled growth. And come and taste the wine. Lalou's wines, according to her, are always extra'. The one-time cellar rat is now a master in her own right, and the wines she produces are triumphantly brilliant. Clive Coates, MW, Côte d'or Clos de Vougeot Domaine Leroy 2002 scuffed label, signs of old seepage "This is quite ripe...overall effect is one of brooding power...this is an incredibly powerful and rich wine that offers superb delineation...96." BH 1/ bottle per lot US$ Clos de Vougeot Domaine Leroy 2011 "An expressive and densely fruited nose...excellent intensity and controlled power to the big-bodied and seductively textured medium weight...95." BH 4/ bottles per lot US$12,000-18,000 Vosne-Romanée Les Genaivrières Domaine Leroy 2012 Côte de Nuits, Premier Cru seven with signs of old seepage "Very elegant, but it the rigidity of its backbone suggests that it will need a couple of years in bottle " WA 12/ bottles per lot US$ Latricières-Chambertin Domaine Leroy 2013 signs of old seepage "...beautifully defined, vivacious and ebullient. The palate is supremely focused and symmetrical, the tannin lacy and the texture so silky you might well mistake it for, say, a Romanée-St-Vivant " WA 12/ bottles per lot US$ Romanée-St-Vivant Domaine Leroy 2013 one with signs of old seepage "...enthralling transparency and clarity on the nose...almost like Richebourg in style!...medium-bodied with saturated, silky smooth tannins...great purity on the long and tender finish. This is very tempting and sensual " WA 12/ bottles per lot US$ Vosne-Romanée Les Beaux Monts Domaine Leroy 2013 Côte de Nuits, Premier Cru three with signs of old seepage "This could turn out to be one of the domaine's finest 2014s...certainly one of Lalou Bize-Leroy's finest Premier Crus " WA 12/ bottles per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com

99 Chambertin Domaine Leroy 2014 "This is a remarkable wine in many respects but the one that perhaps stands out the most is how it can be so amazingly powerful yet refined, graceful and impeccably wellbalanced. Wow...97." BH 1/ bottle per lot US$ Clos de Vougeot Domaine Leroy 2014 "The dusty, intense and well-muscled big-bodied flavors are shaped by very firm but relatively sophisticated tannins on the well-balanced and youthfully austere finale that exhibits simply huge length...95." BH 1/ bottle per lot US$ Clos de la Roche Domaine Leroy 2014 "...power and muscle, all wrapped in a moderately austere and impressively persistent finish where the power really builds from the mid-palate...95." BH 1/ bottle per lot US$ Richebourg Domaine Leroy 2014 "...very fine tannin, the focus and tension interwoven through every atom...the finish is surfeit with nervosité and tension so that is slips down the throat (guilty!) with so much ease. Wonderful -- one of the wines of the vintage " WA 12/ bottle per lot US$ Lots 691, 692, ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com 107

100 Lots 698 & ZACHYS tel fax zachys.com

101 ARMAND ROUSSEAU Chambertin Armand Rousseau cm, nicked, lightly bin-soiled and marked label "Perfumed...very rich and forward medium weight flavors of exceptional length...multiple, and consistent, notes...93." BH 5/ bottle per lot US$ Chambertin Armand Rousseau 2002 original carton "Profound aromas of raspberry and strawberry liqueur and sappy oak, with an almost honeyed sweetness " IWC 3/ bottles per lot US$12,000-18,000 Chambertin Armand Rousseau 2013 "Layers of flavor continue to open up in the glass in a sublime, textured wine that captures the truest essence of what Burgundy is all about. The pulsating, vibrant finish is classic " AG 4/ bottles per lot US$ Griotte-Chambertin Domaine Ponsot 2001 two 6-pack s "There is really lovely detail and plenty of minerality on the strikingly intense medium weight flavors...92." BH 1/ bottles per lot US$ Bonnes-Mares JF Mugnier 2009 "Layers of fruit flow effortlessly as this powerful, rich Burgundy shows off its pedigree...a thrill a minute, with its intense energy and pure freshness...94." WA 4/ bottles per lot US$ Chambertin Clos de Bèze Faiveley 2009 "Compelling aromas...rich, full and serious broad-shouldered flavors brimming with dry extract and supported by impressively refined and ripe tannins...terrific " BH 1/ bottles per lot US$ Clos de Tart Domaine du Clos de Tart 2009 one 6-pack "...considerable volume and depth...intense, powerful finish. There is more than enough depth and pure pedigree to allow the 2009 to enjoy a long life in the cellar " WA 4/ bottles per lot US$ Musigny JF Mugnier 2010 "...deep, full-bodied, pure and utterly seamless, with great depth and intensity hidden behind its supreme façade of refined elegance and weightless beauty...wine simply does not get any better than this! " JBG 12/ bottle per lot US$ Echézeaux Emmanuel Rouget bottles per lot US$ Chambertin Clos de Bèze Les Ouvrées Rodin Faiveley 2012 "The large-scaled flavors are also more concentrated with seemingly endless reserves of palate staining dry extract... This is stunningly good with massive potential though again " BH 1/ bottles per lot US$ Clos de la Roche Anne & Sebastien Bidault 2012 two lightly scuffed labels bottles per lot US$ Clos de la Roche Vieilles Vignes Domaine Ponsot 2012 in original carton "This is a big wine even by the out-sized standards of a great Clos de la Roche yet the balance is faultless. This should be great in time " BH 1/ bottles per lot US$ Clos de Vougeot Petit Maupertui Benjamin Leroux 2012 original carton bottles per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com 109

102 Vosne-Romanée Aux Malconsorts Dujac 2012 Côte de Nuits, Premier Cru two 3-pack s...sophisticated...great clarity...a core a sweetness that lends this real personality and wonderful poise on the finish. Lovely WA 12/ magnums (1.5L) per lot US$ Musigny Vieilles Vignes Comte Georges de Vogüé 2013 "This is breathtaking in just how much power and intensity it packs yet there isn't a hair out of place. In a word, 'wow'! " BH 1/ magnums (1.5L) per lot US$ Chambertin Clos de Bèze Vieille Vigne Jean-Marie Fourrier 2013 one scuffed label "...good freshness and a lovely inner mouth perfume to the very spicy and mineral-driven big-bodied flavors...i like the balance and the underlying material " BH 1/ magnums (1.5L) per lot US$ Vosne-Romanée Les Malconsorts Sylvain Cathiard 2013 Côte de Nuits, Premier Cru original carton "A brooding and ultra-fresh nose...this is a big and robust effort...plenty of punch and power on the overtly mineral-driven and hugely long finish...textbook Malconsorts " BH 1/ bottles per lot US$ Chambolle-Musigny Les Amoureuses Comte Georges de Vogüé 2013 Côte de Nuits, Premier Cru "...ultra-refined and strikingly pure...positively crystalline in its purity and this is an absolute knockout " BH 1/ magnums (1.5L) per lot US$ Clos de Tart Domaine du Clos de Tart 2013 "I like the subtle combination of power and refinement. Refined or not however note that plenty of patience will be required before this reaches its full apogee...94." BH 1/ bottles per lot US$ Clos de Vougeot Henri Boillot bottles per lot US$ La Romanée Liger-Belair 2013 one lightly nicked label "...it remains a show-stopping wine opening page one of a long future...98." WA 6/ bottles per lot US$ ,000 Bonnes-Mares Georges Roumier 2014 "...very well structured, linear and strict...driving acidity here maintaining the freshness with superb minerality on the finish. Oh yes. Yes. Yes. Yes " WA 12/ bottles per lot US$ Chambolle-Musigny Les Cras Georges Roumier 2014 Côte de Nuits, Premier Cru original carton "...a strict and quite compelling bouquet...the deep and bewitching finish. The kind of wine that makes you pause for thought " WA 12/ bottles per lot US$ Gevrey-Chambertin Clos St Jacques Vieille Vigne Domaine Fourrier 2014 Côte de Nuits, Premier Cru one 6-pack original carton vines planted in 1910 "...very well balanced with filigree tannin, extremely detailed, precise and focused, fanning out wonderfully with fabulous intensity and sophistication. Oh yes! " WA 12/ bottles per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com

103 Musigny Louis Jadot 2014 "...a pure, enticing, quite regal bouquet...very well judged acidity and tangible mineralité, especially on the precise finish that carries enormous persistence as it fans out " WA 12/ bottles per lot US$ Musigny Vieilles Vignes Comte Georges de Vogüé 2014 "...deep, full-bodied and very energetic...fine-grained tannins and lovely focus and grip on the long and perfectly balanced finish " JBG 12/ magnums (1.5L) per lot US$ Chapelle-Chambertin Louis Jadot 2015 one 6-pack "...refined with grippy tannin and a commendable sense of energy and tension. The salinity comes through on the finish and lends this Grand Cru fine sappiness, urging you back for another sip " WA 12/ bottles per lot US$ Gevrey-Chambertin Clos St Jacques Vieille Vigne Domaine Fourrier 2015 Côte de Nuits, Premier Cru vines planted in 1910 "The palate is medium-bodied with very fine tannin... harmonious and sustained finish. The class shows through here " WA 12/ bottles per lot US$ La Grande Rue Lamarche 2015 "The palate is medium-bodied with fine definition. There is superb tension on the entry and conspicuous salinity here " WA 12/ bottles per lot US$ Musigny Joseph Faiveley 2015 bottle #51 "This is impressive but it's exceptionally ripe, indeed to the point where there isn't quite the same vivacity compared to the other Grands Crus in the range. Still, if your taste runs to lavishly opulent and seductive Musigny, this is one to hunt for " BH 1/ magnum (1.5L) per lot US$ ,000 Musigny Vieilles Vignes Comte Georges de Vogüé 2015 "...fantastically good length on the youthfully austere, backward and immaculately well-balanced finale. This too is going to require a very long snooze in a very cool cellar but it should be a remarkable Musigny when it emerges " BH 1/ magnums (1.5L) per lot US$ Corton-Charlemagne Maison Leroy 1989 Côte de Beaune, Grand Cru 1cm, lightly marked label bottle per lot US$ Gevrey-Chambertin Les Goulots Vieille Vigne Domaine Fourrier 2015 Côte de Nuits, Premier Cru The mouth feel of the precise, intense and much more mineral-driven medium weight flavors is notably finer though they don't possess the same richness or seductive texture, all wrapped in a saline and impressively persistent finish BH 1/ magnums (1.5L) per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com 111

104 Montrachet Comtes Lafon 2006 Côte de Beaune, Grand Cru "...textured, sweet, powerful, robust and almost painfully intense full-bodied flavors that possess a textured mouth feel yet retain excellent precision and cut as well " BH 7/ bottle per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com

105 Puligny-Montrachet Les Pucelles Domaine Leflaive 2011 Côte de Beaune, Premier Cru one nicked label "Lean and athletic, presenting a firm yet refined structure and a long finish of citrus and mineral. The oak is beautifully integrated...94." WS 9/ bottles per lot US$ Bourgogne Blanc Comte Georges de Vogüé 2012 Côte de Nuits "It is well defined and very complex. The palate is very intense...an exuberant, pithy, spicy finish that you will not forget in a hurry." WA 12/ bottles per lot US$ Corton-Charlemagne Faiveley 2012 Côte de Beaune, Grand Cru bottles per lot US$ Bienvenues-Bâtard-Montrachet Domaine Leflaive 2013 Côte de Beaune, Grand Cru "On the palate the wine is full-bodied, focused and very tightly-knit, with excellent length and grip on the backend, fine focus and plenty of backend energy " JBG 12/ magnums (1.5L) per lot US$ Bienvenues-Bâtard-Montrachet Pernot 2013 Côte de Beaune, Grand Cru original carton bottles per lot US$ Chablis Butteaux Raveneau 2014 Chablis, Premier Cru "The palate is focused and linear with great precision, real intensity here with a compelling sense of salinity. The detail on the finish is just startlingly fresh and shimmering. Watch out for this once in bottle " WA 8/ bottles per lot US$ Chevalier-Montrachet Bouchard Père et Fils 2014 Côte de Beaune, Grand Cru "A very classy, gripping 2014 with a long, vibrant finish featuring citrus fruits, flowers and minerals " IWC 9/ bottles per lot US$ Meursault Domaine Roulot 2014 Côte de Beaune original carton bottles per lot US$ RHÔNE Côte-Rôtie Château d Ampuis Guigal 1999 Rhône two 6-pack s one lightly damp-stained label, one lightly scuffed label bottles per lot US$ Châteauneuf-du-Pape Cuvée da Capo Pegau 2003 Rhône lightly scuffed label, signs of old seepage "Frightfully concentrated with layers of glycerin and fruit, it should prove to be one of the appellation's greatest classics...an enormously endowed, hugely concentrated, exhilarating effort " WA 2/ methuselah (6L) per lot US$ Ermitage Le Pavillon Chapoutier 2005 Rhône two 6-pack s "...a tremendous intensity and a full-bodied power and richness that is awesome. These are monumental wines...98." WA 2/ bottles per lot US$ Châteauneuf-du-Pape Clos des Papes 2007 Rhône Lot 744: one with signs of old seepage, with damaged lid Lot 745: original carton "Full-bodied, intense and beautifully concentrated, with plenty of muscle and depth, it shows the hallmark elegance and purity of the estate " WA 2/ bottles per lot US$ magnums (1.5L) per lot US$ Châteauneuf-du-Pape Clos des Papes 2010 Rhône bottles per lot US$ Hermitage La Chapelle Jaboulet 2015 Rhône Lot 747: two 6-pack s Lot 748: individual s "Richly concentrated and full-bodied, it hits all the expected notes cassis, black olive, smoke, crushed stone, pencil shavings and espresso then finishes long, with an aristocratic sense of reserve and austerity...98." WA 12/ bottles per lot US$ magnums (1.5L) per lot US$ Musigny Blanc Comte Georges de Vogüé magnum (1.5L) per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com 113

106 CHAMPAGNE Charles Heidsieck Blanc de Blancs Millenaires 1995 Champagne two 6-pack original cartons bottles per lot US$ Jacques Selosse Brut Substance NV Champagne disgorged on May 4, 2016 "Even with all of the richness and depth, there is no sense of heaviness at all...one of the world's truly great wines...98." WA 11/ bottles per lot US$ ITALY GIACOMO CONTERNO Barolo Monfortino Riserva Giacomo Conterno 2001 Piedmont "...dense, pure and intense to the core...it is majestic though...there is so much to look forward to...98." AG 5/ bottles per lot US$ Barolo Monfortino Riserva Giacomo Conterno 2005 Piedmont "Full-bodied, with super fine tannins and a great elegance. You can drink now but will age for ages...98." JS 7/ bottles per lot US$ Barolo Monfortino Riserva Giacomo Conterno 2006 Piedmont "The 2006 is one of the most tannic Monfortinos in recent memory, right up there with the 1999 and Conterno fans will not want to miss this riveting, Barolo, a wine with few peers, some of them sitting in the Conterno cellar still unbottled " AG 10/ bottles per lot US$ Barolo Monfortino Riserva Giacomo Conterno 2008 Piedmont Lot 755: individual s "It's full-bodied yet compacted and tight. Tannins are perfectly managed. It makes you want to drink it now with its balance and finesse. All in harmony...so fabulous and so perfect now. Why wait? But will age for decades...99." JS 9/ bottles per lot US$ magnums (1.5L) per lot US$ ,000 Barolo Cascina Francia Giacomo Conterno 2009 Piedmont original carton bottles per lot US$ Barolo Monfortino Riserva Giacomo Conterno 2010 Piedmont "That explosive start is followed by a mounting crescendo of complexity and nuance. The wine is extremely silky and polished in terms of mouthfeel and this helps to underline its impressive persistence. Bravo! " WA 6/ bottles per lot US$ Barolo Francia Giacomo Conterno 2011 Piedmont original carton bottles per lot US$ Barolo Francia Giacomo Conterno 2012 Piedmont original carton "Full to medium body with a compacted center palate. A tight ball of ripe, fine tannins. Minerals and hot stones underneath. Serious structure. No Monfortino was made so it's all here...98." JS 10/ bottles per lot US$ Barolo Bricco Bussia Vigna Cicala Aldo Conterno 1978 Piedmont three 2cm or better, two 2.5cm, one 3cm bottles per lot US$ Barolo Bricco Bussia Vigna Colonnello Aldo Conterno 1978 Piedmont two 2cm or better, four 2.5cm bottles per lot US$ Barolo Per Cristina Clerico 2004 Piedmont two 6-pack s bottles per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com

107 Lots 754, 755 & 757 ZACHYS tel fax zachys.com 115

108 Brunello di Montalcino II Greppo Riserva Biondi Santi 2004 Tuscany bottles per lot US$ Brunello di Montalcino Riserva Case Basse Soldera 2005 Tuscany "It is a pretty wine with gorgeous inner perfume and fine overall balance...92." WA 4/ bottles per lot US$ Barolo Riserva Gran Bussia Aldo Conterno 2006 Piedmont one 3-pack "...augmented by intense flavors and a juicy texture. Long, complete and complex, offering beautifully integrated tannins...97." WS 11/ bottles per lot US$ Brunello di Montalcino II Greppo Riserva Biondi Santi 2006 Tuscany bottles per lot US$ Brunello di Montalcino Biondi Santi 2008 Tuscany bottles per lot US$ Brunello di Montalcino Riserva Biondi Santi 2008 Tuscany original carton "It renders a stirring, melodic performance that plays out slowly but with determination...94." WA 2/ bottles per lot US$ Toscana IGT Case Basse di Gianfranco Soldera 2009 Tuscany The tannins remain quite imposing, but I am inclined to think the 2009 will open up earlier than is typically the case here...it is fascinating to taste AG 2/ bottles per lot US$ magnums (1.5L) per lot US$ Barolo Brunate Giuseppe Rinaldi 2010 Piedmont "I can't wait to taste the 2010 once it has been bottled. From cask, the component wines are insanely vivid and thrilling. This is the essence of Barolo " AG 1/ double magnum (3L) per lot US$ Barolo Cicala Aldo Conterno 2010 Piedmont two 6-pack original cartons "...imparts deep textural richness with lovely finesse and structural integrity. Hold this wine for ten years or more. Its profound beauty is already evident, but the wine has barely started its evolutionary course...97." WA 7/ bottles per lot US$ Barolo Rocche Vietti 2010 Piedmont "Stunning in the glass and impeccable throughout, the 2010 Rocche is firing on all cylinders. Sweet rose petals, mint, spices and licorice are woven into the breathtaking, perfumed finish...99." AG 1/ bottles per lot US$ Brunello di Montalcino Biondi Santi 2010 Tuscany two 6-pack original cartons "...a real knock-out...almost indescribably beautiful, the 2010 is a classic...constantly changes in the glass, revealing different shades of its multi-faceted personality, while the long, saline-infused finish is a thing of real beauty...96." AG 2/ bottles per lot US$ Brunello di Montalcino Casanova di Neri Tenuta Nuova 2010 Tuscany individual s "The tannins reach a level of suppleness that is almost impossible to find...collectors will want to put this wine aside ten years or longer " WA 2/ magnums (1.5L) per lot US$ Brunello di Montalcino Cerbaiona 2010 Tuscany two 6-pack original cartons "An utterly stunning, sensual wine, the 2010 constantly changes in the glass as it conquers all the senses with an exotic kaleidoscope of aromas, flavors and textures...will leave readers weak at the knees. It is every bit that profound " AG 2/ bottles per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com

109 Brunello di Montalcino Madonna delle Grazie Il Marroneto 2010 Tuscany Lot 777: original carton Lot 778: banded "The tannins are firm and linear, adding a great sense of support at the back and lingering persistency. The wine is profoundly beautiful today and shows all the criteria necessary for 20 years or more of cellar aging " WA 2/ bottles per lot US$ double magnum (3L) per lot US$ Brunello di Montalcino Poggio di Sotto 2010 Tuscany Lot 779: one 6-pack original carton Lot 780: individual s "It shows decadence yet class and subtlety that only the great 2010 vintage can give it. Full body, ultra-fine tannins and layers of berries, plums, peaches and cedar. The finish lasts for minutes. Why wait on this? Open it and enjoy the magic...98." JS 8/ bottles per lot US$ magnums (1.5L) per lot US$ Brunello di Montalcino Rennina Pieve Santa Restituta Gaja 2010 Tuscany four 6-pack s bottles per lot US$ Brunello di Montalcino Salvioni Cerbaiola 2010 Tuscany individual s "You taste the most elegant, delicate and ethereal notes that can be extracted from Sangiovese. The tannins are super fine and the texture is silky and supple. This is an iconic wine...98." WA 3/ magnums (1.5L) per lot US$ Ornellaia 25th Anniversary 2010 Tuscany banded individual s in individual original cartons "The wine magically transitions from cherry, spice, chocolate and espresso in one melodic and continuous loop. It exudes balance and elegance over long, delicious minutes. It is profoundly impressive " WA 8/ magnums (1.5L) per lot US$ Solaia Antinori 2010 Tuscany two 6-pack s Parcel: lots 788 & 789 "A triumph for Solaia. It suggests the greatness of the legendary 1997 Solaia. This is a wine with very subtle and complex aromas...wonderful nose. Full body, with ultrafine tannins and a long, long finish. It lasts for minutes on the palate. Love this wine...98." JS 9/ bottles per lot US$ bottles per lot US$ Brunello di Montalcino Riserva Madonna del Piano Valdicava 2010 Tuscany Lot 782: "A wine with superb finesse and depth. So subtle and understated yet powerful and long. The tannin intensity is amazing. It just builds like a massive wave. Superb. Give this time in the bottle. The length is endless " JS 10/ bottles per lot US$ bottles per lot US$ magnums (1.5L) per lot US$ Brunello di Montalcino Riserva Poggio di Sotto 2010 Tuscany two 6-pack original cartons "Shows superb complexity in terms of aromas with cedar, berry, ginger, flower and plum character. Full body and firm and very silky tannins that have been polished to near perfect. This wine just gets better and better with each sip...98." JS 10/ bottles per lot US$ Matarocchio Guado Al Tasso 2011 Tuscany two 3-pack s, one 6-pack original wood case "The mouthfeel is penetrating and powerful, but seamless and silky smooth at the same time. The tannin management is excellent. This is one to keep in the cellar...97." WA 10/ bottles per lot US$ Solaia Antinori 2011 Tuscany two 6-pack Parcel: lots 791 & 792 "A big, rich wine but there's lots of brightness and beauty at the same time. Shows licorice and asphalt. Full body with chewy tannins and a long finish. Terracotta, Tuscan dust and spice; balsamic too...intense finish...96." JS 9/ bottles per lot US$ bottles per lot US$ Masseto 2012 Tuscany "Full body, a wonderful concentration of fruit yet tense and taunt energy...99." JS 8/ bottles per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com 117

110 Sassicaia 2012 (6) banded 2012 magnums (3) 794 above 6 bottles & 3 magnums (1.5L) per lot US$ Barolo Ravera Vietti 2013 Piedmont "I have tasted and followed the 2013 Ravera for a number of years. It has never been anything less than thrilling. It is all that and more today. Readers who can find the 2013 should not hesitate, as it is tremendous " AG 2/ bottles per lot US$ Masseto 2013 Tuscany banded "Full body, ultra-fine tannins and very long. So gorgeous and persistent. It goes on for minutes...98." JS 7/ magnum (1.5L) per lot US$ Sassicaia 2013 Tuscany one 6-pack banded, one 6-pack original wood case with damaged lid "Fabulous structure for a Sassicaia with powerful, polished, chewy tannins and ripe, subtle fruit. Aromas of blueberry, black currant, rosemary and lavender. Full body, bright acidity and a savory finish. Juicy and lively...98." JS 2/ bottles per lot US$ Biondi Santi Brunello di Montalcino Annata 12 Bottle Collector Case Cassette Stampa Tuscany original wood assortment case three bottles each case per lot US$ SPAIN Vega Sicilia Único 1965 Ribera del Duero very top shoulder, slightly depressed cork "The palate was beautifully balanced...leads to an almost Port-like finish with hints of kirsch. There is a sense of completeness to the 1965 that is irresistible...94." WA 8/ magnum (1.5L) per lot US$ CALIFORNIA Colgin IX Estate Red 2006 "With extraordinary intensity, beautiful purity, a texture and flavors that build incrementally on the palate, and a significantly long finish, this is a perfect wine " WA 12/ bottles per lot US$ Kongsgaard The Judge Chardonnay 2009 original carton "Billowing and weightless on entry, then builds inexorably in the middle palate...finishes with outstanding grip... California chardonnay doesn't get any better than this--and very little Burgundy can equal it either " IWC 6/ bottles per lot US$ Joseph Phelps Vineyards Insignia 2010 two 6-pack s "The tannins are sweet, layered and impeccably balanced, which makes me think the 2010 will enjoy a long drinking window once it softens. The 2010 is a beautiful, silky Insignia " AG 11/ bottles per lot US$ Barolo Riserva Gran Bussia Aldo Conterno 1999 magnums (2) Liter (1) 2001 double magnum (1) 799 above 2 magnums (1.5L), 1 double magnum (3L) & one 5 liter (5L) per lot US$ Lail Vineyards J. Daniel Cuvée Cabernet Sauvignon 2011 two 6-pack original cartons bottles per lot US$ Bevan Cellars Sugarloaf Mountain Red 2012 "...perfect wine...great intensity, remarkable unctuosity and thickness, and perfect integration of acidity, alcohol, tannin and wood " WA 10/ bottles per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com

111 Caymus Vineyards Special Selection Cabernet Sauvignon 2012 two 6-pack s "Full-bodied and opulent with stunning concentration and richness, the wine has no hard edges and is much in the Caymus style of terrific fruit intensity...96." WA 12/ bottles per lot US$ Dalla Valle Vineyards Maya 2012 two 3-pack s "...surprisingly deep and powerful in this vintage...dark and brooding, with tons of intensity to match its massive, virile personality. Readers will have to be patient, but the 2012 is a special wine that much is clear " AG 10/ bottles per lot US$ Diamond Creek Vineyards Red Rock Terrace Cabernet Sauvignon 2012 two 6-pack s Impressive aromas...full body, velvety and soft cashmeretextured tannins. It's very structured. Need at least five to six years to come together but a fabulous wine. Greatest Red Rock ever?...99." JS 7/ bottles per lot US$ Dominus Estate 2012 two 6-pack s "Another candidate that flirts with perfection...explosively rich fruit, lots of glycerin, a full-bodied mouthfeel and a pungent, penetrating intensity that goes on and on in the mouth " WA 11/ bottles per lot US$ Lail Vineyards J. Daniel Cuvée Cabernet Sauvignon 2012 two 6-pack original cartons one lightly marked label "Absolutely perfect and one of the monumental wines... amazing bouquet...superb purity, an incremental, yet fullbodied mouthfeel, and an extravagant, layered texture and finish make for the finest wine Robin Lail has produced to date at her winery " WA 10/ bottles per lot US$ Lokoya Mount Veeder Cabernet Sauvignon 2012 Mount Veeder "...as compelling a Cabernet Sauvignon as one could ever hope to taste...magnificent fruit richness, a layered, fullbodied mouthfeel, and incredible length...seamlessly constructed..100." WA 10/ bottles per lot US$ Opus One 2012 two 6-pack s "Glorious purity of fruit here...full body, seamless tannins and wonderful balance. Tight and compacted tannins with beautiful fruit and great length...97." JS 7/ bottles per lot US$ Realm Cellars Beckstoffer Dr. Crane Cabernet Sauvignon 2012 includes 6-pack original carton "...a dense, opulent, full-bodied mouthfeel, and a staggeringly long, multidimensional, 60-second finish. It can be drunk with enormous pleasure now, but promises to evolve for at least a quarter of a century " WA 10/ bottles per lot US$ Realm Cellars Beckstoffer To-Kalon Cabernet Sauvignon 2012 one 6-pack original carton, includes one 6-pack original carton "...incredible complexity and density...full-bodied with the vintage's opulence and drama " WA 10/ bottles per lot US$ Realm Cellars The Bard 2012 original carton "...ostentatious, flamboyant, classic, locked-and-loaded Cabernet Sauvignon. There is some tannin lurking under the surface, but this majestic superstar behaves as if it wants to be drunk young as well as over the next years...99." WA 10/ bottles per lot US$ Shafer Vineyards Hillside Select Cabernet Sauvignon 2012 Stag's Leap District "This is a beauty...no doubt this is a 30- to 50-year wine if you want to cellar it properly and nibble on it over a long period of time...a fabulous effort " WA 12/ bottles per lot US$ Stags Leap Wine Cellars Cask 23 Cabernet Sauvignon 2012 two 6-pack original cartons bottles per lot US$ Caymus Vineyards Special Selection Cabernet Sauvignon 2013 two 6-pack s bottles per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com 119

112 Corison Kronos Cabernet Sauvignon bottles per lot US$ Harlan Estate 2013 "It is probably closest in personality and overall character to the compelling 2001, which is still a youthful wine at age 15. Drink it over the next 50+ years " WA 10/ bottles per lot US$ magnums (1.5L) per lot US$ Opus One 2013 Lot 822: Lot 823: two 6-pack s "Beautifully full-bodied and extraordinarily elegant and pure, this is certainly one of their great achievements over the last 37 years. The wine has an exquisite finish and can be drunk now or cellared for years...97." WA 12/ bottles per lot US$ bottles per lot US$ Philip Togni Napa Cabernet Sauvignon 2013 original carton "...easily the greatest young Philip Togni wine I have ever tasted...magnificent and one of the wines of the vintage " AG 10/ bottles per lot US$ Realm Cellars Beckstoffer Dr. Crane Cabernet Sauvignon 2013 includes 6-pack original carton "A wine of great intensity, depth and richness, if somehow Bordeaux's Haut-Brion were injected with steroids, it might taste like this monumental effort from Napa. This is pure perfection and should drink well young as well as 30 years from now " WA 12/ bottles per lot US$ Realm Cellars The Bard 2013 original carton "This seamless work of vinous haute couture is staggeringly rich, very long...this is a killer effort that's already showing enormous complexity " WA 12/ bottles per lot US$ Schrader RBS Beckstoffer To Kalon Vineyard Cabernet Sauvignon 2013 "It hits the palate with a seamless integration of wood, tannin, acidity and alcohol and has tremendous opulence and palate presence in its full-bodied, long finish...98." WA 10/ bottles per lot US$ Schrader "Old Sparky" Beckstoffer To Kalon Vineyard Cabernet Sauvignon 2013 magnum (1) 2014 magnum (1) 829 above 2 magnums (1.5L) per lot US$ AUSTRALIA Penfolds Grange 2002 South Australia "Lithe, almost subtle, this is a dense, powerful wine... Finishes with vibrant acidity that elevates the fruit and spice...95." WS 9/ bottles per lot US$ Penfolds Grange 2010 South Australia "...mouth-coating density and terrific drive, so tightly coiled...classic Grange that will please the serious collectors. A wine of genuine pedigree " JS 10/ bottles per lot US$ Torbreck The Laird 2010 Australia "...extraordinary perfume...full-bodied, rich, concentrated...the generous fruit is structured with velvety tannins and just enough freshness. It finishes with commendable persistence " WA 6/ bottles per lot US$ Powell & Son Brennecker Grenache 2015 Barossa Valley two 6-pack s "Full-bodied, rich and opulent in the mouth, the palate is silken-textured with seductive flavor layers and wonderful poise, finishing long and spicy...98." WA 2/ bottles per lot US$ Scarecrow Cabernet Sauvignon 2013 two 3-pack s "It is dense, full-bodied, prodigiously rich, massive in intensity, yet relatively light on its feet. This great ballerina of a wine has extraordinary ripeness but pulls back from the edge before going over the top " WA 12/ bottles per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com

113 A WIDE ARRAY OF FINE WINES from a REPEAT CONSIGNOR (LOTS ) From one of our favorite American Cellars comes this fine array of gems. From 2000 Bordeaux from numerous chateaux, to the Burgundies of Dujac, Roumier, Leroy, Roty, Bouchard, and Fourrier. Bouchard's La Romanée 1999 is a highlight, as is Rousseau's Chambertin Chave and Giacosa round out this selection with excellent wines from 2001 and 1998, which should be entering a drinking window. All wines were removed from a NY area professional wine storage facility. Lots 838 & 839 ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com 121

114 BORDEAUX Château L'Evangile 2000 Pomerol "Dense, rich, and full-bodied, with an opulence and succulence that are prodigious, the tannins are present but extremely sweet...98." WA 6/ bottles per lot US$ Château La Conseillante 2000 Pomerol "Full-bodied yet ethereal in the sense that it seems to combine power along with eloquence and delicacy, this is a beautifully pure wine that has just hit its plateau of full maturity...96." WA 6/ bottles per lot US$ Château Pavie 2000 St Émilion, Premier Grand Cru Classé (a) one scuffed label "...stunningly rich nose...fabulously concentrated and fullbodied, with a multidimensional mouthfeel " WA 8/ bottles per lot US$ Château Pavie Decesse 2000 St Émilion, Grand Cru Classé bottles per lot US$ BURGUNDY DUJAC Clos de la Roche Dujac 1999 "Slightly austere with a mineral essence that tends to suppress the pinot baby fat lurking beneath the surface. The potential here is enormous...93." BH 2/ bottles per lot US$ Clos St Denis Dujac 1999 one lightly scuffed label "On the palate the wine is full-bodied, deep and complex, with fine depth at the core " JBG 1/ magnums (1.5L) per lot US$22,000-32,000 Clos St Denis Dujac 2000 "Relatively thick and rich for the vintage with plenty of pinot baby fat. Wonderfully expressive " BH 1/ bottles per lot US$ Bonnes-Mares Dujac 2001 "Austere, backward and brooding nose of red and black fruit, crushed herbs and a touch of earth and leather with full, complex, driving, muscular and very powerful flavors...possess outstanding persistence...93." BH 1/ bottles per lot US$ Clos de la Roche Dujac 2001 "...explode from the glass that merge seamlessly into bigger, richer, rounder and more muscular flavors. Authoritative, gorgeously textured and very stylish...93." BH 1/ bottles per lot US$ Clos St Denis Dujac 2001 "...stunningly precise and pure flavor profile of abundant mineral notes and a chalky, slightly dusty finish. There is a really lovely mouth feel as the flavors are velvety and mouth coating...93." BH 1/ bottles per lot US$ Charmes-Chambertin Dujac 2002 "A beautifully elegant yet altogether serious effort that also finishes with a touch of warmth and a very subtle hint of wood...92." BH 1/ bottles per lot US$ Bonnes-Mares Georges Roumier cm or better, one heavily bin-soiled label, heavily dampstained labels, two lightly bin-soiled labels, one torn label "The big but detailed flavors are somewhat austere but the underlying depth of the medium full flavors plus the sheer length suggest that this will mature into a terrific wine." BH 10/ bottles per lot US$ Vosne-Romanée Les Beaux Monts Domaine Leroy 1991 Côte de Nuits, Premier Cru bin-soiled label bottle per lot US$ Chambertin Armand Rousseau 1999 one lightly torn capsule Gorgeous but rather reticent aromas featuring dried mulberry and rhubarb; lots of dry extract, chewy texture, moderately tannic, imposingly regal...outstanding plus. FH bottles per lot US$ , ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com

115 Lot 847 ZACHYS tel fax zachys.com 123

116 Lot ZACHYS tel fax zachys.com

117 Chambertin Clos de Bèze Faiveley 1999 one scuffed label "Fat, thick and stuffed with fruit...finishes with extremely suave tannins and great resounding length and sweetness " IWC 3/ bottles per lot US$ Bonnes-Mares Georges Roumier 2000 two different importers "...ripe, pure and nicely complex that merges into detailed, balanced and harmonious flavors...built more along the lines of a thoroughbred than a robust draft horse...91." BH 4/ bottles per lot US$ ,000 Charmes-Chambertin Cuvée Trés Vieilles Vignes Joseph Roty 1999 "...extraordinarily concentrated, powerful, and chewy-textured...extremely expressive and last throughout its unbelievably long, thick, and sweet finish " WA 8/ bottles per lot US$ La Romanée Bouchard Père et Fils 1999 "The intensity of this wine is dialed way up...fine, dusty tannins that create a massively structured wine that somehow remains in perfect balance...96." BH 4/ bottles per lot US$ Pommard Maison Leroy 1999 Côte de Beaune bottles per lot US$ Gevrey-Chambertin Clos St Jacques Vieille Vigne Domaine Fourrier 2000 Côte de Nuits, Premier Cru vines planted in bottles per lot US$ Griotte-Chambertin Vieille Vigne Domaine Fourrier 2000 one lightly nicked label vines planted in bottles per lot US$ Musigny Georges Roumier 2000 "This finishes with tremendous length and intensity. Quite structured but the sap tends to bury it. Extremely impressive...93." BH 1/ bottles per lot US$12,000-18,000 Richebourg Gros Frère et Sœur 1999 "Silky mid-palate reveals the pedigree of this wine. Loaded with sweet blackberry character that goes on to a long finish...93." WS 2/ bottles per lot US$ Romanée-St-Vivant JJ Confuron 1999 "Medium to full-bodied and extremely spicy, this wine is packed with blackberries and black cherries. It is refined yet firm and highly structured..." WA 8/ bottles per lot US$ Musigny JF Mugnier 2000 "...medium-full, long, pure and transparent, with lovely intensity of flavor, an excellent core of fruit, superb focus and balance...a profound expression of terroir " JBG 12/ bottles per lot US$ Bonnes-Mares JF Mugnier 2001 "...a fine sense of balance and outstanding length. Mouth coating, precise and very fresh...91." BH 1/ bottles per lot US$ Volnay Clos des Ducs Marquis d'angerville 1999 Côte de Beaune, Premier Cru "...marvellous nose...gorgeously balanced, and possesses outstanding depth of velvety-textured fruit...extraordinarily long, pure, and silky finish " WA 6/ bottles per lot US$ Charmes-Chambertin Hubert Lignier bottles per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com 125

118 Echézeaux Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 2001 one lightly wine-stained label, one with signs of old seepage "...expressive, full, pure, sweet and quite powerful flavors and a long, persistent, mouth coating finish...92." BH 1/ bottles per lot US$ ,000 Bonnes-Mares Louis Jadot 2002 "While enormously powerful and ripe, it magically retains its freshness and sports an ethereal quality that is difficult to put into words. It is a tour de force in winemaking! " WA 6/ bottles per lot US$ Chambolle-Musigny Les Amoureuses Louis Jadot 2002 Côte de Nuits, Premier Cru "...offers a nose of roasted dark berries, coffee, and herbs. Medium-bodied, powerful, and firm, its flavor profile is made up of espresso beans and blackberries." WA 6/ bottles per lot US$ Clos Vougeot Le Grand Maupertui Anne Gros 2002 "This is beautifully balanced and quite powerful on the finish, all wrapped in firm but fine tannins...92." BH 1/ bottles per lot US$ Richebourg Méo-Camuzet 2002 "Brooding, backward and tight but with more aromatic intensity...big, muscular and very powerful flavors and a huge amount of extract...95." BH 1/ bottles per lot US$ Romanée-St-Vivant Hudelot-Noëllat 2002 nicked label "A wine that is at once highly expressive yet a model of grace and understatement. In short, this is wonderfully classy juice " BH 1/ magnum (1.5L) per lot US$ RHÔNE Hermitage JL Chave 1999 Rhône "...fabulous texture, purity, and sweetness as well as a finish that lasts for nearly a minute...96." WA 4/ bottles per lot US$ Hermitage JL Chave 2001 Rhône one heavily damp-stained label "Great richness and texture here, with notes of tar, minerals, saddle leather and cocoa rippling through the finish. Mouthwatering acidity balances it all...95." WS 8/ bottles per lot US$ ITALY Barolo Falletto di Serralunga Riserva Bruno Giacosa 1996 Piedmont "This muscular, massive wine gave me chills. It is an exquisite, virtually perfect Barolo...Awesome!...98." WA 6/ magnums (1.5L) per lot US$ Barolo Le Rocche del Falletto di Serralunga Bruno Giacosa 1998 Piedmont two 6-pack s "Full-bodied, dense, and powerfully tannic, yet extremely harmonious " WA 10/ bottles per lot US$ Barolo Le Rocche del Falletto di Serralunga Bruno Giacosa 1999 Piedmont one lightly torn label "Offers amazing aromas of blueberry and raspberry, with hints of strawberry tart. Full-bodied, showing chewy, powerful tannins and plenty of fruit...95." WS bottles per lot US$ Vosne-Romanée Aux Brûlées Méo-Camuzet 2002 Côte de Nuits, Premier Cru one wrinkled label bottles per lot US$ Chablis Les Clos Raveneau 2000 Chablis, Grand Cru "The purity of expression here is nothing short of riveting with the classic assertive mineral character that suffuses the character of this wine...in short, this is breathtakingly good...95." BH 7/ bottles per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com

119 A CONCISE OFFERING OF MATURE ROUSSEAU (LOTS ) Purchased from various auction houses and removed from a professional wine storage facility. BURGUNDY Chambertin Armand Rousseau 1988 Lot 875: 1cm or better, torn and lightly scuffed labels Lot 876: 2cm or better, one lightly scuffed label, one nicked label, one loose capsule reveals fully branded cork "Bigger, richer and with better intensity plus a bit more mid-palate depth and weight...92." BH 7/ bottles per lot US$ bottles per lot US$ Chambertin Armand Rousseau cm, lightly bin-soiled labels, one lightly nicked label, one nicked label, signs of old seepage "Perfumed...very rich and forward medium weight flavors of exceptional length...multiple, and consistent, notes...93." BH 5/ bottles per lot US$ ,000 ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com 127

120 FINE LEROY AND OTHER MATURE GEMS (LOTS ) The joy in this collection comes from a perusal of the vintages on offer. Giroud from 1947 and Leroy Charmes from Loads of 1993s and 1990s from Ponsot and Comte Armand. For the treasure hunter seeking out rare Burgundy, look no further. Recent vintages were acquired on release and most older bottles were sourced from prominent auction companies. All the wines were removed from the collectors professional installed, temperature- and humidity-controlled home wine cellar. BORDEAUX LEROY Château Lafite Rothschild 1982 very top shoulder, lightly bin-soiled and damp-stained label "In the Pauillac lineup only one person correctly pegged this as Lafite. It was subdued and quiet compared to the other wines in this flight, even though it was doubledecanted well in advance. Tobacco and dark fruit notes on the palate, but slow to open..." SF bottle per lot US$ BURGUNDY CAMILLE GIROUD Charmes-Chambertin Maison Leroy 1985 one 1.5cm, three 2.5cm, three lightly bin-soiled labels, one nicked label bottles per lot US$ Volnay Lassolle Maison Leroy 1985 Côte de Beaune, Premier Cru 1.5cm or better, three damp-stained back labels, three wine-stained back labels, three nicked back labels, one damp-stained label, one lightly bin-soiled label, two nicked labels, two scuffed labels, three wine-stained labels bottles per lot US$ Corton Camille Giroud 1947 Côte de Beaune, Grand Cru 4cm, one heavily damp-stained label, two lightly dampstained labels, two torn labels bottles per lot US$ Richebourg Camille Giroud 1947 two 3.5cm, one 5.5cm, importer tags and tissue-paper adhered to heavily damp-stained labels bottles per lot US$ Musigny Camille Giroud cm, importer tags adhered to labels, two lightly dampstained labels, one lightly nicked label, one slightly depressed cork bottles per lot US$ Bonnes-Mares Camille Giroud 1959 one 2cm, two 3.5cm, two damp-stained labels, one lightly damp-stained label, one lightly nicked label, one with tissue-paper adhered to label, one with importer tag adhered to label bottles per lot US$ Clos de Vougeot Domaine Leroy 1993 slightly protruded cork "Sweet, ripe, red and black cherry flavors pick up a truffle accent as this builds on the palate. Fine richness, culminating in a long finish...95." WS bottle per lot US$ Pommard Les Vignots Domaine Leroy 1993 Côte de Beaune nine with importer tags adhered to labels, one lightly scuffed label bottles per lot US$ Vosne-Romanée Les Beaux Monts Domaine Leroy 1994 Côte de Nuits, Premier Cru one missing back label, one heavily damp-stained back label, two torn back labels, one wine-stained back label, one remnants of label, two damp-stained labels, two heavily damp-stained labels, one heavily torn label, one torn label, two depressed corks, two with signs of old seepage Powerful aromas of sweet peach and cherry, tannic on the palate, with a long, over-sized, massively extracted finish...excellent. FH bottles per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com

121 Clos de la Roche Domaine Leroy 1995 importer tag adhered to torn and heavily damp-stained label, tissue paper adhered to back label obscures bottle number, torn vintage tag "...its admirable fruit (so incredibly evident in its infancy) may well blossom in time to regain command of this offering...94." WA 10/ bottle per lot US$ Richebourg Domaine Leroy 1995 damp-stained vintage tag, torn and heavily damp-stained back label, tissue-paper adhered to heavily damp-stained label "...offers an impressively intricate, dark fruit, spice, and fresh herb-scented nose. This full-bodied, massively broad and concentrated wine is densely layered with blackberries and tar-like flavors. It is tightly wound, firmly structured, and intensely deep...96." WA 10/ bottle per lot US$ Vosne-Romanée Les Beaux Monts Domaine Leroy 1995 Côte de Nuits, Premier Cru three with importer tags adhered to labels, one lightly nicked label, lightly scuffed labels, two slightly depressed corks "Stylish and aristocratic yet down-to-earth, this full-bodied, exciting red starts out with great subtlety, then builds in intensity, concentration and complexity as it unfolds...92." WS 11/ bottles per lot US$ Clos de la Roche Vieilles Vignes Domaine Ponsot cm, lightly damp-stained and scuffed label "...beautifully expressive...big, rich, round and relatively elegant flavors...textured and gorgeous velvety and still tight finish. A very impressive wine...95." BH 11/ bottle per lot US$ Clos de la Roche Vieilles Vignes Domaine Ponsot 1991 damp-stained and lightly scuffed label "...big, full-bodied and powerful flavors of equal complexity that deliver truly extraordinary length. This is drinking perfectly now though there is enough structure that it could still be held...96." BH 3/ bottle per lot US$ Nuits St Georges Aux Murgers Méo-Camuzet 1991 Côte de Nuits, Premier Cru two with importer tags adhered to labels, one lightly scuffed label bottles per lot US$ Pommard Clos des Epeneaux Comte Armand 1993 Côte de Beaune, Premier Cru one lightly damp-stained label, three lightly scuffed labels "...fragrant on the nose...with scents of black fruit, balsam, black olive compote and wild mushroom almost New World in style..." WA 8/ bottles per lot US$ Nuits St Georges Domaine Leroy 1995 Aux Allots (3) wine-stained back labels, one heavily damp-stained label, two lightly glue-stained labels, lightly scuffed labels, slightly depressed corks Aux Lavieres (1) damp-stained back label, damp-stained and torn label 891 above 4 bottles per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com 129

122 SOMMELIER SELECTIONS (LOTS ) All wines removed from a temperature-controlled cellar in Europe. BORDEAUX BURGUNDY Château Léoville Las Cases 2009 St Julien, Deuxième Cru Classé Parcel: lots "It boasts an inky/purple color, monumental concentration and lots of sweet, jammy black currant, black cherry and kirsch fruit intermixed with crushed rock and mineral notes " WA 2/ bottles per lot US$ bottles per lot US$ bottles per lot US$ Vosne-Romanée Cros Parantoux Méo-Camuzet 2014 Côte de Nuits, Premier Cru missing vintage tags, loose capsules reveal fully branded corks "The palate is medium-bodied with filigree tannin, a fine seam of acidity, great depth and intensity on the finish that lingers long in the mouth. This is a classy Cros Parantoux, maybe the standout from the domaine this year " WA 12/ bottles per lot US$ Vosne-Romanée Les Chaumes Méo-Camuzet 2014 Côte de Nuits, Premier Cru "The spiciness continues onto the supple and seductively textured medium-bodied flavors that culminate in a delicious and lingering finish " BH 1/ bottles per lot US$ Corton-Charlemagne Coche-Dury 1996 Côte de Beaune, Grand Cru 4cm, loose capsule reveals vintage and producer branded cork "...minerality dominates the mid-palate and explodes like a grenade on the stupendously long finish. This is truly a great wine in every respect...97." BH 10/ bottle per lot US$ Liger-Belair 2013 original wood assortment case La Romanée (3) Vosne-Romanée La Colombiere (9) 902 above 12 bottles per lot US$ , ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com

123 FINE ROUMIER AND ROUSSEAU (LOTS ) These lots present the opportunity to acquire Rousseau, as well as an amazing Roumier vertical. All bottles have been stored in professional, temperature-controlled storage since acquisition. BURGUNDY GEORGES ROUMIER DOMAINE DE LA ROMANÉE-CONTI La Tâche Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 2014 "The fruit shades from red to more black as it opens, yet the aftertaste is extraordinarily long and persistent. There is a kind of magic in this La Tâche " WA 12/ bottles per lot US$ Romanée-Conti Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 2014 "...remarkably intense and beautifully well-detailed...stony, powerful, focused and explosively long finish that delivers sneaky good length...97." BH 1/ bottle per lot US$11,000-16,000 Romanée-St-Vivant Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 2014 "The refined and caressing middle weight flavors possess a sleek and cool mouth feel while retaining good definition...95." BH 1/ bottle per lot US$ SPECIALIST'S PICK: LOT 907 A must-have bottle of Burgundy. The stand out from a Roumier dinner last year at Vaucluse. Charles Antin Bonnes-Mares Georges Roumier 1999 marked and lightly torn label "...rich, broad, and expansive...silky-textured and leads to a long, black pepper-filled finish..." WA 8/ bottle per lot US$ Chambolle-Musigny Amoureuses Georges Roumier 1999 Côte de Nuits, Premier Cru "Absolute ink with lush, sexy, spicy violets and black fruits with velvet wrapped tannins and stunning depth...seamless from start to finish and a brilliant Amoureuses...94." BH 1/ bottle per lot US$ Bonnes-Mares Georges Roumier 2004 "...textured, sappy, firm and intense flavors that are both serious and more obviously structured " BH 1/ bottles per lot US$ Chambolle-Musigny Georges Roumier 2005 Côte de Nuits "...rich, precise and wonderfully fresh flavors that display a mineral streak on the energetic and persistent finish. A very attractive villages and recommended..." BH 1/ bottles per lot US$ Chambolle-Musigny Les Cras Georges Roumier 2005 Côte de Nuits, Premier Cru "...complex aromas...rich and intensely mineral-inflected medium full flavors that carry wonderful sense of underlying tension that focuses the precise and explosive finish " BH 1/ bottles per lot US$ Bonnes-Mares Georges Roumier 2007 "This is an impressive effort as it's tautly muscular with everything in perfect proportion...94." BH 1/ bottles per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com 131

124 Chambolle-Musigny Les Cras Georges Roumier 1999 (2) 2003 (2) 2004 (2) 2006 (3) 2007 (2) 2009 (1) 2010 (1) 2011 (1) 2012 (1) 2013 (1) 912 above 16 bottles per lot US$ ARMAND ROUSSEAU Chambertin Armand Rousseau cm, bin-soiled label "...pure and incredibly complex and elegant...sweet and quite intricate displaying Grand Cru richness and stupendous length...94." BH 12/ bottle per lot US$ Chambertin Clos de Bèze Armand Rousseau cm, bin-soiled label, signs of old seepage "Substantial, very full and expressive nose...intense, complex, large-scaled flavors, excellent length and Grand Cru finesse...92." BH 10/ bottle per lot US$ Gevrey-Chambertin Clos St Jacques Armand Rousseau 2000 Côte de Nuits, Premier Cru magnum (1.5L) per lot US$ Chambertin Armand Rousseau 2007 "...dusty, textured, precise and palate staining big-bodied flavors that are exceptionally tight on the linear but hugely long finish...94." BH 1/ magnum (1.5L) per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com

125 A SELECTION FROM A NORTHEAST BURGUNDY LOVER (LOTS ) This assemblage of lots below comes to us from a die-hard Burgundy lover who has been collecting wines for decades. He discovered early on that the wines of Burgundy were his true passion, particularly the wines of Domaine de la Romanée-Conti and Domaine Leroy and as such, stocked his cellar generously with wines from this region generally and these producers specifically. As he is generous with his bottles, Zachys specialists have had the privilege of sampling numerous bottles from his cellar. They all show terrific storage and amazing care and are great examples of the wines themselves. His wines have all been stored in temperature-controlled cellars since purchase. BURGUNDY Echézeaux Lucien Jayer 1990 one 2cm, one 3cm, one lightly scuffed label, one scuffed label "...an explosively spicy nose and rich, full, sweet, delicious flavors of real volume and depth plus outstanding length...93." BH 10/ bottles per lot US$ Vosne-Romanée Les Beaux Monts Lucien Jayer 1990 Côte de Nuits, Premier Cru one 2cm, one 3.5cm, one lightly scuffed label bottles per lot US$ Clos de la Roche Vieilles Vignes Domaine Ponsot 1999 "...intensely sappy and concentrated with gorgeously detailed flavors that offer knock out intensity...lingers for minutes...93." BH 1/ bottles per lot US$ Musigny Vieilles Vignes Comte Georges de Vogüé 1999 "...reveals wonderfully complex aromas...huge but fine, powerful but subtle and rich yet detailed with a stupendously long finish...this is genuinely stunning juice...96." BH 11/ bottles per lot US$ Volnay Clos des Ducs Marquis d'angerville 1999 Côte de Beaune, Premier Cru "...marvellous nose...gorgeously balanced, and possesses outstanding depth of velvety-textured fruit...extraordinarily long, pure, and silky finish " WA 6/ bottles per lot US$ Musigny Louis Jadot 2002 includes 6-pack "Like a bon-bon in the mouth, and further sweetened by high-quality oak. A great wine in the making " IWC 3/ bottles per lot US$ Bonnes-Mares Louis Jadot 2005 two 6-pack s "Don't Miss!...toasty, rich, full and massively powerful flavors that are suave and superbly concentrated...impressive wine where the finish doesn't seem to ever end " BH 4/ bottles per lot US$ Musigny Louis Jadot 2003 (3) includes 6-pack 2004 (3) 924 above 6 bottles per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com 133

126 OH MY METHUSELAH OF RICHEBOURG DRC 1995 (LOTS 925 & 926) Property of a prominent West Coast collector, this amazing bottle was acquired on release, kept in perfect storage and came to Zachys still banded in its original wooden case. And don't forget to look one lot below at the amazing magnum of 1985 Salon. BURGUNDY CHAMPAGNE Richebourg Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 1995 banded prior to inspection 8cm, heavily scuffed label partially obscures bottle #2, signs of old seepage "The flavors however are rich and offer excellent detail and are underpinned by dense yet ripe tannins and good extract...93." BH 11/ methuselah (6L) per lot US$24,000-36,000 Salon Blanc de Blancs Le Mesnil 1985 Champagne into foil "Its richness is offset by bracing acidity, yet not quite fully integrated. Full-bodied and aristocratic...95." WS 11/ magnum (1.5L) per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com

127 A SELECTION OF BURGUNDY, KELLER, AND CLOS ROUGEARD (LOTS ) Much of this offering is Burgundy from top sites: whether Les Amoureuses from Mugnier or Charmes-Chambertin from Bachelet (and the Rousseau, Fourrier and DRC). But those in the know will quickly skip to those wines of the moment: assortment cases of Keller and two vintages of Clos Rougeard! The majority of these bottles were purchased on release and removed from a professional wine storage facility. BORDEAUX Château Pavie 2005 St Émilion, Premier Grand Cru Classé (a) "...magnificent concentration, a majestic mouthfeel... Beautifully rich, full and multidimensional, this is a tour de force in winemaking " WA 8/ bottles per lot US$ BURGUNDY Romanée-St-Vivant Louis Jadot 1996 original carton four with importer tags adhered to labels "...glimpses of earth and spice notes with racy and pure middle weight flavors that offer exceptionally good detail on the sappy finish underpinned by firm tannins and acidity...90." BH 1/ bottles per lot US$ Charmes-Chambertin Vieilles Vignes Denis Bachelet 2004 two lightly scuffed labels "The sweet, supple and forward flavors possess notably good length and near perfect balance and the underlying structure on the linear and impressively well delineated finish...92." BH 1/ bottles per lot US$ Clos des Lambrays Domaine des Lambrays 2005 "Great energy propels this to a long, lingering aftertaste. A combination of power and finesse...95." WS 2/ jeroboam (3L) per lot US$ methuselah (6L) per lot US$ Richebourg Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 2008 marked and scuffed label "...detailed, pure and vibrant broad-shouldered flavors that drive home to an explosive, powerful, linear and tautly muscled finish...94." BH 1/ bottle per lot US$ Gevrey-Chambertin Clos St Jacques Vieille Vigne Domaine Fourrier 2009 Côte de Nuits, Premier Cru one scuffed label vines planted in 1910 "...is a seamless beauty laced with hard candy, perfumed cherries, kirsch and spices. The sweetest and silkiest of tannins caress the palate from start to finish as this sublime Burgundy conquers all of the senses. The laser-like, pure finish is breathtaking...96." WA 5/ bottles per lot US$ Chambertin Armand Rousseau 2011 "...outstanding richness to the powerful and impressively scaled...this is a stunner of a wine and one of the great wines of the 2011 vintage...96." BH 1/ bottles per lot US$ ,000 Chambertin Clos de Bèze Armand Rousseau 2011 "...gorgeous combination of power and refinement along with flat out superb complexity on the explosively long, focused and beautifully well-balanced finish...95." BH 1/ bottles per lot US$ Chambolle-Musigny Les Amoureuses JF Mugnier 2011 Côte de Nuits, Premier Cru "...medium-bodied flavors that display an incredibly refined and ultra-pure mouth feel on the deeply complex and gorgeously persistent finish. This is a thing of beauty and textbook Amoureuses " BH 1/ bottles per lot US$ Charmes-Chambertin Vieilles Vignes Bachelet 2011 "There is still some residual wood on the finale but the concentration is such that this should have no difficulty successfully integrating it in time. Another knockout effort in a long string of them for the Bachelet Charmes...93." BH 1/ bottles per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com 135

128 Clos Vougeot Domaine Georges Mugneret-Gibourg 2011 "On the palate the wine is pure, full-bodied and very, very elegant, with a rock solid core, ripe, classy tannins and laser-like focus on the beautifully balanced and wonderfully complex finish. The epitome of elegance!...96." JBG 12/ bottles per lot US$ Gevrey-Chambertin Clos St Jacques Vieille Vigne Domaine Fourrier 2005 (2) one lightly marked label, one lightly torn label, one chipped wax capsule 2010 (1) nicked and scuffed label 939 above 3 bottles per lot US$ LOIRE Saumur Champigny Rouge Clos Rougeard 2009 (6) 2010 (2) 940 above 8 bottles per lot US$ GERMANY Assortment Case Riesling Von den Grossen Lagen Weingut Keller 2013 Rheinhessen original wood assortment case two Riesling Trocken Neirstien Hipping, two Reisling Trocken G-max, one Riesling Trocken Westhoffen Kirschpiel, one Riesling Trocken Dalsheim Hubacker, two Riesling Trocken Neirstien Pettenthal, two Riesling Trocken Westhoffen Morstien, two Riesling Trocken Westhoffen Brunnenhauschen case per lot US$ SPECIALIST'S PICK: LOT 942 This assortment case epitomizes Riesling's ability to teeter in equilibrium between power and finesse. From the very concentrated and powerful G-Max to the bracing acidity and mineral freshness of the dry Kirschspiel and the smoky and noble purity of Morstein, Keller is arguably one of the greatest producers of dry Riesling today. Packed in this swoon-worthy assortment case are also some of the most beautifully balanced and luxurious Auslesen. Fruit profile is a bit more exotic in 2015, but the wines fully deliver with expressive vibrancy and energy. Josephine Young Assortment Case Riesling Von den Grossen Lagen Weingut Keller 2015 Rheinhessen original wood assortment case one Riesling Trocken Hubacker Dalsheim, one Riesling Neirstien Hipping, one Riesling Trocken Westhoffen Kirchspeil, two Riesling Trocken G-Max, one Riesling Neirstien Pettenthal, three Riesling Trocken Westhofen Morstein (two different labels), one Riesling Auslese Abts C, one Riesling Auslese Westhofen Morstein, one Riesling Trocken Westhofen Brunnenhauschen GG case per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com

129 TROPHY BOTTLES OF BURGUNDY (LOTS ) Property of a longtime collector, impeccably sourced and stored in a temperature-controlled home cellar BURGUNDY Grands Echézeaux Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 1999 scuffed label "...beautifully detailed and quite robust flavors that deliver excellent precision. This is a big wine with richness, superb length and impressive refinement...94." BH 7/ bottle per lot US$ La Tâche Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 1999 scuffed label "...big, rich and enveloping flavors of hoisin and pure pinot extract of indescribable complexity and length. The big tannins are completely wrapped in velvet and the finish simply does not quit...99." BH 4/ bottle per lot US$ Richebourg Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 2002 scuffed and lightly bin-soiled label "...deep, wonderfully attractive plummy hint followed by powerfully spiced flavors that offer impeccable balance and real muscle...95." BH 1/ bottle per lot US$ Bonnes-Mares Georges Roumier 2002 nicked label "A complete and seamless wine of enormous complexity and considerable underlying reserve...95." BH 4/ bottle per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com 137

130 A SELECTION OF RARE WINES (LOTS ) Burgundy from Dujac, DRC and Leflaive, a mag of Pegau and the wonderful 2007 Solaia from this concise collection of rarities. A passionate collector, this consignor sourced these bottles from the most reputable of resources and housed in professional, temperature-controlled storage. BURGUNDY Richebourg Gros Frère et Sœur 2005 two lightly marked labels, two lightly scuffed labels "A potent but very reserved, indeed almost backward mix of wood spice, Vosne spice, earth, smoke, animale and gorgeous black berry fruit aromas blend into rich, full and wonderfully deep flavors...94." BH 1/ bottles per lot US$ Vosne-Romanée Aux Malconsorts Dujac 2006 Côte de Nuits, Premier Cru one lightly damp-stained label, one lightly torn label, two wrinkled labels bottles per lot US$ Bonnes-Mares Dujac 2007 four lightly scuffed labels, three scuffed labels "...pure, intense, rich, full and focused middle weight flavors that possess excellent power and punch with ample minerality on the wonderfully long and moderately austere finish...93." BH 1/ bottles per lot US$ Grands Echézeaux Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 2007 scuffed label "...fresh, intense, powerful and moderately well muscled big-bodied flavors that possess an attractive mouth feel and solid finishing depth...91." BH 1/ bottle per lot US$ Chambertin Dujac 2009 "...flat-out stunning. It boasts gorgeous textural finesse and sheer energy...combines power and finesse...pure sophistication...98." WA 4/ bottle per lot US$ Clos St Denis Dujac 2009 one bin-soiled label, one lightly bin-soiled label "The Clos St Denis is the epitome of weightless elegance. Dark raspberries, flowers and sweet spices wrap around the eternal finish...96." WA 4/ bottles per lot US$ Vosne-Romanée Aux Malconsorts Dujac 2009 Côte de Nuits, Premier Cru one bin-soiled label, three lightly bin-soiled labels, one lightly scuffed label "Still, from time to time the wine reveals hints of its brilliance and pedigree. The Malconsorts should be dazzling in another few years...94." WA 4/ bottles per lot US$ Vosne-Romanée Les Malconsorts Cuvée Christiane de Montille 2011 Côte de Nuits, Premier Cru "There is outstanding volume and richness to the largescaled flavors that display superb delineation and ample minerality before culminating in a mouth coating finish of Zen-like harmony and stunning length. This is an indisputable 'wow' wine " BH 4/ bottles per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com

131 Vosne-Romanée Les Malconsorts de Montille 2011 Côte de Beaune, Premier Cru two scuffed labels "There is good muscle and punch to the broad-shouldered, robust and solidly well-concentrated flavors that possess plenty of supporting dry extract, all wrapped in a mouth coating firm, balanced and impressively persistent finish. Good stuff " BH 4/ bottles per lot US$ Bâtard-Montrachet Domaine Leflaive 2009 Côte de Beaune, Grand Cru three with signs of old seepage "...deep, full-bodied, pure and quite young, with a rock solid core of fruit in reserve, brisk acids, great focus and balance and really striking mineral drive on the very long and racy finish...96." JBG 11/ bottles per lot US$ RHÔNE Châteauneuf-du-Pape Cuvée Inspiration Pegau 2010 Rhône "There's a single barrel of this full-bodied, deeply concentrated elixir and I've no doubt it will be very hard to come by. In addition, this Cuvée is only bottled in magnum. Nevertheless, it is spectacular, and I suspect will also have close to three decades of longevity " WA 10/ magnum (1.5L) per lot US$ ITALY Solaia Antinori 2007 Tuscany two 6-pack s two lightly bin-soiled labels "Despite its considerable ripeness and opulence, the 2007 Solaia is never heavy, rather it impresses for its extraordinary finesse and balance. Minerals, graphite and crushed rocks frame a long, seductive finish...97." WA 5/ bottles per lot US$ Brunello di Montalcino Riserva Colle al Matrichese Costanti 2010 Tuscany original carton bottles per lot US$ CALIFORNIA Opus One 2009 "The 2009 Opus One is impeccable. It brings together the silkiness of the 2007 with the power and darkness of the 2008, a combination that is hugely appealing, to say the least " AG 6/ magnums (1.5L) per lot US$ NO LOT ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com 139

132 GEMS FROM AROUND THE WORLD (LOTS ) There's so much goodness in this collection, we'd be foolish to highlight just a few lots. From recent releases from Coche-Dury to JL Chave, there is something for every collector here. Bid with confidence as everything has perfect provenance. 964 NO LOT BURGUNDY Romanée-St-Vivant Hudelot-Noëllat 2002 "A wine that is at once highly expressive yet a model of grace and understatement. In short, this is wonderfully classy juice " BH 1/ magnum (1.5L) per lot US$ Meursault Perrières Guy Roulot 1996 Côte de Beaune, Premier Cru lightly bin-soiled labels, one lightly torn label, one lightly scuffed label "The flavors however were fresh, rich and edgy with an almost pungent sense of minerality and a tight, rather short finish...95." BH 5/ bottles per lot US$ NO LOT 966 NO LOT Clos de la Roche Hubert Lignier 2014 "There is excellent verve and fine detail to the impressively intense and imposingly scaled flavors that are supported by markedly firm tannins on the suave, mouth coating and massively long finish " BH 1/ bottles per lot US$ & 969 NO LOT Bâtard-Montrachet Domaine Jean-Claude Ramonet 2015 Côte de Beaune, Grand Cru magnum (1.5L) per lot US$ Chablis Les Clos Raveneau 1984 (1) 2.5cm, dam-stained label 1994 (1) deteriorated label 1995 (1) damp-stained label 2002 (1) chipped wax capsule 2007 (1) 2008 (1) 975 above 6 bottles per lot US$ Echézeaux Mugneret-Gibourg 2008 magnums (2) 2009 magnum (1) 970 above 3 magnums (1.5L) per lot US$ NO LOT 140 ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com

133 Meursault Coche-Dury 2000 (1) lightly scuffed label 2004 (1) 2008 (1) signs of old seepage 2009 (1) signs of old seepage 2011 (1) 2014 (1) signs of old seepage 976 above 6 bottles per lot US$ Chablis Blanchots Raveneau 2003 (1) 2004 (2) one lightly wine-stained label, one chipped wax capsule 2005 (1) 2007 (1) 2009 (1) 2011 (3) one with signs of seepage 2013 (2) 977 above 11 bottles per lot US$ Chablis Montée de Tonnerre Raveneau 2005 (1) 2006 (3) two with signs of old seepage 2007 (1) 2008 (3) 2009 (3) 2010 (1) heavily chipped wax capsule fully reveals cork 978 above 12 bottles per lot US$ Chablis Valmur Raveneau 2005 (1) 2007 (2) one chipped wax capsule 2008 (1) 2009 (1) signs of old seepage 2011 (1) 2013 (2) 2014 (1) 979 above 9 bottles per lot US$ Meursault Domaine Roulot Clos des Bouchères 2012 (1) Tessons Clos de Mon Plaisir 2013 (1) Bouchères 2015 (1) 2015 (3) Tessons Clos de Mon Plaisir 2015 (1) Tillets 2015 (1) 980 above 8 bottles per lot US$ Domaine Jean-Claude Ramonet 2014 Bâtard-Montrachet magnum (1) lightly scuffed label Bienvenues-Bâtard-Montrachet magnum (1) signs of old seepage 981 above 2 magnums (1.5L) per lot US$ Chassagne-Montrachet Les Ruchottes Domaine Jean-Claude Ramonet 2014 (4) 2015 (4) 982 above 8 bottles per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com 141

134 RHÔNE CHAMPAGNE GUIGAL Côte-Rôtie La Landonne Guigal 1991 Rhône "...huge, smoky, new saddle leather, licorice, Asian spice, meaty, and cassis scents. Black in color, with layers of richness, huge body, massive extraction, and a phenomenal finish...99." RP bottles per lot US$ Côte-Rôtie La Mouline Guigal 1991 Rhône oxidized capsules "...appears to be another perfect wine in the making... superb density...it is a phenomenal wine " WA 6/ bottles per lot US$ Dom Pérignon 2006 Champagne two 6-pack original cartons Parcel: lots "Rich, voluptuous and creamy, the 2006 shows off fabulous intensity in a style that brings together the ripeness of 2002 with the greater sense of verve and overall freshness that is such a signature of the " AG 10/ bottles per lot US$ bottles per lot US$ bottles per lot US$ NO LOT Côte-Rôtie La Turque Guigal 1991 Rhône lightly bin-soiled labels "It is a winemaking tour de force...phenomenal levels of fruit, complexity, and richness into this velvety-textured wine without causing it to taste heavy...99." RP bottles per lot US$ Jacques Selosse Blanc de Blancs Millesime 2002 (2) disgorged February 23, (1) disgorged April 25, above 3 bottles per lot US$ ITALY 986 NO LOT Hermitage JL Chave 1983 (1) 2cm, damp-stained and scuffed labels 1986 (1) 2.5cm 1988 (1) 2.5cm, damp-stained label, signs of old seepage 1989 (1) 2.5cm, scuffed label, lightly oxidized capsule 987 above 4 bottles per lot US$ Barbaresco Gaja 1971 one 3.5cm, one 5cm, one lightly torn label, lightly binsoiled labels bottles per lot US$ NO LOT Hermitage JL Chave 1996 (2) 1997 (2) marked label 1998 (1) lightly wine-stained label, signs of old seepage 2001 (1) stamp on label 2006 (1) 988 above 7 bottles per lot US$ NO LOT 142 ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com

135 RECENT RELEASE YOUNG BURGUNDY WITH PERFECT PROVENANCE (LOTS ) All the following lots were acquired directly on release from importers and have been maintained in perfect storage. BURGUNDY Romanée-St-Vivant Follin-Arbelet 2009 two lightly bin-soiled labels "The palate has a lot of creamy oak, but very well defined, crisp acidity with a cutting citric edge. Dark cherry, raspberry and a touch of smoke, building succinctly to a very poised finish overflowing with fruité " WA 1/ magnums (1.5L) per lot US$ Clos de la Roche Vieilles Vignes Domaine Ponsot 2011 two 3-pack s in two 3-pack original cartons one lightly scuffed label "The broad-shouldered flavors possess superb mid-palate concentration that enrobes the buried but still quite firm tannins while culminating in a beautifully balanced, muscular and explosively long finish...a 'wow' wine " BH 1/ magnums (1.5L) per lot US$ Chambertin Charles Van Canneyt 2012 original carton magnums (1.5L) per lot US$ Chapelle-Chambertin Charles Van Canneyt 2012 original carton bottles per lot US$ Charmes-Chambertin Olivier Bernstein 2012 two 6-pack s bottles per lot US$ Clos de la Roche Olivier Bernstein 2012 two 6-pack s "While there is excellent size, weight and richness to the middle weight flavors, the mouth feel is relatively refined thanks to the fine grain of the tannins " BH 4/ bottles per lot US$ Echézeaux Charles Van Canneyt 2012 Lots 1039 & 1040: original carton Parcel: lots 1039 & bottles per lot US$ bottles per lot US$ bottles per lot US$ Griotte-Chambertin Domaine Ponsot 2012 two 6-pack s in two 6-pack original cartons "There is fine concentration to the mineral-driven, intense and well-delineated medium weight plus flavors that coat the palate with dry extract before culminating in an impeccably well-balanced and strikingly long finish " BH 1/ bottles per lot US$ Chambertin Vieille Vigne Jean-Marie Fourrier 2013 individual s "...deep, full-bodied, pure and nascently complex, with bottomless depth at the core, suave tannins, excellent focus and a very, very long, focused and tangy finish " JBG 12/ jeroboams (3L) per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com 143

136 Charmes-Chambertin Cuvée Des Merles Domaine Ponsot 2013 two 6-pack s in two 6-pack original cartons bottles per lot US$ Mazis-Chambertin Joseph Drouhin 2013 two 6-pack s bottles per lot US$ Bienvenues-Bâtard-Montrachet Louis Jadot 2007 Côte de Beaune, Grand Cru "Subtle nutty and honeyed suggestions add depth and richness to a ravishingly refined, practically delicate, and persistently refreshing expression of the class...94." WA 12/ bottles per lot US$ Corton-Charlemagne Domaine Ponsot 2012 Côte de Beaune, Grand Cru two 6-pack s in two 6-pack original cartons Parcel: lots 1047 & 1048 "On the palate the wine is deep, full-bodied and very pure and complex, with a great core of fruit, superb soil inflection, very suave, seamless acids and simply brilliant length and grip on the complex and perfectly balanced finish. This is a great, great bottle of Corton Charlie!...96." JBG 12/ bottles per lot US$ bottles per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com

137 RARE WINES (LOTS ) From a longtime friend of the firm, from a much larger professionally-stored cellar. BURGUNDY RHÔNE Chambertin Maison Leroy 1969 two 2cm or better, one 2.5cm, one 3.5cm, lightly dampstained labels, one lightly torn label, two lightly scuffed labels, slightly depressed corks "This outstanding vintage is known for balanced, longlived wines, and here is the evidence...98." WS 12/ bottles per lot US$ Clos St Denis Trés Vieilles Vignes Domaine Ponsot bottles per lot US$ Musigny Louis Jadot 2012 "The palate is supremely well balanced with perfect acidity slicing through the sophisticated dark berry fruit interlaced with spice and minerals. There is an effortless quality " WA 12/ bottles per lot US$ Châteauneuf-du-Pape Hommage à Jacques Perrin Château Beaucastel 2009 Rhône Parcel: lots 1053 & 1054 "Massive and full-bodied on the palate, with a sheer density and decadence that's hard to believe, this is a pedal-tothe-metal effort that has the fruit to drink beautifully today, yet the concentration, mid-palate, tannin and balance to age for 3-4 decades...99." WA 2/ jeroboam (3L) per lot US$ jeroboam (3L) per lot US$ ITALY Barolo Riserva Speciale Michele Mascarello 1967 Piedmont five 3.5cm, one 4cm, four lightly scuffed labels bottles per lot US$ Chevalier-Montrachet La Cabotte Bouchard Père et Fils 2005 Côte de Beaune, Grand Cru "...big, rich and sweet flavors that despite all the punch, remains in absolutely perfect balance as the density of the mid-palate buffers completely the firm acid spine...96." BH 7/ jeroboam (3L) per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com 145

138 ROMANÉE-ST-VIVANT DOMAINE DE LA ROMANÉE- CONTI 1993 (LOT 1056) These bottles have been stored in temperature- and humidity-controlled storage since purchase. BURGUNDY Romanée-St-Vivant Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 1993 one 2cm, one 3cm, one 3.5cm, one heavily scuffed label, one lightly scuffed label, one scuffed label "Classic and explosive RSV nose with superbly elegant black fruit nose...tight, pure, concentrated and intense flavors of outstanding complexity and length...a dramatic, extremely impressive wine...94." BH 3/ bottles per lot US$ JACQUES SELOSSE MAREUIL SUY AY SOUS LE MONT NV (LOT 1058) These bottles have been maintained in Zachys' temperature- and humidity-controlled storage since purchase. CHAMPAGNE Jacques Selosse Mareuil Suy ay Sous le Mont NV Champagne individual original gift boxes in two 6-pack original cartons disgorged on January 27, bottles per lot US$ END OF DAY 1 RSV FROM DRC 1993 (LOT 1057) These bottles were purchased and stored in the controlled storage of Zachys. BURGUNDY Romanée-St-Vivant Domaine de la Romanée-Conti cm or better, one lightly marked label, lightly scuffed labels "Classic and explosive RSV nose with superbly elegant black fruit nose...tight, pure, concentrated and intense flavors of outstanding complexity and length...a dramatic, extremely impressive wine...94." BH 3/ bottles per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com

139 Day Two Lots ZACHYS tel fax zachys.com 147

140 A WIDE ASSORTMENT OF FINE WINES (LOTS ) This offering comes on the heels of a very successful portion of this cellar in the July eauction. From a custom temperature and humidity-controlled cellar in New Jersey, the wines in this offering were purchased on or near release and 2005 Bordeaux are in strong supply. The legendary 1970 Único makes an appearance, as do top vintages of Masseto. BORDEAUX Château Margaux 1995 Margaux, Premier Cru Classé three lightly scuffed labels "Full-bodied and thick, yet racy, with masses of tannins and a harmonious structure " WS 1/ bottles per lot US$ Château Mouton Rothschild 1998 one lightly nicked label, one lightly scuffed label "...an extremely powerful, super-concentrated wine...massive, with awesome concentration...96." WA 4/ bottles per lot US$ Château Angélus 2000 St. Emilion, Premier Grand Cru Classé (a) includes 12-pack "Slightly reserved in the nose. Full-bodied, with loads of layered, velvety tannins. Big, yet refined and beautiful. Long and caressing...95." WS bottles per lot US$ Château Cos d Estournel 2000 St. Estèphe, Deuxième Cru Classé "The palate is full-bodied with ripe tannins, superb symmetrical structure...very well balanced, very focused, broadening out nicely towards the ravishing, supple finish...96." WA 9/ bottles per lot US$ Château Lynch-Bages 2000 Pauillac, Cinquième Cru Classé "...exhibits admirable purity, texture, mouthfeel and power combined with elegance. One of the all-time great examples of Lynch-Bages...97." WA 8/ bottles per lot US$ Château Palmer 2000 Margaux, Troisième Cru Classé "I love the blackberry, plum, chocolate and cedar character. It's very long and beautiful. The velvety, textured tannins are impressive...97." JS 4/ bottles per lot US$ Vieux Château Certan 2000 Pomerol "A gorgeous wine of grace, elegance, and power...medium to full-bodied, elegant, and pure with low acidity as well as formidable tannins in the long finish...95." WA 6/ bottles per lot US$ Château Angélus 2005 St. Emilion, Premier Grand Cru Classé (a) "The tannins are beautifully integrated but still present, and the wood, acidity, alcohol, etc., are all beautifully assimilated in this magnificent, majestic vintage of Angélus " WA 8/ bottles per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com

141 Château Cos d Estournel 2005 St. Estèphe, Deuxième Cru Classé "Full and very layered with chewy polished tannins and a long, long finish. Just starting to open...99." JS 10/ bottles per lot US$ Château Ducru-Beaucaillou 2005 St. Julien, Deuxième Cru Classé "A nice, complex wine...full-bodied, with pure fruit...this is balanced and silky, a beautiful harmony. Give this some time if you can...95." JS 5/ bottles per lot US$ Château Léoville Las Cases 2005 St. Julien, Deuxième Cru Classé The palate is full, yet tight and powerful with perfect tannins and a long, long finish. The quality of the tannins is phenomenal, please leave this alone for ten years...99." JS 5/ bottles per lot US$ Château Palmer 2005 Margaux, Troisième Cru Classé "...long, multi-dimensional and textured. This wonderfully pure, stunning wine once again performs as a First Growth...98." WA 6/ bottles per lot US$ Château d'yquem two different importers 1997 half-bottles (6) 1997 (6) one lightly bin-soiled label, two marked labels 1071 above 6 half-bottles (375ml) & 6 bottles per lot US$ ITALY Masseto 1999 Tuscany "Superb red here. Gorgeous black olive and ripe fruit aromas in this Merlot. Full-bodied, with big, rich and chewy tannins and a long, long, ripe fruit finish. Fantastic...96." WS 9/ bottles per lot US$ Masseto 2001 Tuscany "Full-bodied, with loads of velvety tannins and a long, long finish. Very silky indeed. A gorgeous, seductive, classy red. A monument to Tuscany " WS 10/ bottles per lot US$ SPAIN Vega Sicilia Único 1970 Ribera del Duero three top shoulder, one just below top shoulder, three lightly scuffed labels "It has a thrilling Bordeaux-like personality on the nose... The Cabernet component in the blend is pronounced, forming the backbone and austerity of this wine...97." WA 8/ bottles per lot US$ Vega Sicilia Único 1986 Ribera del Duero five bottom neck or better, one top shoulder "A harmonious wine, that appears to have much of its development ahead of it, there is good glycerin, full body, copious tannin, and a backward yet promising style...92." WA 4/ bottles per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com 149

142 CALIFORNIA Dominus Estate 2001 two 6-pack s "...a fragrant, promising perfume of cocoa, cedar, coffee, roasted herbs, and copious quantities of black fruits...rich and medium to full-bodied, with sweet but noticeable tannin, a layered mid-palate, and a long finish...95." WA 12/ bottles per lot US$ Dominus Estate 2002 two 6-pack s "A classic, full-bodied palate possesses great structure, tremendous depth, loads of tannin, and a multilayered, concentrated yet elegant finish...96." WA 2/ bottles per lot US$ Joseph Phelps Vineyards Insignia 2002 one 6-pack, includes one 6-pack original wood case "A rich, polished, seductive style with layers of complexity...plush layers of currant, mocha, berry, mineral and spice...96." WS 11/ bottles per lot US$ Harlan Estate 2005 "...exhibits a gorgeous thick-looking, ruby/purple color in addition to a beautiful nose...full-bodied, dense, pure, and revealing sweeter tannin...97." WA 12/ bottles per lot US$ Colgin IX Estate Red 2007 "This is another seamless tour de force in winemaking " WA 12/ bottles per lot US$ Hundred Acre Ark Cabernet Sauvignon 2007 "...a full-bodied opulence, wonderful intensity, but the wine is not weighty or overripe. Fleshy and voluptuous with terrific floral notes " WA 12/ bottles per lot US$ Hundred Acre Kayli Morgan Vineyard Napa Cabernet Sauvignon 2007 two 3-pack s "The extraordinary intensity, purity and depth in this rich, flamboyant, exuberant wine are mindboggling " WA 6/ bottles per lot US$ Joseph Phelps Vineyards Insignia 2007 "Sweet oak is present, but it is pushed to the background by the wine's extravagant wealth of fruit and full-bodied power...98." WA 12/ bottles per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com

143 A LIFELONG OENOPHILE, AND FORMER PROPRIETOR OF AN EAST COAST VINEYARD (LOTS ) The wines in this collection have been sourced on release from Zachys, Sherry-Lehmann, or direct from the Château. Every bottle has been held in a custom-built subterranean wine cellar with environmental control and full back up systems since their purchase. BORDEAUX Château Lafite Rothschild 1994 includes 12-pack "A luscious Lafite that is silky and elegant with layers of wonderful violet, berry, cherry and chocolate flavors. It's full-bodied, with racy, refined tannins and good length...93." WS 1/ bottles per lot US$ Château Lafite Rothschild 1996 (1) 1998 (1) 1085 above 2 bottles per lot US$ Carruades de Lafite 2000 Pauillac "It's full-bodied and very velvety, with unctuous fruit flavors and a long and exotic aftertaste...93." WS 1/ bottles per lot US$ Château Léoville Poyferré 2000 St. Julien, Deuxième Cru Classé "The plushest, most ostentatious and dramatic of all the Léovilles in 2000, this wine is already sumptuous...97." WA 6/ bottles per lot US$ Château Lynch-Bages 2000 Pauillac, Cinquième Cru Classé "...exhibits admirable purity, texture, mouthfeel and power combined with elegance. One of the all-time great examples of Lynch-Bages...97." WA 8/ bottles per lot US$ SPECIALIST'S PICK: LOT 1086 After trying this wine on three or four separate occasions, I can say I have never once been disappointed. Perhaps sometimes overlooked, though certainly not deserving of attention. Like taking a deep breath on a walk through a dense forest, you'll find earth, mushroom, oak and dark fruit layering beautifully and with perfect integration. Kim Busch Château Pape Clément 2000 Pessac Léognan, Cru Classé "The wine is expansive, has a savory, broad palate and a full-bodied mouthfeel, yet possesses vivid purity and uplift...96." WA 6/ bottles per lot US$ Château Pavie 2000 St. Emilion, Premier Grand Cru Classé (a) "...stunningly rich nose...fabulously concentrated and fullbodied, with a multidimensional mouthfeel " WA 8/ bottles per lot US$ Château Pichon Longueville Comtesse de Lalande 2000 Pauillac, Deuxième Cru Classé "This is a rich, opulent, stunning Pichon Lalande that is beginning to drink beautifully...96." WA 6/ bottles per lot US$ Château Pavie 2003 St. Emilion, Premier Grand Cru Classé (a) "...a serious candidate for one of the wines of this rather bizarre, but interesting, vintage...stunning nose...dense, full-bodied and very succulent and lush...96." WA 8/ bottles per lot US$ Mixed Bordeaux includes 12-pack Château Pontet-Canet 1995 (7) Château Troplong Mondot 2000 (10) 1093 above 17 bottles per lot US$ Château d'yquem 1990 Sauternes, Premier Cru Supérieur bottom neck or better "...a seamless, full-bodied power and richness have created a wine of remarkable harmony and purity...one of the richest Yquems I have ever tasted...99." WA 4/ bottles per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com 151

144 PARCELS-A-PLENTY OF BORDEAUX...AND A SIX PACK OF CORTON-CHARLEMAGNE COCHE-DURY 1996 (LOTS ) This longtime client and dear friend of the Zachys family over-purchased some extraordinary cases of great Bordeaux. Several cases to keep and now several cases to sell. See below for parcels of Ducru-Beaucaillou and Pichon-Baron. BORDEAUX Château Angélus 1990 St. Emilion, Premier Grand Cru Classé (a) bottom neck or better "Full-bodied, flamboyant, and opulent, with low acidity and sweet tannin...96." WA 6/ bottles per lot US$ Château Ducru-Beaucaillou 1995 St. Julien, Deuxième Cru Classé Parcel: lots "The greatest Ducru produced this century. Breathtaking aromas...full-bodied and tannic, yet very fine and long in the mouth. This has fabulous structure for aging...97." WS 6/ magnums (1.5L) per lot US$ magnums (1.5L) per lot US$ magnums (1.5L) per lot US$ magnums (1.5L) per lot US$ Château Ducru-Beaucaillou 1998 St. Julien, Deuxième Cru Classé five with signs of old seepage magnums (1.5L) per lot US$ Château Cos d Estournel 2003 St. Estèphe, Deuxième Cru Classé "With extraordinary richness, full-bodied, and remarkable freshness, elegance, and persistence, this is one of the finest wines ever made by this estate...98." WA 4/ bottles per lot US$ Château Ducru-Beaucaillou 2003 St. Julien, Deuxième Cru Classé bottles per lot US$ La Mondotte 2003 St. Emilion "...extravagantly rich, voluptuously textured, opulent, full-bodied St.-Emilion. Just coming in to full maturity, it is pure, rich and full. Drink it over the next decade or more...96." WA 8/ bottles per lot US$ Château Pichon Longueville Comtesse de Lalande 2003 Pauillac, Deuxième Cru Classé bottles per lot US$ Château Pichon-Baron 2003 Pauillac, Deuxième Cru Classé Parcel: lots "Full-bodied, with big velvety tannins and lots of fruit. Very rich and powerful, even chewy...96." JS 3/ bottles per lot US$ bottles per lot US$ bottles per lot US$ Les Forts de Latour 2010 Pauillac with damaged lid "...expansive, savory, full-throttle wine, which is better than many vintages of the great Latour itself from the past...97." WA 2/ bottles per lot US$ Château Laville Haut-Brion 2001 Pessac Léognan, Cru Classé two 6-pack s bottles per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com

145 BURGUNDY Assortment Case Grand Cru Domaine Ponsot 2004 original wood assortment case one Chambertin, two Chapelle-Chambertin, one Charmes- Chambertin Cuvée des Merles, two Clos de la Roche Vieilles Vignes, two Clos St Denis Vieilles Vignes, two Clos Vougeot Vieilles Vignes, two Griotte-Chambertin case per lot US$ Bonnes-Mares Georges Roumier 2004 original carton "...textured, sappy, firm and intense flavors that are both serious and more obviously structured " BH 1/ bottles per lot US$ La Romanée Liger-Belair 2004 lightly bin-soiled and scuffed label "...an absolutely stunning nose that is genuinely kaleidoscopic in its breadth and complexity...93." BH 1/ magnum (1.5L) per lot US$ Musigny JF Mugnier 2004 "...simply sublime mix of spicy, elegant, pure and sophisticated...extremely pure, indeed crystalline medium full flavors...all wrapped in a vibrant finish of exceptional intensity...93." BH 3/ bottle per lot US$ Musigny Vieilles Vignes Comte Georges de Vogüé 2004 one marked label "...very ripe and ultra spicy red and black berry fruit notes...sweet, supple and utterly classy...this just blows by on the finish with a superbly long and intensely precise finish...crystalline in its purity and exactness " BH 1/ magnums (1.5L) per lot US$ Corton-Charlemagne Coche-Dury 1996 Côte de Beaune, Grand Cru two 2cm or better, two 2.5cm, one 3.5cm, one 4.5cm "...minerality dominates the mid-palate and explodes like a grenade on the stupendously long finish. This is truly a great wine in every respect...97." BH 10/ bottles per lot US$22,000-36,000 Bienvenues-Bâtard-Montrachet Domaine Leflaive 2005 Côte de Beaune, Grand Cru "...almost painfully intense flavors that explode on the wonderfully long and punchy finish that is pure class...94." BH 7/ jeroboam (3L) per lot US$ Bâtard-Montrachet JN Gagnard 2007 Côte de Beaune, Grand Cru "...truly excellent length, impeccable balance and superb length on the lemony finish...one characteristic that it does retain is an intensity level that is, at present anyway, borderline painful. In a word, impressive " BH 1/ bottles per lot US$ Bâtard-Montrachet Joseph Drouhin 2009 Côte de Beaune, Grand Cru two 6-pack original cartons bottles per lot US$ ITALY Barolo Cascina Francia Giacomo Conterno 2004 Piedmont includes 6-pack original carton "The wine offers tremendous length and a finish that lasts forever. This is an especially dense, powerful Cascina Francia with a gorgeous core of perfumed sweet fruit...97." WA 10/ magnums (1.5L) per lot US$ Bonnes-Mares Comte Georges de Vogüé 2008 "The sheer depth, density and incisiveness of the fruit is fabulous. Expressive floral notes round out the finish. This is very much an understated Bonnes-Mares from de Vogüé...95." WA 5/ bottles per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com 153

146 CLASSIC BORDEAUX AND NAPA CABERNET FROM A NY COLLECTOR (LOTS ) From a local Westchester collector, most of the below lots were purchased on release from Zachys and stored in a temperaturecontrolled home wine cellar. BORDEAUX CALIFORNIA Château Mouton Rothschild 1982 one very top shoulder, three top shoulder, three dampstained labels, scuffed labels, one with double label, two with importer tags adhered to labels, one cut capsule reveals fully branded cork, oxidized capsules Half the people in the room picked this as the favorite in this lineup...did keep getting better in the glass and showed a tremendous depth of fruit and formidable structure... SF bottles per lot US$ Harlan Estate 2004 one scuffed label "...has notes of roasted coffee, charcoal, blackberry, spring flowers, and some background sweet, toasty notes...the wine is sensationally well-endowed, long, and rich...98." WA 12/ bottles per lot US$ Château Latour 1989 four bottom neck or better, one top shoulder, two heavily wine-stained labels, one lightly torn label "This was my neighbor's wine of the night at the dinner. It is showing very well at present and very open." SF bottles per lot US$ Château Latour 2000 one lightly damp-stained label, one lightly wine-stained label "Generous, round...feels very luxurious and reminiscent of the 1982 in the expansiveness on the palate, the balance and the sheer depth of flavors and nuances..." SF bottles per lot US$ Château Mouton Rothschild 2000 "A rich, tannic, earthy style, with loads of creme de cassis and floral notes...a full-bodied wine with plenty of coffee, earth, chocolatey notes " WA 6/ bottles per lot US$ ,000 Château Lynch-Bages 2000 Pauillac, Cinquième Cru Classé four wine-stained labels "...exhibits admirable purity, texture, mouthfeel and power combined with elegance. One of the all-time great examples of Lynch-Bages...97." WA 8/ bottles per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com

147 MOUTON, MOUTON, MOUTON DIRECT FROM THE CHÂTEAU'S CELLARS (LOTS ) This offering presents a rare opportunity to buy a case vertical of Mouton Rothschild, starting with the legendary Magnums of 2008 and two cases of the 100-point 2010 are stand outs en route to recent vintages. This collector is a member of the international wine trade, and all of the following cases have been held directly in the cellars of the Château, only released and shipped to NY for this auction. BORDEAUX CHÂTEAU MOUTON ROTHSCHILD Mouton, like much of Pauillac in the sixteenth century, was part of the sprawling Ségur estate. In the mideighteenth century the land that is now Mouton Rothschild was acquired by Baron de Brane, who changed the name to Brane-Mouton. Brane sold it in 1830 to an M Thuret; while it was already a notable Château, first appearing in a Christie's catalog in 1834, Thuret did not make maintenance of the Château a priority and resold it in The purchaser was Baron Nathaniel de Rothschild, at the time head of the English arm of the wealthy Rothschild family. While Mouton was always a highly regarded wine, a big change came when in 1922, when the twenty-oneyear-old Baron Philippe decided to run the Château fulltime. An innovator from the start of his tenure, in 1924 he decided that in order to guarantee quality the entire production would be bottled at the Château, and from 1934 he numbered each bottle released. Also, of course, he started the tradition of works of art on Mouton labels, featuring the famous Carlu ram's head from 1924 to 1926, and since a hiatus from then until 1945, each label has either been designed by a major artist or featured a tribute to a significant event in the Château's history. Perhaps his most significant achievement was persuading the French Minister for Agriculture, Jacques Chirac, that Mouton was and had always been a First Growth that had been wrongly classified. So, in 1973, for the first and only time, a revised edition of the 1855 classification was released with Mouton finally ranked, next to its Pauillac neighbors Lafite and Latour, as a First Growth. Château Mouton Rothschild 1986 bottom neck or better "It boasts a full body of ultra richness, extraordinary length and beauty and an almost chiseled precision to the quality with fabulous length. It lasts for minutes on the palate " JS 3/ bottles per lot US$ ,000 Château Mouton Rothschild 2003 banded Parcel: lots 1128 & 1129 "...full-bodied, meaty, powerful, dry flavors as well as a huge finish...reminded me of a hypothetical blend of the 1982 and 1986 Moutons " WA 4/ bottles per lot US$ bottles per lot US$ Château Mouton Rothschild 2005 Parcel: lots 1130 & 1131 "It shows superb tannin backbone and polish. Tight and youthful. Just starting to open. Currant and berry undertones with lead pencil are impressive...98." JS 10/ magnums (1.5L) per lot US$ magnums (1.5L) per lot US$ Château Mouton Rothschild 2006 banded Parcel: lots 1132 & 1133 "...stunning aromatics...built like a skyscraper with multiple dimensions...super-concentrated, beautiful blend...96." WA 12/ bottles per lot US$ bottles per lot US$ Château Mouton Rothschild 2008 Parcel: lots 1134 & 1135 "...exhibits tell-tale black currant liqueur, incense, charcoal and floral-like characteristics. The oak is pushed to the background...full-bodied, deep and impressively endowed " WA 5/ magnums (1.5L) per lot US$ magnums (1.5L) per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com 155

148 Lots 1127, , , & ZACHYS tel fax zachys.com

149 Château Mouton Rothschild 2009 banded Parcel: lots 1136 & 1137 "...high but sweet, velvety tannins, massive body, and fabulous purity as well as length. This could turn out to be a candidate for perfection...99." WA 12/ bottles per lot US$ bottles per lot US$ Château Mouton Rothschild 2012 Parcel: lots 1142 & 1143 "Full-bodied, extremely fine and polished. Sexy and ethereal. Harmony. A little salty. Fabulous Pure silk...97." JS 2/ magnums (1.5L) per lot US$ magnums (1.5L) per lot US$ Château Mouton Rothschild 2010 banded Parcel: lots 1138 & 1139 "This is pure Cabernet Sauvignon magic with incredible aromas of currants, blackberries and light spices. Tiny hints of hazelnut. Wet earth. Full body, with super velvety tannins. The purity of fruit is breathtaking. It goes on for minutes " JS 2/ bottles per lot US$ bottles per lot US$ Château Mouton Rothschild 2011 banded Parcel: lots 1140 & 1141 "This shows lots of opulent aromas of ripe fruit, light toasted oak, walnut and dried meat. It's full-bodied, with chewy tannins and plenty of fruit. A muscular, solid wine. Baby " JS 2/ bottles per lot US$ bottles per lot US$ Château Mouton Rothschild 2013 two banded 6-pack ss "Very subtle and refined. Full to medium body. Seamless tannins that dissolve on the finish. Wonderful length for the vintage...95." JS 2/ bottles per lot US$ Château Mouton Rothschild 2015 two banded 6-pack "Possessing striking natural beauty framed by impeccable crafting, this 2015 is a total diva and well worth attention. Give it a good 7-8 years in bottle, at least, and drink it over the next 30+ years...98." WA 2/ bottles per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com 157

150 BORDEAUX AND OTHER GEMS FROM A LOCAL WINE ENTHUSIAST (LOTS ) From this repeat consignor, we're proud to present this concise offering of goodies featuring two s of 95 First Growths and a 6-pack of '01 Château d'yquem. All the wines are in amazing condition and reflect the consignor's passion for optimum storage conditions. BORDEAUX BURGUNDY Château Lafite Rothschild 1995 Full-bodied, with a solid core of tannins and a long, silky finish. Still holding back, but is concentrated and powerful WS bottles per lot US$ ,000 Château Mouton Rothschild 1995 "Very beautiful wine. Mouton shows finesse yet richness in this vintage...94." WS bottles per lot US$ Château d'yquem 2001 Sauternes, Premier Cru Supérieur missing lid "This large-scaled, youthful Yquem appears set to take its place among the most legendary vintages of the past " WA 4/ bottles per lot US$ Gevrey-Chambertin Clos St Jacques Louis Jadot 2005 Côte de Nuits, Premier Cru "Here the nose is decidedly fresher with ripe, expressive and dense red berry fruit nuanced with ample Gevrey earth that continues onto the rich, full and very vibrant flavors " BH 4/ bottles per lot US$ CALIFORNIA Dominus Estate 2001 "...a fragrant, promising perfume of cocoa, cedar, coffee, roasted herbs, and copious quantities of black fruits...rich and medium to full-bodied, with sweet but noticeable tannin, a layered mid-palate, and a long finish...95." WA 12/ bottles per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com

151 FINEST AND RAREST BORDEAUX, LA CHAPELLE, AND HARLAN (LOTS ) Property of a fanatically careful collector, the wines offered below are from a friend of mine who began collecting in the early 1970s and whom I have known for forty years. I have enjoyed wine from his collection on occasion throughout our long friendship, and the wines he has presented have without exception been among the freshest examples I have ever tasted. Apart from the Lafite 1959, which was purchased at retail in England in the 1970s, the Bordeaux were purchased as futures and placed in long term storage at 52 degrees F. If you are seeking to prove a point about any of these wines, bid here. Fritz Hatton BORDEAUX Château Lafite Rothschild 1959 upper shoulder, damp-stained and deteriorated label, short capsule "One of the best-ever Lafites...The extraordinary ability to exude not only an immediate cedary perfume...a Lafite specialty, the way it opens up further avenues of fragrance and subtle by-paths, lingering in the mouth..." MB 12/ bottle per lot US$ Château Lafite Rothschild 1982 one very top shoulder, one top shoulder, one upper shoulder "In the Pauillac lineup only one person correctly pegged this as Lafite. It was subdued and quiet compared to the other wines in this flight, even though it was doubledecanted well in advance. Tobacco and dark fruit notes on the palate, but slow to open..." SF bottles per lot US$ ,000 Château Latour 1982 bottom neck or better, one nicked label "This is the freshest, most resounding and interesting example of this wine I have ever tried. Very approachable and enjoyable, with the Latour strength, but still soft with an excellent finish..." SF bottles per lot US$ ,000 Château Mouton Rothschild 1982 six bottom neck or better, four very top shoulder, two top shoulder, seven bin-soiled labels, one lightly torn label, two wine-stained labels Half the people in the room picked this as the favorite in this lineup...did keep getting better in the glass and showed a tremendous depth of fruit and formidable structure... SF bottles per lot US$11,000-16,000 Château Margaux 1986 Margaux, Premier Cru Classé two top shoulder, one just below top shoulder "...emotionally moving. Still incredibly youthful, it showed incredible focus and depth, all backed up by considerable structure...striking in every way " AG 2/ bottles per lot US$ Château Mouton Rothschild 1986 bottom neck or better, one torn label "It boasts a full body of ultra richness, extraordinary length and beauty and an almost chiseled precision to the quality with fabulous length. It lasts for minutes on the palate " JS 3/ bottles per lot US$ Château Lafite Rothschild 1989 into neck "Wonderful berry and tobacco character, with chocolate and cedar. Full-bodied, yet elegant and silky. Beautifully long. This is always outstanding...94." WS 2/ bottles per lot US$ Château Mouton Rothschild 1989 bottom neck or better "This is a Mouton I found massive at the time, then elegant and slightly austere years later, but today true to its former glory. Like the amazing 1947, it should not be forgotten...98." JS 8/ bottles per lot US$ Pétrus 1989 Pomerol bottom neck or better, one nicked label It's a giant, yet also sophisticated and reserved...fullbodied, with opulent fruit and a depth of flavor that lasts for minutes on the palate WS 10/ bottles per lot US$ ,000 ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com 159

152 RHÔNE Hermitage La Chapelle Jaboulet 1990 Rhône 2cm or better, two bin-soiled labels, one lightly bin-soiled label, one lightly torn label, two wine-stained labels, two slightly depressed corks, two different importers "There is extraordinary freshness for such a mammoth wine in addition to abundant tannin, an amazing 60-second finish, and a level of glycerin and thick, fleshy texture " WA 6/ bottles per lot US$ CALIFORNIA Harlan Estate 1992 (1) 1993 (1) 1994 (1) 1995 (1) 1996 (1) 1161 above 5 bottles per lot US$ LAS CASES AND MOUTON FROM A NEW ENGLAND CONNOISSEUR (LOTS 1162 & 1163) These two great lots of legendary vintage are offered courtesy of a consignor Zachys has been proud to work with on many occasions. Stored in temperature and humidity control, we are excited to again be offering a portion of this collection! BORDEAUX Château Mouton Rothschild 1982 bottom neck or better, scuffed labels, one torn label Half the people in the room picked this as the favorite in this lineup...did keep getting better in the glass and showed a tremendous depth of fruit and formidable structure... SF bottles per lot US$ Château Léoville Las Cases 1982 St. Julien, Deuxième Cru Classé bottom neck or better, lightly scuffed labels, one dampstained label, two different importers "Rich flavors of bracken, winter vegetables, cherries, and cranberries. On the rich side for LLC!...Outstanding minus." FH bottles per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com

153 A CONCISE COLLECTION OF RARE WINES INCLUDING ENGEL AND SOLDERA (LOTS ) Amidst mature Bordeaux and Italian wines is a rare gem: a mixed lot from the house of Engel. Individual bottles are rare, but this mixed lot of Grands Crus from excellent vintages is a highlight of the entire auction. This collector is a longtime friend and consignor in many of Zachys' auctions, and the Zachys team has tasted widely from this collector's cellar. Every bottle has been top notch. BORDEAUX Château Lafite Rothschild 1912 mid shoulder, bin-soiled and nicked label, slightly protruded cork bottle per lot US$ Château Mouton Rothschild 1975 includes 12-pack seven top shoulder, three just below top shoulder, one upper-mid shoulder, one mid shoulder, nine glue-stained labels, nine lightly bin-soiled labels, one scuffed label, two lightly oxidized capsules, two slightly depressed corks, two different importers "...a good dark ruby/garnet color, a sweet nose of cedar, chocolate, cassis, and spices, good ripe fruit and extraction, and a weighty, large-scaled, tannic finish..." RP bottles per lot US$ Mixed Bordeaux Château Haut-Brion 1964 (1) 4.5cm, importer tag adhered to bin-soiled, marked and scuffed label Château Latour 1964 (1) upper shoulder, bin-soiled and glue-stained label Château Cheval Blanc 1970 (1) upper-mid shoulder, heavily glue-stained label, oxidized capsule Château Lafite Rothschild 1970 (2) one just below top shoulder, one upper shoulder, lightly bin-soiled labels, short capsules Château Cheval Blanc 1971 (1) just below top shoulder, bin-soiled and nicked label Château Latour 1971 (1) very top shoulder, damp-stained, scuffed and lightly wine-stained label, lightly torn capsule Château Haut-Brion 1976 (1) 3cm, bin-soiled and heavily torn label Château Cheval Blanc 1978 (1) just below top shoulder, bin-soiled label 1166 above 9 bottles per lot US$ Château Mouton Rothschild 1971 (1) upper-mid shoulder, glue-stained and scuffed label, lightly oxidized capsule 1979 (2) one just below top shoulder, one upper shoulder, one lightly nicked label, lightly scuffed labels, one oxidized capsule 1980 (1) top shoulder, scuffed, lightly torn, wine-stained label 1988 (1) bottom neck, lightly scuffed label 1989 (1) very top shoulder, lightly scuffed label 1997 (1) lightly scuffed label 1167 above 7 bottles per lot US$ Mixed Bordeaux Château Margaux 1983 (1) bottom neck, signs of old seepage Château Lafite Rothschild 1985 (1) very top shoulder, lightly bin-soiled label Château Lafite Rothschild 1986 (1) very top shoulder, lightly scuffed label 1168 above 3 bottles per lot US$ Mixed Bordeaux Château Latour 1993 (1) scuffed label Château Haut-Brion 1994 (1) lightly scuffed label Château Latour 1994 (1) scuffed label, slightly depressed cork Château Latour 1998 (1) Château Haut-Brion 1999 (2) one bin-soiled label 1169 above 6 bottles per lot US$ Château Talbot 1989 St. Julien, Quatrième Cru Classé ten bottom neck or better, one very top shoulder, one top shoulder, three lightly scuffed labels, six scuffed labels bottles per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com 161

154 BURGUNDY ITALY René Engel Clos Vougeot 1996 (1) lightly bin-soiled label Echézeaux 1996 (1) wine-stained back label, lightly bin-soiled label Grands Echézeaux 1996 (2) one wine-stained back label, different labels, one lightly scuffed label, one scuffed label, one wine-stained label, one slightly protruded cork Vosne-Romanée Les Brûlées 1999 (1) damp-stained, lightly scuffed and wine-stained label Clos Vougeot 2002 (1) lightly scuffed label Clos Vougeot 2003 (1) lightly scuffed label 1171 above 7 bottles per lot US$ Brunello di Montalcino Soldera Case Basse 1993 (2) one nicked label, scuffed labels, one torn label Riserva 1994 (1) lightly scuffed label 1998 (1) 1172 above 4 bottles per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com

155 PERFECTLY PRISTINE YOUNG BORDEAUX (LOTS ) The following consignment comes courtesy of a distinguished Northeast collector. A lover of Bordeaux, he has been buying on release for several decades and always made sure to acquire excess cases of the top releases. This stock was all held in one of the premier Northeast professional wine storage facilities. Mostly untouched, these cases are in perfect condition. Highlights include original wooden cases of Haut-Brion 1989, Lafite Rothschild 1998, and lots of Pichon Lalande 1982 and Le Pin If you are a Bordeaux lover, these 74 lots are not to be missed. Lots 1177, 1178, 1192 & 1203 ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com 163

156 BORDEAUX Château Cheval Blanc 1949 St. Emilion, Premier Grand Cru Classé (a) top shoulder, tissue paper adhered to tissue stained, torn and heavily damp-stained label, short capsule reveals fully branded cork "Fully mature and glorious. Lovely aromas...shows great elegance and class...97." WS 3/ bottle per lot US$ Château Cheval Blanc 1982 St. Emilion, Premier Grand Cru Classé (a) five bottom neck or better, one very top shoulder, lightly bin-soiled labels, two nicked labels, one lightly torn capsule "Red fruits dominant on nose and very luscious on the palate. The wine is soft and plush, but lots of velvety red fruit throughout. This had none of the grassy notes I sometimes get out of this wine..." SF bottles per lot US$ Château Haut-Brion 1982 Graves, Premier Cru Classé 3cm, one lightly oxidized capsule Very aromatic on the nose with lots of minerality and damp gravel notes. Interesting and expressive..." SF bottles per lot US$ Château Margaux 1982 Margaux, Premier Cru Classé two bottom neck or better, four very top shoulder, five top shoulder, one just below top shoulder, six bin-soiled labels, two damp-stained labels, two lightly nicked labels, two lightly scuffed labels, six lightly oxidized capsules, one lightly torn capsule, three different importers This wine was breathtaking!...beautiful as soon as it was opened and did not really evolve over the course of the evening, but stayed at a really great spot... SF bottles per lot US$ ,000 Château Mouton Rothschild 1986 ten bottom neck or better, two very top shoulder, one with tissue paper adhered to label, two lightly torn capsules "It boasts a full body of ultra richness, extraordinary length and beauty and an almost chiseled precision to the quality with fabulous length. It lasts for minutes on the palate " JS 3/ bottles per lot US$ ,000 Château Haut-Brion 1989 Pessac Léognan, Premier Cru Classé Lot 1178: 1.5cm or better, Lot 1179: 2.5cm, bin-soiled, lightly scuffed and winestained label "This is unbelievable. Greatest Haut-Brion ever made...fullbodied, with an amazing concentration of fruit and velvety tannins. The finish goes on for minutes " WS 5/ bottles per lot US$15,000-22, magnum (1.5L) per lot US$ Château Margaux 1990 Margaux, Premier Cru Classé one into neck, one very top shoulder, scuffed labels "Round and generous with low acidity, but an opulent, full-bodied richness that is fresh with laser-like precision " WA 6/ bottles per lot US$ Château Haut-Brion 1995 Pessac Léognan, Premier Cru Classé "Multi-dimensional and rich, with layers of ripe fruit, and beautifully integrated tannin and acidity...96." WA 2/ bottles per lot US$ Château Mouton Rothschild 1995 four lightly damp-stained labels, one lightly torn label "Very beautiful wine. Mouton shows finesse yet richness in this vintage...94." WS bottles per lot US$ Château Haut-Brion 1998 Pessac Léognan, Premier Cru Classé "The nose is just fantastic, just soars from the glass with brilliant delineation and freshness...the palate is awesome...98." WA 5/ bottles per lot US$ Château Lafite Rothschild 1998 "...close to perfection...the wine is elegant yet profoundly rich, revealing the essence of Lafite's character...the wine is spectacularly layered yet never heavy...98." WA 4/ bottles per lot US$ , ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com

157 Château Mouton Rothschild 1998 Parcel: lots 1185 & 1186 "...an extremely powerful, super-concentrated wine...massive, with awesome concentration...96." WA 4/ bottles per lot US$ bottles per lot US$ Château Margaux 1999 Margaux, Premier Cru Classé banded "Surprisingly charming and round...it grows in the mouth revealing tremendous length as well as purity. An archetypical Château Margaux of richness, finesse, balance, and symmetry...94." WA 4/ magnums (1.5L) per lot US$ Château Mouton Rothschild 1999 "...sumptuous aromas...forward, lush, and full-bodied, it is already complex as well as succulent, fleshy, and long...93." WA 4/ bottles per lot US$ Château Calon Ségur 1982 St. Estèphe, Troisième Cru Classé two bottom neck or better, three top shoulder, one just below top shoulder, one damp-stained label, two heavily damp-stained labels, one torn label, one depressed cork, three lightly oxidized capsules, two different importers "Full-bodied, still extremely tannic (sweet but noticeable tannins), rich " WA 6/ bottles per lot US$ Château Gruaud-Larose 1982 St. Julien, Deuxième Cru Classé bottom neck or better, one nicked label "A massive wine that is clearly of First Growth quality... continues to justify its legendary status...98." WA 6/ bottles per lot US$ Château L'Evangile 1982 Pomerol includes 12-pack bottom neck or better, four with importer tags adhered to labels "This opulent, full-bodied Pomerol caresses the palate with layers and layers of glycerin and fruit. The tannin is barely noticeable in this massive, rich, gorgeous effort...98." WA 6/ bottles per lot US$ Château La Mission Haut-Brion 1982 Graves, Cru Classé eleven bottom neck or better, one very top shoulder Massively rich aromas of tobacco wrapper and of Mirabelle. Wow! Long, deep, alcoholic, with a viscous texture...outstanding plus. FH bottles per lot US$ ,000 Château Pichon Longueville Comtesse de Lalande 1982 Pauillac, Deuxième Cru Classé two bottom neck or better, two very top shoulder, two heavily damp-stained labels, two lightly bin-soiled labels, two different importers It had a beautiful dark fruit nose and very giving fruit on the palate... SF bottles per lot US$ Château Léoville Las Cases 1985 St. Julien, Deuxième Cru Classé bottom neck or better "A fabulous wine; one of the first great Las Cases. Fullbodied and rich, with the tannins extremely well integrated into an impressive background of fruit. Give it time...98." WS 9/ magnums (1.5L) per lot US$ Château L'Evangile 1985 Pomerol bottom neck or better unless noted Lot 1195: five damp-stained labels, two lightly torn labels, includes 12-pack Lot 1196: one very top shoulder, "A charmer...deep, velvety appearance; good fruit, expanding in the glass; sweet, rich, ripe, silky tannins...." MB bottles per lot US$ bottles per lot US$ Château Lafleur 1986 Pomerol one very top shoulder, two top shoulder, glue-stained labels, one lightly bin-soiled label, one lightly damp-stained label, one lightly scuffed label "It possesses a jammy black cherry, herb, mineral, and earthy-scented nose, and dense, rustic levels of tannin in its full-bodied power, and richness...94." RP bottles per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com 165

158 Château Léoville Las Cases 1986 St. Julien, Deuxième Cru Classé five bottom neck or better, one very top shoulder, one top shoulder, one lightly nicked label "The wine has always been phenomenally concentrated, yet wonderfully fresh and vigorous...it is a great example of Léoville Las Cases " WA 1/ bottles per lot US$ Château Lynch-Bages 1989 Pauillac, Cinquième Cru Classé into neck "Powerful and rich with some tannins still to shed at age 22, it is still a young adolescent in terms of its evolution " WA 8/ bottles per lot US$ Château Pichon Longueville Comtesse de Lalande 1986 Pauillac, Deuxième Cru Classé five bottom neck or better, five very top shoulder, two top shoulder, one damp-stained label, five lightly bin-soiled labels "This still remains a fine, rather regal Pichon-Lalande...95." WA 12/ bottles per lot US$ Château Montrose 1989 St. Estèphe, Deuxième Cru Classé five bottom neck or better, five very top shoulder, two top shoulder "Fabulous aromas of roasted fruit, blackberry, tobacco, chocolate and toasted oak. Full and velvety and very, very fresh. Powerful and fabulously structured...97." WS bottles per lot US$ Château La Fleur de Gay 1989 Pomerol bottom neck or better "...great fruit on the palate, layers of richness, medium to full body, and fabulous harmony and precision. Given its superb intensity and elegant personality, it is a dazzling example of winemaking." WA 2/ bottles per lot US$ Château La Mission Haut-Brion 1989 Pessac Léognan, Cru Classé into neck, lightly bin-soiled label "Full-bodied with extraordinary opulence as well as sweet, well-integrated, velvety tannins, this fresh, lively, blockbuster La Mission appears to be one of those rare wines that never goes through a closed, unfriendly stage " WA 8/ magnum (1.5L) per lot US$ Château Palmer 1989 Margaux, Troisième Cru Classé four into neck, one very top shoulder, three different importers "...sweet, jammy nose...full-bodied and supple, with low acidity, copious quantities of ripe fruit and glycerin...95." WA 2/ bottles per lot US$ Château L'Evangile 1990 Pomerol four bottom neck or better, two very top shoulder, one with importer tag adhered to label, two slightly depressed corks, three with handwriting on capsules, four different importers "It is a complex effort with lots of cedar, sweet caramelized black raspberries and cherries as well as hints of licorice and underbrush..." WA 6/ bottles per lot US$ Château Le Gay 1989 Pomerol ten bottom neck or better, two very top shoulder, one heavily damp-stained label, one wine-stained label bottles per lot US$ Le Pin 1989 Pomerol very top shoulder, light tissue paper adhered to lightly binsoiled label, lightly oxidized capsule "...reveals a sweet, roasted herb, coconut, and jammy black currant-scented nose with plenty of smoky new oak...this is a fabulous and fascinating wine, as well as one of extraordinary singularity...96." RP bottle per lot US$ Château Montrose 1990 St. Estèphe, Deuxième Cru Classé bottom neck or better "...absolutely magnificent, broad, savory and mouth-filling. This is one of the all-time modern legends from Bordeaux as well as Château Montrose " WA 8/ bottles per lot US$ Château Léoville Las Cases 1993 St. Julien, Deuxième Cru Classé one 12-pack with damaged lid three lightly scuffed labels bottles per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com

159 Château Angélus 1994 St. Emilion, Premier Grand Cru Classé (a) "The fruit's phenomenal purity and denseness, as well as its overall balance is admirable in view of the massive, muscular personality of this huge, full-bodied wine oozing with extract...93." WA 1/ bottles per lot US$ Château Valandraud 1994 St. Emilion bottles per lot US$ Château Ducru-Beaucaillou 1996 St. Julien, Deuxième Cru Classé "The palate is medium-bodied with fine tannin, crisp acidity, moving firmly into secondary stage...93." WA 10/ bottles per lot US$ Château Léoville Poyferré 1996 St. Julien, Deuxième Cru Classé two 12-pack s Parcel: lots 1220 & bottles per lot US$ bottles per lot US$ Château Clinet 1995 Pomerol bottles per lot US$ Château Cos d'estournel 1995 St. Estèphe, Deuxième Cru Classé "...this terrific Cos possesses remarkable intensity, full body, and layers of jammy fruit nicely framed by the wine's new oak...95." WA 2/ bottles per lot US$ Château Léoville Las Cases 1995 St. Julien, Deuxième Cru Classé "...one of the vintage's great success stories...exceptionally pure, beautifully knit aromas...staggeringly rich...a compelling effort...95." WA 2/ bottles per lot US$ magnums (1.5L) per lot US$ Château Pichon Longueville Comtesse de Lalande 1995 Pauillac, Deuxième Cru Classé Lot 1216: two 6-pack s Lot 1217: "Exquisite on the palate, this full-bodied, layered, multidimensional wine should prove to be one of the vintage's most extraordinary success stories...96." WA 2/ bottles per lot US$ bottles per lot US$ Château La Mission Haut-Brion 1998 Pessac Léognan, Cru Classé "So complex...it's rich and flavorful and at the same time fresh and racy. A modern classic...99." JS 1/ bottles per lot US$ Château Pavie 1998 St. Emilion, Premier Grand Cru Classé (a) "Extremely full-bodied, yet brilliantly delineated, powerful, and awesomely concentrated, it boasts a fabulous mid-palate as well as a finish that lasts for nearly a minute...95." WA 4/ bottles per lot US$ Château Trotanoy 1998 Pomerol "This structured, formidably-endowed, deep ruby/purplecolored, full-bodied, super-rich wine exhibits notes of toffee, truffles, and abundant blackberry, cherry, and currant fruit...95." WA 4/ bottles per lot US$ Château Palmer 1999 Margaux, Troisième Cru Classé "...both power and elegance, it offers sweet tannin along with flavors that caress the palate...this is terrific stuff!...95." WA 4/ bottles per lot US$ Vieux Château Certan 1995 Pomerol bottles per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com 167

160 BORDEAUX 2000 VINTAGE What is the definition of a great vintage? I would postulate that at least one of the ingredients is that it should be consistent hierarchically; that the lesser wines should be ripe, rich, balanced and full of fruit; that one should be able to pick with confidence among the ranks of the bourgeois, the petits châteaux, and in the satellite appellations. Bordeaux has had four such great years in the last thirty: 1970, 1982, 1990 and, now In these vintages not only are there great wines at the top of the hierarchy, not only is the vintage a success across the whole region, from St Émilion and Pomerol to Pauillac and St Julien, but there are delicious examples to be found in the lesser areas such as Côtes de Bourg, Lalande-de-Pomerol, Fronsac, Montagne-St-Émilion and Côtes de Castillon, as well as in the Médoc north of St Estèphe... There is, of course, another way of looking at the proposition. Are the top 2000s going to be as good as the top 1990s, 1982s or 1961s? Here the question is moot, the response is almost impossible. We won't really be able to answer until 2000s are themselves mature. And we still need to wait for the 1990s to reach their peak. My gut feeling is that nothing will surpass the finest 1961s. They seem to be unique. But I am perfectly happy to agree that 2000, at its best, is as good as 1982 and the interest in the vintage was huge. Never has a vintage sold out so fast. The fruit was healthy. It was concentrated. Alcohol levels, and perhaps surprisingly, acidity levels as well, were high. The skins were thick. The potential tannins very high. All the elements were in place for a great red wine vintage... across Bordeaux both geographically and hierarchically, we have wines of very good colour, considerable but at present largely hidden ripe tannins, deliciously concentrated, very pure, intense fruit and very good acidity. The wines have volume, dimension, class and complexity. There are many châteaux which make wine considerably better than they had done a decade earlier. Overall the selections have been severe. A much smaller proportion of the total has been declared as grand vin than in similar years a decade or more ago. So in many cases we have a better result than has ever been achieved before. Others have made the best wine since Overall it was a splendid vintage. Clive Coates, The Wines of Bordeaux Château Beychevelle 2000 St. Julien, Quatrième Cru Classé bottles per lot US$ Château Ducru-Beaucaillou 2000 St. Julien, Deuxième Cru Classé "...clearly outstanding now and seems to get better and better with age...its full body yet very finely textured with pretty fruit concentration and length...96." JS 6/ bottles per lot US$ Château La Fleur Pétrus 2000 Pomerol "It is an opulent, medium to full-bodied, big, substantial yet elegant, precise Pomerol displaying beautiful purity " WA 6/ bottles per lot US$ Château Léoville Barton 2000 St. Julien, Deuxième Cru Classé bottles per lot US$ Château Léoville Las Cases 2000 St. Julien, Deuxième Cru Classé "...with good acidity, the tell-tale purity, layered ripeness and intensity, and a profound finish " WA 6/ bottles per lot US$ Château Léoville Poyferré 2000 St. Julien, Deuxième Cru Classé Parcel: lots 1231 & 1232 "The plushest, most ostentatious and dramatic of all the Léovilles in 2000, this wine is already sumptuous...97." WA 6/ bottles per lot US$ bottles per lot US$ Château Lynch-Bages 2000 Pauillac, Cinquième Cru Classé "...exhibits admirable purity, texture, mouthfeel and power combined with elegance. One of the all-time great examples of Lynch-Bages...97." WA 8/ bottles per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com

161 Château Montrose 2000 St. Estèphe, Deuxième Cru Classé "Just starting to open...it's full-bodied with ultra-fine, integrated tannins and an extremely complex, refined finish...96." JS 4/ bottles per lot US$ Château Pape Clément 2000 Pessac Léognan, Cru Classé "The wine is expansive, has a savory, broad palate and a full-bodied mouthfeel, yet possesses vivid purity and uplift...96." WA 6/ bottles per lot US$ magnums (1.5L) per lot US$ Les Forts de Latour 2002 Pauillac "A classic second wine that shows outstanding potential, the dark ruby/purple-colored 2002 has notes of cedar wood, black currants, earth, and truffles in a medium to full-bodied, supple-textured, beautifully concentrated style...92." WA 4/ bottles per lot US$ Carruades de Lafite 2003 Pauillac banded "A spectacular value as well as a sleeper of the vintage...it is almost too good to be true...93." WA 4/ bottles per lot US$ Château Pichon-Baron 2000 Pauillac, Deuxième Cru Classé "It is superbly concentrated and very pure, with excellent texture and opulence. The acidity seems low, the tannin high but well-integrated...a compelling " WA 6/ bottles per lot US$ Château Pichon Longueville Comtesse de Lalande 2000 Pauillac, Deuxième Cru Classé "This is a rich, opulent, stunning Pichon Lalande that is beginning to drink beautifully...96." WA 6/ bottles per lot US$ Château Pavie 2001 St. Emilion, Premier Grand Cru Classé (a) "One of the candidates for wine of the vintage...exhibits a tight but promising nose of crushed stones, liqueur of blackberries, cherries, and black currants, and subtle smoke and licorice in background...96." WA 6/ bottles per lot US$ Pavillon Rouge du Château Margaux 2003 Margaux banded bottles per lot US$ Bordeaux 1982 bottom neck or better unless noted Château Certan de May (2) one very top shoulder, bin-soiled labels Château Ducru-Beaucaillou (4) Château Léoville Poyferré (2) Château Pichon-Baron (2) one top shoulder, one upper shoulder, one lightly torn label 1243 above 10 bottles per lot US$ Château d'yquem 2001 Sauternes, Premier Cru Supérieur includes 12-pack This large-scaled, youthful Yquem appears set to take its place among the most legendary vintages of the past WA 4/ half-bottles (375ml) per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com 169

162 SPAIN Vega Sicilia Único 1962 Ribera del Duero Lot 1245: very top shoulder, lightly bin-soiled label Lot 1246: into neck, "Youthful, vivacious and utterly compelling, this is a profound wine that even after four decades is surfeit with precocity. Undoubtedly, this must be one of the greatest Spanish wines to have graced this planet " WA 8/ bottle per lot US$ magnum (1.5L) per lot US$ Lots 1245 & ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com

163 FIRST GROWTH BORDEAUX FROM A LOCAL COLLECTOR (LOTS 1247 & 1248) These two cases were purchased from Zachys retail about years ago and have been lovingly stored ever since in climate-controlled home and commercial storage. BORDEAUX Château Haut-Brion 1988 Pessac Léognan, Premier Cru Classé 2cm or better "Full-bodied, with super silky tannins and a beautiful licorice, tar and fruit aftertaste. Long and complex...96." WS bottles per lot US$ Château Lafite Rothschild bottles per lot US$ BORDEAUX GIANTS (LOTS ) From a very longtime friend and repeat West Coast consignor, the following offering is comprised of a few of the rare giants we rarely have the opportunity to see come up at auction. With the realization he owned too many of these bottles and should share a few with other wine lovers in the world, he has decided to offer a few of them here. From magnums of 1961 Gruaud-Larose and 1934 Ausone to a full case of the legendary 1961 Palmer with perfect provenance detailing the purchase history of the Berry Brothers & Rudd bottlings any true Bordeaux lover should bid with confidence. And for the Rhône fanatics, don't miss the magnum of 1989 Bonneau Célestins! All wines have been removed from professional wine storage on the West Coast. BOREAUX Château Ausone 1934 St. Emilion, Premier Grand Cru Classé (a) one upper shoulder, one upper-mid shoulder, one deteriorated label, heavily bin-soiled and damp-stained labels, one torn label, one taped on label, one corroded capsule, one oxidized capsule, one slightly depressed cork, signs of old seepage magnums (1.5L) per lot US$ Château Gruaud-Larose 1961 St. Julien, Deuxième Cru Classé into neck, one bin-soiled label, one heavily bin-soiled label, lightly corroded capsules, signs of old seepage magnums (1.5L) per lot US$ Château Palmer 1961 Margaux, Troisième Cru Classé Berry Bros & Rudd bottling Provenance: Sothebys, December 13, 2017 Lots 404 & 405 which had been acquired directly from BBR between 1970 and 1972 Lot 1251: upper shoulder, two glue-stained labels, one torn label, one nicked label, one lightly torn label, one lightly bin-soiled label, one with signs of old seepage Lot 1252:one upper shoulder, eleven upper-mid shoulder, four lightly torn labels, three scuffed labels, seven lightly bin-soiled labels, five corroded capsules bottles per lot US$ bottles per lot US$24,000-36,000 RHÔNE Châteauneuf-du-Pape Reserve des Célestins Henri Bonneau 1989 Rhône 2.5cm, lightly marked and torn label "The bouquet is deep and brilliantly profound in its purity and complexity...99." JBG 11/ magnum (1.5L) per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com 171

164 THE KING OF TUSCANY (LOTS ) There is no question that we love the Antinori family and their superb wines. The following offering of library vintages of Solaia, Tignanello, and Guado al Tasso, which are becoming harder and harder to find on the market, is the perfect opportunity to acquire some of these rising gems. All wines were purchased direct from the domaine and have been kept in professional wine storage. Buyers can bid with confidence that they will take home wines of pure enjoyment. ITALY ANTINORI Guado Al Tasso Antinori 2003 Tuscany two 6-pack s Parcel: lots 1254 & 1255 "...opens with a lovely nose redolent of spices and flower followed by layers of sweet dark fruit, toasted oak and chocolate that reveal themselves in the glass...91." WA 2/ bottles per lot US$ bottles per lot US$ Guado Al Tasso Antinori 2004 Tuscany two 6-pack s Parcel: lots 1256 & 1257 "Full-bodied and ample on the palate, it offers plenty of sweet dark fruit, licorice, Tuscan herbs and chocolate, with outstanding persistence as well as balance...92." WA 6/ bottles per lot US$ bottles per lot US$ Guado Al Tasso Antinori 2005 Tuscany two 6-pack s Parcel: lots 1258 & 1259 "Full-bodied and fine, with deliciously dense fruit. I really dig the balance and the freshness in this...find the wine...92." JS 4/ bottles per lot US$ bottles per lot US$ Guado Al Tasso Antinori 2006 Tuscany two 6-pack s Parcel: lots 1260 & 1261 "Full-bodied, soft and round with a gorgeous long finish. Incredible class and depth with a long finish. Precision...95." JS 4/ bottles per lot US$ bottles per lot US$ Guado Al Tasso Antinori 2012 Tuscany three 6-pack s "Poised and focused, this is a young red that shows great complexity and style...full body, chewy tannins and a long and flavorful finish...96." JS 8/ bottles per lot US$ Solaia Antinori 2002 Tuscany two 6-pack s Parcel: lots 1263 & bottles per lot US$ bottles per lot US$ Solaia Antinori 2003 Tuscany two 6-pack s Parcel: lots 1265 & 1266 "Richly sumptuous on the palate, this beautiful, expansive Solaia offers terrific length as well as stunning balance with plenty of style...93." WA 7/ bottles per lot US$ bottles per lot US$ Solaia Antinori 2009 Tuscany two 6-pack s "In one of my blind tastings, the 2009 Solaia was flat-out great. There is no shortage of pedigree here " WA 6/ bottles per lot US$ Tignanello Antinori 2001 Tuscany two 6-pack s Parcel: lots 1268 & 1269 "...fully and completely shaped in flavors of impeccable volume, roundness, and depth, caressing and powerful and with an additional power on the close...93." WA 4/ bottles per lot US$ bottles per lot US$ Tignanello Antinori 2003 Tuscany two 6-pack s Parcel: lots 1270 & bottles per lot US$ bottles per lot US$ Tignanello Antinori 2005 Tuscany two 6-pack s Parcel: lots 1272 & bottles per lot US$ bottles per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com

165 COLOSSAL CALIFORNIA CABERNET SAUVIGNON (LOTS ) Property of a distinguished West Coast collector, this renowned doctor has been acquiring the very best of Bordeaux, Burgundy, and France for several decades. Zachys had the pleasure of offering an initial portion of this magnificent cellar in one of our very first Hong Kong auctions. Now the time has come for another pruning with a tremendous selection of Pétrus, Leroy, Dujac, and the very best of California. You know the names, repeat after me; Dominus, Harlan, Hundred Acre, Joseph Phelps Insignia, Screaming Eagle, and Shafer Hillside Select. All the bottles were sourced with the utmost care, all the California lots acquired directly from the producers. Each of these bottles was meticulously cared for and stored perfectly in a custom-built home wine cellar. ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com 173

166 BORDEAUX BURGUNDY Château Latour 1995 one lightly scuffed label "The palate is wonderfully fleshy and opulent with velvety, approachable tannins and a long finish...96." WA 11/ bottles per lot US$ Pétrus 2003 Pomerol two lightly scuffed labels, two different importers "Amazing, jaw-dropping quality. Full-bodied, with super silky, seductive tannins and a finish that lasts for minutes. Out of this world...98." WS 3/ bottles per lot US$10,000-15,000 Château Lynch-Bages 1989 Pauillac, Cinquième Cru Classé bottom neck or better, four lightly nicked labels "Powerful and rich with some tannins still to shed at age 22, it is still a young adolescent in terms of its evolution " WA 8/ bottles per lot US$ Château Cos d Estournel 2005 St. Estèphe, Deuxième Cru Classé four lightly scuffed labels "Full and very layered with chewy polished tannins and a long, long finish. Just starting to open...99." JS 10/ bottles per lot US$ Château L'Evangile 2005 Pomerol "Full-bodied, with layer upon layer of velvety tannins and chocolate, berry, vanilla and tea flavors. Lasts for minutes. I am blown away by this wine " WS 3/ bottles per lot US$ Château La Mission Haut-Brion 2005 Pessac Léognan, Cru Classé "...a long, textured, multi-layered finish that must last 50+ seconds. This is a fabulous wine and a great effort from this hallowed terroir " WA 6/ bottles per lot US$ Château Rieussec 2001 Sauternes, Premier Cru Classé "Full-bodied, very sweet with fantastic concentration of ripe and botrytized fruit, yet balanced and refined...absolutely mind-blowing " WS 6/ bottles per lot US$ Clos de Vougeot Domaine Leroy 2002 one lightly torn vintage tag, two lightly scuffed labels "This is quite ripe...overall effect is one of brooding power...this is an incredibly powerful and rich wine that offers superb delineation...96." BH 1/ bottles per lot US$ Clos Vougeot Jacques Prieur bottles per lot US$ Richebourg Gros Frère et Sœur 2002 two lightly scuffed labels "Silky-textured, deep, and holding much in reserve, this concentrated, elegant wine also displays an exceptionally long finish...95." WA 8/ bottles per lot US$ Chambertin Jacques Prieur 2005 "A supremely classy, refined and regally reserved nose of a simply amazing panoply of aromas that run the entire gamut " BH 4/ bottles per lot US$ Chambolle-Musigny Les Amoureuses Amiot-Servelle 2005 Côte de Nuits, Premier Cru six damp-stained labels, two lightly scuffed labels bottles per lot US$ Clos Vougeot Jacques Prieur bottles per lot US$ Pommard Clos des Epeneaux Comte Armand 2005 Côte de Beaune, Premier Cru bottles per lot US$ Griotte-Chambertin René Leclerc 2009 seven lightly scuffed labels bottles per lot US$ Gevrey-Chambertin Aux Combottes Dujac 2010 Côte de Nuits, Premier Cru one lightly scuffed label bottles per lot US$ Richebourg Gros Frère et Sœur 2009 (2) lightly scuffed labels 2010 (3) 1290 above 5 bottles per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com

167 Lot 1281 ZACHYS tel fax zachys.com 175

168 ITALY CALIFORNIA Sperss Gaja 2004 Piedmont "Powerful and structured. Sneaks up on you and delivers a wine for aging. This is massive. An amazing wine...99." WS 6/ bottles per lot US$ HARLAN ESTATE Harlan Estate 2002 "...profoundly complex...it literally has everything one could ever want...this prodigious offering is worth mortgaging the farm! " WA 12/ bottles per lot US$ Harlan Estate 2003 "...it comes across like a hypothetical blend of a top-notch Pauillac and Graves. Superb texture, low acidity, and gorgeous purity as well as richness...95." WA 12/ bottles per lot US$ Harlan Estate 2009 "Juicy and exuberant, the 2009 has always had a certain raciness that is impossible to resist. Layers of fruit continue to build to the enveloping, sensual finish..." WA 12/ bottles per lot US$ Harlan Estate 2010 "Rich, full-bodied and softer than I would have expected in this vintage, it is a prodigious, multidimensional, compelling wine " WA 10/ bottles per lot US$ Harlan Estate 2014 "Time in the glass brings out a compelling interplay of beautifully layered fruit and lifted aromatics. The 2014 is one of the most understated yet energetic young vintages of Harlan Estate I can remember tasting...98." AG 3/ bottles per lot US$ Harlan Estate 1995 (1) 2004 (2) 2006 (1) 1297 above 4 bottles per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com

169 JOSEPH PHELPS Unlike most Napa winemakers and vineyard owners, Joseph Phelps did not come to the area to make wine; he arrived when the construction company he ran, Hensel Phelps, won the bid to construct Souverain Winery (now Rutherford Hill). He fell in love with the area and in 1973, purchased the land that became the original part of Joseph Phelps Vineyards. For many years, these vineyards were supplemented with purchased fruit from other top Napa growers, including the famous Eisele Vineyard. Today, though, in keeping with the longstanding goal of the family to use only estate grown fruit, all but a small amount of syrah comes from their own holdings. In 1974, Phelps decided to release a wine that profoundly affected the direction of California winemaking, by releasing Insignia, the first Napa wine to blend Bordeaux varieties in the same way as the Bordelais themselves. Insignia is routinely rated as the best of the so-called meritage Bordeaux-style blends by critics including Robert M. Parker, Jr. and the Wine Spectator. Joseph Phelps Vineyards Insignia 2001 (6) 2001 double magnum (1) 1298 above 6 bottles & 1 double magnum (3L) per lot US$ Joseph Phelps Vineyards Insignia 2003 "Full-bodied, opulent, and rich with outstanding depth, purity, and harmony, sweet tannin, and a long finish...94." WA 12/ bottles per lot US$ Joseph Phelps Vineyards Insignia bottles per lot US$ Joseph Phelps Vineyards Backus Cabernet Sauvignon bottles per lot US$ Joseph Phelps Vineyards Insignia 2006 "...it boasts a dense plum/purple color as well as abundant notes of licorice, black currants, charcoal, black olives, and graphite. Full-bodied, pure, and rich with moderately high tannins " WA 12/ bottles per lot US$ Joseph Phelps Vineyards Insignia 2007 two 6-pack s "Sweet oak is present, but it is pushed to the background by the wine's extravagant wealth of fruit and full-bodied power...98." WA 12/ bottles per lot US$ Joseph Phelps Vineyards Backus Cabernet Sauvignon 2008 Oakville two 6-pack s bottles per lot US$ Joseph Phelps Vineyards Insignia 2008 two 6-pack s bottles per lot US$ Joseph Phelps Vineyards Backus Cabernet Sauvignon 2004 two 6-pack s bottles per lot US$ Joseph Phelps Vineyards Backus Cabernet Sauvignon 2009 Oakville one 6-pack bottles per lot US$ Joseph Phelps Vineyards Insignia 2004 two 6-pack s "Dense, voluptuous, full-bodied, rich, long, and harmonious...95." WA 12/ bottles per lot US$ Joseph Phelps Vineyards Backus Cabernet Sauvignon 2005 two 6-pack s two damp-stained labels bottles per lot US$ Joseph Phelps Vineyards Backus Cabernet Sauvignon 2010 Oakville two 6-pack s bottles per lot US$ Joseph Phelps Vineyards Backus Cabernet Sauvignon 2011 Oakville one 6-pack bottles per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com 177

170 SCREAMING EAGLE Screaming Eagle Cabernet Sauvignon 2012 "What complexity. Precision and decadence plus layers of sexy fruit. A new benchmark for. This is the new legend " JS 7/ bottles per lot US$ ,000 Screaming Eagle Cabernet Sauvignon 2013 "It lasts for minutes on the finish. The classicism in this wine is second to none. Incredible subtlety. Lovely austerity. Beauty in simplicity " JS 1/ bottles per lot US$ Screaming Eagle Cabernet Sauvignon 2014 "It grows on the palate with an extremely long finish that goes on for minutes...purity and essence to this. Feminine yet wild and unpredictable...99." JS 1/ bottles per lot US$ Dominus Estate 1994 "...incredibly fragrant nose of jammy black fruits, spice, smoke, and loamy, truffle-like scents...full-bodied, with thrilling levels of extract and richness...99." WA 12/ bottles per lot US$ Shafer Vineyards Hillside Select Cabernet Sauvignon 2003 Stag's Leap District one 6-pack "...aromas of camphor, black currants, licorice, crushed rocks, and white flowers...impeccable balance, purity, and length...95." WA 12/ bottles per lot US$ Cardinale Cabernet Sauvignon 2004 California bottles per lot US$ Lokoya Mount Veeder Cabernet Sauvignon 2004 Mount Veeder "Powerful, rich flavors are unctuously textured, low in acidity, high in tannin and glycerin. This sensational effort will be even better in 2-4 years, and should keep for two decades...96." WA 12/ bottles per lot US$ Cardinale 2005 California bottles per lot US$ Dominus Estate 2005 "A beautiful, sweet nose...fabulous intensity, a layered, opulent, full-bodied mouthfeel, well-integrated acidity, and a stunningly long finish...an outstanding, sexy, ageworthy Dominus...96." WA 12/ bottles per lot US$ Hundred Acre Ark Cabernet Sauvignon 2005 one lightly nicked label "Wonderfully fat, sweet wine with extravagant chocolate, mocha and nutty oak tones. Finishes with rich, broad tannins and a wave of chocolatey dark fruits...93." IWC 6/ bottles per lot US$ Hundred Acre Kayli Morgan Vineyard Napa Cabernet Sauvignon 2005 "...exquisite, performing even better this year than it did last. A beautiful bouquet of licorice, smoke, burning embers, creme de cassis, sweet black cherries, and spice box...unctuous, flamboyant, and incredibly pure...already strutting its remarkable potential...98." WA 12/ bottles per lot US$ Caymus Vineyards Special Selection Cabernet Sauvignon bottles per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com

171 Lot 1313 ZACHYS tel fax zachys.com 179

172 Dominus Estate 2006 "One of the finest wines of the vintage, it is complete, fullbodied, and seamlessly built with beautiful ripe tannins, low acidity, and a luscious, layered mouthfeel...96." WA 12/ bottles per lot US$ Colgin IX Estate Red 2010 "Its opaque purple color is accompanied by copious aromas of blueberries, cassis, pen ink, asphalt, licorice and subtle oak. Full-bodied and rich but light on its feet " WA 10/ bottles per lot US$ Hundred Acre Ark Cabernet Sauvignon 2006 "...delineated, beautifully dense, full-bodied Cabernet with dazzling fragrance and glycerin in addition to an extravagant fruit character...96." WA 12/ bottles per lot US$ Hundred Acre Kayli Morgan Vineyard Napa Cabernet Sauvignon 2006 "...this is a tour de force in winemaking. It is unquestionably one of the wines of the vintage...99." WA 12/ bottles per lot US$ Colgin IX Estate Red 2007 "This is another seamless tour de force in winemaking " WA 12/ bottles per lot US$ Kapcsandy Grand Vin State Lane Vineyard Cabernet Sauvignon 2007 one damp-stained label, one lightly torn label "Full-bodied and slow to unfold, but keeps revealing extra layers of depth and complexity only to be reigned in by gripping tannins...94." WS 10/ bottles per lot US$ Dominus Estate 2010 "...boasts an exceptional perfume of hoisin sauce, licorice, underbrush, forest floor, plums, black currants and jammy cherries intertwined with hints of cedar, baking spices and oak. Full-bodied and voluptuously textured...bravo! " WA 10/ bottles per lot US$ Hundred Acre Ark Cabernet Sauvignon 2010 "The 2010 Ark sits on the razors' edge of ripeness, as the Hundred Acre wines often do. At the same time, these wines have a way of developing notable complexity in bottle. There is a level of intensity matched by expressive inner perfume that is compelling " WA 12/ bottles per lot US$ Colgin IX Estate Red 2014 "Full-bodied, chewy and intense with great length and intensity. Silky and muscular yet agile and energetic...98." JS 1/ bottles per lot US$ NO LOT 180 ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com

173 FURTHER SELECTIONS from a NORTHEASTERN DOCTOR (LOTS ) We are proud to present another offering from this longtime and passionate collector as he attempts to thin out his amazing collection which just seems to have no bounds. As with his previous consignments, the property was purchased from top retail merchants at time of release and then put into climate-controlled home and commercial storage. This offering features an amazing assortment from the three great G's in the wine world: Gaja, Giacosa, and Grange, including multiple cases of Gaja's single vineyard wines from the iconic '97 Piedmont vintage and an incredible four cases of the '98 Grange! Don't overlook the rest of his consignment as it is chock-full of super high-scoring wines such as single-vineyard Giacosas and Fonseca ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com 181

174 RHÔNE Châteauneuf-du-Pape Reserve La Vieille Julienne 2001 Rhône two 6-pack s "It is full-bodied, with multiple layers, a seamless integration of acidity and tannin, and a finish that lasts over a minute " WA 2/ bottles per lot US$ ITALY Tignanello Antinori 1990 Tuscany one very top shoulder, five top shoulder, one lightly binsoiled label, one lightly marked label, two lightly scuffed labels "The palate reveals lots of life left in this wine giving a crisp backbone of acid and a medium+ level of finely grained tannins...very long finish...94." WA 11/ magnums (1.5L) per lot US$ GIACOSA Barbaresco Asili Riserva Bruno Giacosa 1996 Piedmont Lot 1350: two 6-pack s Lot 1351: four 3-pack s Lot 1352: "The wine impresses with its nuances as well as its extraordinarily rich, dense mid-palate...huge tannin, but equally massive concentration, extract, and overall harmony...98." WA 6/ bottles per lot US$ bottles per lot US$ magnums (1.5L) per lot US$ Barbaresco Rabaja Bruno Giacosa 1996 Piedmont Parcel: lots bottles per lot US$ bottles per lot US$ bottles per lot US$ Barbaresco Santo Stefano di Neive Bruno Giacosa 1996 Piedmont "Unmistakably traditional Piedmont--in the best sense--this Italian red offers pleasure all around...95." WS 8/ bottles per lot US$ Barolo Falletto di Serralunga Bruno Giacosa 1996 Piedmont Lot 1357: five with importer tags adhered to labels, one lightly bin-soiled label Lots 1358 & 1359: two 6-pack s Lot 1360: two with importer tags adhered to labels, four lightly scuffed labels Lot 1361: one wine-stained label, one with signs of old seepage, two 6-pack s Parcel: lots 1358 & 1359 "Extremely massive, with layers of concentration, high tannin, a muscular personality, and a 40+ second finish, this classic, young Barolo will require patience " WA 8/ bottles per lot US$ bottles per lot US$ bottles per lot US$ bottles per lot US$ bottles per lot US$ Barolo Falletto di Serralunga Riserva Bruno Giacosa 1996 Piedmont two 6-pack s one scuffed label "This muscular, massive wine gave me chills. It is an exquisite, virtually perfect Barolo...Awesome!...98." WA 6/ bottles per lot US$ Barolo Villero di Castiglione Falletto Bruno Giacosa 1996 Piedmont two 6-pack s Parcel: lots 1363 & 1364 "Yummy Barolo. Wonderful aromas of plums, blackberries and raspberries, with a hint of wet earth. Full-bodied, with fine tannins and a long finish. A balanced and pretty wine..." WS 12/ bottles per lot US$ bottles per lot US$ Barolo Le Rocche del Falletto di Serralunga Bruno Giacosa 1997 Piedmont two 6-pack s "The wine shows its most elegant side in the mouth, where the firming, polished tannins give the wine backbone and grace. It's deliciously silky and extra fine with microscopic precision...95." WA 6/ bottles per lot US$ SPECIALIST'S PICK: LOTS A brilliant showing of elegance and power with huge fruit and tannin, this wine still represents great aging potential. Dave Sutro 182 ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com

175 GAJA In the mid-nineteenth century the Gaja family began producing wine in Piedmont. Giovanni Gaja established the winery and Angelo, the fourth generation, joined the family firm in Angelo Gaja, born in 1940 and the present director of the family firm, has a degree in enology from Alba as well as a masters in economics. In 1974 he went to California, where he presumably fell under the spell of the barrique. Gaja has achieved unequivocal success aging his Barbarescos in small, new oak barrels, where the wine takes on a certain subtlety and suppleness without losing the personality of the Nebbiolo grape. Gaja is the largest private owner of vineyards in the Barbaresco zone, with 153 acres of vines in Barbaresco, Treiso, and Alba. They own fourteen different vineyards in Barbaresco and Treiso that make up their Barbaresco normale. Besides this regular Barbaresco, Gaja bottles three individual crus. Of the three, Costa Russi matures the soonest. It is the most open, with a sweeter taste and more intense aroma. Sori Tildin is more closed and concentrated; it is firm in texture and holds more in reserve. Sori San Lorenzo is the hardest of all in its youth, requiring age to show its real quality. It is the slowest maturing of the crus as well as the longest lived. Wasserman, Italy's Noble Red Wines Lots ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com 183

176 Sori San Lorenzo Gaja 1996 Piedmont Lot 1366: two lightly bin-soiled labels, one lightly nicked label Lots 1367 & 1368: Parcel: lots 1367 & 1368 "...amazingly dense and filled with silky, ripe, fat tannins that just balloon on the palate...refined and elegant despite its full-bodied, rich personality. Slightly smoky, toasted complexity on the blackberry-packed finish...96." WS 10/ bottles per lot US$ bottles per lot US$ bottles per lot US$ Sori Tildin Gaja 1996 Piedmont Lot 1369: one lightly bin-soiled label Lot 1370: lightly bin-soiled labels, includes 12-pack original wood case Lots 1371 & 1372: Parcel: lots 1371 & 1372 "Enormous on the palate, with multiple layers of fruit, soft tannin, huge body, and a knock-out finish, it is backward and brawny...96." WA 8/ bottles per lot US$ bottles per lot US$ bottles per lot US$ bottles per lot US$ Sperss Gaja 1996 Piedmont Parcel: lots "...enormously ripe...extremely full-bodied, with compelling intensity and purity, this is a large-scaled, massive Barolo " WA 8/ bottles per lot US$ bottles per lot US$ bottles per lot US$ Sperss Gaja 1996 double magnum (1) Liter (1) 1376 above 1 double magnum (3L) & one 5 liter (5L) per lot US$ Barolo Falletto di Serralunga Bruno Giacosa 1997 Piedmont two 6-pack s two lightly bin-soiled labels, two lightly scuffed labels "...plenty of acidity as well as high tannin, but concentrated, chewy flavors. The wine is tight, dense, impressive, and surprisingly structured for a " WA 6/ bottles per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com

177 Brunello di Montalcino Rennina Pieve Santa Restituta Gaja 1997 Tuscany Lots 1378 & 1379: Parcel: lots 1378 & 1379 "Full-bodied, with very polished tannins, it coats your mouth with fruit...93." WS 4/ bottles per lot US$ bottles per lot US$ magnums (1.5L) per lot US$ Sassicaia 1997 Tuscany Lot 1382: "...this Tuscan red is full-bodied on the palate, with intense velvety tannins. Long, long finish...93." WS 7/ bottles per lot US$ bottles per lot US$ Sori San Lorenzo Gaja 1997 Piedmont two 6-pack s Parcel: lots "There is tremendous balance here between the rich dark fruits, toasted oak and spices, and the more backward flavors of tar, licorice, and balsam all of which are wrapped around an intense core of minerality...96." WA 12/ bottles per lot US$ bottles per lot US$ bottles per lot US$ Sori Tildin Gaja 1997 Piedmont Lot 1386: Lot 1387: two 6-pack s "Full-bodied, with velvety, rich tannins and a long finish. Refined and very well-done...95." WS 11/ bottles per lot US$ bottles per lot US$ Sperss Gaja 1997 Piedmont Lots : Lot 1391: two 6-pack s Parcel: lots "A virtually perfect effort represents the essence of truffles, earth, and black cherries in its striking aromatics and multidimensional, opulent, full-bodied palate...99." WA 6/ bottles per lot US$ bottles per lot US$ bottles per lot US$ bottles per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com 185

178 Lots 1392 & ZACHYS tel fax zachys.com

179 Barbaresco Santo Stefano di Neive Riserva Bruno Giacosa 1998 Piedmont Lot 1393: two lightly scuffed labels "Delicious. Full-bodied, with luscious, ripe plum, berry and cherry character and silky tannins, all in balance. Goes on and on. Wonderful. Always refined and inviting..." WS 11/ bottles per lot US$ bottles per lot US$ Sassicaia 1998 Tuscany Lot 1397: three bin-soiled labels Lots : Lot 1399: six wrinkled labels Lot 1400: two lightly marked labels, one torn label, four wrinkled labels bottles per lot US$ bottles per lot US$ bottles per lot US$ bottles per lot US$ Barolo Falletto di Serralunga Bruno Giacosa 1998 Piedmont two 6-pack s "...reveals intensity and volume...perfume of rose water, melted tar, truffles, and cherry jam...spice box and cigar smoke also emerge. Full-bodied, dense, and powerfully tannic, yet extremely harmonious " WA 10/ bottles per lot US$ Ornellaia 1998 Tuscany two 6-pack s Lot 1396: two lightly scuffed labels bottles per lot US$ bottles per lot US$ Barolo Le Vigne Sandrone 2004 Piedmont Parcel: lots 1401 & 1402 "...a phenomenal effort. Sweet, long and pure...notable concentration it is made in a restrained style, showing remarkable elegance as well as harmony, with superb length and finessed tannins on the close...96." WA 1/ bottles per lot US$ bottles per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com 187

180 Lots 1408, 1409 & ZACHYS tel fax zachys.com

181 PORT CALIFORNIA Fonseca 1977 Douro bottom neck or better unless noted Lot 1403: eleven lightly damp-stained labels, eleven with signs of old seepage, Lot 1404: lightly damp-stained labels, five with signs of old seepage, Lot 1405: two very top shoulder, six lightly scuffed labels, four lightly oxidized capsules, one oxidized capsules, one slightly protruded cork, nine with signs of old seepage "This is in total balance now with such harmony. What amazing aromas...full and sweet, the tannins are complete dissolved. The fruit is perfect. This goes on for minutes " JS 8/ bottles per lot US$ bottles per lot US$ bottles per lot US$ Fonseca 1977 (11) ten bottom neck or better, one very top shoulder, five lightly damp-stained labels, three with signs of old seepage, includes 12-pack 1977 magnum (1) into neck, lightly scuffed label 1406 above 11 bottles & 1 magnum (1.5L) per lot US$ SPECIALIST'S PICK: LOTS The Fonseca '77 possesses the amazing combination of great aromatics and balance of fruit and tannin. It took forty years for this ultimate expression to be achieved, but it was certainly worth the wait! Dave Sutro DOMINUS ESTATE Dominus Estate 1991 lightly scuffed label 1407 one 6 Liter per lot US$ Dominus Estate 1994 Lot 1410: individual s Lot 1411: two wrinkled labels, two lightly bin-soiled labels, two lightly scuffed labels Lot 1412: lightly scuffed label "...incredibly fragrant nose of jammy black fruits, spice, smoke, and loamy, truffle-like scents...full-bodied, with thrilling levels of extract and richness...99." WA 12/ bottles per lot US$ bottles per lot US$ double magnums (3L) per lot US$ double magnums (3L) per lot US$ one 6 Liter per lot US$ AUSTRALIA Penfolds Grange 1998 South Australia two 6-pack s Parcel: lots "...astonishing wine, utterly seamless, maybe the best Grange yet. Powerful, aristocratic and impressive...99." WS 5/ bottles per lot US$ bottles per lot US$ bottles per lot US$ bottles per lot US$ Clarendon Hills Astralis 2002 South Australia two 6-pack s "...sweet tannin, sensational concentration, full body, an unctuous texture, and a full-throttle, tannic finish. Yet it reveals unbelievable elegance and finesse...a tour de force...99." WA 10/ bottles per lot US$ Clarendon Hills Astralis 2003 South Australia two 6-pack s "...revealing abundant amounts of sweet, ripe tannin, and huge extract, richness, and depth...99." WA 10/ bottles per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com 189

182 190 ZACHYS tel fax zachys.com

183 The SUPERLATIVE COLLECTION OF RICHARD & SUSAN ROGEL offered by THE UNIVERSITY OF MICHIGAN TO BENEFIT THE ROGEL CANCER CENTER (LOTS ) ZACHYS tel fax zachys.com 191

184 Let's set the stage: Longtime supporter of everything Michigan, Rich Rogel is at a dinner in Detroit in the early 90s with the one-and-only Bob Parker. By this point, Rich was already interested in fine wine Bob had helped him start buying in the late 80s. But at this particular dinner, they were talking about the 1989 Haut-Brion, a wine that, not long after, Bob would give 100 points (a score he would reaffirm in the Wine Advocate in 1992, 1993, 1994, 1997 and 2002). The 1989 Haut- Brion became a favorite of Mr. Rogel's, and he bought heavily. Now, you'll find quite a bit of pristine 1989 Haut-Brion in this offering all, of course, bought on release after that brief chat with Bob. Rich Rogel always had a taste for older wines, which is probably why he never drank that 1989 back when he bought it. He started feeding this interest with select purchases from Davis & Company Chicago and Butterfield & Butterfield in California (later called Bonhams & Butterfield). He also bought locally in Michigan, but Davis was the main source. Most importantly, his collection was put together during a relatively short period of time: around 8 years. Rich hasn't added to this collection in 25 years. It has rested, maturing slowly under temperature control, for this auction. Now, as a component of a pledged $150m to the University of Michigan Cancer Center (now the Rogel Cancer Center), and because he doesn't drink wine any more, Rich has decided to donate his entire collection to the University, which in turn has consigned it to Zachys. The wines were all stored in the Rogels' custom built, temperature and humidity-controlled wine cellar in Colorado. As usual, the collection was inspected in situ by a team of Zachys Specialists, accompanied by Michael Egan, who spent an entire week in the cellar. The wines were transported via dedicated, temperature-controlled truck to Zachys' White Plains warehouse for this auction. By bidding in this auction, you are supporting the University of Michigan Rogel Cancer Center, which is committed to improving the health and well-being of people who have or are at risk of getting cancer. As a National Cancer Institute-designated comprehensive cancer center, more than 500 members work to prevent cancer, improve outcomes for those diagnosed, and improve quality of life for cancer patients and survivors. Seventeen multidisciplinary cancer clinics offer one-stop access to teams of specialists who develop personalized treatment plans for each patient. Learn more at rogelcancercenter.org. 192 ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com

185 ZACHYS tel fax zachys.com 193

186 THE SUPERLATIVE COLLECTION OF RICHARD & SUSAN ROGEL OFFERED BY THE UNIVERSITY OF MICHIGAN TO BENEFIT THE ROGEL CANCER CENTER BORDEAUX CHÂTEAU CHEVAL BLANC Château Cheval Blanc 1959 St. Emilion, Premier Grand Cru Classé (a) upper-mid shoulder, damp-stained label, signs of old seepage "...bouquet slightly singed, with faintly raisiny fruit and, once again, very sweet on the palate, rich, glorious with perfect tannin and acidity...at best." MB bottle per lot US$ Château Cheval Blanc 1975 St. Emilion, Premier Grand Cru Classé (a) Lot 1420: three bottom neck or better, four very top shoulder, two top shoulder, one just below top shoulder, one bin-soiled label, one damp-stained label, six lightly scuffed labels, six with importer tags adhered to labels, two different importers, two with signs of old seepage Lot 1421: top shoulder, damp-stained label, signs of old seepage "...it has a deep ruby/garnet center, as well as plenty of sweet, ripe fruit with noticeable glycerin and extract. It is a rich, firmly-styled Cheval Blanc that juxtaposes power and tough tannin with plenty of sweet jammy fruit..." WA 2/ bottles per lot US$ double magnum (3L) per lot US$ Château Cheval Blanc 1982 St. Emilion, Premier Grand Cru Classé (a) Lot 1422: four top shoulder, one just below top shoulder Lot 1423: bottom neck or better, one damp-stained label Lot 1424: seven bottom neck or better, four very top shoulder, one just below top shoulder, one lightly marked label, one marked label Lot 1425: five bottom neck or better, three very top shoulder, four top shoulder Lot 1426: very top shoulder "Red fruits dominant on nose and very luscious on the palate. The wine is soft and plush, but lots of velvety red fruit throughout..." SF bottles per lot US$ bottles per lot US$ , bottles per lot US$ , bottles per lot US$ , bottles per lot US$ ,000 Château Cheval Blanc 1983 St. Emilion, Premier Grand Cru Classé (a) Lot 1427: two bottom neck or better, two very top shoulder, one faded label, lightly damp-stained labels Lot 1428: one very top shoulder, one top shoulder, winestained labels, signs of old seepage "...opulent, medium to full-bodied and lush, this is a gorgeous, very sexy, seductive style of Cheval Blanc...93." RP bottles per lot US$ magnums (1.5L) per lot US$ Château Cheval Blanc 1990 St. Emilion, Premier Grand Cru Classé (a) seven bottom neck or better, three very top shoulder, two top shoulder, one lightly damp-stained label, three lightly scuffed labels "...a complex bouquet of tobacco leaf, Christmas fruitcake, sweet black fruits, bordering on fig and plum...notions of new saddle leather, mint, and incense " WA 6/ bottles per lot US$ , ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com

187 CHÂTEAU HAUT-BRION Haut-Brion has the longest history of all the First Growths. It was even mentioned by Samuel Pepys in his diary entry of April 10,1663, when he was dining at the Royal Oak Tavern in Lombard Street, London:...and here drank a sort of French wine called Ho Bryan that hath a good and most particular taste I never met with. The famous Pontac family set up the estate in the first portion of the sixteenth century. Wealthy and well connected, they had the means to promote the wine in fashionable places, and by the early 1700s it was as well known as a wine of the highest quality. While parts were split off, the estate stayed with the family until it was passed to Joseph Fumel in He was largely responsible for creating much of what we see today, including the buildings, the gardens and the general layout of the property. He famously hosted a visit from Thomas Jefferson on May 25, 1787, and became Mayor of Bordeaux three years later. With its popularity waning under a succession of different owners, the estate was finally put up for auction in 1836, where it was purchased by the Larreau family. Two years later, in 1838, they managed to acquire a further piece of the estate previously lost through inheritance laws. Although it was included as a First Growth in the 1855 classification of Bordeaux, difficult times lay ahead. A further succession of owners and the depression of the early 1930s forced another sale. This time, successful American financier Clarence Dillon stepped up, and for a little under $200,000 walked away with the estate. It remains in the Dillon family today. Jeff Zacharia Château Haut-Brion 1945 Graves, Premier Cru Classé upper-mid shoulder, Illinois tax stamp adhered to binsoiled and lightly torn label, short capsule reveals vintage branded cork "It is a fabulously rich, monumental example of a fully mature Haut-Brion that exhibits no signs of decline. Awesome! " WA 10/ bottle per lot US$ Château Haut-Brion 1959 Graves, Premier Cru Classé Lot 1431: 6.5cm, lightly bin-soiled and scuffed label, signs of old seepage Lot 1432: 5cm, bin-soiled, damp-stained and lightly nicked label, Nicolas stamp, torn capsule "Sensational. Mature, generous and deep, a many-layered wine that shows sweet berry and chocolate flavors under a layer of slightly scratchy tannins...98." WS 4/ bottle per lot US$ magnum (1.5L) per lot US$ Château Haut-Brion 1961 Graves, Premier Cru Classé Lot 1433: 5cm, one lightly nicked label, one with importer tag adhered to label, one oxidized capsule, two slightly depressed corks, two with signs of old seepage, different importers Lot 1434: one 4.5cm, two 5cm, two 5.5cm, one 6cm, four lightly bin-soiled labels, three lightly scuffed labels, one lightly torn label, one lightly wine-stained label, two cut capsules reveal fully branded corks, three oxidized capsules, four different importers, two with signs of old seepage "...pure perfection, with gloriously intense aromas. This has always been a prodigious effort " WA 2/ bottles per lot US$ , bottles per lot US$15,000-24,000 Château Haut-Brion 1982 Graves, Premier Cru Classé four 3.5cm, one 4cm, lightly scuffed labels, one lightly oxidized capsule Very aromatic on the nose with lots of minerality and damp gravel notes. Interesting and expressive..." SF bottles per lot US$ Château Haut-Brion 1988 Pessac Léognan, Premier Cru Classé 2cm or better, one lightly bin-soiled label, one lightly nicked label, two lightly wine-stained labels, four with signs of old seepage "Full-bodied, with super silky tannins and a beautiful licorice, tar and fruit aftertaste. Long and complex...96." WS bottles per lot US$ Château Haut-Brion 1989 Pessac Léognan, Premier Cru Classé 2cm or better Lot 1437: one lightly scuffed label, one lightly wine-stained label Lot 1440: one lightly wine-stained label Lot 1441: one lightly nicked label Parcel: lots 1438 & 1439 "This is unbelievable. Greatest Haut-Brion ever made...fullbodied, with an amazing concentration of fruit and velvety tannins. The finish goes on for minutes " WS 5/ bottles per lot US$ , bottles per lot US$15,000-22, bottles per lot US$15,000-22, bottles per lot US$15,000-22, bottles per lot US$15,000-22,000 THE SUPERLATIVE COLLECTION OF RICHARD & SUSAN ROGEL OFFERED BY THE UNIVERSITY OF MICHIGAN TO BENEFIT THE ROGEL CANCER CENTER ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com 195

188 THE SUPERLATIVE COLLECTION OF RICHARD & SUSAN ROGEL OFFERED BY THE UNIVERSITY OF MICHIGAN TO BENEFIT THE ROGEL CANCER CENTER CHÂTEAU LAFITE ROTHSCHILD For as long as anyone can remember, Lafite has been the most highly regarded wine in Bordeaux. From their very first book, published in 1845, Cocks & Feret have listed Lafite first, and it was ranked first in the famous 1855 classification of Bordeaux. Fite is an old French term meaning small hill, rise or mound; it is from this humble feature in Bordeaux' somewhat bland landscape that France's most esteemed producer takes its name. The château itself is one of the oldest in Bordeaux, with much of it dating from the mid-sixteenth century. It was purchased by the wealthy Ségur family in the seventeenth century, but like much of the region at the time, the land was used for a variety of farming. Beginning in the 1670s, the Ségurs spent around twenty years converting a large portion of the land to vineyards. With Latour and Calon, as well as Lafite, under their ownership, the Ségurs began to find a market for their wines in London. It was first mentioned in the London Gazette in 1707 and soon became famous: by the early 1730s, it was a favorite of the Prime Minister, Robert Walpole. Lafite remained in the Ségur family until It was sold several times, finally to Baron de Rothschild in 1868, by which time there were some seventy-four hectares of vines. It was a new era of industrial wealth and the Rothschild purchase certainly added much celebrity to the area. Château Lafite Rothschild 1945 upper-mid shoulder, torn label, short capsule reveals vintage branded cork "Just about every note over the years refers to a glorious fragrance which seems to unravel itself after 15 or 20 minutes in the glass...a glorious mouthful..." MB 4/ bottle per lot US$ Château Lafite Rothschild 1947 bottom neck or better, one heavily bin-soiled label, marked labels, one nicked label, two different importers, signs of old seepage, rebouchée au Château en 1986 "Combining richness and charm...its appearance mellowing as well as was its bouquet. Still fairly sweet, soft, drinking well...." MB bottles per lot US$ Château Lafite Rothschild 1959 upper-mid shoulder, lightly damp-stained and nicked label "One of the best-ever Lafites...The extraordinary ability to exude not only an immediate cedary perfume...a Lafite specialty, the way it opens up further avenues of fragrance and subtle by-paths, lingering in the mouth..." MB 12/ bottle per lot US$ Château Lafite Rothschild 1960 Lot 1445: four very top shoulder, one top shoulder, one heavily damp-stained label, two torn labels, three oxidized capsules, two protruded corks Lot 1446: very top shoulder, signs of old seepage magnums (1.5L) per lot US$ jeroboam (4.5L) per lot US$ Château Lafite Rothschild 1961 Lot 1447: two upper shoulder, one upper-mid shoulder, damp-stained labels, one torn capsule Lot 1448: upper shoulder, heavily damp-stained label, torn capsule reveals cork, signs of old seepage "...many 5-star notes - gentle, spicy, silky tannins, a certain delicacy and always great length...it had the sweetness of fully ripe grapes and alcohol, a mouthfilling flavour, very good tannins and acidity. Complete...." MB 5/ bottles per lot US$ imperial (6L) per lot US$10,000-15,000 Château Lafite Rothschild 1982 Lot 1449: five top shoulder, three just below top shoulder, two upper shoulder, one lightly scuffed label, two lightly corroded capsules, one with signs of old seepage Lot 1450: bottom neck, damp-stained, scuffed and lightly nicked label, signs of old seepage "It was subdued and quiet...tobacco and dark fruit notes on the palate, but slow to open..." SF bottles per lot US$22,000-36, jeroboam (5L) per lot US$15,000-22,000 Château Lafite Rothschild 1985 three bottom neck or better, one very top shoulder, one lightly bin-soiled label, one lightly scuffed label "A very intense, firmly structured wine. It reveals notes of cedar, leather and herbs with a firm well-structured finish. Shows great complexity and depth." DS 9/ bottles per lot US$ Château Lafite Rothschild 1990 Lot 1452: four very top shoulder, two top shoulder, two with signs of old seepage Lot 1453: ten bottom neck or better, two very top shoulder, one nicked label Lot 1454: ten bottom neck or better, two very top shoulder, two with signs of old seepage "...it boasts gorgeous aromas of cedar, tobacco leaf, cassis, and lead pencil shavings. The explosive aromas are followed by a fleshy, full-bodied wine...96." WA 6/ bottles per lot US$ bottles per lot US$ , bottles per lot US$ , ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com

189 CHÂTEAU LATOUR Some of my fondest wine memories are of drinking wine bottles of the renowned Château Latour. It is, without a doubt, one of the greatest wine estates in the world. While its history goes well back to the fourteenth century, Latour began to be clearly defined as one of the greatest wine estates in the world in the mid-nineteenth century, and amazingly, It has kept that position for the last 150 years. Their wines, which are known for their power, richness and longevity, are sought after by collectors and wine lovers throughout the world. As Robert M. Parker says of Château Latour in The World's Greatest Wine Estates, The wine produced here has been an impeccable model of consistent excellence, in great, mediocre, and poor vintages. For that reason, many have long considered Latour to be the Médoc's finest wine Latour remains one of the most concentrated, rich, tannic, and full-bodied wines in the world. In 2000, I had the wonderful opportunity to taste over twenty-five vintages of Château Latour, including fourteen wines older than 1961 and four from the nineteenth century. It was an evening I will never forget. The wines were so rich, alive and fresh. What an extraordinary experience it was to be able to taste the 1900 and the 1899 side by side and discuss the differences, or to argue whether the 1955 or the 1949 is showing better right now (at my table we all thought the 1955 had the slight edge). In the end we tasted Latour from a 125 year span and although there was a lot of discussion about which were the better wines, the final conclusion of everyone in the room was that, Latour makes some of greatest wines that any of us have ever tasted. Jeff Zacharia Château Latour 1945 one upper-mid shoulder, one mid shoulder, bin-soiled and torn labels, slightly protruded corks, short capsules reveal vintage branded corks "Full-bodied and brimming over with sweet fruit character, ripe and velvety tannins. Long and succulent finish " WS 8/ bottles per lot US$ Château Latour 1949 mid shoulder, lightly bin-soiled and torn label, short capsule "Sweet on the attack, with a rare opulence, a voluptuous texture, full body, terrific freshness, and a chewy, fleshy, succulent finish...98." WA 6/ bottle per lot US$ Château Latour 1955 one top shoulder, two upper shoulder, three upper-mid shoulder, bin-soiled labels, one lightly torn label, one corroded capsule, short capsules reveal Château branded corks, three corroded capsules reveal corks, three with signs of old seepage "...its extraordinary perfume...seductive. It is full-bodied, with a sweet, intense mid-palate, plenty of power, and decades of life remaining...94." WA 6/ bottles per lot US$ Château Latour 1959 one top shoulder, two just below top shoulder, three upper shoulder, one upper-mid shoulder, five bin-soiled labels, four marked labels, three torn labels, three wine-stained labels, one lightly corroded capsule, short capsules reveal Château branded corks, four different importers "Very expressive and nuanced...this is a spectacular bottle..." SF bottles per lot US$13,000-22,000 Château Latour 1961 Lot 1459: just below top shoulder, tissue paper adhered to lightly bin-soiled label, slightly protruded cork, short capsule reveals Château branded cork Lot 1460: upper-mid shoulder, bin-soiled and scuffed label, corroded capsule "Very robust and impressive wine...long finish, great balance, still fresh and again does not seem like it has the age on it that it does..." SF bottle per lot US$ magnum (1.5L) per lot US$ ,000 Château Latour 1964 bottom neck or better, three lightly damp-stained labels, lightly scuffed labels, Nicolas stamps, one loose capsule reveals fully branded cork, one rebouchée au Château en 1988, two with signs of old seepage "It goes on and on gaining extra dimensions...marvelous mouthful, plump, perfectly balanced, rounded...bouquet of cedar and old oak...fully mature, lovely flavour...." MB 10/ bottles per lot US$ THE SUPERLATIVE COLLECTION OF RICHARD & SUSAN ROGEL OFFERED BY THE UNIVERSITY OF MICHIGAN TO BENEFIT THE ROGEL CANCER CENTER ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com 197

190 THE SUPERLATIVE COLLECTION OF RICHARD & SUSAN ROGEL OFFERED BY THE UNIVERSITY OF MICHIGAN TO BENEFIT THE ROGEL CANCER CENTER Château Latour 1966 Lot 1462: one top shoulder, one upper shoulder, one upper-mid shoulder, heavily deteriorated labels, two oxidized capsules Lot 1463: one top shoulder, one just below top shoulder, two upper shoulder, two damp-stained labels, one lightly bin-soiled label, one cut capsule reveals fully branded cork, one loose capsule reveals fully branded cork, one with thumb tack on capsule, three different importers "This showed spectacularly. A real standout...a great bottle to add to your cellar. Beautiful tannins, resolved and soft, perfect for drinking now and showcasing everything that you come to expect and look for in Latour..." SF bottles per lot US$ bottles per lot US$ Château Latour 1970 one very top shoulder, three just below top shoulder, five upper shoulder, one upper-mid shoulder, bin-soiled and glue-stained labels, two damp-stained labels, one heavily damp-stained label, three different importers "Full-bodied, fabulously concentrated and intense, with a sweet inner-core of fruit...98." WA 6/ bottles per lot US$ Château Latour 1975 two bottom neck or better, two very top shoulder, one top shoulder, three just below top shoulder, two upper shoulder, three bin-soiled labels, one damp-stained label, seven lightly bin-soiled labels, one lightly damp-stained label, one marked label, one torn label, one depressed cork, one oxidized capsule, three different importers "Medium bodied and crisp in the mouth with a medium level of velvety tannins...long spicy finish...93." WA 11/ bottles per lot US$ Château Latour 1982 bottom neck or better unless noted Lot 1466: two very top shoulder Lot 1467: three very top shoulder, four top shoulder Lot 1468: three very top shoulder, two top shoulder, two just below top shoulder "This is the freshest, most resounding and interesting example of this wine I have ever tried. Very approachable and enjoyable, with the Latour strength, but still soft with an excellent finish..." SF bottles per lot US$11,000-17, bottles per lot US$15,000-22, bottles per lot US$15,000-22,000 Château Latour 1986 five bottom neck or better, four very top shoulder, two just below top shoulder, one upper shoulder, one lightly nicked label, one nicked label, two different importers, two with signs of old seepage "...consistently been outstanding...medium-bodied, austere, but youthful, vigorous, and concentrated...90." WA 6/ bottles per lot US$ Château Latour 1990 bottom neck or better unless noted Lot 1470: two very top shoulder, one top shoulder, three just below top shoulder, three lightly scuffed labels Lot 1471: one very top shoulder Lot 1472: nine very top shoulder, two just below top shoulder, two lightly scuffed labels, one scuffed label "The nose was tremendous with all the typical Latour characteristics...it was concentrated and dense on the palate... Very open and generous and wonderful to drink at present..." SF bottles per lot US$ bottles per lot US$ , bottles per lot US$ , ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com

191 CHÂTEAU MARGAUX Perhaps the grandest of the Bordeaux châteaux, Château Margaux is the epitome of style and refinement. At Château Margaux one has truly arrived at the heart and soul of Bordeaux, the world's most renowned wine region. For centuries before the French Revolution, the château was owned by the Lestonnac family. The revolution, though, saw the estate's owners beheaded, and when the heirs were unable to pay the costs of running the château, Margaux was put up for auction. The successful bidder, the Marquis de la Colonilla, demolished the old château, and in 1802 work began on the grand château we know today. The Château was sold several times until it was acquired by the Ginestets, longtime shareholders who finally became sole owners in 1949, with the purchase financed by the sale of their St Emilion property, Clos Fortet. However, First Growth châteaux are expensive to run, and to finance the operations of the estate, the owner sold off the vineyards of Dufort Vivens in the 1960s and transferred Cos d'estournel to his sister in Even those moves, though, were not enough, and collapse of the Bordeaux market in the early 1970s forced Ginestet to sell the château in 1976 to Greek supermarket magnate Andre Mentzelopoulos. A serious oenophile, he was also a major shareholder in the French wine firm, Nicolas. Château Margaux 1945 Margaux, Premier Cru Classé upper-mid shoulder, tape adhered to bin-soiled label, short capsule reveals vintage branded cork "A vivacious and fabulously fragrant bottle at the Sveass dinner and showing its magnificent best at both of the Wagner's Margaux tastings in 1997 and " MB bottle per lot US$ Château Margaux 1961 Margaux, Premier Cru Classé one upper shoulder, three upper-mid shoulder, one dampstained label, three lightly bin-soiled labels, one scuffed label, one wine-stained label, two different importers, one with cage around bottle "Another splendid '61...with a fully evolved bouquet; sweet entry, dry finish, excellent body, fruit and flavour. Great length, still concentrated...." MB bottles per lot US$ Château Margaux 1982 Margaux, Premier Cru Classé bottom neck or better unless noted Lot 1475: two very top shoulder, three top shoulder, one just below top shoulder, one upper shoulder, one lightly marked label, one marked label, three different importers, two with signs of old seepage Lot 1476: three very top shoulder, five top shoulder, one just below top shoulder, three damp-stained labels, one lightly damp-stained label, two lightly scuffed labels, one marked label, one torn label, three with signs of old seepage Lot 1477: five very top shoulder, five top shoulder, one just below top shoulder, one nicked label Lot 1478: five very top shoulder, four top shoulder, two just below top shoulder, two with signs of old seepage Lot 1479: two very top shoulder, eight top shoulder, one just below top shoulder, one lightly marked label, one lightly scuffed label, one nicked label This wine was breathtaking!...beautiful as soon as it was opened and did not really evolve over the course of the evening, but stayed at a really great spot... SF bottles per lot US$ bottles per lot US$ , bottles per lot US$ , bottles per lot US$ , bottles per lot US$ ,000 Château Margaux 1983 Margaux, Premier Cru Classé Lot 1480: four bottom neck or better, five very top shoulder, two top shoulder, one just below top shoulder, two lightly bin-soiled labels Lot 1481: one bottom neck, six very top shoulder, four top shoulder, one just below top shoulder, one lightly binsoiled label, one lightly torn label, two scuffed labels Lot 1482: seven top shoulder, four just below top shoulder, one upper shoulder, one bin-soiled label, one lightly marked label, one lightly scuffed label, two different importers, two with signs of old seepage "The wine is medium to full-bodied, deep, rich, and powerful, with sweet tannins and loads of fruit concentration...96." WA 1/ bottles per lot US$ bottles per lot US$ bottles per lot US$ THE SUPERLATIVE COLLECTION OF RICHARD & SUSAN ROGEL OFFERED BY THE UNIVERSITY OF MICHIGAN TO BENEFIT THE ROGEL CANCER CENTER ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com 199

192 THE SUPERLATIVE COLLECTION OF RICHARD & SUSAN ROGEL OFFERED BY THE UNIVERSITY OF MICHIGAN TO BENEFIT THE ROGEL CANCER CENTER Château Margaux 1986 Margaux, Premier Cru Classé bottom neck or better unless noted Lot 1483: one very top shoulder Lot 1484: two very top shoulder, one scuffed label, one wine-stained label, one with signs of old seepage "...emotionally moving. Still incredibly youthful, it showed incredible focus and depth, all backed up by considerable structure...striking in every way " AG 2/ bottles per lot US$ bottles per lot US$ Château Margaux 1988 Margaux, Premier Cru Classé bottom neck or better unless noted Lot 1485: two very top shoulder Lot 1486: one lightly torn label "Full-bodied, with ultra velvety tannins and loads of berry and chocolate character. Dense and firm. Big wine, muscular...96." WS bottles per lot US$ bottles per lot US$ Château Margaux 1990 Margaux, Premier Cru Classé bottom neck or better unless noted Lot 1487: two very top shoulder, one damp-stained label, one nicked label Lot 1488: two very top shoulder, two top shoulder, two just below top shoulder, one slightly protruded cork "Round and generous with low acidity, but an opulent, full-bodied richness that is fresh with laser-like precision " WA 6/ bottles per lot US$ , bottles per lot US$ ,000 CHÂTEAU MOUTON ROTHSCHILD Château Mouton Rothschild 1949 Pauillac, Deuxième Cru Classé upper-mid shoulder, lightly bin-soiled label, short capsule reveals fully branded cork "...possesses superb concentration and a remarkably long finish. It appears to be fully mature, yet the balance, length, and tannin level...a formidable Mouton...94." WA 10/ bottle per lot US$ Château Mouton Rothschild 1955 Pauillac, Deuxième Cru Classé upper-mid shoulder, bin-soiled labels, one heavily winestained label, one torn label "In the mouth, there is stunning concentration, magnificent extraction of fruit, and plenty of tannin in the long finish. The wine still tastes remarkably young...amazing!...97." WA 10/ bottles per lot US$ Château Mouton Rothschild 1959 Pauillac, Deuxième Cru Classé upper-mid shoulder, lightly scuffed labels, short capsules reveal vintage branded corks, one lightly corroded capsule partially reveals cork, two different importers, one with signs of old seepage "...one of the greatest Moutons...Astonishingly young and unevolved " RP bottles per lot US$ Château Mouton Rothschild 1961 Pauillac, Deuxième Cru Classé upper shoulder, damp-stained and torn label "Full-bodied, rich, and super-intense, this was a profound bottle of 1961 Mouton that would have stood up against the compelling " RP bottle per lot US$ Château Mouton Rothschild 1966 Pauillac, Deuxième Cru Classé Lot 1493: one upper shoulder, one upper-mid shoulder, three mid shoulder, bin-soiled labels, one damp-stained label, one heavily wine-stained label, one lightly torn label, one scuffed label, four different importers, signs of old seepage Lot 1494: upper-mid shoulder, bin-soiled label, signs of old seepage "...powerful tannin in the finish, which contributes to the dry, austere character this example has always exhibited. One of the more intellectually-styled Moutons...a classic example of the vintage..." RP bottles per lot US$ magnum (1.5L) per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com

193 Château Mouton Rothschild 1975 Lot 1495: two upper shoulder, one upper-mid shoulder, bin-soiled labels, two damp-stained labels, two lightly wine-stained labels, one scuffed label, two torn labels Lot 1496: one top shoulder, one just below top shoulder, one damp-stained label, one lightly damp-stained label, scuffed labels, one with tissue paper adhered to label, signs of old seepage "...a good dark ruby/garnet color, a sweet nose of cedar, chocolate, cassis, and spices, good ripe fruit and extraction, and a weighty, large-scaled, tannic finish..." RP bottles per lot US$ double magnums (3L) per lot US$ Château Mouton Rothschild 1982 Lot 1497: four very top shoulder, one top shoulder, two lightly scuffed labels, one marked label Lot 1498: two bottom neck or better, one very top shoulder, five top shoulder, two just below top shoulder, two upper shoulder, five lightly damp-stained labels, one marked label Lot 1499: three very top shoulder, seven top shoulder, one just below top shoulder, one upper shoulder, one lightly damp-stained label, eight scuffed labels, one with signs of old seepage Lot 1500: three very top shoulder, five top shoulder, three just below top shoulder, one upper shoulder, four scuffed labels, two torn labels, three different importers Lot 1501: two very top shoulder, five top shoulder, four just below top shoulder, one upper shoulder, one lightly bin-soiled label, one lightly torn label, one marked label, eleven with importer tags adhered to labels Lot 1502: very top shoulder, damp-stained label, signs of old seepage "Half the people in the room picked this as the favorite in this lineup...did keep getting better in the glass and showed a tremendous depth of fruit and formidable structure..." SF bottles per lot US$ bottles per lot US$11,000-16, bottles per lot US$11,000-16, bottles per lot US$11,000-16, bottles per lot US$11,000-16, double magnum (3L) per lot US$ Château Mouton Rothschild 1983 two bottom neck or better, two very top shoulder, three top shoulder, two damp-stained labels, one torn label, three different importers "The classic Mouton lead-pencil, cedary nose has begun to emerge. This medium dark ruby, elegant, medium-bodied wine...the flavors are ripe and moderately rich." RP bottles per lot US$ Château Mouton Rothschild 1986 Lot 1504: four top shoulder, four just below top shoulder, one wine-stained label, three with signs of old seepage Lot 1505: one bottom neck, three very top shoulder, eight top shoulder, one with signs of old seepage "It boasts a full body of ultra richness, extraordinary length and beauty and an almost chiseled precision to the quality with fabulous length. It lasts for minutes on the palate " JS 3/ bottles per lot US$ bottles per lot US$ ,000 Château Mouton Rothschild 1990 Lot 1506: four very top shoulder, two top shoulder, one nicked label, one wine-stained label, one with signs of old seepage Lot 1507: five bottom neck or better, two very top shoulder, two top shoulder, two just below top shoulder, one upper shoulder, one scuffed label "Black red. Coffee, cigar box and chocolate aromas. Fullbodied, yet harmonious, with a lovely, silky texture. A caressing and rich wine...97." WS 6/ bottles per lot US$ bottles per lot US$ THE SUPERLATIVE COLLECTION OF RICHARD & SUSAN ROGEL OFFERED BY THE UNIVERSITY OF MICHIGAN TO BENEFIT THE ROGEL CANCER CENTER ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com 201

194 THE SUPERLATIVE COLLECTION OF RICHARD & SUSAN ROGEL OFFERED BY THE UNIVERSITY OF MICHIGAN TO BENEFIT THE ROGEL CANCER CENTER PÉTRUS Pétrus today is a little over eleven hectares, including five hectares purchased in 1969 from neighboring Château Gazin. The vineyards have clay topsoil and gravelly subsoil, allowing good initial water retention but excellent longer term drainage. The vines are old, around forty to fifty years, planted with ninety percent Merlot and five percent Cabernet Franc. To increase concentration the vines are pruned extensively and a green harvest is performed. At harvest time, nearly two hundred workers pick the grapes at their peak of balance and ripeness. Sometimes up to four passes are needed but if pressed, as in 1982, the entire harvest can be completed in just one day. The grapes are partially destemmed and after a fairly lengthy maceration period, sometimes almost a month, the wine spends twenty months in new oak before being fined (but not filtered) and bottled. Pétrus is a classic example of careful vineyard management and winemaking yet the result leaves evidence of something even greater. These methods combine with exquisite terroir for Merlot to create something that is, in good vintages, not only earthshatteringly tasty, but distinctive, lending the name Pétrus majesty because of its quality but also its inimitability. Pétrus 1945 Pomerol Lot 1508: upper-mid shoulder, heavily bin-soiled and lightly nicked label, corroded capsule partially reveals cork Lot 1509: mid shoulder, slightly protruded cork, corroded capsule "...the nose offers aromas of black fruits, licorice, truffles, and smoked meat. Massively-constituted, with formidably high tannin and extract levels...98." WA 10/ bottle per lot US$ bottle per lot US$ Pétrus 1947 Pomerol upper-mid shoulder, lightly bin-soiled and torn label, cut capsule reveals vintage branded cork "...the most decadent 'wine of the century'...a massive, unctuously-textured, viscous wine with amazing power, richness, and sweet fruit...it is so sweet, thick, and rich... loaded with dream-like quantities of fruit, as well as high alcohol, but there is no noticeable tannin " WA 11/ bottle per lot US$ Pétrus 1959 Pomerol upper-mid shoulder, lightly torn label, corroded capsule, signs of old seepage "A monumental wine, with lots of structure...medium ruby-garnet in color, with black olive and chocolate aromas. Full-bodied...97." WS 10/ bottle per lot US$ Pétrus 1961 Pomerol one top shoulder, one upper-mid shoulder, one with handwriting on label, one with signs of old seepage "...amber and garnet...extremely full-bodied, with huge amounts of glycerin and alcohol, this unctuously-textured, thick wine makes for an awesome mouthful " WA 2/ bottles per lot US$16,000-24, ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com

195 Pétrus 1964 Pomerol Lot 1513: upper-mid shoulder, importer tag adhered to lightly damp-stained label, signs of old seepage Lot 1514: mid shoulder, corroded capsule partially reveals cork, signs of old seepage Lot 1515: one top shoulder, two just below top shoulder, one upper shoulder, one lightly torn label, three lightly oxidized capsules, one slightly depressed cork, two different importers, three with signs of old seepage "This huge, massively-endowed wine is packed with alcohol, glycerin, and high tannin. There is stupendous extraction of fruit and amazing length...97." WA 10/ bottle per lot US$ magnum (1.5L) per lot US$ magnums (1.5L) per lot US$24,000-36,000 Pétrus 1970 Pomerol Lot 1516: one very top shoulder, three upper shoulder, two damp-stained labels, three lightly corroded capsules, two different importers, two with signs of old seepage Lot 1517: one very top shoulder, one top shoulder, one just below top shoulder, one upper shoulder, two uppermid shoulder, five lightly corroded capsules, two different importers Lot 1518: three just below top shoulder, two upper shoulder, one upper-mid shoulder, three heavily damp-stained labels, lightly corroded capsules Lot 1519: top shoulder, bin-soiled label, corroded capsule, signs of old seepage "It is a profound Pétrus...unctuously textured and very fullbodied, with extraordinary sweetness and glycerin, and a layered, viscous finish...99." RP bottles per lot US$ , bottles per lot US$14,000-22, bottles per lot US$14,000-22, magnum (1.5L) per lot US$ ,000 Pétrus 1971 Pomerol top shoulder, damp-stained label, corroded capsule "...rich, velvety, full-bodied wine with layers of silky fruit. The 1971 must surely be the wine of the vintage...95." RP bottle per lot US$ Pétrus 1975 Pomerol Lot 1521: upper-mid shoulder, lightly corroded capsules, two with signs of old seepage Lot 1522: one just below top shoulder, two upper shoulder, one upper-mid shoulder, two torn labels, one winestained label, one lightly torn capsule partially reveals cork, one protruded cork, two different importers, two with signs of old seepage Lot 1523: one top shoulder, one just below top shoulder, one slightly protruded cork, signs of old seepage "...reveals a youthful, rustic, brutally powerful style... Extremely full-bodied, ferociously tannic, but awesomely concentrated...98." WA 2/ bottles per lot US$ bottles per lot US$ magnums (1.5L) per lot US$ ,000 Pétrus 1978 Pomerol top shoulder, heavily scuffed label "...modest in terms of intensity, autumnal and a little leafy, a light marine influence developing with time and a hint of wild mint. The palate is medium-bodied with light tannin, balanced...there is harmony here, and a sense of honesty..." WA 7/ bottle per lot US$ THE SUPERLATIVE COLLECTION OF RICHARD & SUSAN ROGEL OFFERED BY THE UNIVERSITY OF MICHIGAN TO BENEFIT THE ROGEL CANCER CENTER ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com 203

196 THE SUPERLATIVE COLLECTION OF RICHARD & SUSAN ROGEL OFFERED BY THE UNIVERSITY OF MICHIGAN TO BENEFIT THE ROGEL CANCER CENTER Pétrus 1979 Pomerol Lot 1525: one very top shoulder, two top shoulder, three just below top shoulder, three upper shoulder, one uppermid shoulder, two damp-stained labels, two torn labels, three different importers, two with signs of old seepage Lot 1526: one bottom neck, one very top shoulder, dampstained labels "...firm backbone of silky tannins and sweet black olive, vanilla and berry aromas and flavors." WS 2/ bottles per lot US$10,000-16, magnums (1.5L) per lot US$ Pétrus 1982 Pomerol bottom neck or better unless noted Lot 1527: one very top shoulder, one lightly damp-stained label, one lightly oxidized capsule, two different importers Lot 1528: lightly nicked label, signed by Christian Moueix Lot 1529: one wine-stained label, one with signs of old seepage Lot 1530: tape adhered to nicked and wrinkled label, cut capsule reveals fully branded cork, signs of old seepage Lot 1531: one lightly scuffed label, one lightly wine-stained label, one nicked label Lot 1532: handwriting on lightly damp-stained, gluestained and nicked label, depressed cork, signed by Christian Moueix "Full-bodied, silky, firm and fresh. Long. A beauty. One of the best bottles I have ever had...96." WS 6/ bottles per lot US$20,000-34, magnum (1.5L) per lot US$ , magnums (1.5L) per lot US$48,000-75, double magnum (3L) per lot US$17,000-26, double magnums (3L) per lot US$50,000-80, jeroboam (5L) per lot US$28,000-42,000 Pétrus 1985 Pomerol very top shoulder, lightly glue-stained and scuffed label, signs of old seepage "Another superb bottle from Pétrus. Solid as a rock with mint, raspberry, cherry and tar character, full body and firm tannins...93." WS 10/ jeroboam (5L) per lot US$ ,000 Pétrus 1986 Pomerol Lot 1534: bottom neck or better, two damp-stained labels, two torn labels Lot 1535: very top shoulder, lightly scuffed label, signs of old seepage "Dark red, with an amber edge. Aromas of chocolate, stewed berries, Merlot and raisins. Full-bodied, velvety and rich. Lovely palate..." WS 6/ magnums (1.5L) per lot US$13,000-19, double magnum (3L) per lot US$ Pétrus 1989 Pomerol bottom neck, bin-soiled label, signs of old seepage It's a giant, yet also sophisticated and reserved...beautiful aromas of fruits and spices. Full-bodied, with opulent fruit and a depth of flavor that lasts for minutes on the palate WS 10/ double magnum (3L) per lot US$14,000-20,000 Pétrus 1990 Pomerol bottom neck or better "...massive in the mouth as well as incredibly pure and well-delineated...an incredible achievement! " WA 6/ bottles per lot US$40,000-60, ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com

197 Lot 1527 ZACHYS tel fax zachys.com 205

198 THE SUPERLATIVE COLLECTION OF RICHARD & SUSAN ROGEL OFFERED BY THE UNIVERSITY OF MICHIGAN TO BENEFIT THE ROGEL CANCER CENTER CHÂTEAU LA MISSION HAUT-BRION Although the histories of Château Haut-Brion and La Mission are entwined, both have always been separate entities, sharing a common family name. It is only since 1983 that they have shared the same proprietor when it was taken over by the owners of Haut-Brion On November 2nd 1983, the present owners acquired La Mission after the owner Francis Dewavrin was unable to resolved internal family disputes over the way the property was managed and it marks a convergence of histories between Château Haut-Brion and La Mission, though only in the sense that they share the same owner: Clarence Dillon. He enlisted Jean-Bernard Delmas as Château-manager and there followed a period that has consolidated La Mission's position as one of the greatest estates, hovering just outside the First Growths. Their commitment to innovation and improvements has been a catalyst for many estates in the Graves region to improve their wines, particularly with respect of clonal selection research. In 1987 the old chai was renovated, a new state-of-the-art cuvier was installed and a new bottling line was implemented in It must be emphasized that the estates are treated as separate entities, even though at some point the vines of both run side-byside. In 2003 Jean-Bernard retired and handed the reins over to his son, Jean-Philippe Delmas. The Wines Certainly since the arrival of Jean-Bernard Delmas the style of wine has improved: the wine is more pure and the volatile acidity has been eradicated. At its best (the 1966, 1975, 1998) La Mission is a massive, tannic behemoth that has more in common with Château Latour than Château Haut-Brion. It is a powerful, sturdy wine with firm tannins and admirable longevity This is definitely one of the most intriguing wines in Bordeaux: the appeal of La Mission is that it seems to avoid the vagaries of wine-making trends and wears its heart on its sleeve. This is a classic wine in every sense of the word and it can make a seamless match with food. A poor La Mission is still a better wine than most; a good La Mission is a great wine and a great La Mission can be a religious experience. I have met few wine-critics who do not hold this estate in high esteem: it is a wine for true wine-lovers. Neil Martin, The Wine Advocate, November 2006 Château La Mission Haut-Brion 1959 Graves, Cru Classé two bottom neck or better, three very top shoulder, one upper shoulder, two lightly bin-soiled labels, one lightly wine-stained label, Nicolas stamp on labels, one rebouchée en 1988 branded cork, one cut capsule reveals fully branded cork, two different importers "...as great as the 1961 La Mission is, the 1959 is a richer, deeper-colored, more concentrated and powerful wine... Spicy and super-concentrated, with a dense, plummy/ purple color...young, broodingly backward, formidablyendowed " WA 4/ bottles per lot US$18,000-28,000 Château La Mission Haut-Brion 1961 Graves, Cru Classé Lot 1539: one just below top shoulder, one upper shoulder, damp-stained labels, lightly oxidized capsules, short capsules reveal vintage branded corks, one with signs of old seepage Lot 1540: two top shoulder, three just below top shoulder, one upper shoulder, three nicked labels, one wine-stained label, short capsules reveal vintage branded corks "Dense, full-bodied, alcoholic, and super-rich, this soft, opulently-textured wine makes for a fabulous drink " RP bottles per lot US$ , bottles per lot US$20,000-30,000 Château La Mission Haut-Brion 1975 Graves, Cru Classé Lot 1541: three top shoulder, one just below top shoulder, one bin-soiled label, three lightly bin-soiled labels, one lightly nicked label, importer tag adhered to labels, one cut capsule reveals fully branded cork, one oxidized capsule, one with signs of old seepage Lot 1542: one very top shoulder, three top shoulder, one just below top shoulder, one bin-soiled label, one dampstained label, one lightly bin-soiled label, two different importers Lot 1543: three very top shoulder, four top shoulder, three just below top shoulder, one upper shoulder, one uppermid shoulder, two lightly torn labels, three lightly winestained labels, three nicked labels, importer tags adhered to labels, two slightly protruded corks, two with signs of old seepage Lot 1544: bottom neck, torn capsule "...indisputably the wine of the vintage...based on the aromatics alone, this offering would merit a perfect score... very concentrated, dense and remarkably youthful...97." WA 8/ bottles per lot US$ bottles per lot US$ bottles per lot US$ , magnum (1.5L) per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com

199 Château La Mission Haut-Brion 1982 Graves, Cru Classé Lot 1545: bottom neck, wrinkled label Lot 1546: three bottom neck or better, five very top shoulder, four top shoulder, two lightly marked labels, one wrinkled label, two slightly protruded corks, six different importers Lot 1547: very top shoulder, lightly wine-stained label, cut capsule reveals fully branded cork Massively rich aromas of tobacco wrapper and of Mirabelle. Wow! Long, deep, alcoholic, with a viscous texture...outstanding plus. FH bottle per lot US$ bottles per lot US$ , magnum (1.5L) per lot US$ CHÂTEAU PALMER Château Palmer 1928 Margaux, Troisième Cru Classé Lot 1548: just below top shoulder, scuffed labels, one cut capsule reveals fully branded cork, signs of old seepage, one rebouchée au Château en 1988 branded cork Lot 1549: one top shoulder, two just below top shoulder, one upper shoulder, one upper-mid shoulder, lightly scuffed labels, one lightly torn capsule, Nicolas stamps "...intensely fragrant...remarkably chewy, ripe flavors, and some of the vintage's renowned austerity and tannic bite...96." WA 10/ bottles per lot US$ , bottles per lot US$16,000-24,000 Château Palmer 1959 Margaux, Troisième Cru Classé upper shoulder, wine-stained labels, one cut capsule reveals fully branded cork, oxidized capsules, one Mahler- Besse "...offers up a superb bouquet...on the palate the wine is full-bodied, deep, black fruity and plush...95." JBG 10/ bottles per lot US$ Château Palmer 1983 Margaux, Troisième Cru Classé bottom neck or better, two scuffed labels "One of the superb wines of the vintage...superconcentrated, powerful, and full-bodied, this huge, unctuously textured win...97." WA 10/ double magnums (3L) per lot US$ ,000 Château Canon 1945 St. Emilion, Premier Grand Cru Classé (b) mid shoulder, damp-stained and scuffed label, slightly protruded cork "In the mouth, this Canon exhibited a typically rustic, super-concentrated, hard, tannic, massive constitution. It is still capable of improvement - as hard as that may be to believe...92." WA 4/ bottle per lot US$ Château Canon 1982 St. Emilion, Premier Grand Cru Classé (b) two bottom neck or better, two very top shoulder, one top shoulder, lightly damp-stained labels, one lightly nicked label, one torn label "A fragant, sweet nose of minerals, cherry jam, smoke, earth, cedar and vanilla is enticing. Medium to fullbodied, with fabulously sweet fruit, a viscous texture, yet vibrant...94." WA 6/ bottles per lot US$ Château Certan de May 1982 Pomerol very top shoulder, one damp-stained label, one nicked label, one wine-stained label "Rich, powerful, and full-bodied, with a thick, unctuous texture, considerable fat and glycerin, and dazzling concentration...unquestionably the finest Certan de May I have ever tasted...98." WA 6/ magnums (1.5L) per lot US$ Château Figeac 1982 St. Emilion, Premier Grand Cru Classé (b) four very top shoulder, five top shoulder, four lightly binsoiled labels, one lightly damp-stained label, three lightly scuffed labels, three different importers "A dense plum/garnet color with a slight lightening at the edge is followed by a sensational Figeac nose...medium to full-bodied with lovely freshness...94." WA 6/ bottles per lot US$ Château Gruaud-Larose 1982 St. Julien, Deuxième Cru Classé three bottom neck or better, three very top shoulder, one top shoulder, two torn labels, two different importers, one with signs of old seepage "A massive wine that is clearly of First Growth quality... continues to justify its legendary status...98." WA 6/ bottles per lot US$ THE SUPERLATIVE COLLECTION OF RICHARD & SUSAN ROGEL OFFERED BY THE UNIVERSITY OF MICHIGAN TO BENEFIT THE ROGEL CANCER CENTER ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com 207

200 THE SUPERLATIVE COLLECTION OF RICHARD & SUSAN ROGEL OFFERED BY THE UNIVERSITY OF MICHIGAN TO BENEFIT THE ROGEL CANCER CENTER Château Lynch-Bages 1982 Pauillac, Cinquième Cru Classé one bottom neck, two very top shoulder, one top shoulder, one just below top shoulder, lightly bin-soiled labels, one lightly damp-stained label, signs of old seepage "One of the most drinkable, complex, and tasty 1982s of the northern Medoc...offers up classic aromas of cedar wood, fruitcake, tobacco leaf, and creme de cassis...94." WA 6/ bottles per lot US$ Château Pichon Longueville Comtesse de Lalande 1982 Pauillac, Deuxième Cru Classé bottom neck or better unless noted Lot 1558: two very top shoulder, six top shoulder, dampstained and lightly wine-stained labels, three with signs of old seepage Lot 1559: eleven top shoulder, one bin-soiled label, one damp-stained label, two lightly scuffed labels, three with importer tags adhered to labels Lot 1560: five very top shoulder, five top shoulder, one upper shoulder, two lightly scuffed labels, two different importers Lot 1561: two top shoulder, nine just below top shoulder, four damp-stained labels, two heavily damp-stained labels, two different importers Lot 1562: signs of old seepage Lot 1563: one torn label, one with signs of old seepage Lot 1564: into neck, damp-stained and wine-stained label, signs of old seepage "It had a beautiful dark fruit nose and very giving fruit on the palate..." SF bottles per lot US$ bottles per lot US$ bottles per lot US$ bottles per lot US$ magnums (1.5L) per lot US$ magnums (1.5L) per lot US$ , jeroboam (5L) per lot US$ Château Léoville Las Cases 1986 St. Julien, Deuxième Cru Classé one bottom neck, two very top shoulder, one just below top shoulder, one wine-stained label, one with signs of old seepage "The wine has always been phenomenally concentrated, yet wonderfully fresh and vigorous...it is a great example of Léoville Las Cases " WA 1/ bottles per lot US$ Château Angélus 1990 St. Emilion, Premier Grand Cru Classé (a) bottom neck or better, two lightly scuffed labels, two depressed corks, one with signs of old seepage "Full-bodied, flamboyant, and opulent, with low acidity and sweet tannin...96." WA 6/ bottles per lot US$ Château Beauséjour Duffau Lagarrosse 1990 St. Emilion, Premier Grand Cru Classé (b) bottom neck or better, one damp-stained label, lightly glue-stained labels, two nicked labels "It reveals low acidity and high tannins, which are largely concealed by the sheer concentration and lavish glycerin the wine possesses " WA 6/ bottles per lot US$ Château La Conseillante 1990 Pomerol ten bottom neck or better, two very top shoulder, one wrinkled label, two different importers, two with signs of old seepage "An exuberant, atypically flamboyant effort, it possesses supple texture, medium to full body, sweet fruit, plenty of glycerin, and attractive melted tannin...97." WA 6/ bottles per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com

201 Château Léoville Las Cases 1990 St. Julien, Deuxième Cru Classé nine bottom neck or better, three very top shoulder, two scuffed labels, one torn label, two wine-stained labels, three with signs of old seepage "In the mouth, it is full-bodied, and while technically low in acidity, there is a freshness, delineation, and classicism...96." WA 6/ bottles per lot US$ Château Lynch-Bages 1990 Pauillac, Cinquième Cru Classé bottom neck or better unless noted Lot 1570: one very top shoulder, four with signs of old seepage Lot 1571: two very top shoulder, two top shoulder "It is a hedonistic as well as intellectual turn-on. There is not a hard edge to be found...97." WA 6/ bottles per lot US$ bottles per lot US$ Château Montrose 1990 St. Estèphe, Deuxième Cru Classé bottom neck or better unless noted Lot 1572: one top shoulder, two lightly bin-soiled labels, two with signs of old seepage Lot 1573: two very top shoulder, three top shoulder, one lightly scuffed label, one lightly wine-stained label, two with signs of old seepage Lot 1574: four very top shoulder, one top shoulder, one just below top shoulder, four lightly bin-soiled labels, three wine-stained labels, one depressed cork, four slightly depressed corks, two with signs of old seepage "...absolutely magnificent, broad, savory and mouth-filling. This is one of the all-time modern legends from Bordeaux as well as Château Montrose " WA 8/ bottles per lot US$ bottles per lot US$ bottles per lot US$ Château Pichon-Baron 1990 Pauillac, Deuxième Cru Classé bottom neck or better, one nicked label "...it reveals an extraordinary bouquet of charcoal, incense, creme de cassis, blue and black fruits, and a hint of licorice as well as an impressively long finish...97." WA 6/ bottles per lot US$ BURGUNDY DOMAINE DE LA ROMANÉE-CONTI ROMANÉE-CONTI DOMAINE DE LA ROMANÉE-CONTI Romanée-Conti Domaine de la Romanée-Conti cm, bin-soiled and wine-stained label, signs of old seepage "...fully evolved after an hour and holding well for another; on the palate sweet, excellent flavour, great length, and good grip...." MB 3/ bottle per lot US$ ,000 Romanée-Conti Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 1966 Lot 1577: one 4cm, two 4.5cm, one 5.5cm, two lightly nicked labels, two lightly scuffed labels, two scuffed labels, interdiction d'exporter stamp on labels Lot 1578: one 3.5cm, two 4cm, two 4.5cm, one 5cm, lightly scuffed labels, one nicked label, one wine-stained label, one wine-stained vintage tag, missing back labels, three corroded capsules, four with signs of old seepage, sequential bottle numbers, interdiction d'exporter stamp on labels Gorgeous, pure, focused aromas of rhubarb and cherries with an appealing hint of decay, with a bright, atomizing acidity; the long, persistent, powerful finish...one to contemplate...outstanding plus plus. FH bottles per lot US$48,000-75, bottles per lot US$70, ,000 Romanée-Conti Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 1969 Lot 1579: two 3cm, one 4.5cm, one 5.5cm, one 6cm, one 7cm, two bin-soiled labels, three damp-stained labels, four heavily torn labels, one torn label, three wine-stained labels, four missing monopole tags, two obscured bottle numbers Lot 1580: two 4cm, two 4.5cm, two 5cm, bin-soiled and scuffed labels, four marked labels, five torn labels, five missing back labels, five missing monopole tags, one lightly corroded capsule "...by far the finest...it happens to be the excellent acidity which made, and has sustained these wines...." MB bottles per lot US$50,000-85, bottles per lot US$50,000-85,000 THE SUPERLATIVE COLLECTION OF RICHARD & SUSAN ROGEL OFFERED BY THE UNIVERSITY OF MICHIGAN TO BENEFIT THE ROGEL CANCER CENTER ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com 209

202 THE SUPERLATIVE COLLECTION OF RICHARD & SUSAN ROGEL OFFERED BY THE UNIVERSITY OF MICHIGAN TO BENEFIT THE ROGEL CANCER CENTER Romanée-Conti Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 1971 Lot 1581: 4.5cm, damp-stained, marked and lightly winestained label, lightly marked monopole tag Lot 1582: 5.5cm, lightly damp-stained label, cut capsule reveals fully branded cork "...a somber yet unbelievably complex...incredibly rich, dense, round and velvety full-bodied, beautifully nuanced flavors that completely coat the palate...98." BH 4/ bottle per lot US$16,000-24, magnum (1.5L) per lot US$32,000-50,000 Romanée-Conti Domaine de la Romanée-Conti cm, interdiction d'exporter stamp on bin-soiled, nicked and lightly scuffed label, signs of old seepage "Very rich...broad, ample, lovely texture, very velvety. Rich. Full, concentrated, very good grip. Real intensity here. Multi-dimensional. Again a lot of structure... Brilliant " CC 10/ bottle per lot US$ ,000 Romanée-Conti Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 1976 Lot 1584: 3cm, lightly nicked label Lot 1585: 5.5cm, lightly bin-soiled label, cut capsule reveals fully branded cork "...sumptuous mix of spices...which continue onto the sappy, elegant, velvety medium full flavors that possess obvious class and refinement..." BH 10/ bottle per lot US$ , magnum (1.5L) per lot US$20,000-30,000 Romanée-Conti Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 1978 Lot 1586: 3cm, wine-stained vintage tag and label, signs of old seepage Lot 1587: 4.5cm, marked and lightly wine-stained label, signs of old seepage Lot 1588: 5.5cm, lightly bin-soiled label, wine-stained importer tag "Magnificent...medium-pale, lively looking...sweet, rich, lovely fragrance, pure mature 'beetroot' varietal bouquet that opened up in the glass, soft fruit, whiff of raspberry... full-bodied, interesting texture, peppery acidity...." MB 3/ bottle per lot US$17,000-26, bottle per lot US$17,000-26, bottle per lot US$17,000-26,000 Romanée-Conti Domaine de la Romanée-Conti cm, damp-stained and lightly nicked label, chipped wax capsule, wine-stained monopole tag, signs of old seepage "An exceptionally floral nose...with more freshness than the typical '83 displays today...the initial hints of sous bois that continue onto the delicious and complex flavors that offer impressive concentration..." BH 4/ jeroboam (3L) per lot US$42,000-60,000 Romanée-Conti Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 1985 Lot 1590: 3.5cm, lightly bin-soiled label, signs of old seepage Lot 1591: one 2.5cm, two 5cm, one lightly scuffed label, one torn label, one with signs of old seepage, consecutive bottle numbers "...a mix of primary and secondary black fruit aromas, violets the classic dried rose petal. The big yet refined flavors are rich, intense, mouth filling...94." BH 1/ bottle per lot US$11,000-16, bottles per lot US$32,000-48,000 Romanée-Conti Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 1990 one 3cm, one 4cm, bin-soiled labels, one lightly nicked label, one scuffed monopole tag, one with signs of old seepage "This is a dramatic wine in every sense of the word yet it's not at all showy but rather discreet and understated...99." BH 1/ bottles per lot US$34,000-50, ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com

203 Lot 1590 ZACHYS tel fax zachys.com 211

204 Lot ZACHYS tel fax zachys.com

205 LA TÂCHE DOMAINE DE LA ROMANÉE-CONTI La Tâche Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 1957 two 2.5cm, one 3cm, one 4cm, one lightly scuffed label, three scuffed labels "...still fairly pale, fully mature looking; a lovely, ripe beetroot of Pinot fragrance, almost too exotic...had a wonderfully open, fully developed, entrancing flavour, with a '57 piquant acidity..." MB bottles per lot US$ ,000 La Tâche Domaine de la Romanée-Conti cm, interdiction d'exporter stamp on scuffed label "...incredibly rich, dense and pure flavors of stunning depth and length...this is flawless and drinking perfectly with nothing but sheer silk and velvet in the mouth...97." BH 1/ bottle per lot US$ La Tâche Domaine de la Romanée-Conti cm, remnants of label, obscured bottle number "...medium-deep, open, fully mature colour; 'scented beetroot' nose; rich, fabulous, perfection...." MB 6/ bottle per lot US$ La Tâche Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 1966 Lot 1596: one 4.5cm, one 5.5cm, one 6cm, two 6.5cm, one lightly bin-soiled label, one lightly marked label, two lightly scuffed labels, three with signs of old seepage Lot 1597: three 4cm, one 4.5cm, three 5.5cm, one heavily wine-stained label, one lightly marked label, one lightly wine-stained label, scuffed labels, export stamp on labels, three with signs of old seepage Lot 1598: one 3.5cm, three 4cm, three 4.5cm, two 5cm, two 5.5cm, one 6cm, one lightly wine-stained label, scuffed labels, export stamp on labels, five with signs of old seepage A fully mature-looking hefty, spicy, sweet and powerful bottle...with quite a bite and remarkable acidity.... MB 2/ bottles per lot US$13,000-20, bottles per lot US$18,000-28, bottles per lot US$32,000-48,000 La Tâche Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 1969 Lot 1599: 5cm, bin-soiled and scuffed labels, one dampstained label, one lightly marked label, one nicked label, one with interdiction d'export stamp on label Lot 1600: one 3.5cm, one 4cm, one 6cm, importer tags adhered to bin-soiled and damp-stained labels, two lightly torn labels, one torn label, one wine-stained label, one protruded cork Lot 1601: 10cm, scuffed and lightly bin-soiled label, wrinkled monopole tag, chipped wax capsule partially reveals cork, signs of old seepage "...medium to full-bodied...beautifully sweet, expansive, and rich, with complex aromatics...it is a terrific La Tâche...94." WA 8/ bottles per lot US$ bottles per lot US$ jeroboam (3L) per lot US$15,000-22,000 La Tâche Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 1971 Lot 1602: one 3cm, one 3.5cm, one 5cm, bin-soiled labels, one damp-stained label, one heavily torn label, one lightly marked label, one lightly scuffed label, one lightly winestained label, one damp-stained monopole tag, one slightly depressed cork, two with signs of old seepage Lot 1603: two 5cm, one 6cm, one 6.5cm, lightly bin-soiled labels, one lightly scuffed label, one nicked monopole tag, one cut capsule reveals fully branded cork "...extremely rich, sweet and wonderfully concentrated with a deep, very sweet essence of pinot finish...pure silk and velvet...95." BH 10/ bottles per lot US$19,000-30, magnums (1.5L) per lot US$60, ,000 La Tâche Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 1978 two 4.5cm, one 5cm, two 5.5cm, damp-stained labels, three heavily wine-stained labels, two wine-stained labels "...concentrated, sweet, very rich essence of mature burg with superb length and quality depth...92." BH 4/ bottles per lot US$26,000-40,000 La Tâche Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 1985 one 2.5cm, one 3cm, one damp-stained label, one lightly damp-stained label, one lightly scuffed label, one nicked label, one lightly damp-stained vintage tag "A great wine, and an obvious cellar trophy...the very long expansive finish was accented by back-of-palate aromas of dried plums and apricots. Outstanding." FH bottles per lot US$ ,000 THE SUPERLATIVE COLLECTION OF RICHARD & SUSAN ROGEL OFFERED BY THE UNIVERSITY OF MICHIGAN TO BENEFIT THE ROGEL CANCER CENTER ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com 213

206 THE SUPERLATIVE COLLECTION OF RICHARD & SUSAN ROGEL OFFERED BY THE UNIVERSITY OF MICHIGAN TO BENEFIT THE ROGEL CANCER CENTER La Tâche Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 1988 Lot 1606: one 2.5cm, one 3cm, one 3.5cm, one 4cm, one 5cm, two damp-stained labels, two glue-stained labels, one wine-stained label, one wine-stained vintage tag, one with tissue paper adhered to label, one with tissue paper adhered to vintage tag, export stamps on labels, one with importer tag adhered to label, oxidized capsules, four with signs of old seepage Lot 1607: two 2.5cm, three 3cm, one 4cm, one bin-soiled label, two damp-stained labels, one lightly wine-stained label, oxidized capsules Lot 1608: three 2cm or better, two 2.5cm, three 3cm, one 3.5cm, one 4cm, two lightly bin-soiled labels, one lightly marked label, one lightly torn label, export stamp on labels Lot 1609: one 2.5cm, five 3.5cm, four 4cm, one 4.5cm, one 6cm, three lightly bin-soiled labels, two lightly scuffed labels, one torn label, one wine-stained vintage tag, export stamps on labels, six with signs of old seepage, consecutive bottle numbers "There is fine length here and the power is impressive...93." BH 9/ bottles per lot US$11,000-18, bottles per lot US$14,000-22, bottles per lot US$22,000-36, bottles per lot US$28,000-42,000 La Tâche Domaine de la Romanée-Conti cm or better unless noted Lot 1610: three 2.5cm, one 3cm, one 3.5cm, one 4cm, one lightly scuffed label, one marked label, one depressed cork, one slightly depressed cork, three with signs of old seepage Lot 1611: four 2.5cm, three 3cm, two 3.5cm, one 4cm, two lightly bin-soiled labels, two lightly marked labels, one lightly torn label, eight with signs of old seepage, consecutive bottle numbers Lot 1612: three 2.5cm, three 3cm, two 3.5cm, two 4cm, two lightly scuffed labels, two lightly torn labels, one torn label, two depressed corks, five with signs of old seepage, consecutive bottle numbers bottles per lot US$28,000-44, bottles per lot US$32,000-48, bottles per lot US$32,000-48,000 La Tâche Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 1990 Lot 1613: one 2.5cm, one 3cm, one 3.5cm, three 4cm, three lightly scuffed labels, one wine-stained label, one scuffed monopole tag, five with signs of old seepage Lot 1614: three 4.5cm, one 5cm, one 5.5cm, lightly binsoiled labels, one lightly wine-stained label, one winestained vintage tag, two with signs of old seepage "The flavors are big, rich, refined, classy, penetrating and superbly powerful yet everything is in perfect balance...99." BH 6/ bottles per lot US$32,000-48, magnums (1.5L) per lot US$65,000-95,000 RICHEBOURG DOMAINE DE LA ROMANÉE-CONTI Richebourg Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 1959 Lot 1615: 5cm, heavily wine-stained and torn label partially obscures vintage, interdiction d'exporter stamp on label Lot 1616: one 2.5cm, one 3.5cm, bin-soiled labels, one heavily torn label, one heavily wine-stained label, one torn label, one wine-stained label, interdiction d'exporter stamps on labels Lot 1617: three 4.5cm, one 5cm, two bin-soiled labels, one heavily damp-stained label, one heavily wine-stained label, scuffed labels, three torn labels, one missing back label, importer tags adhered to labels, one torn capsule, one with signs of old seepage Sweetly decaying aromas of rhubarb, cherry, and dank earth compost pile in November warm, expansive, and alcoholic on the palate, with a very long rich finish... Outstanding. FH bottle per lot US$ bottles per lot US$ , bottles per lot US$16,000-24,000 Richebourg Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 1962 one 5.5cm, two 6cm, two heavily damp-stained labels, two heavily torn labels, one lightly bin-soiled label, one lightly torn label, one with tissue paper adhered to label, two with importer tags adhered to labels, two slightly protruded corks, one with signs of old seepage "Fantastically complex nose...remarkably fine and pure, velvety, rich flavors that dance across the palate and the length here is simply phenomenal...one of the finest vintages I have ever tasted for this wine...96." BH 5/ bottles per lot US$ ,000 Richebourg Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 1964 one 4cm, one 4.5cm, one 5cm, bin-soiled labels, two damp-stained labels, one lightly scuffed label, two missing back labels, one torn capsule partially reveals cork, two with signs of old seepage "...the breadth of nuance and perfume here is impossible to describe and leads to still powerful, very rich and full, indeed even muscular flavors of real depth and a velvety, superbly long finish...94." BH 5/ bottles per lot US$ , ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com

207 Richebourg Domaine de la Romanée-Conti cm, scuffed and lightly wine-stained label "...caramel and lots of sous bois followed by flavors that are rich and nicely defined...beautifully detailed and satisfying...the tannins are quite refined...91." BH 1/ bottle per lot US$ Richebourg Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 1971 Lot 1621: one 4.5cm, three 5cm, two 6cm, heavily dampstained labels, three lightly nicked labels, two marked labels, two scuffed labels, one wine-stained label Lot 1622: 5.5cm, lightly bin-soiled and scuffed label, cut capsule reveals fully branded cork "...the nose is incredibly complex...incredible dried rose petal, spice and touches of sous bois followed by mouth coating flavors that deliver superb detail plus a finish that is class personified...96." BH 10/ bottles per lot US$32,000-48, magnum (1.5L) per lot US$14,000-20,000 Richebourg Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 1976 one 2cm, one 3cm, one 4cm, lightly bin-soiled labels, two lightly wine-stained labels, two nicked labels, one lightly oxidized capsule, one with signs of old seepage "Medium-full mature colour. Rich, more opulent and more vigorous than the [DRC] Romanée-St-Vivant...Fullish, rich, very intense, very youthful. This is very lovely. Very long and very fine " CC 3/ bottles per lot US$ Richebourg Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 1986 one 2cm, one 2.5cm, one 3cm, one 3.5cm, one 5cm, three damp-stained labels, three lightly scuffed labels, two lightly wine-stained labels, one torn label, two with signs of old seepage "A fully mature nose that is displaying notes of sous bois, spice, underbrush, smoke and lovely overall complexity leads to delicious and complex flavors..." BH 4/ bottles per lot US$ ,000 Richebourg Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 1988 consecutive bottle numbers Lot 1625: two 2.5cm, four 3cm, two 3.5cm, three 4cm, one 4.5cm, one nicked label, interdiction d'exporter aux USA stamps on labels, four with signs of old seepage Lot 1626: two 2.5cm, three 3cm, six 3.5cm, one 4cm, four lightly scuffed labels, export stamps on labels, one oxidized capsule Lot 1627: six 3cm, four 3.5cm, two 5cm, two lightly scuffed labels, export stamps on labels, five with signs of old seepage There are ample tannins but the extract more than buffers them. Huge, rich and long from beginning to end BH 4/ bottles per lot US$24,000-36, bottles per lot US$24,000-36, bottles per lot US$24,000-36,000 Richebourg Domaine de la Romanée-Conti cm or better unless noted Lot 1628: three 2.5cm, two lightly scuffed labels, three with signs of old seepage Lot 1629: four 2.5cm, two 3cm, one 3.5cm, two 4cm, one lightly marked label, one nicked label, two wine-stained labels, two with signs of old seepage, consecutive bottle numbers "...big, rich and intense, underpinned by surprisingly rustic tannins and offering fine length. This is a big wine for the vintage with plenty of character and ample structure..." BH 7/ bottles per lot US$22,000-32, bottles per lot US$22,000-32,000 Richebourg Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 1990 Lot 1630: one 2.5cm, two 3.5cm, one 4cm, lightly binsoiled labels, three lightly scuffed labels, two wine-stained labels, signs of old seepage Lot 1631: one 3.5cm, one 4.5cm, one heavily scuffed label, one lightly scuffed label, one lightly wine-stained label, one slightly protruded cork, two with signs of old seepage "...very ripe, beautifully complex flavors...this has excellent density of extract and solid balance. Rich, long and impressive...93." BH 7/ bottles per lot US$13,000-19, magnums (1.5L) per lot US$14,000-20,000 THE SUPERLATIVE COLLECTION OF RICHARD & SUSAN ROGEL OFFERED BY THE UNIVERSITY OF MICHIGAN TO BENEFIT THE ROGEL CANCER CENTER ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com 215

208 THE SUPERLATIVE COLLECTION OF RICHARD & SUSAN ROGEL OFFERED BY THE UNIVERSITY OF MICHIGAN TO BENEFIT THE ROGEL CANCER CENTER ROMANÉE-ST-VIVANT DOMAINE DE LA ROMANÉE-CONTI Romanée-St-Vivant Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 1971 Lot 1632: 6.5cm, marked label, Christie's auction sticker adhered to corroded capsule Lot 1633: one 5.5cm, one 6cm, one 7cm, one dampstained label, lightly bin-soiled labels, consecutive bottle numbers "Very lovely concentration, nice, intense and stylish nose...this is still very fresh. Delicious fragrance. Very fine. Fullish. Very good grip. Marvellous fruit. Hugely intense " CC 3/ magnum (1.5L) per lot US$ magnums (1.5L) per lot US$16,000-24,000 Romanée-St-Vivant Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 1976 one 2cm, two 2.5cm, lightly bin-soiled labels, one torn label "Mellow, laid-back nose...ripe and fragrant...very mellow, very lovely fruit. Real intensity, complexity and depth. Very, very long and lovely. This is very fine...18." CC 3/ bottles per lot US$ Romanée-St-Vivant Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 1978 one 2cm, two 3.5cm, two 4cm, one heavily damp-stained label, one heavily wine-stained label, three lightly binsoiled labels, two different importers, three with signs of old seepage "Ripe, rich and spicy aromas of superb complexity with quite supple flavors that offer excellent richness, depth and length...genuinely amazing stuff...92." BH 1/ bottles per lot US$16,000-24,000 Romanée-St-Vivant Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 1986 three 2cm or better, two 2.5cm, two 3cm, three 3.5cm, two 4cm, one damp-stained label, one glue-stained label, one heavily damp-stained label, one lightly torn label, one marked label, one wine-stained label, export stamps on labels, seven with signs of old seepage, consecutive bottle numbers bottles per lot US$11,000-16,000 Romanée-St-Vivant Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 1988 Lot 1637: one 2.5cm, two 3cm, export stamps on labels, one with signs of old seepage Lot 1638: four 2.5cm, two 3cm, three 3.5cm, two 4cm, one 5.5cm, export stamps on labels, three with signs of old seepage, consecutive bottle numbers "Rich, elegant and powerful...purity of expression (yet no lack of power) which combined with the outstanding length make this a terrific effort...92." BH 4/ bottles per lot US$ bottles per lot US$14,000-20,000 Romanée-St-Vivant Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 1990 two 2cm or better, two 3cm, one 3.5cm, one 4cm, two lightly bin-soiled labels, one torn label, one wine-stained label, signs of old seepage "...while this displays only a bit of the classic RSV velvet, this character will undoubtedly become more pronounced with age as there is plenty of mid-palate density...92." BH 9/ bottles per lot US$11,000-17, ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com

209 GRANDS ECHÉZEAUX DOMAINE DE LA ROMANÉE-CONTI Grands Echézeaux Domaine de la Romanée-Conti cm, damp-stained and nicked label, slightly protruded cork, signs of old seepage "...a beguiling sweetness here with nothing out of place as everything is delivered with style and grace. A lovely, lovely wine in every respect...96." BH 7/ bottle per lot US$ Grands Echézeaux Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 1966 two 3cm, one 4cm, one 4.5cm, export stamps on labels, three lightly scuffed labels, one marked label, one nicked label, two wine-stained labels, two lightly corroded capsules, two with signs of old seepage "...the nose is explosive and spectacularly complex with a stunning mixture of spice, earth, caramel and definite sous bois notes that lead to sweet, velvety, wonderfully rich and beautifully textured flavors that possess outstanding length...97." BH 1/ bottles per lot US$12,000-20,000 Grands Echézeaux Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 1971 one 4cm, one 5cm, one damp-stained label, one lightly oxidized capsule, consecutive bottle numbers "Huge, rich, full, complex and mature burg nose that displays seductive nuance after nuance...incredibly rich, almost sweet flavors completely stain the palate and they just go on and on in one never ending wave...93." BH 10/ magnums (1.5L) per lot US$20,000-30,000 Grands Echézeaux Domaine de la Romanée-Conti cm, torn and lightly bin-soiled label "Powerfully ripe and expressive aromas...quite ripe and intense flavors...a classic Grands-Echézeaux...93." BH 1/ bottle per lot US$ Grands Echézeaux Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 1988 Lot 1644: one 3cm, three 3.5cm, one 4cm, export stamps on lightly bin-soiled labels Lot 1645: one 2.5cm, two 3cm, five 3.5cm, two 4cm, one heavily wine-stained label, two lightly bin-soiled labels, two lightly scuffed labels, one marked label, two scuffed labels, export stamp on labels, gov't health warning labels adhered to back labels, two with signs of old seepage "...supremely elegant nose...ripe and balanced and remain well integrated on the phenomenally long finish...94." BH 10/ bottles per lot US$ , bottles per lot US$13,000-20,000 Grands Echézeaux Domaine de la Romanée-Conti cm or better unless noted Lot 1646: six 2.5cm, two 3.5cm, two wine-stained labels, five with signs of old seepage Lot 1647: three 3cm, four 3.5cm, one 5cm, two lightly binsoiled labels, seven with signs of old seepage, consecutive bottle numbers "...sweet, chewy with lots of fruit...well endowed with tannin and acidity... ( )." MB bottles per lot US$12,000-18, bottles per lot US$14,000-22,000 Grands Echézeaux Domaine de la Romanée-Conti cm, wine-stained, lightly bin-soiled and torn label, signs of old seepage "...offers fantastically rich yet not excessively ripe fruit and flavors with excellent density, concentration and superb length...outstanding...stunning overall quality...94." BH 7/ bottle per lot US$ THE SUPERLATIVE COLLECTION OF RICHARD & SUSAN ROGEL OFFERED BY THE UNIVERSITY OF MICHIGAN TO BENEFIT THE ROGEL CANCER CENTER ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com 217

210 THE SUPERLATIVE COLLECTION OF RICHARD & SUSAN ROGEL OFFERED BY THE UNIVERSITY OF MICHIGAN TO BENEFIT THE ROGEL CANCER CENTER ECHÉZEAUX DOMAINE DE LA ROMANÉE-CONTI Echézeaux Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 1959 one 2.5cm, one 3cm, one 4cm, lightly bin-soiled labels, two lightly scuffed labels, importer tags adhered to labels, one with signs of old seepage bottles per lot US$ Echézeaux Domaine de la Romanée-Conti cm, export stamp on lightly bin-soiled and torn label, lightly corroded capsule, signs of old seepage "A super expressive nose...sweet, spicy and mouth coating flavors that are delicious...the finish is long, detailed and impressively persistent...91." BH 1/ bottle per lot US$ Echézeaux Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 1986 six 2cm or better, three 2.5cm, one 3cm, two 3.5cm, eleven bin-soiled labels, one damp-stained label, two heavily damp-stained labels, two lightly scuffed labels, one winestained label, one with signs of old seepage "...an exotic, intense bouquet...this is among the few superstars of this vintage." RP bottles per lot US$13,000-19,000 Echézeaux Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 1987 two 2cm or better, four 2.5cm, two lightly bin-soiled labels, one scuffed label, one wine-stained label "...flattering and precocious in style, it shows excellent color, a lovely rich bouquet of plum-like fruit, plenty of spicy oak, relatively full body, and a long, crisp finish..." RP bottles per lot US$ Echézeaux Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 1988 five 2cm or better, one 2.5cm, three 3cm, one 3.5cm, one lightly bin-soiled label, one lightly marked label, export stamps on labels, three with signs of old seepage "Wonderfully complex nose...rich, detailed and relatively big flavors...every bit a true Grand Cru. Very impressive...92." BH 11/ bottles per lot US$12,000-19,000 Echézeaux Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 1990 Lot 1654: one 2cm, one 2.5cm, three 3.5cm, three 4cm, two 4.5cm, four lightly bin-soiled labels, one lightly marked label, one lightly wine-stained label, one nicked label, one wine-stained label, seven with signs of old seepage Lot 1655: 4cm, lightly bin-soiled label, slightly protruded cork, signs of old seepage "...good richness, noticeable structure...in short, this is delicious in a robust fashion..." BH 11/ bottles per lot US$16,000-26, magnum (1.5L) per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com

211 LEROY Ruchottes-Chambertin Maison Leroy cm or better unless noted Lot 1656: one 2.5cm, three 3cm, six bin-soiled labels, one lightly marked label, one lightly wine-stained label, two scuffed labels, one slightly protruded cork, five with signs of old seepage, two different bottlings Lot 1657: two 2.5cm, four 3cm, four with signs of old seepage "Perfectly mature, lovely autumnal cherry...excellent." FH bottles per lot US$ bottles per lot US$ ,000 Clos de la Roche Domaine Leroy 1990 one 2cm, two 3cm, one 3.5cm, two bin-soiled labels, one wine-stained label, two wine-stained back labels, one heavily chipped wax capsule, one heavily chipped wax capsule reveals top of cork, one slightly protruded cork, two heavily chipped wax capsules fully reveal corks, signs of old seepage "...exquisite equilibrium and focus, as well as a seemingly unending luxurious finish...98." WA 10/ bottles per lot US$ ,000 Clos de Vougeot Domaine Leroy 1990 Lot 1659: 3.5cm, importer tag adhered to wine-stained label, signs of seepage Lot 1660: one 3.5cm, two 4cm, lightly wine-stained labels, one with sticker adhered to back label, two chipped wax capsules partially reveal corks, signs of seepage, two different importers Lot 1661: two 2cm or better, three 3cm, three 3.5cm, four 4cm, one lightly wine-stained label, two wine-stained labels, two wine-stained vintage tags, two chipped wax capsules, ten heavily chipped wax capsules reveal corks, signs of seepage, consecutive bottle numbers "Intense, high-toned aromas of dried cherries. Some unresolved tannins, otherwise great balance. Needs another ten years!...outstanding." FH bottle per lot US$ bottles per lot US$ bottles per lot US$18,000-28,000 Gevrey-Chambertin Les Combottes Domaine Leroy 1990 Côte de Nuits, Premier Cru Lot 1662: four 2.5cm or better, four 3cm, two 4.5cm, three wine-stained labels, one wine-stained vintage tag, six winestained back labels, one slightly protruded cork, one heavily chipped wax capsule reveals vintage and vineyard, eight chipped wax capsules reveal corks, signs of old seepage Lot 1663: three 2.5cm or better, seven 3cm, one lightly wine-stained label, two slightly protruded corks, chipped wax capsules reveal corks, signs of old seepage bottles per lot US$ , bottles per lot US$ ,000 Latricières-Chambertin Domaine Leroy 1990 Lot 1664: four 2cm or better, one 3cm, three 3.5cm, five lightly wine-stained labels, five wine-stained vintage tags, three lightly wine-stained back labels, chipped wax capsules fully reveal corks, signs of old seepage Lot 1665: eight 2.5cm or better, two 3cm, two 3.5cm, three bin-soiled labels, one wine-stained label, one winestained vintage tag, three lightly wine-stained back labels, heavily chipped wax capsules fully reveal corks, signs of old seepage, two different importers "...gorgeous aromatic depth...intense, hugely fashioned character crammed...this is a deep, medium-to-fullbodied, satin-textured, and well-structured wine...95." WA 10/ bottles per lot US$16,000-24, bottles per lot US$24,000-36,000 Nuits St Georges Les Boudots Domaine Leroy 1990 Côte de Nuits, Premier Cru 3cm, bin-soiled and lightly wine-stained label, wine-stained vintage tag and back label, signs of old seepage bottle per lot US$ Nuits St Georges Vignerondes Domaine Leroy 1990 Côte de Nuits, Premier Cru one 2cm, one 2.5cm, one lightly bin-soiled label, one lightly wine-stained label, one scuffed label, one wine-stained vintage tag, one chipped wax capsule partially reveals cork, signs of old seepage bottles per lot US$ THE SUPERLATIVE COLLECTION OF RICHARD & SUSAN ROGEL OFFERED BY THE UNIVERSITY OF MICHIGAN TO BENEFIT THE ROGEL CANCER CENTER ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com 219

212 THE SUPERLATIVE COLLECTION OF RICHARD & SUSAN ROGEL OFFERED BY THE UNIVERSITY OF MICHIGAN TO BENEFIT THE ROGEL CANCER CENTER Richebourg Domaine Leroy 1990 Lot 1668: three 3.5cm, one 4cm, one 4.5cm, one 5cm, two lightly wine-stained labels, three chipped wax capsules partially reveal corks, one chipped wax capsule fully reveals cork, signs of old seepage, two different importers Lot 1669: six 3.5cm, one 4cm, two 4.5cm, lightly binsoiled labels, one wine-stained vintage tag, two winestained back labels, six heavily chipped wax capsules fully reveal corks, signs of old seepage "Sumptuous and majestic...the length here is stunning as it lingers and lingers on the palate and the wine has the size of a classic Hermitage with its huge buried tannin...93." BH 1/ bottles per lot US$18,000-28, bottles per lot US$26,000-42,000 Romanée-St-Vivant Domaine Leroy cm or better unless noted Lot 1670: two 2.5cm, lightly bin-soiled labels, one lightly wine-stained label, two chipped wax capsules, three heavily chipped wax capsules fully reveal corks, signs of old seepage Lot 1671: two 3cm, two 3.5cm, three wine-stained vintage tags, four wine-stained back labels, four with signs of old seepage Lot 1672: four 2.5cm or better, two 3cm, two wine-stained back labels, chipped wax capsules reveal corks, signs of old seepage Lot 1673: four 2.5cm, one 3cm, two 3.5cm, two heavily wine-stained labels, two lightly wine-stained labels, one wine-stained label, two wine-stained vintage tags, four chipped wax capsules, seven heavily chipped wax capsules fully reveal corks, one chipped wax capsule partially reveals cork, signs of old seepage "...an interesting mix of spicy black fruit aromas of incredible richness and complexity...the flavors are big, rich, intense and very concentrated...92." BH 3/ bottles per lot US$13,000-19, bottles per lot US$15,000-24, bottles per lot US$15,000-24, bottles per lot US$30,000-46,000 Clos de Vougeot Remoissenet 1959 two 2.5cm, one 3cm, two bin-soiled labels, one nicked label "...very harmonious and fresh. The finish is dainty but does not short-change you on fruit intensity. This is everything I would want from a 1959 Burgundy...94." WA 4/ bottles per lot US$ Romanée-St-Vivant Marey-Monge 1964 one 4.5cm, one 5cm, one 6cm, two lightly scuffed labels, one wine-stained label, two oxidized capsules, one heavily oxidized capsule "An explosively spicy and opulent nose of exceptional purity jumps from the glass to reveal silky, sweet and absolutely delicious flavors of impressive depth and serious length that coat and stain the palate. In particular I admire the precision of the finish...93." BH 4/ bottles per lot US$ Romanée-St-Vivant Marey-Monge 1969 one 3.5cm, one 4cm, scuffed and lightly bin-soiled labels, one nicked label, oxidized capsules, consecutive bottle numbers bottles per lot US$ Vosne-Romanée Les Brûlées Henri Jayer 1978 Côte de Nuits, Premier Cru two 2cm or better, three 3.5cm, three torn labels, one missing vintage tag, one cut capsule reveals vintage branded cork, one slightly protruded cork, four with signs of old seepage "...fully mature spice and sous-bois-infused nose of superb depth complements rich, full and sweet mediumbodied flavors that deliver fine but not truly exceptional length...91." BH 5/ bottles per lot US$20,000-30, ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com

213 Lot 1677 ZACHYS tel fax zachys.com 221

214 Lot ZACHYS tel fax zachys.com

215 Chambertin Domaine Ponsot 1985 two 4cm, one 5cm, one nicked label, two torn labels, one with signs of old seepage "...this may be the finest vintage that I have ever tasted of the Chambertin...The rich, powerful and full-bodied flavors offer excellent depth and plenty of mid-palate fat along with beautiful length on the velvety finish...92." BH 10/ bottles per lot US$ Clos de la Roche Dujac cm, heavily bin-soiled label, loose capsule reveals fully branded cork "An expressive nose featuring strong secondary aromas leads to delicious, complex and moderately firm flavors that offer a wonderfully long if slightly drying finish...91." BH 11/ bottle per lot US$ Clos de la Roche Hubert Lignier 1985 one 3cm, two 3.5cm, two 4.5cm, one damp-stained label, one lightly wine-stained label, four scuffed labels, three slightly depressed corks, three different importers "...still vestiges of primary fruit that remain even though the majority of it has indeed passed into the secondary phase...93." BH 11/ bottles per lot US$ Clos de la Roche Vieilles Vignes Domaine Ponsot cm, lightly damp-stained label, slightly protruded cork, cut capsule reveals producer branded cork "Fleshy and succulent, with an expansive, chewy texture, outstanding purity, and a long, lusty finish, this is a terrific example from Ponsot...98." WA 2/ magnum (1.5L) per lot US$ ,000 Grands Echézeaux Gros Frère et Sœur 1985 one 3.5cm, one 4cm, one 5cm, two heavily damp-stained labels, one wine-stained label, one corroded capsule partially reveals cork, one depressed cork, two with signs of old seepage bottles per lot US$ Bonnes-Mares Comte Georges de Vogüé 1990 Lot 1683: one 2cm, three 2.5cm, one 3.5cm, one 4cm, four with importer tags adhered to labels, one with tissue paper adhered to label, four with signs of old seepage Lot 1684: four 2cm or better, four 2.5cm, one 3cm, two 3.5cm, one 4cm, three with signs of old seepage "Complex nose of very ripe aromas and earth and this is already showing strong secondary elements. The flavors are big and rich, indeed even rustic with lots of structure." BH 11/ bottles per lot US$ bottles per lot US$ Bonnes-Mares Georges Roumier cm, lightly wine-stained label "This is a big, robust, powerful wine with good depth and richness with ample structure...93." BH 9/ bottle per lot US$ Chambertin Louis Jadot 1990 two 2cm or better, one 3cm, one 3.5cm, one with signs of old seepage bottles per lot US$ THE SUPERLATIVE COLLECTION OF RICHARD & SUSAN ROGEL OFFERED BY THE UNIVERSITY OF MICHIGAN TO BENEFIT THE ROGEL CANCER CENTER ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com 223

216 THE SUPERLATIVE COLLECTION OF RICHARD & SUSAN ROGEL OFFERED BY THE UNIVERSITY OF MICHIGAN TO BENEFIT THE ROGEL CANCER CENTER Charmes-Chambertin Mommessin 1990 Lot 1687: nine 2cm or better, one 3cm, one 4cm, two with signs of old seepage Lot 1688: two 2cm or better, eight 2.5cm, one 3.5cm, one 4.5cm, two different importers, one with signs of old seepage Lot 1689: nine 2.5cm, two 3.5cm, one 4.5cm, two different importers, four with signs of old seepage Lot 1690: five 2.5cm, three 3cm, one 3.5cm, three 4cm, two wine-stained labels, three with signs of old seepage bottles per lot US$ bottles per lot US$ bottles per lot US$ bottles per lot US$ Clos de la Roche Vieilles Vignes Domaine Ponsot 1990 Lot 1691: one 3cm, one 3.5cm, one lightly marked label, one with signs of old seepage Lot 1692: two 2cm or better, one 3cm, Riedel import stamp on labels, two lightly marked labels, two depressed corks, signs of old seepage "...beautifully expressive...big, rich, round and relatively elegant flavors...textured and gorgeous velvety and still tight finish. A very impressive wine...95." BH 11/ bottles per lot US$ bottles per lot US$ Clos de Tart Mommessin 1990 Lot 1693: two 2.5cm, two 3.5cm, one 4cm, two winestained vintage tags, four with signs of old seepage Lot 1694: six 2cm or better, three 2.5cm, one 3cm, two 3.5cm, one nicked label, three with signs of old seepage Lot 1695: four 2cm or better, four 2.5cm, one 3cm, two 3.5cm, one 4cm, one slightly depressed cork, seven with signs of old seepage "Massively constituted nose of blackberries, pinot extract, game and earth that frame intense, complex, large-scaled flavors, excellent length and Grand Cru finesse. A very impressive Clos de Tart...92." BH 10/ bottles per lot US$ bottles per lot US$ bottles per lot US$ Echézeaux du Dessus Jayer-Gilles cm or better unless noted Lot 1696: two 2.5cm, one 3.5cm, one lightly wine-stained label, one wine-stained vintage tag, four with signs of old seepage Lot 1697: one damp-stained label, one slightly protruded cork bottles per lot US$ magnums (1.5L) per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com

217 Gevrey-Chambertin Clos St Jacques Louis Jadot 1990 Côte de Nuits, Premier Cru three 2.5cm, one 3cm, two 3.5cm, three with signs of old seepage "...it only seems to get better and better...more importantly, it should continue to drink well for many years to come, perhaps even for several more decades...93." BH 7/ bottles per lot US$ Griotte-Chambertin Domaine des Chezeaux 1990 one 2cm, five 2.5cm, one 3cm, one 4cm, two lightly binsoiled labels, one lightly torn label, four nicked labels, two scuffed labels, one torn label, one slightly depressed cork, two with signs of old seepage bottles per lot US$ Griotte-Chambertin Joseph Drouhin cm or better, bin-soiled labels bottles per lot US$ Musigny Vieilles Vignes Comte Georges de Vogüé cm or better unless noted Lot 1701: two 2.5cm, one lightly bin-soiled label, one lightly scuffed label, two marked labels, one with signs of old seepage Lot 1702: one 2.5cm, three 3cm, two marked labels, two different importers "This loaded effort should prove to be one of the longestlived red Burgundies made in the last twenty years...96." WA 2/ bottles per lot US$ , bottles per lot US$ ,000 Romanée-St-Vivant Louis Jadot 1990 one 2cm, ten 2.5cm, one 3.5cm, one lightly scuffed label, five with signs of old seepage bottles per lot US$ Ruchottes-Chambertin Louis Jadot 1990 eleven 2cm or better, one 3cm, one lightly marked label, two different importers "A stunningly beautiful nose that is still fresh and redolent of truffles and damp earth introduce delicious, powerful flavors that remarkably enough, still evidence upside potential. Impressive and very long...92." BH 10/ bottles per lot US$ Vosne-Romanée Les Chaumes Daniel Rion 1990 Côte de Nuits, Premier Cru four 2cm or better, five 2.5cm, two 3cm, one 3.5cm bottles per lot US$ Corton Le Rognet Ambroise 2cm or better unless noted 1989 (8) one 3cm, one nicked label, one wrinkled label 1990 (6) one 2.5cm, one wrinkled label, two chipped wax capsules, one heavily chipped wax capsule partially reveals cork, one with signs of old seepage 1706 above 14 bottles per lot US$ Montrachet Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 1983 Côte de Beaune, Grand Cru 3.5cm, scuffed label, oxidized capsule "The rich, full-bodied and impressively intense broadshouldered flavors coat the palate with dry extract on the sappy and ever-so-slightly warm finish that displays a hint of backend dryness." BH 11/ bottle per lot US$ THE SUPERLATIVE COLLECTION OF RICHARD & SUSAN ROGEL OFFERED BY THE UNIVERSITY OF MICHIGAN TO BENEFIT THE ROGEL CANCER CENTER ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com 225

218 RHÔNE CHAMPAGNE THE SUPERLATIVE COLLECTION OF RICHARD & SUSAN ROGEL OFFERED BY THE UNIVERSITY OF MICHIGAN TO BENEFIT THE ROGEL CANCER CENTER GUIGAL Côte-Rôtie La Landonne Guigal 1988 Rhône 2cm or better, scuffed labels, one with signs of old seepage "...exciting nose of truffles, minerals, Asian spices, and fruitcake. When the wine hits the mouth with its enormous weight and extraction of flavor, one can't help but be seduced by such enormous richness and purity " RP bottles per lot US$ Côte-Rôtie La Mouline Guigal 1988 Rhône 1.5cm or better, lightly scuffed labels, one with signs of old seepage "Among so many exceptional La Mouline's, this is one of the most profound...this thick, super concentrated, fullbodied, tannic La Mouline is loaded with fruit, massive, and full-bodied " RP bottles per lot US$ Côte-Rôtie La Turque Guigal 1988 Rhône five 2cm or better, one 2.5cm, lightly bin-soiled labels "This thick, unctuously textured, full-bodied, monster... exhibits awesome concentration, terrific purity " RP bottles per lot US$ Bollinger RD Année Rare 1973 Champagne into foil bottle per lot US$ Krug 1979 Champagne into foil, lightly scuffed label "It has a classically well-balanced structure, with a long, nutty aftertaste that is close to perfection...97." RJ 8/ bottle per lot US$ Dom Pérignon Rosé 1982 Champagne individual s into foil, one lightly torn foil "A beautifully mature, mellow Champagne that has lots to offer the serious connoisseur. Almost Burgundian in flavor, with mushroom, spice and almond accents to the core of honey and cherry. The flavors linger and blend on the finish...92." WS 12/ bottles per lot US$ Jacques Selosse Blanc de Blancs Millesime 1989 Champagne into foil, one lightly scuffed label, one nicked label, one scuffed label bottles per lot US$ , ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com

219 Lot 1714

220 Lots 1727 & 1728

221 ITALY GAJA Barbaresco Gaja 1961 Piedmont 2cm or better, bin-soiled and scuffed labels, one lightly damp-stained label, one with cardboard adhered to label "One of the most glorious Italian wines I have ever drunk. Fine mature red; soft, warm nose, singed fruit lurking beneath, holding beautifully in the glass; medium - the sweetness of ripe grapes, medium full-bodied, soft, with a flavour that opened up into a crescendo. Lovely texture. Gentle tannins...." MB bottles per lot US$ Barbaresco Gaja 1978 Piedmont two 2.5cm, two 3.5cm, one glue-stained label, two scuffed labels, two with signs of old seepage "...shows generous amounts of dark fruit in a concentrated style with much persistence, length and the structure of the vintage...92." WA 5/ bottles per lot US$ Barbaresco Costa Russi Gaja 1982 Piedmont two 2cm or better, two 2.5cm, two 3cm, one 3.5cm, two lightly scuffed labels bottles per lot US$ Barbaresco Gaja 1982 Piedmont Lot 1718: 2.5cm Lot 1719: 8cm with elongated neck, lightly bin-soiled label bottles per lot US$ double magnum (3L) per lot US$ Barbaresco Sori San Lorenzo Gaja 1982 Piedmont Lot 1720: six 3cm, four 3.5cm, two nicked labels, three with handwriting on labels, two different importers Lot 1721: one 2cm, one 2.5cm, one lightly bin-soiled label bottles per lot US$ magnums (1.5L) per lot US$ Barbaresco Sori Tildin Gaja 1982 Piedmont Lot 1722: one 2cm, two 2.5cm, lightly bin-soiled labels Lot 1723: three 2.5cm, two 3.5cm, one lightly scuffed label bottles per lot US$ magnums (1.5L) per lot US$ Barbaresco Sori San Lorenzo Gaja 1985 Piedmont three 2cm or better, three 2.5cm, five lightly scuffed labels bottles per lot US$ Barbaresco Sori Tildin Gaja 1985 Barbaresco 2.5cm or better, one torn capsule partially reveals cork bottles per lot US$ Barbaresco Gaja Costa Russi 1978 (2) 2.5cm, wine-stained labels Sori San Lorenzo 1978 (1) 4cm, damp-stained and lightly nicked label, signs of old seepage Costa Russi 1982 magnum (1) 3cm, lightly scuffed label 1990 (1) 2cm 1726 above 4 bottles & 1 magnum (1.5L) per lot US$ Sassicaia 1985 Tuscany bottom neck or better unless noted Lot 1727: one very top shoulder, one lightly bin-soiled label, two lightly damp-stained labels, one slightly protruded cork Lot 1728: three very top shoulder, one top shoulder, one nicked label, two with signs of old seepage "Exceptionally dense, concentrated, and full-bodied...one of the greatest wines made this century " WA 2/ bottles per lot US$11,000-17, bottles per lot US$19,000-30,000 THE SUPERLATIVE COLLECTION OF RICHARD & SUSAN ROGEL OFFERED BY THE UNIVERSITY OF MICHIGAN TO BENEFIT THE ROGEL CANCER CENTER ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com 229

222 ITALIAN STALLIONS (LOTS ) Three of our all-time favorite Piemontese winemakers are represented in the following lots Giacomo Borgogno, Gaja, and Bruno Giacosa from epic vintages such 1931, 1958, 1971 and For Nebbiolo lovers, this is a consignment not to be missed! All bottles are in fantastic condition for age and were removed from professional storage in Europe prior to this sale. BORDEAUX Château Haut-Brion 1929 Graves, Premier Cru Classé upper shoulder, heavily torn label, protruded cork, short capsule reveals vintage branded cork, signs of old seepage "Magnificent. Complex, powerful and deep, juicy and totally alive with beautifully focused, vibrant flavors of black cherry, citrus, red plum and anise, with a firm backbone...97." WS 4/ bottle per lot US$ ITALY Barolo Gaja 1958 Piedmont four 3.5cm, three 4cm, one 4.5cm, one heavily torn label, two lightly scuffed labels, one with different vintage tag bottles per lot US$ Barbaresco Gaja 1961 Piedmont one 3cm, one 3.5cm, two 4cm, one heavily torn label, three lightly scuffed labels, two different bottlings "One of the most glorious Italian wines I have ever drunk. Fine mature red; soft, warm nose, singed fruit lurking beneath, holding beautifully in the glass; medium - the sweetness of ripe grapes, medium full-bodied, soft, with a flavour that opened up into a crescendo. Lovely texture. Gentle tannins...." MB bottles per lot US$ Barolo Le Rocche di Castiglione Falletto Riserva Speciale Bruno Giacosa 1971 Piedmont just below top shoulder, heavily scuffed label, slightly depressed cork bottle per lot US$ Barolo Bussia di Monforte Riserva Speciale Bruno Giacosa 1978 Piedmont into neck, scuffed labels, one slightly protruded cork bottles per lot US$ Barolo Riserva Giacomo Borgogno 1931 (1) 4cm, bin-soiled and scuffed label 1937 (1) 5cm, bin-soiled label 1947 (1) 3.5cm, heavily bin-soiled label 1955 (1) 4cm, bin-soiled label 1961 (1) 4cm, bin-soiled label 1734 above 5 bottles per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com

223 Lots 1732 & 1733 ZACHYS tel fax zachys.com 231

224 Lot ZACHYS tel fax zachys.com

225 A SELECTION OF GREAT RARITIES (LOTS ) This cellar includes two amazing rarities: a 1980 Gentaz and the 1974 Heitz Martha's! The other wines (such as 1990 La Chapelle) are equally excellent. Zachys is pleased to once again offer wines from this consignor's well-researched collection. All bottles housed in perfect temperature and humidity-controlled storage. RHÔNE CALIFORNIA Côte-Rôtie Côte Brune Cuvée Reservee Gentaz-Dervieux 1980 Rhône 3cm, lightly damp-stained label, slightly depressed cork bottle per lot US$ Hermitage JL Chave 1988 Rhône four 2cm or better, two 2.5cm, one depressed cork, three with signs of old seepage "...this opaque, dark ruby/purple-colored wine reveals a tightly knit nose of cassis, minerals, and tar. Fullbodied, with superb concentration...this is a superb Hermitage...93." WA 6/ bottles per lot US$ Hermitage La Chapelle Jaboulet 1990 Rhône 1.5cm or better, one lightly scuffed label "There is extraordinary freshness for such a mammoth wine in addition to abundant tannin, an amazing 60-second finish, and a level of glycerin and thick, fleshy texture " WA 6/ bottles per lot US$ PORT Taylor Fladgate 1992 Douro eleven with importer tags adhered to labels "...unquestionably the greatest young port I have ever tasted...if Château Latour made a late-harvest Cabernet Sauvignon, I suspect it might smell like this " WA 2/ bottles per lot US$ Heitz Wine Cellars Martha's Vineyard Cabernet Sauvignon 1974 top shoulder, lightly bin-soiled label, lightly oxidized capsule, signs of old seepage "Incredibly generous, continually unfolding, always balanced, larger and longer than life! Outstanding plus plus plus. This example is my favorite CA wine of all time." FH 5/ bottle per lot US$ Joseph Phelps Vineyards Insignia 1994 (6) 1994 magnum (1) slightly depressed cork 1740 above 6 bottles & 1 magnum (1.5L) per lot US$ Marcassin Marcassin Vineyard Chardonnay 2009 Sonoma Coast "...beautiful fruit, a full-bodied mouthfeel, penetrating acids and an underlying minerality and richness...sensational Chardonnay and very much in keeping with this vineyard...98." WA 8/ bottles per lot US$ Marcassin Marcassin Vineyard Chardonnay 2012 Sonoma Coast "A wine of great intensity, yet incredibly ethereal elegance, this light greenish gold-colored wine is full-bodied, stunningly rich, and altogether remarkable " WA 3/ bottles per lot US$ Sine Qua Non 2015 Le Chemin Vers L'Heresie Grenache (2) Trouver L'Arene Syrah (4) 1743 above 6 bottles per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com 233

226 SCREAMING EAGLE AND THE BEST OF CALIFORNIA CABERNET (LOTS ) This collector has been acquiring the finest California wines via mailing lists for over a decade. The following exceptional lots are a sampling of these exquisite bottles, representing the very best of. All of these bottles were stored perfectly in a custombuilt home wine cellar. BORDEAUX Château Pavie 2000 St. Emilion, Premier Grand Cru Classé (a) "...stunningly rich nose...fabulously concentrated and fullbodied, with a multidimensional mouthfeel " WA 8/ bottles per lot US$ CALIFORNIA Sine Qua Non 2006 original wood assortment case A Shot in the Dark Syrah (4) In the Crosshairs Grenache (2) 1745 above 6 bottles per lot US$ Screaming Eagle Cabernet Sauvignon 2008 "If Grand Cru Burgundy were made in, it would taste like Screaming Eagle. A delicate, classy finish lets the sheer purity of the fruit come through beautifully here...97." WA 12/ bottle per lot US$ Scarecrow Cabernet Sauvignon 2010 "Firm yet polished tannins support a core of expressive dark fruit, but ultimately it is the wine's textural finesse and polish that stand out most. The 2010 is all about delineation, balance and harmony " WA 12/ bottles per lot US$ Araujo Estate Eisele Vineyard Cabernet Sauvignon 2012 "...a thick-looking, dense ruby/purple color, sensational extract and richness...it pulls back before it becomes heavy or overly extracted. The finish lasts seconds " WA 10/ bottles per lot US$ Hundred Acre Ark Cabernet Sauvignon 2012 three 3-pack s "...certainly another blockbuster wine with no hard edges that comes across like a flawlessly constructed dress from an haute couture house in Paris. It should drink well for years as well " WA 8/ bottles per lot US$ Araujo Estate Eisele Vineyard Cabernet Sauvignon 2010 one with signs of old seepage "Vibrant, precise and beautifully chiseled, the 2010 boasts serious depth and concentration. The aromas and flavors are incredibly vivid...98." WA 12/ bottles per lot US$ Screaming Eagle Cabernet Sauvignon 2012 "What complexity. Precision and decadence plus layers of sexy fruit. A new benchmark for. This is the new legend " JS 7/ bottles per lot US$ ,000 Harlan Estate 2010 "Rich, full-bodied and softer than I would have expected in this vintage, it is a prodigious, multidimensional, compelling wine " WA 10/ bottles per lot US$ Scarecrow Cabernet Sauvignon 2013 "It is dense, full-bodied, prodigiously rich, massive in intensity, yet relatively light on its feet. This great ballerina of a wine has extraordinary ripeness but pulls back from the edge before going over the top " WA 12/ bottles per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com

227 SELECTED FROM THE CELLAR OF A RENOWNED COLLECTOR (LOTS 1754 & 1755) Zachys is pleased to offer the following from a longtime entrepreneur and wine enthusiast. Stored in perfect, custom-built home storage, this is the final offering of a collection built almost entirely on direct acquisition. With such outstanding provenance, you can bid with absolute confidence! CULT CALI (LOTS 1756 & 1757) This pristine offering of cult California wine is as good as it gets. Purchased upon release from the winery and kept, unopened, in original woods in the consignor's temperature- and humidity-controlled home cellar. The provenance on this is unmatched. Happy Bidding! CALIFORNIA BORDEAUX Château Laville Haut-Brion 1937 Graves, Cru Classé mid shoulder, torn label, signs of old seepage bottle per lot US$ BURGUNDY Clos de la Roche Armand Rousseau cm, importer tag adhered to scuffed and lightly torn label, slightly depressed cork bottle per lot US$ Screaming Eagle Second Flight Red 2014 "Dark flavors abound...especially muscular, brooding Second Flight. Accordingly, it is likely to require at least a few years to come into its own...94." AG 12/ bottles per lot US$ Screaming Eagle Cabernet Sauvignon 2015 "...signature elegance and finesse, it's the incredibly fine, oh-so-pixelated tannins that help to define the signature of this vineyard...a very sensuous, pensive style " WA 10/ bottles per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com 235

228 HIGHLIGHTS courtesy of a LAUDABLE COLLECTOR (LOTS ) Legends from banks Right and Left, the following is an excerpt from a cellar built by many years of judicious collecting. Featuring case quantity of both the famed Haut-Brion, as well as La Mission from 1989, this offering goes on to feature a who's who of 1980s Bordeaux. Purchased almost entirely as futures, all bottles have been kept in the same custom temperature- and humiditycontrolled home cellar since purchase. 236 ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com

229 BORDEAUX Château Lafite Rothschild 1982 very top shoulder, lightly bin-soiled labels, one lightly nicked label "In the Pauillac lineup only one person correctly pegged this as Lafite. It was subdued and quiet compared to the other wines in this flight, even though it was doubledecanted well in advance. Tobacco and dark fruit notes on the palate, but slow to open..." SF bottles per lot US$ Château Lafite Rothschild 1985 bottom neck or better "A very intense, firmly structured wine. It reveals notes of cedar, leather and herbs with a firm well-structured finish. Shows great complexity and depth." DS 9/ bottles per lot US$ Château Margaux 1986 Margaux, Premier Cru Classé six very top shoulder, one top shoulder, one upper shoulder, one bin-soiled label, one lightly oxidized capsule "...emotionally moving. Still incredibly youthful, it showed incredible focus and depth, all backed up by considerable structure...striking in every way " AG 2/ bottles per lot US$ Château Mouton Rothschild 1986 two very top shoulder, three top shoulder, three just below top shoulder, two lightly bin-soiled labels, two with importer tags adhered to labels, four different importers, one with signs of old seepage "It boasts a full body of ultra richness, extraordinary length and beauty and an almost chiseled precision to the quality with fabulous length. It lasts for minutes on the palate " JS 3/ bottles per lot US$ Château Lafite Rothschild 1988 ten bottom neck or better, two very top shoulder, one lightly nicked label "Full-bodied, with super silky tannins and a pretty balance of fruit and mint. Long and caressing. Real claret here...94." WS bottles per lot US$ Château Margaux 1988 Margaux, Premier Cru Classé bottom neck or better, one bin-soiled label, one heavily bin-soiled label, one lightly nicked label "Full-bodied, with ultra velvety tannins and loads of berry and chocolate character. Dense and firm. Big wine, muscular...96." WS bottles per lot US$ Château Mouton Rothschild 1988 includes 12-pack missing lid eight bottom neck or better, three very top shoulder, one top shoulder, two lightly nicked labels, one torn label, two different importers "...classic in quality. It's rich and fruity...full-bodied, with silky tannins and an elegant finish...94." WS 11/ bottles per lot US$ Château Haut-Brion 1989 Pessac Léognan, Premier Cru Classé 2cm or better, one lightly damp-stained label, one lightly scuffed label, one with importer tag adhered to label "This is unbelievable. Greatest Haut-Brion ever made...fullbodied, with an amazing concentration of fruit and velvety tannins. The finish goes on for minutes " WS 5/ bottles per lot US$16,000-24,000 Château Lafite Rothschild 1989 bottom neck or better "Wonderful berry and tobacco character, with chocolate and cedar. Full-bodied, yet elegant and silky. Beautifully long. This is always outstanding...94." WS 2/ bottles per lot US$ Château Lafite Rothschild 1990 into neck, one lightly tissue-stained label, one lightly torn capsule "...it boasts gorgeous aromas of cedar, tobacco leaf, cassis, and lead pencil shavings. The explosive aromas are followed by a fleshy, full-bodied wine...96." WA 6/ bottles per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com 237

230 Château Latour 1990 Lot 1768: bottom neck or better, two lightly damp-stained labels Lot 1769: into neck "The nose was tremendous with all the typical Latour characteristics...it was concentrated and dense on the palate... Very open and generous and wonderful to drink at present..." SF bottles per lot US$ magnum (1.5L) per lot US$ Château La Mission Haut-Brion 1978 Graves, Cru Classé three bottom neck or better, one very top shoulder, two lightly damp-stained labels "It is deep ruby/purple-colored with no signs of evolution... It is intensely fragrant, displaying a supple, smooth, velvety texture, and well-developed, rich, cassis, gravel, and smoky scents and flavors. It is very full-bodied, rich, and supple...96." WA 5/ bottles per lot US$ Château L'Eglise Clinet 1982 Pomerol seven bottom neck or better, three very top shoulder, one top shoulder, one lightly bin-soiled label, one marked label, one wine-stained label, importer tags adhered to labels bottles per lot US$ Château Lynch-Bages 1982 Pauillac, Cinquième Cru Classé one very top shoulder, three top shoulder, one just below top shoulder, three upper shoulder, one lightly bin-soiled label, two lightly nicked labels, two lightly scuffed labels, four different importers "One of the most drinkable, complex, and tasty 1982s of the northern Medoc...offers up classic aromas of cedar wood, fruitcake, tobacco leaf, and creme de cassis...94." WA 6/ bottles per lot US$ Château Talbot 1982 St. Julien, Quatrième Cru Classé bottom neck or better, one damp-stained label, one lightly scuffed label, one lightly torn label, one depressed cork "...exhibits a dense garnet color...wine remains fleshy and full-bodied with sweet tannin and an expansive, heady mouthfeel...95." WA 6/ bottles per lot US$ Château Pichon Longueville Comtesse de Lalande 1983 Pauillac, Deuxième Cru Classé six bottom neck or better, three very top shoulder, two top shoulder, one upper shoulder, four bin-soiled labels, one lightly scuffed label, one scuffed label "...full-bodied, gorgeously concentrated and well-proportioned wine with low acidity, plenty of glycerin, and a savory, highly extracted, fleshy mouthfeel. This has always been one of the stars of the vintage...94." WA 6/ bottles per lot US$ Château Rauzan Ségla 1985 Margaux, Deuxième Cru Classé bottom neck or better, six damp-stained labels, one heavily damp-stained label, one nicked label bottles per lot US$ Château Cos d'estournel 1986 St. Estèphe, Deuxième Cru Classé bottom neck or better, three lightly bin-soiled labels, one lightly torn label, four different importers "...exhibits massive, huge, ripe, extremely concentrated flavors with impressive depth and richness...power, weight, and tannin...charming...95." WA 10/ bottles per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com

231 Château Gruaud-Larose 1986 St. Julien, Deuxième Cru Classé Lot 1777: two bottom neck or better, four top shoulder Lot 1778: nine very top shoulder, one top shoulder, two just below top shoulder, six lightly scuffed labels, four oxidized capsules, one with signs of old seepage, original carton "The wine is massive, very impressively constituted, with still some mouth-searing tannin to shed...it is a great Medoc classic, and certainly one of the most magnificent Gruaud-Larose ever made...96." WA 2/ bottles per lot US$ bottles per lot US$ Château Léoville Las Cases 1986 St. Julien, Deuxième Cru Classé three very top shoulder, one top shoulder, one bin-soiled label, one lightly scuffed label, three different importers "The wine has always been phenomenally concentrated, yet wonderfully fresh and vigorous...it is a great example of Léoville Las Cases " WA 1/ bottles per lot US$ Château Lynch-Bages 1986 Pauillac, Cinquième Cru Classé two bottom neck or better, three very top shoulder, four top shoulder, two just below top shoulder, four lightly binsoiled labels "Frankly this Lynch-Bages is a 1986 Claret that you cannot own too much of and as I commented to Jean-Michel Cazes tasting alongside me, at 30 years of age it still has more to give...94." WA 7/ bottles per lot US$ Château Lynch-Bages 1988 Pauillac, Cinquième Cru Classé bottom neck or better bottles per lot US$ Château Pichon Longueville Comtesse de Lalande 1988 Pauillac, Deuxième Cru Classé eight bottom neck or better, three very top shoulder, one top shoulder, two slightly depressed corks "Aromas of black olive, blackberry and currant. Complex and fascinating. Full-bodied, with soft and velvety tannins and a long, caressing finish. Pretty and satisfying...92." WS bottles per lot US$ Château Angélus 1989 St. Emilion, Premier Grand Cru Classé (a) bottom neck or better unless noted Lot 1783: one very top shoulder, one just below top shoulder Lot 1784: four very top shoulder, "...exceptionally endowed, backward, rich, full-bodied, and crammed with fruit...possesses a huge finish...96." WA 2/ bottles per lot US$ bottles per lot US$ SPECIALIST'S PICK: LOTS 1783 & 1784 A brilliant wine of the vintage. Incredibly aromatic, with just the most delicate of dark fruit character as you taste. Wrapped together with smoky vanilla and cigar notes. Angélus does not disappoint, enjoy that lengthy velvet finish for some time to come! Kim Busch ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com 239

232 Château La Conseillante 1989 Pomerol bottom neck or better unless noted Lot 1785: one lightly scuffed label, two different importers Lot 1786: four very top shoulder, "...great purity, sweet tannin, but noticeable structure and muscle, this is a relatively large-scaled La Conseillante that has always been one of the top wines of the vintage...96." WA 1/ bottles per lot US$ bottles per lot US$ Château La Mission Haut-Brion 1989 Pessac Léognan, Cru Classé bottom neck or better "Full-bodied with extraordinary opulence as well as sweet, well-integrated, velvety tannins...fresh, lively, blockbuster La Mission " WA 8/ bottles per lot US$10,000-16,000 Château Lynch-Bages 1989 Pauillac, Cinquième Cru Classé bottom neck or better "Powerful and rich with some tannins still to shed at age 22, it is still a young adolescent in terms of its evolution " WA 8/ bottles per lot US$ Château Palmer 1989 Margaux, Troisième Cru Classé eleven bottom neck or better, one very top shoulder, two scuffed labels, Mahler-Besse "...sweet, jammy nose...full-bodied and supple, with low acidity, copious quantities of ripe fruit and glycerin...95." WA 2/ bottles per lot US$ Château Pichon-Baron 1989 Pauillac, Deuxième Cru Classé into neck "Full-bodied and very soft, with round, caressing tannins and a deliciously fresh berry, plum aftertaste...98." WS 5/ bottles per lot US$ Château Angélus 1990 St. Emilion, Premier Grand Cru Classé (a) bottom neck or better unless noted Lot 1791: two very top shoulder, one top shoulder, original wood case "Full-bodied, flamboyant, and opulent, with low acidity and sweet tannin...96." WA 6/ half-bottles (375ml) per lot US$ bottles per lot US$ Château Lynch-Bages 1990 Pauillac, Cinquième Cru Classé into neck "It is a hedonistic as well as intellectual turn-on. There is not a hard edge to be found...97." WA 6/ bottles per lot US$ Château Montrose 1990 St. Estèphe, Deuxième Cru Classé bottom neck or better "...absolutely magnificent, broad, savory and mouth-filling. This is one of the all-time modern legends from Bordeaux as well as Château Montrose " WA 8/ bottles per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com

233 Lots 1765 & 1787 ZACHYS tel fax zachys.com 241

234 1995 BORDEAUX (LOTS ) Purchased from Zachys, these three lots of 1995 Bordeaux and one lot of 1998 Ornellaia are the perfect addition to your cellar. Bid with confidence. BORDEAUX ITALY Château Haut-Brion 1995 Pessac Léognan, Premier Cru Classé includes 6-pack "...beautiful, knock-out set of aromatics, consisting of black fruits, vanillin, spice, and wood-fire smoke. Multidimensional and rich, with layers of ripe fruit, and beautifully integrated tannin and acidity...96." WA 2/ magnums (1.5L) per lot US$ Ornellaia 1998 Tuscany two 6-pack s "Full-bodied, with a wonderfully silky palate of fine tannins and a long, fruity finish. Very sophisticated and reserved...96." WS 11/ bottles per lot US$ Pétrus 1995 Pomerol into neck "Unquestionably one of the vintage's superstars...on the palate, it possesses teeth-staining extract levels, massive body, and rich, sweet black fruits buttressed by powerful, noticeable tannin...96." WA 2/ bottle per lot US$ Château La Mission Haut-Brion 1995 Pessac Léognan, Cru Classé "With low acidity and chewy, full-bodied flavors, this intense 1995 appears to be a top-class La Mission-Haut- Brion...92." RP magnums (1.5L) per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com

235 SELECTIONS FROM AN ACCLAIMED PRIVATE CELLAR (LOTS ) The following lots are offered on the behalf of a lifelong friend of Zachys. We could not be more pleased to once again represent this exalted collection. Featuring top tier Bordeaux, including 1982 Margaux in 3L, an exciting mixed lot of d'yquem spanning several vintages from , and an extensive selection of Colgin, this offering has something for everyone. All bottles have been stored in perfect, custom built temperature- and humidity-controlled storage. BORDEAUX Château Latour 1982 bottom neck, lightly bin-soiled label "This is the freshest, most resounding and interesting example of this wine I have ever tried. Very approachable and enjoyable, with the Latour strength, but still soft with an excellent finish..." SF bottle per lot US$ Château Margaux 1982 Margaux, Premier Cru Classé bottom neck, importer tag adhered to damp-stained and lightly wine-stained label, protruded cork This wine was breathtaking!...beautiful as soon as it was opened and did not really evolve over the course of the evening, but stayed at a really great spot... SF double magnum (3L) per lot US$ Château Latour 1990 bottom neck or better, one lightly nicked label, one lightly wine-stained label, two different importers "The nose was tremendous with all the typical Latour characteristics...it was concentrated and dense on the palate... Very open and generous and wonderful to drink at present..." SF bottles per lot US$ Château Latour 1994 one lightly damp-stained label, one scuffed label "...a superbly rich, concentrated, full-bodied Latour with remarkable intensity...this wine will shock many tasters who have not given the 1994 vintage much consideration...95." WA 4/ bottles per lot US$ Château Lafite Rothschild 2002 Lot 1805: one lightly damp-stained label, one lightly winestained label "Beautiful. Full-bodied, with gorgeously velvety tannins and a long finish of pretty fruit. This is a racy yet elegant Lafite. Classy...95." WS 3/ bottles per lot US$ bottles per lot US$ Château Haut-Brion 2008 Pessac Léognan, Premier Cru Classé "...presented in a vivid, vibrant, full-bodied style that cuts an ethereal feel across the palate " WA 4/ double magnum (3L) per lot US$ Château Branaire Ducru 1982 St. Julien, Quatrième Cru Classé four bottom neck or better, four very top shoulder, one top shoulder, one just below top shoulder, lightly damp-stained labels bottles per lot US$ Château Calon Ségur 1982 St. Estèphe, Troisième Cru Classé five very top shoulder, one top shoulder, two just below top shoulder, one with signs of old seepage "Full-bodied, still extremely tannic (sweet but noticeable tannins), rich " WA 6/ bottles per lot US$ Château La Conseillante 2000 Pomerol "Full-bodied yet ethereal in the sense that it seems to combine power along with eloquence and delicacy, this is a beautifully pure wine that has just hit its plateau of full maturity...96." WA 6/ bottles per lot US$ Château Haut-Brion 1998 Pessac Léognan, Premier Cru Classé "The nose is just fantastic, just soars from the glass with brilliant delineation and freshness...the palate is awesome...98." WA 5/ bottles per lot US$ Château Pavie 2000 St. Emilion, Premier Grand Cru Classé (a) "...stunningly rich nose...fabulously concentrated and fullbodied, with a multidimensional mouthfeel " WA 8/ bottles per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com 243

236 Château Pichon Longueville Comtesse de Lalande 2000 Pauillac, Deuxième Cru Classé scuffed label "This is a rich, opulent, stunning Pichon Lalande that is beginning to drink beautifully...96." WA 6/ jeroboam (5L) per lot US$ Château Pichon Longueville Comtesse de Lalande 2002 Pauillac, Deuxième Cru Classé Lot 1812: Lot 1813: two nicked labels, one torn label, one with signs of old seepage bottles per lot US$ bottles per lot US$ Château d'yquem 1976 (1) top shoulder, damp-stained label 1983 (1) very top shoulder 1986 (1) very top shoulder 1991 (2) 1993 (2) 1994 (1) loose capsule reveals fully branded cork 1995 (2) 1996 (1) 1997 (2) 1998 (2) 1999 (1) 1814 above 16 bottles per lot US$ RHÔNE Hermitage JL Chave 2005 Rhône "Really packed, but amazingly supple and velvety in texture, with layer upon layer...all driving through the long, long finish...98." WS 7/ bottles per lot US$ CHAMPAGNE Krug Clos du Mesnil 1995 Champagne original coffret "Its firm structure is seamlessly integrated into the finegrained texture, ending with a mouthwatering finish...98." WS 12/ bottle per lot US$ ITALY Sassicaia 2009 Tuscany "It is full and powerful with a big juicy character that goes on for minutes. Muscular yet covered with pretty fruit JS 6/ one 6 Liter per lot US$ SPAIN Vega Sicilia Único 1987 Ribera del Duero bottom neck "It is interwoven by edgy, crisp acidity with touches of cooked meat and mandarin, plus a little liquorice towards the sappy, succulent finish...95." WA 8/ magnum (1.5L) per lot US$ Artadi El Pison 2004 Rioja one torn label "...with an ethereal bouquet found only in the greatest wines " WA 2/ bottles per lot US$ Artadi El Pison 2006 Rioja four damp-stained labels, one lightly damp-stained label "...a layered wine with an elegant personality that still has plenty of grip, breadth, and length. It is a tour de force that will provide pleasure over the next years...97." WA 2/ bottles per lot US$ SPECIALIST'S PICK: LOT 1816 A taste was all, but still enough to have me seeing stars. Admittedly, Krug is my absolute favorite Champagne house stylistically, but the '95 Clos du Mesnil is unbelievably, and expertly complex. Perfect acidity, followed by the smooth, creamy nature we have come to know and love about Mesnil. Kim Busch 244 ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com

237 CALIFORNIA BRYANT FAMILY Bryant Family Vineyard Cabernet Sauvignon 2001 two lightly damp-stained labels "...exhibits the classic Bryant bouquet of melted creosote intermixed with blackberry liqueur and other black fruits. It is medium to full-bodied, opulent and sumptuous..." WA 12/ bottles per lot US$ Colgin IX Estate Red bottles per lot US$ Colgin IX Estate Red 2012 "Simply loaded, but with pristine harmony and equilibrium, this is a sensational tour de force and a great tribute to this spectacular hillside site...99." WA 10/ bottles per lot US$ Bryant Family Vineyard Cabernet Sauvignon 2004 "A gorgeous perfume...full-bodied, concentrated, spectacularly layered and nuanced wine " WA 12/ bottles per lot US$ Bryant Family Vineyard Bettina Bryant Proprietary Blend 2010 "...drop dead gorgeous...this is a stellar showing from Bryant " AG 12/ bottles per lot US$ Bryant Family Vineyard Cabernet Sauvignon 2011 "The 2011 is a bit understated relative to previous years, but its balance is terrific. High-toned floral and savory notes add an attractive upper register to the finish " WA 11/ bottles per lot US$ Bryant Family Vineyard Cabernet Sauvignon 1998 (5) one damp-stained label, one wine-stained label 1999 (1) 1999 magnum (1) 2001 magnum (1) 2002 (2) 2005 magnum (1) 1825 above 8 bottles & 3 magnums (1.5L) per lot US$ Colgin Herb Lamb Vineyard Cabernet Sauvignon 1994 (1) 1996 (3) one nicked label 1998 (2) one lightly scuffed label 2001 (2) 2003 (1) 1829 above 9 bottles per lot US$ Colgin Cariad Red 1999 (2) one nicked label 2000 (1) 2001 (4) 2003 (1) 2008 (3) 1830 above 11 bottles per lot US$ Colgin Tychson Hill Vineyard Cabernet Sauvignon 2000 (6) one lightly torn label 2003 (4) 2005 (3) 2008 (1) 2010 (3) 2011 (3) 1831 above 20 bottles per lot US$ COLGIN Colgin Cariad Red 2005 four bin-soiled labels "Full-bodied and velvety textured with fabulous concentration, high but sweet tannin and a 60+ second finish... should age effortlessly " WA 6/ bottles per lot US$ Colgin IX Estate Red 2004 (5) 2005 (1) 1832 above 6 bottles per lot US$ Colgin Cariad Red 2009 (6) 2011 (6) 1833 above 12 bottles per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com 245

238 Lots ZACHYS tel fax zachys.com

239 HARLAN ESTATE AUSTRALIA Harlan Estate 2011 "Deep, round and generous with silky tannins and a forward, evolved style...93." WA 10/ bottles per lot US$ magnums (1.5L) per lot US$ Penfolds Grange 1998 South Australia "...astonishing wine, utterly seamless, maybe the best Grange yet. Powerful, aristocratic and impressive...99." WS 5/ bottles per lot US$ Harlan Estate 2012 Lot 1836: "Vivid and captivating from the very first taste...stunningly beautiful delineated wine that represents the height of total finesse...98." AG 12/ bottles per lot US$ magnum (1.5L) per lot US$ Harlan Estate 1999 (1) 2006 magnum (1) 2009 (1) 1838 above 2 bottles & 1 magnum (1.5L) per lot US$ Lokoya Mount Veeder Cabernet Sauvignon 2002 Mount Veeder "As it sits in the glass, scents of flowers, espresso roast, and black fruits emerge...when this winery gets everything right, they produce some of the finest Cabernet Sauvignons made in northern California...96." WA 2/ bottles per lot US$ Shafer Vineyards Hillside Select Cabernet Sauvignon 2003 Stag's Leap District "...aromas of camphor, black currants, licorice, crushed rocks, and white flowers...impeccable balance, purity, and length...95." WA 12/ bottles per lot US$ SPECIALIST'S PICK: LOT 1840 If you love the Stag's Leap District, you cannot pass on the Hillside Select from Shafer. This is one of the best expressions from the region, a beautifully balanced California Cabernet in its prime drinking days! Julia Banks ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com 247

240 Property of a GENTLEMAN (LOTS ) This offering of wines is focused primarily on Bordeaux, but the selection of Burgundy, Guigal's La Las, and a smattering of rare SQN is strong as well. The best part of this cellar is that the youngest Bordeaux is a couple of decades old, and the great vintages: 1990, 1989, 1982, and so on, are plenty. The First Growths are present, but this is truly a drinker's cellar, with wines at every price point. Leroy, DRC, Dugat, and others make up an excellent Burgundy section. Rare mature Rayas and the La Las are in supply as well. The wines in this collection were sourced mainly from NYC-area retailers (Sokolin) and auction houses (Christie's) and stored in a temperatureand humidity-controlled custom cellar until removed by Zachys specialists for this auction. Bid with confidence. 248 ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com

241 BORDEAUX Château Lafite Rothschild 1982 one bottom neck, one very top shoulder, lightly dampstained labels, one nicked label "In the Pauillac lineup only one person correctly pegged this as Lafite. It was subdued and quiet compared to the other wines in this flight, even though it was doubledecanted well in advance. Tobacco and dark fruit notes on the palate, but slow to open..." SF bottles per lot US$ Château Lafite Rothschild 1986 bottom neck or better "...beautifully defined, still full of energy...it must rank as one of the finest wines from the estate...98." WA 12/ bottles per lot US$ Château Latour 1988 bottom neck or better "Surprisingly rich towards the finish, as if the wine had forgotten its vintage and thought it was a 1990!...92." WA 9/ bottles per lot US$ Château Lafite Rothschild 1989 bottom neck or better "Wonderful berry and tobacco character, with chocolate and cedar. Full-bodied, yet elegant and silky. Beautifully long. This is always outstanding...94." WS 2/ bottles per lot US$ Château Mouton Rothschild 1994 "Medium to full-bodied, with outstanding concentration, a layered feel, plenty of tannin, and rich, concentrated fruit...91." WA 2/ bottles per lot US$ Château Lafite Rothschild 1995 Full-bodied, with a solid core of tannins and a long, silky finish. Still holding back, but is concentrated and powerful WS bottles per lot US$ Château Lafite Rothschild 1996 three different importers "...extremely powerful and full-bodied, with remarkable complexity...oozing with extract and richness, yet has managed to preserve its quintessentially elegant personality " WA 4/ bottles per lot US$ Château Latour 1996 "...generosity on the palate and similar notes on the nose...a truly breathtaking effort...way too young to drink now, although I am still glad I did..." SF bottles per lot US$ Château Mouton Rothschild 1996 importer tags adhered to labels "Incredible nose of ultraripe fruit, it's yet subtle and complex. Full-bodied, with very ripe, almost sweet fruit and a long, long caressing finish. Superb...96." WS bottles per lot US$ Château Lafite Rothschild 1998 "...close to perfection...the wine is elegant yet profoundly rich, revealing the essence of Lafite's character...the wine is spectacularly layered yet never heavy...98." WA 4/ bottles per lot US$ Château Mouton Rothschild 1998 "It is massive, with awesome concentration...96." WA 4/ imperial (6L) per lot US$ Château Latour 1999 one lightly bin-soiled label "A big, concentrated offering...long, ripe, and mediumbodied, with high levels of sweet tannin, this surprisingly full, concentrated " WA 4/ bottles per lot US$ Château Mouton Rothschild 1999 "...sumptuous aromas...forward, lush, and full-bodied, it is already complex as well as succulent, fleshy, and long...93." WA 4/ bottles per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com 249

242 Château Cos d'estournel 1982 St. Estèphe, Deuxième Cru Classé bottom neck or better, three lightly damp-stained labels "Gorgeous aromas of sweet celery (I like celery!!), currants, and blueberries. Rich and warm on the palate, viscous, balanced, with flavors of buttery blackberries. A great showing...outstanding plus." FH bottles per lot US$ Château Ducru-Beaucaillou 1982 St. Julien, Deuxième Cru Classé four bottom neck or better, two very top shoulder, one top shoulder, two different bottlings, four different importers "...sweet perfume of forest floor, spice box, cedar, and copious quantities of black fruits. Medium to full-bodied beautifully pure with sweet tannins...96." WA 6/ bottles per lot US$ Château Gruaud-Larose 1982 St. Julien, Deuxième Cru Classé two very top shoulder, four top shoulder, three just below top shoulder, six lightly bin-soiled labels, one lightly torn label, six depressed corks, three heavily depressed corks "A massive wine that is clearly of First Growth quality... continues to justify its legendary status...98." WA 6/ bottles per lot US$ Château Léoville Las Cases 1982 St. Julien, Deuxième Cru Classé six bottom neck or better, one very top shoulder, one top shoulder, five damp-stained labels, two deteriorated labels, two torn labels, two different importers "Rich flavors of bracken, winter vegetables, cherries, and cranberries. On the rich side for LLC!...Outstanding minus." FH bottles per lot US$ Château Clinet 1989 Pomerol three bottom neck or better, five very top shoulder, one oxidized capsule "This spectacularly concentrated, full-bodied, multi-dimensional wine is the stuff of dreams " WA 12/ bottles per lot US$ Château Palmer 1989 Margaux, Troisième Cru Classé bottom neck or better, one Mahler-Besse "...sweet, jammy nose...full-bodied and supple, with low acidity, copious quantities of ripe fruit and glycerin...95." WA 2/ bottles per lot US$ Château Montrose 1989 St. Estèphe, Deuxième Cru Classé bottom neck or better "Fabulous aromas of roasted fruit, blackberry, tobacco, chocolate and toasted oak. Full and velvety and very, very fresh. Powerful and fabulously structured...97." WS bottles per lot US$ Château Cos d'estournel 1990 St. Estèphe, Deuxième Cru Classé into neck "Expansive, round, and sensual, with wonderful purity as well as lushness, this irresistible wine...94." WA 6/ bottles per lot US$ Château Léoville Las Cases 1990 St. Julien, Deuxième Cru Classé eight bottom neck or better, two very top shoulder, one bin-soiled label, one lightly scuffed label, two different importers "In the mouth, it is full-bodied, and while technically low in acidity, there is a freshness, delineation, and classicism...96." WA 6/ bottles per lot US$ Château Montrose 1990 St. Estèphe, Deuxième Cru Classé five bottom neck or better, three very top shoulder, one top shoulder, one lightly nicked label, one lightly winestained label "...absolutely magnificent, broad, savory and mouth-filling. This is one of the all-time modern legends from Bordeaux as well as Château Montrose " WA 8/ bottles per lot US$ Château Pichon-Baron 1990 Pauillac, Deuxième Cru Classé bottom neck or better "...it reveals an extraordinary bouquet of charcoal, incense, creme de cassis, blue and black fruits, and a hint of licorice as well as an impressively long finish...97." WA 6/ bottles per lot US$ Château Angélus 1995 St. Emilion, Premier Grand Cru Classé (a) two different importers "Slightly reserved in the nose. Full-bodied, with loads of layered, velvety tannins. Big, yet refined and beautiful. Long and caressing...95." WS bottles per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com

243 Château Ducru-Beaucaillou 1995 St. Julien, Deuxième Cru Classé "The greatest Ducru produced this century. Breathtaking aromas...full-bodied and tannic, yet very fine and long in the mouth. This has fabulous structure for aging...97." WS 6/ bottles per lot US$ Château Valandraud 1996 St. Emilion "Dense and powerful, with a thick, moderately tannic palate feel, this full-bodied, rich, persuasive wine " WA 4/ bottles per lot US$ Château Léoville Las Cases 1996 St. Julien, Deuxième Cru Classé "It stands as one of the best wines of the vintage... You might call it 'proper Claret.' You might call it 'delicious"...98." WA 10/ bottles per lot US$ Château Lafleur 1999 Pomerol one lightly nicked label "Super concentrated, extraordinarily pure, with moderately high tannin, this dense, powerful, impressively endowed wine should turn out to be a classic for Lafleur..." WA 4/ bottles per lot US$ Château Angélus 2000 St. Emilion, Premier Grand Cru Classé (a) "Slightly reserved in the nose. Full-bodied, with loads of layered, velvety tannins. Big, yet refined and beautiful. Long and caressing...95." WS bottles per lot US$ BURGUNDY Bonnes-Mares Louis Jadot 1990 four 2cm or better, three 3cm, five nicked labels, six with signs of old seepage "...very expressive, very ripe and spicy mix of primary and secondary fruit aromas though the big, intense, rich, robust flavors...the finish is long, complex and velvety...91." BH 3/ bottles per lot US$ Romanée-St-Vivant Domaine de la Romanée-Conti cm, scuffed label "...while this displays only a bit of the classic RSV velvet, this character will undoubtedly become more pronounced with age as there is plenty of mid-palate density...92." BH 9/ bottle per lot US$ Vosne-Romanée Les Beaux Monts Domaine Leroy 1990 Côte de Nuits, Premier Cru 1cm, importer tag adhered to label, lightly chipped wax capsule "Deep and very darkly colored with extremely ripe, borderline over ripe nose that evidences loads of spice and rich black fruits followed by sexy, sappy, intense flavors... Impressive...92." BH 5/ bottle per lot US$ La Tâche Domaine de la Romanée-Conti cm, lightly scuffed label "Balanced, with lots of beautiful fruit, but above all it has pleasure and harmony etched all over it...95." WS 9/ bottle per lot US$ Château La Conseillante 2000 Pomerol missing lid "Full-bodied yet ethereal in the sense that it seems to combine power along with eloquence and delicacy, this is a beautifully pure wine that has just hit its plateau of full maturity...96." WA 6/ bottles per lot US$ Charmes-Chambertin Claude Dugat regales the olfactory senses with sweet and perfumed red and black cherry scents that are lively, profound, and verging on jammy - reminiscent of the filling of a deep dish cherry pie WA 8/ bottles per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com 251

244 Lot ZACHYS tel fax zachys.com

245 La Tâche Domaine de la Romanée-Conti 1996 discolored label and vintage tag "The tannins are big, ripe and are completely buffered by the sap with length that is simply phenomenal...96." BH 7/ bottle per lot US$ Vosne-Romanée Les Beaux Monts Domaine Leroy 1996 Côte de Nuits, Premier Cru "Profound aromas...full-bodied, extremely feminine, and massively ripe and vibrant core...96." WA 8/ bottle per lot US$ Clos de la Roche Domaine Leroy 1998 "It has huge quantities of sweet cherry, blackberry, and violet-infused blueberries, a huge velvety-textured character, and a full body...96." WA 10/ bottle per lot US$ Corton Renardes Domaine Leroy 1998 Côte de Beaune, Grand Cru "...awesome...this expansive wine is deep, well-balanced, velvety-textured, and has a long, flavor-packed finish...95." WA 10/ bottles per lot US$ RHÔNE Châteauneuf-du-Pape Hommage à Jacques Perrin Château Beaucastel 1990 Rhône one 1.5cm, one 2.5cm "...super-concentrated, mammoth-sized wine...a huge, fragrant perfume...muscular and tannic, with tremendous amounts of glycerin and concentration " WA 2/ bottles per lot US$ Châteauneuf-du-Pape Reserve Château Rayas 1995 Rhône lightly bin-soiled labels "...spectacular...deeply-colored and still young...huge body, yet great structure and delineation...96." WA 1/ bottles per lot US$ GUIGAL Côte-Rôtie La Turque Guigal 1991 Rhône lightly scuffed labels "It is a winemaking tour de force...phenomenal levels of fruit, complexity, and richness into this velvety-textured wine without causing it to taste heavy...99." RP bottles per lot US$ La Romanée Bouchard Père et Fils 2001 "...incredibly concentrated...dense, tight, understated, broad scaled flavors of stunning length. The depth here is nothing short of mind blowing " BH 4/ magnum (1.5L) per lot US$ Musigny Vieilles Vignes Comte Georges de Vogüé 1991 (1) marked and lightly scuffed label 1993 (1) 1996 (1) lightly scuffed label 1997 (2) one lightly damp-stained label, one lightly torn label 2000 (1) lightly marked label 1883 above 6 bottles per lot US$ Côte-Rôtie La Landonne Guigal 1995 Rhône three with importer tags adhered to labels, three lightly scuffed labels "...with copious quantities of black fruits and smoke in this complex, structured, muscular, massive Côte- Rôtie " WA 2/ bottles per lot US$ Côte-Rôtie La Mouline Guigal 1995 Rhône one slightly protruded cork "Medium to full-bodied and lush, with a terrific multi-layered texture and outstanding purity, this is a phenomenal example of La Mouline " WA 2/ bottles per lot US$ Côte-Rôtie La Mouline Guigal 1998 Rhône three different importers "...a seamless, full-bodied classic with many characteristics of the 1997 La Landonne, but more structure, tannin, and muscle...this wine's aromatic fireworks, sumptuous texture, and seamless personality represent perfection...97." WA 4/ bottles per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com 253

246 Côte-Rôtie La Landonne Guigal 2003 Rhône two glue-stained labels, two lightly scuffed labels "I suspect this is more akin to a dry vintage port than most Côte-Rôties ever tend to be, but the purity, the richness, the texture, the length are all out of this world " WA 4/ bottles per lot US$ Côte-Rôtie La Mouline Guigal 2003 Rhône "...enormous full-bodied opulence and striking velvety, seamless texture make for one of the most memorable wines anyone could every drink " WA 4/ bottles per lot US$ Côte-Rôtie La Turque Guigal 2003 Rhône "Powerful, thick flavors ooze across the palate with a viscous texture, amazing purity, and just enough acidity and tannin to give uplift and precision to this remarkable tour de force in winemaking " WA 4/ bottles per lot US$ Côte-Rôtie Guigal 1996 La Landonne (6) La Mouline (2) different importers La Turque (4) 1893 above 12 bottles per lot US$ CALIFORNIA SINE QUA NON Sine Qua Non Over and Out Pinot Noir 2005 Santa Ynez Valley bottles per lot US$ Sine Qua Non Just For The Love Of It Syrah 2002 Central Coast one torn label "A dead-ringer (at least aromatically) for Guigal's single vineyard Côte-Rôtie La Mouline...the greatest California Syrah I have yet tasted " WA 8/ bottles per lot US$ Sine Qua Non Eleven Confessions Inaugural Syrah 2003 California "...boasts a magnificent bouquet...remarkable intensity, purity, and full-bodied power, but it somehow manages to dance across the taste buds with the gracefulness of a ballerina. Awesomely long " WA 8/ bottles per lot US$ Sine Qua Non Papa Syrah 2003 Santa Rita Hills one lightly scuffed label "One of the most aromatically compelling offerings in SQN's portfolio...decadently rich, lavishly fruity, full-bodied 2003 boasting tremendous purity " WA 6/ bottles per lot US$ Sine Qua Non Heart Chorea Syrah 2002 California "...possesses extraordinary levels of concentration, intensity, and subtle nuances, a fabulous nose...opulent, fullbodied, and super-intense, but neither heavy nor out of balance...99." WA 8/ bottle per lot US$ Sine Qua Non Into The Dark Grenache 2004 Ventura one torn label "...sumptuous, sweet perfume of candied black cherries, licorice, spice, and pepper. On the palate, the wine is fleshy, full-bodied, well-delineated, structured, powerful, and long...96." WA 8/ bottles per lot US$ Sine Qua Non Poker Face Syrah 2004 Central Coast "...another potentially perfect wine...continues to go from strength to strength, refusing to make any compromises on the long and less traveled road he has chosen " WA 8/ bottles per lot US$ NO LOT 254 ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com

247 CENTURIES OLD MADEIRA FROM A REMARKABLE COLLECTION (LOTS ) If you know your Madeira, then you certainly know how rare and exciting the following lots are. Rarities aplenty with 1795 Terrantez Barbeito, 1827 Bual Quinta do Serrado and 1931 Quinta do Noval Nacional. All of these sourced meticulously, mostly from Christie's and Sotheby's Madeira sales in late 1990s. This collector has consigned with Zachys several times over the last couple of years, always releasing bottles that show amazingly well. All of these bottles were stored with the utmost care in a professionally built, temperature- and humidity-controlled home wine cellar. PORT MADEIRA Antonio Jose de Silva Port 1931 Douro top shoulder, wine-stained shipper label, T&W Wines Thetford, Norfolk bottling, signs of seepage bottle per lot US$ NO LOT Quinta do Noval Nacional 1931 Douro one into neck, one top shoulder, marked facsimile labels stating"probably Nacional from his private cellar MB." shipped by Da Silva, one with signs of old seepage Provenance: Christie's, February 22, 1997 Lot bottles per lot US$ ,000 Madeira Verdelho Justino Henriques Solera 1748 Madeira bottom neck bottle per lot US$ Madeira Boal Justino Henriques Solera 1792 Madeira bottom neck, chipped wax capsule bottle per lot US$ Madeira Terrantez Barbeito 1795 Madeira bottom neck or better bottle per lot US$ bottles per lot US$12,000-18,000 Madeira Bual Quinta do Serrado 1827 Madeira Lot 1909: one bottom neck, one very top shoulder, winestained Christie's shipper labels, chipped wax capsules, signs of old seepage, bottled in 1988 Lot 1910: two bottom neck or better, one just below top shoulder, Christie's shipper labels, one lightly wine-stained label, chipped wax capsules, one with signs of old seepage, bottled in 1988 "A fabulous wine, with all the great, old-vintage attributes, concentration yet finesse, length, fragrance. Most recently, very rich amber; sweet, mouth-tantalising, very high acidity. Superb...." MB 3/ bottles per lot US$ bottles per lot US$ Madeira Malvazia Barbeito 1834 Madeira Lot 1911: into neck Lot 1912: bottom neck or better, one chipped wax capsule, bottled in October 1995 Lot 1913: bottom neck or better, chipped wax capsules "The flavors melt in the mouth in this medium-sweet Madeira of beautiful balance and structure. The chocolate notes echo on the finish...96." WS 1/ bottle per lot US$ bottles per lot US$ bottles per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com 255

248 Madeira Sercial Blandys Solera 1835 Madeira bottom neck, heavily damp-stained label, Sherry-Lehmann Bottling, bottled by Edward Young & Co. Ltd. England bottle per lot US$ Madeira Verdelho Solera Leacocks 1872 Madeira bottom neck or better, lightly bin-soiled labels, one with signs of old seepage bottles per lot US$ Madeira Bual Centenary Solera Cossart Gordon 1845 Madeira four bottom neck or better, one very top shoulder, dampstained labels, four chipped wax capsules "...glowing amber; high-toned, harmonious, very nutty nose; medium-sweet, very powerful...." MB bottles per lot US$ Madeira Sercial Reserva D Oliveiras 1862 Madeira bottom neck or better bottles per lot US$ Madeira Bual Barbeito 1863 Madeira bottom neck or better, two chipped wax capsules, bottled in October bottles per lot US$ ,000 Madeira Malmsey Leacock Solera 1863 Madeira bottom neck bottle per lot US$ Madeira Bual Blandys 1864 Madeira bottom neck, heavily bin-soiled shipper label, heavily chipped wax capsule, signs of old seepage bottle per lot US$ Madeira Grand Cama de Lobos Blandys Solera 1864 Madeira three bottom neck or better, one top shoulder, three heavily damp-stained labels, one scuffed label, three shipper labels, one heavily depressed cork, one with signs of old seepage, bottled by Edward Young and Co. London Provenance: Khoury Collection "...all lovely, with exciting tangy, smoky, slightly tarry, refined spirit bouquet; medium-sweet, fabulous flavour, great length, cockle-warming yet exquisite...." MB bottles per lot US$ Madeira Verdelho Lomelino Solera 1865 Madeira two bottom neck or better, two very top shoulder, one upper-mid shoulder, shipper labels, three with signs of old seepage Provenance: Khoury Collection bottles per lot US$ Madeira Bastardo Shortridge Lawton and Co 1875 Madeira into neck, lightly scuffed label, chipped wax capsule, specially selected for Sherry-Lehmann bottle per lot US$ Madeira Bual Cossart Gordon 1895 Madeira bottom neck bottle per lot US$ Madeira Terrantez Blandys 1898 Madeira bottom neck or better, one wine-stained label, chipped wax capsules, signs of old seepage bottles per lot US$ Madeira Terrantez Blandys 1902 Madeira three bottom neck or better, one very top shoulder, two top shoulder, three lightly wine-stained labels, oxidized capsules, two with signs of old seepage, specially selected by Frank Packard bottles per lot US$ Madeira Malmsey Cossart Gordon 1920 Madeira bottom neck, corroded capsule Provenance: Khoury Collection "Big, bold, balanced and elegant. Plenty of acid and an incredibly long and lively finish...this wine will outlive my grandchildren...97." RH 8/ bottle per lot US$ Madeira Blandys Malmsey Solera 1863 (3) one into neck, one just below top shoulder, one upper shoulder, one deteriorated label, one scuffed label, one with signs of old seepage, two different bottlings Verdelho Solera 1880 (1) mid shoulder, depressed cork, signs of old seepage Bual 1897 (1) bottom neck, shipper label, heavily chipped wax capsule reveals cork, signs of old seepage 1928 above 5 bottles per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com

249 A VERTICAL OF SCREAMING EAGLE IN 3-PACK OWC (LOTS ) Property of a California Collector, all wines were purchased from the mailing list and stored thereafter in a custom home temperature-controlled cellar. CALIFORNIA SCREAMING EAGLE Screaming Eagle Cabernet Sauvignon 2009 "Layers of intensely sweet, perfumed fruit are woven together with remarkable elegance and sheer polish...a translucent, weightless finish rounds things out in style...98." WA 12/ bottles per lot US$ Screaming Eagle Cabernet Sauvignon 2010 "The firm acidity conveys an almost peppery impression. Finishes seriously tannic, structured and very long, with a lingering peppery quality " IWC 6/ bottles per lot US$ Screaming Eagle Cabernet Sauvignon 2011 "Cool, graphite-infused veins of minerality provide the backbone for layers of dark, brooding fruit " AG 11/ bottles per lot US$ Screaming Eagle Cabernet Sauvignon 2012 "What complexity. Precision and decadence plus layers of sexy fruit. A new benchmark for. This is the new legend " JS 7/ bottles per lot US$ ,000 Screaming Eagle Cabernet Sauvignon 2013 "It lasts for minutes on the finish. The classicism in this wine is second to none. Incredible subtlety. Lovely austerity. Beauty in simplicity " JS 1/ bottles per lot US$ Screaming Eagle Cabernet Sauvignon 2014 "It grows on the palate with an extremely long finish that goes on for minutes...purity and essence to this. Feminine yet wild and unpredictable...99." JS 1/ bottles per lot US$ Screaming Eagle Cabernet Sauvignon 2015 "...signature elegance and finesse, it's the incredibly fine, oh-so-pixelated tannins that help to define the signature of this vineyard...a very sensuous, pensive style " WA 10/ bottles per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com 257

250 MOUTON & HARLAN IN ORIGINAL WOOD (LOTS 1936 & 1937) This concise offering listed below comes to us from a tristate area consignor who has held them in his custom built, temperaturecontrolled storage facility since purchase. BORDEAUX CALIFORNIA Château Mouton Rothschild 1995 "Very beautiful wine. Mouton shows finesse yet richness in this vintage...94." WS bottles per lot US$ Harlan Estate 1994 three tissue-stained labels "...I have tasted the wine for three consecutive years, and each time it satisfied all of my requirements for perfection...comes close to immortality in the glass " WA 12/ bottles per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com

251 AN AMAZING COLLECTION OF RARE SQN (LOTS ) From a custom home cellar not far from NYC comes this enormous selection of mailing list SQN. Rare older vintages are present here, but what's most impressive are the large formats. It's not often we see this many magnums (Just for the Love of it, Lil E, Into the Dark, others) and to see rare double magnums is truly incredible. You get the idea. This offering is a chance to bid on wines that will likely never or least for another few years come up for auction again. All wines in this offering were bought from the SQN mailing list by the current consignor and haven't left his cellar until being removed by Zachys in temperature-controlled transport for this auction. CALIFORNIA SINE QUA NON In the jargon of English speaking wine nerds, they are called garage wines, garagistes in Spanish, vins de garage in French, and delicious, expensive, and impossible to find wines by the mainstream consuming public. They are some of the most exciting efforts being produced in winedom today are these limited production gems The truth is in the bottle, and garage wines often provide compelling drinking experiences. The ultimate garage wine from southern California emanates from a rusty warehouse that appears to be on the wrong side of the railroad tracks running through Ventura. The winery's name is Sine Qua Non (literally translated from Latin means without which one cannot.), and as the proprietors' (the husband and wife team of Elaine and Manfred Krankl) indicate on the label of their sumptuous 1997 Syrah called Imposter McCoy, the truth is inside Elaine and Manfred Krankl are both very involved in the production of artisanal wines from their small garage/warehouse...their first serious commercial venture was a Syrah called Black and Blue, which was made at Napa's Havens winery in This was followed by an assortment of oddly-named offerings under the Sine Qua Non moniker. These included the Queen of Spades in 1994, Red Handed, The Bride, and The Other Hand in 1995, Omadhaun and Poltroon, Eclipse, Against the Wall, and The Complicator in 1996, and Twisted and Bent, Imposter McCoy, and Veiled in The funky labels have all been reproductions of Manfred Krankl's artwork, and the wines are put in heavy, antique bottles that seem intentionally designed to provoke lower back pain. Most importantly, the wines are undeniably distinctive, individualistic, and brilliant. In short, this is wine geek code for they taste real good. Elaine Krankl looks for accessibility, fullness, and length, as well as a wine that is completely alive. She accuses her husband of thinking more long-term, and he tends to agree, claiming that she has a more visceral reaction to wine quality, which he admires. Manfred claims to be the analyst, trying to project what the wine will taste like in the future. They make no secret (and are in agreement) about their favorite producers. First and foremost, these include the late Jacques Raynaud of Château Rayas in Châteauneuf du Pape, followed by Henri Jayer in Burgundy, California's Helen Turley, France's Gérard Chave, François Raveneau, and Marcel Guigal, and Italy's Elio Altare After a few forays into northern California, all the fruit since 1994 has come from Santa Barbara, the region they believe has the greatest potential for Rhône Valley-styled wine (known in the vernacular as Rhône Rangers ). Until they began making wine at their own garage/warehouse facility in 1997, they produced wine at the Ojai Vineyard in Ojai and at the Alban Vineyard in San Luis Obispo. The Syrah utilized in The Queen of Spades, Red Handed (blended with Grenache and Mourvèdre), The Other Hand, Against the Wall, and Imposter McCoy has largely come from the Alban Vineyard, although this has recently been supplemented by grapes from both the Bien Nacido and Stolpman Vineyards. The Roussanne and Chardonnay have come from the Alban Vineyard, and the Grenache from the Stolpman Vineyard. Their sweet wines are made from sources such as the Brander and Alban Vineyards. Their small quantities of Pinot Noir are exported from the Northwest, shipped in reefer (temperature-controlled) trucks from Oregon's Willamette Valley Shea Vineyard Sine Qua Non Midnight Oil 2001 (3) one with signs of old seepage 2001 magnum (1) 1938 above 3 bottles & 1 magnum (1.5L) per lot US$ Sine Qua Non 2002 original wood assortment case Just For The Love Of It Syrah magnum (1) More Than a Number magnum (1) 1939 above 2 magnums (1.5L) per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com 259

252 Sine Qua Non Papa Syrah 2003 Santa Rita Hills one lightly scuffed label bottles per lot US$ Sine Qua Non 2003 original wood assortment case Non Li'l E Grenache magnum (1) Papa Syrah magnum (1) 1941 above 2 magnums (1.5L) per lot US$ Sine Qua Non Into The Dark Grenache 2004 (2) one lightly scuffed label 2004 magnum (1) heavily scuffed back label, chipped wax capsule 1942 above 2 bottles & 1 magnum (1.5L) per lot US$ Sine Qua Non Ode to E Eleven Confessions Vineyard 2004 original wood assortment case Grenache (2) Syrah (4) 1943 above 6 bottles per lot US$ Sine Qua Non 2004 original wood assortment case Into The Dark Grenache double magnum (1) Poker Face Syrah double magnum (1) 1944 above 2 double magnums (3L) per lot US$ Sine Qua Non The Naked Truth Grenache 2005 Central Coast one lightly tissue paper stained label, one with tissue paper adhered to label "The dense ruby/plum/purple-colored Naked Truth reveals an extraordinary bouquet of sweet black raspberries, boysenberries, kirsch, licorice, pepper, and spice. Full-bodied with noteworthy concentration, freshness, texture, and length...99." WA 8/ bottles per lot US$ Sine Qua Non The 17Th Nail In My Cranium Eleven Confessions Vineyard Syrah 2005 Ventura "...stunning nose...dense, with an endless (and I mean endless) finish, remarkable purity, and layer upon layer of flavor, but no sense of heaviness " WA 8/ bottle per lot US$ Sine Qua Non 2006 original wood assortment case A Shot in the Dark Syrah (4) In the Crosshairs Grenache (2) 1947 above 6 bottles per lot US$ Sine Qua Non Raven Series Grenache 2006 #1 (1) lightly wine-stained label #6+7 (2) one heavily wine-stained label #9 (3) one wine-stained label 1948 above 6 bottles per lot US$ Sine Qua Non Raven Series Syrah 2006 #3 (2) wine-stained labels #4 (3) one wine-stained label #5 (1) wine-stained label 1949 above 6 bottles per lot US$ Sine Qua Non Dangerous Birds 2007 original wood assortment case Grenache (2) Syrah (4) 1950 above 6 bottles per lot US$ Sine Qua Non Labels Syrah 2007 California "Inky purple. Sexy aromas of black raspberry and blueberry preserves, sandalwood, cracked pepper and licorice, with a lashing of sexy Asian spices adding vibrancy and complexity...94." IWC 11/ bottles per lot US$ Sine Qua Non Pictures Grenache 2007 Central Coast "Supple tannins gain strength with air and add shape to a long, juicy, vibrant finish. Most of this fruit came from the Eleven Confessions site...94." IWC 11/ bottles per lot US$ Next of Kyn No. 2 Red original wood assortment case 2008 (3) 2008 magnum (1) 1953 above 3 bottles & 1 magnum (1.5L) per lot US$ Sine Qua Non The Duel Grenache 2008 (2) 2008 magnum (1) 1954 above 2 bottles & 1 magnum (1.5L) per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com

253 Lot 1944 ZACHYS tel fax zachys.com 261

254 Next of Kyn No. 3 Red original wood assortment case 2009 (3) 2009 magnum (1) 1955 above 3 bottles & 1 magnum (1.5L) per lot US$ Next of Kyn No. 4 Red original wood assortment case 2010 (3) 2010 magnum (1) 1956 above 3 bottles & 1 magnum (1.5L) per lot US$ Sine Qua Non Five Shooter Grenache 2010 (3) 2010 magnum (1) 1957 above 3 bottles & 1 magnum (1.5L) per lot US$ Sine Qua Non Stockholm Syndrome 2010 original wood assortment case Grenache (3) Syrah (3) 1958 above 6 bottles per lot US$ Sine Qua Non Five Shooter Syrah 2010 Ventura "Dusty, fine-grained tannins add support to the very sweet, persistent, well-focused finish. Shows a very suave blend of richness and vivacity...94." IWC 11/ bottles per lot US$ Next of Kyn No. 5 Red original wood assortment case 2011 (3) 2011 magnum (1) 1960 above 3 bottles & 1 magnum (1.5L) per lot US$ Sine Qua Non Atlantis Fe 2O3 Syrah A magnum (1) 1B (2) 1C (1) 1961 above 3 bottles & 1 magnum (1.5L) per lot US$ Sine Qua Non Atlantis Fe 2O3 Grenache A (1) nicked label 2A magnum (1) 2B (3) one lightly nicked label, two torn labels 2C (2) 1962 above 6 bottles & 1 magnum (1.5L) per lot US$ Sine Qua Non Raven Series 2006 #10 Syrah magnum (1) lightly nicked label #8 Grenache magnum (1) 1963 above 2 magnums (1.5L) per lot US$ Sine Qua Non 2008 B20 Syrah magnum (1) 2-pack original wood assortment case with The Line Grenache The Duel Syrah (2) The Line Grenache magnum (1) 2-pack original wood assortment case with B20 Syrah 1964 above 2 bottles & 2 magnums (1.5L) per lot US$ Sine Qua Non 2009 The Thrill of Stamp Collecting Syrah (3) one torn label Turn The Whole Thing Upside Down Grenache magnum (1) Upside Down Grenache (3) 1965 above 6 bottles & 1 magnum (1.5L) per lot US$ Sine Qua Non This Is Not An Exit 2009 Grenache (1) Syrah (3) 1966 above 4 bottles per lot US$ Sine Qua Non Dark Blossom 2011 Grenache (3) Syrah (3) 1967 above 6 bottles per lot US$ Sine Qua Non Twisted and Bent Roussanne/Chardonnay 1997 (1) The Rejuvenators White 2004 (1) The Hoodoo Man 2006 (2) Body And Soul Roussanne / Viognier 2007 (4) Kolibri 2008 (3) 1968 above 11 bottles per lot US$ Sine Qua Non Autrement Dit Rosé 2006 (2) On The Lam White 2009 (3) The Monkey White 2010 (3) The Moment White 2011 (3) 1969 above 11 bottles per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com

255 SCREAMING EAGLE, COLGIN, AND SQN (LOTS ) A concise consignment of mailing list wines. Without the mailing list. CALIFORNIA SCREAMING EAGLE COLGIN Colgin IX Estate Red 2006 includes 6-pack "With extraordinary intensity, beautiful purity, a texture and flavors that build incrementally on the palate, and a significantly long finish, this is a perfect wine " WA 12/ bottles per lot US$ Colgin Cariad Red 2007 "...but the sweetness of the tannin, the enormous concentration of fruit (blackberry, blueberry, cherry) intermixed with graphite, chocolate, coffee and crushed rock characteristics is striking " WA 6/ bottles per lot US$ Colgin IX Estate Red 2007 "This is another seamless tour de force in winemaking " WA 12/ bottles per lot US$ Colgin IX Estate Red 2010 "Its opaque purple color is accompanied by copious aromas of blueberries, cassis, pen ink, asphalt, licorice and subtle oak. Full-bodied and rich but light on its feet " WA 10/ bottles per lot US$ Screaming Eagle Cabernet Sauvignon 2007 "An exquisite, celestial bouquet...full-bodied and seductive, the 2007 conquers all of the senses with its head spinning, beautiful personality " WA 12/ bottles per lot US$ ,000 Screaming Eagle Cabernet Sauvignon 2008 "If Grand Cru Burgundy were made in, it would taste like Screaming Eagle. A delicate, classy finish lets the sheer purity of the fruit come through beautifully here...97." WA 12/ bottles per lot US$ Screaming Eagle Cabernet Sauvignon 2009 "Layers of intensely sweet, perfumed fruit are woven together with remarkable elegance and sheer polish...a translucent, weightless finish rounds things out in style...98." WA 12/ bottles per lot US$ Sine Qua Non The Thrill of Stamp Collecting Syrah 2009 Ventura "Dark fruit, spices, licorice and violets sit on a core of firm tannin as this powerful wine opens up in the glass...95." WA 8/ bottles per lot US$ Colgin Cariad Red 2006 (3) 2008 (3) 1974 above 6 bottles per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com 263

256 A COUPLE OF GEMS FROM A RENOWNED COLLECTION (LOTS ) Zachys has had the pleasure of working with this notable collector over several consignments, and she has always delivered impeccable bottles with perfect provenance. The following lots are no exception and represent a few choice selections from this classic cellar. All of these bottles were stored perfectly in a professionally installed home wine cellar with all but the 1963 Quinta do Noval Nacional acquired directly on release. BURGUNDY CALIFORNIA Musigny Vieilles Vignes Comte Georges de Vogüé 1983 two 2cm or better, one 2.5cm, two lightly scuffed labels bottles per lot US$ Corton Clos des Cortons Faiveley 1990 Côte de Beaune, Grand Cru seven 2cm or better, two 2.5cm, two 3cm, two lightly bin-soiled labels, two lightly scuffed labels, one lightly torn label, one with signs of old seepage "Black fruit nose that is quite rich and complex with slightly rustic tannins and a long, intense, moderately structured finish." BH 11/ bottles per lot US$ Chambertin Louis Jadot 1993 two heavily wine-stained vintage tags, one nicked label, six with signs of old seepage bottles per lot US$ ITALY Barbaresco Sori San Lorenzo Gaja 1990 Piedmont 2cm or better, three lightly scuffed labels "...a dark, hulking wine boasting masses of dark fruit, scorched earth and herbs. Initially somewhat rustic, the wine becomes rounder and more generous with time in the glass...94." WA 2/ bottles per lot US$ Ornellaia 1995 Tuscany two lightly scuffed labels bottles per lot US$ Opus One 1991 three lightly marked labels "This monumental wine has enormous richness, depth and polish, brimming with ripe, juicy plum, cherry, currant and cedary oak. Should be uncommonly long-lived. Delicious...97." WS 2/ bottles per lot US$ Ridge Vineyards Monte Bello Cabernet Sauvignon 1992 Santa Cruz Mountains three bin-soiled labels, three lightly damp-stained labels, one lightly scuffed label "...exhibits aromas of tar, cedar, damp earth, white chocolate, black cherries, and sweet black currants...impressive wine...94." WA 12/ bottles per lot US$ Opus One 1994 one lightly bin-soiled label, one lightly marked label "...a wonderful sense of harmony and finesse to this graceful, elegant wine. Lots of complex flavors, with tiers of spicy currant and black cherry. Long, intricate aftertaste...97." WS 2/ bottles per lot US$ AUSTRALIA Penfolds Grange 1993 South Australia "It delivers a ripe core of plum and dried currant, then branches out, hinting at anise and mineral on the finish...95." WS 11/ bottles per lot US$ PORT Quinta do Noval Nacional 1963 Douro one bottom neck, one very top shoulder, importer tags adhered to scuffed labels "Like several other of the very best 1963 Ports, the '63 Nacional is still a fairly young wine and will continue to dazzle for another fifty or sixty years. It was an absolute privilege to taste this legendary wine! " JBG 10/ bottles per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com

257 SPANISH SHOWSTOPPERS (LOTS ) Zachys is thrilled to once again offer a portion of this collection. Almost entirely acquired on release direct from the estates, to look back on the meticulously kept purchase records of these bottles is to look directly into history. Decades of Único, some particular rarities from vintages such as 1941 and 1962, as well as 1965 from Mag! Stored in perfect, temperature- and humidity-controlled conditions, bid with absolute confidence on this spectacular offering. SPAIN VEGA SICILIA Vega Sicilia, often called the Lafite of Spain for its elegance, is among the oldest extant wineries in Spain and remains among its most celebrated. Toribio Lecanda purchased 2,000 acres of farmland from the Marquis de Valbuena in 1848, but it was not until 1864 that his son, Eloy, began to convert it to viticulture by planting Cabernet Sauvignon, Malbec and Pinot Noir. Originally, he made brandy, and even before it was a winery Vega Sicilia was appointed to be the brandy supplier to the royal family of Spain. Vega Sicilia Unico ( unique ) and Valbuena both date from 1915, when the vineyards had recovered sufficiently from phylloxera to permit great wine to be made. Unico, made only in outstanding years, is typically mostly Tempranillo, with the balance Cabernet Sauvignon, Malbec and Merlot. It spends at least seven years in barrel, and at least three in bottle, before release, and in some vintages, it is aged for astonishingly long periods before it reaches the market. The 1970, for example, was not released until 1995, and magnums did not follow until 2000! The wine lives up to its designation as unique. It is intensely fragrant, complex on the palate but also extremely concentrated, with very high acidity to balance the richness. Occasionally, the winery will release a small quantity of wine designated Reserva Especial, a blend of two or three Unicos; these bottlings are generally considered to be of the same high quality as the single vintage releases. Vega Sicilia Único 1941 Ribera del Duero upper shoulder, bin-soiled label, corroded capsule bottle per lot US$ Vega Sicilia Único 1948 Ribera del Duero just below top shoulder, bin-soiled and lightly dampstained label, slightly depressed cork bottle per lot US$ Vega Sicilia Único 1958 Ribera del Duero upper shoulder, bin-soiled label, signs of old seepage bottle per lot US$ Vega Sicilia Único 1962 Ribera del Duero one bottom neck, one very top shoulder, one dampstained label, one lightly damp-stained label "Youthful, vivacious and utterly compelling, this is a profound wine that even after four decades is surfeit with precocity. Undoubtedly, this must be one of the greatest Spanish wines to have graced this planet " WA 8/ bottles per lot US$ Vega Sicilia Único 1964 Ribera del Duero bottom neck or better, two bin-soiled labels, one dampstained label, two deteriorated labels, one with signs of old seepage "...exuberant and vivacious...but overall, this remains a seductive Único of immense breeding and passion...96." WA 8/ bottles per lot US$ Vega Sicilia Único 1965 Ribera del Duero Lot 1994: two bottom neck or better, one top shoulder, one bin-soiled label, two heavily damp-stained labels, one lightly scuffed label, two depressed corks Lot 1995: top shoulder, wine-stained label "The palate was beautifully balanced...there is a sense of completeness to the 1965 that is irresistible...94." WA 8/ bottles per lot US$ magnum (1.5L) per lot US$ Vega Sicilia Único 1966 Ribera del Duero one bottom neck, one very top shoulder, one dampstained label, one lightly nicked label, one torn label, winestained labels bottles per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com 265

258 SPECIALIST'S PICK: LOT 2001 I had the incredible privilege of tasting this wine from bottle alongside several other vintages. After a healthy decant, easily one of the most expressive in recent memory. Beautiful red berries underwritten by a spicy character that truly tantalizes the palate. Impressive staying power, this wine will go for a great many years yet. I can only imagine the enduring power when tasted out of Mag! Kim Busch Vega Sicilia Único 1967 Ribera del Duero just below top shoulder, damp-stained and nicked label, signs of old seepage "It is vivacious and floral, unfolding with each sip. The palate is medium-bodied with very fine tannins, vivacious almost port-like fruit intensity...96." WA 8/ bottle per lot US$ Vega Sicilia Único 1973 Ribera del Duero two top shoulder, one just below top shoulder, two lightly bin-soiled labels, one wine-stained label, one with signs of old seepage bottles per lot US$ Vega Sicilia Único 2005 Ribera del Duero two 3-pack s "It's still powerful, but at the same time it's elegant and has a polished mouthfeel and fine-grained tannins...96." WA 2/ bottles per lot US$ Vega Sicilia Único 2006 Ribera del Duero two 3-pack s "Full body, dense and so soft and complex. The finish goes on for minutes...drink forever. A wine that you want to spend time with " JS 1/ bottles per lot US$ Vega Sicilia Único 1974 Ribera del Duero just below top shoulder, two with signs of old seepage "Leaving it aside for one hour, it turns into one powerhouse of a wine, with laser-like focus and a vibrant, life-affirming finish with orange zest and liquorice. What began a potentially disappointing Único, ultimately turns out to be a barnstormer...93." WA 8/ bottles per lot US$ Vega Sicilia Único 1980 Ribera del Duero Lot 2000: very top shoulder, bin-soiled labels, one lightly torn label Lot 2001: just below top shoulder, lightly wine-stained label, signs of old seepage "...displays Único's tell-tale lavish, toasty new oak, vanillin, and smoke aromas, as well as earthy, red and black fruit scents. Spicy, dense, and medium to full-bodied...91." WA 2/ bottles per lot US$ magnum (1.5L) per lot US$ Vega Sicilia Único 2007 Ribera del Duero "...balanced and deep...delivers plenty of structure, with well-integrated tannins and lively acidity. The wine remains graceful through the long, spicy finish...94." WS 10/ magnum (1.5L) per lot US$ Marques de Murrieta Castillo Ygay Gran Reserva Especial 1925 Rioja bottom neck or better, one with signs of old seepage bottles per lot US$ Marques de Murrieta Castillo Ygay Reserva 1954 Rioja five bottom neck or better, one very top shoulder, one heavily damp-stained label, one lightly bin-soiled label, one lightly torn label bottles per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com

259 COLLECTIBLE SPIRITS FROM AN INTERNATIONALLY KNOWN AUTHOR AND ACCREDITED AFICIONADO (LOTS ) Zachys Wine Auctions is pleased to offer the following collection from an avid West Coast collector, author, and member of the trade. All were sourced on release or from reputable brokers and maintained in excellent home storage. No stranger to the nuances of collecting rare spirits, this consignor's collection includes one of only 50 bottles of the Ardbeg Auriverdes Gold Label in existence. SCOTLAND GLENLIVET 45-YEAR-OLD SINGLE MALT SCOTCH 1968 (LOT 2010) Perfectly stored and from a well-known member of the international wine trade. SCOTLAND Glenlivet 45 Year Old Single Malt Scotch 1968 Scotland 3.5cm below foil, Andrew Murray & Co. private labels, push corks, bottled by Glenlivet for Alexander Murray & Co., 40% abv, Speyside bottles per lot US$ Macallan 18 Year Old Single Malt Scotch 1976 Scotch original carton 3.5cm, laser code: L443MCI M29:07, 43% abv, distilled in 1976, bottled in 1994, Speyside bottle per lot US$ Ardbeg Auriverdes 2-pack special edition assortment case 49.9% abv, Islay NV (1) 3.5cm below cork Gold Label Single Malt Scotch NV (1) push cork, only 50 bottles produced 2008 above 2 bottles per lot US$ KENTUCKY Pappy Van Winkle Family Reserve 23 Year Old Bourbon Kentucky original velvet bag 4cm, lightly scuffed label, push cork, gold capsule, bottle #c15439, 47.8% abv, illegible laser code bottle per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com 267

260 RARE EARLY 1970S CHARTREUSE V.E.P. (LOT 2011) This lot of rare Chartreuse in original packaging is ripe for the Chartreuse aficionado. Bid with confidence. FRANCE Chartreuse V.E.P. each in in original carton Green liter (1) 7cm, bottled in 1972, bottle #8774, 54% abv Yellow liter (1) 4cm, bottled in 1970, bottle #003714, 42% abv 2011 above two 1 liters (1L) per lot US$ ZACHYS tel fax bid@zachys.com zachys.com